Upload
still-rage
View
224
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 1/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 1 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
•Subscribe•Renew•Give a Gift•Digital Edition
Skip Navigation
The Atlantic Home
Wednesday, December 7, 2011 SEARCH OUR SITE Go Follow the Atlantic »
PoliticsBusinessEntertainmentInternationalTechnologyNationalLifeMagazinevideo
Presented By
Caitlan Halligan Lost, and So Did You
Andrew Cohen
Huntsman Goes Squishy on Climate Change
Molly Ball
The Donald Trump Primary
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 2/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 2 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
Molly Ball
Presented By
Don't Celebrate Cheaper Oil
Derek Thompson
Who Doesn't Go Online for Fun? These people.
Derek Thompson
Who Killed the Postal Service?
Jordan Weissmann
Presented By
Amy Winehouse Lives On With 'Lioness'
Spencer Kornhaber
Should There Be Two Heisman Winners?
Allen Barra
TV's Most Memorable Human-Animal Pairings
Romy Oltuski
Presented By
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 3/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 3 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
Can Oxford Teach Your Dictator to Behave?
Robert M. Danin
Syria Is Stockpiling Chemical Weapons
Rachel Oswald
Anna Hazare's Plan for India
Jon Sawyer & Kem Knapp Sawyer
Presented By
Astronauts Enjoy a Different Kind of Levity
Rebecca J. Rosen
What Went Wrong With Gmail?
Alexis Madrigal
Library Wars: Amazon vs. Publishers
Peter Osnos
Presented By
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 4/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 4 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
How Many Experts Does it Take to Admit DNA Evidence?
Garrett Epps
An Original Newsreel of Pearl Harbor
Kasia Cieplak-Mayr von Baldegg
Why Innovation Can't Fix America's Classrooms
Marc Tucker
Presented By
How Forest FirefightingMay Be Harming Trees
Edward Tenner
What's Wrong Withthe Farm Bill?
Marion Nestle
Reflections of anAccidental AIDS Activist
Hans Villarica
Presented By
Our Pakistan Problem
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 5/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 5 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
Marc Ambinder and Jeffrey Goldberg
How Walmart Is Changing China
Orville Schell
Why Oprah Is Misunderstood
Caitlin Flanagan
Presented By
Time-Lapse of Oregon's Spectacular Landscapes
Kasia Cieplak-Mayr von Baldegg
NASA's Vintage Airstream Astrovan
Kasia Cieplak-Mayr von Baldegg
Time-Lapse of the Sky Every Day of the Year
Kasia Cieplak-Mayr von Baldegg
Derek Thompson - Derek Thompson is a senior editor at The Atlantic, where he oversees business coverage forthe website.More
He is a visiting research fellow at the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget at the New America
Foundation. Derek has also written for Slate, BusinessWeek , and the Daily Beast. He has appeared as a guest onradio and television networks, including NPR, the BBC, CNBC, and MSNBC.
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 6/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 6 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
All Posts dkthomp · 3,220 followers
Share
« Previous Thompson | Next Thompson » Email Print
This is Why You're Fat
By Derek Thompson
0 Jul 20 2009, 4:08 PM ET 10
Elizabeth Kolbert, writing in the New Yorker, asks a simple question: Why are we so fat? The short answer --We eat too damn much -- is unbefitting a proper New Yorker essay, and so we're served a long, fascinating look
at the literature of "weight-gain" books that aim to explain how Americans gained more than a billion pounds inthe last ten years. The most convincing answer I found is: Price and elasticity of appetite.
Kolbert, reviewing The Fattening of America by Eric Finkelstein and Laurie Zuckerman, notes that food hasgotten cheaper relative to the other goods and services. And fatty foods have gotten a lot cheaper. The price of soft drinks, for example, have dropped by more than 20 percent, and they now account for seven percent allcalories in the US. The New York Times offered a striking graph that told just that story:
7Recommend
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 7/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 7 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
But, Kolbert follows up with a good question: Sure, food became cheaper -- fatty food especially. But thatdoesn't mean our bellies had to grow at an equal and opposite pace. Why didn't we just spend less money eastingless? How did our appetites grow so suddenly in the 1980s and 90s?
The most convincing idea she floats is the "elasticity of the human appetite." Simply stated: We have no ideahow hungry we are, so we respond to growing portion sizes with growing appetites. In one depressingexperiment, participants ate bowls of pasta soup that were secretly being refilled through a hidden tube. Onaverage, people eating out of these "trick bowls" consumed 73 percent more than the regular bowl eaters.Somewhere between our brain and our stomach, the word "stop" is swallowed -- along with a lot of calories.
The elasticity of our appetites is perhaps most visible in our relationship with fast food and chain restaurants.McDonald's used to offer one size of french fries, with 200 calories. Now it also offers a large, with 500calories. This jives with a graph, also produced by the New York Times, that compares time spent eating andnational obesity.
