Upload
ryena-mina-estrada
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
1/29
UPLIFTING SUSTAINABILITY AND MODERNISM TO THE INTERIORS OF A
CONVENTION CENTRE
A Thesis Presented to
The Department of Interior Design
College of Fine Arts and Design
University of Santo Tomas
Espaa, Manila, Philippines
In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements
For the Degree of
Bachelor of Science Major in Interior Design
Submitted by:
RYENA M. ESTRADA
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
2/29
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Title Page
i
Table of Contents.. ii-
vi
Approval Sheet..
vii
Jurys Approval Sheet........................................................................................... viii
Acknowledgement....
ix
Thesis Abstract
x
CHAPTER I: Introduction
A. Background of the Study......................................................................................
B. Statement of the Problem......................................................................................
C. Significance of the Study.........................................................................................
D. Scope and Delimitation of the Study......................................................................
CHAPTER II: Theoretical and Conceptual Framework
Review of the Literature and Related Studies.............................................................
Conceptual Framework.............................................................................................
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
3/29
Definition of Terms...................................................................................................
CHAPTER III: Methodology
Research Design........................................................................................................
The Sample..............................................................................................................
The Instrument...........................................................................................................
Data Collection Procedure...........................................................................................
Data Analysis Procedure..............................................................................................
CHAPTER IV: Presentation of Analysis and Data
Area 1: Cinema Lobby..................................................................................................
Master Plan.................................................................................................................
A. Data Analysis.................................................................................................
B. Design Documents.........................................................................................
Area 2: Restaurant.....................................................................................................
Master Plan.................................................................................................................
A. Data Analysis.................................................................................................
B. Design Documents......................................................................................
Area 3: Cinema...........................................................................................................
Master Plan.................................................................................................................
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
4/29
A. Data Analysis.................................................................................................
B. Design Documents.........................................................................................
Area 4: Convention Hall..............................................................................................
Master Plan.................................................................................................................
A. Data Analysis.................................................................................................
B. Design Documents......................................................................................
CHAPTER V
Summary, Conclusion, and
Recommendation...............................................................
Re-capitulation............................................................................................................
Bibliography...............................................................................................................
APPENDICES
Letter to Architect.......................................................................................................
Letter of Consent..........................................................................................................
Interior Design Contract...............................................................................................
Charts.........................................................................................................................
Brochures.....................................................................................................................
Bio data.......................................................................................................................
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
5/29
APPROVAL SHEET
In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Fine Arts Major in
Interior Design, this thesis, entitled, UPLIFTING SUSTAINABILITY AND
MODERNISM TO THE INTERIORS OF A CONVENTION CENTRE has been
prepared by RYENA M. ESTRADA, who hereby recommended for oral deliberation.
Recommendation Approval:
_____________________________
Asst. Prof. Rodolfo s. Olaso
Thesis Adviser
Interior Design 4A Thesis Programme
Approved by:
_____________________________
Asst. Prof. Rodolfo s. Olaso
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
6/29
Interior Design Department Head
College of Fine Arts and Design
__________________
Date
JURYS APPROVAL SHEET
This thesis entitled, UPLIFTING SUSTAINABILITY AND MODERNISM TO
THE INTERIORS OF A CONVENTION CENTRE prepared by RYENA M.
ESTRADA, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Bachelor of Science
Major in Interior Design is hereby accepted after having been presented in oral
defense.
PANEL OF JURORS
______________________________
Chairman
______________________________
Member
______________________________
Member
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
7/29
______________________
Date
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
8/29
THESIS ABSTRACT
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
9/29
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
The discussions in this chapter consist of an overview of the study,
specifically divided and labeled into parts as: Background of the Study,
Statement of the Problem, Significance of the Study and Scope and
Delimitation of the Study.
