8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

1/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

2/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

3/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

4/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

5/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

6/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

7/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

8/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

9/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

10/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

11/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

12/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

13/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

14/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

15/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

16/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

17/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

18/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

19/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

20/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

21/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

22/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

23/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

24/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

25/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

26/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

27/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

28/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

29/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

30/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

31/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

32/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

33/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

34/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

35/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

36/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

37/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

38/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

39/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

40/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

41/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

42/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

43/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

44/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

45/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

46/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

47/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

48/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

49/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

50/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

51/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

52/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

53/54

8/14/2019 The Power of the Purse with a $94 Billion Hole: The Legal Basis and Constitutional Implications of "Black Budget" Appropriations

54/54