Upload
jacqueline-anne
View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 1/40
The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
Supervisor: Susan Resnick-West
Dissertation (COMM 599) submitted to the Department of Media and Communications,
University of Southern California, April 20111 in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the
MSc in Global Media and Communication
Jacqueline Smith Global Media and Communications
1
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 2/40
Introduction! Decades ago, when press advertisements and direct marketing were at the cutting edge
of media, a humanitarian aid organization by the name of Oxfam used startling photographs to
depict victims of world hunger and called for public participation in the Western world for
alleviation. While I am not suggesting that was the beginning of visual appeals in aid, I amsuggesting the representations were the beginning of a bond; one that subtly built a structure of
confined agency in the representation of the sufferers, yet more importantly, came to symbolize
a call to convene for an emerging public whose resources and collective capacity for empathy
were needed. The corollary that evolved over the next 60 years has shown to follow a complex
growing process in the representation of others. This process involves an intricate relationship
between humanitarian aid organizations, publics and audiences and most importantly, the ways
in which they distribute these representations; the media.
! A strong example of this juncture is illustrated in the organization Invisible Children, a non-
profit founded in 2003, which serves afflicted areas of northern Uganda and central Africa that
have been infiltrated and terrorized by Joseph Kony and his transient Lords Resistance Army
(LRA). The organizations model relies on the traditional need for donations and fundraising, but
channels its communication in new ways; their interactive Web site offers interactive information
about their mission, maps, games, links, forums and most importantly, video.
! In previous research endeavors, I argued that the shift to media and technology centricity
in our society is responsible for shifting audiences attention away from the one dimensional
views of suffering. With that, I take the idea further by su40ggesting that the proliferation of aid
and social welfare appeals can be attributed to widespread use of online new media platforms
and because of that, the representation of crisis and actor agency has transformed as well.
Through multi-modal analysis of dialogue, visual imagery and their interplay, I look at the 3 part
web mini series and newest campaign, “The Protection Plan ”, by Invisible Children. I seek to
satisfy the question, In what ways have new aid campaigns, specifically Invisible Children ̓ s
Protection Plan, adapted their visual and textual representation of crisis by using new media?
and What implications does Invisible Children ̓ s multi media approach have for the audiences?
! I chose this piece for analysis as it defines the idea of aid organizations using new media
in news; the 3-part webisodes are all under 7 minutes long and have a unique narrative that
exemplifies, yet does not preach, the power of grassroots movements which has proven to be
widely successful on a national level. It is the most contemporary campaign from Invisible
Children and the first completely interactive campaign theyʼve had. Invisible Children is a worthy
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
2
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 3/40
organization for study because of itʼs belief that this kind of online exposure and interaction
between organization, sufferer and audience will help revolutionize the way citizens see being
ʻactiveʼ in an aid campaign.
! In three sections, post-humanitarianism and media logic, representation and discourse
and lastly compassion and morals, I construct a review of literature from each standpoint of the
relationship that creates the space Invisible Children operates in. Post humanitarianism and
media logic frame organizations through the scope of modernity and reliance on emerging
technologies which helps define the independent, Web based nature of Invisible Children. In
representation and discourse, I look at the historical image of suffering through a conditioned
popular discourse to explain why new representations, such as ones used in the piece for
examination, are more than a breakthrough on negotiating compassion fatigue, but also
progress in discourse itself. Lastly, I recognize a crucial academic debate concerning the
audience and form a theoretical foundation for the audience ʼs role in acting and reacting to
representations through popular discourse.
! Chapter 2 of this paper outlines the chosen methodological approach, multi-modal
analysis of discourse and image. There will be a discussion of both strategies, defining them in
terms of this paper and a justification for employing them for this particular piece of discourse.
Limitations and general research notes will be addressed before delving into the results and
discussion. Finally I would conclude with a summary of findings from my research and provide
recommendations for further study on this topic.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
3
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 4/40
Literature Review
! For years, humanitarian and international aid agencies have witnessed and responded to
a plethora of global tragedies5. Social, political and technological change has had an impact on
this sector, specifically in changing the landscape for communicating their need to the public.
Increased awareness in a global media environment has led to more social issues becoming
public and apparent, creating more a competitive field in vying for audience attention and
compassion. Coupled then with the sometimes tense relationship between humanitarian
initiatives and political support, the need and abilities for aid organizations to define themselves
and their voices distinctly becomes key in finding a strong audience base. With the impact of
new media use and practices, what impact does this have for the appeal of the organization?
What are the potential implications of those changes? What follows is a summary of relevant
literature in the field that highlights key tensions, agreements and debates that seek to provide
answers to these, and other questions.
Media Logic
! To begin, aid organizations, or any other kind of business for that matter, are reactors to
the environment in which they operate and arguably nothing in our social environment has
proven to grow as fast or as powerful as the mass media. David Altheide and Robert Snow
(1979) refer to this reaction from different social sectors as making use of “media logic”. The
authors describe media logic as a mode of understanding and interpreting affairs in the social
and sub social realms (popular culture, entertainment, news, sports etc.) through the framework
of a reality the media portrays. Further to the point, people wholly adopt this logic and have
made it a way of life (1979, p.237).
! This framework of media logic helps explain some of the key changes in the humanitarian
aid sector particularly well, as evidenced by the many global agencies vying for more media
time which could result in more support. Following this notion, Simon Cottle and David Nolan
describe what they see as the relationship between the media and aid organizations. Illustrating
and framing the dynamics of such a relationship, they recount Larry Minearʼ
s (1996) descriptionof what is known as ʻthe crisis triangleʼ. Crisis triangles exist at the junction of governments,
news media and humanitarian organizations and they are inextricably linked in an ebb and flow
type relationship to survive (Cottle, Nolan, 2007, p.863). In theory, each facet is considered an
individual actor yet simultaneously part of the collective actor (the crisis triangle) in relation to
the larger concept of media logic. Therefore, humanitarian organizations have reacted to a more
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
4
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 5/40
media centric environment in four ways. First, by branding themselves organizationally to
respond to the constant exposure in the media, second, by preparing stories, events and
celebrity spokespeople in advance to stay relevant in a 24 hour-a-day information society. Third,
by regionalizing their information and coverage of aid work while “marginalizing if not occluding
local relief responses and indigenous participants” and fourth, using time and resources to
protect their organizational image and credibility against potential damaging media claims (p.
864).
! These four processes provide an insight into an association aid organizations have with
the government and news media. An example could be an agency taking legal action against a
media outlet to protect confidential information about victims involved in a tragedy, but shortly
thereafter working with the media on publicity for a staged event raising awareness about relief
efforts for that same tragedy.
!
On Representation and Discourse
! As the sub-title suggests, representation and discourse are two non-mutually exclusive,
almost inextricable terms. In terms of this paper, representation will be understood as being a
product of dominant media discourses and more specifically discourse on race and ethnicity are
framed as being carved out of the subtle details these dominant media discourses choose to
provide to the masses. In other words by Stuart Hall:
“What the media produce is, precisely representations of the social world, images, descriptions,
explanations and frames for how the world is and why it works the way it is said and is shown to work.
And, amongst other kind of ideological labor, the media construct for us a definition of what race is, what
meaning the imagery of race carries and what the “problem of race” is understood to be.” (Hall, 1981.
Bridges and Brunt, 1981, 35.MacDonald, 2003, 7)
! A key example of this, and most relevant to this research, is the idea of the ʻsuffering black
Africanʼ or ʻstarving African childʼ. Imagery and discourse on these constructs can be found
scattered through the media for the last 60 years. Oxfam with their famous visuals of skeletal
black children on the brink of death6 if only for the 10 cents a day a wealthy Westerner could
donate. Stanley Cohen discusses the ʻold charity discourseʼ whereby humanitarian
organizations subscribe to representations of the Other as ʻpragmatic amorality – patronizing,
ethnocentric, fatalistic (poverty just happens, like natural disasters)ʼ (Cohen, 2001, p. 178). He
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
5
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 6/40
further discusses this discourse as becoming more engrained in media logic as charity and relief
efforts start using these pornographic images of suffering as bait to reel the consumer to buy (in
some cases, literally) into the cause.
