The Problem of Solid Waste Management - Zambrut · The study is significant because it will help the researcher to discover the problems of solid waste management. It will help create

International Journal of Health, Nursing, & Medicine ISSN: 2193-3715, Volume 2, Issue 2, page 44 - 64

Zambrut

Zambrut.com. Publication date: April 2, 2019.

Ackah, J. Y., Adaobi, C. & Miracle, A. 2019. The Problem of Solid Waste Management ............. 44

The Problem of Solid Waste

Management (A Case Edification Introspecting the Kwahu

West Municipality of Ghana)

Ackah, James Yamekeh1, Chukwuma Adaobi

2 & Atianashie Miracle

3

1Fr, Dr. Ackah, James Yamekeh,

2Chukwuma Adaobi &

3Atianashie Miracle

Catholic University College of Ghana

Ghana

1. INTRODUCTION Solid waste is grouped into two main characteristic types, namely, combustible and non-combustibles.

Combustible waste comprise of card, paper, plastics, wood these are wastes which can easily be burnt. Non

combustibles are those that cannot be easily burnt such as cans, metals, glasses, among others (Nang‟echi,

1992, p.6).

Abstract: This study was conducted to determine problems of solid waste management at

Nkwakaw. The study consisted of 100 respondents chosen from 90 households using systematic

sampling technique. This study is purely descriptive cross sectional study with both quantitative

and qualitative methods. Statistical package for social scientist (SPSS) version was used for the

analysis after data collection using close and open ended questions. At the end of the study, the

findings came out that the respondents have a way of managing their solid waste with some of

them using the services of private contractors. Twenty-three percent (23%) of the respondents

dumped their solid waste elsewhere which is later used as manure for their backyard farming. It

was noted that inadequate communal containers for storing waste, lack of routine collection of

waste and inadequate resources for the sanitation unit to effectively collect the waste generated

are some of the problems uncounted in terms of waste management. The researcher at the end of

the study recommends that the public should be educated by the environmental health officers on

solid waste and its related issues. Basically, hygiene practices should be taught especially on

radios, televisions, in newspapers, and in schools to educate people on proper ways of handling

solid waste and keeping the surrounding clean. Also, there be adequate supply of resources and

regular collection of waste.

Keywords: 3 Solid Waste, Attitude and Perception, West Municipal, Hazard.

https://zambrut.com/

https://zambrut.com/problem-waste/

























Zambrut



“Waste handling is one of the greatest challenges facing human kind in the modern times in spite of

the numerous technological achievements that have been documented. Technology alone has not been able

to effectively control waste generated in communities‟ worldwide. Rather it appears that new technologies

bring new types of waste into the environment to add to the complex accumulation puzzle” (Kwawe,

1995:53). “a great mixture of substances including fine dust, cinder, metals, glass, paper and cardboard,

textiles, pesticides, vegetable materials and plastics characterized solid waste” (Simmens, 1981).

Solid management has been the integral part of every human society (Shekdar, 2009). This problem

has been increasing with change in in consumption pattern; increase in consumerism and unavailability of

waste management facilities. One obvious consequence of rapid urbanization is the growing generation of

solid waste and many city authorities face unprecedented challenges in managing these, including

problems of coping their collection and disposal (2006).

According to Tchobanoglous et al. (1993), solid waste management is a discipline associated with the

control of generation, collection, transfer and transport, processing and disposal of solid waste in a manner

that is in accordance with the best principles of public health, economics, engineering, conservation,

aesthetic and other environmental considerations and that is also responsive to the public attitudes.

“Recent events in major urban Centres in Africa have shown that the problem of waste management

has become a monster that has aborted most effort by city authorities, state and the federal government and

professionals alike” (Onibokun 1999). Waste is more recognized than defined, something can become

waste when it is no longer useful to the owner or it is used and fail to fulfill its purpose (Gouley, 1992).

According to Miller (1988), solid waste is any useless, unwanted or discarded material that is not liquid or

gas.

Eating healthy food to be strong, productive and live long is synonymous to caring about waste

management in our society. According to the United Nations conference on human settlement report, one-

third to half of solid waste generated within most cities in low and middle income countries are not

collected. They usually end up as illegal dumps on streets open space and waste lands (UNCH, 1996).

Throughout the western world, there are no longer convenient holes in the ground into which to tip

unwanted matter (Gouley, 1992). The developing countries, having refused to become the „garbage

container‟ of the western world, also lack appropriate storage facilities, treatment technologies and

methods of waste disposal. In the olden days, waste disposal did not pose problems as inhabitants and were

sparse and enough land. Waste management became a problem due to the rise of town and cities where

large numbers of people started to migrate to relatively small areas in search of greener pastures.

According to Mensah et al. (2005), based on an estimated population of 22 million an d average daily

waste generation per capita of 0.45kg, Ghana generates annually about 3.0million tons of solid waste.

Ghana‟s first sanitary landfill facilities were commissioned in the four largest towns in the country

namely Accra, Kumasi, and Sekondi Takoradi between 2003 and 2004. Solid waste is waste consisting of

domestic waste, industrial waste, public cleansing or street waste containing less than 70% of water. Solid

waste is widespread environmental problem and has been categorized into two broad terms namely

hazardous and non-hazardous. Hazardous waste are those unwanted materials capable of posing a

substantial threat to health or the environment. Non-hazardous waste is those waste that pose no direct

threat to human, animal or plant life. However, they are risk to the society and the ecology if too much is

generated and not properly managed.

Solid waste management involves collection, storage, transportation and disposal of solid waste.

Nkawkaw is engulfed in fifth because it has a serious waste management from generation through storage

to disposal. The wrong perception and unconcern attitude of resident towards waste management might

also be the cause of this problem.

