The Battle in Pakistan is Over Resources-Islam just used as a tool to justify ethnic chauvinism

8/2/2019 The Battle in Pakistan is Over Resources-Islam just used as a tool to justify ethnic chauvinism

1/5

UCF IHUUDF KB WH@K]UHB K] J^FY YF]JVYMF],K]DHL K] OV]U H UJJD UJ OV]UKN[ FUCBKM

EK]MYKLKBHUKJB

HACH C HLKB

H ljbjucfk}u ifdkf~fy kb Aje lh{ }uhuf uchu }uhuf} hyf myfhufe qcfb Aje qhbu} ku ( H}}f}}lfbu} mhbbju

ek~kbf ek~kbf ef}kab} ivu h}}f}}lfbu} i{ lfhb ljyuhd} mhb h}}f}} ef}kab} jn ljyuhd} (

Qckdf }uhuf} hyf `f{ wdh{fy} kb }uhuf myfhukjb ucf{ ej ku qcfb ucfyf k} h kbekafbjv} fdflfbu kb~jd~fe kb

ucf whyukmvdhy mh}f (

Uck} lfhb} uchu }uhuf} mhb hmu h} lkeqk~f} uj myfhuf h bfq }uhuf hwhyu nyjl ek~kbf ef}kab"

Uck} ch} chwwfbfe kb Kbekh hnufy 8;57 qcfb ucf Iyku} efmkefe uj ek~kef Kbekh"Ucf kefh qh} nky}u

wyjwjvbefe i{ h Iykuk}c mk~kd }fy~hbu ]ky Lkmchfd J Eq{fy kb dhuf 8;=7}"

Ihbadhef}c }klkdhyd{ qh} myfhufe qkuc lhojy ]j~kfu hbe Kbekhb yjdf hbe ucf V] hd}j qhbufe uj dklku

mjllvbk}u kbndvfbmf kb Fh}u Ifbahd hbe }hq Hqhlk dfhavf h} h hdufybhuk~f"

H ef nhmuj @vyek}c }uhuf ch} hdyfhe{ iffb myfhufe kb Kyhx ivu jbd{ qkuc V] cfdw"

Ij}bkh hbe @j}j~j qfyf myfhufe qkuc hmuk~f V] }vwwjyu"

Wh`k}uhb qh} myfhufe i{ Iykuk}c wjdkm{ uj wvbk}c ucf Hdd Kbekh Mjbayf}} qckmc qh} yfnv}kba uj if whyu jn

ucf Iykuk}c qhy fnnjyu hbe dhufy jn Iykuk}c }uyhufakm wjdkm{ kb H}kh (

Ucv} ucf kefh jn Wh`k}uhb qh} ak~fb h} h ucflf uj Ly Okbbhc i{ ucf Iykuk}c Aj~fybjy Afbfyhd kb

]fwuflify 8;=; kb jyefy uj mjvbufy ucf hbuk Iykuk}c Kbekhb Bhukjbhd Mjbayf}}"

Wh`k}uhb qh} ~k}vhdk}fe h} h Iykuk}c ih}f hahkb}u ucf V]]Y ( H mcfhw vb}uhidf }uhuf qckmc mjvde if

lhbkwvdhufe qkuc fh}f i{ ucf Iyku} ( Kb 8;65 ucf Iyku} chbefe j~fy Wh`k}uhb uj ucf Hlfykmhb} (

Ucf myvs jn ucf wyjidfl k} uchu qcfb ucf V] qkuc ]hvek he~kmf hbe Wh`k}uhbk lfymfbhy{ uyhekukjb }uhyufe

v}kba K}dhl h} h ujjd jn }uyhufa{ hahkb}u ucf V]]Y ucf qcjdf }mcflf qfbu jvu jn }wkb i{ 8;;; (

