Upload
georgina-lewis
View
216
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
THE THREE Appeals:FUNDAMENTALS OF PERSUADING AN AUDIENCE
What every writer NEEDS TO KNOW TO ABOUT ARGUING WELL
HISTORY: the wisdom of the ancients
Aristotle, the ancient Greek philosopher, developed the theory of how arguments are constructed that is still used today.
Aristotle was a student of Plato and teacher of Alexander the Great.
He said that the goal of persuasion is to…
1. Convince an audience that your point is valid
2. Or that your point is more valid than another’sAristotle (384-322 BC)
Persuasion: introduction
Persuasion is not about showing that others’ arguments are stupid or wrong but rather that
your argument is stronger.
Check out this introductory video
“Persuasive Appeals: Ethos, Pathos, Logos”
http://teachertube.com/
DEFINITION: rhetoric
• RHETORIC (n) - the art of speaking or writing effectively (Webster's Definition).
• According to Aristotle, rhetoric is "the ability, in each particular case, to see the available means of persuasion."
• Aristotle described three main forms of rhetoric: LOGOS, PATHOS, and ETHOS.
DEFINITION: logos
Appeal to the mind; used to make readers think; use of reason
Comes from Greek word meaning “divine words”—the words of God. Literally means “logic.”
1.Used to create rational explanations that make sense
2.Used to provide specific, demonstrable evidence that is either factual or probable
1. An argument that makes sense
a syllogism will determine truth and fact
Major premise: All books from that store are new.
Minor premise: These books are from that store.Conclusion: Therefore, these books are new.
an enthymeme will show probability and implication
Major premise: People who lie cannot be trusted
Minor premise: This man lied to me.
Conclusion: This man is not to be trusted.
Here, the conclusion may not necessarily be true—one lie does not always make a person completely untrustworthy.
2. Logical evidence
facts, case studies, statistics, experiments, analogies, anecdotes, illustrations, examples, testimony, definitions, quotations, citations,
authorities/experts, informed opinions, common beliefs, ideas & feelings
EXAMPLES OF LOGOS
Which kind of logos is used in each example?
•Pesticides contain deadly particles that destroy the nervous system, as reported by the EPA and various studies conducted by researchers.
•Pesticides are sprayed around the school and community, filling the air that the kids breath with dangerous, harmful chemicals.
Analyzing logos
QUESTIONS TO CONSIDER:
•Where does the writer use reasons that make sense?
•Is the writer’s thesis reasonable and worth considering?
•What conclusions or answers does the writer provide to questions and problems?
•Is the writer’s supporting evidence clear, specific, and convincing?
•Does the writer use accurate evidence?
•Does the writer provide sources/citations?
Idea: Students should be allowed to use cell phones during school hours.
list specific evidence to support idea
Practice: brainstorming logos
DEFINITIONS: pathos
Appeal to emotion; used to move readers, hopefully into action
Comes from Greek words meaning “suffering,” “pitiable,” “sad”; pathos can be humor too
Used to excite, arouse, and/or interest an audience
A powerful appeal that must be used appropriately
1. Using pathos RESPONSIBLY
Emotions are powerful and can be very convincing. However, emotion can also cloud people’s judgment and overthrow logic.
appeals to emotion must have relevance
appeals to emotion must be appropriate
appeals to emotion must be justifiable
appeals to emotion must be made honestly
2. Using pathos IRRESPONSIBLY
Emotions are dangerous and used in ways that are unfair and divert the attention of the audience inappropriately.
appeals to emotion can manipulate
appeals to emotion can overthrow logic
therefore, use pathos with care and caution
Pathetic evidence
vivid descriptions, loaded language, connotative meanings, examples, stories,
narrative, emotional word choices, figurative language (metaphors & similes), references to
common morals, beliefs, and/or ideas
Commonly targeted Emotions
affection, anger, contempt, delight, disgust, despair, embarrassment, envy, excitement,
fear, guilt, hope, horror, humiliation, humor, jealously, joy, love, loyalty, passion, pity,
pride, joy, remorse, ridicule, sadness, shame, shock, shyness, sorrow, vengeance
EXAMPLES OF pathos
Responsible or irresponsible use?
•Obama knows a lot about Muslims because he secretly is one, making him the most dangerous man in America.
•Knowing the warning signs of cancer could save you from suffering the loss of someone you love, like I did.
Analyzing pathosQUESTIONS TO CONSIDER:
•Does the writer use vivid description, examples, personal stories, or shocking facts to get a response from readers?