1.2 STATEMENT OF THE RESEARCH PROBLEM

Solid waste management anywhere in the world is a problem that continually accelerates as a product

of industrialization and population growth. As cities grow economically, greater business activity and

diverse consumption patterns serve to drive up the solid waste quantities. Ghana has been principal victim


Zambrut



of this disaster. Enough attention has been given to this challenge, but it seems to be a mere lip service that

is played. A holistic and technical approach is needed since solid waste management is a complex

challenge for the environment. (Allafrica.com 24-09-11).

Waste that are not properly managed are a serious health hazards leading to the spread of infectious

diseases. Unattended waste lying around attracts flies, rats, and creatures that in turn spread diseases.

WHO (2004) estimates that about 1.8 million people die annually from diarrheal diseases where 90% are

children under five, mostly in developing countries. With the increasing influx of the people and the rapid

urbanization, huge amount of human and small scale business waste of about 950 tones generate out of

which 480 tones are collected representing 51%. This leaves a substantial amount of back log that creates

various kinds of inconveniences including health hazards to the people of Nkawkaw. Indiscriminate

dumping of waste, irregular collection of waste generated and inadequate resources are the problems

facing solid waste management in the municipal. Also lack of equipment and the absence of proper

engineered final disposal sites delay the emptying of containers placed at vantage points. These containers

overflow and litter scattered around it leading to the possible factors of diarrheal diseases. It therefore

becomes necessary for this study to examine the problems of solid waste management in Nkawkaw.

1.3 JUSTIFICATION OF THE STUDY

Records of the Nkawkaw Holy Family Hospital shows that aside diet, most of the reported cases are

sanitation related of which solid waste is inclusive (records of HFH Nkawkaw). Diseases such as malaria,

typhoid fever and diarrheal diseases are commonly found in the area. Human resources could be lost

through poor waste management and this can affect productivity in the area. Solid waste management

seems to be neglected and as such prompted the researcher to study in problems with solid waste

management at Nkawkaw in the Kwahu West Municipal. The study therefore intends to explore

appropriate strategies and recommendations in clearing solid waste in the sustainable manner.

1.4 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY

To assess solid waste management both at household level and the municipal level.

To ascertain the attitude and perception of people towards solid waste management.

To assess the kind of incentive available for Kwahu West Municipal workers in dealing with

solid waste in terms of health hazards.

1.5 RESEARCH QUESTION

How often do you assess solid waste management both at household a municipal level?

What are the attitudes and perceptions of the people in view of solid waste management?

What kinds of incentives are available for the workers?

What is the health hazards associated with solid waste?

1.6 SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY

The study is significant because it will help the researcher to discover the problems of solid waste

management. It will help create awareness about the dangers associated with improper waste management.

It will be relevant to the \kwahu municipal Assembly and the Municipal Environmental Health Department

as to how to properly manage solid waste. The study will assist policy makers to draw concrete plans that

will tackle the problems of solid waste management and also stimulate further research.

1.7 SCOPE OF THE STUDY

Although there are quite a number of suburbs in Nkawkaw, the researcher decide to include Zongo,

Akuajoo and Maamaso communities for the household level. The reason is that, it is normally in these

three communities that communal refuse containers get full and litters scattered around the containers.


Zambrut



2. LITERATURE REVIEW

2.1 Solid Waste Management Practices both at Household and the Municipal levels.

According to Nyachhyon (2006), public partnership has been identified as efficient instrument to

promote solid waste management at the municipal level. Usually in the area of urban public service such as

waste management, are promoted as a means to deliver service through a contractual relationship with a

private sector firm.

Nyang' echi (1992 p. 45) , stated that when solid waste is left to lie and heap on the ground,

decomposition takes place and the nuisance of smell , flies and invasion of rodents occur. These

decomposition waste can be used as manure through composting for farming purposes. He therefore

explains that waste at the households and the municipal levels can be use be used various purpose called

composting when the waste is condensed. Benneh et al. (1993) observed that residential domestic waste

forms the bulk of all sources of solid waste produced in urban areas. These household wastes are known to

have high densities with high moisture content and the organic component of solid waste, which properly

accounts for about 70% to 90% , while tins , cans and proper are probably responsible for about 5% to

10% of the total waste generated is still weak , about 83% of the population dump refuse in either

authorized or unsanitary conditions.

The overall problem of solid waste management at municipal level is obviously multi- faceted ; many

organizations including the United Nations and various non - governmental organizations advocated an

integrated approach to solid waste management at the municipal level by identifying key stakeholders,

identifying specific issues which comprise " stumbling blocks" and making recommendations based on

appropriate technologies, local information, pressing human and environmental health concern (

UNEP,2009; Hope , 1998 ) . Within each sector, there are various sub sectors which can and are being

dealt with separately by many nations and municipalities.

Developing countries have solid waste management problems different from those found in fully

industrialized countries, (Cointreau, 1982 ) , in his study noted several common differences in the

composition of solid waste of solid waste in developing nations;

Waste density two to three times greater than industrialized nations.

Moisture content two three greater than industrialized nations.

Large amount of organic waste (vegetable matter).

Large quantities of dust, dirty (street sweeping)

Smaller particle size on average than in industrialized nations

These differences from industrialized nations must be recognized both in terms of the additional

problems they present as well as the potential opportunities which arise from their waste composition. In

areas where there are collection services which removes waste from individual households, often there are

no standardized containers used to store waste prior to pick up.

Headley (1998), stated that in Barbados, there are no containers designated by municipalities to " set out

" waste for collection; it is sort of collection containers. Frequently, these are plastic barrels or discarded oil

drums, however the majority of households simply place grocery bags full of waste on the street to await

collection. There may be physical dangers to collection threatening the integrity of the later.

