The early repolarization variant—an electrocardiographic enigma

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/2/2019 The early repolarization variantan electrocardiographic enigma

    1/10

    The early repolarization variantan electrocardiographic enigma

    with both QRS and J-STT anomaliesB

    John P. Boineau, MD4

    Division of Cardiology, Department of Medicine, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, MO, USA

    Division of Cardiothoracic Surgery, Department of Surgery, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, MO, USA

    Department of Biomedical Engineering, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, MO, USA

    Abstract A detailed description of the electrocardiogram of the early repolarization variant, including its most

    common morphological variations is presented. Included is a recently identified anomaly of the QRS

    complex, which has not previously been reported. Ventricular activation data is presented to explain

    the unique QRS changes. A comparison with Wolff-Parkinson-White (preexcitation) reveals certain

    similarities related to a premature completion of depolarization in early repolarization variant.

    D 2007 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

    Keywords: Electrocardiogram; Early repolarizationvariant; Left ventricularhypertrophy (bAthlete heartQ); Early depolarization

    Introduction

    The electrocardiogram (ECG) of early repolarization

    variant (ERPV) is familiar to all cardiologists and consid-

    ered to be a benign condition (Fig. 1). The most notable

    characteristic of the ECG is ST-segment elevation. If thesubject is young, healthy, and in no distress, it is usually

    interpreted as benign early repolarization. However, if a

    patient presents with chest pain, he is often admitted to rule

    out acute myocardial infarction or pericarditis.

    Early repolarization is initiated by and, thus, immediately

    follows early depolarization. In addition, early repolariza-

    tion and late depolarization are occurring simultaneously in

    the heart and their separate effects are superimposed near

    the end of QRS in the ECG. Because of this superimposi-

    tion, ST elevation is only noticeable after the end of QRS

    with termination of the dominant activation wavefronts.

    Thus, there is usually some bnormalQ early repolarization in

    most ECGs, and perhaps, bexaggerated repolarizationQ

    would be a more appropriate designation for ERPV. Reports

    have described the features of ERPV in young adults and a

    predominance in blacks and other melanotic subjects.1-8

    Early repolarization variant consists of different ECG

    anomalies involving both QRS and ST-T. Although the

    unusual repolarization features are well recognized, except

    for the frequently observed increases in voltage, the atypical

    QRS features have received no attention.

    In a subsequent report, the theory is advanced that several

    previously unrelated cardiac findings, including athletesheart, sudden death in active and apparently normal young

    individuals, cardiomyopathy, and some sudden death related

    to inappropriate adrenergic stimulation or drugs (cocaine,

    etc) may be related to a common mechanism which is

    expressed as ERPV in the ECG. Although there is no

    established link between ERPV and either sudden death or

    cardiomyopathy, one study reported an association between

    hypertrophic obstructive cardiomyopathy and ERPV.9

    The purpose of the present report is to (1) describe the

    different morphological types of the early repolarization

    pattern which are quite variable, (2) point out previously

    unreported anomalies of the QRS complex in subjectswith early repolarization ST elevation and J waves, and (3)

    demonstrate ventricular activation mechanisms of the

    unique QRS pattern, which have some similarities to those

    in the preexcitation syndrome.

    Electrocardiographic description of the ERPV

    Because of individualvariability, poor resolutionof standard

    gain and speed ECGs, and foremost, the lengthening effect of

    left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) on the QRS and QT

    intervals, which is often associated with ERPV, quantitative

    0022-0736/$ see front matterD 2007 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.doi:10.1016/j.jelectrocard.2006.05.001

    B Supported in part by National Institutes of Health grant numbers 5

    R01 HL33277 and 5 R01 HL33722 and Veterans Administration

    grant 1013.

    4 Washington University School of Medicine, Box 8234, St. Louis,

    MO 63110, USA. Tel.: +1 314 362 8311; fax: +1 314 361 8706.

    E-mail address: [email protected]

    Journal of Electrocardiology 40 (2007) 3.e13.e10

    www.elsevier.com/locate/jelectrocard

  • 8/2/2019 The early repolarization variantan electrocardiographic enigma

    2/10

    comparisons between depolarization and repolarization dura-

    tions in normal and ERPV subjects did not prove to be useful.