Ku k} mdfhy bjq uchu ucf V] k} dj}kba ucf qhy fmbjlkmhdd{ hbe Wh`k}uhb hbe ]hvek Hyhikh mhb if }f~fyfd{

ef}uhikdk}fe i{ fsuyflk}u hbe f~fb j~fyqcfdlfe (

Uck} k} bju ucf uklf uj mjlwj}f h nvbfyhd lhymc ivu uj nkbe h lfekhb }jdvukjb qckmc dfhe} uj }jlf

mjvbufy mcfm` (

Ucf Ihdjmc kb Wh`k}uhb qhbu uj myfhuf h nyff }uhuf ifmhv}f ucf{ }ff ucf Wvbohik,Wh}cuvb,Ljchoky

f}uhidk}clfbu qhbukba uj uvyb ucfl kbuj hb fucbkm lkbjyku{ hbe Ihdjmck}uhb"Ucf Ihdjmc wfymfwukjb k}

uchu uck} f}uhidk}clfbu chuf} ucf Ihdjmc hbe k} jbd{ kbufyf}ufe kb ucf jkd hbe ah} hbe lkbfyhd} jn

Ihdjmck}uhb"


2/5

]ffb kb ucf hij~f mjbufsu kn Wh`k}uhb qh} myfhufe i{ Klwfykhdk}u ef}kab qc{ mhbbju bfq }uhuf} if

myfhufe kb ucf yfakjb bjq uj mjvbufy fsuyflk}l :

Ucf wyklfy jn uck} hyukmdf qh} h mjb~fy}hukjb qkuc h ~fy{ }fbkjy Wh`k}uhbk lkdkuhy{ jnnkmkhd"

Ch~kba }uvekfe kb Ihdjmck}uhb njy lhb{ {fhy} hbe ch~kba }fy~fe kb ucf Wh`k}uhbk lkdkuhy{ K ch~f ucf

vbkxvf jwwjyuvbku{ jn `bjqkba ucf `f{ wdh{fy} jb ijuc }kef} (

Uck} kbmdvef} ucf whyhbjke Wh`k}uhbk kbufddkafbmf jnnkmkhd} qcj}f whyhbjkh kb }v}wfmukba hdd f~fb kbmdvekba

ucfky qk~f} fsufbe} h} nhy h} ucfky ayhbeljucfy}(

Kb Ihdjmck}uhb qchu K hl }ffkba k} h bfq `kbe jn Ihdjmc bhukjbhdk}l kb qckmc f~fb ucf Ihdjmc Uykihd Mckfn

`bjqb h} ]hyehy k} ifmjlkba kyyfdf~hbu"

[f} njyfkab chbe} hyf kb~jd~fe" Ivu qf lv}u yflflify uchu njyfkab chbe} }vmmffe jbd{ kn ucfyf k} hb

kbekafbjv} afbvkbf kb}vyafbm{ kb}kef h mjvbuy{" Ucf }hlf qh} uyvf njy Ihbadhef}c$ hbe bjq njy Kbekhb

jmmvwkfe @h}clky hbe Ihdjmck}uhb"

Njyfkab chbe} qfyf kb~jd~fe kb myfhukba Wh`k}uhb ujj"Hnufy hdd ucf nhucfy} qfyf ]ky Lkmchfd J Eq{fy hbe

ucf Iykuk}c yf}jd~f uj wvbk}c Mjbayf}} njy bju }vwwjyukba ucf Iykuk}c qhy fnnjyu"

Hdd k} bju kbf~kuhidf "uck} k} h nhkdvyf jn Wh`k}uhbk wjdkm{ hbe hij~f hdd Wh`k}uhb Hyl{"

Uck} hyukmdf lh{ bf~fy if wvidk}cfe kb h Wh`k}uhbk bfq}whwfy :

Uck} k} }j ifmhv}f kb Wh`k}uhb f~fy{uckba k} fucbkm hbe vdufykjy ifmhv}f ku k} hb klwfynfmu $ hbhmcyjbk}ukm