Zubrugg stated that solid waste management at the municipal level in developing countries has typical

problem area that can be identified. He described them as:

Limited utilization of recycling activities

Inadequate landfill disposal.

Inadequate management of hazardous and health care waste.

Guoley (1992) argued that by focusing on the production process itself , examining where waste are

generated and exploring how they can be reduced , even simple measure such as separating was so that

they can be reused more easily, using different raw materials or replacing non-biodegradable product with

biodegradable ones can help achieve large waste reduction results. He also claimed that the greater put of


Zambrut



present waste arises not because the producer does not want it in such quantities that waste is inevitable.

This argument paces emphasis on recycling and conversation of waste management practices.

No solid waste management technology can function successful unless the municipal corporation

authorities strictly adopt the practice of segregation the garbage at domestic level, said Amrit Mann ,

Mayor of Borough of Hounslow , London , here today. He said segregation of garbage at household-level

was initiated by the local government in London long ago, for which the key aspect was to make the

residents aware about the utility and necessity of this system. In fact, the cost of the three - coloured bins,

which are positioned in front of every house in London is borne by the residents. The corporation's

responsibility is only to lift the garbage regularly and dispose it off, he said.

When the government of African countries were asked by the World Health Organization to prioritize

their environment health concerns, the result revealed that while solid waste was identified as the second

most important (after water quality) , less than 30% of urban populations have access to "proper and

regular garbage removal " ( Senkoro, 2003 ).

Meeting the financial demands of solid waste management at the municipal level will continue to be a

problem in the cities of developing countries. In areas where residents are assessed fees for waste removal,

the rate collection can be quite poor. Further, fewer and fewer people will not be willing to pay in the face

of poor or declining service. Many municipalities may not even be aware of the degree to which revenues

are collected, or the true cost of their entire solid waste operations. In this wise many municipalities have

tuned to privatization as a potential solution; certainly the financial picture is cleared somewhat when the

entire system is turned over to outside contractors. However local government will still be held

accountable if service declines ( Sc ' hu ' beler 1996 ).

2.2 The Attitude and Perception of People towards Solid Waste Management.

Navez - Bounchaire (1993) stated that management of household refuse is tied to perception and

socio- cultural practices which result in modes of appreciation of space which are greatly different to

whether the space is private or public. This is relevant as the population is heterogeneous.

Abrokwah ( 1998 ) , observed that ignorance , negligence and lack of law to punish sanitary offenders

and low level of technology in waste management are three major causes of waste management problems

in Kumasi ; he suggested that awareness should be created among the residents to manage household I

refuse and educate them on hazards that I'll - disposal waste could pose to the environment and to them.

Kendie (1999 ) argue that , the recent upsurge in waste disposal problems stems from the fact that,

"attitude and perception towards waste and rating of waste disposal issues in people's minds and in scheme

of official development plans have not been adequately considered ". There has been a tendency to

concentrate on the design of waste management technologies and how to apply them in context rather than

looking at the problem from governance perspective.

According to Agbola ( 1993 ) the root cause of many nations' environmental problems can be traced to

the way and manner in which " the imbibed behavioral patterns and acquired values are superimposed on

the environment" . Attitude are derived from experiences or leadership. He further said that beliefs,

perceptions and attitude are learned response sets and can therefore be changed through education.

In an article, " Do Attitude Matter”: Waste Disposal and Wetland Pollution in the Cape Coast

Municipalities of Ghana " Kendie ( 1999) , set out to develop an in-depth understanding of sanitation

practices and underlying factor responsible for the state of environmental sanitation in Cape Coast by

exploring the relationship between perception, attitude and beliefs on the same hand and sanitation

practices on the other. In this article Kendie was quick to dismiss the argument on rapid urbanization and

Inadequate funds.

According to him there is a positive relationship between the growth rate of cities and environmental

health. This view suggests that the faster the growth rate of urban centers, the more likely that

environmental services would be provided. Besides Ghana's urban population growth rate (4.0 - 4.5 per

annum) is lower than countries such as Botswana (12%), Zimbabwe ( 6% ) which have relative improved

sanitation services. Again Kedie thought that " while inadequate funding may have contributed to poor


Zambrut



sanitation in the 1970's and early 1980's this argument no longer holds argument no longer holds in recent

years. This study clearly shows that most people do not believe nor not sure whether the authorities in

charge of waste can solve the problems.

Although these weakness have been attributed to lack of logistics and financial management, people's

attitudes towards waste management should not be ignored (Nze , 1978 ) . He outlined several factors,

which have conspired to promote several factors, which have conspired to promote the massive buildup of

urban garbage and waste. Nze noted that they resulted from inadequate and deficient infrastructure,

Inadequate structure for environment administration, and deficient infrastructure, inadequate structures for

environmental administration, lopsided planning pastures and disregard for basic aesthethetic, industrial

and commercial growth, and other human factors. According to him, urban waste in Nigeria are regarded

as " non-resources" having at best a nuisance value and therefore not surprising that an equally negative

posture has been adopted in managing waste from urban concentrations in the country.

2.3 The Kind of Incentives Available for Solid Waste Management Workers.

Dumping picking is more hazardous than street picking. There are no reports of significant reduction

in health risk for dump pickers except when there have been substantial improvements in their basic living

conditions. The provision of gloves and boots pickers in Calcutta and other places failed. Schemes for

setting up coveryar belt plants at dump sites to facilities sorting ( as was done in Europe in the 19th century

) are often discussed . Mexico City and Cuidad Jurez have built such plans. In Seoul, on the other hand,

NGOs have assisted dump side communities more broadly, with sanitary facilities, medical care , and

education . It is possible that establishing designated picking areas at dumps, away from the tipping face

would help dump management. In fact, at large dumps, pickers usually cooperate among themselves and

with staff to avoid chaos and accidents. ( UNEP 2009 ).

