Upload
zahid-mashhood
View
53
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Three Giants of SothAsiaGhandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination.
Citation preview
2004
Three Giants of South Asia: Gandhi, Ambedkar andJinnah on Self - Determination
Prof. Richard Bonney
EditorProf. Richard Bonney
First Published byUniversity of LeicesterCentre for the History of Religious and Political PluralismInstitute for the Study of Indo-Pakistan RelationsLeicester, LE1 7RH, UK
All rights reserved to the Author andCentre for the History of Religious and Political PluralismInstitute for the Study of Indo-Pakistan RelationsLeicester, LE1 7RH, UK
Published in India by:Media House375-A, Pocket 2, Mayur Vihar Phase-I, Delhi - 110 091, IndiaPh: 011-22750667, 22751317, Fax: 011-22757040E-mail: [email protected], [email protected]: www.mediabooks.org
Printed at:Jyoti Printers, E-94, Sector-6, Noida
ISBN:
Media HouseDelhi2004
Professor Richard Bonney4
!"
#$#%&'$ # ' ' % ()**+,'
-# %%./#'#%
0$)1+
' '+
G46##'''+&33$%'%#+'''##'+
'%
%'' 0101# %'' +&()**
%%#%
#''-
0 $ (4 ' ()**1 % 5'$! ' %6()78%'
''''
%''+%5%!+%
'%9'#
'$''+
Professor Richard Bonney6
&&,
&%$%''+ % % % :&''
5'!0++;!'10()*8
7 8Introduction to the Indian Edition of Three Giants of South Asia Professor Richard Bonney
.!@3%.>5%%%%&!+*>
9 1 0Introduction to the Indian Edition of Three Giants of South Asia Professor Richard Bonney
'''''#>'##$
=+H
#''$O+=+O$
%
=P6%-=$0-()**!%7E1%$
'9!#%=
.
& $ $ %+ & &
()(A&%#'$#
&%% #=/# # ()78F()@8+
. # ' 9
%$$ % % # + 1 2 2 3 2 2 4 2 1 5 "& N '' ' # % % % +
M # % $ $ %+
N
P6 %
&'''
''#+
#%''
$#:%#%#&$+='' % & . /#+ ##&.%
:%$'
$#&.+%%5
1211Introduction to the Indian Edition of Three Giants of South Asia Professor Richard Bonney
59#'!%#5#-#'%S!(@ '# T &'#;
$%!''+;
13 14Introduction to the Indian Edition of Three Giants of South Asia Professor Richard Bonney
% $ $ % # '+-'' 5%'% -#J !K!%'%5
!+78N'%9$''-''%$5'#$ &!:-'' 5#&%$!+='7).()*75#+#$+N
,9$--+!7(./#'-''
-# + =.% % #$ 5# '$&!%
%9'+ %9'%!'5$$&!%%.()*7%'
-''
%5'
16 Professor Richard Bonney
5'%#'.'$%!+74
+ + ; > -'' #%-#()*A+5-''%$$J;K&
# ! +5#$:%
%Q#R'+!$
5#!8-#6-.''%+%-##5-#
$ %# ' '$ #'#!+-7H
& % % '% $ ' # 9 $ 3#-#!9'#% # '#
+ 5 ! 5## # /# -# #
'# '+! -'' > % #
%
% '+
'
-#;%'%$#'+-''''%' # ''.&+@70
74 &+ *AE+7H &+ *E4+7) &+ *E8F(+
@8 &+ *(E+@( &+ **E+ & -'' 0+ *@(1 5%
# # & $ % /# % $-#%%-#$%$/#+!%%$'' ' 6+
@7 &+7H4+-!=-((. ()*7 ' 5 =6 # # % .
# '!+ & $% .&:%
Introduction to the Indian Edition of Three Giants of South Asia 15
17 18Introduction to the Indian Edition of Three Giants of South Asia Professor Ram Puniyani
$ '' >'5'-!
+'9$%@@#$6#$%##.'$1+
+1
$' #'##'':
$ ' % %>'% '' ## >'#
+#
% % $+@*
% 9 >'$./# % # # #-+=# # $ +#''$
2019Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination: Introduction Professor Richard Bonney
5&7(%%#'$#+%
#+!%#
G46 &- # %%#>$& = # .&-=#+ ' #C;M
=#--'#'$C;+(
C;@(.7887 P '+7,77.7888.#''''
''#'+@
;#'$
&%P#'
&C5'!+'$C&0''$1%'C'#+$%,C++P ' %
2221Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination: Introduction Professor Richard Bonney
$'$$ &'E % '# .''#
#
'+ '' 5$$&!''
'%##%'' &+ '' $%''+
N''%$+4M$''#'.###()**+.+;#$
#+ ## %'$+
##'%.
' .B6'
&.+##+%'''
# %'
$+
%' % ''%-#./#+#'%%+&-()*4.'
'%%&+
5#!%5'#+&
$'#+!&'$(7()*H5%#$
&'%&=&+
2423Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination: Introduction Professor Richard Bonney
#%$+.=
25 26Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination: Introduction Professor Richard Bonney
()@8+ C % 5''>%=.#.QR!+5%
$ $=F.#+=##=F.'>6''$&!#!+G46=5./#'%#P$%
-#'$!+#%
-#5=.# '' % + & ./#'$#%=.%$#JK% % '' =F.''+!(*
%$%'9'$ 9$+ G46 &$+%%$
#%'''##$+'()@8$+9'()*4%$%5!5'9#'6+!(EG469'
%''6'$#%;B+P+P.-''-''!5%!G46()@H%'''
-+(A%9%&
$#$
0&1-%()74()@80'##%&1+-''M
()*75%#'$$!
!%5!G46()@H+(4%./#''+&-$$'
/ ' ()78 ''&+(H
%%+/&JK-#(H)A5#
091!9''%$%
#+!;%/()
(* .+ = 0 $%%'$&A/ 0. ())*1 7H7F)@ '+ 7HH 7)7F@+
(E &+ 7H@+(A + + . B B" 4
0M9 ()H@1 4* @E8+
(4 + + .
$&A&$&-' 0M9()4)1$+%#$ % + " 5 2 0 788(1 (() (@8+ # 5 % 9 / #$ %
&! 5 ;!'L ; %# -''
$ $# $Y$ +;%%'
% JK J% K>L # # % $ %;0B+P+P.1 -# .+ " ; "!
(H . B B A+() B+&+/*900()(H1
( 5 ''
' +! 5LQ R .9! #
' $% $ # ' ' !G%%%+9+#D$DD%D()(*DD8(+I - '' ##%
%#.=+
% # /! '
2827Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination: Introduction Professor Richard Bonney
78 %
$
%#5%$#->>JK
%!+5#!
#%$#$'''+5##
3029Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination: Introduction Professor Richard Bonney
' ,' # #'
% + % % ''$#+ &- ,,'%$ % ' # $ %+
' + &
'% ' $: -
, ,' % ' +
-9%5'!,,' ,'%%'$0'%++5''$
!1+ =%$ # G46$%,'$##5' $ $
' ' # %$D$D9$!+-[P#7*
9 ' '%:%$$ 6 # ' # # >
' + M $ '' $ :% ''
$ # ' ' ' L - $ 6
#
#
:
'$#
%
# ' 9'
' $# +
$.5''%''#!%&%> 5#$#'05''!1$
'#>#'!+'5'$'
!+-##5''! 5! P # 5## ###!+
'%% #'# 5''! % 5!+&$#%6C; > 5 ''+&%''%''!+7E'%
&.&
3231Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination: Introduction Professor Richard Bonney
#+5=$%##'C=%
3&,#+!74 ,$%% ' C %# '6+7H%$##5% % &% ' '#+%
L!0$1+&()@H=' '$ -#0 1+ C 5##%$$''$##$
''!+&!C5$%$%%##.+@* / &% # 5.#$!%5''#&%,'
!+@E %#()()% $ #
''$+@A&%''#
#%5##!'#
##$#%##$#%%
'-#0%#9()7)1@4%'
74 G46
3433Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination: Introduction Professor Richard Bonney
#5'$$&;-#%###'+=6#'%J;K $ %+!@H #$&
'
$###:@)'#-# # # : $%#'#'+&
$''-#%'%+*8
#%'#()()F77()7)F@*()@)F**%#'
''+,%/%5%''#&! 3 %
()(): -()74:B!
&%% ()@)+!*( %' # *7
'##+*@
$ %$ # $''#'#%#+
%'&'''
()*8'''$
%5
##'%!5
%$''!&+**&%6$#$'$%'5%'!%
##$
%+#%#$.
%'%%%5#'%&!!+*E##-#P -'% #'%''%&5''!+=# $ % 5 #$ # '
%&%'#&!+*A
-!''$F- - # # ()*(
+&''& ' ,'+ 5'#$ $ #$##''%%#%!#%
',';>+*4
'65'&%$'
&!%!+*H&'&'$
-!'-''%%#''$#,'+*)
'
&+ $&()(E %
%$%%' % & '+ % 4 *+
@H /% ? 0 A)+@) &+(*(+&%A'()@(5
9' L ''# J-#K % '!+ 6 # 5' %!+
*8 &+ (H@+*( &+ (H8F(+*7 -#()():F&%()@8:
-'' # ()*7+*@ P$()78F7-$
$ ()@7: 5T &! '# ()*7+
** .
*@+*E +>$#98"2?2
$&AD$&-A 0/ ()4H1 (EH+*A &+ (4*FE+*4 .
*7+*H &+ *)+*) >$ #98 (4E+
3635Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination: Introduction Professor Richard Bonney
%%C%%#+
#'()*75.&% # !%%'%'+M''.#/()*8%#.5%.'$'!$#5#%&
!+G46
/%#5$!5##!+E8M$#%5%%'!5'$ ' ' 9'$%% % % ' #'-+!E(
.5%
3837Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney
'9'%,#+!4
% % #'$%'%%
%-#(HHE+&5#.!'$6#-#%$##$#+P0(H(4F)H1.#M0.M1-#(H4E%#C$()78H% #
@ $%.($&'$ = 0O# ()AA1+?92 ' -++$: % - # : ++ P+ 0 ()471+
* 5# & ! H*+E -++ G46 0 0@
-# ()*41 (E@+A 5# & ! )(+
4 9 E " @9 5""$&/($&(.+P+P+>>0/;%N ())H1 @EEF4+
H #&./#()(8G46+-++9 5" , 4; 5 $%D/$&(A 0-#()4*1 ())+
4039Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney
B!-(H4H+
# $% ' 5J.K!%#'%=. ##P!#()8A+)
M(M()8A%' /.B&0()8EF(81$.#P01+ # ' & '5L'L$%%''L%#%$#%'&'!+'.'$#$ %#5%#%' '$
%,'!+()8(%$A7.5#
4241Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney
' ' + #% ' % '
#''$$#'%'''' % +
% % = .+ $ $$ %$# % & '# # '# % ' # - =+ $
9#
#9$''% ' %%%' # 9 +& =6% 6 % ' # 9 ' ' $
'L
;%''#=%'
' # % #># .#$# # 6 + ' % & #>
' % #
JK
$% #
% . $ L
#P5%
''!
