The Top 100 Reds of Napa Valley 2016 - Clos Du Val · 2018. 6. 5. · The Top 100 Reds of Napa Valley 2016 Wednesday, November 23, 2016 I couldn’t have picked a better time to create

The Top 100 Reds of Napa Valley 2016

Wednesday, November 23, 2016

I couldn’t have picked a better time to create a Top 100 list for Napa than in 2016. What a year it’s been

for America’s most famous wine region, as most wines I scored were from the glorious 2012 and 2013

vintages. I tasted about 1,000 wines from Napa this year over four different trips. JamesSuckling.com is

committed to the region and its unique wines and fantastic terroir and microclimates. We believe in the

future of Napa wines in both America and abroad, particularly in Asia where I spend five months

working each year and have two full-time staff in Hong Kong. That’s why I also now live part of the

year in St. Helena so that I can keep my hand on the region’s pulse.

Gorgeous Napa weather during one of our vineyard visits.

It won’t be a surprise that Opus One Napa Valley 2013 is our Napa Valley Red of 2016. It was also my

Wine of the Year in 2016. The 100-point Bordeaux blend highlights what is great about the best Napa

reds at the moment: It has a classic balance and structure that recalls the valley’s past alongside a new

style of precise and ripe fruit full of irresistible energy and drinkability. It also shows that the region is

ready to move on from overblown, jammy fruit with too much alcohol. That is not the way forward.

The Dominus Napa Valley 2013 is a close second (also a perfect wine). This bottle, too, shows its

history and pedigree from one of the founding-father’s vineyards. What a wine with such beauty and

class.

The No. 3—Realm Cellars Napa Valley Oakville Beckstoffer To Kalon Vineyard 2013—and No. 4 —

Paul Hobbs Napa Valley Oakville Beckstoffer To Kalon Vineyard 2013—both hail from a legendary

valley floor vineyard, To Kolan. These wines show the true character of the soil, offering stone and

oyster shell undertones to the fresh fruit. This is a departure from the many jammy, fruit bombs I’ve

encountered from here that always masked the terroir.

Continuum Napa Valley Continuum 2013 is at No. 5. This bottle shows the superb quality and intensity

of mountain grown grapes. I love Pritchard Hill reds, and this Bordeaux blend shows such complexity

and structure yet a balance and freshness. This will age beautifully, but it’s also hard to resist opening

now.

http://www.jamessuckling.com/wine-tasting-reports/top-100-wines-2016/

The No. 10 Dominus Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon Napanook 2013 is simply one of the best value,

top scoring Napa reds out in 2016.

The list continues with many classics as well as relative newcomers. I tried to pick wines that excited me

not so much for their flamboyance but for their beauty, complexity and balance. Drinkability, of course,

is paramount and I think great wines are great from the beginning, whether from barrel or from bottle

and through the years in the cellar. I mostly kept to picking one wine per winery on this list. The No. 10

Dominus Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon Napanook 2013 is the exception. It’s simply one of the best

value top scoring Napa reds out in 2016.

Next year’s tasting should be just as exciting with the release of so many great 2014s from Napa Valley.

I’ve had many from barrel and already they’re showing inspiring freshness and a fruitiness that gives

them a more linear profile than the structured 2013s or ripe and fruity 2012s. Napa is on a roll with a trio

of great vintages and fabulous wines—and we look forward to spending even more time with these great

wines. —James Suckling, CEO/Editor

Tasting Notes

1

OPUS ONE NAPA VALLEY 2013

Country United States

Region California - Napa

Valley

Vintage 2013 Score

100

The greatest Opus ever. Terrific aromas of crushed

black currants, blueberries, and flowers with hints

of sweet tobacco. Roses continue to exude

opulence and class. Full body, superb balance of

ultra-fine tannins and vibrant acidity. Complex

aftertaste of black fruits and citrus fruit. Extremely

persistent. So approachable now and enjoyable. But

will be even better in 2019 and beyond. 79%

cabernet sauvignon, 7% cabernet franc, 6% merlot,

6% petit verdot, 2% malbec. This will always be

beautiful to drink.

2

DOMINUS NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

100

The aromas to this are multidimensional and

fascinating with black truffles, bark, cloves, black

currants, citrus, and even ginseng. Full-bodied, yet

reserved and austere with chewy and powerful

tannins that remain polished and refined. The

flavors are more umami and savory. Then there are

forest fruits and blood-orange undertones. The wine

goes on for minutes. A wine to age for a lifetime.