}uhuf }kabknkmhbud{ lhbkwvdhufe i{ ucf lkdkuhy{ $ i{ ucf lkdkuhy{ kbufddkafbmf hbe i{ mdh}}f} qcj ch~f h~fy{ vbnhky he~hbuhaf kb uck} vb}uhidf hbe ~jdhukdf }uhuf"

Ku k} qjyuc heekba }jlf ihm`ayjvbe kbnjylhukjb njy ucf njyfkab dh{lhb yfhefy cfyf"

Cjq k} ku uchu Wh`k}uhb} wjdkukmhd hbe lkdkuhy{ f}uhidk}clfbu qckmc bjq hmu} h} oveaf ovy{ hbe

fsfmvukjbfy $ hdd ucyff mjlikbfe kb jbf mdh}} ifmhlf ucf lh}ufy} jn ef}ukb{ jn Wh`k}uhb} df}}fy yhmf} :

Ucf Ifbahdk} ifnjyf 8;18 qcj qfyf yfahyefe h } kbnfykjy Eyh~kekhb yhmf i{ uck} f}uhidk}clfbu : Ucf

Ihdjmc hbe ]kbeck} qcj uck} f}uhidk}clfbu }ukdd yfahye} h} hb kbnfykjy yhmf ukdd uj ehuf (

Ucf fdkuf qckmc mjddhijyhufe qkuc iykuk}c qh} ucf Wvbohik lv}dkl $ }fuudfe hyfh Wh}cuvb} hbe Vyev

}wfh`kba qcj ahkbfe h wj}kukjb jn vbnhky he~hbuhaf hnufy whyukukjb jn Kbekh i{ fdklkbhukba ucf Ckbevnyjl mjlwfukukjb fshl} h} qfdd h} iv}kbf}} hbe haykmvduvyf"


3/5

Ucf hij~f mdh}}f} ahkbfe h wj}kukjb jn vbnhky he~hbuhaf kb ucf wyf 8;51 Iykuk}c Kbekhb Hyl{ bju ifmhv}f

ucf{ qfyf ljyf lhyukhd ivu ifmhv}f ucf{ mjddhijyhufe qkuc ucf Iykuk}c kb `kddkba Kbekhb} $ ijuc Lv}dkl

hbe bjb Lv}dkl nyjl 8361 ukdd 8;51 (

Ucf kefh jn wh`k}uhb kb yfhdku{ qh} uj ahkb h wj}kukjb jn vbnhky he~hbuhaf njy ucf hij~f fdkuf i{

fdklkbhukba ucf Ckbev hbe ]k`c qcj cfde }vwfykjyku{ kb iv}kbf}} $ haykmvduvyf hbe mk~kd }fy~kmf"

Hb flkbfbu Iykuk}c }mcjdhy Nyhbmk} Yjikb}jb ch} iykddkhbud{ fswdjyfe uck} vdufykjy ucflf kb ck}

lh}ufywkfmf ijj` Lv}dkl ]fwhyhuk}l kb Kbekh"

Okbbhc $ Wh`k}uhb} njvbefy yfwyf}fbufe ucf Ijlih{ Avoyhuk iv}kbf}} hbe uck} k} qc{ Hehloff ucf

Ijlih{ iv}kbf}} u{mjjb ah~f ckl h idhb` mcfxvf h} }vwwjyu uj Okbbhc} Lv}dkl Dfhavf} xvf}u njy

Wh`k}uhb"

Ucf qcjdf jn okbbhc} wjdkm{ qh} evhd }uhbehye}"Kb h vbkufe Kbekh cf qhbufe qfh` mfbuyf hbe }uyjba

wyj~kbmf} }j uchu Ckbev lhojyku{ hyl{ mjvde bju mch}uk}f ucf hij~f lfbukjbfe Lv}dkl mdh}}f} uchu ucf

Lv}dkl Dfhavf yfwyf}fbufe"