    Repolarization J-STT waveforms

    This interval begins with the end of the S wave of the

    QRS complex or at the J junction and is introduced by the

    positive J wave. It is assumed that the J wave represents a

    repolarization event, and mapping data will be presented

    later to confirm this.

    The pattern of the ST elevation varies in morphology,

    degree, and location. It can also be dynamic, the pattern

    changing in degree from one recording to the next. In

    addition, with sinus tachycardia, exercise, or dobutamine

    stress testing, much or all of the ST elevation disappears. In

    the most frequently observed pattern (Fig. 2, panels 1A-C),

    the elevated ST segment is introduced by a small positive

    knoblike deflection at the end of QRS, referred to as a Jwave, resembling the Osborn wave of hypothermia.10 The J

    is followed by a cuplike ST-segment elevation and a terminal

    positive T wave. This pattern resembles a bwestern saddleQ

    with horn, seat, and back rest corresponding to the J wave,

    ST segment, and T wave, respectively. The T wave can be tall

    and peaked (panel 1C). In panel 1D, the ST is bdomedQ and

    associated with a terminally negative T wave; this type is

    most often confused with acute myocardial infarction. Less

    frequently observed is the type (panel 1E) where there is no

    obvious J wave, a domed ST elevation, and a small or

    indistinct T wave.

    The location of the maximal ST elevation is also variable.The most common pattern is for the maximal ST elevation

    and most obvious J wave to be located in chest leads V3 and

    V4, referred to here as apical early repolarization (Fig. 2,

    panel 1). Maximal ERPV can also occur more laterally (leads

    I, aVL, V5, and V6), inferiorly (leads II, III, and aVF; Fig. 2,panel 3), and anteriorly (leads V1 and V2; Fig. 2, panel 2).

    The ST segment can be reciprocally depressed in lead aVR

    which bviewsQ the basal left ventricular (LV) opening and the

    negative side of the repolarization field projecting toward the

    apex. These patterns suggest variation in the regional

    distribution of the early repolarization. Certain ECGs with

    anterior ERPV resemble Brugada syndrome.

    QRS waveforms

    QRS is also anomalous in many ECGs of subjects with

    ERPV, exhibiting increased amplitude and a unique

    morphologic asymmetry. An increased amplitude of QRS

    is often present and has been described. The QRS voltageis greatest in young subjects with ERPV and can persist

    into late adult life. Initial QRS is also atypical in many

    subjects with ERPV. In many subjects with ERPV, there is

    an initial slurring (slowing), which is subtly similar to the

    delta wave in Wolff-Parkinson-White (WPW). This deflec-

    tion can be followed by an ascending R wave with a

    reduced slope angle. The slower ascending R contrasts with

    the more rapid descent of the intrinsicoid deflection (Fig. 2,

    panel 1B [arrow]). This results in a QRS complex which

    resembles a bleaning tower.Q The ID is so fast that the QRS

    appears to end prematurely. In some subjects, this is

    associated with apparent QRS brevity (b70 milliseconds).In other subjects, the upward sloping part of QRS can take

    Fig. 1. An example of ERPV with marked ST elevation in an apparently healthy 26-year-old black man. Only the chest leads (V 1-V6) are shown. Note that the

    maximum ST elevation is in leads V3 and V4, has the typical bwestern saddleQ pattern, and is introduced by a prominent J wave.

    J.P. Boineau / Journal of Electrocardiology 40 (2007) 3.e13.e103.e2

  • 8/2/2019 The early repolarization variantan electrocardiographic enigma

    3/10

    longer to reach its maximum peak, and even the fast ID

    cannot abbreviate the total interval. In certain subjects, theshort QRS duration and fast descent of the intrinsicoid

    deflection are more prominent than the ST elevation, which

    may be minimal. These individuals might not be identified

    with the ERPV group except for a prominent J wave and

    atypical QRS features.

    Variations in ERPV

    Variations in the ECG patterns of ERPV are shown for

    8 subjects in Fig. 3. Only the chest leads are displayed.

    Fig. 3A represents the most frequently observed pattern with

    the western saddle J wave, STE, and positive T wave, all

    maximal in leads V3, V4, and V5. Electrocardiograms Athrough E exhibit a short QRS duration and rapid

    intrinsicoid deflection. Initial QRS slurring with sloping

    ascending R wave (leaning tower) is shown in 3B. TheST segment in 3C is domelike, and the T wave is inverted.

