21
Greenbaum: The Final Hour, pg.1 The Final Hour Article by the composer July 2019 The composer Having studied composition with Broadstock and Conyngham at the University of Melbourne, Stuart Greenbaum holds a position at the Melbourne Conservatorium of Music as Professor and Head of Composition. He is the author of over 200 works including 15 sonatas, 7 string quartets, 5 piano trios, 5 concertos, 4 symphonies and 2 operas. Words and music Stuart Greenbaum and Ross Baglin have been working together since 1985 when they met in Doncaster, Melbourne. It was night and raining heavily. Stuart auditioned to join Ross’s band, The Front. They never performed live, but wrote a lot of pop songs. And two operas (Nelson and The Parrot Factory), a dozen choral works and numerous art songs. Their major choral works include The Foundling, commissioned by Cantori New York in 1997 and From the Beginning commissioned for the sesquicentenary of the Royal Melbourne Philharmonic in 2003. Concept Albums I have always been drawn to the idea of concept albums. Four that have been notably influential for me are Pink Floyd’s Dark Side of the Moon (1973), Mike Oldfield’s Tubular Bells (1973), Jean-Michel Jarre’s Oxygene (1976) and Pat Metheny Group’s The Way Up (2005). The overlapping tracks and unifying themes intensify the cumulative experience. For many years I had this idea of making a ‘concept album’. It’s hard to use the term ‘album’ without also thinking ‘vinyl’. But it wasn’t 33 revolutions per–minute that that was playing on my mind. And neither necessarily was the term ‘concept’ – shouldn’t that be a given for any work of art? Rightly or not, the concept album is a relatively specific genre. Aligned with progressive rock, concept albums tend to feature extended duration, are often largely instrumental and feature overlapping tracks (or segues), frequently changing or unusual time signatures and extended harmonies; all tied together by a unifying theme. I taught Pink Floyd’s Dark Side of the Moon (1973) for over 20 years in a 2 nd year undergraduate subject (Electro-Acoustic Music) and enjoyed all the conversations with students about what is wonderful and/or flawed about it. I think what I love most about it is the intention. That pop/rock might be more than an incidental playlist. That it might aspire to grander structural design. For the same reason, I’m also very engaged by Mike Oldfield’s Tubular Bells (same year, 1973). Granted, some of that album is arguably dated (strange voices, out of tune timpani, a second–half that runs out of ideas). But certain sections are highly memorable and Oldfield’s aspiration towards something symphonic still seems a worthy quest. The 70’s, in general, was a fertile decade for further exploration of The Beatles’ Sgt. Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band (1967) and beyond. Before returning to my own music, I would also cite Miles Davis and Pelle Mikkelborg, Aura (1985), Steve Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be concept albums in the 1970’s prog-rock sense, but which have been influential in determining what I wanted my own to be. Perhaps most of all, the albums of Pink Floyd from the early 70’s onward was what seemed most striking. And in particular, the brooding instrumental

The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    8

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.1

TheFinalHourArticlebythecomposerJuly2019ThecomposerHavingstudiedcompositionwithBroadstockandConynghamattheUniversityofMelbourne,StuartGreenbaumholdsapositionattheMelbourneConservatoriumofMusicasProfessorandHeadofComposition.Heistheauthorofover200worksincluding15sonatas,7stringquartets,5pianotrios,5concertos,4symphoniesand2operas.WordsandmusicStuartGreenbaumandRossBaglinhavebeenworkingtogethersince1985whentheymetinDoncaster,Melbourne.Itwasnightandrainingheavily.StuartauditionedtojoinRoss’sband,TheFront.Theyneverperformedlive,butwrotealotofpopsongs.Andtwooperas(NelsonandTheParrotFactory),adozenchoralworksandnumerousartsongs.TheirmajorchoralworksincludeTheFoundling,commissionedbyCantoriNewYorkin1997andFromtheBeginningcommissionedforthesesquicentenaryoftheRoyalMelbournePhilharmonicin2003.