Jbmf Wh`k}uhb qh} myfhufe Okbbhc qhbufe }uyjba mfbuyf hbe qfh` wyj~kbmf} hbe v}fe hyl{ uj mch}uk}f

wyj~kbmf} ucf nky}u uklf kb Ihdjmck}uhb kb 8;53"

@hdhu }uhuf} hmmf}}kjb uj Wh`k}uhb qh} h} evikjv} h} hmmf}}kjb jn @h}clky uj Kbekh"Cjqf~fy uck} hd}j

chwwfbfe ifmhv}f jn Okbbhc} }fdn klwj}fe nhvs wh} (

Uck} qh} qcfb Okbbhc yfofmufe ucf Iykuk}c ^kmfyj{ Djye Ljvbuihuufb!} lj}u ov}u wyjwj}hd uchu Lv}dkl

lhojykyu{ wykbmfd{ }uhuf} ojkb Wh`k}uhb h} h njylvdh hbe ~kmf ~fy}h njy Ckbev hbe ]k`c lhojyku{ }uhuf}

ojkbkba Kbekh "

Ih}fe jb uck} Wh`k}uhb ch} bj mh}f jb @h}clky h} ku ojkbfe Kbekh i{ h dfahd njylvdh: Bfcyv mjllkuufe h

nhvs wh} qcfb cf hayffe uj kbmdvef ucf VB kb ucf ek}wvuf hbe hayffe uj wyj}wfmuk~f wdfik}mkuf kb

@h}clky kb jyefy uj efmkef qcfucfy ucf @h}clkyk} qhbufe uj ojkb Kbekh jy Wh`k}uhb"

Ih}fe jb }hlf njylvdh Wh`k}uhbk lkdkuhy{ hmukjb kb @hdhu kb 8;53 k} ljyf kddfahd uchb kbekhb lkdkuhy{

kbufy~fbukjb kb `h}clky qckmc qh} wfynfmud{ dfahd"

F~fb `h}clky k} hb fucbkm k}}vf h} dkbavk}ukmhdd{ `h}clkyk} hbe wvbohik} hyf hdlj}u ucf }hlf"@h}clky k}

hijvu qhufy uj kyykahuf Wvbohi hbe ]kbec"

H} }uhufe fhydkfy ucf hij~f Wh`k}uhbk fucbkm mvl mdh}} fdkuf yfahyefe ucf Ifbahdk} $ Ihdjmc hbe f~fb

]kbeck} h} kbnfykjy hbe ykacu nyjl 8;51 kbuyjevmfe hb vbnhky ljbjwjd{ kb Wh`k}uhb"

Qcfb Ifbahdk} qfyf kb lhojyku{ kb wjwvdhukjb uck} fdkuf qhbufe ek}uykivukjb jn nvbe} bju jb ih}k} jn

wjwvdhukjb $ ivu qcfb wvbohik} ifmhlf lhojyku{ uck} fdkuf qhbufe ek}uykivukjb jn nvbe} jb ih}k} jn

wjwvdhukjb"


4/5

Yfdkakjb qh} v}fe i{ ucf hij~f fdkuf uj nvyucfy ucfky ljbjwjd{" Wvbohi hbe whyu} jn BQNW yfahyefe h}

cfhyu jn Wh`k}uhb hbe jucfy} yfahyefe h} }flk uyhkujy} jy nvdd uyhkujy}"

F~fb ucf efnfb}f }uyhufa{ h} uhvacu hu ucf Wh`k}uhbk }uhnn mjddfaf hbe bhukjbhd efnfb}f mjddfaf yfahyefe

bjyuc Wvbohi h} mfbuyf jn Wh`k}uhb!} ayh~ku{ hbe ucf lhkb kefh jn ucf hyl{ qh} uj efnfbe bjyuc Wvbohi $

}wfmknkmhdd{ }wfdu h} ucf uykhbadf Dhcjyf Yhqhdwkbek Nhk}hdhihe"