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 8/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 8 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
The conclusion I would draw is not that you should spend more quality time with your Burger King QuadStacker. I'm more interested in the relationship between the fatter countries and fast-food proliferation. If youdraw a horizontal line just under Canada to isolate the countries with the highest obesity rates, you get a groupof six countries. Four of those countries -- the US, New Zealand, Australia and Canada -- happen to be the fourcountries with the most McDonald's per capita in the world (the UK is number 9). Our evolutionary instinct to
maximize caloric intake befriends our economic instinct to buy cheap, and the result is, well, something likethis.
*Thanks to Suzanna Pacaut for soup/pasta mixup. Pasta, in retrospect, could be prohibitively difficult to refillthrough a tube.
Share
Email Print
Presented by
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 9/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 9 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
Like
Sponsored Links
Elsewhere on the Web
More at The Atlantic
The War For Web Domination
What Went Wrong With Gmail?
What's the Greatest Modern Holiday Film?
The Lesson of Amy Winehouse's 'Lioness: Hidden Treasures'
The DNA Expert Debate
Join the Discussion
After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.
[what's this]
From credit crunch to oil rushes, keepahead of market trends with the BBC'sbusiness podcast (from BBC Podcast)
These 4 Things Happen Right Before aHeart Attack (from Newsmax.com)
Why Is China Building These GiganticStructures In the Middle of the Desert?(from Wired)
If You Own One of These Popular High-Yielders, Pay Attention (from Global Dividends)
Are You Trying to Appear Richer thanYou Are? (from Coupon Shoe Box)
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 10/18
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 11/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 11 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
3. No, I'm not dense enough to think that beer is more healthful than an avocado for the sole reason of their relative fat content, but
apparently you are dense enough to not realize that I was simply pointing that healthfulness and non-fattiness are not the same thing, not
that healthfulness and fattiness are positively correlated.
Any further questions?
Like
There are really two separate questions involved in this issue, and one cannot be answered without addressing the other. First, individuals get fat
because they eat too many calories and don't burn them off. (Not to downplay the importance of macronutrient ratio.) Of course, those in the "fat
acceptance" crowd wish to obfuscate this simple truth and decry the notion that impulsive gluttony combined with physical sloth is the root of the
problem. But that does not negate reality. The second question--why is the average American's waistline increasing--must be analyzed through
the lens of the first answer. Rephrased, the question becomes: Why is the average American amassing a surplus of caloric energy? I'm quite
certain the answer has much more to do with most Americans' general lack of self-control combined with inaccurate health education and the
crack-pusher style antics of the food industry than it does with elastic appetites. Magic soup bowls aside, if you don't realize that a super-sized
Wendy's Baconator meal exceeds any reasonable bounds of caloric necessity, evolutionary survival instincts are the least of your problems.
Henry Rollins's 7 word diet would go a long way to solving this problem: eat better, eat less, move your body.
Like
Sure, but it's also important to keep in mind that there isn't necessarily an independent relationship between calories consumed and
calories burned. If people worked like bonfires, you could throw a lot more fuel on the fire (eat more) and have the fire burn hotter and
faster (burn more). Of course, people aren't bonfires, but their metabolism is complex and affected at least somewhat by their food
intake.
Like
Draw a line through Canada just because that's where we choose to draw the line. The countries above the line have more vowels in their names
than those below. QED.
Like
Oh come now, tcrosse. It's not like I'm drawing a 45 degree angle through the graph and excluding the states that rhyme with "ania." The
point is simple enough: Of the six fattest countries in the world, four have the world's highest McDonald's per capita. If you find the fact
redundant -- Duh, Derek, of course countries with significant Anglican ties will be the fattest! -- then I'd love to hear your reasons.
Otherwise, I don't think I'm exaggerating the role of cheap, fatty food on our fatness, and McDonald's density seems to me like an un-
silly proxy of cheap, fatty food.
Like
What I don’t see addressed in this article is the disparate impact these food costs have on lower income Americans. If the lower-cost foods have
the worse nutritional make-up, it’s no surprise that the poorer Americans who buy those foods are generally the fattest and unhealthiest.
Reply
2 years agoTyler
Reply
2 years agoJoshua Lyle
Reply
2 years agotcrosse
Reply
2 years agoDerek Thompson
Reply
2 years ago jwescott
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 12/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 12 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
I’ve seen several ‘nutrition makeovers’ on programs like the Today Show trying to address the rapidly expanding waistlines of the average
American family. They take lower-income families who are living on fast food and revamp their lifestyle to include more fresh produce, whole
grains, beans, etc. The families are always assured that preparing their own healthy foods at home will save them money in the long run.
