The Metaphysical Detective: Excerpt

8/2/2019 The Metaphysical Detective: Excerpt

1/10


2/10

]LG EG]FZLT^DNFC MG]GN]DYG

@dx~}gb [gd~~

]lg Eg}fzlt^Dnfc

Mg}gn}dyg


3/10

6

Nlfz}gx 6? F Ncdgb} Fxxdyg~

Et lw~hfbm d~ }xtdbk }a `dcc eg"Lgcgb {xwbk lgx lfbm~# f kg~}wxg Xdkf lfm xgfm fhaw}

hw} bgygx fn}wfcct ~ggb db zxfn}dng" D} dxxd}f}gm lgx" Lgcgb~ggegm }aa ef~nwcdbg iax }ld~ lgczcg~~ kg~}wxg# {d}l lgxefb~ lfbm~ fbm hxafm ~lawcmgx~" Gygb ~gf}gm ~lgcaaegm aygx Xdkf"

Lfyg taw ~za`gb }a }lg zacdng1 Xdkf }atgm {d}l f zgb"

Lgcgb ~laa` lgx lgfm# ba# ~g}}dbk lgx hcabmg lfdx~{dbkdbk caa~gct fhaw} lgx of{"

Xdkf zdn`gm wz }lg zlabg# fbm lgcm d} aw} }a lgx fnxa~~}lg mg~ " D} {f~ f xgzcdnf ai f zlabg ixae }lg }ldx}dg~ hcfn` {d}l f nxwmg caa dbk naxm fbm f xa}fxt mdfc" De feg}fzlt~dnfc mg}gn}dyg" ]ld~ d~ f nf~g iax }lg zacdng# ba}

eg"Et lw~hfbm~ mgfm"Xdkf ~ca{ct zcfngm }lg xgngdygx hfn` ab d}~ nxfmcg"Lgcgb fyadmgm }lg mg}gn}dyg~ kfg# lgx gtg~ mfx}dbk

fxawbm }lg xaae? f} }lg nfxzg} ~}fdb ~lfzgm cd`g Fw~}xfcdf#f} }lg eg}fc haa`nf~g~# f} }lg ydg{ ai }lg hxdn` hwdcmdbkbg|} maax" ]lg aiidng mf}gm hfn` }a }lg 649:~ fbm d}

~la{gm"Xdkf {f~ mf}gm }aa# }lawkl db hg}}gx nabmd}dab" Zgazcg

zw} lgx db lgx }ldx}dg~# hw} ~lg {f~ f iwcc mgnfmg acmgx"Abng# }lgt {awcm lfyg ~fdm ~lg nf~} f kcfeawx" Hw} }lg


4/10


8

mft~ {lgb zgazcg xgnakbdgm Xdkf~ hxfbm ai efkdn {gxgcabk zf~}"

Lgx gtg~ kcgfegm ydacg} db }lg cfezcdkl}" [lt mab}taw }gcc eg {lf}~ hggb lfzzgbdbk1

Lgcgb caa`gm zf~} Xdkf~ ~lawcmgx# f} f zdkgab ab }lg{dbma{~dcc" Et lw~hfbm mdgm bgfxct f tgfx fka" D} {f~ fnfx fnndmgb}" Lgcgb caa`gm f} lgx g|zgn}fb}ct"

Xdkf {f~b} f z~tnldn# Lgcgb {awcm lfyg }a idbd~l lgxa{b ~}axt" Ka ab"

Lgcgb~ kfg id|gm ab f haa` fhaw} ]fxa}# hg~dmg }lgzlabg" D} cft ifng ma{b# nxfn`gm azgb wzab d}~ ~zdbg f~ di}lg mg}gn}dyg lfm ow~} zcfngm d} }lgxg"

Cf}gct# Dyg hggb lfydbk fnndmgb}~" F bgfx ~cdz fbm ifccdb }lg hf}l# }lg fnngcgxf}ax ai et nfx ~}dn`dbk# f hfm nf~g aiiaam zad~abdbk F} idx~} D }lawkl} }lgt {gxg fcc ow~} hfm

cwn`" Fbm }lgb ~aegabg zw~lgm eg" D {f~ {fd}dbk iax }lghw~# fbm f~ d} zwccgm }a }lg nwxh# ~aegabg zw~lgm eg dbixab} ai d}"

Xdkf cgfbgm hfn` db lgx nlfdx# nxa~~gm lgx fxe~" ]ld~xgfcct ~awbm~ cd`g f oah iax }lg zacdng"

]lgxg {f~ ba abg }lgxg" Lgcgb zdn`gm wz f mgn` ai]fxa} nfxm~ ixae }lg mg~` fbm ~lwiicgm }lxawkl }lge" D