! The constructed myth of the inevitable sufferer has been an accepted visual cue that
audiences have been conditioned to through decades of normalization yet there is strong
evidence to suggest this use of intense suffering and negative imagery is counter-productive to
charity organizations cause. Evelyn J. Dyck and Gary Coldevin conducted a study in
conjunction with the World Vision Canada charity in which they developed a way to test the
appeal of negative versus positive images for fundraising applications (Coldevin & Dyck, 1992;
Tester, 2001, p. 82-83). Splitting 45,855 English speaking Canadians into three groups to
receive three different versions of a pamphlet asking for donations, the results were a challenge
to the normative model of imagery for donation appeal. The first group received a photo of a
happy, healthy child represented in a positive manner, the second group received an image of a
sick looking, unhealthy child represented in a negative manner and the third group received no
image at all, just a textual appeal for a donation.
! While this study dealt with many more layers such as gender and economics, the
overarching hypothesis was that positive imagery would yield higher donations than negative
and pure textual ones alike. The surprising response was that of the pure text averaging higher
responses than both image categories, which is discussed in the following section, but for the
purposes of this paper, the important conclusion was that the positive image was more
successful than the appeal using the traditional sufferer (Coldevin & Dyck, 1992; Tester, 2001, p.
82-83). This conclusion directly confronts the traditional representations humanitarian
organizations use in appeals circulating through the media and dominant discourse. While the
representation of the Other is redesigned, located at the same origin is the allowance for
popular conception of audiences as lethargically sympathetic to be rethought and possibly given
more credit as an active consumer of images.
! Although this study shows that positivism is more productive in terms of garnering
spectators attention than negativism, there is still tension as to the consistency of either. The co-existence of both appeals is suggested to be present in just about every aid campaign and
subtleties within the campaign can produce/validate or contest existing ideologies and
discourses within the same mediated space (Dogra, 2007, p.6). This creates a duality between
coherence and ambivalence within one single message which is worth noting, particularly for
purposes of this paper, as multi-modal analysis is especially esteemed at finding such visual
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
6
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 7/40
and textual tensions. These tensions are important because it exemplifies a transition or attempt
at transitioning from an emotion-oriented appeal to an overall more reflexive position to give
room for the spectator to make their own judgement on the need for their help. At the same
time, negativism can be found in slight undertones in appeals in humanitarian communication to
remind the viewer that it is still a precarious, timely situation. This continual theme of coherence
and ambivalence within the humanitarian message will be explored in this case study, paying
close attention to the rational claim for help.
! Roland Barthes helps expand the view on rationality and positivism in a work of essays
titled Mythologies in the 1950ʼs established a theory as to why a positive image in relation to a
tragedy could garner more funds or support. Although work on this, from the chapter ʻThe Great
Family of Manʼ, was not set in context of humanitarian aid, using the scope of this paper to
frame his argument, it becomes applicable. Barthes argues that beyond all signs and symbols
dominant discourse train us to process, we are all humans who engage in ʻmoral universalismʼ.
We feel for the human condition on a raw level of being, therefore in the context of
representation we relate to the setting and the affliction. What sounds so simple is actually the
myth he is debunking; it is not in the negative photo of suffering we relate to, it is in the positive
image of a sufferer that serves as evidence that it is humanly possible to find a resolution to
stop the suffering (Barthes, 1972, p.100-116; Tester, 2001, p.89). There is not sufficient
evidence agencies today employ these positive imagery tactics, but with the evidence on
dominant discourse and representation we turn to a discussion on the audiences role in
consuming and reacting to information on the suffering Other.
Compassion and Morals
! ! If the public is the target of efforts for support of aid agencies, there are certainly
implications of the representations comprising the efforts. A highly contested subject in the
academic world by theorists researching the humanitarian condition is that of ʻcompassion
fatigueʼ and the role of human morals. Susan Moeller (1999) theorizes in full support of active
human morals but also of the reality and prominence of compassion fatigue among the westernworld today. She discusses the state of audiences as having ʻIʼve-seen-it before syndromeʼ, but
even more interestingly, discusses compassion fatigue as a pronounced ʻprior-restraintʼ on all
media outlets (p.2). In other words, the desensitization of audiences to sensational news is so
great that the fatigue dictates what stories news outlets will report on. It is an ongoing adaption
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
7
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 8/40
of news outlets to the feelings of the viewer, which is in effect a never-ending process as one
continually affects the other (media logic)
! Stanley Cohen (2001) postulates compassion fatigue is built on three key, overlapping
concepts: information overload, normalization and desensitization. As he argues cases against
each, for the purposes of this paper I choose to focus on his unique case against information
overload. Cohen makes no question of the proposed arbitrary argument the overload or fatigue
theory carries:
“It implies that individuals and societies have thermostats that switch off when too much information
comes in. This is contrary to all theories of cognition and memory. It is not even a good metaphor: baths
fill up and overflow; minds and cultures donʼt.” (2001, p.188)
What seems at first to be a complete denial of fatigue theories, Cohen does not disbelieve
audiences feel overwhelmed, he just does not believe images and news stories are doing the
damage; he argues it is all in the demands these appeals make. A concept called “demand
overload” is the high psychological, emotional or financial demands that turn us off, but up to the
point of overwhelming audiences, any amount of information can be consumed. He goes further
by saying when these demands are made in relation to distant suffering, viewers get a sense of
helplessness but instead of turning off, they will be more apt to act locally to problems
surrounding them. That way, the demand that is being made of them is reconciled, lest being on
a micro scale (Cohen, 2001 p.189).
! The theory of demand brings us back to the Dyck and Coldevin study of the use of images
and representation appeals in aid campaigns for fundraising. After the data is presented and
discussed, a key take away message appears; audiences are rational people, they view the
demands that are made of them through what is called “consumption logic”. This logic follows
that potential supporters of the organization want to feel as if their donations will be made out of
a rational state, not an emotive one that negative pictures or representations try to elicit (Dyck
and Coldevin, 1996. Tester, 2001).
! Considering media-logic as the construct in which humanitarian organizations have been
using to channel their audiences emotions may be lacking in terms of fully accounting for the
fundamental change the democratization of media has had on aid appeals. Lille Chouliaraki
introduces a new approach to this change by defining it as ʻpost-humanitarianismʼ. She states,
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
8
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 9/40
! “It is this humanitarian sensibility, characterized by textual games, low intensity emotional regimes
! and a technological imagination of instant gratification and justification, that we may call
! post-! humanitarian communication... the key feature of post-humanitarianism lies precisely in
! loosening up this ʻnecessaryʻ link between seeing suffering and feeling for the sufferer and in
! de-coupling emotion for the sufferer from acting on the cause of suffering (Chouliaraki, 2010, p.
! 17)”.
She goes further into analysis by separating the approaches pre and post humanitarian
campaigns used as appeals; the former, emotional-oriented appeals rely on the assumed moral
universalism of the audience while post-humanitarianism aims at reflexive particularism of the
individual viewer (2010, 18). In other words, traditional aid appeals have spoken to a low
common moral denominator among viewers, not particular to each individual, but something
common everyone can feel and understand. Given the complexity of the new media
environment (instant information gratification, multi-dimensional and multi-sensory mediums,
high speed online connectivity, etc) Chouliaraki points out that the segmentation and diversity of
channels for communication on humanitarian aid issues have changed not only the way viewers
engage with aid organizations, but have also informed the new approaches to those viewers
from the organizations themselves. The culmination of these two shifts has given way to the
embrace of reflexive particularism, or, a shift to promotion of individual judgement and decision.
Instead of presenting the cause as an appeal for specific action based on assumed morality of
the viewer, a reflexive particularist appeal would try to be as void of viewer assumption as
possible, presenting the scenario and then relying on ʻthe deliberative cognition reflections” from
the audience to make a choice of whether to act or not (Levy, 2011, 141).
