38

THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case
Page 2: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

THE WAR OF CURRENTSTHE WAR OF CURRENTSTHE WAR OF CURRENTSTHE WAR OF CURRENTSIS NOT OVERIS NOT OVERIS NOT OVERIS NOT OVER

AND HOW IT IMPACTS THE ELEVATORAND HOW IT IMPACTS THE ELEVATORAND HOW IT IMPACTS THE ELEVATORAND HOW IT IMPACTS THE ELEVATOR

Dr. Pilar MolinaDr. Pilar MolinaDr. Pilar MolinaDr. Pilar Molina----GaudoGaudoGaudoGaudo

Page 3: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

IN THE PAST…

Page 4: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

WHAT WAS THE WAR OF CURRENTS?

Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison

Page 5: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

HOW TO DISTRIBUTE ENERGY

AC• Advantages

o Transformation of voltage levels

with transformers

o AC motors � Simpler

o Poly phase systems reduce losses

• Disadvantageso Suboptimal power transmission

o Hazardous high voltage AC

o Line inductances and capacitances

DISTANCE BETWEEN GENERATION AND LOAD �LONG LINES �

LINE LOSSES � HIGH COST

DC• Advantages

o Safer and simpler

o No synchronization

o No harmonic problems

o DC motors

o Maximizes power transmission

• Disadvantages

o Difficult high-voltage generation

o Difficult DC / DC transformation

o DC circuit breakers

EO7

Page 6: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

Folie 5

EO7 La info de est transpa, está contrastada en algún sitio?Estanis Oyarbide; 05.10.2017

Page 7: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

AND THE WINNER WAS…

Chicago 1803 World Fair

Page 8: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

ENERGY DISTRIBUTION IN THE WORLD TODAY

Source: http://www.worldstandards.eu/

Page 9: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

AND HOW DOES THIS IMPACT THE ELEVATOR?

Source: IEEE Spectrum Magazine. Nov. 15, 2012

Page 10: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

IN THE PRESENT…

Page 11: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

Source: The Economist. Oct. 19, 2013

Page 12: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

Source: MIT Technology Review. Arpil 24, 2012

Page 13: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

USE OF ENERGY IN THE WORLD TODAY

LEDs are DC powered

Page 14: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

USE OF ENERGY IN THE WORLD TODAY

Monitors and TVs

https://www.repairfaq.org/

Page 15: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

USE OF ENERGY

Data centres

Source: T. Aldridge, A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating 400 V Direct-Current

for Data Centers,” A case study comparing 400 Vdc with 480-208 Vac power distribution for energy

efficiency and other benefits.

Page 16: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

USE OF ENERGY

Electric Vehicles

Page 17: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

LOCAL GENERATION OF ENERGY

Solar panel

Page 18: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

ENERGY STORAGE

Source: Tesla.com

Page 19: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

Feature Lead Acid LiOn Ultracapacitor

Number of cycles 300-2000 >5000 >1000000

Specific power (W/kg) 30-180 300-2000 5000

Specific energy

(Wh/kg)

30-60 30-140 5

BMS/VMS no yes (BMS) yes (VMS)

Cost (€/kWh) 170 1200 17000

AVAILABLE STORAGE TECHNOLOGIES

18

AVAILABLE STORAGE TECHNOLOGIES

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 1400

1

2

specific energy (Wh/kg)

spe

cifi

c p

ow

er

(kW

/kg

)

Lead Acid

Ult

raca

pa

cito

rs

3

4

5

Li-ion

Page 20: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

AND THE ELEVATOR?

Motor + inverter (VVVF drive)

Based on well-known industrial drivers

500 to 800V at its DC bus

M

Rectifier Inverter

400Vrms

AC

0-400Vrms

AC

500-800VDC

AC/DC/AC converter(Variable Votage Frequency,

VVF)

Page 21: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

OPPORTUNITIES OF ENERGY STORAGE 1

Energy recovery system with ultracapacitors

M

rectifier inverterbraking R

standard motor drive

Energy recovery system and peak power mitigator with ultracapacitors

BusDC

Page 22: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

Two wire connection to drive

• New or existing

One size fits all

• Parallelization

No maintenance

<2W standby

Page 23: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

Po

we

r

Time (s)

Page 24: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

OPPORTUNITIES OF ENERGY STORAGE 2

Low-voltage battery high-performance UPS

M

rectifier inverterbraking R

standard motor drive

Low voltage Battery module-based UPS

BusDC

Page 25: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

48V batteries

• Low cost

• Low size

No additional control

• Simple connection

Power scalable

• From 3k5 to …

Energy scalable

• Full evacuation of buildings

Page 26: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

OPPORTUNITIES OF ENERGY STORAGE 3

Intelligent power supply (all-in-one energy hub)

M

rectifier inverterbraking R

standard motor drive

BusDC

350-600Vdc

120-230VRMS24-48Vdc

charger DC/DC

MPPTAC/DC

Solar-wind powered lift with auxiliar grid connection

Page 27: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

48V batteries

• Low cost

Low power charger 500W

• Peak reduction

No UPS required

Regenerated energy

Solar

Page 28: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

IN THE FUTURE…

Page 29: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

NET-ZERO (NEAR-ZERO) ENERGY BUILDINGS

Beyond BREAM / LEEDs

Page 30: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

IN CONCLUSION

Page 31: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

BRING YOU ELEVATOR CLOSER TO A (POSSIBLE) DC FUTURE

DC powering of systems

• No AC/DC

• Energy storage

• Solar energy

DC powering of elevators

• High-performance UPS systems

• Peak power mitigation

• Energy recovery systems

Page 32: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

Thank you for your attention

Page 33: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

www.epicpower.eswww.epicpower.eswww.epicpower.eswww.epicpower.es

PavillionPavillionPavillionPavillion, 103, 103, 103, 103

Page 34: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

-30.000

-20.000

-10.000

0

10.000

20.000

30.000

40.000

50.000

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

Mo

tor

po

we

r [W

]

Motor Power

CASE STUDY N

Page 35: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

Ahorro: 16.09%

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80-3

-2

-1

0

1

2

3

4x 10

4

Time [s]

Pow

er [

W]

Generation and consumption trips (1 ERS)

Motor consumption

Power provided by ERS 2GMains consumption

Page 36: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80-3

-2

-1

0

1

2

3

4x 10

4

Time [s]

Pow

er [

W]

Generation and consumption trips (2 ERS)

Motor consumption

Power provided by ERS 2GMains consumption

Savings: 32.17%

Page 37: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80-3

-2

-1

0

1

2

3

4x 10

4

Time [s]

Pow

er [

W]

Generation and consumption trips (3 ERS)

Motor consumption

Power provided by ERS 2GMains consumption

Ahorro: 48.26%

Page 38: THE WAR OF CURRENTS · Westinghouse (and Tesla) Thomas A. Edison. ... A. Pratt, P. Kumar, D. Dupy, G. AlLee, Intel Labs, “Evaluating400 V Direct-Current forData Centers,” A case

[Wh]

10 trips 136

10 trips with REGEN drive 92

10 trips with ERS 83

CASE STUDY 3 – COMPARISON WITH REGEN DRIVE

Test tower in Madrid

No standby considered

Only motor is measured

Case Study 3

Test tower

ERS P3k