It's an experience to taste this. A new classic

showing its history and tradition as a source of the

greatest wines ever from Napa. A wine to enjoy

forever.

3

REALM CELLARS NAPA VALLEY OAKVILLE BECKSTOFFER TO KALON VINEYARD

2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

100

This is extraordinary on the nose with cold stones,

minerals, wet earth and fresh spices. Full body, an

incredible backbone of tannins, and great length. It

really lasts for minutes. When you taste it, it brings

you down to the root and soul of the wine.

Extraordinary. This is what To Kalon is supposed

to taste like. Pure cabernet sauvignon. 450 cases.

4

PAUL HOBBS CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY OAKVILLE BECKSTOFFER TO

KALON VINEYARD 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

100

This is incredible with blackberries, oyster shell,

and iodine. Stones and graphite. Perfect nose. Full-

bodied, yet so balanced and dense with terrific

subtle fruit and a salty, savory finish. Like sea salt

with raw wagyu meat. Perfect. Better in 2020, but

amazing now.

5

CONTINUUM NAPA VALLEY CONTINUUM 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

99

Impressive purity of fruit and definition with

blackcurrant, oyster shell, blueberries and slate.

Graphite, too. Very complex yet subtle. Full-

bodied, very chewy and powerful yet polished and

gorgeous. Muscular, well-formed tannins. Electric

style. Drink in 2020.

6

PETER MICHAEL WINERY NAPA VALLEY OAKVILLE AU PARADIS 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

99

The complex aromas are amazing with hot stones,

blackcurrants, meat, and iron. Turns to porcini and

wet earth. Cassis leaf, too. Full-bodied, velvety,

and savory with blueberries, iron, iodine and oyster

shell. Classic texture. So fabulous to taste now but

will age beautifully for decades to come.

7

SPOTTSWOODE CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY ST. HELENA 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

98

Glorious blueberries, blackberries, violets, and hot

stones. Cloves and other spices. Even sliced

mushrooms. Full body, very firm tannins, and a

persistent and savory finish. A tight and polished

young cabernet.

8

QUINTESSA NAPA VALLEY RUTHERFORD 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

98

This is really fantastic on the nose with

blackberries, blueberries, lavender, and violets.

Even sage. Full body plus extremely integrated

tannins that are polished and refined. The balance

and harmony are phenomenal. Goes on for minutes.

Beautiful now but will satisfy for decades.

9

DIAMOND CREEK CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY GRAVELLY MEADOW 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

98

The aromas of blueberries and blackberries in this

wine are phenomenal. It's so perfumed and floral

with violets, lilacs, and roses. Full body with firm,

super silky tannins. And yet it's cool and racy.

Minerally with stones, as it should be. Classic

Diamond Creek style. Better in 2020 but a joy to

taste. 430 cases made.

10

DOMINUS CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY NAPANOOK 2013

Country United States Score Fabulous nose of mushrooms, like porcini, with


Valley

Vintage 2013

97 black truffle that turns to citrus fruits such as

orange and tangerine. Some vine bark. Full-bodied

yet wonderfully firm and formed with refined and

polished tannins. Super definition. Drink in 2018,

but wonderful to experience.

11

ABREU CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY CAPPELLA 2012



Valley

Vintage 2012

Score

100

A beautiful and fresh red with flowers and blue

fruits along with raspberries and blackberries. Full

body, ultra-fine tannins, and wonderful length.

Finesse. Fine-grained. Harmony and balance. Sexy

and very, very beautiful. Magic and seamless.

About 200 cases made. Drink now.

12

SCHRADER CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY BECKSTOFFER TO KALON

VINEYARD SCHRADER 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

100

This is a red with amazing structure and muscle,

yet it remains fresh and agile. Full body and chewy

and polished tannins. Salty with chili and sweet

tobacco. So savory. Marvelous, seamless texture. In

synch. Why wait? Beautiful to drink now.

13

DANA ESTATES CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY RUTHERFORD HELMS

VINEYARD 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

100

Unique aromas of citrus fruit such as tangerines

and oranges which combine with plums, black

cherries, and blackcurrants. Lemon rind, too. Full-

bodied with ultra-fine tannins that give the wine a

precise and focused finish that lasts for minutes.

Laser-guided. A savory and subtle, minerally

finish. This redefines the greatness of Napa Valley

wine and California. 282 cases made.