0(H*)F()7H:% &1 + &
)()8)#59#'##
#%''J6K L % #'!+.%$E@:5'
%6#!+(*&5%;%&! %
&./#@8()8A+(4.%$%+#P5
%&%#
!'
$+(H
(* 5 >@9 2 ++> 0/ ()AH1 @@EF)+
(E &+ 7A7F@+(A &+)7(+(4 .+ =0 $&$D
$&(% 0 ()4)1 E8F( J =0()4)1K+ 6$ /# % 51 '#J.K $ $' #$%#: 1 ' $ ' # J.K & '
'
' $: 1 '$
# J.K & #
% % '6 6 #! 4 0 9(E)+ G46 # P! 9' ()E* 9 E + >>+(48F( ' % 5%% .! $% /# %5$# # ! /# %
4443Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney
%&P6()%''
. 5! ' # % $# # 5& #!+ 6&.%''#78%+0&6!'5
%7%#6
+=/##QMM'R+!17(6
./#()(@
% '6 ' ' -#:77 #% $
-#'P+
4645Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney
# ' '
# %
$ +7A
.F.'# & ' '' '+=#B&0()8AF(81%#>'#5&!74
()(7 5.#$'#.&%%'#L $'#.L!7H
9'->!$#()8E
%'5
'!+G46 5%$!:%#.#'#'+!7).$
% ' && '%''%+665%%()@)$%'. /# % %
47 48Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney
=.1
%''
59$# %.##'#$!.F.+@*,$='%'%5$' % '' %
!+6-#(H)E()87$% -# ()8) %59$'''#$%'#J++.K:JK6$#%.. 6L
5049Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney
'#''$''()(A/%%.=5''#6!+*8
,.6#
.5%%'!-## % ' '6 . '' 5%! 5%!+*($%'%#.$#%
'%=##$%%$59'
!+.>=
= /# %-#()(E% %%=F.()(E()(A#/%+
%=.%%()(E+;%#*E&./#'
#$5#!%+&;-##P''#'9'#' % /# ' '
' %# ' $ L -# % ' 9' /#
%$$ ' 6
5251Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney
''%+ $%%+*A
%;&./#/%()(A
5'$!48&.+$5'
#!''
%
+ 5&! ,''+'$
% 'L
5-#
#'!5$!+=%$'5'!%5#'%!%$./#%%5##'#%#'%C&!+ = # $ $# $ ' ' $ ' $
+ J.K &
#
5453Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney
' % # ' '
# % #% ' %
%
5655Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney
$
# ' %$LL'' ''$ =F.
+
%''$ 5#
##!5.!0!%'1#'5.>>&!+E@6;#%()78
H;$()7)E*
/ $# & % # # % .+
%#' '
' '
' & # -+ .+
$ ' ' B% %# %
% '%+ M '
# %##
-+
5857Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney
#%'#
#!+A8%$%-#5.'
59 60Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney
'> $ # # %
=47%#!$% % % $ '+ & ' % # 9' % $
% . '' '
% . +
G46'$ $ 5 # '#$!+4@ & $ # =%=6#
$#'4*
% # ##%##%%%%+%'#+=%$$0
6(@'()()#%#1
,'%5
+&*4+2!+ % 2+ 0 1 '%%*4+2*+2+*+2%
8+5%#8+%%
+!4EM# 5%%*4+2%$*+2'$!+4A* 2 ()@8%=.#
P$%5#! #$ & % 5!+44
#'%&&' $ % %4H
& % + . = . + $ %6 . 6 #
% . & % . '% . ' &+. = # $%#6%+
' ! '+ & $ '% ' +##'%'+$ #+ $ % = $ #
6261Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney
: % $ # J%K
:%%$%
% P+
% '5'> '! . ' '+H8ME;$()78-
H(
L % #$ .' #
% # 6 % += 9 . $ ' # % '# % $L % '' ' ' # '
' 8++
6463 Professor Richard BonneyGandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination
'9+&>295$%!58+;%##$%+ # 296$#"G465!'%+=''+!HH!%%'''%''%#%%#+''%5=.!()():.()77%'
'$
%#--%#%;% 60
5'#--!1:H)7@.()77:)8
65 Professor Richard BonneyGandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination 66
#$#%%$6 $%#'+&%$ '%-# '# ()78%%%=.'+C-##>=69 ' =+ % %#=#%;
#'+;'!'$#-#%#%=$$#%%''%=+!
*+20#!1-#'!#%.?05=
.!$=#P1%'$./#$#9$=-#0
1+?%#%$-#@(()7H%%$ )E #%'-#=.9+'$
#=F.
5'!!:%5''!+)A&.!%5=#$%!''%6=F.!+
#5%#%
%.%$
.'%'=+!)4
=-/#$.- ;$()7A%'='''$#%#.$'#+)H#
&=/##%()M()78))
& 5% !'#& & ' & $
L $ 'JK $JK $
$ '' : ' # = . %==..$%
: L 9 '# # 9' # + ' #> L & % ##''
+
='
# 5 #$!+ 6 #!5%$%
!+(88'
!5'$!:'$%5'$'''!:''%'
'+5 $!$ 5 % $
)E % 4 @H+)A &+ 7*+ 9+ *4A (+ ()74+)4 + . 5 0/ ()AH1 74A+
67 Professor Richard BonneyGandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination 68
'#+!(8( &
69 Professor Richard BonneyGandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination 70
+7*()7@
5.##!%5!%=.'..5.#$'
#%=.+!= #> # 5 #!+ % ()7A %$+
...$''=$$#'=#+==%$5#.!:%%$%5'$JK#=!+((8&.()7A
.#= $
%':=%5$
9'=
=!+(((#%9
'' % % + .$%
= . $ %% $ ' +'
% $
9#$'%+()7@#%+ & ()7* #;+P; G46$ = '' % $+ ()7E % #''
#+ & ' ()7A # -
((8 &+ (A7+((( &+ (A4+((7 &+ (EH+((@ &+ (47+((* = 0())*1 7H8+
((E 15 * ? ((H+((A 4(A@F(H*+T
C
71 Professor Richard BonneyGandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination 72
%# %$ %*8 #
()4 ' 6 (A88+(()
73 Professor Richard BonneyGandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination 74
%#
+!(7E*2 ()@85
()74 > + HA*+
(7A * 2 + 7E4+(74 % 4 (7+(7H G46 # '
' + B B 4 #"1 5 0;%=$ / 78871+
(7) >C
75 Professor Richard BonneyGandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination 76
%''./#-'$#P @( ()7H+ # P ;'+(@@%6;'(@*
# $ & '
# % + % #L $%
-%$$$ '$
. &L
& ' . $ '' ' & ' '$ % =L & % ''#$# # ' . JK % L
' $
9 + & # '
5!&'#. & ' ' JK''L #L $L '% ,'+
$ L '. ##$#+=% ' .'' $ %
'6+
-( ()7)%
' % %
.'$%
+(@E - ##'
5 ' .%''#$''!:(@A
% # %
%% %
'> # ' %
LM6
77 Professor Richard BonneyGandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination 78
%'%$
'$+(@)
$'!G46.'*'()@(+=%#
.'$%#5
79 Professor Richard BonneyGandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination 80
G46 & %
# 3 ' %$6.''+% $ % % ' ' ' + % # % & 9' ,' -
+%
'% '
+
* / % -()@@F()*8
% . #+
.5!#0#1 '+%
'$.6''
#'
#''
'$':9%$
#'+ % # $ '6+=%$#()*8
/%'+M%/%''%%##>%5&%% #$ !+(*H
##
=.%%'5!+#%'6P%P9#(*)%%
.,-#(HHA0(H)8-%
#%&;-#1+&
%%'#$
5#%!%#5''%!+
%.%6-#'
%.6#> (*. (HHH+(E8 %# -#'
% %
' '' #'+$% . # '.+(E(=''-#(HHH#&%%'.=%%''-#+
' % %&'+#'.%#+5!%-'''()@@0804+/#%%%
'$%%
.+(E75!%
(*H E4+(*) $ 5
7EF*H+
(E8 4 0 9(*H+ E7 + @8+
9 +
(E( 4 0 9(*)+(E7 5QR C%+ & '
3Q&R QR+ 6 # 0; G46$1P&0#PP%1#+&
3 ' ' + & > #'':
# G46+ &
##:
'+ % % $ ' % $ # $ # # ' #'+!-++ G46
81 Professor Richard BonneyGandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination 82
5! '% 5#!+'
()@@'
;.$+ '$ &./#9'$
-
&-'#%5!'!+(E@
=%$##%#.+
%.P%$;
G46-
()7@ J.K % $ '
J=K.7@J=K#.+$%' & J-' -K #
J=K # % .+(E*
%#.=. % = % 0=F.1'&%#>:=.6'$%%6:% ' #$
'#=.+%&&+/=//6'''#&=.+(EE. &% # 6,#'&5'.!+(EA
%!%=''''%%-
!'5$'#!+
$.%.&
83 Professor Richard BonneyGandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination 84
'#>%#$''$#
$#.
!+ $' %%5'%.L&$%$'.%'&+'&$ $%%
##'=F.L!(E)
&
85 Professor Richard BonneyGandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination 86
/#+!%
5
$#%
'%#$#.%%.=+!#-!()*8%5!%$+#M()*75%$J=K$ J=K
#+ G46 # %#!+(A*
# - $'# '9 .%%'$#
=6%&%'+$$;.$#$%.'