Background of the Study
Through communications and interactions, the world and its many
industries has prospered and evolved with time, culture, and most especially
the societys expanding needs. In all sorts of businesses, theres always a
need for meetings, seminars, expos and trade shows that involves a great
mass of attendees. Thus a Convention Centre that allows these activities to
take place is definitely one of the necessities of the world today. Somehow in
our way of living we cant deny that the environment just sometimes couldnt
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
10/29
handle it anymore. Because frankly saying, construction itself is already
destructive to our environment. Our built environment most of the time adds
up to the problems of the environment or the nature itself. And theres no
one else to fix our damage but us, this is why Sustainable or Green Design
has emerged and has to be put into practice and application.
One of the newest establishments here in the Philippines specifically in
Mandaue, Cebu is the JCX Convention Centre which was opened during
November 2011, and developed by Everjust Realty Development Corp. The
Centre has an area of over 1, 700sqm with three (3) meeting/conference
rooms. Providing companies, exhibitions and shows a place to conduct their
big events.
This study intends to get a clear and precise understanding of the
principles of sustainable design (acc. to College of Architecture and Urban
Planning; The University of Michigan), namely Economy of Resources, Life
Cycle, and Humane Design.
This also aims to explore the different Modern
Design strategies for a sustainable future. Incorporating comfort and function
to the requirements of the four selected areas. And create a green and
healthy interior for us and the natural world. In conclusion, this study aims to
create a modern and sustainable interior for the Convention Centre.
Our primary necessity is the environment, and it is a responsible
design to create interior spaces that ensures us sustainable and better
future. This study is expected to present the client and consumers innovative
indigenous resources and materials Cebu offers, some of it are; Coco Coir,
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
11/29
Cogon Grass, Giant Bamboo, Gmelina and Water Hyacinth, which are healthy,
eco-friendly and not toxic to the environment and most of all to us.
Statement of the Problem
Conventions are one of the fast growing industries today in our
world. And the fact that conferences and conventions are in no doubt will be
with us in the next decades, this leaves us a big challenge. The modern-day
society needs a built environment thats sustainable for the future; this is not
just for the nature or our environment. This is above all for every one of us,
for our health and especially for the future generation.
Exhibitions, Trade shows and Conventions are mostly what the public
awaits every year. And this is a place where a great number of people from
different places and sometimes of different culture and environment gathers
and communicate. Which means though its not used daily, once the area is
used by the consumers; it is used vigorously for a long period of time. To this,
this study seeks to answer the following questions:
1. How can the modern designs cope with the sustainable environment
the clients of the Convention Centre needs?
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
12/29
2. What are the latest sustainable design strategies and materials can
our country specifically Cebu City, offer us today?
3. What advantages can these designs provide the environment and
the people?
4. How can this study be beneficial not only to the exhibitors but also
to the public?
5. How can this study be able to present Sustainability, Modern Design,
health and comfort in the interiors of the Convention Centre?
Significance of the Study
Conventions provide us new opportunities, investments and it also
allows us to be exposed to the new discoveries available in our world. Expos
brings together the best in any given field making it easy for exhibition goers
to get what they need with less effort. And top companies and businesses are
always interested for any break they could use to introduce new things to the
public. It is just right that we design these spaces critically, because all over
the world today, more meetings and conventions are held every day.
If we want more establishments then we should think to design for our
survival in designing our built environment with respect to our main source of
materials, the nature. This study provides Sustainable Design solutions for
the convention centre and new alternatives for the materials we normally use
in designing such spaces. It also provides better environment for us, spaces
that are not only good for the nature but also to our health. This study aims
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
13/29
to establish an innovated area for companies and audience of any field to
conduct expositions and shows. This can serve as an inspiration to any
designer or person thats interested in creating spaces that could help us
sustain our environment.
Everyone is expected to benefit from the findings and outcomes of this
study, but the main people that could wholly profit from this are as follows:
1. Public Assembly designers, managers and even attendees.
2. Designers that are about to embark on Sustainable Design.
3. Business men that held conventions, expositions, shows and
meetings very often.
4. Researchers focusing on the subject Sustainable Design.
5. Investors and Product Companies that seeks more knowledge for the
event spaces they use and its effects unto them.
