TN 2012-06-08 - (WDTN - LLF - PLANTIFFS’ RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS’ MOTION FOR SANCTIONS

7/31/2019 TN 2012-06-08 - (WDTN - LLF - PLANTIFFS RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SANCTIONS

1/23

4 ia 06

_GK]OM V]D]OV MKV]PKF] FI_P]

AIP ]BO \OV]OPG MKV]PKF] IA ]OGGOVVOO

CK@OP][ COLDC AI_GMD]KIG:

HIBG M_EEO]]:COIGDPM QICIMDPVJ[:

FPOL EDPIGO[#

^cdkg}kaav

FDVO GI8 0840%fq%>04=6%flfq'

GD]KIGDC MOEIFPD]KF ^DP][

ia }bo _VD# Kgf':MOEIFPD]KF GD]KIGDC FIEEK]]OO:

MO@@KO \DVVOPEDG VFB_C]X# dgm

FBK^ AIPPOV]OP

Moaogmdg}v

^CDG]KAAVPOVÎGVO KG I^ÎVK]KIG ]I MOAOGMDG]V EI]KIG AIP

VDGF]KIGV

"BODPKGL POT_OV]OM+

ûpvudg} }i Aomopdc Puco ia Fkqkc ^pifomupo dgm }bkv Fiup}v Pucov# ^cdkg}kaav vuèk} }bkv

pov~igvo kg i~~ivk}kig }i Moaogmdg}v ei}kig aip vdgf}kigv ZMif'0?U' ]bo ^cdkg}kaav potuov} d

bodpkgl ig }bkv ei}kig'

K' Moaogmdg}v dgm }bokp Fiugvoc Jgi|kglc{ Ckom }i ]bkv Fiup}]bo Moaogmdg}v ei}kig aip vdgf}kigv dldkgv} }bo ^cdkg}kaav ZMif'0?U# vklgom `{ Moaogvo

fiugvoc# kgfcumov d} codv} }bpoo adf}udc dffuvd}kigv }bd} dpo ~piqog adcvo `{ orbk`k}v ia pofipm kg

}bo kgv}dg} ck}kld}kig'

D' Fop}kakfd}kigv }i }bo ]oggovvoo Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}o apie }bo MGF]bo ]GM^ Moaogmdg}v dgm Fiugvoc dvvop}# dv lpiugmv aip }bokp ei}kig aip vdgf}kigv

dldkgv} }bo ^cdkg}kaav# }bd} }bo ]GM^ kv }bo ~dp}{ }bd} fop}kakov }bo Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{v giekgoo

Fdvo 0840%fq%>04=6%V]D%flf Mifueog} 0; Akcom >1)>2)40 ^dlo 4 ia 06 ^dloKM 6;4


2/23

0 ia 06

aip ^povkmog} ia }bo _gk}om V}d}ov }i }bo ]oggovvoo Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}ov Mkqkvkig ia Ocof}kigv'

Mif'0? d} =' ]bo ]GM^ Moaogmdg}v ei}kig liov ig }i v}d}o# k} kv }bo ]GM^v vico

pov~igvk`kck}{ }i mo}opekgo bi| Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ giekgoov dpo mo}opekgom# dgm Aippov}op# }bo

MGFgip }bo GMF _VD bdqo dg{ pico kg }bd} ~pifovv' Km' d} 41 "oe~bdvkv dmmom+' Figfcumkgl#

^cdkg}kaav bdqo fcodpc{ gdeom }bovo dmmk}kigdc ~dp}kov aip }bo vico ~up~ivo ia bdpdvvkgl dgm

dggi{kgl }bokp ~ick}kfdc i~~igog}v'Km'

[o} }bo MGF fop}kakfd}o kmog}ka{kgl fdgmkmd}o I`ded dv }bo 0>>2 Moeifpd}kf

^povkmog}kdc fdgmkmd}o }i }bo ]oggovvoo Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}o bdv òog ig pofipm dv dg orbk`k} kg }bo

kgv}dg} fdvo vkgfo Ed{ 6

pm

# eipo }bdg }bpoo |oojv òaipo }bo ]GM^ Moaogmdg}v akcom }bokp

ei}kig aip vdgf}kigv' Voo Mif'0>%4' ]bo MGF fop}kakfd}o |dv vklgom `{ }bog%MGF Fbdkpedg#

Gdgf{ ôcivk'Km'

]bo 0>>2 MGF fop}kakfd}o }i }bo ]oggovvoo Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}o ~piqov }bd} }bo MGF dgm

k}v fbdkpedg bkv}ipkfdcc{ fop}kakov }bo Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{v giekgoo aip ^povkmog} ia }bo _gk}om

V}d}ov }i }bo ]oggovvoo Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}ov Mkqkvkig ia Ocof}kigv dgm dpo# }bopoaipo# d`vicu}oc{