ConceptAlbumsIhavealwaysbeendrawntotheideaofconceptalbums.FourthathavebeennotablyinfluentialformearePinkFloyd’sDarkSideoftheMoon(1973),MikeOldfield’sTubularBells(1973),Jean-MichelJarre’sOxygene(1976)andPatMethenyGroup’sTheWayUp(2005).Theoverlappingtracksandunifyingthemesintensifythecumulativeexperience.FormanyyearsIhadthisideaofmakinga‘conceptalbum’.It’shardtousetheterm‘album’withoutalsothinking‘vinyl’.Butitwasn’t33revolutionsper–minutethatthatwasplayingonmymind.Andneithernecessarilywastheterm‘concept’–shouldn’tthatbeagivenforanyworkofart?Rightlyornot,theconceptalbumisarelativelyspecificgenre.Alignedwithprogressiverock,conceptalbumstendtofeatureextendedduration,areoftenlargelyinstrumentalandfeatureoverlappingtracks(orsegues),frequentlychangingorunusualtimesignaturesandextendedharmonies;alltiedtogetherbyaunifyingtheme.ItaughtPinkFloyd’sDarkSideoftheMoon(1973)forover20yearsina2ndyearundergraduatesubject(Electro-AcousticMusic)andenjoyedalltheconversationswithstudentsaboutwhatiswonderfuland/orflawedaboutit.IthinkwhatIlovemostaboutitistheintention.Thatpop/rockmightbemorethananincidentalplaylist.Thatitmightaspiretogranderstructuraldesign.Forthesamereason,I’malsoveryengagedbyMikeOldfield’sTubularBells(sameyear,1973).Granted,someofthatalbumisarguablydated(strangevoices,outoftunetimpani,asecond–halfthatrunsoutofideas).ButcertainsectionsarehighlymemorableandOldfield’saspirationtowardssomethingsymphonicstillseemsaworthyquest.The70’s,ingeneral,wasafertiledecadeforfurtherexplorationofTheBeatles’Sgt.PeppersLonelyHeartsClubBand(1967)andbeyond.Beforereturningtomyownmusic,IwouldalsociteMilesDavisandPelleMikkelborg,Aura(1985),SteveReich,TheCave(1993)andPatMethenyandLyleMays,TheWayUp(2005).Theyarealsopointsofreferencethatmaynotexactlybeconceptalbumsinthe1970’sprog-rocksense,butwhichhavebeeninfluentialindeterminingwhatIwantedmyowntobe.Perhapsmostofall,thealbumsofPinkFloydfromtheearly70’sonwardwaswhatseemedmoststriking.Andinparticular,thebroodinginstrumental

Page 2: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.2

interludesinminorkeyswithlow-registerminor3rds,ostinatopatternsandeeriesounddesign–suchasSheep,fromAnimals(1997).Thishadallbeenbrewingforsometimeinmyaestheticsense.Forovertwodecadesmymusichasbeenafusionofpop,rock,jazzandminimalismwiththecanonofWesternclassicmusic.Butthishasmostlybeenpresentedinconcert–ascommissionedbysoloists,ensemblesandorchestras.It’sindicativeofthecontemporaryclassicalmusicindustrythatcomposersaregenerallycommissionedtowriteworksforperformance(whichmayormaynotbesubsequentlyrecorded).GenesisWhentheopportunitycameaboutinthesecondhalfof2013totakestudyleavesolelytowritenewmusic,itseemedagoldenopportunitytothrowmyselfheadlongintothelandoftheconceptalbum.InMay2012,Iaskedmylongstandingcollaborator,RossBaglin,towriteapoem(around500words)calledTheFinalHour.Andalsoaskedthatthepoemconcludedwiththosethreewords.Thisprocess(fromJanuary2013)tookaround8monthsandwentthrough24draftsuntilwearrivedatthetextIwantedandRosswashappywith.Behindthe24draftsliemanymoreemails,phonecalls,Skypesessionsandtheoccasionallyluxuryofworkinginthesameroom(RossisAustralianbutlivesinLondon).Iwantedtocreateacommentaryabouttheperceptionofthepassingoftimeinourmodernnew-millenniallives.Ofhowwevalueit.Anhouroftime(notjustthefinalhour)andbyextension,thedurationofalife.IusedthetextRosscreatedasastructureforaninstrumentalstudioorchestrawithelectronicsandnarrationofthetext.Combiningthewesternclassicaltraditionwithjazz,pop,electronica,sonicartsandminimalism,TheFinalHouris60minuteslong(tothenanosecond)in10overlappingsectionsinanarchformproportionedaroundtheFibonacciseries.Thereisa2–secondgapbetweenthetwohalf–hourpartsasanodtowardsflippingavinylrecordovertotheB–side.Iwrotetheshortscoreonstudyleaveinthesecondhalfof2013andorchestratedthoselinesthatcouldberepresentedinnotation(1,495bars).Havingmadeitthisfar,theideaofrealizingitinsoundseemedabridgetoofarandIpromptlyputitasidefor2years.Butearlyin2016IcaughtupwithMelbournepianistandcomposerLukeHowardoverlunchandafterwardsshowedhimthescore.ItoccurredtomethatLukewouldbetheidealpersontopushtherecordingprojectforward(notonlyasamusicianbutasaproducer).Andhewasinterestedandavailablesoworkre-commenced,includingLuke’ssuggestiontoaddarhythmsection(keys,bassanddrumkit),orchestratingthestringsection,producinginstrumentalparts,settingupMIDIandaudiotechnologyanddevelopingastrategyforrecording.Thisinvolvedrenderingsynthlinesandrecordingeachindividualmusiciantrack–by–track,layer–by–layer.Thiscontinuedoninto2017.And2018.By5December2018,theworkwasmastered.StructuralarchitectureThetwohalf–hourpartstotheworkfurtherdivideintotensections:

Page 3: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.3

section title duration(minutes)

1 prelude 1’2 pulseandpresence 3’3 memoryjar 5’4 speedingcarandbrokensignal 8’5 fateiswherelostchancesgo 13’ 6 citytowers 13’7 thistleseed 8’8 stationarytrains 5’9 theatmosphere 3’10 coda 1’

Thiscanbeshownproportionallyasagraph:1’

3’ 5’

8’ 13’

13’ 8’

5’ 3’

1’

TheexpandingsectionsrelatetotheFibonacciseriesquiteclosely,withonesmallalteration.AFibonacciseriestechnicallyshowsthesumoftheprevioustwonumbersasfollows:1,1,2,3,5,8,13etc.Thatwouldbefine,butaddsupto33andIwasseekingaseriesthatwouldaddupto30(halfanhourwhichcouldbedoubledtomakeanexacthour).SoIwentstraightfrom1to3andthenfollowedthesequence,making:1,3,5,8,13(=30)Thisisthenreversed(archform)tomakeastructureofexactly60minutes.ThepresenceofFibonacciratiosatthe‘macro’levelisalsowovenintothemiddleand‘micro’levelsasdiscussedbelowwithinthesectionanalysis.FirstmusicalsketchesWiththe60–minutestructuralscaffoldinginplace,Iwrotefragmentsofmusic(chordprogressions,melody,ostinato,rhythmiccycles)asemotionalandpsychologicalresponsestothetext.ButtheveryfirstmaterialactuallydatesbacktoApril2012:

Page 4: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.4

Thissketchfrom15April2012satinthedrawerforoverayearwithaverygeneralideaof‘TheFinalHour’andonlylaterwasspecificallyalignedwithPart2(citytowers).Probablythesecondmusicalideatoemergewasathemewrittenaroundmidnight(ahotsleeplessJanuarynight):

ThisthemeisfoundinPart1(speedingcar).

Page 5: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.5

PART11:preludeThis60–secondintroductionhasnotext.Itisaseriesoforchestraltutti‘hits’basedonaharmonicsketchoftwopitchescollapsinginwardincontrarymotion:

Itrepresentstheideaofbirthorre-birthing–metaphorsofdefibrillatorsorimplodingstarswerepartofthatconcept.Andthehits arespacedapartinbarsectionsof 2– 3– 3– 5– 8,whichhave Fibonacciproportions:

Inbetweenthesehitsarefreedrumkitfills(marked‘ominous–likethunder’)alongwithenvironmentalsoundsofoffices,trains,wineglasses,camerashutterclicksandsuch:literallyasnapshotofsoundsthatwillhaveapresenceandmeaningoverthesubsequenthourahead.

Page 6: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.6

2:pulseandpresenceThisisthefirstsectiontoincludetextnarration:Pulse.Presence.Thisalone,Andthenanother.GraftingdarknessIntoresonance,Thensenseandperiod,Fracturingtorhythm-This.Thennothing.AndanotherAndthoughtheradialclockthatstruckThisfinalhourofyourconcealment’sspanHasmouldedworldsfromcirclinghandsAndlongforgottenwhatthewrittensandsInkedintorockbeforeyourtimebeganItstopsamomentnowtotwistthestrandsOfpulseandpresenceintotime’scommand Baglinisdescribingtheemergenceofahumanlifeinutero(inthewomb).Forthissection,Icreatedarhythmiccycleof30quaversthatwouldhaveenergyandpropulsion:3+2+3 ∆|∆ 2+2+2 |||3+2+2 ∆||3+3+3 ∆∆∆Theuseofthistechnique(foundinmanyofmyworks)wasnotablyinfluencedbytwoworksfromthe1980’s–Tehillim(1981)bySteveReich;andTheFirstCircle(1984)byPatMethenyandLyleMays.Thesecellsrepresentthesmallestor‘micro’levelofFibonaccirelationshipsinthework.Andthistranslatedintoa4–barmetricalpattern:4/4+3/4+7/8+9/8Atfirst,this30–quaver,4–barpatternisfragmented,presentinganunstableoscilloscope–likeblip,torepresenttheemergenceoflife:

Page 7: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.7

ThisinturnhasharmonyoverlaidagainstthenowmoreconstantG(abovemiddleC)withalternatingshadesofminorandmajorharmonies:

Andthatisfollowedbythebeginningsofamelodythatwilllaterbecomethecentralmelodyfortheentirework:

ItisbasedaroundGmajorwithmodalalternation(Enatural/Eb)andtheemergingmelodyisanthemic,initiallyusingjust4notes(G–A–B–D)–aGmajortriadwiththeadditionoftheseconddegreeofthescale.The30–quavercycleasarhythmicmotiveappearsinsections2,4,6,9+10.Whilenotatedasabove,attimesthedrumkitisgivenlicensetoplayafullycrotchet–basedmetricalschemeagainstthat:4/4+3/4+4/4+4/4Thequaverpulseisshared/locked–ineitherway;butthiscreatesanambiguityofmetricalgrouping.Thelatterislike4barsof4/4withamissingbeat–andwithnotablyoffbeatquaversyncopationoverthefinaltwobarsof4/4.Bycontrastthewrittenmetreendingwith7/8+9/8createsan(atfirst)unpredictablealternationofcellsofeither2or3quavers.