    Fig. 3D illustrates another example in which the J wave is

    not as obvious. Panels E through H represent patterns of

    anterior ERPV where the principal features, including the

    J wave and STE, are maximal in leads V1 and V2. Fig. 3E

    illustrates anterior ERPV, where ST elevation and J wave are

    maximal and associated with early R-wave progression in

    chest leads V1 and V2. Panels F and G are examples of

    anterior ERPV in association with an rsrV complex in V1and V2. Note the fusion of separate late QRS forces and

    the J wave. Panel H represents anterior ERPV with a broad

    rV

    complex merging gradually with a down sloping STE inthe anterior chest leads (Brugada-like).

    Fig. 2. Different ECG patterns of early repolarization. Panels numbered 1, 2, 3 designate three different spatial locations of maximal ST elevation and J-waves.

    A, B, C, etc, refer to morphologic variations in the pattern of early repolarization within each group.

    J.P. Boineau / Journal of Electrocardiology 40 (2007) 3.e13.e10 3.e3

  • 8/2/2019 The early repolarization variantan electrocardiographic enigma

    4/10

    Summarizing, the ECG in ERPV is characterized by

    (1) increased QRS voltage, (2) an asymmetric QRS complex

    with slurring and a reduced slope angle of the ascending

    positive R wave, (3) an extremely rapid intrinsicoid deflec-

    tion, (4) a prominent J wave, and (5) different morphologic

    forms and spatial distributions of ST elevation.

    Short and nonuniform QT interval in ERPV

    The J-STT interval appears atypically short in some

    subjects with ERPVand can become exceedingly short with

    sinus tachycardia (Fig. 4). In Fig. 4, note that in addition to

    the uniformly shortened QT in panel A, there are bifed T

    waves in the ECGs of subjects shown in panels C and D.

    This bifed morphology can be interpreted as a form of

    repolarization heterogeneity in which the first T peak (T1)

    represents a greater degree of Q-T shortening in one area

    and less shortening in other areas (T2). In addition, it is not

    rare to observe a third peak in certain subjects. Whether this

    represents a third region of latest repolarization or a

    nonrepolarizaton U wave event is unclear. As mentioned,

    the repolarization duration is difficult to assess usingstandard QT interval rate correcting algorithms. There is a

    tendency for LVH to prolong the QT electromechanical

    interval which further complicates comparative QT assess-

    ment in ERPV. Although the J-STT can be short, the QT

    may be normal due to the effect of LVH, which tends to

    prolong QRS. Thus, if both QRS and J-STT intervals are

    short, the QT is short. However, if J-STT is short and QRS

    is long, then QT will be normal or prolonged. In spite of this

    ambiguity, nonuniform repolarization shortening may be

    detected as T-wave asymmetry.

    Left ventricular hypertrophy with ERPV

    Unlike other subjects with typical LVH with secondary

    ST depression and T-wave inversion (typical LV strain

    pattern; Fig. 5A), the ECG in patients with combined LVH

    and ERPV can exhibit ST elevation in association with

    T-wave inversion. Instead of the usual degree of ST

    elevation of ERPV, the J junction can be depressed, but

    ST demonstrates a domelike upward convexity (Fig. 5B) in

    contrast to the typical LV strain pattern (Fig. 5A). This

    represents the combined and opposed interaction of

    repolarization changes due to LVH and the ERPV. InERPV with LVH, the ECG can exhibit marked anterior

    Fig. 3. Different ECG examples of early repolarization. Panels A through D demonstrate morphologic variations in QRS and ST-T in four subjects. Panels E

    through H are four other subjects in which the ST elevation and J-wave are expressed maximally in the anterior chest leads, VI and V2.

    J.P. Boineau / Journal of Electrocardiology 40 (2007) 3.e13.e103.e4

  • 8/2/2019 The early repolarization variantan electrocardiographic enigma

    5/10

    Fig. 4. Short and nonuniform QT in ERPV. Note the ST elevation with short QT in A and B and with nonuniform short QT in C and D, which demonstrate

    two T-peaks.