14

HARLAN ESTATE NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

100

This is really sensational with such precision and

focus. Glorious aromas of tar, graphite,

blackcurrants, and blackberries. Full-bodied, very

tight, and reserved. Phenomenal tannic structure

that is supple and wonderful. This new classicism

makes me speechless. It's pure pleasure. You can

drink it now, but it's built for aging.

15

KENZO ESTATE NAPA VALLEY AI 2013


Region California

Vintage 2013

Score

97

Aromas of tobacco leaf and currant. Hints of black

currants. Iodine. Full body, pinpointed fruit and

tannins that melt into the wine. Dense yet agile.

Goes on for minutes. Superb classic structure

showing finesse and style. Classicism here. Better

in 2022 but hard not to drink now.

16

KAPCSANDY FAMILY WINERY NAPA VALLEY STATE LANE VINEYARD ROBERTA'S

RESERVE 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

100

The aromas to this are mind-blowing. Pure violets,

lilacs, blueberries, blackberries, licorice, and

flowers. Full body and superb tannin tension with

polish and balance. Harmony. The layers and

texture to this are phenomenal. The greatest

American merlot ever made. Ranks among the best

in the world. Only about 300 cases made.

17

SCREAMING EAGLE NAPA VALLEY OAKVILLE 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

100

Breathtaking aromas of blueberries, wet earth,

black truffle, vine bark, and lavender undertones.

Full-bodied, yet tight and compressed with

fabulous savory and dark-fruit flavors. It lasts for

minutes on the finish. The classicism in this wine is

second to none. Incredible subtlety and a lovely

austerity. Beauty in simplicity. Glorious to taste,

yet a wine for decades ahead. 76% cabernet

sauvignon, 13% merlot, and 11% cabernet franc.

800 cases made.

18

BOND NAPA VALLEY ST. EDEN 2013



Valley

Score

99

Extravagant aromas of crushed raspberries and

boysenberries follow through to a full body with

fabulous velvety tannins and a superb finish of

Vintage 2013

exotic fruit and lusciousness. Mesmerizing now but

better in 2019.

19

COLGIN CELLARS NAPA VALLEY IX ESTATE 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

98

The aromas to this are perfect with black truffle,

sage, blueberry and wet earth. Changes all the time.

Full body with lots of richness and fruit. The

intensity is electric. Chewy tannins yet polished

and silky. It lasts for minutes on the palate. A joy to

taste (drink) now but it's made for long-term aging.

20

DAVID ARTHUR CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY RUTHERFORD ELEVATION

1147 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

98

This is a phenomenal wine with incredible

precision and length. The tannins are so finely

polished and long, giving the wine such

persistence. Full, dense and stunning. A wine to

enjoy for decades. Fabulous.

21

EISELE VINEYARD CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2013


Region California-Napa

Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

98

The aroma of dried rose petals is stunning. Hints of

dark fruits too. Intensely perfumed. Full-bodied,

deep and condensed with incredible depth and

subtlety. Powerful tannins that are hidden under the

beautiful fruit. The finish lasts for minutes. Precise

and gorgeous. Very tight. Needs four to five years

to soften and amalgamate. One of best ever from

Araujo? The first wine from grape to bottle from

the new owner, Francois Pinault, who also owns

Château Latour.

22

SHAFER VINEYARDS NAPA VALLEY STAGS LEAP DISTRICT HILLSIDE SELECT 2012



Valley

Vintage 2012

Score

98

A wine with incredible finesse and elegance.

Blackberry, blueberry, mineral, violet and lavender

aromas. Wet earth floor and stone. Full body, very

fine tannins and fabulous freshness. The length and

polish is truly exceptional. The hint of austerity

makes it irresistible. A joy to drink. But has a great

future ahead of it.

23

NICKEL & NICKEL CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY STATE RANCH 2013


Region California

Vintage 2013

Score

97

Impressive aromas of blueberry and lavender with

hints of rosemary. Full to medium body, solid core

of fruit and a gorgeous finish. Compacted and

refined. Better in 2019 but already fantastic. Best

wine ever from here?

24

CHAPPELLETT CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY PRITCHARD HILL 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

97

Amazing aromas of dark fruits but there's a soulful

undertone of forest floor, sweet tobacco and leaves.

Full body, ultra-fine tannins and a delicious finish.

Ultra-refined. So drinkable now. Harmonious and

thoughtful. Elegant.

25

INGLENOOK NAPA VALLEY RUTHERFORD RUBICON 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

97

The clarity and precision to this wine are

phenomenal with blackcurrants, floral notes,

blueberries, and orange peel. Complex and subtle

with grace and stature. Full body, ultra-polished

and refined tannins and bright acidity. The wine

needs three to four years to open on the palate, but

already it has a caressing quality to it.