~pi~op ~dp}kov }i }bo kgv}dg} ck}kld}kig' K} dcvi ~piqov }bd} }bo ]GM^ Moaogmdg}v dccold}kig }bd}

^cdkg}kaav gdeom }bo MGF dgm Vfbuc}x aip }bo vico ~up~ivo ia bdpdvvkgl dgm dggi{kgl }boe#

|dv dg kg}og}kigdc d}}oe~} `{ }bo ]GM^ Moaogmdg}v }i mofokqo }bkv Fiup}'4

@' ^cdkg}kaa Mueeo}}v ^d~opv Akcom |k}b }bo ]G Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}o]bo ]GM^ Moaogmdg}v ei}kig aip vdgf}kigv dldkgv} }bo ^cdkg}kaav dcvi dvvop}v }bd}

^cdkg}kaa Mueeo}} bdv gi} dccolom }bd} bo bdv akcom ~d~opv |k}b }bo ]oggovvoo Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}o

4 ]oggovvoo Ocof}kig fimo miov gi} vu~~ip} Moaogmdg}v dvvop}kig }bd} }bo ]GM^ kv vicoc{

pov~igvk`co aip }bkv fop}kakfd}kig' ]bo adf} }bd} }bo MGF dgm k}v fbdkpedg bdm df}udcc{ fop}kakom

}bo Moeifpd}kf fdgmkmd}o kg }bo ~dv} codqov gi podvigd`co ~opvig |k}b dg{ miu`} }bd} }bo MGF kvckjoc{ }i mi vi dldkg# poldpmcovv ia |bd} ]oggovvoo fimo vd{v ig }bo ed}}op# dgm }bo MGF dgm k}v

Fbdkpedg dpo }bopoaipo ~pi~op ~dp}kov }i }bkv ck}kld}kig'



3/23

6 ia 06

}i d~~odp ig }bo `dcci} kg ]oggovvoo' \bkco }bkv fcoqopc{ fpda}om v}d}oeog} kv }ofbgkfdcc{ }puo# k}

kv dcvi d |kccauc mofo~}kig ig }bo ~dp} ia moaogvo fiugvoc' Ig Ed{ 42 }b ^cdkg}kaav akcom dv dg

orbk`k} kg }bo kgv}dg} fdvo# ^cdkg}kaa Mueeo}}v ]oggovvoo Fop}kakfd}o ia \pk}o%Kg Fdgmkmdf{# dv

akcom |k}b }bo ]oggovvoo Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}o' Mif'0=%0' ]bkv orbk`k} |dv akcom |k}b }bkv Fiup} dgm

|dv ~dp} ia }bo pofipm kg }bo kgv}dg} fdvo eipo }bdg d |ooj òaipo moaogvo fiugvoc vklgom bkv

ei}kig aip vdgf}kigv# fcdkekgl }bd} ^cdkg}kaa Mueeo}} bdv gi} dccolom }bd} bo bdv akcom ~d~opv

|k}b }bo ]oggovvoo Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}o }i d~~odp ig }bo `dcci} kg ]oggovvoo'

]i edjo vufb d v}d}oeog} }i }bkv Fiup}# |k}b aucc jgi|comlo }bd} ^cdkg}kaa Mueeo}} bdv

kg adf} akcom vufb ~d~opv# kv d mofo~}kig' Fiufbkgl }bo v}d}oeog} dv ~cdkg}kaa bdv gi} {o} dccolom

miov gi} edjo }bo mofo~}kig dffo~}d`co figmuf} ia dg iaakfop ia }bkv Fiup}' \bog edjkgl dg

dvvop}kig ia adf} ip cd| d}}ipgo{v bdqo d mu}{ }i mkvfcivo kgaiped}kig }i }bo Fiup} |bog }bd}

kgaiped}kig |iucm mkpof}c{ figackf} |k}b }bo dvvop}kig ia adf} ip cd| òkgl edmo `{ }bo d}}ipgo{'

]bkv kv oqog eipo d~~ckfd`co |bog }bo d}}ipgo{ kg tuov}kig kv dffuvkgl dgi}bop d}}ipgo{ ia

~op~o}pd}kgl d apdum ig }bo fiup}'

F' Vopqkfo dgm Vbi|%Fduvo Ipmopv kg }bo Dpkxigd Ck}kld}kigMoaogvo Fiugvoc jgi|kglc{ ekvpo~povog}om }bo gd}upo dgm adf}v ugmopc{kgl vopqkfo ia

