22
99 Mo Topical Meeting. Santa Fe. December 4 -7, 2011 The LEU conversion project of IRE

The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

99Mo Topical Meeting.

Santa Fe. December 4 -7, 2011

The LEU conversion project of IRE

Page 2: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

Menu

1. Presentation of IRE.

2. Supply performance.

3. LEU Conversion.

1. Master Plan2. Progress Report3. Project cost of phase 14. Risk assessment

ire_en.flv

Page 3: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

SUPPLY PERFORMANCE

3

Page 4: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

4

Radiochemical productions> 95% exports; approx. 50% EU.Unique producer of I-131 in EUShare the EU Mo-99 production:

approx. 50/50 with CovidienOther Isotopes: Y-90, Re-188, Xe-133 ...

Customer base: all generator manufacturers worldwide;Partnerships: NTP – ANSTO (LEU conversion & Supply chain management), SCK/CEN (R&D), INVAP (Engineering), ANL (Long term solutions).

Page 5: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

5

National Institute for RadioelementsLicensing

24 targets / week + reserve capacity +12 targets/week

Capacity 2500 Ci/W 6 day cal+ Reserve capacity + 50%

Current processAnnular targets 93% U5Alkaline dissolution

Page 6: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

6

IRE key success factorsPublic Utility FoundationOperated as a private commercial entityLean organization (140FTE / 42 M€)Priority: Highest Service Level and Quality for Health Care

… And a commitment to LEU conversionStrategic location for logistics

Transport routesRoad network5 int’l airports < 350km

Multi-sourcing: a MUST !Network of Research Reactors

3 reactors < 300km1 reactor < 1000km

Strategic alliancesInnovation => Is 99Mo is a mature or decliningcommodity product?Other companies on site

Cyclotron isotope productionGamma sterilizationTransport

Page 7: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

80%

20%

2009– 2010 – Spring 2012 ...

Page 8: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

Strategic Alliance

Page 9: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

Supply Excellence & LEU conversion

• Mutual Back-up aiming at long term excellence in service level • 6 Reactors • 3 reactor projects + processing unit projects•Technical cooperation• Co-ordinated LEU conversion

Page 10: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

Reactor Projects

Project FRM II:

LEU project =>New target designPlateFeasibility study=> 2015

26/09/2011

Page 11: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

Reactor Projects (cont.)

Project JHR:

Non Binding LoI signed in 2010. (IBA – IRE –CEA)

LEU production

2016

26/09/2011

Réunion IRE-IBA–CEA 1er juin 2011 Gov Board 4th May 2011

JHROperation

and Services Project

JP Chauvin, JP Coulon & Al

Page 12: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

LEU CONVERSION

12

Page 13: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

Supply Excellence & LEU conversion

Co-ordinated LEU conversion

2015

20082010

Page 14: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

14

< 2008 : reluctance to LEU conversionSummer 2008: Commitment to LEU conversion.NAS: IRE to go for brown field conversion

2 production lines XeMo II & XeMo IDecision made to renovate XeMo II => HEUDecision made to further renovate XeMo I => LEU

IRE Master Plan

Page 15: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

15

2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) Mitigation in the supply crisisHigh volume but burning of HEU inventories Transfer of production on XeMo IIBack-up NTP while converting to LEUOff-Gas: record figures: - 75%

Award CTBTOSafety – Economics – Financial: the recovery

IRE Master Plan

Page 16: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

16

LEU technology90’s: B&W< 2009: ADS: negative NPV2010: FoilSummer 2011 after Fukushima: two phases

Phase 1: UAl2: 2015Phase 2: LEU long term solution in a new plant,

“state-of-the-art” & stress test compliant.

IRE Master Plan

Page 17: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

Progress report N°1.Q4 2011

LEU conversion project.

IRE. Belgium

17

Page 18: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

IRE progress report. Phase 1

Q4 2011: target geometry and size. (5 reactors + CERCA). Q1 2012:

target specification + design of dissolution processPre-licensing initiated.

Q2 to Q4 2012: testing, + design and manufacturing of equipment, incl. rigs in reactors and containers.2013, prototyping + renovation XeMo I line + waste.2014,

Installation of new production equipmentValidationLicensingTesting. Revision of drug master files

18

Page 19: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

19

Page 20: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

Expenses

Project cost phase 1: approx. 10 M€

Current manufacturing cost estimate: + 20%

20

Page 21: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

Risk AssessmentThe LEU conversion is not an issue, The supply performance is an issue:

Higher safety requirements on Phase 1 than anticipated prior to Fukushima => delays,Supply of HEU until conversion,Statistically, we are likely to experience new major unexpected shortages in the next coming years, What if phase 2 is non profitable, ?, Full cost recovery not implemented globally / not accepted by the end-users, Supply chain management, quality and safety management are underestimated by new entrants to a large extent.

21

Page 22: The LEU conversion project of IREmo99.ne.anl.gov/2011/pdfs/Mo99 2011 Web...2009 – 2010 : renovation XeMo II (3 M€) ¾Mitigation in the supply crisis ¾High volume but burning of

22

Thank you for your attentionThank you for your attention