I’ve always wondered how that could possibly be the case, and this article only strengthens my skepticism. When a parent could spend $3-4 on a
red bell pepper that would buy their child an entire meal at Taco Bell, it’s no surprise they choose the latter.
Like
As the old saying goes, your eyes are usually more hungry than our bellies.
We need to consciously stop over-feeding ourselves just because of the availability of food. Fast food sells by duping hungry customers that
they need that much food to be content. Unfortunately, not many can put down the burger and fries despite being full.
Eating less fatty and more nutritious foods will leave you feeling more content and less likely to over-feed yourself.
If you're interested in learning about how to Value [the] meal check out http://valuethemeal.blogspot.com
Like
Comments powered by DISQUS
Derek Thompson's Archive
Recent PostsBy SourceBy DateSpecial Report
Wikimedia
What's On Evan Williams's Wish List?See what the Twitter co-founder and others are eying this season in our Holiday Gift Guide.
Read more ›
Reply
2 years agogeetha
Reply
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 13/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 13 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
Just In
Maria Popova6:12 PM ET
Inside the Sketchbooks of the World's Greatest Type Designers
Voices
James Fallows
Now It's the Administration's Turn to Be…
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 14/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 14 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
5:30 PM ET
Megan McArdle
In Defense of Kitchen Gadgets
11:43 AM ET
Ta-Nehisi Coates
HHS Rules On Over-the-Counter Morning-After Pill
2:31 PM ET
Jeffrey Goldberg
Avigdor Lieberman Rises to Putin's Defense (of…
3:46 PM ET
Alexis Madrigal
What Went Wrong With Gmail?
Dec 6, 2011
Steve Clemons
Property Rights and the Arab Spring
11:44 AM ET
Derek Thompson
Is Christmas Bad for the Economy?
2:28 PM ET
Clive Crook
Divided We Stand: Why Inequality Keeps Rising
Dec 6, 2011
Correspondents
Garrett Epps
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 15/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 15 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
How Many DNA Techs Does It Take to Admit DNA Evidence?
Edward Tenner
Why Newt Gingrich's Ph.D. Thesis Doesn't Matter
Peter Osnos
Library Wars: Amazon and Publishers Vie for Control of E-Book Rentals
View All Correspondents
The Biggest Story in Photos
2011: The Year in Photos, Part 2 of 3 Dec. 7 2011
what matters now in business
Stephen Glass's Weird Childhood Stories Are Not Legal Qualifications
Stanley McChrystal Is Teaching AOL How to Win
A Guardian Photo Flub Replaces Canada's Maple Leaf with Pot
Last Update: 5:20 PM
Cape Town, Design Capital
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 16/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 16 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
Ramallah's Art Scene Comes Home
The Return of the Village Post Office
Last Update: 6:11 PM
Subscribe Now
SAVE 59%! 10 issues JUST $2.45 PER COPY
NAME
ADDRESS 1
ADDRESS 2
CITY
STATE ZIP
Subscribe
AccediDevi eseguire l'accesso a Facebook per
vedere le ultime attività dei tuoi amici.
Organic Can Feed the World
2.695 persone consigliano questo
elemento.
Why Innovation Can't Fix America's
Classrooms687 persone consigliano questo elemento.
Why A Newt Gingrich Candidacy Would
Doom the Tea Party
519 persone consigliano questo elemento.
2011: The Year in Photos, Part 1 of 3 -
Alan Taylor - In Focus - The Atlantic
839 persone consigliano questo elemento.
Plug-in sociale di Facebook
Newsletters
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 17/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 17 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
Sign up to receive our three free newsletters
This Week on TheAtlantic.com (sample)
This Month in The Atlantic (sample)
5 Best Columns from The Atlantic Wire (sample)
I want to receive updates from our partners and sponsors
EMAIL Submit
Most Popular
12011: The Year in Photos, Part 2 of 3
2National Geographic Photo Contest 2011
32011: The Year in Photos, Part 1 of 3
4World War II: After the War
5A Russian Awakening?
6All the Single Ladies
7Why a Newt Gingrich Candidacy Would Doom the Tea Party
8 The 10 Worst-Performing States in America9
Occupy Big Business: The Sharing Economy's Quiet Revolution10
What Went Wrong With Gmail?
Subscribe HelpFaqFollow the AtlanticMasthead
StoreMerchandiseJobsEducational ProgramPrivacy Policy
Site MapTerms & ConditionsAdvertisePressContact Us
Special ReportsAtlantic Scene Atlantic.Live
8/3/2019 This is Why You'Re Fat
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/this-is-why-youre-fat 18/18
08/12/11 01.02This is Why You're Fat - Derek Thompson - Business - The Atlantic
Pagina 18 di 18http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2009/07/this-is-why-youre-fat/21684/
Copyright © 2011 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All Rights Reserved.CDN powered by Edgecast Networks.