Concerning salaries and incentive for solid waste management workers in Syria , they are generally

included in the grade of salaries, wages and incentive for workers in the government sectors plus the

compensation of solid waste management workers , which is a value of about 100% of the original salary.

This equals to about 50% of over the income of workers in other field. For example, the monthly income

of cleanliness worker is 3,700 Syrain pounds. This increase every two years at a rate of 7-9% (Ministry of

State Environment 2002).

Many local governments have utilized an incentive or " task pay” system for their waste collection

crews. In this type of system, each crew is assigned specific route, with a fixed number of stops to service

each day. They are paid a full day's work no matter how quickly or slowly they take to complete the route.

This gives workers an incentive to finish their routes as quickly as possible, while still ensuring that all

residences will be picked up in the course of the day. While this type of system has many advantages for

both collection crews and the local government, it also creates problems. Workers might place speed ahead

of safety, causing injuries to themselves or traffic accidents.

Also as waste generated patterns and neighborhood demography change over time, the route may

become unbalanced, with some becoming too long and others too short. These changes become especially

significant when a community increases waste diversion through recycling and / or "pay - as you throw "

fee structure (where households are charged on the basis of the amount of waste they produce). It is often

difficult to adjust work assignment to reflect these changes. ( Bartone, 1995 ).

Caincross et al. (1994, p. 113 - 146), noted that epidemiological studies conducted on compost use in

the United States of America revealed that aspergillus fumigatus as nose and throat culture positive were

more common among compost workers than other workers. Proper measure such as wearing of boots,

masks and gloves should be taken seriously in order to prevent the of spores of secondary pathogens

especially through the turning of compost piles.


Zambrut



3. METHODOLOGY

3.1 Background of the study area

Kwahu West District was curbed out of Kwahu South District in 2004 as part of Government local

reform policy. The District was upgraded to a Municipal status in January 2008 by the legislature interment

1870. The municipal lies between latitude 6 ' 30 North, 7'North and longitude 0'30 West, 1' West of the

equator, covering an area of 414 square kilometers . The Municipal capital, Nkawkaw is located about 241

kilometers North - West of Accra with a projected population of 53,520 (KWMA).

The Municipal is bounded to the north by Kwahu South District , to the west by Asante Akim South

District . To the east, it is bounded by the Fanteakwa District and to the south by Birim North and Atiwa

Districts. A very high proportion (66 per cent ) of the municipal population is Kwahus . The other

significant tribes are ewes (15 per cent ) and Asantes (17 per cent ) . These figures portray the municipal as

heterogeneous in terms of ethnicity. Again the municipal is predominantly Christian as they constitute 89

per cent. Ismalic and the traditional religions also constitute 10 per cent. The commercial activities of the

people are farming, trading and surface mining. It has social amenities such as schools,

telecommunication, electricity and water. Nkawkaw play host to both civil and public servant as well.

Kwahu South West Municipal lies within the semi - deciduous zone with very little of virgin forest

existing due to the negative effect of timber extraction and farming practices. There are are three forest

reverse in the municipal namely southern scarp being the largest , Kade bepo and Nkawkaw forest reverse.

Pra , Trado , Asuoboni and Adensua are some rivers in he municipal. The existing transportation networks

are roads and railways. However with the disfunctioning of the railway system, road networks are roads

and railways. However with the disfunctioning of the railway system, road network is the only available

transport system. Ghana Private Road Transport Union of TUC is the major road transport provider with

support from Cooperative Transport Association and Private Owner Transportation Association.

The following are some of non -governmental organizations in the municipal;

Word Vision International

Adventist Development and Relief Agency

Coalition for HIV / AIDS Awareness

Alcohol Nicotine Free Association

Passionate Friends Foundation

The Huger Project.

Table 1: Top ten disease in the municipal

Diseases Figures

Malaria 25,394

Hypertension 5,621

Skin disease 4,518

Acute respiratory infection 2,912

Acute eye infection 2,398

Diabetes mellitus 1,487

Gyaenocological conditions 1,468

Pregnancy related diseases 1,420

Rheumatism 1,320

Diarrheal diseases 1,319

(Kwahu West Municipal Health Directorate)

Most people visit the hospital and clinics for treatment. Some buy from the chemical shops whereas other

treat themselves with herds. The type and source of treatment depends on the person's perception of the

cause of a particular disease, individual's location and distance from recognized health institutions.


Zambrut



Table 2: Health Facilities in the Municipal

FACILITY NUMBER COMMENTS

Hospital 1 Mission

Hospital 3 Private

Maternity clinics 5 Private

Homeopathy clinics 2 Private

RCH 6 GHS

CHPS 21 GHS

(Kwahu West Municipal Health Directorate)

The municipal has over 94 Traditional Birth Attendants out of which 68 have been trained ,77 Herbalist

and Spiritual Healers. There is piped water system, hand dug Wells or boreholes in the municipal. Some of

the communities also depend on rivers and streams as their source of water supply. It has also got few

sanitary facilities.

Table 3: Toilet Facilities

TYPES OF TOILET PRIVATE PUBLIC

WATER CLOSET 384 5

VIP 1600 -

KVIP - 13

ENVIROLOO - 8

STL 133 22

Pit Latrine 1509 1

Pan Latrine 14 1

Sources: Environmental Health Unit

3.2 Types of Study / Study Design

This study was non - intervention study which adopted a descriptive study type. The issue of solid

waste management at both household level and municipal level has been a matter of great concern. The

researcher chose this study type because the researcher knows the problems of solid waste management

and want to carry out an in - depth description of solid waste management and its associated causes.