    Fig. 5. Left ventricular hypertrophy and early repolarization. Classical LVH QRS and ST-T patterns are shown in A to compare with LVH plus earlyrepolarization in B and C.

    J.P. Boineau / Journal of Electrocardiology 40 (2007) 3.e13.e10 3.e5

  • 8/2/2019 The early repolarization variantan electrocardiographic enigma

    6/10

    T-wave inversion (V1-V3) due to exaggeration of the type

    of ERPV shown in Fig. 3C and is incorrectly referred to as

    banterior ischemia.Q

    QRS duration is often increased in subjects with typical

    LVH (90-130 milliseconds). However, in some subjects

    with LVH and ERPV, QRS duration may be normal or

    appear paradoxically abbreviated. In patients who have

    both ERPV and LVH, the slurring/sloping of the initial

    QRS limb is even further exaggerated and often associated

    with prominent notching (Fig. 5C). Note the slurring and

    sloping of the ascending R wave, which contrasts with the

    rapid intrinsicoid deflection. Also note the earlier T peak

    (T1) and later T (T2 or U wave) in lead V4. Occasionally,

    as many as 3 repolarization peaks (T1, T2,and a U ) are

    observed in subjects with LVH and ERPV. In Fig. 5C,

    although the total durations of QRS and Q-U are

    prolonged, the rapid QRS intrinsicoid deflection and earlier

    T peak are consistent with local regions of shortened

    activation and repolarization.

    Methodsactivation mapping

    Normal transmural LV activation in canines

    Fig. 6 demonstrates activation across the LV wall,

    recorded in 2 dogs, and is intended as a normal reference

    for comparison with the atypical depolarization in Figs. 7

    and 8. The maps of the isochronal depolarization sequence

    were constructed from 5 to 6 needle or bplungeQ electrodes

    inserted through the LV wall from epicardium to endocar-

    dium. Each needle contained from 15 to 20 electrode-

    recording terminals with precisely 1-mm spacing. Bipolarpotentials were recorded between adjacent electrode pairs.

    The isochrones were constructed by connecting points of

    equivalent activation time on each needle. Fig. 6A

    demonstrates a typical normal spread of the activation from

    the endocardium toward the epicardium. In Fig. 6B, in the

    region of the anterior papillary muscle, the depolarization is

    slightly more complex. Again, there is outward endocardial-

    to-epicardial spread in the LV wall and, simultaneously,

    spread in the papillary muscle from its basal attachment

    inward toward the cavity.

    Mechanism of shortened depolarization in a canine

    Fig. 7A illustrates a cross section of the LV in anotherdog. A unique transmural activation pattern of this same

    cross section is shown in B. In contrast to the typical

    unidirectional endocardial-to-epicardial activation shown in

    Fig. 6, the earliest activation in this animal was initiated at

    a deep intramural level in the LV midwall. Thereafter, the

    wavefronts spread circumferentially (elliptically) in all

    directions, both toward the endocardium and epicardium

    simultaneously. The mechanism of this unique onset and

    spread of activation is indicated by the cross-sectional

    anatomy in panel C. This is an immediately adjacent

    section of the LV, only a few millimeters distant to the one

    mapped in panel A. Note that the endocardium is deeplyinvaginated into the wall, carrying the endocardial Purkinje

    fibers intramurally to a mid-LV level (arrows). This effect

    of increased trabeculation decreases the transmural distance

    that the wavefronts travel at the normal velocity and

    shortens the transmural activation time to 25 milliseconds.

    This unique type of LV activation results in an approxi-

    mately 37% reduction in the transmural activation time.

    Note that the axial component is faster than the endo-

    cardial-to-epicardial spread, which is related to the

    predominant fiber orientation, because activation is faster

    in the long axis of parallel fiber bundles than cross-

    fiber spread.11

    Activation data in a human subject with ERPV

    Fig. 8A illustrates lead V4 in a patient with ERPV

    before epicardial activation mapping at the time of

    coronary artery bypass grafting. Note the short QRS

    duration, fast intrinsicoid deflection, and J wave introduc-

    ing the elevated ST segment. QRS duration from onset to

    peak is 40 milliseconds, and the intrinsicoid deflection

    from R peak to J wave is 15 milliseconds. Excluding the Jwave, total QRS duration is only 55 to 60 milliseconds in

    this lead. Fig. 8B demonstrates the anterolateral and

    posteroinferior aspects of the heart, and epicardial activa-

    tion times are indicated for 36 locations recorded

    simultaneously. Activation time numbers also represent

    Fig. 6. Normal transmural depolarization in 2 dogs is illustrated. Panel A

    demonstrates typical activation isochrones representing the wave front

    spreading from the endocardial surface outward toward the epicardium.