Qckdf ucf hij~f fdkuf qfyf `kba lh`fy} ucf{ mhlf kb jwfb hnufy 8;11"Ucf }hlf fdkuf mjb}wkyfe uj

dhvbmc ucf hyl{ kb Ihdjmck}uhb kb 8;53$63$8;>7$8;1="

Hb{jbf qcj k} jvu}kef ucf hij~f fdkuf k} iyhbefe h} uyhkujy"

Yfdkakjb hbe v}f jn wyjskf} qh} hejwufe kb Jmujify 8;51 h} h wjdkm{$ ek}mhyefe uflwjyhykd{ hnufy 8;53 $

yf,wkm`fe qkuc njymf hnufy 8;>; hbe nvdd{ fbnjymfe hnufy 8;11"

Ucf ihuudf kb Wh`k}uhb k} f}}fbukhdd{ j~fy yf}jvymf}" Jkd hbe ah} ifkba ucf mfbuyf jn ku" F~fb h `kdjayhl jn

DWA xvjuh mhb if hddjuufe jbd{ i{ uck} fdkuf kb Wh`k}uhb"Bffedf}} uj }uhuf lj}u jn ucf Jkd hbe Ah}

kbev}uy{ k} ejlkbhufe i{ uck} fdkuf"

Qhy qkuc Kbekh hbe Kbekhb ucyfhu k} v}fe i{ uck} fdkuf uj ov}ukn{ ku} vbnhky ljbjwjd{"

Qkuc ucf bfq V] Hnachb ]uyhufakm hayfflfbu ku hwwfhy} uchu ucf V] lh{ fbefh~jvy uj myfhuf bfq

}uhuf} kb Wh`k}uhb (

Ku k} uklf njy ucf Wh`k}uhbk f}uhidk}clfbu uj }uhyu uckb`kba (

Ihd`hbk}hukjb k} bju kbf~kuhidf kn Wh`k}uhb} fucbkm f}uhidk}clfbu }ujw} ifkba fucbkm (

cuuw?**qqq"}mykie"mjl*ejm*>83=;>>>*Kbej,Wh`,Qhy},H,Wkmujykhd,Ck}ujy{

cuuw?**qqq"}mykie"mjl*ejm*98>3>336*UHDKIHB,QHY,KB,WH@K]UHB,HNACHBK]UHB,H,QYKUFY],

WFYMFWUKJB],NYJL,9778,UJ,9788

cuuw?**qqq"}mykie"mjl*ejm*995613>9*Lkdkuhy{,Efmk}kjb,lh`kba,hbe,dfhefy}ckw

cuuw?**qqq"}mykie"mjl*ejm*998681>6*Ck}ujy{,jn,Wh`k}uhb,Hyl{,nyjl,8161,uj,8;18,WYKBUKBA,

FBHIDFE,Ej,hm`bjqdfeaf,uj,ucf,hvucjy

cuuw?**qqq"}mykie"mjl*ejm*99566813*Dfuufy},uj,Mjllhbe,hbe,]uhnn,Mjddfaf,Xvfuuh,Mkuhefd,Ojvybhd

cuuw?**qqq"}mykie"mjl*ejm*9=867791*Wh`k}uhb,Hyl{,ucyjvac,f{f},jn,Wh`k}uhbk,Afbfyhd}

cuuw?**qqq"}mykie"mjl*ejm*9=178589*Qhy,jn,Kbefwfbefbmf,jn,8361

cuuw?**qqq"}mykie"mjl*ejm*998719=3*CK]UJY[


5/5

cuuw?**qqq"}mykie"mjl*ejm*98>;=31=*Kbej,Wh`,Qhy},8;51,18,H,]UYHUFAKM,HBE,JWFYHUKJBHD,

HBHD[]K],I[,H,C,HLKB,UCK],IJJ@,MHB,IF,WYKBUFE,NYJL,UCK],]KUF

Documents

The Battle in Pakistan is Over Resources-Islam just used as a tool to justify ethnic chauvinism