3.3 Data Collection Techniques (s) Tool (s)

Questionnaire and interview was the main instrument developed and used to gather data for the study.

The questionnaire was administered to some respondents while others were interviewed. The questions on

the instrument were mainly open ended. The items on the questionnaire were organized into two sections.

Section A deals with the bio data of the respondent while sections B deals with the main data comprising

specific objectives of the study. The questionnaires were given to respondent for completion either

immediately or at their convenience during the day. Those who could not read and write were interviewed

in their local languages.

3.4 Study Population

The target group for this study was some selected households and all municipal environmental health

workers at Nkawkaw who are at age 20 and above comprising of both males and females.

3.5 Sampling Techniques

Systematic sampling technique was applied to select 72 houses out of the 1440 houses. Starting from

the Eastward of the main Accra to Kumasi road, the first house was included after which every twentieth


Zambrut



house was also included in the study. Accidental sampling was also used to select the various households

in the first one to three households are selected depending on the number of household in each house.

3.6 Sample Size

The sample for the study was made up of 30 households in each of the three communities chosen

namely Zongo , Akuajoo and Maamaso and all environmental health officers. The reason is that , it is

normally in these three communities that communal refuse containers get full and liters scattered around

the containers . Through this process, size of 100 respondents was engaged for the study.

3.7 Data Analysis

The data collected from the respondents were edited, coded and fed into the computer. Special

Package for Social Science ( SPSS) version ..... was used to run the data . The results were presented in the

form of frequency distribution tables, bar charts and pie charts.

3.8 Limitation(s) of the Study

The following constraints were encountered during the study

1 Time frame was limited. Considering the time frame coupled with academic work is very limited.

2 No funds for mobilization and transportation. Due to lack of funds, purchasing of stationary and the cost

of printing the entire work was a problem and transportation to the communities.

3 Language barrier . The questionnaires had to be translated into local language ( Akan ) for those who

cannot read and write.

4 Some respondents put up criticism and argument which resulted in their inaccurate response to the

questionnaire.

5 Some respondents wanted to be compensated for the time spent in responding to the questionnaire. This

made the administration of the questionnaire quite difficult.

3.9 Ethical Considerations

Permission letter were sent to the Kwahu West Municipal Assembly and Environmental Health and

Sanitation Unit to seek permission to conduct the study in the municipality. The respondents were assured

of confidential and annoymity. Their right of privacy was Paramount to the researcher and that made them

to feel to provide the right information needed for study.

4. RESULTS PRESENTATION

This portion of the study provide comprehensive interpretation of result and discussion of findings.

4.1. Bio data respondents

Table 4: Gender of Respondents

Gender Frequency Percentage (%)

Female 48 53.3

Male 42 46.7

Total 90 100.0

(Sources: Field data)

Result from table 4 indicates that respondents who are Female recorded the highest percentage of total

population (53.3) whiles their Male counterparts recorded the last percentage of the study representing

(46.7%).


Zambrut



Table 5 : Age ( in years ) Distribution of Respondents

Age Frequency Percentage %

20 11 12.2%

21 - 30 39 43.3%

31 - 40 18 20.0%

41 and above 22 24.4%

Total 90 100.0%

(Source: Field data)

Table 2 depicts that respondents within the age of 21 - 30 years participated in the study representing (43.3

%) of the total population of the study. This is followed by (41 and above) years constituting a percentage

of (24.4%) of the population. The least age group that participated were 31 - 40 years and 20 years

representing (20%) and (12.2%) respectively of the respondents interviewed.

Table 6: Distribution of Respondents Residence / Community

Residence/community Frequency Percentage %

Akuajoo 30 33.3%

Maamaso 30 33.3%

Zongo 30 33.3%

Total 90 100.0%

(Source: Field Data)

Table 7: Educational Background of Respondents

Educational background Frequency Percentage%

Elementary/ JSS 29 32.2%

No formal education 13 14.4 %

Primary 8 8.9%

SSS 31 34.4%

Tertiary 90 10.0%

Total 90 100.0%

(Sources: Field data)

The results of the study revealed that majority (34.4%) of the respondents had only SHS education. It also

revealed that (32.2%) had Elementary/ J H S education, (14.4 %) of the respondents had no formal

education (8.9%) however had up to primary education.

Table 8. Religion of Respondents

Religion Frequency Percentage %

Christian 60 66.7%

Muslim 21 23.3 %

Traditional 9 10.0%

Total 90 100.0%


Table 8 shows that majority (66.7%) of the respondents were Christmas followed by (23.3%) of the

respondents who were Muslims. However, (10%) of the respondents were Traditional Worshipers.


Zambrut



Table 9. Marital Status of Respondents

Marital Status Frequency Percentage%

Divorce 7 7.8%

Married 39 43.3%

Single 38 42.2%

Windowed 6 6.7%

Total 90 100.0

(Source : Field data)

Table 9: indicates that there are (43.3%) of respondents who are married in the study However, the results

also revealed that (42.2%) of the respondents are single, (6.7%) of the respondents were no longer staying

with their husbands/wives or are widowed but (7.8%) were divorced.

4.2 Solid waste management practices both at the household and municipal levels.

FIGURE 1: SHOWING RESPONDENTS’ MEANS OF DISPOSING REFUSE.

Findings from figure 1 shows that 40% of the people use the facilities of the eh, 33.3% use private

contractor, 23.3% dump elsewhere and 3.3% burn their solid waste.


Zambrut



FIGURE 2: Showing Respondents’ Type of Storage Facility

Figure 2 indicates that 46.7% use dustbin with fitting covers, 28.9% use basket and 24.4% use others.