#+ 5 ! $ #(88.0##%)8(AE1%%6+(AA%
'%>+.' % ' >
%$''-#
./#+
'##.'-# % % 5! .()*8%/+&
$##'& # % 5
''! J - K(A4L & %% ' & ' + ,$ % # # % ' % %
% % % % /
+(AH
;%'>/ %' % % ' J.K # %#'' ##' # #%%6 % . 6 % > & #' 5' ! % $#L
'$ $ #%5!+%% / %#
$ ' # / ./#%##>'
''#+%;%%##./#!5#%L!=
(A* &+ 7A4+(AE N + (@7A+(AA G460@4@+
% # M
87Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination 88 Professor Richard Bonney
%
%.5./#+%
% -# #$+(48%' .(4( 5 !(47 -#0;15%.%!(4@
5'$#!+=;!%=F. =
Professor Richard BonneyGandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination 9089
' ' -# ' #
' # . & '# '% 9$ =: $ #$9'$%6
$%'#% . 9' 6
' + $ % 6%$ '%
. /# ' ## '#+
% 6 ' %''# : %#$%+ ''#% % '+
& . /#
# # .
$+ ''+
+%./# % $ '
-#L -#
' # # % .
$ % .
+ & # $ + $ % %# $ % #+ #
% #$ L
% > $ $$
+## # '% $ # 9 $ 3 # $# # $# '
# #
$ %#% ' # % $ ## & %+ ,# . &
$# + $ L
5#.P>+ !0M1+%>!P
$ % ' #$
' 9 $'
'=.+.+ " 99+ **A+ ' (E G46+ ()@H5; ' # $: $
&!%' $ +! &+ 99+ E8@+. 4 E)FA8+
(H@ 0(()@41 5 $
% -# % .%%% # # $ !+N + E(@+ & #>9 $&AD$&-. 0 ()H4 '+ ())41 *(+=%$ B / /#% ' #.6=.
5$'=!= 5&! ; + = (@+
(H*
-#-## && % ,.'&(HE>%'.%''-#+& ' % . 5 !$()@4FH$%.
-#+(HA.()*7#>6 %% ' % 5$# % 9' %%+%%$%%''%'+
$%%+ $
%.%##++%$9'%+!(H4
#%7H'()@H$
#'01+'
./#
-#5#=!#
5'#-#=6&!+-$-#
5#>G46
!+(HH
; 5 =!(H) -% % '%./#''#+ %#%6
!'%./#''# ;> 05 % .$=!1 5. /# $
!+()8 =()(
& % = -# 5 &!+ &
= % $ '
+()7&%'>
% % : #
(HE P> 0(HHHF()EH1 6,9 5 5 7()FE@+ = ' 7@M()*4$>! % 5 " &
#+&'''$+&%$%
#+&$6 +
' #
$%'&%'$##L 9 L & % + % #
% $ $%$%%L&.
./#!#'L! + O @9 4" 9 15 * 0 ())A1 H4FH+ > $ ' % 5$! 5 $ ' ''!+ 5=# &! ! ; + =(74+
(HA .+ = 5.. - -'# # ' >! ; + =(@@F(E)+=-#'''% 5$## $$ ' . !+
(H4 999+ )* E. ()*7+ $ 56 % . # /#
$ %+ ' . '' ' $+&
J K $ % # + =% $"! ! ' %
5 #%+
% #%
+ & ' . $ % $$ % % +!
(HH .4 A7+N +)8EF(H'+ +)(*+G46 "
5 #9 $&/D$&-." + > @87F(( 0% # C 1+ $ '
'
+
(H) >9780()@41
()8 -% 5 7)E+()( &+ 7)EF@88 '+()7 =%$ # 5& ##
=$&
$
% L
-#% + & ()@H /# 5''!
.
' -# '$ #$+ M(7()@)%#$$ #98 (8(F7+()4 & #>9 @@+
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney93 94
>#./#()H
# % . J -K % % $ # .% ()@7
%
+ ''$% .+%##
. ' + & $
%%.+-#()@H.+ % % + $ ' '%; .+ $ $ ;
.++ = #$ %# #
'
'+ #$# % 5! % # L # ' $ %+ & T> # & % & % % 5/# /$ T> +! G46 % $ # '
$# % & % #+
##'%#'+&
%'5$###%
#!'.
+
&%5' = . # %6L!G46''$ . $ =5#'$ # !+78* & ' 7G46 ()*8 5 %'4!+ #-
&./##$6#G46#-
$
/#%$%##&.78E
(+ .&%)8''' # % ' +
7+ . & #
'9# ' $ 9'+
@+ . #
$.$' ' +
*+ . $# &
. # '$# #+
E+ & #%
'' &.
$ 6$+
9###%!%%''
&'$%.%.6'$:..'$$%#%
+ 5#!%'=.
E / %;.()*8
& . .$+ ; & #+ &%
& ' % + . & %
=$ % / #
&" # &" #
$ ' .+
6#'+78)
% #'+%' +=#$'55#!%!'#+5'+&+&'+=+!7((
.%()@A()*8#'$#
'5#!0C#
+ ;$ %.+ += +9 ' '% % % #
+ .+ % $ % $ $' '#.+ # = P%%%.+/++''
$'+&
! AG46 ()*81+
7(@ + ,9 5 5 7*@+7(* ' % &
$ & '' &+% & E"#+ & .+ % P# = &B G46L % . = &B $ # ;>%..++:>+$$% #.+ ' #%#%$#'#
. #' ' '+
# +++7(E
;.%$.!$%'$ % 5C!+;$!'%=&BG46%''
#$%#%'.''+B//#%9'H'()*(%5!%.+7(A%#'
!'>.''' +
'
'+ B %$ $'+ # % #
6 #%# JK '
#$ +
= ' 9' C&->$+= % ##' &%%#
$ % $ $ #+ ' $ #
$# + /% # ' $ & + ' &%9
# ' #$
% % % %$ $ % #
# & % $ = & .&+ ' &
. 6 ; , O & #' 5&'! % -C $#:
*+
'>%.''#'% #># % #
%.F0%%1+77*&M()@)''- $% B+77E#
'' $# ''''
'()@777A
'-#%=
+=6!'5!5!01+1+ -#
#1+()@H '' # # %
+(@M()@E#=9#'-$=#+=%'5&%=&%=+!774
()*8$-#''$%'+#>%# 5'/#/QR!+77H%5'''6!$#5'
#'!+&'%%(()*E5
6%#%$#!%%5'%!+77)
%'7H()*8+7@8#/% . /#
+ % ' ' % ''
'% $ + M $
' .
'#'$
& $ % % ' 6
' '' )8 '++ JK . &+ &$ ''
''
# 6# +7@(
'%%=.$
5%&$%'%' = % # # '-##
$% ,'!+= 5 $!+7@7. '$ '' +;#7@@
&%#''
% $ #+ # # #
+ # -$ & % # #' #% # %' ' &+;% '
# # $# '
+ % # # '% $# + '' $
# ''
$ +
##.#/+ %
./##"&
.%01$%#: 01.% # $ % '. '01.$'$019'%=
%6.#
% > +7@*
/ '#
'.& % % $ ()(7=+7E+5'# .6 # =6% # $ '$
#'
' % $ + ' ' . ' 9$ # = # ! /+ + 5$ # ' ()*4 ! ; + = 7HA+
7@4 7H+7@H &+ @8+
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney109 110
# % % #"5' # # $ = J.K'##+''#''
'%JK
#
L!#5'
%$#'+'#
#$''#$'#+'' $+&=$%=J.K
#+ ''L!7@).'#$''$
5#$$
=6!+%
-##$='$$5'
-#!+
!'
% . 77()@)$$-#6#$
'$+&$%%
%-#
#>./#'$ .: -# . -#$+M'-#%'''./#.'#>;.C+%'./#'$.+&!$%-#%#'#+ 5%
'$+
-#$.9'+.#'
-#
'$#%$%
%+!7*8
M'-##.'$#'6 -# # -# '#+=%$%-#%%''%#'#-#'#+.%5%#'"!7*(=7*7
-# =# - $% . +
#'6 '$ %L
'% $# '
9+ ' = ' % ;> +% =% # $ # ' ' .
; +
''%$''+#5L$+&$%%$
+!7*4-%%%5!7*H
'#."= 5L '' #. 6#%#%%'=9+'%'#$ ''9+!7*) & ; G46$%
=''% 6+ &
#''''%#5
#'+!7E8
%$
*E.#=%"&
%.6%'%#.%+!%% 5
$#%
'%
#$#.% % . =+!7E(#$%#$%$# & % $ # # $# .+7E7 & $% .''%''5L%$'%==.''+&= % % 6 '' '
'+!7E@
&&&&%$$#%
+ # ' $' &9'''
=.%''5!+=
#$# '% 9$#>==.%%'$$#$ = ' $
#$
$6
L!
'8+ '''()8H5&!"7EEG46%='''$%''
+-%5'!%=F.+%##=##+ %'=8+"$%
#+JK'#+/$'
+ & # % = .
&+
!6#%$5#
''.+$.+#''4%'#+#
#%&3 . =+
#% % $+! G46
'%
$%'+#
&'%#7A@
L3 3 # $% ' 9 + # 9 ' 9## #% #''''# %+ % '' # >
'
' '' ' 9 ' $ # 6 ''
+
%#=%.%%
->$% $ # +%9'%
7A*
L% '$ ' %'%''+
'+ # #> .+ 5 # # '% ' + & '$
% $ %!+
='"#5'J%K
$9# % !+ # '' 7AE
.9= = 9 +
# % & +
#%+&
#%'& # ' +
$ % # +
# % $ #+ ,+,#+# + & = ' $ %$ % ## = = C+' # % +& #-$+ $
# ' &+
!#%'+
='$ ##$+6#.'*49*,912()))%5##'$'' = &!
% .''%$#% #$&+7AA%=$ $ ' 6 %# # 5 '!+=#.5&%$$$&!+
M('()*8%%#=# . ' $# JK$$&%"&% 8+%"!'7A4
& ' . /# /
# + & # JK
# $ 'L JK
.%%+C
& % ## % $ . .%+&%$'#
#.%
&%$'%6'+. $ #
& + ' 6 + $+
7A@ &+ ()@F*+7A* &+ 7(EF(A+7AE &+ 778+
7AA + *49 * ,9 12 0;%: / J# K ()))1+
7A4 99+ @H4F@)8+
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney121 122
& '' 8+ % # % & ()()L
& $ . %
% $ % $$+ # % '$ + % + #%$%'%+5%!+$6. & $ & $+ ' $+ # . '
# # =
=#++& $
# % #%#=#.LJT> K =+ &
&%%.+&% #% & #$ + =%%
L.&% $ " & # % & = #" M & =" %#% ## = % % %"LT> %$ J . .#!-5%"&$6&.