    Panel B demonstrates normal activation in the region of the papillary

    muscle. Activation times are in milliseconds, and the positions of the wave

    front at each 10-millisecond interval are indicated at the boundary betweenthe different time zones.

    J.P. Boineau / Journal of Electrocardiology 40 (2007) 3.e13.e103.e6

  • 8/2/2019 The early repolarization variantan electrocardiographic enigma

    7/10

    the locations of the electrodes, and the unipolar electro-gram associated with each electrode is displayed to the

    right of the recording site. At the time of this early digital

    recording (1980), the purpose (then) was to focus only on

    activation. The total repolarization interval of the electro-

    gram was not digitized and cannot be demonstrated.

    However, data relevant to ventricular depolarization,

    QRS brevity, and the J wave are present. Several points

    are emphasized:

    1. A wide area of the LV surface anteriorly and

    posteriorly was depolarized between 50 and 60

    milliseconds or within 10 milliseconds (gray zone),

    and this correlated with the rapid intrinsicoiddeflection in the ECG. Only the lateral LV margin

    and basal regions of the posterior LV and right

    ventricle (RV) activated later than 60 milliseconds.

    This LV epicardial activation brevity with such a

    large surface completed within a 10-millisecond

    window is atypical.12

    2. Note the prominent J waves (arrows) at several, but

    not all, epicardial sites. Particularly note the larger J

    complexes indicated by the larger arrows in the

    anterior LV at sites activating at 51 and 54 milli-

    seconds and posteroinferiorly at LV and RV sites.

    Smaller arrows indicate less prominent J waves atadditional epicardial sites in LV and RV.

    3. Observe t hat all of t he J waves occur aft er completion of epicardial depolarization at each site,

    that is, after the rapid (negative) intrinsic deflections.

    These data indicate that the J wave is a postactiva-

    tion complex and represents an anomaly of early

    repolarization.

    The circles on the anterior and posterior LV in panel B

    indicate the locations of two 20-point bplungeQ electrodes

    such as those used in the canines. The encircled values

    represent the activation times of the electrode points closest

    to the epicardium. Fig. 8C is a representative cross section

    approximately midway between apex and base, and super-

    imposed is transmural activation recorded from these2 locations. Although activation in the anterior wall began

    at the endocardium and spread unidirectionally and outward

    toward the epicardium, depolarization in the postero-

    inferior wall began deep intramurally at the midventricular

    level and spread bidirectionally toward epicardium and

    endocardium simultaneously. As a result, posterior wall

    activation terminated earlier (42 milliseconds), compared

    with 59 milliseconds in the anterior wall (D = 17 milli-

    seconds). Although it cannot be demonstrated from this one

    electrode, it is assumed that the posterior depolarization

    spread circumferentially (elliptically) from this midwall

    site, forming a highly canceling electromotive field as in thedog in Fig. 7.

    Fig. 7. Bidirectional transmural activation from the mid-LV wall toward the endocardium and epicardium due to deep penetration (invagination) of the

    endocardium containing the Purkinje system in a dog in panel B, recorded from the LV cross section shown in panel A. Panel C illustrates the adjacent LV cross

    section demonstrating the marked endocardial invagination carrying the Purkinje fibers (arrows) deeply into the midmyocardium.

    J.P. Boineau / Journal of Electrocardiology 40 (2007) 3.e13.e10 3.e7

  • 8/2/2019 The early repolarization variantan electrocardiographic enigma

    8/10

    Discussion

    Comparison of early repolarization and

    preexcitation (WPW)

    To emphasize and explain certain features of the ERPV

    ECG, it is compared with the ECG in WPW for which

    mechanisms have been established.13,14 Fig. 9 compares the

    ECG of a subject with ERPV (panel A) with that of a patient

    with ventricular preexcitation (panel B). Only the lateral

    chest leads (V4-V6) are illustrated for this comparison. Note

    the subtle similarity of the initial QRS slurring and sloping

    in ERPV (panel A) to the delta wave and more exaggerated

    sloping in the patient with preexcitation (panel B). Thus,

    initial QRS in ERPV can resemble a mini delta wave.