FIGURE 3: SHOWING HOW RESPONDENTS TREAT THEIR REFUSE

Figure 3 depicts that 60% practice compositing, 30% practice crude dumping and 10% practice sanitary

landfill.


Zambrut



FIGURE 4: SHOWING PROBLEM RTESULTING FROM THE MODE OF SOLID WASTE

MANAGEMENT

Figure 4 indicates that 30% perceive the problem surface water pollution, 20% think there will land

pollution, and 20% also think the site will serve as breeding grounds for this flies, 20% think there will be

offensive odour and 10% think there can be an outbreak of disease.

FIGURE 5: RESPONDENTS SOLUTIONS TO THE TO THE PROBLEMS OF SOLID WASTE

MANAGEMENT


Zambrut



4.3 THE ATTITUDE AND PERCEPTION OF PEOPLE TOWARDS SOLID WASTE

MANAGEMENT.

FIGURE 6. RESPONDENTS’ KNOWLEDGE ON WHOSE RESPONSIBILITIES IS TO CLEAN

THE ENVIRONMENT.

Figure 6 shows that 57.8% is both, 35.6% are individual and 6.7% said health inspectors.

FIGURE 7: RESPONDENTS KNOWLEDGE ON WHETHER WASTE MANAGEMENT

PERSONNELS ARE IMPORTANT

Figure 7 explains that 94.4% of the respondents said yes while 5.6% said no.


Zambrut



FIGURE 8: RESPONDENTS’ KNOWLEGDE ON WHETHER THEY WILL OFFER ANY

POSSIBLE ASSISTANCE FOR SOLID WASTES MANAGEMENT IN NKAWKAW

Figure 8 SHOWS 82.2% SAID THEY OFFER ASSISTANCE WHILE 17.8% SAID THEY WILL NOT.

FIGURE 9: SHOWING RESPONDENTS’ RECOMMENDATION FOR PROPER

MANAGEMENT OF SOLID WASTE IN NKAWKAW

Figure 9 indicate that 35.6% suggested that dustbins with fitting covers should be placed at vantage points,

18.9% also said that communal containers should be emptied frequently, 15.6% said that health education

should be given on proper waste, 14.4% said that solid waste should be burnt regularly, 13.3% said there

should be clean-up exercise twice a week and 22.2% suggested recycling of the solid waste.


Zambrut



The kind of incentives available for solid waste management workers.

Table 10: Available equipment and its optimum number

EQUIPMENT AVAILABLE OPTIMUM

NUMBER FREQUENCY PERCENTAGE%

Hand Fork 4 10 6 60%

Wheel Barrow 2 10 4 40%

Rake 3 10 8 80%

Shovel 5 10 3 30%

Long Broom 5 10 2 20%

Wellington

boots 4 15 2 20%

Dustbins 13 15 2 20%

Total 36 80 27 100%


Results from table 7 indicate that a required of 10 hand forks were needed as against 4 that were available

representing 60%, 10% rakes were needed as against 2 that were available representing 40%, 10 rakes

were needed as against 3 available ones representing 80%, 10 shovels were needed as against 5 that were

available representing 30%, 10 long broom were needed as against 5 available ones representing 20%, 15

wellington boots were needed as against 4 that were available representing 20%, 15 dustbins were needed

as against 13 available ones representing 20%. The optimum number is the number of equipment they

presently have.

Table 11: Available labour force and its optimum number

Description Available Optimum

Number Frequency Percentage%

Sanitary

Labourers 10 20 6 60%

Sweepers 4 10 8 80%

Refuse

collectors 5 10 6 60%

Cleaners 9 15 5 50%

Total 28 55 25 100%

Table 8 shows that 20 sanitary labourers were needed as against 10 that were available representing 60%,

10 sweepers were needed as against 4 that were available representing 80%, 10 refuse collectors were

needed as against 4 that were available representing 60%, and 15 cleaners were needed as against 9 that

were available representing 50%.


Zambrut



Do you feel comfortable in where you work?

FIGURE 10: SHOWING WHETHER RESPONDENTS FEEL COMFORTABLE IN WHERE

THEY WORK.

Result from figure 8 shows that 90% of the health inspectors feel comfortable while 10% do not.

5. DISCUSSION OF RESULTS

5.1 Bio data of respondents

Results of the study revealed that, although females are more associated with waste generation males

are also more concerned about the consequences theses wastes will cause. As such, a substantial number of

male respondents participated in the study. Most of the respondents fall within the ages of 21-40

representing a youthful society. All the respondents had some level of education with majority of them

34.4% being SSS leavers, 32.2% JSS, 14.4% non-formal, 10.0% tertiary and 8.9% primary. All the

respondents belong to a religious affiliation. Majority of the respondents were without partners and were

from all walks of life.

5.2 Solid waste management practices both at the household and municipal level.

In the study it was noted that the respondents had a way of managing their solid waste with some of

them using the services of private contractors. This affirms to the study done by Nyachhyon (2006), that

public private partnership has been identified as efficient instrument to promote solid waste management.

Usually in the area of urban public services such as waste management, are promoted as a means to deliver

service through a contractual relationship with a private sector firm.

Twenty-three percent of the respondents dump elsewhere which is later used as manure for their

backyard farming. As stated by Nyang‟echi (1992) that when solid waste is left to lie and heap on the

ground, decomposition takes place and the nuisance of smell, flies and invasion of rodents occur. These

decomposed waste can be used as manure through composting for farming purpose. He therefore explains

that waste at the households and the municipal levels can be use be use various purposes such as fertilizers

through a process called composting when the waste is condensed. On the other hand, some out of the 23%

of the respondent dumped elsewhere without any intention of future use thus making the environment look

insanitary. This had been confirmed by Benneh et al. (1993 ) , when they observe that residential domestic

waste forms the bulk of all sources of solid waste produced in urban areas. These household waste are

known to have high densities with high moisture content and organic component of solid waste, which

90

10

YES NO


Zambrut



properly accounts for about 70% to 90% , while tins , cans and proper are probably responsible for about

5% to 10% of the total waste produced. They further argued that because of the capacity to handle all of

the household waste generated is still weak, about 83% of the population dump refuse in either authorized

sites in their neighborhood which creates unsanitary conditions.