26

LARKMEAD NAPA VALLEY THE LARK 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

97

Blueberry, blackberry, and licorice aromas follow

through to a full-bodied palate, velvety tannins, and

a flavorful finish. Generous yet reserved. Shows

class and depth. Better in 2020.

27

MARTIN RAY CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY SYNTHESIS 2012



Valley

Score

97

Love the decadence and rich-earth style to this,

which shows plenty of dark fruits. Full-body,

velvety, and a caressing texture. The mouthfeel is

Vintage 2012

wonderful here. So easy to love and to drink.

28

FUTO CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY STAGS LEAP DISTRICT 5500 ESTATE

2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

98

Very elegant and fine with real tannin tension that

drives the subtle fruit at the finish. Full yet very

refined and linear. Stoney, mineral core to this with

an undertone of bark, wet earth and mushroom.

Lightly savory. Endless finish. Purity and focus.

Better in 2019 but very fine now. Harmony in a

bottle.

29

GRACE FAMILY VINEYARDS CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

97

So perfumed and beautiful in the nose with

spearmint, blueberry, and blackberry aromas. Full-

bodied yet reserved and refined. Very linear and

tight yet gorgeous and long. Compressed

mouthfeel. Wonderful minerality with a flinty

undertone. A young cab with great length and

excitement. Needs at least five or six years to open.

Wonderful potential.

30

ULYSSES NAPA VALLEY 2012



Valley

Vintage 2012

Score

97

Subtle aromas of crushed berries and tile.

Mushrooms. Almost dusty. Full to medium body,

powdery tannins and mouthfeel. Bright acidity that

gives the wine beautiful and enticing freshness.

Gentle and ethereal red. The first vintage of the

new wine from the owners of Dominus. The

vineyard is located in Oakville near Vine Hill.

Drink or hold.

31

AMICI CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY SPRING MOUNTAIN DISTRICT 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

96

A dense and powerful red with amazing depth of

fruit and chewy tannins, yet savory and beautiful.

Full body, spice, walnuts and plum. Sage too.

Superb. Classic Napa cabernet. 260 cases. October

release. Better in 2019.

32

BRYANT FAMILY VINEYARD NAPA VALLEY BETTINA 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

97

There's a phenomenal nose to this wine with

crushed berry, wet earth, wet slate and hints of

flowers. Full body with a chewy tannic structure,

yet soft and polished. Powerful and rich. Muscular

and toned. Has form. Slightly austere tannins. This

needs at least four to seven years of bottle age. The

high percentage of merlot from Howell Mountain

gives this wine a real edge and beauty. A blend of

62.3% cabernet sauvignon, 30.2% merlot and 7.5%

petit verdot. Try in 2020.

33

TOR CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY BLACK MAGIC 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

97

Complex aromas of blueberries, rose petals, black

peppercorns, and black licorice. Full body, firm and

silky tannins, and a long and flavorful finish.

Integrated and polished. Better in 2019.

34

ARROW & BRANCH CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY BECKSTOFFER DR.

CRANE VINEYARD 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

97

Wow. Such character and style to this Dr. Crane

with lavender, rosemary, flowers and sage as well

as dark blueberries. Yet always reserved and

focused. Full-bodied, ultra-refined and super long

on the finish. A triumph. Drink or hold.

35

KATA NAPA VALLEY BECKSTOFFER BOURN VINEYARD 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

97

This is a fascinating red with so much high-toned

blackberry, blueberry and stone. Asphalt and tar.

Lavender and violets. Full-bodied yet agile and

lively. It's seamless and formed. Incredible depth

and refinement, yet posture. Cabernet sauvignon

and 20% petite sirah. Give it two or three years, but

so great now.

36

BRYANT FAMILY VINEYARD CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

96

The purity of fruit here is terrific with licorice,

black currant and oyster shell. Blackberry too. Full

body. The finish is overwhelming with such great

intensity and grip. High-tensioned austerity.

Energetic and intense. Tannins are austere. Drink in

2021.

37

CORISON CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY KRONOS 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

96

A glorious old vine wine with mineral, stone,

blueberry, black currant and wet earth. Full body,

silky tannins and a long finish. Salty undertone,

even iodine. There's an ethereal quality to this that

makes you think. Released spring of 2017. 400

cases made.