•What emotions do you think the writer is trying to rouse: sorrow, fear, guild, hope…?
•Is pathos used appropriately and relevant?
•Does the writer seem sincere, fake…?
•How does the writer’s appeal to emotion reinforce his or her appeal to reason?
Idea: Being an international student is challenging. list evidence to support idea AND the emotion it would appeal to.
Practice: brainstorming pathos
Who is that? She must be thinking very, very hard about pathos….
DEFINITION: ethos
Appeal of ethics; refers to the writer’s credibility and character
Comes from Greek word meaning “image”—the writer’s image
Indicates writer’s reliability, competence, and ethics
Used to gain or build readers’ trust & confidence in the writer
The writer’s Character
depends of reputation
personal history/past
what people know and say about him/her
often but not always based in reality
references to the past & present
involvements, affiliations, advocacy,
accomplishments, successes, examples of helping others,
and positive highlights of past actions
The Writer’s CREDIBILITY
expertise/authority & how these are portrayed
confidence, reasons why others respect & admire; interest in topic
education, experience, positions held,
publications, research/studies, awards,
respect for readers: accuracy & complete explanations,
common ground with readers: morals, values, beliefs,
appropriate use of logos and pathos, recognizes counterarguments
logically organized, reader-friendly & error-free writing
Ethical evidence
Ethos is presented through references to writer’s reliability & competence as well as the writer’s language use & style:
audience-appropriate language, vocabulary, tone
references to education, experience, accomplishments
complete & accurate explanations
sound use of logos; appropriate use of pathos
morals, values, beliefs held in common with audience
knowledge of subject; fairness & recognition of opposition
organized, articulate argument
Attributes of ethos
Examples of the “image” a writer may present in an argument:
compassion, courage, credibility,
decency, dedication, dignity,
enthusiasm, goodwill, honesty, honor,
idealism, intelligence, kindness, morality, nobility, patriotism, resolve, respect, responsibility,
sincerity, strength, trustworthiness, valor, vigor, wisdom, friendliness, concern,
indifference, apathy, arrogance, conceit
Humor as pathos
Using laughter to touch readers’ hearts, make them think, inspire respect for the writer by delighting & surprising readers, employ ridicule & irony to highlight truth
Using humor can be difficult & risky
EXAMPLES OF ethos
What do these passages convey about the writer?•Good decisions cannot be made when knowledge is ignored and understanding is incomplete. We must realize that educating young Americans about the Muslim world is the only intelligent option we have.
•For 18 years, I have worked at the state prison where about 95% of inmates are minorities. This has clearly proven to me that minorities are a negative element of America’s population and society.
Analyzing ethos
QUESTIONS TO CONSIDER:
•What does/doesn’t make you think the writer is trustworthy, fair, and credible?
•What authority does the writer have on the subject? What experience does he/she have with the subject?
•What is the writer’s tone (attitude) toward the subject and audience?
•What morals, values, and beliefs does the writer seem to share with the audience?
•How does the writer’s character reinforce his or her appeals to reason and to emotion?
•Has the writer organized and edited the argument well? Does he/she explain what is necessary?
Idea: Studying in another language isvery challenging.
what could you (the writer) include to give readers a sense of your character and credibility?
Practice: brainstorming ethos
OTHER APPEALS
Kairos Nomos
Mythos
These are noteworthy appeals that may be used along with one or more main appeals, depending on how they are used.
DEFINITION: kairos
Appeal of timeliness; emphasizes significance of moments in time
Used to convey urgency of a problem & use the past to predict future consequences
Argument Development: problem, solution, justification
Specific considerations:
Significance of problem, effectiveness of solution, counterproposals
DEFINITION: mythos
Appeal to tradition; emphasizes whether violating tradition is appropriate or inappropriate
Used to appeal to readers’ culture
Types of Evidence:
proverbs, beliefs, figures, symbols, practices
DEFINITION: nomos
Appeal of culture; emphasizes shared cultural beliefs & practices
Used to allow the writer to “identify with” readers by emphasizing what the have in common and their similarities
Used to convince an audience to come to the same conclusion as the writer
Practice: kairos, mythos, nomos
Idea: The people of my country must accept that globalization makes change is necessary.
brainstorm one supporting example of each appeal.
appeals are never used alone…
Arguments always use all 3 main appeals,
though not they are rarely used evenly
The writer may rely heavily on one appeal,
but an argument needs all 3 to be effective
Appeals often overlap; some sentences, sections, or elements demonstrate more than one appeal, even all 3
Kairos, mythos, or nomos may also be used with a main appeal