% = %%"!7AH
6#5$$!' - 5 #$
#+.$$&"=$$%.SL.&%%&%" $" %Q$$R"!7A)5L=%6$9'
%!()*(+ 5=.% 6%$%% % = JK6 $ % # % '' + ''$$#&'
''+!748& % 5 !+74('##&.!+
7A) N + (@@@F*+748 N + (*7*FE+74( N + (7)E+747 N + (747+ ! ' % '$
9 =F. (*7 P# ! 05 G46! L!1+
74@ N + (()@ 5. 6#'! # $#
' P# $ #
>'%L&'' -#L!
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney123 124
%+
''''4'()*85%%= # %# . !1 999+ (7E (4 . ()*7 0' 1+ 77.1+
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney125 126
-# 9' ' % %# & # #$ # ' =6 ' 6+ -# # = ' # G46 ;> #
# + & 3% %
JK =63 % '$ #% % = ''
=+ '$%.+&
' $% '
+
7H8
# $' #
%
+ # # #$ % % ''+ # ' '$
#$+ #
'+
=% '% '# %'%'##>7H(
& ' ''+ ' ' $ + '> + . /# =. '# % + . /# '' .+ # .
#6''.+./## &+ /# '' # '' + /# P . 6 ''. = .+& = . = '' .+ & % ' = = # 6 '' .+ # #
' = . % '$# ''
6 $ # #> % % ##+ & %
%
%$ ' ''$9 % $$ $ ''
>
# '# # 3 % # . % 9 " =$# $ # 6 $ %; G46$+ % +
% $ # $ & ", # + / #$ ' J.K # #' #$ % > % 6+ =$ % % #'
$ $ #$ " ### "&$# (* ' . C $+
$ ". C $ #':
+ ## > #' % 9' # %
$> #$ + & ' &$ ' + . #': # 9
# +
!% 5''!+'%%#. #+ & . 6 #+ .+ '' ' .%' ' $
7H8 @4(+7H( &+ @4(F7+
7H7 N + (A*HF)+ T @4E+ = + @4EFA+
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney127 128
"&
'' %
' + ' +& #' '' '+ " & & ' $ %
# $% $ ' % #
% %
% '' + -
#% % # % '' # % + # .+!#+.+%#
= 6#
%#%$.6 . # $ " # % + & # #
% .+ # + & # # ' %
# & % = .
$ # '"
-%''5!%$#
'''+M$%$'.017H@
&
./#+&
#
%/#%' # '' +$%$66
5!/0,#1%'$5&!'!$#&=+= 66 G46 %5''. &! 0 $1+ ./#'()*@>#5%#%&=!+7HE
' -# # ()*7% $$ 5 # -'&'JK
#'G46-$$ &% $%#=6!0%;1+
9'''/('()*8+
5&'$#''+&&%$&'
#$#!+ /" #.% ./#'"0
%%1+!'''&0%G46$1 &$ #9 $ = ' '# &'# '6# # = + M =% ##+ & $ %
. & $ & '' / + & % ' '# % $'% '' 5
%&!#''
% % & '
+
5=% # #+! #%9' % +!0G46G46G46G46$15.+++!!0 0
G46$17HA5%.=%6! 0 %G46$1+ ; .''&%'# = &'+&.6
& ' # + '''
'' $ $ # '$ #
% $
# # +
/'%@8()*4 ./#'5#'#'L./##>#+!7H4%';%%#%5!&%'+ .6P&
$&':%%'';$09'7;$()*4#/
/#%#$
# ' ' # ' $ #
% ' =.!
'#+7)8
125
598F$&%/G
289 G%%%+'+D9+'"X8)AI # ' # # $ '' ' (E8' 4E ' + #
'$ # $ 6% % + & @( ()E8 $''% 9' 59'
!%#%'+& $''% % # ' 5'!
5# ' $ '$ $!+ % 5'% $ !+ '$ #$ % ''# # 5'$ ' # -
! !+ # # ' + # # '0-19+=%$'''' ' ' 0, #
#'1+
'59'%#
# ()*H ! 5# % & .
!'5B*+@0()E81@**F@*A+G%%%++#+D.,D;D7+I
7)8 . 4 (*)FE8+
-# =+(
-# #
&'+
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney135 136
7@
*
E
A
4
H
)
(8
./# '$ &.+
' =+
'= -# %6.$+
& # '+
& #$#9+
=.#+
=.
%+
#''#
#% 05!1
%'# ' % #+
/# # .''+
' &+
&' $ '$&
$+
&+' '
$$+
. %#
-# '##+
&.$=+
'!#6##+
%
.+
% #%#+
((
(7
(@
(*
(E
(A
(4
&F F& ''
$# ' &+
#.+
'
'''%$$+
'$#+
.$
#+
;.$ #
.+
'##' +
#$ %
+
''
'&+
B '' $ # +
'. 9 #
%&+
#'+
'
$''$
''
+
&%
#+(8()*A%;'
'%-#-
$ . /#!'#'%%
'$%
'$%#'+&%-.'%;%$
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney137 138
'' > '$ ''+ './#F-##%0G46M1+>
5.
$#J;!K!+7)(
& % '+ ()*7
#
#'%%B'#.-+ .P+.+'''%$
B++.%
B $%'+. ' ' %# $!$%+.F'7@()*A%%/5''%'()*4!+7)75
6#%'#0.
$ #' ' % 1
%L!/%+ 5&6'%' !.6 #%.6&+!
#%'' $#'%B++.
'%%/ $AG46()*A+7)@
G46 -%%#()*A5# ' ' ># J'()**K$%%#
!+&' 5% !'$%!+7)*'6#%''%'$#$
#%
%=+7)E
## ' # ':'% .+ 0' . % '# # /#
. & +5 #
+!1 % '$#$'&%'%'
09'
#%1%#$% %
$#'3 # + # ' & # 6 # %
%
% #
: % % #
7)( .++=+&'C '' %'''%%./# & $ .6 '$ % + &% % '!93 # % = . 3 9 /# .6
> &L! 5,9'#'. !024 + # 0 ())41 )*FE+
7)7 + / + E $&-.$&-% 0=# ())41 @@+
7)@ &+ HE+7)* -%50$++()*A:
'+ / ()A@1 @()+7)E &+ @() @7(F7+
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney139 140
% # ' % ' $# +
%
##' ':
# #
'' #
$+$ '$%##'./#+ $# # $ 0 #1$E8'.''+%7)A% G46 $ ' # 6 $.6+## 5% !: %
' % ' 5 '
'$% ' $ % !J K+ & % /# # ' & % #
'#6+0'#
5 &! ' %
#''
9L''
$ ()*4 '# #!+ =%$ %
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney141 142
##'9'$$$% % % ' # $'+
G46 ' $ ' & % $$%%'''#$'&
% + $#
% '$
0G46G46$1@88
& .6 . $ '6 . # ' '
%$ ' %# '$ '# .6 % 6 .+ - ''+ - '$ J
% ''K+@8( & %
-
'+
$% '' '
+G46% $ 6
-'$:$#%''%
%()*4+#$$ + . '#+ $+ &
6 '+ & #$ = +%%
6+$.+
#''5-''M
!()*7@8@
% ' $ : ! ()** %% '' '+ $ % % 6+
@88 @)7+
@8( &+ @HAF)7+@87 &+ @)@+@8@ &+ @)A+ .
%-''!+G46
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Professor Richard Bonney143 144
%'
-'' " ,$% # ' $$ $ + ' %+&%
$
''L
## ' % % %
##
@8. ()*7G%%%++#D'D'D()*7D*78@@8+I
@8* 4E # 5
# '$ ' -'' ' '$ '%$$%!# ' %# /#!
!+ # 5 '$ #
-'' & # !''+-'''#$!+.# /# -'' M
#># '' .5 ! ; =(H4 0 /# # -
(('()*71+M*'()*75.&% #
!N+(EEA+G46 /#! 6 -'' ' (@ ' 5% 9 % '' # ''' 01%
% ' '$ '$
L &
%
%%
%'!%+P''$'#
#%'+%
()*AF4''% '%%%%$+ 5''$!'%%"()**@84
9" &!%%JK+ &% % &% %+& $ ''
' +
H ,'#+ P '-#;& % ; P!&
''+@8H
.
!'B $;! P' ()*49##+@8);!#
.
(4()*4#'%B!
&'()*4## % % +@(@
()A* 5; '!@(*
%.;$9+ P
;!$##+!@(E
$+##'%'%%
#'+=%$%% $% 6 % %$ %
6+ G46 %@(A
$ ' P '$ # 3 5! & . + ' 9 P % + & ' $ ' 'L ' # # # ## ' # % 3
# ' #+ & $ # #
' '
' #' ''
$ # ''
6 '' # '
$ % # +
%%%&.@(4
P % % ''3
% 3 + %
P+P! & & & % % P # .6 % '
% % &!+& $%P %
&''9L
'+
@(@ 4 E )7 # (4 + ()E(+& # G%%%+'+#$+'D'DDP\+I
@(* TC
''9M
M$%F()**#
M
.++@.()@H&$$
7*G46()@H+&'#&%%+&
&'%' #% %''
'#&
#
%%#.P>++&'%'##%9''+#'$%#
#%%#%"''%% -+ -
#% ' % %#''$9'%'=%%#'$ -#%$6=.#+
$#%
#>&./#
$ '$ #> .&'
-#=#+&
% ' $''+
M#&
7 .$-#+
@ /##>.#>$.'$.+
* .'
+
E .#9##+
A ='+
4 -##'
+
H .-#'.+
) ''.'%J.K/#+
; $ &+ ' G46F
78D78F77+
G46
# -
-#7'()*7 #-
$#$
'' -#&
-''+''%$$'$$&!
'''#$% %$% #
$ '#&$'%+
-# ' $ '()@)''&%$%'#$
%'
%'%
+%
&>'
#%%$+#
&-#-
%5M'&'
' # ##%+!
-!%''''
' + -
%#>#
''&'''
#
'$ $ % #$'$'
+ ,$ #''!#$'$+''&$% '-# ' 9''%
#''''%&+
'$'' '$ $ % '&''##%#'$%%
% #$&C+-#% & '%%''! $ $ #
% 6 9# ' '+ ;$ -
'#''&C#
%+ #>#''-
$
%%'
$'#'$+ ' '' $ $$
# % '#'#9#'%+,$'%C % # + ''%' -
#%
''$ ' C 6
% ' #%
+'''
%$''+&'$&%'$##''#&!+&
'''''
$%%+
''#'+-
''''%
-+
999$+ *E4F*E)
G46$
& -
-#7.()*7
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents155 156
&-- JK ' '' #$#' & C G46%# ''
'$
%-#
#''+
HE+ P% # ; / ''+
9
6606#'1G46H()**
%&;-#&./#%6.#JK%%$'$ # -# /# ''$
( 6 % # JK&./#
&&'%'%JK$'+
7 ''##; ,&%.''6+&'
#' ' =+ & 6
$ # $# ' =#$
%
'6#
6+
@&%''$'$%'+
*&$'###-''+
E''$+
A#'%'#$&+
)@F*+&+)EFH'66F
' 'F ()**+
$
(4'()**
% % & % ' '#+%
+&$%&%6+&$%
+
&%+ %%$+!#&.+&$%$%%+''+
N
; $ & ' G46)HDE4+&+DE*C6
6$# D EH ! ' (* 0''# #1+ 9 !