38

PROMONTORY NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

96

This shows beautiful aromas of cedar, walnuts,

currants and pine needles. Full body, firm tannins

and bright acidity. Vibrant and muscular with a

crisp and energetic finish. A lively combination of

fruit, tannins and acidity. Better a few years after

release but already gorgeous. Juicy. Best

Promontory yet, as the first commercial year was

2009.

39

PAHLMEYER NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

96

So much purple fruit here like blueberries as well

as minerals and black pepper. Full body, firm and

silky tannins. Tight and compressed style with

great persistence. Better in 2020, but so gorgeous

now.

40

M BY MICHAEL MONDAVI CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2013


Region California - Napa Score

The purity and brilliance to this wine is fantastic

with blueberry, black currant, and boysenberry.

Valley

Vintage 2013

96 Full body, very fine tannins and a bright finish. The

tannin texture is sublime. Give it two or three years

to develop. A wonderful example of new Napa.

41

YAO MING CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

96

A solid cabernet with a depth of spicy, plum and

tile aromas and flavors. Full body, firm and chewy

tannins and a flavorful finish. Shows poise and real

structure. Give it two to five years to soften. Try in

2018.

42

ROBERT MONDAVI WINERY CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY OAKVILLE TO

KALON VINEYARD RESERVE 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

96

Aromas of black currants, violets, lavender, and

stone follow through a full body, chewy tannins

and toned muscular structure. This is a Mondavi

reserve that harkens back to the great years of the

1970s. A tribute to the 50th anniversary of the

winery. Try in 2022.

43

JOSEPH PHELPS VINEYARDS CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY INSIGNIA 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

95

Extravagant aromas of crushed blackberries, mint,

eucalyptus and flint. Full body, round and velvety

textured. Rich and flavorful finish. Lusciousness

with form. Reserved palate. Very attractive now but

better in 2020.

44

WORLD’S END CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY PRITCHARD HILL STIR IT UP

2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

95

A pure and beautiful red with blackberry,

chocolate, and light vanilla character. Shows form

and tension in a thick and dense style. Better in

2019 but already so delicious and impressive.

45

AMUSE BOUCHE NAPA VALLEY RED BLEND 2013


Region California

Vintage 2013

Score

95

With such beautiful definition and balance, this

may be the best ever from Amuse. Medium to full

body, linear backbone and length, and a lovely,

fresh finish. Drink now. Mostly merlot.

46

TURNBULL CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY OAKVILLE BLACK LABEL 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

95

Black licorice, blueberry and tar aromas. Full body

plus soft and velvety tannins that are polished and

delicious. Persistent and beautiful. Drink or hold.

47

QUIVET CELLARS CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY BECKSTOFFER LES

PIEDRAS VINEYARD 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

95

So much eucalyptus in the nose with blackberry

and white pepper. Full body, round and silky

tannins and a bright and fresh finish. Chewy and

serious. Fantastic finish. A super wine with focus

from the Las Piedras Vineyard. Better in 2019.

48

VIADER NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

95

A red that shows lots of black currant and fresh

floral aromas. Full body, velvety tannins and a

flavorful finish. Yet reserved and very pretty.

Refined at the finish. About half cabernet

sauvignon and half cabernet franc. Drink or hold.

49

NEWTON CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY THE PUZZLE 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

95

Lots of licorice and graphite here on the nose. Cool

and seductive. Full body, very layered and exciting.

Superb finish. It goes on and on. The best Newton

in years. Beautiful to drink now but better in 2018.

50

LEVENSOHN CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY ST. HELENA 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

95

So much blackberry and black licorice aromas

follow through to a full body, chewy tannins and a

tight and polished finish. Muscular and fit red.

Needs two or three years of bottle age to soften.

51

CLIFF LEDE CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY BECKSTOFFER TO KALON

VINEYARD 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

95

A powerful and structured red with firm yet

polished tannins that are always present. But there

is a richness and intensity of fruit as well. Needs

time to soften though clearly outstanding. Better in

2020.

52

JCB NAPA VALLEY THE SURREALIST 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

94

The surreal packaging of this wine with its baroque

bottle and kissing heads suggest something very

unique. Indeed. It shows balance and pleasure with

black currant, spice and cedar undertones. Give it

three or four years and see the love.

53

SPRING MOUNTAIN CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2012



Valley

Vintage 2012

Score

95

This has a lovely dusty character with currant, tile

and sweet tobacco. Full body, chewy and beautiful

tannins. Wonderful austerity yet softness. Flavorful

finish. Delicious now but shows finesse and length.