! The two key aspects of post-humanitarian appeal that Chouliaraki outlines are moral
properties that would be antithetical to traditional one-dimensional shock effect or agency
branding messages. The technologicalization of action is the first statute and it speaks to the
new media that is used to present this appeal. It looks at why appeals over new media are
getting more audience reaction and attributes the cause of it the new media itself, purely
because it makes donating or signing a petition simple . The online platform creates a simple
structure to get involved (click you mouse or use pay-pal) while the voice of post-
humanitarianism backs away from emotion and justifying why you should care to make way for
the viewers immediate reflexive feelings.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
9
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 10/40
! The second imperative aspect of the voice of post humanitarianism is the de-
emotionalization of the cause or the avoidance of traditional emotional triggers (guilt,
indignation, etc.) as they are considered to be non-actionable feelings (as opposed to rational
thought that leads to an actionable outcome). This of course does not suggest post-
humanitarian messages are void of emotion, they are not, but the emotion elicited is meant to
taken into consideration and examined by the viewer (Chouliaraki, 2010, p. 15). De-
emotionalizing while still implementing an emotional-rational appeal requires delicate navigation
on part of the organization and can be seen as being a large part of the coherence/ambivalence
struggle in post-humanitarian sensibility
Invisible Children: The Protection Plan
! Invisible Children takes a unique media based approach, producing dozens of promotional
videos for fundraising events, as benchmarks for on the ground initiative progress and
informational videos aiming to give full scope to the issue. Invisible Children's most recent
campaign for “The Protection Plan” is a 3 part web mini-series that introduces the initiative,
focuses on the infrastructure being built and illustrates what you can do to be a part of it. The
aim of this project is “to implement a strategy in the LRA affected areas that will protect innocent
civilians from brutal LRA violence, prove rehabilitation for children rescued form the LRA and
facilitate progress towards apprehending the top LRA commanders”(Invisible Children
Protection Plan, p. 3, 2011). The 5 key objectives in the plan for protection and rehabilitation
include:
• building an early warning radio network
• educate local communities and encouraging safe LRA surrenders,
• funding search and rescue teams,
• providing rehabilitation and family reunification
• promoting the arrest of Joseph Kony and other top LRA commanders
! What makes these webisodes markedly different from previous examples of aid appeals is
the strong dialectic and visual focus on the spectators potential impact on the objectives rather
than focusing on the victim and the problem. The issue of violence is portrayed in a community
sense with little to none singularizing the experience of the crisis and the necessity for
infrastructure reform. To engage viewers, Invisible Children is garnering grassroots support for
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
10
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 11/40
an event being held on April, 25th 2011 whereby supporters of the plan pledge $25 and go silent
for 25 hours in solidarity with those victims of the LRA whose voices have been silenced. The
funding necessary for the protection plan is outlined in detail in the packet and to actively
participate in the plan, Invisible Children asks for a donation of $25 (which can be made online)
that will provide the patron with a tee-shirt , protection plan outline, two pieces of paper for
writing your respective congressmen letters to address the issues going on with the LRA and a
necklace with small cards to be passed out to people, explaining the reason for silence. The
viewer can create an online profile where they are responsible for using their own social network
to help the project go viral and are asked to raise an independent $25 from friends and family
(also can be donated online). While the webisodes provide information on how to participate in
this, they certainly do not make a focus on it. That raises the question, how do all these factors
fuse to create a nationally successful grassroots campaign?
Research Questions
! My previous research and literature review suggests there been a development of
representation in aid campaigns that began with the ʻotherʼ as a hopeless sufferer lacking
context, to a more positivist approach with capabilities of more self-reflexivity and agency to
assert their own Identity. To further that idea, I look at a web mini-series that introduces and
outlines The Protection Plan. The primary question I will seek to answer through my research is:
In what ways have new aid campaigns, specifically Invisible Children ̓ s Protection Plan, adapted
their visual and textual representation of crisis by using new media?
What implications does Invisible Children ̓ s multi media approach have for the audience?
Research Design and Methodology
!I rely on multimodal analysis as an agent for exploration of these question when looking at
this case study. Kay OʼHolloran describes this method as “the practice of analysis of discourse
and sites which make use of multiple semiotic resources; for example. language, visual images,
space and architecture. (2001, p.4)”. Multimodal analysis looks at many different channels
going on within one piece of communication and the importance of their impact on one another
while interacting. For that reason I will broadly outline two main channels that will be covered in
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
11
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 12/40
my research, discourse and visuality. Other modal considerations will be discussed at hand
when addressed.
Critical Discourse Analysis
" As a method, critical discourse analysis aims to unpack relationships, interactions and
other forms of communications to find underlying motivations and social conditions that can
help explain their meaning. As put by Lillie Chouliaraki,
“CDA is a method of analysis of the television text that treats the linguistic and visual choices on the
screen as subtle indicators of the power of television to mediate the world to the world. This is the power
of television to classify the world into categories of ʻusʼ ʻthe otherʼ and orientate (or not) the spectator
towards the suffering other” (2006, p.84).
For this discussion, discourse itself can be broadly distinguished into two categories defined by
the intent of the language used by the speaker, or in other terms, intent of language to be
interpreted. Norman Fairclough makes a delineation between the readability of certain texts by
categorizing them into ʻconventionalʼ and ʻcreativeʼ texts, the former which strengthens existing
social identities and ideologies and the latter which strives to transform them (1995, p. 55).
Umberto Eco, whom theorizes one can gauge a text on the ability and ease of interpretation,
further explains this notion by providing a paradigm of open and closed texts. A ʻclosedʼ text
encourages little change in the socially constituted thought and an ʻopenʼ text warrants a wide
interpretation on the original idea (Eco, 1981; Chandler, 2001).
" With this critical eye, one engages with analysis tactics and is able to pull significant
themes and practices that hold a piece of discourse together. Underlying power relations, latent
motivations or submissive social constructs become apparent and can thus aid in identifying
and describing subtle cultural shifts that would not, or could not, be seen under ʻnormal
conditionsʼ. Using a critical framework that employs CDA, one can trace social themes and ties
that relate language to ʻother facets of the socialʼ, whether it be political, social, confrontational
or commercial (1995, p.54). As CDA provides qualitative data, critical frameworks differ from
scholar to scholar.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
12
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 13/40
" Lillie Chouliaraki breaks CDA into two equal parts, orientation and representations
(representations will be discussed in relation to images and visual composition; orientation will
be addressed at hand). Chouliaraki places orientation in a dual-dimensional construct of
agency. This dialectical relationship among agency constructs interact with one another by
having one focus on the individual actor and the way he or she is portrayed in an act of
suffering and secondly focusing on the supporting actors (non sufferers) and how they interact
with the victims (2006, p. 85). To compliment and create a fuller methodological framework for
research we turn to the secondary technique, visual interpretation.
Visual Analysis
" Visual representation through imagery constitutes the other half of the paradigm of what
Chouliaraki describes as ʻorientationʼ and ʻrepresentationʼ. This sections involves the physical
scene of suffering and uses analysis of the space-time temporality to involve the viewer in the
ʻcommunication eventʼ being mediated (2006, p. 85; Fairclough, 1995, p. 56). This
complimentary technique informs the audiences as to the intensity of the event, distance or
proximity they occupy in relation to the suffering event and most importantly, hones the
ʻurgency/finalityʼ they should feel related to the event (2006, p.85).
" An inherent interaction that takes places between the audience members and the
sufferers is due in whole to the nature of constructing visual representation in general and
suffering specifically. The depictions and visual representation of communication events on
suffering are intended to be seen by a specific viewing audience, and it is by that intent alone
that analysis of the scene set up becomes a visual discourse to be deconstructed. The
construction of space (dangerous/safe, isolation/interaction) and time (past/present, open time/
scripted) provide matter for analysis as does the semiotic choices made (camera position/visual
editing/graphic specification), which, together can be interpreted for clearer answers to the
research endeavor (Chouliaraki, 2006, p. 86)
Methodological Justification
Fairclough would consider this piece a ʻcreative communication eventʼ, meaning it engages
multiple discourse types, or, audio and visual. Although I discuss CDA and visual analysis in
two separate sections I use Lillie Chouliarakiʼs justification, “representations and orientations are
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
13
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 14/40
not separate parts of the television text... (they) coexist in one single news and the analytical
perspective on discourse must therefore look at once into both metafunctions in order to
determine how they are brought together in each.. sequence” (2006, p. 85). CDA provides a
qualitative lens for documentation and deconstruction of these happenings and can help define
a catalyst and implications of this potential change. In terms of the specific methodological
framework used, the orientation/representation binary will be used within my methodological
design to identify the changing agency of the actors on one hand and answer questions of
context and audience on the other.
Methodological Limitations
" There are several limitations to using these methodologies, the most obvious being the
single source of discourse for analysis. Resource restraints and guidelines for this paper dictate
a limited breadth of research on the topic, but in using the most qualitative method of research I
hope the depth of this one piece to be sufficient. That qualitative freedom also works as a
drawback as there is not one definitive frame for use of CDA as a research method and with
endless theoretical lensʼs to analyze through, many interpretations of this piece can exist at one
time (Wodak, Meyer, 2009, p.5). We these considerations in mind, we move to the key findings
from this research.