999$+ ()) % '
C+
,#
!%
.+6#'!G46%#
+&
%+
999$+ 77(+
;
&$%@8()**% 9' .+ .
&9'T>%'
#+'G46 ' #
+&
+& $ +&$#&$'6G46+;
''+&
%$%#%+&'$'''+66G46 '$ + & % $''6'+
999$+ 7E@F*+
'.#-&./#/@8()**5 # $ '#.+'''''!.+.+++
.5.+''&$%'
'%%-+6#'=.
&%%
+
#'#'9
'+M(H.()*@!
'*.()*@%% 8 '
%%#'
#+=
.+!+&
.+
5&$%'#./#'8+&%$+####'+&+&'
%#''
$% $+M # &
+5!$+&%&$#"%!+&%&!+
&%
$
%:
& ' %
&9'.+'''%&''()*@'
./#+ &%
%%.+
%5!$%%$ $ -# ' $# # % $#'%'$'+5!
$+ .+%''%#PB%#''%B
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents159 160
%$#''$'
##'+
#92
9 '+
%//#%#%$./#'##'##$%%/ $$#
%,'%-# #-
'
''5&'%'+&%##%$%!+
-%&'''-#./#+ ; -'' % % -#/ #-
%%9'##%$'%-#./#+% # -''!''%'
% % + .+ -+6#'#=+
''#+ & ' -+ 6#' 9'-#%$$
$%$''$.+''#.+!+.+'
.+'%#$'
=.
= '#
'.!/#.()*8%./# $ # $+ G46 % '"%'''%"
'
' .+ 6#'! + G46 ' % ' %'./#%.%%#'##
-+6#'%-#'$'%$+% 56
%#!&5! + "#&'+&'%#'''&.+.+6#'%
#%./#+
;9%%'%-#'$#$
' ## -#''
+ & # % ' '%'.+6#'&9'#%''.+%$%$#$$##'$#&+&./#&%'%''''=.
.+6#'''$.+&+$#+
&$''##+
#$'#.+5''!'
''+ %
=%9''#%%T> %' ' $
'$%''%
'%'#$&+%''+=66G46%%#-##'%L=
%%%+
999$+74(F7+.6 5& #$% % .6 $ '
9' % & % #''# .+ 6#'! G46 ' $%
& %+ % L!
%$
!$%C&4#()**TC,&M; N # 5
% % # $# + 5N+!'% $&+01 5N+!&
5&%#&
'+!L
A+66!
$$%+#
'##G46#
-$#+$#+
4+&$#%$###JK+
'#
+ $ & $ #L
H+'+=%&$9##+
$%
$+#$',#'6+-$% # +
)++='$+01#&%+&$
'$#+M%%%+%$%&%%#$#+
(8+.%&'+%$&+
((+.$$$%+&%$
+,$$$-#%'%'#+%'$'''#%'%"M'%
+='+=%%%
+ & % & ##+
999$+ 7H4)+
G46
!%T/67@#()**TC,&M;.6$#%'#''#&''$$+=%''#$#''66!''"
; ,#$%+&$#$$&$+66!
JK#
39'+$$&'#'''&%'+&'+
T+ $#%.+!#$#66!
%''%$ & % ' % $
"
+&%
%$$'+ % '' '
'#+%$#
%$%&+G4666!%9#'+
T+.6#'66!
.'%
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents171 172
%+
+G46'&$$ 6 +##.
+.'. % $$ +&'&!'%%%5!$+''6#
#
+&$# + ; $ % # $''%%+&6
'' $
&
+&%%&$''%%+&'$9%$+C$
$'$% #
%.++&$9'&'##% '6 &''%$''#%T>%'6'$$ + ###%+
T+&$9!.69$'
% % # '&"
+$$#&$#%.$#%+&%$#%%
$#'+&$&'&% $ #
##%'+
T+.6
'# %$##=.$#$=F.$+! &'%#&".
.+!''#%
=-#+!&5;&$='$-#+&$ $+ N $ /#%$%'+%66' G46 % $ # '$#>'%'
+%66+N%$''%+;%&$+!=%
/#+ %&%'#9'" %$
#"&%()@)+%#+N&
#&%#%+!&'+&5&%%$$"&+N#$% &% ''%+! 5N &%&$%!(+=&%#%#%+=%#6%$+&5&%+!5N!+5!&'+
G46+=%% '+ 5 %$ ' =!+5 ##$
' '+! && $ ' + & $ ''&+5&%'&!'+&$#'%'&%&+!=5.%+/#'.%'+!&5/#'%.#>+$
'.&.%+
$+!= 5 ."!& 5N''$''$+N%6%"!&%P 5& % %%#%##'#+$$+!5&6!&5%$+&%#%%$+%6%+&%+!
=#9$
G46+ & 5& %
#
$
G46"!5M!%+&5
9#"!= +5M+&9#!5&$%$##&%9#+! &%#6G46+=%+5.&"!+5N&%+!=#+&5&%#%+!&%5N
&$%'%#+=#+#5%'"!= 5;
+ ;$ % #%%'
+!
999$+ @A)F4(+
9
(8'()** ' ) & =F.
%$' '$ '
( % '+=%#
' '! #+
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents175 176
= -# +&'%#'$ %% & # '
=F.%&'&6#$#+&>%
=.
'% #% #%"
''
%
'$&=%/.()*8'
%+N/+N$9''''$''+&%%%%'/+B#$'+M''&9''%&$#-&./#
/@8()**+
7+N59#
$#'6
'#''#&+ &6'%##!+'&$''
##'' ' &./###()*7+&$'''&
=F.
+
M&%'# $% -##%
#6##%$$'+&'%%'$&$+;%6
#%/#-#
$# ' $
#%&%%%''$&$%#$'
+
@+N$
%
'#'
%&+6
M#
'%&+&%''#%$+&$%%+.'=#'%#'' # # +&% + = 5& % '
% # # % ''%'+! ' % '+''''%+ $'#$$
+%>!#+N'=##$%$&L
999$+ @4E+
%
(*'()**&$
(@+&%%&%
#
$'# ' %
%%$#+&''$%'+ # #+ &
#66G46%##++./#/()*8+
/#%&%'
+
' %$
66'/
'#$
+&$%66G46&$'/'###+
'#'
+
&%'%$'%+&
%#$#'%+
N''$#$+&%$& + & # % % #
% '+ &
'$#$''''+
$&$'$'#%$%
%$$& $ % $
##%+''$#$#''#%#$
#-+%''$%+6656!G46#'%$%#'%+%%+%''###''+''$#$%%+&
#+
5'!&$#$%
#$
%+
%%
(E'()** (@+G46&$66G46%''#$
/./#+
N
%+& $ ' ' & %++=.
$
&$+#'##'''+&%#%+#%#%+&' $ #''
+&&%$&'#$#+
N ' # %"
4+&'#'"
H+&%
%'%+&%
#$
# $
%/#-#'+
999$+ @H*FE+ 7*F7E+
%G46$
(4'()**&$
(E'&+&$66G46''#$/./#+&9'/''$##$$'+&$$.#&$9#$= & % #%'###'$'
$% '$ ##%+
N$
'((
/5!+&'%%%'
/%&$$
'(E'+
'#'
#
(7+5.!/&++=+
(E+ & #$ '' % '%$%
#'+
0^1+% : 01./#$'$#>.&:01;+%01+
# '#' $# $ ' 6#/%5&%
#%#
'%&!+&$'
'$%%$'%6=.''&
%'''
& & # & '
+ &
$#'%+&'%$%'$
$+&
%#$%$'6+
$''#%
#
+G46&%'+.''$'$'+
&'9''/%#'+&
%
'+-%#
$#%''
' (E
%#%% # / 5$&''#&'
!%'$$+
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents195 196
N
'((
%5&&'+//#+/#+!&
' '
'((%5N/+ N $ 9''''$
''+&%
% %% ' / !&'(@% '
' (E
#
#9
%%&'
'(E
'(4%
# $
% '+
&$#$
%
#'&$%%'&!+&$
## % + / ' %%$+
N $ '+ & '
'/#' ''
'+ &'''##9'
''# $+
#&%'%'##()*7.&+%
01-'&'JK
#'G46-$
$&%
$%#=6+
01;$'%$$-%% %%''
$&%-
%'$%#6=4E'+
01 -# #
$%-#+
''.&/$.&>#%%.&+&'%#+
G46$$ ' '$''$'%#%#%/% ' $ $+ % & $
'# '$
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents199 200
&$+%$%##''
'
(+N5&$##%+/
'%%$!+&%%&%''#$#%%%$'%%
$$#/+
7+N5/''#$%!+.&'$' $#
$"=%
'& # % $#'+
01 '% '$
G46#
& ---%
%#'+
01##
#%+&
' # -#
/#%'
'&+
01/#%%$ % -# %/#%#''+
%' % %$ '
/ -#"&&'
''%+&
7@'5''/!'
+%&&$'
'# $ ' $
'# #$#$
###;/!+&$'
%F66G46##566'/'#$!'5$%66G46&$'&%###+!
&%
'(E#5&$66G46%&''#$/./#+!%F66G46%
%
##$+
%#'#%#
=JK'%##%'+####&$9'
'
(4()**%&$%&%#%$
$
7A'()**&$$
'7A&
$%
%66!$+M
%$&%+&
$F66G46#%'G46#$$%/+N
'$''
'7*#$
/+&'$
G46#$ 5!/+&$%
%'
'
##&$9''6#/+M'
'.&+&$$ ' $ &/+
#+
&$&$'&' & #% #%'$$+M$'
# &$9' +N#''%''-#+&$$### &$#$+N'$ ' '% #''&%$+;'#>''$%$#'%
#> #> '$+=%$&'&$9''$'+
&%$#/+&
999$+ *4H+ A7FA@+
;!-%7H'()**&
'#%%#+''+%+&6+,%''
$%'+&%'''%
#+.9'
'$%$%' '% +$%+&'$'$%9+;$#
%&$#%+
#.