Scope and Delimitation of the Study
Predominantly, this study aspires to formulate a sustainable design
solution for the Convention Centres interiors where as comfort and modern
design is incorporated. Succeeding goal of this study is to discover the latest
of our countrys available resources for sustainable design. Different
strategies are to be applied to the four (4) selected areas from the
Convention Centre to be designed. The focus of this study will be on these
four areas having certain objectives as listed:
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
14/29
o Cinema Lobby
1. To be able to create relaxed, comfortable and inviting
atmosphere.
2. To rely more on sustainable materials rather than artificial
materials.
3. To provide enough space for a good traffic flow of the
attendees.
o Restaurant
1. To design a healthy and sustainable setting for eating.
2. To create an appetizing mood for the customers.
3. To be able to offer a green and modern interior.
o Cinema
1. To introduce a sustainable interiors for the cinema through a
modern approach.
2. To be able to create a healthy surrounding that is appropriate
for all ages.
o Convention Hall
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
15/29
1. To construct a sustainably designed free space thats
convertible and adjustable according to an events needs.
2. To offer a variety of lighting modes depending on a certain
events requirements.
3. To provide modifiable ventilation contingent upon an
expected number of attendees.
CHAPTER II
THEORETICAL AND CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
This chapter will be discussing first, about the Review of the Literature
and Related Studies, Conceptual Framework and lastly the Definition of
Terms.
Review of the Literature and Related Studies
A. Cebu
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
16/29
It has been named that Cebu is the Philippines home for the most
innovative design products, and is aiming to be Asias design destination. And
even more, Cebu has been hailed as Philippines furniture capital.
The Cebu furniture industry has gained significant achievements over the
past ten years. It has grown from mere rattan pole trading to being one of
the major contributors to the Philippine economy. Always noted for their good
designs, excellent craftsmanship and the creative use of traditional and
indigenous materials, Cebu furniture is one of the top five exports of the
province.
(cebueuropeconnect.com, 2007)
An article written by AJ de la Torre in 2009 for Philstar entitled
Development plans to push use of indigenous materials discussed the
factors on why the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) would to set in
motion the employment of native materials of Cebu.
DTI Undersecretary for regional operations Merly Cruz said in a recent
interview that they are bracing up business development plans to shift
towards using materials that are not harmful to the environment.
Cruz said that they would like to share the concept of being able to minimizethe pollution through injecting in their product development plans the use of
indigenous materials.
It is good not to be in the industry for the business only but also for the
protection of the environment.
Cruz said that with the current problems caused by typhoons, people are
becoming more active in participating in efforts and initiatives that are
geared for environment protection and they are hopeful of the participation
of more industries through this reinforcement of projects.
According to Cruz, they are also partnering with other offices like the
Department of Environment and Natural Resources for their projects and also
the Technical Education and Skills Development Authority and the
Department of Science and Technology in helping more people be educated
in using materials that would not harm the environment.
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
17/29
Cruz said that this could also have a good effect on the exporters most
especially since the efforts on environment protection is being strengthened
worldwide and products that are made by indigenous materials would be
highly appreciated by a lot of people.
(philstar.com, 2009)
B. Convention Centre
Convention and conference centers belong to the visitor industry,
wherein collaboration with other industries such as business and hospitality
industry is a necessity. Amenities offered by a convention centre is one of the
main factors clients, investors and business men look after. As what is said in
the book Public Assembly Facilities:
Again, the size of the facility, population of the community, and theamount of the convention sales budget will to a great degree determine thefacility managers involvement in this aspect of the marketing picture.
In smaller communities the manager may be serving in a major roleand working directly with the hotel/motel industry by inviting conventions tothe city. In larger metropolitan areas in which major hotels with sales
personnel are allocated in the facility managers responsibility may be morethat of supporting and assisting the sales activity of the convention bureau.