Results and Interpretation
With support of a strong theoretical background and thorough methodological analysis,
the Protection Plan responds to the original research question, In what ways do new aid
campaigns, specifically Invisible Children ̓ s Protection Plan, create their visual and
textual representation of crisis by using new media? in a direct sense. I structure the
decomposition of these Webisodes to move from pure visual/textual properties through
the stage of sufferer/donor relationship negotiation (modal imagination) and conclude by
looking at network activation as a result of such using such appeal. I use the terms,
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
14
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 15/40
I. Multi-modal tensions and Aesthetics
! As the scene opens for the first webisode, a transistor tone comes across the
speakers as a hand flips switches on an old high-frequency (HF) radio, the movement
not coinciding with the sound. A voice over in French begins and in subtitles reads,
! “I donʼt know if anyone can hear me. The Lordʼs Resistance Army have attacked all the
! surrounding villages. There is nowhere that is safe from the LRA, they are killing,
! mutilating and abducting children and forcing them to become fighters. The people here
! are fleeing. They are desperate. This is Camarade Belinda from Dungu Village reporting
! in on the community radio. Something is going to have to change soon or I am afraid
! there is not going to be many of us left. Please, if you can here this, help” (Protection
"Plan , 00:07 - 1:04).
! Although the man is identified by name, there are no specific actors in the visual
sequence that accompany his monologue. Instead, there is a visual montage that
loosely tells a story of a village under attack, men slowly preparing for conflict with
archaic-looking bows and arrows and a distressed community leader relying on the only
communication technology available to try and receive help. With only this narration laid
over the split image sequences, there is no definition to the concrete spatial or temporal
realities of these events, thus, little orientation as to the proximity and urgency of the
circumstances.
! I find the lack of a spatiotemporal locale can be indicted to a few elements, but
primarily and most important for this discussion I attribute it to the tension between the
dual modalities, voiceover and image (specifically montages), of the webisode. Neither
mode tells an unabridged story individually or together, rather, they have separate
focusʼs that can interact in ways to create a humanitarian voice for Invisible Children. I
hinge this tension together with ʻchronotopicityʼ, a conceptual construct that deals with
an unstable idea of time. It allows events and representations located in complex
spatiotemporal environments the ability to sway between multiple space-times, and
thus, multiple realities (Bakhtin, 1981; Chouliaraki, 2006, 87).
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
15
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 16/40
! In this case, there are two separate modalities that at once create a disjuncture
between and reciprocality of the verbal-visual relationship, and is is carried out as an
overarching theme that continues throughout the short three-part series. In her book,
The Spectatorship of Suffering, Lillie Chouliaraki looks critically at narrative style and
various avenues of realism as useful tools for analyzing such multi-modal
communication. Applying her categories to the Protection Plan , the visual-discursive
correspondence can be seen as visually representing an ideological realist approach,
which appeals to audiences with a claim for justice, a universal moral or idealogical
issue that must be corrected, and then the more subdued textual account focused on
the local actors collective proximity to safety or danger (Chouliaraki, 2006, 80, 127).
Although not always aesthetically vexing, the visual level and the discursive level are
relating two subtle yet very distinct messages. Take for example, Laren Poole, an
Invisible Children founder and main actor on behalf of the organization in these
webisodes, explaining,
! “Visiting these areas out here itʼs very clear to see the LRA is alive and very able !to
! continue to terrorize the population. Though the problem is very serious, the community
! has banded together to come up with some ideas on how to protect themselves and
! welcome home the child soldiers” (Protection Plan, 5:33-5:43).
Poole refers to the community as a collective being, a population, and as such are all ingrave danger of an organizationally active (ʻthe LRA is alive”) and strong (“very able”,
“problem is very serious”) off-the-grid terrorist network. The dialect descriptors incite an
immediate sense of risk and fear, placing the communities much closer in relation to
danger than to safety. Consider that sentiment in relation to the the accompanying
visual.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
16
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 17/40
!
(Fig. 1)
! In imagining a community or village in a conflict against a terrorist organization
where the community stands as a collective whole against a ring of coordinated
criminals, one could assume that the most valuable and vulnerable asset to that
collective body would be their young, the children. This image, and the ones that quickly
follow, illustrate the most vulnerable and delicate actors in the conflict and frame them
from what appears to be an unknowing, susceptible angle. From this stealthy position,
the children seems to be alone, thus, in danger. As Chouliaraki discusses ideological
realism, she explains that the concept encourages a stark stance on the most macro of
issues (i.e. whether or not you are against humanity) and urges viewers to take
unapologetic public ground (2006, 80). In this visual scenario, a decision is being asked
to be made by the spectators to either protect the communities children, or not
(protection in this sense is understand with a liberal view and will be discussed further in
the next section). These modalities reciprocate with one another by embracing their
place in a chronotopicit conception, moving from one time-space to the next as they
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
17
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 18/40
interact to create a more robust contextual background and deeper symbolic meaning of
suffering, crisis and terror. In decoupling the frequencies for closer examination of
appeal though, they can be understood as periodically being ambivalent to one another.
It is at the juncture of this ambivalence that the inability to securely situate the actors
and cause in a defined time and space has occurred.
! Another level of analysis that deserves attention here is the role of actor agency.
Thus far, the local actors have been community oriented, not based in singularity in any
way. In the second webisode, ʻChild Soldier Rehabilitationʼ there is a linear visual
narrative telling a story of a boy escaping the LRA, being welcomed home, feeling
isolated and entering rehabilitation provided by Invisible Children and being reunited
with his family for recovery (Fig. 2 - 5).
(Fig. 2, 00:24)
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
18
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 19/40
(Fig. 3, 00:58)
(Fig. 4, 2:16)
(Fig. 5, 3:24)
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
19
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 20/40
! The boys orientation here is singular. He is acting alone and most times he is the
only actor that is focused on in any one scene, anyone else appearing next to him
clearly being secondary. His motion is slow, is gaze is distant and although it is
performative, is not cognitive of the camera. This has the capacity for low reflexivity and
self-awareness which can be characteristic of negativism in appeals, the webisode is
still presented in a positivist fashion. His agency is shown in direct relation to the
rehabilitation center which frames his representation as being a ʻconditional agentʼ.
Conditional agency are only allowed to act in a limited way and ineffective way, visually
implying the need for external infrastructure to help gain empowerment (Chouliaraki,
2006, p. 119). This focus on infrastructure and agency is low-intensity in terms of
emotions and invites the non-addressed spectator to consider the real utility of having a
facility like this.
! All of these factors create a construct of positivist appeal through subtle visuality
which stands in contrast to the first reading of the first webisode where language and
imagery negotiated a hyper-mediated urgency (negativism). This illustrates an earlier
concept of narrative tension within an aid campaign, coherence and ambivalence. On
an organizational level, the message is coherent - there needs to be infrastructure to aid
in the recovery and prevention of LRA attacks. Yet on a level that deals with
representation, these two orientations of the problem and the actors are ambivalent one
one another. There is urgency, risk and need for immediacy in the first example and in
the next, there are cues to an expanded distance from danger, requiring less
immediacy. In this dichotomy of coherent message and ambivalent portrayal, one can
place Invisible Children in the post-humanitarianist approach to adapting visual and
textual roles of crisis for web content.
! As the boy approaches his parents is in figure 5, text on the screen reads:
“HELP BUILD THE FIRST LRA REHABILITATION CENTER CONGO.
INVISIBLECHILDREN.COM”.
This brings us to the next important element in reading their appeal, the engagement of
the spectators.
!
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
20
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 21/40
II. Audience Activation
" There are indicators that demarcate the idea there is a reason why a spectator
should act on behalf of the crisis with the LRA, yet they are not overt. There are painful
images in a montage in the first video and a website with an invitation to get involved at
the end of each webisode but void is the grand plea for action on the audiences part.