Page 8: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.8

3:memoryjarTakeouttheglassyouplantedonceBelowasaplingtreeAndturnthelid–alockOfchild’shair,(brown,yourown)…Adesiccatedchrysalis…OneSummer’sghostofthistledown…ApictureofyourmotherDancingwithamanYouthoughttobeyourfatherUntiltheirlastproprietiesBrokeopenliketheglassUnderthetall,memorialleavesOnemorninglikethis(ThennothingThenanother).MemoryJarisaimedatportrayingthebeautyandsadnessofnostalgia.Itchangestoa3/4metreforthefirsttimeintheworkandexploitsthehemiolarelationshipsthatcomewiththat(3:2+4:3).Itislooselyinaternaryform(ABA)withthelongestsectionfirstandtheshortest(returnofA)last.Itfeaturesthefretlesselectricbassasafront-linemelodicinstrument,presentingan8–barantecedent/consequentphrase:

Theviolinandoboeanswerthisinflowingcounter–melodicstyle,firstincallandanswer,andthencomingtogether:

ThemiddleBsectionfeaturesflowingconnectedsemiquaversinprogrammed(MIDI–triggered)synthlinesthathighlightdifferentgroupings:

Page 9: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.9

Allninepitchesstartoutpannedcentreandthengraduallyfanoutacrossthefullstereofield.Theeffectismostapparentlisteningonheadphones–somewhatakintowatchinga2–dimensionalimagegraduallycometolifein3dimensions.4:speedingcarandbrokensignalThissectiondescribestheunpredictabilityofaroadaccident:Thehourholdswhathappened,howyouwalkedIntothecamera’seyeat2am,stillunafraidForwhatthehouraheadmightholdWasnotyetwhathadhappenednext:TheliquidcirclesofthecitriclightsLitlinksofraindropslikeelectricjewelsUponthewindscreenasyouturnedthekey;ThecarrodesoftlyintorollsoflightAndtheodometerquickenedoverlinesTowardthesignalflash,andthenaspeedingcarFlewlikeaboltofcolourthroughtherain-Andshop-lightsDicedtobiscuitglass,Weredancingonthetar,Brightparticlesofcircumstance.Itisbuiltoverasimplequaverostinatooscillatingbetweentwopitchesaperfect4thapart:

The8–minutestructuralarcofthis4thsectionismadeupof5elements:•soundscape(pulseless)•ostinato•travellingmotive•bridge(accident/interruption)•variationsThese5elementsplayoutinchangingorderandvariablelength,asshowninthefollowingdiagram:

Page 10: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.10

Thetravellingmotiveandvariationsaresharedbetweenfretlessbass,distortionguitarandsopranosaxophone.Ofparticularnotearethethreebridgesectionsthatreferencetheearlier30–quavergrouping–butatamuchfasterspeed(crotchet=180):

ThisearlysketchfromJuly2013wasfurtherrefinedmelodicallyandharmonically:

Thebridgeideawasintendednotonlyforoverallthematicconnection(cross-pollinationbetweensections),butalsotoconveyaheightened‘accidentalert’mode.Itinterruptsthesteadydrivingfeelofcrotchet=120bymetricmodulation;andthehighertempoofthealternatinggroupsof2and3quaversishereevenhardertopredict.Thebridgesectiongetslongereachtime,leadingtoafinalcascadingof“shop-lightsDicedtobiscuitglass…dancingonthetar”.Thisend–of–sectionclimaxincludesafrenziedsopranosaxophonesolotogetherwithsoundsofatraincrossing.Interestingly,thepoetimaginedacollisionoftwocarsatanintersection.AndIimaginedacarcollidingwithatrainatasignalcrossing.Eitherway,it’safrighteningscenariothatstandsasametaphorforthefragilityofhumanlife.

Page 11: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.11

5:fateiswherelostchancesgoFateiswhereLostchancesgoOutsidemywindow,SnowisshapedTothemaskofthewindThatblowsitscoldforgetfulnessOverallthatliesbelowThefinalsectionofPart1is13minuteslong.Andasthehandsketchbelowshows,therewasanintentiontofurthersubdividethisaccordingtoFibonacciproportions.Certainly,themiddledivisionof5+8minutesismarkedbythestartoftheextendedfretlesselectricbasssoloagainstlongstringsectionchords.Thefurthersubdivision(bottomline)madesenseonpaper,butinrealitytheoutersectionsof‘fate’utilizeanumberofmetricmodulations;andatcrotchet=50,thatsmalleststructuraldivisiondidnoteventuate.