    However, in contrast to WPW, the PR segment is not

    abolished, and the QRS is not wide.

    Slurring and reduced sloping of QRS is typically absent

    when there is normal rapid expansion and abrupt extin-

    guishing of multiple opposing wavefronts. This action

    results in fast swings in the deflections. In contrast, slurringor exaggerated sloping of QRS occurs in conditions where

    focal, noncompeting activation is occurring, as in WPW.

    The mechanism of the early QRS changes in ERPV is

    explained by the activation data obtained in that subject

    (Fig. 8). This initial slurring is related to the local

    depolarization of the anterior wall and septum in which

    the opposing effects of posterior wall activation have been

    minimized. Because of the deep midwall onset of activation

    in the posterolateral wall, with wavefronts spreading in all

    directions, that is, midwall to both epicardium and

    endocardium and axially, the spherical or closed electro-

    motive surface of this wavefront results in maximal local

    cancellation effects. Thus, the outward, endocardial-to-

    epicardial activation in the opposite anteroapical wall has

    minimal competition. Although not preexcited as in WPW,

    the local anterolateral activation in ERPV is, nevertheless,

    relatively unopposed early in QRS and dominates and

    produces the sloping and slurring. Thus, it is the

    unbalanced activation of the anterior LV succeeded by

    the rapid and premature termination of the remaining LV

    depolarization that coincides sequentially with the initial

    sloping of QRS, followed by the fast intrinsicoid deflection

    in ERPV.The initial QRS sloping is further enhanced by LVH

    because of the larger and longer-lasting wavefronts moving

    outward in the thickened septal and anterior walls. In some

    Fig. 8. Ventricular activation in a patient with ERPV. Panel A illustrates the ECG recorded from lead V 4. Panel B demonstrates the epicardial activation

    sequence and unipolar electrograms recorded from the anterior and inferoposterior aspects of the ventricles. Transmural activation in the same subject is shownin panel C. The data were recorded from two 20-point needle electrodes inserted into the anterior and posteroinferior LV. See text.

    J.P. Boineau / Journal of Electrocardiology 40 (2007) 3.e13.e103.e8

  • 8/2/2019 The early repolarization variantan electrocardiographic enigma

    9/10

    subjects with ERPV and LVH, a longer activation time of

    the anterior LV results in a wider QRS and later ID, which

    can overlap and mask the J-wave and the early ST elevation.

    In those subjects, the early J is obscured and its terminal

    component is merged with late QRS and appears as a

    terminal QRS notch or slope.Questions relating to what anatomic mechanisms

    underlie the atypical midwall activation process must also

    be addressed. It is postulated that this is due to

    exaggerated LV endocardial trabeculation. Both the canine

    and human activation data implicate an increased trabe-

    culation with greater depths of endocardial invagination,

    carrying the Purkinje system deeper into the midmyocar-

    dium. Studies in various animal species demonstrate an

    increased trabeculation and endocardial invagination as a

    basis for a more rapid activation of a thicker LV wall.15

    Diffusely distributed LV trabeculation should even further

    narrow the total QRS duration. Another feature sometimesobserved in subjects with ERPV and short QRS duration

    is high-frequency notching of QRS complexes in some

    leads. These fine, fast notches are usually best visualized

    in low-voltage transitional leads where major activation

    events do not compete. This type of notching may result

    from changing discontinuities in wavefronts propagating

    through a highly trabeculated subendocardium.