When you follow the link to website youʼll find plenty more media and countless
avenues for donation; click to donate, twitter apps and a personalized page for you to
track your progress in public. This can all be done in the comfort of your own home
without getting up between watching the videos and is exemplary of what Lillie
Chouliaraki would the simplicity of the technologicalization of action (2010, p.14). With
this and the de-emotionalization of the campaign I discussed in the previous section, it
creates a space and time for the viewer to consider, judge for themselves and become
reflexive of whether or not to help. Considered in that regard there seems to be little
interference on part of the organization to spur action, but evaluating the level of
reflexivity with the level of urgency and ambivalence also discussed in the previous
section, there has to be a motivation that makes this appeal so actionable.
! Before I do so, I would like to define the constituency of actors on behalf of
Invisible Children or, the spectators. The webisode platform and interactive nature of
their organization (their public essentially convenes online or communicates online on
how to physically convene) lend itself well to Lance Bennettʼs ʻSPIN Networksʼ. That is,
a network of people who segmented , polycentric and integrated which results in a
network (2003, p. 10). Although there is not a strong emotional appeal, this network
works by relying on the reflexivity and personal judgement of all the individual viewers
and their ability to recognize their likeness among one another based on the fact
someone else came to the same logical conclusion they did about these issues.
Because they are segmented and polycentric, they integrate themselves into the online
platform to reach over geographical boundaries if necessary. The question then
becomes how to harness the solitude of a network as fluid and polycentric.
! Pamphleteering relies on the objectivity of the spectator and a ubiquitous
(multimodal) voice narrating the appeal with which the spectator has no moral
reservations with. On that contingent, the viewer will then adopt the view of the
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
21
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 22/40
omnipresent voice and is moved into a “moral position (spectator, see for yourself what
there is to see” (Chouliaraki, 2006, 140). From there the option, not demand, to act is
presented visually in an aesthetically pleasing way.
(Fig 6, 6:17)
The voiceover suggests no pity or grand emotion:
“Theyʼve already done a lot with the little resources they have and through out travels we have
documented the projects that show the best potential to save lives with little investment. We ʼve
compiled all of these projects in a document called ʻThe Protection Planʼ. The best way you can
help the Protection Plan become a reality is sign up for 25” (The Protection Plan, 6:17).
! The voiceover suggests a heavy weight of post-humanitarian appeal. It is
precisely the loosening up of the necessary link Chouliaraki describes when decoupling
the emotion for the sufferer from acting on the cause of suffering (2010, p. 17). The
technologicalization of action then comes into play as it gives the option of the best way
to help, which is by signing up on the website. It secures voluntary commitments from
viewers to sign up for demonstrations, share the link, create a profile or acquire them on
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
22
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 23/40
their database for future communication. All of these, though mundane and simple,
(exactly the kind of technologicalized action that makes up the post humanitarianism
approach) are forms of protesting and shift the spectators into a SPIN network that has
become activated.
Conclusion "
" In summary, The Protection Plan, a web based mini series created by Invisible
Children has been found to have visual and textual implications that stem from, 1) the
increased connectivity of media conglomerates, governments and the humanitarian
sector (media logic), 2) the open, informal nature of being a web based campaign that
essentially came into being due to the prevalence of media and news online and 3)
audiences new use and practices of new media in their everyday life (also in part to
media logic).
! These implications come in the form of modality, aesthetics and agency. A low-
intensity emotional regime is is used in forms of visuality, such as not singularizing or
orienting the crisis on any one face and this works as a de-emotionalizing agent for the
viewer to engage in reflexivity contemplate whether or not they should act. Yet looking
at the combined mode of the textual, there are still underpinnings of an immediacy
appeal, creating a tension between the coherence of the overall message (“please getinvolved”) and the vacillating ambivalence between modalities (textual is assuring actors
in crisis are stable and competent while visual suggests the urgent need to act, or vice
versa) (Dogra, 2007). I argue that this is possible by the orientation of chonotopicit time,
in which there is no defined spatiotemporal place these events are happening and that
allows for movement of the modalities to move from space to space or from one reality
to another (Chouliaraki, 2006).
! When considering the role of the audience in this paradigm, they are segmented,
polycentric, integrated users (because they are connecting over the web based
platform) and create a network based on their mutual, voluntary interest in Invisible
Children and the fight against the LRA. Their movement as one is brought into being by
new forms of protest, signing a petition online, sharing the link to the video or
connecting with local users to participate in the demonstrations. This
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
23
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 24/40
technologicalization of action simplifies the aid message as making it effortless to feel
you have made a difference in such a huge crisis.
! With all of these factors and processes combined, I conclude that in part due to the
use new media and increase in intensity of media logic, the appeal of aid has changed
and is entering into a new era of post-humanitarianism (Chouliarki, 2010). The role of
the audience is transformed through this process thus creating a new spectator/sufferer
relationship. Although this is one, limited case-study, I think is indicative of a new trend
for humanitarian agencies. I believe more research should be conducted on the topic to
find and further the analysis of this shift to better understand its implications on a
broader basis.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
24
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 25/40
Bibliography
Aguayo, A. J. Prospectus For Documentary Film and Social Change: A Rhetorical Investigationof Dissent. Intellectual Entrepreneurship. Austin, University of Texas.
Andrejevic, M. (2002). "'The work of being watched: interactive media and the exploitation ofself- disclosure'." Critical Studies in Media and Communication 19(2): 230-248.
Barnett, C. (2004). Convening Publics: The Parasitical Space of Public Action. The SAGEHandbook of Political Geography. K. Cox, Low, M. and Robinson, J. London, Sage Publications:p. 403-417.
Barthes, R. (1972). The Great Family of Man. Mythologies New York, Hill and Wang: p100-116.
Bennett, L. (2003). “New Media Power: The Internet and Global Activism”. Contesting MediaPower: Alternative Media in a Networked World. Rowman & Littlefield Publications.
Boltanski, L. (1999). Distant Suffering. Politics, Morality and the Media. Cambridge, CambridgeUniversity Press.
Brecht, B. (1938). Popularity and Realism
Browning Cole, E. C. M., Susan. (1992). Toward a Feminist Conception of Moral Life.Bloomington, IN, Indiana University Press.
Chandler, D. (1994, 2001). "Encoding/Decoding." Semiotics for Beginners. Retrieved 3 August2010, from http://www.aber.ac.uk/media/Documents/S4B/ .
Chomsky, N. (1986). Knowledge of Language: its Nature, Origin and Use. New York, Praeger.
Chouliaraki, L. (2006). The Spectatorship of Suffering. London, Sage Publications.
Choularaki, L. (2010). Post-Humanitarianism: Beyond the politics of pity. London, Journal ofCultural Studies.
Cohen, S. (2001). Images of Suffering. States of Denial: Knowing about atrocities and sufferingP. Press, Blackwell Publishers, USA: 168-195.
Coldevin, G., & Dyck, E. (1992). "Using Positive vs. Negative Photographs For Third-WorldFund Raising." Journalism Quarterly Vol. 69(3): 8p.
Cottle, S., & Nolan, D. (2007). "Global Humanitarianism and the Changing Aid-Media Filed "Journalism Studies Vol. 8(No. 6): 863-876.
Cousins, J. M., Davis, R. L. (1974). 'Working Class Incorporation'. Social Analysis of ClassStructure F. Parkin. London, Tavistock Publications Limited.
Cross, A. R. (2006). Happy 125th Birthday American Red Cross! 1881-2006. A. R. Cross.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
25
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 26/40
Dogra, N. (2007). ʻReading NGOʼs Visually - Implications of Visual Images for NGOManagement. London, Journal for International Development.
Eco, U. (1981). The Role of the Reader. London, Hutchinson.
Ellis, J. (2005). Seeing Things: Television in the Age of Uncertainty. London, Tauris.
Fairclough, N. (1995). Critical Analysis of Media Discourse. Media Discourse, Arnold Publishers:p. 53- 74.
Goodwin, C. (2001). Practices of Seeing Visual Analysis: an Ethnomethodological Approach.Handbook of Visual Analysis C. Jewitt, van Leeuwen, T. London, Sage Publication: P. 157.
Habermas, J. (1984). LIfeworld and System: A Critique of Functionalist Reason. Boston, BeaconPress.
Hall, S. (1981). Racist Ideologies in the Media. Silver Linings: Some Strategies for the 80's. G.Bridges, Brunt, R. London, Lawrence and Wishart: p 28-52.
Hall, S., Ed. ([1973], 1980). Encoding/Decoding. Culture, Media, Language: Working Papers inCultural Studies 1972-79. London, Hutchinson.