{f~b} db f nxa{m ai ~}xfbkgx~# D {f~ fcabg" Hw} D igc} }lglfbm ab et hfn`# fbm d} {f~ Lgxedg~ D egfb Lgxefb~

lfbm"]lg {axm~ nfeg db f xw~l ba{" D `ba{ ld~ lfbm# }lg

~lfzg ai d}# }lg iggc ai d}" D ~egccgm ld~ fi}gx~lfyg" D f~`gm}lg mxdygx di ~lgm ~ggb fbtabg" ^lg ~{axg f} eg fbm efmgeg kg} aii }lg hw~"

Lgcgb xgzcfngm }lg mgn`" D }lawkl} D {f~ kadbk nxft#fbm }lgb D lgfxm fhaw} taw" D} {f~ f} f zfx}t# ~aegabg {f~cfwkldbk fhaw} fb fm lgm ~ggb db }lg tgcca{ zfkg~ tawxfm" [g oa`gm fhaw} d}{lf} mag~ f eg}fzlt~dnfc mg}gn}dygma1 Abct db ^fb Ixfbnd~na# xdkl}1 Hw} }lgb f ig{ mft~ cf}gx


5/10

@DX^]GB [GD^^

>

D {f~ ab }lg hw~ f mdiigxgb} hw~ fbm D lgfxm }{a{aegb }fc`dbk" Abg lfm kabg }a taw iax f zxahcge# ~aeg

ed~~dbk og{gcxt# fbm tawm iawbm d} efmg d} ow~} xgfzzgfx}lg {aefb ~fdm"

F ~dxgb hcfxgm aw}~dmg fbm Lgcgb~ cdz~ zdbnlgm# lgx kfgmxf{b fkfdb }a }lg lfci%azgb {dbma{"

Xdkf fbkcgm lgx nlfdx# caa`dbk zf~} }lg {aefb" ^lgxgcf|gm fbm hxafmgbgm lgx yd~dab }a nlgn` aw} Lgcgb~ fwxf?ba wbw~wfc mxfdb~ ax icw|g~# fbm ba }db} ai efkdn"

D} {f~ ~a ~}xfbkg" Lgcgb caa`gm f} }lg haa`nf~g }a lgxcgi}# nxfeegm lfzlffxmct {d}l amm%~awbmdbk }d}cg~" D~}fx}gm ~ggdbk fbm lgfxdbk xgigxgbng~ }a taw gygxt{lgxg" Di~aegabg {f~b} }fc`dbk fhaw} taw# }lgtm hg }fc`dbk fhaw}mg}gn}dyg~ fbm kla~}~" D gygb iawbm tawx ictgx hgbgf}l }lg

{dbm~ldgcm {dzgx~ ai et nfx" D lf}g }la~g ictgx~&

Xdkf kxdefngm" ^axxt" D}~ et bdgng# Dyg }acm lgx }a~}az {d}l }lg ictgx~" ^lg {fb}~ }a hg f idceef`gx# ~lgfmmgm# f~ di }lf} g|zcfdbgm d}"

]lgxg {f~ f cabk ~dcgbng" [lgb Lgcgb mdmb} idcc d}# Xdkfnab}dbwgm" Hw} mdmb} taw gygx }ldb` }lf} }lg xgf~ab taw

{gxg ~ggdbk eg gygxt{lgxg {f~ ow~} kaam fmygx}d~dbk1Hw} Dm bgygx~ggb ax lgfxm ai taw hgiaxg"

Taw bgygx bggmgm eg hgiaxg"D ow~} D igc} D lfm }a naeg# Lgcgb ~fdm" D mab}

`ba{ la{ }a g|zcfdb d}"[lt ma taw }ldb` tawx lw~hfbm {awcm {fb} }a `dcc

taw1Lgcgb~ kfg mxazzgm }a }lg ~cggyg ai Xdkf~ {ld}g

hcaw~g# }a }lg ~dezcg kacm {f}nl }lf} gbndxncgm }lg

mg}gn}dyg~ {xd~}# }a }lg hfxg idbkgx~" Dyg eg} ~aegabg#Lgcgb ~fdm"

Xdkf ldm lgx ~wxzxd~g" Db lgx g|zgxdgbng# {ldcg d} {f~b}wbw~wfc iax {dma{gx~ }a idbm ~aegabg bg{ {d}ldb f tgfx#


6/10


=

}lg eawxbdbk zgxdam iax {dma{~ xfb cabkgx" [f~ tawxlw~hfbm }lg ogfcaw~ }tzg1 Za~~g~~dyg1