In either event the facility manager can help his community and thebuilding by analyzing his property to determine exactly what its capabilitiesmay be; for example, the number of exhibit booths that can beaccommodated in exhibit areas; the seating capacity of each room undervarying conditions, and the number of people that can be served at foodfunctions.
(Don Jewell, 1978)
D. Modern Design
From the Latin word modo which means just now, came the word
Modern. In which was applied into design in the late 19 th century through the
early 20th century, and named as the Modernism design movement. In both
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
18/29
architecture and interior design, modern design was always up to newest
styles and materials, and updated trends in the field of art. Modern Design
has always been and will always be associated with the concept of energy.
For the reason, art copes up with time and technology. This is the basis why it
is called a movement; it will and always come along with the era and the
latest available materials and ideas.
The development of the concept of modern style or internationalstyle, whether through intention or misunderstanding, was fundamentallyantithetical to Modernism. The rejection of the a priori application of style,whether neoclassical or gridded curtain wall, was, and remains, at the heartof a true modernist attitude.
Modern architecture could not have happened without the availabilityof concentrated energy, primarily petroleum. The drake oil well, which isusually cited as the first commercial operation of its kind, was drilled in 1859and began the pattern of exponential growth in hydrocarbon fuelconsumption that now so threatens the ecosystem. Here is one of the greatironies in the history of architecture and environmental consciousness: thetechnologies that underlie the evolution of modern thought were dependenton readily available energy sources-electricity, oil, and gas. The modern city,with all of its global environmental benefits, is a product of modernism.
(Carl Stein, 2010)
E. Public Assembly
Many has said and pointed out that a facility for public assemblies are
now one of the necessities of a community, especially when its residents or
occupants mostly come from the business and trade industry.
To accommodate shows, exhibitions and mostly convention of great
population, convention centers were built and delivered to the people. And to
the reason that, these are the factors that would be necessary for every one
of us especially in the near future, it is in no hesitation that these
establishments should be sustainable.
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
19/29
In some situations the need for a performing arts center or aconvention hall may be obvious. In others, however, the first step in planningis to determine carefully what-if anything-is required.
Ideally, an investigation of a communitys current demands shouldinclude an inventory of existing facilities, followed by an examination of
future requirements. In most cases accommodations for sports, shows,exhibitions, conventions, concerts, and other cultural events may beincluded. Further study will fix seating capacities, floor dimensions, numberof meeting rooms, and other specifics.
Feasibility studies of one kind or another are one of the normalbeginning points for most communities interested in the development of newor expanded facilities. These studies may be directed toward a broadassessment of community requirements or sometimes toward determiningthe need for a hall to serve a specific purpose or segment of the community.
It is at this point that the marketability, or perhaps usability, of a
building should be closely scrutinized. A city, state, country, or provincerarely, if ever, erects a building or complex of this kind of its own use. Agovernmental body customarily builds a facility for leasing to others. If the
potential user or lessee finds that he does not want it, that he cannot affordthe rent, or that it fails to fill his requirements, the building may stand idle agreat part of the time.
(Don Jewell, 1978)
F. Service Industry
An industry that provides adequate help and assistance is the Service
Industry. Offering the community services that are much in need for our daily
activities and living.
As the tertiary sector of industry, stressing attention to the many and
increasing activities done by the people today is highly required. Not only on
the material things our body should receive but as well as the environment,
space and physical factors our daily commotions requires us to have.
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
20/29
In economics textbooks and most other mainstream microeconomic worksthe pair of goods and services are treated as one. There is little recognitionof the fact that services are different from material goods in some basicrespects for microeconomic analysis, In view of the size of the service sector,even macroeconomic analysis can be seriously flawed when the specialnature of services is overlooked.
There is really just one characteristic of services that has attracted theattention of economists, and given rise to a substantial literature: theassumed much lower rate of productivity growth of services compared togoods. In this connection, however, too little account is taken to the fact thatthe heterogeneity of the service sector is great; it is misleading to treatservices, the service sector or the service industries as a reasonablyhomogeneous aggregate for economic analysis.