Home Box Office, I. (2010). The Lazarus Effect. Before and After photos. H. Documentaries.
Kalichman S C; Simbayi, L. C. (2003). "HIV testing attitudes, AIDS stigma, and voluntary HIVcounselling and testing in a black township in Cape Town, South Africa." Sex Transm Intefect79: 442-447.
Khalifa, M. (2010). The 'cause-marketing' conundrum. The Gateway newspaper. London,Career Gateways Limited. 27: p. 11.
MacDonald, M. (2003). Chapter 1: Representation and Discourse. Exploring Media andDiscourse, Arnold Publishers p. 9-26.
Minear, L., Scott, C., & Weiss, T. G. (1994). The News Media, Civil War and HumanitarianAction. Boulder, Lynn Reinner Publishers, Inc.
Moeller, S. (1999). Compassion Fatigue: how the media sell disease, famine, war and death.New York, Routledge.
Mylonas, Y. (2007). "Crisis, Conspiracy and Rights; Imaginaries of Terrorism in DocumentaryFilm." Critical Approaches to Discourse Analysis across Disciplines 1(2): 96-116.Natsios, A. (1996). Illusions of Influence: The CNN Effect in Complex Emergencies. FromMassacres to Genocide: The Media, Public Policy and Humanitarian Crisis. R. I. Rotberg, &Weiss, T. G. Cambridge, World Peace Foundation.
Pickering, M. (2001). Chapter 3: The Concept of the Other. Stereotyping: The Politics ofRepresentation. Houndsmills, Palgrave Macmillan: 264p.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
26
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 27/40
Porter, E. (2003) Can Politics Practice Compassion? Project(RED) (2006). "Join Red Web Site."Retrieved July 1, 2010, from joinred.com.
Rosaldo, R. (1993). Narrative Analysis. Culture & Truth: the remaking of social analysis Boston,Beacon Press: 127-146.
Rosenthal A; Corner, J., Ed. (1988). New Challenges for Documentary. Manchester ManchesterUniversity Press.
Shoumatoff, A. (2007). "The Lazarus Effect." Vanity Fair. Retrieved July 2010, from http:// www.vanityfair.com/politics/features/2007/07/lazarus200707?currentPage=all.
Snow, R. P., & Altheide, D. L. (1979). Media Logic. Beverly Hills, California, Sage Publications.
Tester, K. (2001). Lifting the Lid on Compassion. Compassion, Morality, and the Media. Oxford,Open University Press: 74-103.
Van Dijk, T. A. "18 Critical Discourse Analysis." from http://www.discourses.org/OldArticles/ Critical%20discourse%20analysis.pdf.
Werry, C. (2007). "Reflections on Language: Chomsky, linguistic discourse and the value ofrhetorical self-consciousness." Language Sciences 29: 66-87.
Wodak, R., Meyer, Michael, Ed. (2009). Methods of Critical DIscourse Analysis. London, SagePublications.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
27
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 28/40
Appendix 1
“Protection Plan” Webisode 1 TranscriptFilm from Invisible ChildrenRun Time: 6:58
Transcribed: Jacqueline Smith! ! 17 March 2011
A close up of a very old radio. Makes transistor sounds as a hand flips knobs along the top and picks up a phone. Close up of a mans eyes, looking downward
Camarade Belinda:! (Being spoken in native language in background, captions! ! ! ! onscreen)
! ! ! ! I donʼt know if anyone can hear me.Spears laying in the dirt.! ! ! !
The Lordʼs Resistance Army have attacked all the
! ! ! ! surrounding villages. There is nowhere that is safe from the! ! ! ! LRA.
A hand picks the spears up out of the dirt, ties them together. Cut to a man closing a flimsy door.! ! ! ! There is nowhere that is safe from the LRA, they are killing
Camera cuts to a child ̓ s bloody, disfigured face.
! ! ! ! mutilating
Cuts to a quick shot of a man holding a child ̓ s lip to a knife. Cuts to another shot of a child their nose cut off.! ! ! ! and abducting children and forcing them to become fighters.
Child walks on dirt road with a bloody machete in hand, twirling it by his side.
! ! ! ! The people here are fleeing. They are desperate.
Group of people walking down dirt road together. Camera pans past woman and children standing alone in empty village. Pans across people gathered in a circle crying,
screaming.! ! ! ! The ones that are staying are forming a resistance.
Group of men walking into bush territory with arrows on their back. Facing forward with cross bows in hand.
! ! ! ! This is Camarade Belinda, from the Dungu village reporting! ! ! ! in on the community radio.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
28
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 29/40
Hand holding phone. Camera follow the cord up to his mouth. Camera cuts to the men with the arrows walking through bush, cross bow and arrows in hand.
! ! ! ! Something is going to have to change soon or I am afraid
! ! ! ! there is not going to be many of us left.
Men pulling cross bow string back.
! ! ! ! Please if you can hear this, help.
Arrows being picked up off the ground. Men walking through bush cutting their way through by machete.
In text: ! ! SINCE 2008 THE LRA HAS VIOLENTLY EXPANDED INTO! ! ! THREE COUNTRIES
Info graphic:! ! African continent. Zoom to Central African Republic, Sudan and! ! ! D.R. Congo
In text:! ! LITTLE INFORMATION ABOUT THEIR ATROCITIES EVER! ! ! MAKES IT TO WESTERN MEDIA! ! ! INVISIBLE CHILDREN PRESENTS! ! ! THE NEW CHAPTER: THE PROTECTION PLAN
[MUSIC] Ultility cargo vehicle drive down a muddy, unpaved road. Mud splashes everywhere. View from someone facing the back of the vehicle, can see down his rifle.
Camera pans and watches people watch the vehicle as it moves down the road.
A man stands out of a vehicle with a large gun. Kid riding a bike past village
In text: ! ! IN 2010 MEMBERS OF THE INVISIBLE CHILDREN TEAM! ! ! TRAVELED TO LRA AFFECTED AREAS OF D.R.CONGO! ! ! TO VISIT REMOTE VILLAGES TO SEE HOW WE COULD HELP
Two children, boy and girl sit next to each other in village.
In text:! ! Limai, D.R. Congo
Civilians walk and ride a bike down dirt road. Cut to view of village, smoke coming out of home make out of straw. Cut to shot of Laren Poole, a founder of Invisible Children, with hand rubbing his temple.
Laren Poole:! ! Um, we just got to Limai, and um, a Congolese guy was out! ! ! ! in the bush fishing and hunting and he was shot in leg by the! ! ! ! Congolese government cause they thought he was the LRA.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
29
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 30/40
Man laying on ground with large open wound in his thigh, woman tending to him.
! ! ! ! Heʼs been for like, 24 hours already and he has a huge! ! ! ! gunshot wound. This place is so remote, thereʼs no cell
! ! ! ! service.
Close up of mans bloody leg. Cut to Laren hiking through bush with guide and man with gun.
! ! ! ! This village had no way to communicate with Dungu that this! ! ! ! man needs medical attention (map of distance between! ! ! ! Limai and Dungu).
Laren speaks to camera in front of large group people to one another in native language.
! ! ! ! Heʼs telling us that the LRA is like 10, 5 kilometers away! ! ! ! from here. There are groups that operate, like, around this! ! ! ! area because weʼre close to Garamaba Forest which is a! ! ! ! national forest that the LRA operate out of. This area is still! ! ! ! very much at risk. (map illustrating Garamba national forest,! ! ! ! LRA ground, Limai and Dungu)
Shot of Girl standing on her own. Shot of man against an orange sky with large rifle. Cut to scene in hospital where a man is shielding his face with rag. Man lays on his side on hospital bed. Cut back to man laying outside with large gunshot wound to the thigh.
! ! ! ! Seeing that man laying there on the ground shot, I realize! ! ! ! how much we take for granted the ability to pick up the! ! ! ! phone and call for help when we need it. These villages are! ! ! ! literally cut off from the outside world. Itʼs making it! ! ! ! impossible for us to know when the LRA attacks or even! ! ! ! when kids escape and manage to return to the villages.
Shot of dirt road leading up to a church. Laren stands with a man outside.
Laren Poole: ! ! What do these people think of the LRA, I mean, what did
! ! ! ! they think when they came and started abducting children?
Camera pans to man, Abbe Benoit, from the Peach and Justice Commission.