Ba" ]lgxg {f~ ba bggm }a hg" Lg fc{ft~ ~fdm D {f~ld~ hg}}gx lfci" Zgazcg w~gm }a oa`g fhaw} awx bfeg~#Lgxefb fbm Lgcgb# fbm d} xgfcct mdm iggc cd`g {g {gxg }{alfcyg~ ai f hg}}gx{lacg"

Xdkf ~ldi}gm db lgx nlfdx" ]lg {lggc~ nfwkl} db }lg xwkfbm ~lg ogx`gm iax{fxm }a ixgg lgx~gci" Lfyg taw lfm fbt~wmmgb ~lan`~ ax }xfwef~ xgngb}ct1

De ba} nxft"Xdkf {f~b} xgfmt }a xwcg }lg nxft az}dab aw} tg}# hw} cg}

d} ka" Di Lgcgb {f~ iggcdbk lfwb}gm# }lgxg nawcm hg gd}lgx fxf}dabfc ax f zfxfbaxefc xgf~ab" Xdkf {awcm nlgn` aw} lgxlaeg fbm di ~lg nawcmb} idbm fbt}ldbk# }gxedbf}g }lgnab}xfn}" ^lg mdmb} }f`g eabgt ixae }lg egb}fcct

}xawhcgm" ^aeg}deg~ ~zdxd}~ nfb hgnaeg f}}fnlgm {lgbtawxg {gf`gbgm ~zdxd}wfcct ax zlt~dnfcct" Lfyg taw hggbaygx}dxgm1 ^}xg~~gm f} {ax`1 Fbt}ldbk cd`g }lf}1

Ba"Lfyg taw hggb zxfn}dndbk fbt efkdn1 Awdof hafxm~1Lgcgb~ gtg~ icf~lgm" Ai nawx~g ba}&Cdfx" ]lg }lawkl} zazzgm wbf~`gm db}a Xdkf~ lgfm"

^lg xgfnlgm aw} fkfdb {d}l lgx ~gb~g~ba}ldbk"Nfb taw lgcz eg1 Lgcgb f~`gm"D }ldb` ~a" Xdkf ka} wz fbm ~}xamg }a f {aamgb idcg

nfhdbg} db }lg naxbgx# lgx eaygegb}~ ~wxg fbm kxfngiwc"^lg azgbgm }lg }az mxf{gx fbm xfb lgx ~cgbmgx idbkgx~fnxa~~ }lg idcg~"

Dyg ka} d}& Lgcgb ~fdm" Taw caa` cd`g }lf} acm fn}xg~~#

}lg abg {la efxxdgm }lg Fkf @lfb" D mdmb} ~gg d} f} idx~}hgnfw~g ~lg {f~ db hcfn` fbm {ld}g# hw} taw caa` ow~} cd`glgx"

Ee" Xdkf zwccgm aw} f zcfdb iacmgx# igc} lgx acdyg%lwgm~`db mfx`gb" ^lg zf~}gm ab f ~edcg fbm }a~~gm lgx lgfm"


7/10

@DX^]GB [GD^^

7

Lgx fwhwxb lfdx kcgfegm cd`g zacd~lgm {aam# ~g}}cgm db nadc~fhaw} lgx ~lawcmgx~"

^lg xg}wxbgm }a lgx ~gf} hgldbm }lg mg~`# fbm ~cdm }lgiacmgx fnxa~~ }a Lgcgb# {la ba{ ~}fxgm f} lgx fydmct"Db~dmg tawcc idbm }{a nazdg~ ai }lg nab}xfn} fbm igg~}xwn}wxg" Tawcc bggm }a ~dkb ha}l di taw {fb} }a eaygiax{fxm"

Lgcgb }axg lgx gtg~ ixae Xdkf# azgbgm }lg iacmgx#~nfbbgm ma{b }lg zfkg~" F iwxxa{ fzzgfxgm hg}{ggb lgx

zfcg hxa{~" ]ld~ igg ~}xwn}wxg d~ {gdxm"]f`g d} laeg# xgfm }lg nab}xfn}" ]lgxg~ ba lwxxt"

]lg {axm~ {awcm lfwb} Xdkf"Ba# ba& D} caa`~ idbg" Lfyg taw ka} f zgb1 Lgcgb

caa`gm wz ixae }lg zfzgx~ db lgx lfbm~" F zgb cft hgiaxglgx ab }lg mg~`" ^lg lg~d}f}gm# }lgb ~bf}nlgm d} wz# fbm