TheopeningmotiveforfatewaswritteninJuly2013andatthattimewasseenasbeingsection4(eventuallysection5):

Inadditiontothesomewhatminimalistpianomotivewhichexpandsouttotheminor3rd,major2ndandthenminor7th,thecountermelodyinthefretlessbasspresentsthat4–notemotiveroughlyinreverse(startingwiththe7th).Aftertheopening95secondsoffate,theharmonyshiftsupamajor3rdtoF#,withmultipleguitarsdovetailedincallandanswer:

Page 12: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.12

Thesepatternsalsonotablymakeuseoftheintervalofa7th.Rhapsodicoboemelodiesareoverlaidleadingtoametricalshifttoa12/16metricalre-grouping,followedbyareturntotheguitarcounterpointin3/4.Thiscreatesasmallinternalstructuralarch,referencingthelargerglobalarchofthetwoparts.Thefretlesselectricbasssolothatcommences5minutesintofateisfullimprovisedoveratwoandahalf–minutespan,withtheinstruction:“SOLO:freely– lyrical,consoling,mystical.Makeuseofdelayand/oroverdubs(polyphony).”Additionally,thebassplayerisgivenjazzchordsymbols(Emin9,Gadd11,13etc.)thatreflecttheharmonyinthestringsunderneath.AharmonicreductionofthestringsshowsthefollowingEminor–basedprogression:

Thisisscoredin4/4,buttheharmonicshiftsaresoslowthatthemusicisalmostbeyondmetricaltime–oratleasthighlyfluid.Thebassplayer,however,hastheadvantageofclicktrackonheadphonesinrecording.Sowhiletheyarefreetogooff–the–gridmetrically,theycantargettheapproachtoeachnewchord(especiallythosewithachangedbassnote)inharmonicallymusicalways.Inmymindthisbasssolorepresentsanoasisinthemiddleofabarrenorfrozenlandscape.

Afterthefretlesselectricbasssolo,theopeningfatematerialreturns–thoughwithanumberofmotiveseitherinretrogradeorinversion.Thisovertlyreferencesthepossibilitiesofarchform.Andsotherearearches(3/4to12/16andbackto3/4),withinarches(fate)withinanoverallarchstructurefortheentirework.Thiscanbelooselyconsideredlikefractals:self–similarityonmultiplelevelsorscales.

Page 13: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.13

PART26:citytowersLikefatebeforeit,citytowersis13minuteslongin4sections:

section title duration 1 euphoria 5' 2 intrigue 4' 3 bleak 3'

4 despair 1' NightfallsaslogoscrystalliseOncitytowers,whoseabstractedlightsCutvacantdesk,andemptyscreenThattraffickedrumourthroughthedayLikestreetlightsspellinglostcommandsTosilentintersections,inthedeadofnight.Andyoursisthelastdesk,there,totheright:Yourphotos,andmug-ring,somepropertydeeds,Andhere,wherethefinalhoursarefiledTheminutesofmeetingsinmarginsofpower:Part2ofTheFinalHourstartswithpulsingenergizedsynthchordsoutliningthe4–bar,30–quavermotivefirstfoundinpulseandpresence.Theopeningdirectionforcitytowersis‘saw-toothwave–hot,electric’.Iwantedasynthpatchthatwouldbelikethesoundofelectricity.Andso,ontheadviceofmyco–producerLukeHoward,wetookalaptopdowntotheMelbourneElectronicSoundStudio(MESS)inNorthMelbournetoaccessanoriginalProphet10synthesizer,retro-fittedwithMIDItoallowittobetriggeredbycomputer:

Theanalogequipmentisnotwithoutitschallenges–ittooksometimetogetintune;andtoreliablyvoicechordsofupto9notes(5intheupperstaff,upto4inthelower).Butthesoundqualityisquitefat–arguablyricherthanasoftwareemulationversionofthesamesynth:

Page 14: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.14

This8–barphraseharmonicallyshowsmodalalternationbetweenF(add9)andFmin7(addb13).Itisrepeatedagainwithalowbassentry.Andthenthose16barsarethemselvesalsorepeated.After32bars,anotherelementisadded–ahigherregistersemiquaverarpeggiofigure:

Thislineinturnisharmonizedin3rds.Thesynthpatchforthislineincorporatesamonophonicpitch–glideeffectthatismorepronouncedthewidertheintervallicleap.Thistypeofmonosynthpatchwasnotablypopularizedinthe1970’sthroughgroupslikeEmerson,LakeandPalmeronalbumslikeBrainSaladSurgery(1973)–andtobeprecise,around4’55intoKarnEvil9.ThemonopatchusedbyKeithEmersonisagoodreferencepoint.Thealbumcreditslist‘custombuiltMoogSynthesizers’asthelikelysoundsource.Theopeningmaterialcontinuesfor120barsandthenmorphsintoahockettexturecreatedby3electricguitars.

