42
The New Superconductors Z. Fisk UC Irvine China/US Winter School Hong Kong 2013 Supported by AFOSR MURI

The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

The New Superconductors

Z. Fisk UC Irvine China/US Winter School

Hong Kong 2013

Supported by AFOSR MURI

Page 2: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

What does the record tell us?

•  What drives materials discovery? •  What is role of theory? •  What constitutes a breakthrough? •  Will there be a room temperature

superconductor?

Page 3: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 4: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 5: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 6: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

Where do we find superconductivity?

•  High temperature phases

•  Mo and W films

•  Magnetic elements: Fe, Cr

•  4f elements: Ce, Eu

•  5f elements: U, Am

•  Cluster compounds

Page 7: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 8: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

Uranium under pressure

Page 9: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

1950s: the Edisonian approach to discovering new superconductors

and the era of conventional superconductivity

Fermi: systematics of materials may give a clue

Page 10: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 11: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 12: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

Batterman and Barrett Phys. Rev. 145, 296 (1966)

Page 13: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

C. W. Chu V3Si: TMartensitic / Tc

Page 14: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 15: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

1957 the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer theory arrives

Tc = Tlatticee-1/NV

Page 16: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

timeline of maximum superconducting transition temperature Tc

Page 17: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

Superconductivity at the border with Magnetism

•  superconducting/magnetic interface competition —› co-habitation —› marriage

•  vast broadening of materials phase space

Page 18: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 19: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 20: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 21: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 22: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 23: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 24: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 25: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

1979: Heavy Fermions: superconductivity marries magnetism, its enemy, in CeCu2Si2 (Tc = 0.5K)

Page 26: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 27: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

Mathur et al. Nature 394, 39 (1998)

Page 28: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 29: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

Phase diagram of CeRhIn5 (Park and Thompson)

Page 30: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

What happens at Tc in heavy Fermions?

•  Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface

•  The electronic spectrum carries strong magnetic fluctuations that can mediate superconductivity or magnetic order

•  Establishing superconductivity can be seen as resolving the opposed conflict of local moment magnetism versus non-local itinerant electronic states

Page 31: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

Stock et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 087001 (2008)

Page 32: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 33: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

M. Nicholas et al. Phys. Rev. B 76, 052401 (2007)

Page 34: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

1986: the new age of cuprates

La1.84Sr0.16CuO4 Tc = 40K

Page 35: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

generic cuprate phase diagram

Page 36: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

the new iron age: pnictides Tc = 56K

Wolfgang Jeitschko

Page 37: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

the path to this new material

Page 38: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 39: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

M. Norman Physics 1 (2008) 21

Page 40: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 41: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum
Page 42: The New Superconductors Hong Kongctcp/China_US_Workshop/Zach Fisk.pdf · • Superconductivity opens a gap in the electronic spectrum at the Fermi surface • The electronic spectrum

Onward and upward?

•  the record says that Tc is raised by finding new classes of materials

•  maximum Tc within each class appears near a boundary separating local and non-local physics

•  no obvious maximum to Tc