In accordance with the supply-side definition applied in the NationalAccounts, the service sector can be divided up in five sub-sectors which arevery different in some important respects for economic analysis: (1)
Distribution of goods; (2) Housing; (3) Business-to-business services; (4)User-financed consumer services; (5) Tax-financed consumer services.
(Jansson and Garzon, n.d.)
G. Sustainable Design
The natural resources presented to us by the earth are finite, meaning
somehow, sometime in the future this resources will come to an end, only if
we do not know how to maintain and take care of it. The question is how the
expanding built environment and human needs can cope up with the
resources given by our natural environment? Sustainable design is the
answer established by designers and architects.
A sustainable future, one in which humankind will have a place in theecosystem of the earth, depends on a fundamental reconsideration of howwe utilize all of the resources that support the qualities of our life. The earth
is essentially a finite system. The limits of nonrenewable resources areobvious. Renewable resources are limited by the rate at which they arereceived and by the environmental disruption caused by their capture anduse. There are limited amounts of ways the earth can accommodate beforeenvironmental conditions change to the point that current life patternsbecome untenable. Each new demand on limited resources creates additional
pressures on other critical areas. There is a finite amount of arable land onthe planet. We have already seen that initial, small steps from petroleum to
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
21/29
bio fuel produce dramatic effects on the coast and availability of food. Thereis no quick fix. There is no technological fix. What is required is a change inour fundamental approach to providing quality of life-from basic survival tothe highest planes of culture and spirit.
While advances in science and technology will certainly address many
of the problems we are now confronting as we move ever nearer to thelimiting conditions of resource availability, they will take decades toimplement and will have issues we do not yet fully understand. The onebroad strategy that can produce immediate, meaningful results is to do morewith less. This, in turn, requires we first be clear about what we need to domore of. A modernist perspective offers some guidelines.
(Carl Stein, 2010)
Conceptual Framework
Fig.1
Sustainable
Design
CONVENTION
CENTRE
Area 4
Convention
Area 1
Cinema
Area 2
Restaurant
Area 3
Cinema
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
22/29
Definition of Terms
Cinema- a theatre where films are shown for public entertainment
Convention- a meeting or formal assembly, as of representatives or
delegates, for discussion of and action on particular matters of
common concern.
Convention Centre- a large civic building or group of building designed for
conventions, industrial shows, and the like, having
Application of
Modernism
Sensual
Social
Visua
l
Tactil
e
Intelligent
Design
Solution
Indigenous CebuMaterials
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
23/29
large unobstructed exhibit areas and often including
conference rooms, hotel accommodations, restaurants,
and other facilities.
Green Design- Product design philosophy that treats environmental
attributes as designobjectives and not as constraints.
It aims at incorporating those attributes without
compromising performance, quality, functionality,
and the useful life of the item.
Lobby- a room providing a space out of which one or more other rooms or
corridors lead, typically one near the entrance of a public
building
Modern Style- The architecture, furniture and furnishings of today. Hence a
constantly changing style influenced by various
countries, new inventions, new materials, etc. Generally in
the 20th century, modern can be described as clean,
straight lines with simple refined curves and a
recognizably functional quality.
Sustainable Design- A process that maintains an ecological balance between
the natural and built environment
Recycle- convert (waste) into reusable material
Reduce- make smaller or less in amount, degree, or size
http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/product-design.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/environmental-attributes.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/environmental-attributes.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/design.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/objective.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/constraint.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/aim.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/attribute.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/product-design.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/environmental-attributes.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/environmental-attributes.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/design.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/objective.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/constraint.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/aim.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/attribute.html7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
24/29
Restaurant- a place where people pay to sit and eat meals that are cooked
and served on the premises
Reuse- use again or more than once
CHAPTER III
METHODOLOGY
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
25/29
This chapter will be containing discussions regarding the Research
Design, The Sample, The Instrument, the Data Collection Procedure used, and
lastly the Data Analysis Procedure used.