4minutesin,thecentralanthemmotivefrompulseandpresence appearsisoverlaidintheoboe– stillnotfullyformed;butmoresothaninPart1:

Thetwo–barantecedentisansweredbytheconsequentinbars3+4.Inall,thematerial,soundandlayeringofelementsaredesignedtoconjuretheeuphoriaofbigcitieslitupatnight.Butunderneaththeelectric,neonsurfaceliesdarker,seedierrealitiesand‘euphoria’thenshiftsto‘intrigue’.ElectricguitarsgraduallyweaveacanonicwebaroundtheveryfirstmaterialcomposedforTheFinalHour:

Page 15: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.15

Theinternalrepeat(shownhereaftertwobars)wasjettisonedinfavourofusingthefull4–barphraseandallowingthesubsequentcanonicbuilduptogenerateforwardmotion.ThisclearlyreferencesSteveReich’stechniqueofsubstitutingbeatsforrests.IanalysedhisNewYorkCounterpoint(1985)formyHonoursthesisin1988.It’snotatechniqueIuseonaregularbasisinaformalway–butusingitonthismotiveisperhapsascloseasIhavecometodoingthat.Thisbuildstoanensembleclimaxatthe8–minutemarkofPart2:

It’snoaccidentthatthis4–barriffisin4/4withthefinalbardroppingacrotchet(3/4).Itaddsupto30–quavers–referencingthemainmotiveforthework.Itisrepeated3timesbeforesubsidingbacktothemutedguitarriffthatthesectionisbuiltover.Andthisinturnslidesfurtherintothe3rd‘bleak’section.Withthiscomesarepriseofthe4–bar,30–quavermetricalstructure;thoughnowmostlyintheverylowregisterwithjustoccasionalharmonyandcolourwovenoveraveryslowrateofchange–almostnothingishappening.Itcouldbeinterpretedthereforeas‘thedeadofnight’.Finally,forcitytowers,thelastminutebottomsoutinto‘despair’.Rhythmicenergydriesupleavingmostlylowsustainedorgantones,lowsustainedstringsandafretlesselectricbasssolo–alastglimmeroflighthiddenawayinadesertedunseenlanewayorbasement.7:thistleseedFromthedepthsofdespairarisesahopefulprayer:“Howheavythewindtreadsoverthereeds,Hownumbtheclock,alonewithitshours;Lord,floatmelikeathistleseedAndfindmyplacetoflower”Despitethereligiousreference,itisessentiallyasecularprayer;acalltofindplaceandpurposeinaworldmeasuredbyfinancialsuccess.Thisisrepresentedbythevoiceofasoloviolin(marked‘moody,rhapsodic–intense,lyrical’)overaglitteringsynthpedalnote.Andthisleadstotheintroductionofapianochoralmotive–adaptedfromtheearlierchant–likefigurefromfate;butnowtransformedharmonicallyintothemajor:

Page 16: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.16

Soloviolinandpianocontinuetoworkaroundeachotherleadingtoadance–likesectionbuiltaroundtripletsemiquaversinMIDI–programmedcelestesynthlines:

Thepolyphonycontinuestothickenandoverlapwiththeadditionofashufflefeelinthelivedrumkitandawritten–outsoloforthefretlesselectricbass.Whenthechoralthemereturns(againtheinfluenceofarchforms),theviolinandpianonowcometogether.

Page 17: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.17

8:stationarytrainsSomewhereinthefinalhour–Thesquare,illuminatedfaces,Singinginthebaseofaglass,Constructinghalf-rememberedsongsFromlong-crematedyears,IsawthefearstartinyoureyeAndtwistlikewatertoadrain;Thathopeandpromisewouldnotcomeagain,AnddawnwasknockingLikeabailiffatabrokendoor.Then,whenthefinalhourhadstruck,YouturnedandraisedthewindowblindandsawAthistle’sarmour,rustingonamoorOfstationarytrainsAmoonthecolourofwinterrain.Thissectionrecapitulatesthematerialofspeedingcartoahighdegree–thoughnotnecessarilyinthesamephraselengthororder.It’snowa5–minutesection(ratherthan8)andfurtherdividesinto3’+2’.After3minutes,wegetoneofthelongestcontinuousspeechnarrativesagainstsemiquaverpatternflow.Andthen,towardtheend,thereisvariationoftheanthemmaterial:a7–crotchetphrasecastin4/4+3/4initiallyinthepiano:

Whilethisisanewmetricalpattern,thefirst3notesoftheupperline(scaledegrees1,2+5)are,ofcourse,thefirst3notesofthemainanthemicmotivefortheentirework.So,whileitcreatesanotable(ifquiet)arrival,itishighlyconnectedtothefabricofthework.