Although 47% use dustbins with fitting covers which is recommended, those using baskets and others

however create the medium for diseases transmission. With the exception of the dustbins, none of the

containers had covers. A substantial percentage of the garbage is put into polythene bags. These waste

handling methods are likely contributory factor for poor sanitation in the area, because much of the refuse

is littered about before reaching the sanitary sites.

Generally, it was realized that greeter percentage of the respondents relied on sacks than other

storage methods. This might be because it was cheaper and perhaps could store more waste but lacks of

any covers have serious health implication. Most of the refuse is kept close to kitchens and rooms, which

may cause diseases like cholera and typhoid fever. The Municipal Assembly's subsiding the prices of

standard dustbins with fitting covers could help change this situation for the better.

5.3 The attitude and perception of people towards solid waste management.

Majority of the respondent think it is the responsibility of both the individual and the environment

health staffs. As such when there is a clean -up activities, they expect that the environment health staff

should provide logistics and food and sometimes money in order to give in their best. This confirms Nze

study in 1978 that although lack of logistics and financial management contribute to improper solid waste

management, people and perception should not be ruled out. The problem of solid waste management and

people's attitude and perception can be linked to levels of formal education. Improved teaching and

learning of issues on sanitation in all levels of education could help improve the general sanitation in the

communities.

This supports the suggestion of Agbola (1993) that perceptions and attitudes are learned response sets

and can therefore be modified or changed through education. Hence, continuous public education of

people of Nkwakaw many help improve the the sanitation in the Area . Education of households on

cleaning their surroundings was discussed. The causes of many nations' environmental problems could be

found by the way the imbedded behavioral patterns and acquired values are sueperimposed on the

environment. The imbedded behavioural patterns are cultural in origin , derived from the socializing

processes in families and communities (Agbola, 1993 ) . A large percentage of the respondent see the

essence of environmental health staff and their readiness to offer any assistance towards proper solid waste

management yet the respondents want to financially motivated as stated earlier on.

5.4 The kind of Incentives available for solid waste management workers.

Human are known to work better under certain favourable conditions or incentives.90% of the workers

feel comfortable in their area of work due to the fact those repondents who were ready to offer any form of

assistance to boost solid waste management live in their catchment area. The other 10% of the workers

happened to work with those respondents who do not see the relevance of them and for that not offer any

help. This problem was the reflection of data collected on the field. Another reason was inadequate

equipment and labour force to work with.Some of these workers are prone to diseases. This confirms a

study by Caincross et al .(1994) . They noted that epidemiological studies conducted on compost use in the

United States of America revealed that asperillugus fumigatus as nose and throat culture positive were

more common among compost workers. They however suggested that proper measure such as wearing of

boots , masks and gloves should be taken seriously I'm order to prevent the spores of secondary pathogens

especially through the turning of the compost piles.


Zambrut



6. CONCLUSION

6.1 Solid Waste Management Practices both at the Household and the Municipal Levels

This study was conducted to find out problems with solid waste management at Nkawkaw. Findings

from this study revealed that, most of the respondents had ways of managing their solid waste. Although

not all the approaches were appropriate hence serving a threat to disease outbreaks. It was also realized

that a greater percentage of the respondents relied on sacks than other means of storage. This was due to

the cheap nature and could store more waste but lack any covers that could have health implications.

6.2 The Attitude and Perception of the People Towards Solid Waste Management

In addition, majority of the respondent think it is the responsibility of both the individual and the

environmental health staff to attend to sanitation issues. As such when there is some clean-up activities,

they expect that the environmental health staff should provide logistics and food and sometimes money in

order to give in their best.

It was realized that the problem of solid waste management and people‟s attitude and perception was

linked to levels of formal education which can be modified through continuous public education.

6.3 The Kind of Incentives Available for Solid Waste Management Workers

Humans are known to work better under certain favorable conditions or incentives. 90% of the

workers feel comfortable in their area of work due to the fact that those respondents who were ready to

offer any form of assistance to boost solid waste management live in their catchment area.

They however suggested that proper measures such as wearing of boots, masks and gloves should be

taken seriously in order to prevent the spores of secondary pathogens especially through the turning of the

compost piles.

7. RECOMMENDATIONS

1. The public should be educated by the environmental health officers on solid waste and its related issues.

Basically, hygiene practices should be taught especially on radios, televisions, in newspapers, and in

schools to educate people on proper ways of handling solid waste and keeping the surrounding clean.

2. stricter enforcement of byelaws should be ensured by the sanitation unit where administrative penalties

for minor violations should be taken with urgency.

3. the sanitation unit should make it a responsibility of introducing the use of standard bins with lid for

domestic and commercial use to the people of Nkawkaw.

4. people should develop proper attitudes and perception towards waste handling, which should be

achieved through both formal and informal education.

5. the government, donor countries, Nongovernmental Organisations (NGOs) and other stakeholders

should be encouraged to donate money and equipment to the sanitation unit to enable the unit acquire

effective and efficient personnel and equipment.

6. The community should adopt a self-help approach to solve the problem. Much can be achieved when the

various communities mobilize themselves and organize periodic clean up exercises and by contributing

financially to support the exercise, the residents can also act as watch dogs and make sure that they

themselves adhere to proper waste disposal practices.