Abe Benoit:! ! ! (In French and subtitles) The problem is there are hundreds! ! ! ! of children who have been abducted by the LRA. LIke this! ! ! ! girl came from southern Sudan.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
30
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 31/40
Camera sees young girl standing behind Abbe, looking skeptically at the lens.
! ! ! ! She needs psychological help and help reintegrating with the! ! ! ! community.
Girl looks down at ground.
Laren Poole: ! ! How long was she in the LRA?
Girl continues looking down. Woman, Mami, also an LRA abductee that defected and a forced wife asks girl Laren ̓ s question in French.
Girl:! ! ! ! Two years. ! !Mami:!! ! ! (Asks how old she is in French)
Girl: ! ! ! ! I am 16 years old (subtitled)
Mami:!! ! ! (to Laren) She is 16. She was a wife to commander called! ! ! ! Wai Wai.
Close up of girls face. Cuts to Abbe Benoit.
Abbe Benoit:! ! These are human beings who are being destroyed by! ! ! ! Joseph Kony
Camera moves to woman, Jolly Okot from Invisible Children.
Jolly Okot:! ! ! Iʼm asking if she knows how to use a gun. She said! ! ! ! yeah, she has been trained.
Abbe Benoit:! ! Now they are escaping from the LRA, we need to take care! ! ! ! of them, to help build their new life.
Camera shows Laren, Jolly, Abbe and girl standing together in circle.
Jolly Okot:! ! ! I am telling her to be very grateful to God because she came! ! ! ! back without a child. I also got abducted and came back
! ! ! ! without a child.
Laren Poole:! ! Sheʼs so young.
Close up of girl, tilts head down, almost smiles.Cut to Laren and Jolly getting into a vehicle. They sit inside.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
31
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 32/40
Jolly Okot:! ! ! Sheʼs really young and all she wants to do is go back to! ! ! ! school. (Gets emotional) Iʼve seen more difficult things but! ! ! ! looking at this girl... it has been really... I donʼt know how to! ! ! ! describe it. Itʼs hard. Itʼs hard. Itʼs really really hard. (Begins " " " " to cry, wipes her tears.)
" " " " Why would you be like somebodyʼs wife at the age of 14,! ! ! ! you know? That is high level of trauma. There is nothing! ! ! ! else, that is why I couldnʼt handle it. I couldnʼt. It is very hard.! ! ! ! And that is one out of many, so..
[Music] Cut to girls gathered, laughing. Next frame, small girl staring into camera.Children gathered. Close up Jolly speaking to camera.
Jolly Okot:! ! ! I think itʼs the role of Invisible Children to help educate the! ! ! ! world again about what it happening in Congo. So I feel it is
! ! ! ! our responsibility since we did it for northern Uganda. I feel a! ! ! ! rehabilitation center in the Congo would help so much to! ! ! ! bring back these children into a normal lifestyle.
Boys standing in village, looking stoic.
! ! ! ! There has to be a message of peace. There has to be a! ! ! ! message of hope to the people of Congo.
Camera cuts to girl from earlier smiling. Camera pans to scene of village center with children playing.
Laren Poole:! ! Visiting these areas out here itʼs very clear to see the LRA is! ! ! ! alive and very able to continue to terrorize the population.! ! ! ! Though the problem is very serious, the community has! ! ! ! banded together to come up with some ideas on how to! ! ! ! protect themselves and welcome home the child soldiers.
Images of community together, offering project plans for endeavors. Family of 5 stands together outside of home. Mother stands with two children in large group, looks sorrowful.
Camera back to Laren as he speaks. Images of community erecting signal tower and laying down infrastructure for radio networks.
! ! ! ! From setting up HF radios in remote villages to create early! ! ! ! warning radio networks to having aspirations to have a! ! ! ! locally run rehabilitation center for ex-combats.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
32
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 33/40
Images of community rolling out blue print plan for grassroots organized rehabilitation center. Men share in the displaying - team explaining the details.
! ! ! ! Theyʼve already done a lot with the little resources they have! ! ! ! and through out travels we have documented the projects! ! ! ! that show the best potential to save lives with little! ! ! ! investment. Weʼve compiled all of these projects in a! ! ! ! document called ʻThe Protection Planʼ. The best way you! ! ! ! can help the Protection Plan become a reality is sign up for! ! ! ! ʼ25ʼ. 25 is a worldwide event happening April 25th.
Images of the plan and logo mixed with fast moving shots of Invisible Children helping out locally and on the ground. Cut to image of Invisible Children 25 demonstration with a group of young people gathered with their fingers to their mouths.
! ! ! ! Weʼre asking thousands of participants to unite in solidarity! ! ! ! for the victims who are being silenced by the LRA by going! ! ! ! silent for 25 hours.
Image of community members; working together, carrying something down a dirt road.
! ! ! ! Weʼre hoping that silence will be heard worldwide and brings! ! ! ! attention to this emergency. When you make this! ! ! ! commitment we ask that you pledge to raise at least 25! ! ! ! dollars to help fund the Protection Plan. Itʼs simple. One
! ! ! ! dollar for every hour your going silent to help fund these! ! ! ! life-saving projects. Stand in solidarity with the victims of the! ! ! ! most neglected humanitarian crisis of the 21st century.
In text:! ! SIGN UP AT INVISIBLECHILDREN.COM
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
33
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 34/40
Appendix 2
Child Soldier Rehabilitation - Webisode 2 TranscriptFilm from Invisible ChildrenRuntime: 3:44
Transcribed: Jacqueline Smith! ! 17 March 2011
Scene opens with a boy holding machine gun over his shoulder looking down into camera.[MUSIC] He walks through a field has the sun goes down, with machine gun over his shoulder.He walks along dirt road, in the distance you can see a small village.He puts his hands up as he approaches the village; stops at a man with a bow and arrow pointed at him.
In text:! ! DURING THE PEAK OF ABDUCTIONS BY THE LORDS! ! ! RESISTANCE ARMY IN NORTHERN UGANDA
! ! ! THERE WERE THREE FULL-TIME REHABILITATION CENTERS! ! ! RECEIVING RETURNING CHILD SOLDIERS
! ! ! IN THE LRA AFFECTED AREAS OF CENTRAL AFRICAN! ! ! REPUBLIC AND D.R. CONGO THERE ARE NONE
Boy sits as desk as man in background makes phone call; sound of a transistor in
background.
Laren Poole:! ! Currently in Congo there is these locally run Congolese! ! ! ! teams that travel to really remote villages to find kids who! ! ! ! have escaped from the LRA; they are crucial in the! ! ! ! rehabilitation and return process of formerly abducted child! ! ! ! soldiers.!
As Laren speaks, boy sitting at desk looking down at the ground as two men talk on the phone and communicate. Scene shifts to a van, boy gets in and as the van drives away he is visible through the back window looking out.
! ! ! ! The funding for these teams only allow them to put! ! ! ! returnees into host homes, or strangers homes while they! ! ! ! they kids family.
Boy walks up to a straw house with two strangers standing outside; scene shift to a hand tracing over a map.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
34
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 35/40
" " " " There is no formal rehabilitation in this region to ex-LRA! ! ! ! combatants
Boy walks out of bush, surrender his gun to villagers.
In text:! ! THERE IS ONE CONGOLESE MAN WHO WANTS TO CHANGE! ! ! THAT
Man speaks to camera
Abbe Benoit:! ! (from the Peace and Justice Commission)" " " " The problem is there are hundreds of children who have! ! ! ! been abducted by the LRA. Now they are escaping from the! ! ! ! LRA, we need to take care of them, to help them build their! ! ! ! new life.
Scene break
Matthew Brubacher:! (UN Demobilization)" " " " Itʼs really important to have a rehabilitation center thatʼs run! ! ! ! by the local community where people can come in and have! ! ! ! a certain time to adapt.
Boy from all the previous scenes is seen walking with a man up stairs into a building Scene break
Els De Temmerman:! (LRA Rehabilitation Specialist)
" " " " All the children who have come back from the LRA are! ! ! ! extremely traumatized. They have suffered the worst abuses! ! ! ! and have been forced to commit the worst abuses. Most of! ! ! ! them were forced to kill, some were even forced to kill their! ! ! ! own relatives.
Profile of child ̓ s face; man handing clean clothes to a child.
! ! ! ! Then they were abused themselves. They need to go! ! ! ! through trauma counseling as they did in northern Uganda,! ! ! ! and the most important part of that is they need to express
! ! ! ! themselves, they need to bring out the trauma.