Page 18: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.18

9:theatmosphereAndnowthefinalhourisopeningoutLikebackwardmusic,slowcadenzaOfthemitochondrion;theteemingstarsAreghostedonthedustandracingIntorealmsoflight,burning,dyingInthecauldronoftheblast,Aswehurry,andrummageOntheoutskirtsofamortalstarMakeloveinthemidstofmyriaddislocations,AndfeeltheorchestraofcellsdissolveAtlasttoimpersonaldissonance;Thesuntreadsatomsintoflame,Alifetimeshapesaboutyourname,AndfarabovetheatmosphereIsvaultedwithcoldtomorrowsAsthememoryjaropens,thechrysalisfliesThethistledownseedescapesintoflower,AndaspiralunwindsandtwirlsintolightAndwakesinthepulseofafinalhour.Section9featuresanevenlongervirtuallycontinuousnarrativeoverthe30–quavercycleandrepeatednotesfirstpresentedinpulseandpresence–harkingbacktothebeginningsofthework(modalalternationofmajorandminorintervalsagainstafixedpitchof‘G’).Thatnarrationlasts1minuteandleadstothefirstfullstatementofthework’smainanthemicmotiveintheoboe:

Thisissubsequentlyfollowedby8barswithouttheanthem–butitthenreturnsinsixrepetitions,eachtimewithalteredinstrumentation,registeroraccompanyingharmony.Gasatonicpedalcontinuesthroughouttheserepetitions,graduallyalsobuildingtensionthroughmotoricquaverrepetitionuntilarrivingatthecodaforthefinalminuteofthework.10:codaThecodacontainsnofurthernarrative;itisapurelyinstrumentalconclusion–thoughcertainlyintendedtosumupthefulldramaofthework.Itcontinuestherhythmicflowandtensionbuiltacrossthepreviousthreeminuteswithafewnotabledifferences.Thelast60secondscontainsafasterrateofharmonicchangethananywhereelseinthework.Itachievesthisthroughchromaticalterations,modalalternation,alternativebassnotesandmetricalvariation.Theanthemmelodyisstillinplay,butnotasfullphrases–thesearenowdeliberatelyfragmentedintosmallerunits,oftenleftsuspendedandun-resolved;orresolvingmelodically,buttounexpectedharmonicchange.Mostofall,theharmonicprogressionisdeliberatelydesignedtodelayresolutionuntiltheveryend.Takenoutsideofitsrhythmic,metricalcontext,areductionofthisharmonicprogressioncanbeseenhere:

Page 19: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.19

Thecentralpitchof‘G’isofteninplay–butgenerallynotasabassnote–andwhereitis,thereisoftenmodal,chromaticalterationabove.ThisisdesignedtomaximizethefinalcadencetoG(albeitwithaddedtones).InstrumentationTheFinalHourdeliberatelysetsouttocombineclassicalandpopularinstruments,acousticandelectric,playedandprogrammedsounds.Tothisend,theorchestralinstrumentsutilizedincludeoboe,sopranosaxophone,grandpiano,vibraphone,suspendedcymbals,soloviolinandastringsection.Thejazzandrockinstrumentsincludearhythmsectionofelectrickeyboard,uprightacousticbassanddrumkit;4synthesizers,4electricguitars(alsoincludingnylon-stringacousticandtwelve-stringguitars),electricfretlessbass,shaker,triangleandotherpercussion.Ofcourse,anumberoftheseinstrumentsexistinbothworlds.Andforthispiece(andinmymusicingeneral)theinstrumentsaredeliberatelyambiguousbysound,languageandfunction.Thesoundworldisnotattemptingtobeovertlypostmodern.Whatisattemptedandintendedisasynthesis,notacollision.NarrationThenarrationisdeliberatelysegmentedandevenfragmentedacrossthefullcourseofthehour–longstructure.Sometimesjustawordoralineisused,atotherssomemoreextendedsectionsarepresented.Echodelayisusedasadeliberatetechnique(ie:another,nother,other,etc.).ThiswasinfluencedbytheuseofthistechniqueinPinkFloyd’sDarkSideoftheMoon(1973),wheresongvocalsonUsandThemaregiventhistreatment.Here,thewordsareonlyspoken(neversung)–buttheinfluenceisclearenough.Thewordsaremostlyfrontandcentreinthemix(astheywouldbeincinematicnarration).Butattimesthenarrationisfiltered(astheyareinfate)togiveasenseofdistance.Andsomesyllablesareexaggerated:“fffff–fateiswherelostchancesgo”.The4–linepoemforthistleseedisheardfirstbythemainnarrator,thenheardagainrepeatedinthevoiceofayounggirl.Additionally,whilethetextessentiallyisreadfrombeginningtoend,certainlinesarerepeated,sometimesinquitestructuralistways.Incitytowers,thefirstthreelines:NightfallsaslogoscrystalliseOncitytowers,whoseabstractedlightsCutvacantdesk,andemptyscreen