7. The chiefs and other opinion leaders must be given additional roles to play in ensuring environmental

cleanliness. This can be done by authorizing the chiefs in each area or community to take up the

additional job of ensuring clean environmental practices with the youth playing an important role.

8. The women should be made to play an important role as it has been realized that women do a greater

part of solid waste handling and disposal in the community.

9. prioritize the issue of waste management.


Zambrut



8. BIBLIOGRAPHY

Abrokwa, K., (1998). “Refuse Management Problems in Central Kumasi”: status report on population,

Human Resource Development Planning Policy in Ghana 1960.

Agbola, T., (1993). Environmental Education in Nigerian Schools” In Filho W.L (Ed) Environmental

Education in Commonwealth of Learning Vancouver.

Allafrica.com Retrieved on 24/09/11.

Bartone, C.R., (1995). “THE ROLE OF THE Private Sector in Waste Management in Developing

Countries.” Singapore.

Benneh, G., Songsore, J., Nabila S.T., Amuzu A.J., Tutu K.A., Yaugyourn (1993).

“Environmental Problems and Urban Household in Greater Accra Metropolitan Area Ghana.” M.A.C

Stockhelm, Ghana.

Caincross, C., and Freachen R., (1993). “Environmental Health Engineering in the Tropics.” (2ND

Edition).

Chichester: John Wiley and Sons Ltd.

Cointreau, S., (1982). “Environmental Management of Urban Solid Wastes in Developing Countries: A

project Guide. Washington, DC: Urban Development Department, World Bank.”

Goulay, K.A., (1992). “World of Waste, Dilemmas of industrial Development, Zed books Limited

London.”

Headley, J., (1998). “An overview of Solid Waste Management in Barbados”. Inn solid Waste

Management: Critical Issues for developing Countries, edited by Elizabeth Thomas- Hope, Kingston:

Canoe Press.

Kendie, S., (1992). “Do Attitudes Matter? Waste Disposal and Wetland Degradation in the Capecoast

Municipality of Ghana.” Development and Project Planning Center, University of Bradford

Discussion Paper no.21 Bradford.

Kwawe B., (1995). “ Cultures of Waste Handling; Experience of a Rural Community.” Journal of Asian

and African studies. Volume XXX, number 1-2.

Landy, Marck, Marc J. Roberts; and Stephen R. Thomas. (1990). “The Environmental Protection Agency;

Asking the Wrong Questions.” New York; Oxford University Press.

Mbande, C., (1996). “Some Problems of Waste Management in Developing Countries.”

McCarthy, Jmes and MarkPeisch.(1987). “Harzadous Waste Fact Book.”Environmental ad Natural

Resources Policy Division, Congress and Resource Service, ENR.

Mensah, A., and Larbi, E., (2005). “Solid Waste Disposal in Ghana”.

(www.trend . wastan.net) Accessed on 24/04/2005. Retrieved 18/10/11.

Miller, J.G., (1988). “Perspective of Solid Waste Mangement in Ghana, Recycling Option Seminar on

Abfall Borse Stock Exchange for Industrial Waste” Geoth Institute, Ghana.

Navez-Bouchaive, F., (1993). “Cleanliness and the Appropriation of Space, Refuse and Living Habitation

Large Moroccan Town People‟s Mediterranean.” Morocco.

Nyachhyon, B., (2006). “Prospects and Constraints of Public Private Partnership for Urban Waste

Management”, Policy Paper 15, Kathmandu, Nepal: SCAEF, Economic Policy Network, Asian

Development Bank.

Nyang‟echi, N., (1992). Management of Solid and Liquid Waste.

Nze, F.C., (1978) “Managing Urban Waste in Nigeria for social and Economic Development” Journal of

Management Studies, Lagos Vol. 5, Nigeria.

Onibakun A., and Kumuyi J., (1999) “Governance and Waste Management “is Africa in Adepoju G.

Onibokun (Ed), “Managing the Moster” Urban Waste Management and Governance in Africa.

International Development Research Center, Canada.

Pacey, A., (1990). “Hygiene and literacy” in Kerr, C (Ed), Community Health and Sanitation, Immediate

Technology Publications, Nigeria.

Schubeler, P. (1996.) “Conceptual Framework for Municipal Solid Waste Management in Low Income

Countries”. United Nations Development Program Working Paper Series no.9 St. Gallen,

Switzerland: SKAT.


Zambrut



Senkoro, H., (2003). “Solid Waste Management In Africa”. AWHO/AFRO Perspective Paper 1.

Shekdar, A., (2009). “Sustainable Solid Waste Management: an integrated approach for Asian Countries”.

Simmens, R., (1981). “Refuse Management in Kumasi”. Land Administration Research Centre Kwame

Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, Kumasi.

UNCHS. (1996). “An Urbansing World Global Report on Human Settlements” Oxford University Press.

United Nations Environmental Programme. (2009).” Developing Integrated Solid Waste Management Plan

Training Manual, Vol.2: Assessment of Current Waste Management Systems and Graps Therein”.

Osaka/Shiga Japan.

W.H.O (2004). “Estimation on Diarrhoeal Diseases”. Geneva: W.H.O Publication.

Williams, R., (1993) “Hazardous and Industrial Waste Compositing. In: Science and Engineering of

Compositing.” Renaissance Press, Worthington, OH.

Work Shop about Solid Waste Management in Syria. (2000). Ministry of State Environment.

Zambrut Journal, Link Access;

https://zambrut.com


© Copyright International Journal of Zambrut | Zambrut, Inc.




Documents

The Problem of Solid Waste Management - Zambrut · The study is significant because it will help the researcher to discover the problems of solid waste management. It will help create