Research Design
The ideas and findings in this study are done using a descriptive
research method. This is to be able to present the public or the audience a
clear and well stated interpretations and processes.
The descriptive method is something more and beyond just data-gathering; the latter is not reflective thinking nor research. The true meaningof the data collected should be reponed from the point of view of theobjectives and the basic assumption of the project under way. This followslogically after careful classification of data. Facts obtained may be accurateexpressions of central tendency, or deviation, or of correlation; but the reportis not research unless discussion of those data is not carried up to the level ofadequate interpretation. Data must be subjected to the thinking process interms of ordered reasoning.
(Aquino, n.d.)
This studys aim is to create a sustainable space for conventions. The
researcher of this study is desires to explore the members or staff of the
convention centre. Information gathered are expected to present the
researcher accommodating inspirations and ideas she could apply in
designing the four (4) selected areas from the Convention Hall.
The Sample
Sampling may be defined as measuring a small portion of somethingand then making a general statement about the whole thing.
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
26/29
(Bradfield and Murdock, n.d.)
In requirement for the information needed in the process and
completion of this study, certain persons are to be interviewed by the
researcher to get further knowledge of the study. They are as follows; 20% of
the staff, or management including the convention manager and event
supervisor, and 10% of the public or the attendees population. Attendees
include persons that have attended and experienced trade shows,
conventions and expositions.
The Instrument
To gather relevant idea the study uses multi-method approach, books,
magazines, electronic sources, semi-structured interview using sets of tape
and transcribed structured questionnaire. Broad researches on the main
subjects; Sustainable, Green Design, Modernism and Convention Centre are
done through understanding and reading articles, researches, journals and
books containing further studies of the topics. Here are the primary questions
asked during the interview:
- What are your experiences in this industry?
- For you, how important is the convention industry today? Being 1 as
the lowest and 10 as the highest.
- Has sustainable design or eco design been introduced to your
industry?
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
27/29
- Do you think your establishment is helping Cebu City in promoting its
natural resources? In what way?
- Does your establishment provide environment friendly facilities and
amenities?
- Does your office provide you enough space? Does it provide you a
comfortable and productive ambiance?
- During event decorations, do you provide the materials or is it the
presenter or client?
- What is the most number of events you get in a month?
Data Collection Procedure
The field of conventions, exhibits and shows are not much away from
any field or job a person has. Almost all of us, even kids experience shows
and mostly expositions of many kinds. The method used in the completion of
this study includes extensive research through different sources, namely
books, journals, magazines, theses, encyclopedias and electronic sources.
Thoughts and knowledge coined from reviewing the said materials are
interpreted into words and put into design. This study has undergone
researches on better and sustainable materials and alternatives for
construction the Philippines can offer the construction industry.
Some of the main methods in completing this study are as follows;
getting a precise topic, determining the problem and the solution acquired,
gathering of information from books, literatures, journals, magazines and
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
28/29
from electronic sources in further understanding of the research topic,
formulation of questions for the interviewees as well as for the questionnaire
that are to be distributed and answered.
7/28/2019 Thesis in the Making
29/29
Name: ________________________________________________ Age:_______________
Occupation: __________________________________________
Answer the following questions precisely. Please check the box of your
answer.
1. How many conventions, trade shows, expos, exhibitions, launching events,
etc. have you already attended?
1 2 3 4 5 and more
2. Rank the following according to what you think is the most important (5),
important and least important (1) factors you consider during expos,
conventions, etc.
___Ventilation ___Ambiance ___Space Allocation ___Appearance of the
Area ___Lighting
3. During events, what do you think is more important to you?
Comfortable walk space or seating How healthy the area is
4. Rate how strong do you think lighting affects an exposition or a
convention, being 1 as the lowest and 5 as the highest.
1 2 3 4 5
5. Rate how strong do you think ventilation and color scheme affects your
mood and interest towards a current expo or convention, being 1 as the
lowest and 5 as the highest.
1 2 3 4 5