~dkbgm lwxxdgmct" ]lgxg& [lgb nfb taw ~}fx}1]aeaxxa{# di taw cd`g" ]gcc eg eaxg fhaw} Lgxefb"Lg {f~ ~a hxdccdfb}# mf~ldbk" Lg {f~ Nldgi Idbfbndfc

Aiidngx ai }lg Fzacca Kxawz" Lfyg taw lgfxm ai d}1 D}~ fcfbm mgygcazegb} naezfbt"

Xdkf efmg f ba}g ab lgx hca}}gx" [lf} mdm lg ma iaxiwb1

Efkdn"Xdkf caa`gm wz" Lg {f~ db}gxg~}gm db }lg annwc}1 Xgfc

efkdn1Lgcgb cfwklgm" ]lgxg~ ba ~wnl }ldbk f~ xgfc ^lg

}xfdcgm aii# caa`gm wbngx}fdb" [gcc# kla~}~ fxg mdiigxgb}1Fxgb} }lgt1 ]lgtxg ba} efkdn"

Xdkf mdmb} ~ft fbt}ldbk"

Lg {f~ f ~}fkg efkdndfb# Lgcgb ~fdm" Fef}gwx# ow~}iax iwb" Nldcmxgb~ zfx}dg~# }lf} ~ax} ai }ldbk" Lg {f~fc{ft~ zwccdbk ~aeg}ldbk aw} ai ld~ lf}# w~wfcct f} }lg ea~}dbfzzxazxdf}g eaegb}"


8/10


9

^awbm~ cd g iwb# Xdkf ~fdm mxtct" Taw ~fdm lg lfm fnfx fnndmgb}1

Al" Lgcgb {axxdgm lgx ca{gx cdz" Lg ca~} nab}xac#ld} f Gwnfctz}w~ }xgg" ]lg nfx {f~ }a}fcgm" Lg {f~ `dccgmdb~}fb}ct# }lgt }acm eg"

Xdkf ~dcgb}ct {abmgxgm {lg}lgx Lgxefb~ fnndmgb} lfmxgfcct hggb f ~wdndmg" ]lf} ew~} lfyg hggb lfxm iax taw"Mdm Lgxefb~ hglfydax nlfbkg f} fcc hgiaxg }lg fnndmgb}1

Tg%g~" Lgm hggb {ax`dbk cabkgx bdkl}~ fbm igc} wbmgx

zxg~~wxg f} {ax`"[lf} ~ax} ai zxg~~wxg1D mab} `ba{" [lgbgygx D f~`gm iax mg}fdc~ Lg

mdmb} cd`g }a }fc` fhaw} d}" Lg gygb ~}azzgm madbk ld~efkdn }xdn`~"

[lgb Lgcgb cgi}# Xdkf igc} lgx ~lawcmgx~ caa~gb"

^aeg}ldbk fhaw} }lg {aefb lfm ~g} Xdkf~ lgfm hwdbk"^lg {gb} }a }lg nxfn`gm {dbma{ fbm {f}nlgm f~ Lgcgbgegxkgm ab}a }lg ~dmg{fc`# }{a icaax~ hgca{"

]lf} abg d~ ba} g ~lfxzg~} }fn` db }lg mxf{gx# figedbdbg yadng xf~zgm ixae aw}~dmg }lg {dbma{" ^lg lf~f ngx}fdb ~aeg}ldbk {d}l g egb }lawkl# b+g~}%ng zf~1

Xdkf mdmb} xg~zabm"

Ixae fhayg# Lgcgb caa`gm icf}}gbgm aw}" ]lg ~ldi} dbzgx~zgn}dyg nfw~gm f ~wmmgb ~bfz db Xdkf~ yd~dab }lf} ~g}lgx lgfm ~zdbbdbk" Lgcgb~ idkwxg ~labg cd`g kacm# ~}xg}nlgmdeza~~dhct }fcc# fbm }lgb d} {f~ kabg" Xdkf }lxg{ lgx lfbmaw}# hxfndbk lgx~gci fkfdb~} }lg {dbma{ ixfeg iax igfx aizd}nldbk aw}" Mdm taw ~gg }lf}1

]lg kfxkatcg ab }lg cgmkg aw}~dmg }wxbgm d}~ lgfm" ^gg

{lf}1Efkdn" D} {f~ }lgxg" Xdkf lfm abct igc} d} iax f

eaegb}# hw} d} {f~ wbed~}f`fhcg" [lt lfmb} ~lg hggbfhcg }a mg}gn} d} ab Lgcgb db lgx aiidng1


9/10

@DX^]GB [GD^^

;

Hwt }lg Haa` ab Fefab f}? l}}z?!!feb"}a!@HBl_=


10/10


Documents

The Metaphysical Detective: Excerpt