Boy in casual clothes, drawing and talking with older man outside.[MUSIC] Boy drawing with colored pencils by himself As he draws, flash backs (real footage) of being in the bush with the LRA fighting cut in; picture he draws has man with machete to his neck, blood around him.Flashback shows chaos and burning.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
35
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 36/40
Camera pans slowly across his face.
Laren Poole:! ! The local community has plans for the regions first! ! ! ! rehabilitation center. The curriculum that Els and the! ! ! ! community has developed up here is really important and it
! ! ! ! relies a lot on art therapy.
Boy drawing; close up of his face as he flashes back to holding a gun in the bush.
! ! ! ! Kids are able to draw the experiences they were forced to! ! ! ! live through in the bush. One of the most symbolic things! ! ! ! she has the kids do is literally burn the clothes they come out! ! ! ! of the bush wearing.
Boy standing in circle with other kids holding camouflage apparel. Throws it into fire and watches it burn.
Scene refocus on Laren
! ! ! ! Itʼs a symbol of entering normal society once again and no! ! ! ! longer be a fighter but a productive member of society and a! ! ! ! kid once again.
[MUSIC] Kids kick soccer ball in grassy lawn Same boy that has been seen all along plays with friends when doors to center open and his parents walk through. He gives his father a hug and closes his eyes as his father holds him.
In text:! ! HELP BUILD THE FIRST LRA REHABILITATION CENTER IN! ! ! CONGO
! ! ! INVISIBLECHILDREN.COM
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
36
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 37/40
Appendix 3
Early Warning Radio Network - Webisode 3 TranscriptFilm from Invisible ChildrenRuntime: 4:10
Transcribed:!Jacqueline Smith! ! 18 March 2011
Soldiers walking across dirt into a village; boot with a rip in it; a man running his hands over bushes - voice over:
Ida Sawyer! ! ! ! (Human Rights Watch)! ! ! !
! ! ! ! ! Between December 14th and 17th 2009, the Lordʼs! ! ! ! ! Resistance Army, a Ugandan rebel group carried out! ! ! ! ! a horrific attack in the Mokombo area of Otoweli! ! ! ! ! district. A group of about 20 combatants, and they! ! ! ! !
were pretending at this time to be Congolese army! ! ! ! ! soldiers.
Woman barefoot in dress, camera only focuses on her feet. Pans to mans feet in big black boots and gun pointed into dirt.
! ! ! ! ! They passed a woman and they asked her “Excuse! ! ! ! ! me maʼam, is there a school nearby where kids might! ! ! ! ! be studying?” and she said “No school is not in! ! ! ! ! session” and he said “Well what about a church, is! ! ! ! ! there a place where people might be gathered around
! ! ! ! ! praying?” and she said “No, itʼs not Sunday” and he! ! ! ! ! said, “What about a market?” and she said “Oh yeah,! ! ! ! ! thereʼs a fishermanʼs market just up the road there,! ! ! ! ! Mabanga Ya Talo.
Map shows area and highlights the LRA route in red from December 13th to 14th.
" " " " " So the LRA combatants moved up the road to this! ! ! ! ! fishermenʼs market and the LRA surrounded them,! ! ! ! ! tied people up, looted goods and then pushed people! ! ! ! ! out into the forest along the path.
Men in camouflage walk into market with guns; women drop food items; a basket of corn is thrown into the air; feet run along the ground."
" " " " " All along the way they started killing people that they! ! ! ! ! had abducted and those people were chopped to! ! ! ! ! death with heavy wooden sticks and others were tied! ! ! ! ! to trees before their heads were chopped with axes.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
37
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 38/40
Image of a bloody hand fallen to the side. Map shows furthering route of the LRA as they journeyed on with crosses denoting all the murders that took place along the way.
" " " " " Just before they got to the village of Tapili, the chief
! ! ! ! ! there got a message that maybe something was! ! ! ! ! happening but it wasnʼt at all clear. Weird noises,! ! ! ! ! something might be going on.
Men on motorcycles talking in confusion. Men riding through village into bush.
" " " " " So he the chief went with another Congolese army! ! ! ! ! soldier by motorcycle just up the road and there they! ! ! ! ! ambushed by the LRA. The LRA killed both of them! ! ! ! ! and gouged their eyes out and burned their! ! ! ! ! motorcycle.
Image of bloody hand; kids running down dirt road; trail of blood in dirt
" " " " " Then they entered the town of Tapili, abducted other! ! ! ! ! and killed many more. They continued their journey,! ! ! ! ! the LRA went from village to village along this 105! ! ! ! ! kilometer route abducting more civilians and killing! ! ! ! ! them along the way.
Info-graphic map illustrates the route the LRA took over the course of 4 days, killing civilians.
In text:! ! IDA SAWYER IS A RESEARCHER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH! ! !
! ! ! SHE WAS THE FIRST TO DOCUMENT THE CHRISTMAS! ! ! MASSACRES!
! ! ! THE LRA KILLED MORE THAN 345 CIVILIANS AND ABDUCTED! ! ! 250 OTHERS INCLUDING OVER 80 CHILDREN
Ida Sawyer:! ! ! ! This is one of the 5 worst attacks ever committed by! ! ! ! ! the LRA in the groups brutal history. From researching
! ! ! ! ! previous LRA attacks it became clear to us that better! ! ! ! ! communication and an early warning mechanism are! ! ! ! ! crucial both to more effectively protect civilians in at! ! ! ! ! risk areas for LRA attacks and to be able to respond! ! ! ! ! and go after the LRA group when there is an attack to! ! ! ! ! try and apprehend the groups leader.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
38
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 39/40
Clips of archaic looking radio, hand flipping switches; children playing in dirt in center of village Close images of men standing; one by himself in the village; a man in the bush as the sun set; Camera looks down the gun of a man sitting in the back of a cargo truck.
Scene break [MUSIC]
Men carrying large electronic piece into house; image of them lying on the ground figuring it out. Camera cut to Laren;
Laren Poole:! ! ! Our first day in Congo weʼre uh, weʼre procuring HF! ! ! ! ! radios in order to take from Goma up to Dungu Congo! ! ! ! ! where the LRA has been affecting civilian population.! ! ! ! ! We were able to take 12 HF radios up there to expand
! ! ! ! ! the Congo Early Warning Radio Network
Walkie-talkies tuning into an Invisible Children frequency; people communicating and gathering around the network.Images of community putting equipment together
! ! ! ! ! So weʼre going to set up this HF radio, itʼs going to go! ! ! ! ! in this church. Itʼll get twice daily broadcast about the! ! ! ! ! LRA; where they are and where theyʼre active. And! ! ! ! ! they can also, if thereʼs an attack or a sighting, they! ! ! ! ! can send that information into Dungu which is kind of
! ! ! ! ! like the military base hub up here.
Whole community working together to ensure HF radio works; Laren works with local community putting signals up.Community members install solar panels on the church Images of the old equipment; Images of members of community using and communicating through devices
Matthew Brubacher:! ! The only mode of communication is through these HF! ! ! ! ! radios which are basically solar powered radios that! ! ! ! ! are able to transmit long distances, 500 to 1,000
! ! ! ! ! kilometers so communities that are very very far apart! ! ! ! ! can start communicating with one another.
Men in the community learning to actually wire the HF radios and stringing cables along the village to create an infrastructure. Group growing in participation.
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!
39
8/4/2019 The Protection Plan: A case study in post-humanitarianism
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-protection-plan-a-case-study-in-post-humanitarianism 40/40
Jolly Okot:! ! ! ! The roads in congo are very bad and as such if there! ! ! ! ! is a radio communication it would give enough time to! ! ! ! ! save lives
Ida Sawyer:! ! ! ! If there were communications, if there were a way for
! ! ! ! ! the people in Mabanga Ya Talo and Nokondo villages! ! ! ! ! to report somewhere and let them know - if there are! ! ! ! ! people there to respond when there is an attack they! ! ! ! ! can help them and maybe all of those people might! ! ! ! ! not have been killed and abducted
In text:! ! HELP EXPAND THE CONGO EARLY WARNING NETWORK!
! ! ! AND PREVENT THE NEXT LRA MASSACRE! ! !
! ! ! INVISIBLECHILDREN.COM
Jacqueline Smith ! Global Media and Communications!