&'+ & '
'+&%$'+
&66G46%/%#
"
#'%%
%+G46 &9 $% ' ' ' T> '+&'%
'+T> ' + ' % & '''$&%
/# ' +
%6%'+
.+!$%##'$#$
&T>'#%#
#$+$9'' #$ % $+&
#%#%''+&%$9'
'''
##+
.%.%
%/#.#+='
&$/#
'$.'&''#$.#+
$.#
''#..%#"%''#
$#=6+&'9%
$# % $ +-%##''%$'%%+
%' %+%%#>+
6;.
-##.#.+''#
$#
%&+
. ' % 9##+;.%'%+=
& '
&%+&''T>&'';.;+;.&%%#%&''T>%#%
''&%
' + C ;.''
.%'+=%#.+#&%#&+
%
% '
%./#()*7.
$ #
+ & ()*7 66
5!#P%''+&$#'+=$''%
$#'%
+=
$#$'&$$#$'+ #P'
G46&$$&5N! & % '+. %+&$+&$%+&$'#&$+&>#66!&+%%3%'
#'&+ $
%()*7+=%$&$'-#'#+-#'66G46'
''G46#+
#.9''
'' $# %
+=
G46##%%%
9#
%%+
999$+ *()F7@+ AEF4*+
G46%%+&$% #$ 08 / 7) ' ()**
.+ % %.+
'=F.
+5& ' %+ %.+!+=%#; G46$%6#$#''
+!=%.+#'
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents217 218
&%#% '+ = 6 6#'G46+
&.+%%''#>% '#+
=%'+='5&%
&$.+&
# % # $''''''+&%##
'$%#'$#'.'%=+' %# # #
+$
%'&+!#.+%.%%6 %=+$%'%''%%$#&+5C.+%$#''%'+!
&.+'
#5!$#%#''+
='5%#''+&.+!$%%#$#
%%%#&%$''#$
6
#B'+
##0(1%''%+ $%#6.& %'' $ -# $#>'#..$%%-#+-# # '
' # '$ ''#-#+ % ## #>+
##071&
''./# # 5!
%$C''#5%!''+
&$.=#6'/#5!$#'' $# 5 %
!
$'=+
0,?88
& % 9'%# + %##%'''+ %$'+
= > 5 %%%="!
. &&$$#>
$%'$$#''###+$'
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents223 224
$$&
'$%
&-+
&'''###$%./#
%''+.&$'#'$
+%$
$+
&%''#%
##'.&%##''+ $ % $''#'./#''
+'&%'
#+ '%%
%$#'%$
# #+ & ' %'&%+
* 2
T+&$%'#%
%#'%"
%N#&%$+&
%%%'%#>%6
%'%%$%#+
%3&%'9'&9'''%%#>+%
'+N+
G465
T+ % ''
./#"
%+./#$3 63%% '+
#6./#$#+#$'+%#
#$%%%%
%#%
' ' #'$#%'-#&$'%'%'#%#%%+
0**49
&$'''#%=.+&&'%$#$''$'#+
&$%
''.
%$'$$#+M$.3%#6
'3$#JK'%#$>+
> C! + = % '%
$ ' # ' $%%'+++ %# ''!+=
':#&+++
0% ;1
/ & E8 &'+. # % ''#$!' '' $ '' 9'##'' # ##+ ''%
' ' # % # '' ## ##'+
!'''$+ & # $# # $ '#+='#%#'%%%$''%'#+='''+=%++
+&'##$'&''+%.()785''!=.'8++!
.++$%+M% % # ''6%
'#.+ ' 'F"&'
''
$#"M $ 9%%#%+
$%'#&+=
6#-#:+=#5$!'+ # -#=.'##&!%+
!'6
'9''
# # ' #
## ## '%'#+%6;!5=.C!!T>" '% "=%%#."
9' % '%$+%'%%
29'
$+=$'%'.+#()@4%$!-#./#%''!'+N%%+= ## 96 '#%#$+
%%J # 6+
%
+ % %#'%#'+=%''#$'6:#+=%##+=''%+=$%$%%+
.%'' #+=%'%+=''$%
%#+=%$$''' +=$'' #
''9%G46G46 0()*81+(*
'%'& = #$ %
%#'
0(1 ''$&
071 '
0@1 ' '' =$$+
M'
&&&+./#=.'#%+./#''.+#.#6''.+./##
&+/#''#''+/#P.6''.=
.+&=.=''.+&%
'= = # 6 '' .+##'
=.%'$#''6$##>%%##+&%%
%$'''$9 % $$$''
'+%'#%
%#+&
''%'
+!
% % + G46'' #$ # '$$#$+'
6%
.6% > & #'
#'.%$#+!
'./#'./#-'''%%%+.+#$%+'#(A;$()*7.+'$9'%#
_'>>#'''##%#.%9"=$#$#6$:%;
G46$+%+
0
5 %$#$&",
# +/#$
'.##'#$
%>%
6+ =$ %% #'
$$#$" ## #
"&$#(*'+.
C $+ $ ".C$#':
+ ##
>#'%
9'#%$>$+&'&$'+.#':
# 9 # +!
.+''+' % % # .#+&.6#+.+''
'.%''$"&
''%
'+'+''''+ " & & '$
% # $% $ '%#%
%
%''+-
#%%#%''#%+#.+!#+.+%#=6#
%#%$.6.#$"#%
+#
%.+#+# '% #&%=.$#'"
9 '%#+#%#''''#%+%$+M+$6%##..
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents237 238
G46+$.G46
$=
%%
'%6#''''+./#.+%'#+.6#%#+&.''%##
=6 % = % ##.6"&.=5#%!
%!` #%-#` #
=6##.
%#+
'
''+
#% %+&' #%%'+&'#+$#+5#$##
%## +!M$
##+/#
+
B&'+&%%
'%%$%+%'#+
G46 '$# ''#+&
#'+
'$ =+.'''%%#%
9#'''+#
###
#'+
# '+ &
'%
'###
#+
#%'+M%##" +&'6#%%
$
%=###%
5$ = # '' - #
#'%#+&% '#%'+
' ' #$
'+M$%
''%#+;%%%#+ %%9'&+
'+
'$''
#'+&
#%'$'+
'#
###
#+
G%%%++#I+ @A)FH*+
G46G46$ ! 0()**1+ -' (E -" ,'#%
7 071 $# & =+#;%
#;,+
@0(1#-$ # % =.6'+
@ 071 %#
A0(81-&
$ ' /#/#='$
-' % $$
$+
40(1/#=#-&'% /#$=%'%#9
-+
4071'%#%%'%%%'''%'%
- & =$#'$/#=#%#
9'$%%%% % %=+
40@1-
% '' %$$
$ ''%='$+
((0(1M=
-&9
/#$&'%9-&+
((071/#$&'% /# $ =#'%9/#$9+
(70(1''' $ /#=.6'#%''#'+
(7071$ '##'+
(70@1,$#$; G466#+
(@ & -0$1()*0"1+
&9'
%#'&$$+'
#$#
''%'6#$
'#%-''''+
&''%'
#&'%
'#+
''%+%&$''5$&0$1!+#
%''+&&'''..
'.$+&.6.$'6.#'' %$ ' %#'$ '#.6%6.+-''+-'$+&%
- '+
'.. % '' % & #
+ # '# 6+&'+#'$#
6
.'%+'''3%%+#.%% $ #%'+% % #$-$''=+=%$''% +.% 9'%=66+'+.$#
' % ' #% # '=''6#+
'&+' 6# ' ' $
+&%#.%'&$#%#$+&$' ' $ '$ '0(1'
071'+&''$#&$#$%%+&%
.$9'+9' #+&9
%'#$''+&$%='$##%#''$#+-'$+&+&$+&''#$'#
=#+
+ & %'+9+&
= # + & #>.'#+$+& 6'+ $ =
+ %%6+$.
+
'''%
-''+''%#$ '+7).()*@%#
5=.6!$%#
01&''
'& #% # %&+
01$%''+
01 =.6! $ ' '%6
01#'$&
'''%'
' '$ #
5%>$'+&%'''%#%
# % $#+
5&%#
!#
'$%%$##+#$%#%##
#+
5 %%'$&+-
# 3 #$ #$
'$
% '$ # % 6 ##$%$
C '#$+!
''% -+ ,9'# ' '$
-''5&-'#'$'$%'%6C%'3'$$'$$A8'#+&% A8' '%'$#%
''+&'6%#+
9''#%$'$$$+#'$%'#'-C'##'#+!
% '
-''
'$+M'': + % & $##+&'+G46$ # + $#
$'%'' + & $ % '''!##$'+#
%$+=#$#CC9'%+$
>''+$'#
%%9%
'$+
#$ # ''- -%''%$%%99
'+' & '%%+%
6
6
+&$%6 #+##'#'#+%#+ &$#$ #+ & % =.#$+
'#%+M'#%#
0(1&=F.&!'$"&'>%#%#=.#%
"
071&=F.'''
"
0@1&$''%%
. %#'%'6"
0*1&$
%
"&%$01$ & =01G46/#,9$$%$'"
0E1 % ' = . '#%"
0A1=$##'$##%= . $# # %# # % '#''%#%
'%%%'"
041 M ' % % % # ' $'##
' ''6#'%"
0H1&&
&'&'
%'="
0)1
'$#%
% ''.#=#=
'$
''&$'=.%'"
;#%
##'%#%%
'##'#9' # 0(1 '071'9$%' 0@1 %# +M
#$+C#&
# + '=+%#'#+$+= 6+# 6 $%' S ' '
' 6+'%$#'
# %
'&%#%%$'+##+&%'#
+'%'+$ % ,'%$#'#(E8+%'+&+&'+=
$&''&+%&E"#+&.+%P#=&B G463 '' % ,#
P#-&+=&B%=#+
-- +=$#=## % ' ' '%''+%=&B$#;>%
.++& #: >+$$%#.+'#%#%$#'#
.#'''+#+.+!9$%9%;.+&
%.%./#;
.+&9
%;
.$'%-#%
./#+&-##$%
%%;.-#'.+$%
'+ ; # ' '$$/#+
;%#.+##%.+ . /# % $%
+=#-#'T&H#
()*7+T&%'#
$+%
'%%$$
.