Better in 2019 but so gorgeous already.

54

MINER CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY STAGECOACH VINEYARD 2013


Region California

Vintage 2013

Score

95

Aromas of blackberry, walnut and light, wet earth

follow through to a full to medium body, light

chocolate and a long finish. Refined and polished.

Classic style. Better in 2019.

55

CAIN NAPA VALLEY SPRING MOUNTAIN DISTRICT CAIN FIVE 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

95

Lots of plum, clay tile and spice aromas from

cumin to cloves. Decadent. Full body, ultra-fine

and chewy tannins, and lovely energy and verve.

Needs two or three years to soften but complex

already.

56

KRUPP BROTHERS CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY STAGECOACH VINEYARD

M5 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

95

This is a big and luscious red but shows style and

tension. Full body, polished and silky tannins. Very

long finish of tar, blackberry and crushed stone.

Very tannic. Give it a year or two to soften. Better

in 2018.

57

HE-LI-AN-THUS NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

95

This shows so much iodine, dark fruits and stone

aromas and flavors. Full body, soft and velvety

tannins. Full grain yet polished and very focused.

Lovely finish. This is the first release from the

winemaker of Futo and Jessica Futo, the daughter

of the owner of Futo. A blend of cabernet

sauvignon, merlot and petit verdot. From a

vineyard in Soda Canyon.

58

GRIGICH HILLS ESTATE CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY YOUNTVILLE OLD

VINE 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

94

Wonderful aromas of black fruits, bark and moss

follow through to full body, ultra-refined tannins

and a long and caressing finish. Shows energy and

translucence. Made from biodynamically grown

grapes. Better in 2018.

59

TREFETHEN FAMILY VINEYARDS CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY OAK

KNOLL DISTRICT RESERVE 2012

Country United States Score A very rich red with crushed blueberry, spice and


Valley

Vintage 2012

94 bark undertones. Full-bodied, firm and silky with

tone tannins and gorgeous fruit. This is a 2013 cab

for aging but intrigues you now. Why wait?

60

CLOS DU VAL CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY STAGS LEAP DISTRICT 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

94

Unctuous red with blueberry, blackberry and hints

of vanilla on the nose and palate. Full body, very

fine tannins and a fresh, clean and beautiful finish.

Better in 2018 but already a joy to taste.

61

ROBERT CRAIG CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY SPRING MOUNTAIN

DISTRICT 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

94

Loads of sweet fruit with spices, blackberry and

black currant character. Full body, silky tannins and

a bright finish. Sexy and flashy. Drink or hold.

62

ROCCA CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY COOMBSVILLE COLLINETTA

VINEYARD 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

94

Subtle aromas of blackberry, licorice and light tar

follow through to a full body, silky tannins and a

long, refined finish. Very sexy. Drink or hold.

63

FORMAN CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

94

A ripe and sexy red with blueberry, tile, smoked

meat, walnut shell, and terracotta aromas that

follow through a full body, velvety tannins and a

savory finish. Turns to sage and rosemary. Soulful.

Drink or hold.

64

BERINGER NAPA VALLEY PRIVATE RESERVE CABERNET SAUVIGNON 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

94

A dark colored red with intense aromas of

blackberry, coffee, treacle tart and smoky oak. Full

body and powerful with silky tannins and gorgeous

fruit. Remains in balance with a lovely polished

texture. Beautiful length. Drinkable now—and will

deliver so much more with bottle age.

65

MYRIAD CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY BECKSTOFFER DR. CRANE

VINEYARD PORTRAIT LABEL 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

94

Plenty of blueberry, blackberry, fresh herb and

sweet tobacco aromas follow through to a full

body, velvety tannins and a long and flavorful

finish. Full-throttle yet the breaks are on with a bit

chewy tannins.

66

SEQUOIA GROVE CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY OAK KNOLL RANCH

LAMOREAUX VINEYARDS 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

94

Wow. Blackberry, wet bark, blueberry and dark

chocolate aromas follow through to a full body,

ultra-fine tannins and a beautiful finish. This show

finesse and style. Drink or hold.

67

ZEITGEIST CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

94

The fresh sage, blackberry and sweet black tobacco

aromas and flavors are compelling. Full body, yet

shows form and tension. Fresh and delicious finish.

Drink or hold.

68

GALLO CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY SIGNATURE SERIES 2012



Valley

Vintage 2012

Score

94

Fabulous aromas of blackberries, blueberries,

licorice and cloves follow through to a full body,

polished and caressing tannins, and a long, long

finish. Needs a couple years to soften but extremely

well-crafted.