    In addition to the similarities in QRS, note that there is

    also a pattern of ERPV ST elevation introduced by a J

    wave in the subject with WPW. This is due in part to the

    premature completion of depolarization which, by its

    advancement, exposes the J and early ST, which might

    otherwise be obscured by late QRS in both ERPV and

    WPW. In addition, because of the earlier termination and

    reordering of activation and, secondarily, repolarization

    in the posterior LV walls, there are diminished outward

    posterior repolarization forces to counterbalance those of

    the anterior LV, and this exaggerates the anteroapical

    J-STE deflections in both conditions. Thus, at least some

    part of the J-STT anomaly is contributed or exaggerated by

    alterations in the phase and distribution of activation and,secondarily, repolarization. An issue in ERPV is whether

    the QRS and ST-T anomalies are separate and unrelated

    but linked by some common genetic polymorphism or

    whether the ST-T changes are all secondary to the QRS

    changes. That the J-STE morphology can be seen in

    subjects with longer QRS duration and also that subjects

    with very narrow QRS can have minimal ST elevation

    implicate separate primary alterations in both depolariza-

    tion and repolarization phases.

    As in most natural systems, different morphological

    features are usually associated with certain specific func-

    tions or effects, bnothing exists for no reason.Q In the

    following publication, a two-part theory involving both the

    electrophysiologic and electromechanical systems in ERPV,

    as well as possible consequences of these anomalies, is

    presented along with certain supporting clinical evidence for

    the concepts.

    References

    1. Littman D. Persistence of the juvenile pattern in precordial leads of

    healthy adult Negroes with a report of electrocardiographic survey on

    300 Negro and 200 white subjects. Am Heart J 1946;32:370.

    2. Goldman MJ. RS-T segment elevation in mid- and left precordial leads

    as normal variant. Am Heart J 1953;46:817.3. Grusin H. Peculiarities of the Africans electrocardiogram and the

    changes observed in serial studies. Circulation 1954;19:251.

    4. Greene CE, Kelly JJ. Electrocardiograms of the healthy adult Negro.

    Circulation 1959;20:906.

    5. Morace G, Padeletti L, Porciani MC, Fantini F. Effects of isopro-

    terenol on the bearly repolarizationQ syndrome. Am Heart J 1979;

    97:343.

    6. Mirvis DM. Evaluation of normal variations in S-Tsegment patterns by

    body surface isopotential mapping: S-T segment elevation in absence

    of heart disease. Am J Cardiol 1982;50:122.

    7. Guillem JP, Haissaguerre M, et al. Echocardiographic study of the

    early repolarization syndrome. Demonstration of dynamic obstruction

    with isoprenaline. Apropos of 16 cases. Arch Mal Coeur Vaiss 1988;

    81(2):199.

    8. Spodick DH. Early repolarization: an underinvestigated misnomer.Clin Cardiol 1997;20:913.

    Fig. 9. Comparison of ECGs V4-V6 in a subject with ERPV (A) and a

    patient with ventricular preexcitation (B). Note the similarities in both QRS

    and J, ST-T. See text for explanation.

    J.P. Boineau / Journal of Electrocardiology 40 (2007) 3.e13.e10 3.e9

  • 8/2/2019 The early repolarization variantan electrocardiographic enigma

    10/10

    9. Surawicz B, Parikh SR. Prevalence of male and female patterns of early

    ventricular repolarization in the normal ECG of males and females

    from childhood to old age. J Am Coll Cardiol 2002;40:1870.

    10. Osborn JJ. Experimental hypothermia. Respiratory and blood pH

    changes in relation to cardiac function. Am J Physiol 1953;175:389.

    11. Spach MS, Miller WTI, Dolber PC, Kootsey JM, Sommer JR, Mosher

    CE. The functional role of structural complexities in the propagation

    of depolarization in the atrium of the dog: cardiac conduction dis-

    turbances due to discontinuities of effective axial resistivity. Circ Res1982;50:175.

    12. Durrer D, Van Dam R, et al. Total excitation of isolated human heart.

    Circulation 1970;41:899.

    13. Boineau JP, Moore EN. Evidence for propagation of activation across

    an accessory atrioventricular connection in types A and B pre-

    excitation. Circulation 1970;41:375.

    14. Boineau JP, Moore EN, Spear JF, Sealy WC. Basis of static and

    dynamic eletrocardiographic variations in Wolff-Parkinson-White

    syndrome. Am J Cardiol 1973;32:32.

    15. Durrer D, Van der Tweel. Excitation of the left ventricular wall of thedog and goat. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1957;65:779.

    J.P. Boineau / Journal of Electrocardiology 40 (2007) 3.e13.e103.e10