Page 20: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.20

Unfoldgraduallythus:NightfallsNightfallsaslogoscrystalliseNightfallsaslogoscrystalliseOncitytowers,whoseabstractedlightsCutvacantdesk,andemptyscreenvacantdesk–emptyscreendesk–screen–vacantempty(echodelay)Thisisanadditive/reductiveapproach(inarchform)tousingthetext.Whilethepoemwouldnotbereadonpaperinthisway,itsfunctionwithinthemusicalnarrativeisalreadyaltered;andasthemusicmakesuseofadditiveandreductivetechniques,havingthenarrationalsoaffectedinthiswayhelpstosynthesizetheotherwisequitedifferentartisticdisciplinesofwordsandmusic.SettingnarrationagainstamusicalbackdropissomethingthatRossBaglinandIhavedonebefore.Ourfirstopera,Nelson(2005),hasanarratorforsomesections;theywereplayedbyanactor(notasinger)andwefelttheyworkedeffectively.Theprincipleissimilarhere,exceptthatitisattimesadditionallyalteredthrougheditingandsoundprocessing.EnvironmentalSoundsInadditiontothestudioorchestraandnarrator,TheFinalHourmakesuseofenvironmentalsounds(‘foley’incinematicterms).Thesesoundsdirectlyrelatetothetextandincludethefollowing:Officesoundsfilingcabinetshutting,scissorscutting,computerkeyboardtyping,phoneringing,writingonpaper,scannerSoundsof(orrelatingto)childrenmusicbox,younggirl’svoice,childrenplayinginthebackyard,breakingstickCarsoundscarignitionstart/stop,windscreenwipers,cardooropen/close,carhandbrake,carseatbeltlockTrainsoundstraincrossing,boomgatesignalOthermiscellaneoussoundscamerashutterclick,rummagingthroughbox,icecubesinglassofwater,wineglassesrubbedandtappedSoundProcessingAsaconceptalbum,thetechnologicalpossibilitiesofsoundmanipulationwerefullyinplay.Notallsonictransformationsthatwereattemptedwereusedorkept.Someaudioprocessingwasconceivedaspartofthecompositionalprocess–andmarkedinthescoreassuch.Butsomeaspectswereconsideredandtriedoutaspartofthepost–compositionalstudioproductionprocess.Eitherway,abasicquestionwasasked:doesthisenhancethelisteningexperienceordetractfromit?Themostcommonaudioprocessingtechniquesusedwere:

Page 21: The Final Hour-article - Stuart Greenbaum Final...Reich, The Cave (1993) and Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays, The Way Up (2005). They are also points of reference that may not exactly be

Greenbaum:TheFinalHour,pg.21

•reversal•pitch–shift(includingslow–downglissandi)•timeexpansionandcompression•distortion,grungeandlo–fi•EQfiltering•reverb•delays•panningandvolumeAnumberofthesewereautomatedtoallowforgradualchangeandmorphingofsounds.TherecordingprocessTheFinalHourwasrecordedatGingerStudios,MelbaHall,Lukktone,BrianBrownStudio,MelbourneElectronicSoundStudio(MESS)andsundrydomesticresidencesandon-sitelocations(2016–2018).Environmentalsoundrecordingsweremadebythecomposer.Allotheraudiowasrecordedinhighdefinitionat96k/24bbyHadynBuxton(recordingandmixingengineer)withLukeHowardandStuartGreenbaum.Itwasmasteredat96/32byLachlanCarrickatMooseMasteringinDecember2018.Therecordingartistswere:

BarryCockcroftsopranosaxophoneCeliaCraigoboeDanielFarrugiadrumkitLeonardGrigoryanguitarsLukeHowardpianoandkeyboardsCraigNewmanfretlesselectricbassAlexPertoutpercussionBenRobertsonacousticbassMarianneRothschildsoloviolinAmyValentCurlisvibraphoneThestringsectionwasorganizedbyMattHoyfromtheAustralianNationalAcademyofMusiccomprisingcurrentandformerANAMmusicians:ZoeFreisbergviolinManaOhashiviolinMatthewLaingviolaAnnaPokornycelloMatthewHoycelloBenHanlondoublebassThenarrationwasrecordedbyAustralianactor,JohnStanton.TheFinalHourwasrealisedasastudioalbum.Itmayalsobeperformedlivewithsamples/stemswithasmallorlargerensembleofplayers.Theworkhasvisualpotentialincludingdanceandfilm.ThefullscoreisavailablethroughtheAustralianMusicCentreandpartsdirectlythroughthecomposer.Article©StuartGreenbaum,27July2019