69

SOMERSTON CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2012



Valley

Vintage 2012

Score

94

I like the blackberry, mint and lavender aromas and

flavors in this. Full-bodied, very velvety and

chewy, yet has a bright undertone of acidity.

Persistent. Better in 2019.

70

DAVIES VINEYARDS NAPA VALLEY JAMIE 2012



Valley

Vintage 2012

Score

94

Dried flowers with lots of black currants and some

sweet tobacco. This is rich, full-bodied and juicy

with chewy tannins. It has a wonderful intensity yet

it remains constrained. Beautiful cabernet from the

Diamond district. Long finish. Drink now.

71

STAGS’ LEAP WINERY CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY THE LEAP 2012



Valley

Vintage 2012

Score

94

This is really wonderful with complex aromas of

blackberries, slate, fresh herb and sweet tobacco

that follows through to a full body, integrated

tannins and a long, long finish. Better in 2018 but

so excellent now.

72

CHARLES KRUG CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY VINTAGE SELECT 2012



Valley

Vintage 2012

Score

94

Wonderful aromas of sweet tobacco, black licorice,

lead pencil and graphite. Full body with juicy and

velvety tannins that give the wine energy and form.

Better in 2020 but try it now.

73

POETRY CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY STAGS LEAP DISTRICT 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

94

A cool and linear red with deep dark fruits such as

blueberries and blackberries. Hints of mint and

mineral too. Full body, ultra-fine tannins and a long

and flavorful finish. Impressive for this vintage.

Better in 2019.

74

FLORA SPRINGS CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY ST. HELENA RENNIE

RESERVE 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

94

Wow. Impressive nose with so much dark and

opulent fruit, yet remains floral and precise. Full-

bodied palate with lots of licorice, dark chocolate,

black currant and toasted oak. Flamboyant yet fresh

and lively. Drink now.

75

MICHEL ROLLAND NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

95

Very cool and seductive nose of slate, graphite and

purple fruits. Full body, silky and lively tannins.

Lots of tension and intensity. Cool and crafted.

Best ever under this label. Drink or hold.

76

KEEVER VINEYARDS CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

94

Extremely aromatic with violets, lilacs and

blackberries. Full body, ultra-fine tannins and a

fresh finish. This is so well crafted and beautiful to

drink. Why wait?

77

SBRAGIA FAMILY VINEYARDS CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY MT. VEEDER

GODSPEED 2012



Valley

Vintage 2012

Score

94

This is very fine and intense with blueberry, dark

chocolate and hazelnut aromas and flavors. Full

body, firm tannins and a fresh and clean finish.

Needs two to three years of bottle age to soften.

78

LE PETIT VICE CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2012



Valley

Vintage 2012

Score

94

Lots of tar, rubber and blackberry aromas. Full

body, chewy and velvety texture. Flavorful and rich

finish. Needs two or three years to soften. I like this

wine's muscle.

79

VICE VERSA NAPA VALLEY 2012



Valley

Vintage 2012

Score

94

A big style but there's depth and length with

tension and form. Full body, silky tannins and a

flavorful finish. Drink or hold.

80

OAKVILLE EAST CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY CORE STONE 2013


Region California

Vintage 2013

Score

94

Very pretty core of blueberry and black currant

fruit in this wine with polished tannins and a fresh

acidity. Medium to full body, fine and focused. A

beauty. Drink in 2018 but already gorgeous to taste.

81

ARKENSTONE CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY HOWELL MOUNTAIN ESTATE

OBSIDIAN 2013


Region California

Vintage 2013

Score

95

Wow. This is very impressive with black currant

and wet earth aromas and flavors. Full body, chewy

tannins and a long, flavorful finish. Rich yet full of

tension. Better in 2019.

82

JANZEN CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY BECKSTOFFER MISSOURI HOPPER

VINEYARD 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

94

Lots of tar, asphalt and blackberry aromas and

flavors. Full body, chewy and polished tannins. A

rich and intense wine with a lot of alcohol but

shows form and tension. Better in 2019 but

impressive now.

83

BUCCELLA CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

95

A big red with lots of blackberry, licorice and black

currant character. Full body, round texture tannins

that are chewy and rich. Dry and attractive finish.

Give this time. Better in 2020.

84

RAMEY CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY ANNUM 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

A cab with tension and brightness plus lots of rose

petal, blueberry, currant and lavender character.