'
''+%#%+ 6 '$ % ''##'C6#6''9'%'$
#+$
'+ %$% $$##
-++G46+&''
%#+
M$+
#$#
' $#+ &
%
-#9#
'+ % ' #
##%-#''#$ % % -#+ ''$#+&$6-##6
$
'$$'#&+&'%'$'$%
' -# $+&$'$#'+6'+&6$&+#
''$''+
%'%.
6#G46>'O &+@
%'$%5%&' B % ' %+ 3%'
''!'H#+A$
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents277 278
@ M = = -' @(.7887+O0+1$+*@(F*+
!'#B%#>#0#'$ .
#
%'#1+4
G46$
5.+++!!0 0()*@1
G46%T>..7*()*7& ' % '
##' %$#$%%%''#$ + ' $9' = -# =#>=.+&$+&+&'%6
.=+$$
'+
&% %6
=.#%'%,'+&$###''%:
.; ,>%6%''48
''&'$#JK+H.
0 $/&%#+%%&& ' %6#=
.%$>##$''%6'
'
'#+
M$%9'
$%./#+&$%%
%%%'&! & %
'%'%
# '#$'&6=.+
5"*"" "80
-#F/# ' $ =.
%'+-#%$
#' $ '
&+'-## . /# % $'$#>)8.+
M'=$#%%''#'$.#'&%=+.
#
#'''''.#
+
..(($
&+.(7
=.$
+# %'
# +,$=J$'K(@%5'=!='%= ' .&+'%5%%''#'&+!
&%'$%$%=%#
$'=%#>=.'+
/+=JX=0(HH*F()@)1K%()7E/(*&
=%#
=%'$
$=# $ ,'+6$#
%#L!(E
'$ %#$####.$=6$.$%
+9$###+&=#.$#$''+
-$$'
%# . $ & =.%'
'#;#,'%$'##
$
'
.$#.5.+$.'+=
$ # += %
$#+N''.'+&=%."!
-# # 7( 5=%%#'6%%> 6 + M%
6%+#
#####'###6+%$
% '$#9'6+%%+!
$%#
##=.%8+%%
%#%6%%+=->$%#
'%'###+
-# '$% &!#$'> =F. #
5'%#9' !+ . $ #$ ' $ # & +
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents285 286
() 5.!% # 5G46! %.+ (*8
=$''%'
%+ %#'##$+ 5& ' ''+!#5''+
$'+!
.+77G46%''%5-'%%+$
"&$+-+::O$+!
7@9'$% %+ 5''''
' % +!#'#%''# # &+ .$7*
'#'#''$#
,''5,'%'+&%$+%'$--%#+!
7E #
- #%5'+++-% $ $ % 6 %''6'''+% %#=,'##+!
5.+++!!0 0()*7:7+()*@1+
''9
,$-G46#.-
M.''-()7(=
#.
$ ' '%'$
. 7H*8*HH A+4(
@H78(E@ ()+4*
# 7E7(8H87 E*+88
C$ A*H(8@7 (*+7H
6 ((***@7( EE+@@
M @A)8(H7 (8+HE
-$ EA@E4* *+8E
7787*A8 7H+)A
; 78A74HA )(+A7G46$
= 0()4)1 (8+
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents287 288
77
7!''%&()*E
. .' ' &
(+6 (@@@7*A8 (+ AA**74AA.'&0,9#1+
7+;+ +G46++ 7774@8@
@+ 7H@8H88
*+ *8E@8) 7+. *4H)4@8( '
#',#+
E+, 74*)4A7*#
. @+ (HE*E*AE .
=
01, 74*)4A7*#
01 (A8@H8E
*4H)4@8(
0()*E1 + A 5 '!+
@'&()*(-
- & & #
(+= (E8H)8(*A EE774(H8 78A((4@7A
7+. 4)@)HE8@ (7AE)E)@ )7+8EH+8)A
@+ @))78H84 H+H)7@4@ *HH(@(H8-
*+ (A4(@7EA H+47H7@@ 7E**(*H)
E+ *(AE8)4 (E7A@E8 EA)(**4
A+-
01& (AEE)H7 (*(@H8H @8A)4)8-
01#& ((@)@A 7A*HA (*8*77
01M 4E4E( 448H H@*E)
4+ E4H@47 H48)(* (+**)+7HA
H+ (A4*(@ A*E)8 7@788@
)+ (8()AH (7)77 ((*H)8
(8+% ()+@74 @(E@ 77*H8
((+M @4(*8@ @H*4* *8)H44
7)*(4()A( H)*4(4H* @H@A*@4*E
;M,+#-&$+
#6.%&%+-'
()*8 #$ #+ 0()*E1+
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents289 290
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents291 292
((+.*)@*(H(8@H)A*E7
4+)
H8AH*)7(A+*
788(8H7*+8A*(H
+88(
(7+;+ +G46++@8@H8A474HH4)4
)(+H;
E*7A
+7E4)H)
(+)
(@+M
H47HE**(*A@8(
(+4
(7@H(4((*+7
7AEH*
+@7@7
+88@
(*+67H*(HH()(A7(47*7E4
(7*HA@E*+*
*HA8@H
(+4
@4E4*8((@+7
(E+
E7A4
7E(
*+H
)(H
(4+*
7(A
*+(
;
'
(A+
*77)77(@8E*A@E
47+7()(A@*
*+E
(@7@7
+@@(8((
+4
(4+C
EE878A(4H*(A@8H
(E+@((4(4(EH7(+@
(@(@74
+77@7**E
+*$
7)EE87+)@E4)@**HA@7A+)*8)()4**(@+)
@7*E*E@(+8
*(EE(*4(+8
V
7HH7@H87*(AH*48
(*+*@)()A()(@+A
(7AE(
+8*@78*
+8(
-
4E(A@*)E*4H**
4+@
*784A8
E+A
(78*7
+7(888)
+(;#'
V-++
(@78H4(H**HE7H
@+*
7@E)H@A(4+)
*7(@E
+@(74AA
+(
@+A8*HAA@@E(A)
)@
A)(+E44
()+7
A(7E
+777@8
+8E
#
*8)8@(*4A7@(8A7
(E7H8(HH8@()+A
(78E*)
+@77A8)A
+E
M
(*((**487(HE7*A
(E+E@A)H@EE7A+7
(844H
+8HA@*)
+8E
.
&
-
-
$
'
'
W
'
W
'
W
'
W
(+6EH@A)@
H)H))
(E+*;
@H)E
+HHA4
+(E
.%
7+@@4AH
H88E
7@+4;
44)
7+@
4**
7+7
;
@+
(878*4@@@**7*4)
@@+4A4A7)(
A+A
@44E8
+*@*A*
+8@
*+
E8(A@(
*@H)@8
H4+EE(87
(+8
7A@@
+E(()(H
7+@
E+#
A8@8AE7E@@88E*@*E*+44H4H)48(@+8
((8)7@
+7(A7H(
+8@
A+
@A@*8(E(*4(A@(*
(7+)*H*8@4)(@+@
7*A)@
+84(@7(@
+8*
4+78H*)H*8()78@AH
)+7
(HEE(*HH+)
@@HH(7
(+A
H8((
+8*
H+-
(AH(@EH*4H@A)4
*+4
@8E(*(@(H+(
*H7A8
+@(*))A
+8)
$
^
)+-#
(AH47A
(*4H8
H+H
7E4*8
(E+@
@@8)
7+8
;
(8+
)(4)@)
@8*)4(
@@+7(7(A)@
(@+@
(8*)*
(+(
(A(E4
(+H
*-
''
$
&()*(
+
0()*E1+
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents293 294
((+=
(A@@HE@*78)4*4E(7+H
7)7H8*H(4+)
7(E)H)
(+@
E@@8
+8@
(7+P*87(+A(A@84@E*84A+*
((@*A*
7+H
@84)
+8HAE)8@
(+A
G46
(@+.*)H4E*
@87A@
A+8
H@4@*
(A+H
78H8A
*+7
E
(*+.
4@7)(*8*HE7@8
AA
(*8E8A4()+7
)HEH8
(+@
7A)
88*
(E+;+ +G46++*A7A4
778AH
*4+4
;
E4(
(+7
**47
)+(
(A+M
@87@4@((*@EE
8+*4@E78HH
$$"D
77*)
+84(E(
+88E
(4+6
EE8@EE*77E(*E)*8+)
@*))A7
A+*
A)E7
+((@*7AHE7*+*
(H+6=(8)8A***AA4H
*+@
7@H44*
7(+)
(HH
+87(44@)
(A
()+6'
(@A4878H(7)4H*()+E
*@*)
+8@H(H)A
+A
78+
(7(E78
H@
8+844A
8A
@*
+8@(
7(+$A+8488(H*@*(E8
4+7
@)E)E7
A+E
()EH*)(@7+@@(
77+C++
)7H*48
74@A7E
7)+E
(E7)74
(AE
(7H(
+(4@(
+8H
7@+
*)8*(EAA88**8
(7+7
@EH8@H
4+@
@(8E
+8A7@)
+88E
&
)(H(8E4((E4@@(@@(A+E)HH)7@4@)+4
74)*)E)@+(
(E7A@E8(+4
.
&
#
'
-
-
'
W
'
W'
W
'
W
(+
47EAEE
@(AA7
*+*
7AE
+8*
7E)(@
@+A
@H(
+8E
7+
@EA78*
@*A7E(
)4+7
AE
+87
*8
+8((7A
+8*
@+
7HEE8(877@A(8
4+H
7@84)*
H+(
)(H7
+@EAA
+87
*+#
7(**H7)@47((@
(4+@
7A)47)
(7+A
EA*
+8@7H
+88(
E+-
4E8A*74*@)HE8
E+)
(87488)(@+4
4EH7
+(74@(
+8*
&
A+-
*8E88887H44@
8+4
*H@(@7
((+)
((H78
+@E84
+8(
#
4+-
(*77H4E(8)(HH
4+4
(*((E*
)+)
@))@)*
7H+()
H+
74HE*7H(H78@A
A+E
@8AH)H
((+8
(47@A
+A77
+88(
0
P'1
)+6
(*EH487EH888
@+)
EE78*
@H
*7(E
+@(H7
+8(
(8+%*88A(E)7*8)8@
A+8
(@E7
+8@7@*7
+8A
E-
''
&
-
()*(
0()*E1
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents295 296
.