Full body, firm tannins and a fresh finish. Drink

and enjoy on release or hold for a few years as it

comes more together.

85

BLACK STALLION CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

This is extremely fine and focused with ultra-fine

tannins and a beautiful black currant and spearmint

undertone. Full and fruity. Yet reserved and

interesting. A triumph for the price. Drink or hold.

86

STAGLIN FAMILY VINEYARD CABERNET SAUVIGNON RUTHERFORD NAPA VALLEY

2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

A ripe and generous red with ripe berry, smoky

meat and leather. Full-bodied, round and velvety.

Extremely rich style for 2013. Drink or hold.

87

CALLA LILY CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY ULTIMATE RED 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

A sleek and polished red with blackberry and

lavender aromas and flavors. Medium to full body.

Silky tannins. Drink or hold.

88

TURNBULL CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

Love the aromas of crush blackberries, black

currants and black tobacco. Full body, integrated

and rich tannins, and a flavorful finish. Rich yet

tensioned. Better in 2018 but so delicious now.

89

QUIVET CELLARS CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY PELLET VINEYARD 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

Aromas of blackberry, black cherry, moss wood

and mushrooms follow through to a full body,

round and velvety tannins and a tangy finish. Drink

or hold.

90

GROTH CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY OAKVILLE 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

Subtle and complex with mint, black currant and

licorice aromas. Full body, ultra-fine tannins and a

fresh finish. Clean and refined. A delicious

cabernet to drink now or later. Yes.

91

SULLIVAN VINEYARDS CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY RUTHERFORD 2012


Region California

Vintage 2012

Score

94

Aromas of blackberry, licorice and stone follow

through to a medium body, firm and silky tannins

and a fresh and clean finish. Very fine and pretty.

Very serious. Drink in 2018

92

CASTELLO DI AMOROSA CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

A solid cab with an excellent depth of fruit and

core of tannin backbone. Black currant, walnut and

dark chocolate undertones with ripe tannins. Shows

reserve and focus. Better in 2018 but delicious

now.

93

PETER FRANUS NAPA VALLEY RED WINE 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

A red with beautiful depth and texture showing a

velvety mouthfeel and ripe yet reserved fruit. Full-

bodied, flavorful and beautiful. Bordeaux blend.

Drink or hold.

94

FRANK FAMILY VINEYARDS CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY RUTHERFORD

RESERVE 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

This shows rich fruit with fascinating blackberry,

tile dust and stone character as well. Full body,

silky tannins and a savory finish. What wait?

95

ST. CLEMENT CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY OROPPAS 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

A balanced and juicy red with plums, currants and

roasted meat character with hints of espresso bean.

Full body, silky tannins and a flavorful finish.

Remains subtle and interesting.

96

COHO CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY HEADWATERS 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

Aromas of black currants with dried leaves and

hints of cappuccino. Full-bodied with round,

polished tannins, lots of blackberry character, some

raisiny notes and a persistent finish. 1,710 cases

produced.

97

SILVERADO VINEYARDS CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

A polished and pretty 2013 cabernet that delivers

blueberry, slate and blackberry aromas and flavors.

Full-bodied yet reserved and tight. Drink or hold.

98

WHITEHALL LANE CABERNET SAUVIGNON NAPA VALLEY RUTHERFORD

MILLENNIUM MM VINEYARD 2012



Valley

Vintage 2012

Score

93

Pretty aromas of flowers and ripe fruits follow

through to a full body, firm and silky tannins and a

lovely dark chocolate, currant and stone finish.

Better in 2019.

99

CHARLES KRUG NAPA VALLEY GENERATIONS FAMILY RESERVE 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

Plenty of black currants and licorice aromas with

blueberries and hints of tar. Full body, fine tannins

and an asphalt and slate finish. Drink in 2018.

100

ST. SUPÈRY NAPA VALLEY ÉLU 2013



Valley

Vintage 2013

Score

93

Black currants with sweet tobacco as well as

espresso undertones dominate the nose of this

Bordeaux blend. On the palate, this wine shows

concentration, plenty of tannins and a finish with

lots of dark fruits. A blend of 65% cabernet

sauvignon, 22% merlot, 9% malbec with the

balance of cab franc and petit verdot. Better in two

years.

Documents

The Top 100 Reds of Napa Valley 2016 - Clos Du Val · 2018. 6. 5. · The Top 100 Reds of Napa Valley 2016 Wednesday, November 23, 2016 I couldn’t have picked a better time to create