&
=
-
-
'
W
'
W
'
W
'
W
'
W
'
(+=(88A48)7HE78H7H+@(7H7*8(7+4(7@E
+(A84@(
A+8E7*A87E7+(
7+
)EA@))(AAEA)(4+*(@E(8@(*+((87A
+((*AA
+7A*E@4(E4+E
@+#HE(*EH7HE))7@@+A(()7E8(*+8(*E4
+7A@4
+84**(7H4E(+H
*+P))*E4E@8*@*A@8+A(@A4(@(@+4(77@
+(()HH4
7+8E7)EHHE@+7
E+H*44*E7AH)))@(+4(7*88A(*+A*H)7
+A(E@E*@(H+(7HHAE7@*+8
A+
@HE4A
4877
(H+748)7
(H+*E8H
(+@(8@7
7+477@4*
EH+8
4+P#H))@44*@7*)
*+H
(7(A77(@+EE)8
+84*H8)
+E47E)8)H8+4
H+=((48@7@@H84E)@7+E(48HEE(*+AA8A8
+E()H()*(A+)*(@H@4@E+*
'
)+(+(74()8E8)H8**E+7(E**@((@+4E)4(
+E7)H4**7A+E(EAE4)(@+)
(8+/H(HA(E@87*H7@A+)AH*A)
H+*
(A@7
+7@*((4E*(+4(8A7*A(7+)
+
((+G46(+*7@84AA*(**H*E+(4@E8*
E+(
((8@(
+H*4)*HA@@+47(A77)(E+7
>'+
(7+/(A)E@4E(874447A8+A@74@E
(+)
A4AHA
*+8@(8A*H(H+@7E788*(*+)
(@+(*(@H4AAE4A)E*A+E774E8
(+A
7E@@8
(+HE(8H*E@A+(()*474(@+H
(*+((E@E((EH))7@E(+(*EH@)
*+8
*87A7
*+*77(7E(()+77**)@E7(+7
'+
(E+
(()8*)44@)7(HA7+(AE@E*
E+E
4@H*A
A+7(@)*8)((+4(AE)AE(@+)
(A+6)(77@EA*748A48+E4*HE
+HA8@H8
A+A))(@)
(8+)(88A@8((+8
%
(4+HE7E8HE*7@**A@+A77*@H
7+A
E))HE
4+8(A848A(H+)AA4**
4+H
'
(H+6
((8*E7)*EA8)HE+A*A7(
+**@)(
+*48+7@@
A+@H8877
4+7
()+))H)7(H@E)(HH@+4)A)@
(+8
(7A)8
(+@*H+8*A
*+H)7*4)
)+7
'
78+A7)AEHEA@8@@H)+*44(
+(4@8
+(7*AH8
@+)*8((4
A+*
+
A-
''
6
-
()*(
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents297 298.
&
=
-
-
'
W'
W
'
W
'
W
'
W
7(+%
4HE7@(A7H()@H8+8*+7@@
+E*7(7
+EA*(74
H+7
4H7*E
(8+8
'
77+
A4EH4EA(((7H)8+*(8(E
+(E8*
+8)78(87
@8
*7()*
A+7
7@+.%E8A@7(*@A7A8HA+7(88H
+7@7*
+8AAHAE
(+@
A(H8A
(7+7
7*+.
#(@7)(8@)(HEA*A)+(*@*EA
@+7
7*(8(
(+)
(4E+8A*(@+7(A4E(8(7+A
7E+/'(@)A@8EH44E(HA7+HAH777
*+)
E(A)*
@+4
7A74@4(H+H(@EA@4)+4
7A+#+H7(A@(A4H4@AH7+A()*@
+74**
+((77@H
(+E(74)*A(E+A
74+.
(*H*@@@((E4)((4H+87*+E@8
(+4
(@748
+)A(A7H
*+(
77E@*7(E+7
7H+.>
4(7H*)A(A84*HA+*7A)(
+*7(H
+8@E+HH7
+HH4)E7
(7+@
#
7)+
EH(@E8E(7A4HHH+((8E)
+7*A
+8((+847
+7AA@*H
((*
>P
@8+
*87*A
*88H*
))+A;
;
7(A8
+*
+
7H+*(HH78(A7(47*7E4+((E)7@78E+A
*HA8@H(+4
@4E4*8((@+7A@8(4@477+7
.
-
=
&-
'
W
'
W
'
W
'
W
'
(+%
(H)84@7@@AAAE
(4+H
*@8@88
77+H
)A@E78
E(+8@7H8
+7
7+
(8*H@(47H4@(8
74+*
7H87E*+7A+4
*8A(H7
@H+H@**
+8@
@+
(7H)A*8EEEA*
*+@
@EE7)8
)4+E
47@7A)
'D"$(7(A
+(
*+.'@()8A*47*AEE)
4+4
@@)8AA
(8+A
7+@*7H)4
.A"-@H@*
+(
E+=#
(@4447)784844
(E+8
7*EH(8
(4+H
HE@+4@*
D$"&E*@
+8*
A+=%
(*)8@8*
7)A@7E
()+)
(H*@(H
(7+*
(888E*HA4+())*
+8A
4+7*
@E@A@HA((*H(H8@7+E
4*@@)4
7(+8
(+EAAE))**+@78H7@
+A#
H+-
7(8HH)(*)4E@E
7@+A
EE77H
7+A
(*4A7H*48+8(A*@(
+H
)+;
(4E)H*A(84H884A(+@
(*@AH7
H+7
E(*7AH
7)+7(84*)
+A
(8+.
(A*8E@8)744*4
EA+A
(A4(H*
(8+7
E(4H8@
@(+A@)*
+87
((+P
()*@7(H)E)(47
-&"-
*48EE8
7*+7
E84(*@
7A+(@E@H
+7
(7+6(E4(4E8((4@+7HE4*+A
4EAE8
*+H
7E@EH8
(A+(((AA
+84
0()*E1+
4-
''
#
-
()*(
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents299 300(@+6'()7AH@@)A47*A
'/"(
@))*(8
78+4
@4E7(7
()+E(**H
+84
(*+'#(8H)E(@7E(*A8
7@+*
@7EE8*
7)+)
77A(*@
78+H7EH)
+7
(E+6#@4A@A)
)(7E
7+*
7H)77
4+4
(*)E4*
@)+47E))
+4
(A+#'7H44H*478EE(HA4(+*
*)E*A7
$."(
@84@H4
(8+4@H)
+8(
(4+#
(7A8+*A@(8E4)87H@+)
A(@8@
*+)
(7A77)
(8+87HA
+87
(H+
(48E847
(@(@)AH44+(
((*4@H
A+4
7A)8(4
(E+H7HE
+87
()+.+
(7@7A(HA)))*E
EA+4
4EE@E
A+(
@)8(*@
@(+A*AA
+8*
78+
*777(*@7H*(7A(A4+@
*8))8E
)+4
)E8774
77+E(EH*A
+*
7(+.#A87@4EH*AA*+E*H44+*
@*8A4A
E+4
)EE)A7
(E+)7@77
+8*
77+G46'7HHHH8@(H4(@@AA*+*
E74*)A
(H+@
*4H4*7
(A+A)E*)
+@
7@+#6@E*)8(87EA487447+@
*74AA4
(7+(
*H8)A7
(@+A)@E4
+7
7*+''
@HA8(@)7)4E)8(44+(
774A*@
E+)
AE7@(H
(A+)*7H
+8(
7E+;77(4*87(H8@)@4H(+@
H(H(4
@+4
@@8+*)*
(*+)E@E
+87
7A+-
##7(E@7)A(A8E(H@4*+E
E487*
7+A
*8(8E8
(H+A@)E
+87
74+-
##7*48E@
4748
7+)
7H@
+(*E)H
(+)
A8
+87
=
+
7H+
(H7H7(A((884(@A8+7
@(*HEA
(4+7
*8A77@
77+7(8E4
+8A
A8@8AE7E@@88E*@*E*+4
4@4H+)48(7+7
(4A@88E*7)+@((8)7@
+7
0()*E1
.
&
=
-
-
'
W
'
W
'
W
'
W
'
W
'
B
(+PA*((H(7@7)E8@A+@E()A(
H+(
@4**
+A3
3(4@HEE74+(
7+
@((AA87(H)7((4A8+4@A*E(8((+47E)8
+8H3
34HE88*7E+7
@+P((HAAE(EEE
(+@
A@
+8E(78
+(3
3(7A4A(8+4
=
*+;#=(H)A*(E@(
+7*E
+87)
3
3*(E@
7+7
E+/=(E74HA(8(
+8A77
+8(;
3
37*7E
(+A
B
3
3
A+'(8(*7HE*AH)7**A+77@*@*
7+@
7A)
+8@3
37H74H)74+)
4+P'(7A*788@A(E77@)(E)8)7
*+4
(8@H
+8H3
3A@4*E4E8+*
H+#4@A4)((78))E(A+*()+*4E
7+A
A@A4
+H3
3@7H7H@**+A
)+;%##4(8H887E8((@@E+7E)7(*
H+@
*8*)
+A3
377)(@4@7+7
H-
''
-
()*(
Gandhi, Ambedkar and Jinnah on Self-Determination Documents301 302
(8+#(+84*+4*(E(+4A)
*+H
E8(H*
*+4
(E7AH
(+*3
3E)@884EE+7
((+/'H)*H*7**+E4)
E+8
*@E74
*+)
+@4HA
+*3
3*E4E8)E(+(
(7+=7@@EA)(8@)H
*+E
4H)
+@(
3
3(@E(HE+H
(@+A8((H
HA*
(+*
@))(
A+A
*HA
+H3
3(*+A8E7*+@
G46
(*+'AE(7
A(
+)4*
(+(
7@
+*3
37+E(*
@H+A
G46
(8+78*4@@@**7*4)@@+4A4A7)(A+A
@44E8
+*@*A*
+8@@E@A)@7@*+A
+-+
+-+
'
.
.
;.
;.
'
'
'
=>
4)A7@8
4EA88*
)*+)
*877A
E+(
.
E8AE@)
*H@E4E
)AE
77)A*
*+E
%
HE(H@@
4A)EH)
)8+*
H77**
)+A
P
7H)*8*
7AA77*
)7+8
7@(H8
H+8
7)E)@8
7E4A*H
H4(
@H7H7
(7+)
+&+P+
7)H(@(
7EE4E4
HE+H
*7@4*
(*+7
0()*E1
0()*E1
); +G46+$''
.''
-
()*(
& & 0&;,/1%788(-=#C$/+&6$ & + % $()*4%+
&'7(%#'+&;,/!%'9 % '%+ %
#'%#5'!'
C$/+%#%%
#''+
='0=1 &;,/ $+ '%
''$%# > & $%'+ '' $%+M''#
%%&;,/+
% '+ ' '' &;,/+M''$''
# M$
+
$% 9' '' &+
304
,
www.eiwo.org