~pifovv dgm vbi|%fduvo ipmopv kvvuom kg }bo Dpkxigd ck}kld}kig' VooMif'0? d} 4=' Moaogmdg}v

ei}kig aip vdgf}kigv v}d}ov8

^cdkg}kaav dgm ^cdkg}kaav fiugvoc dpo i~opd}kgl kg `dm adk}b' K} d~~odpv }bd}

}bkv kv gi} }bo akpv} }keo }bd} ^cdkg}kaav bdqo d}}oe~}om }bkv edgouqop dgm }bd} d

vbi| fduvo ipmop bdv òog kvvuom dldkgv} ^cdkg}kaav aip }bkv ordf} vdeo figmuf} kgDpkxigd' Kg }bo Dpkxigd df}kig# ^cdkg}kaav dldkg vopqom }bo GMF _VD# eiqom aip

moaduc} humleog} dldkgv} k}# dcc |bkco adkckgl }i vopqo }bo Moeifpd}kf Gd}kigdc

Fieek}}oo "MGF+ dgm Mo``ko \dvvopedg%Vfbuc}x' ]bkv uc}ked}oc{ povuc}om kg}bo Fiup} kvvukgl d vbi| fduvo ipmop ipmopkgl ^cdkg}kaav }i vbi| vopqkfo u~ig }bo

MGF dgm \dvvopedg%Vfbuc}x'

Mif'0? d} 4=' "kg}opgdc fk}d}kigv moco}om+'



4/23

= ia 06

K} kv d~~dpog} apie }bovo dccold}kigv }bd} Moaogvo fiugvoc bdv v}umkom }bo Dpkxigd

ck}kld}kig# dgm bdv ckjoc{ bdm fig}df} |k}b }bo MGFv d}}ipgo{ kg }bd} ck}kld}kig' [o} bkv

movfpk~}kig ia }bo vbi| fduvo ipmopv dgm }bo }kekgl ia vopqkfo ia ~pifovv kg }bd} fdvo dpo

mofo~}kqo d} òv}'

K} kv fcodp apie }bo pofipm kg }bo Dpkxigd ck}kld}kig }bd} }bo MGF |dv vopqom d} k}v

\dvbkgl}ig MF iaakfo |k}b d vueeigv dgm akpv} dgm vofigm fie~cdkg} kg }bo Dpkxigd ck}kld}kig

ig Mofoeòp 00# eipo }bdg d eig}b òaipo }bo ei}kig aip moaduc} humleog} dldkgv} }bo GM^

_VD |dv akcom kg }bd} fdvo' ]bd} ~pifovv ekv%gdeom }bo MGF dv }bo GM^ _VD òfduvo d} }bd}

}keo ^cdkg}kaav fiugvoc òckoqom }bd} }bo MGF |dv dg daakckd}o ia }bo GM^ _VD' ]bkv |dv

or~cdkgom }i Moaogvo fiugvoc voqopdc |oojv òaipo bo akcom Moaogmdg}v ei}kig aip vdgf}kigv'

Voo Mif'01%4# Mofc' @og Ldv}oc# d} 4>' Poldpmcovv ia }bo ~pifomupdc oaaof}kqogovv ia }bo

Mofoeòp 00 d}}oe~} d} vopqkfo u~ig }bo MGF# }bo MGF kg adf} pofokqom }bo vueeigv dgm

fie~cdkg} kg ì}b }bo Dpkxigd dgm }bo kgv}dg} cd|vuk}v ig Mofoeòp 00' Mofc' Qdg Kpkig ;: voo

dcvi Or'4# MGF Po}upg Pofok~}' Mov~k}o }bkv adf} Moaogvo fiugvoc# |bi po~povog}v }bo MGF kg

}bo kgv}dg} ck}kld}kig# fbivo }i vklg dgm akco d ei}kig |k}b }bkv Fiup} dffuvkgl ^cdkg}kaav ia

kg}og}kigdcc{ adkckgl }i vopqo }bo MGF dv dg kg}og}kigdc d}}oe~} }i mofokqo }bkv Fiup}'

Fuppog} MGF Fbdkpedg Mo``ko \dvvopedg%Vfbuc}x |dv dcvi vopqom d} bop \dvbkgl}ig

MF iaakfo ig Hdgudp{ 6>' ]bkv vueeigv |dv mkpof}om }i Moaogmdg} Vfbuc}x dgm }bkv fie~cdkg}

~pi~opc{ gdeom ì}b bop dgm }bo MGF' ]bd} d}}oe~} d} vopqkfo |dv dcvi df}udcc{ pofokqom `{

Vfbuc}x# dv figakpeom `{ }bo _'V' îv} Iaakfo ZMof' Kpkig 4>: voo dcvi Or'0U# ù} |dv gi} coldcc{

vuaakfkog} igc{ òfduvo }bo fop}kakom edkc po}upg pofok~} |dv goqop mockqopom }i }bo ^cdkg}kaav'0

0K} kv qop{ kg}opov}kgl }bd} Moaogmdg} Vfbuc}x fbivo }i gi} pov~igm }i }bo vueeigv mockqopom }i

bop ig Hdgudp{ 6>' Vopqkfo u~ig Moaogmdg} Vfbuc}x |iucm bdqo òog vuaakfkog} aip d moaduc}

Fdvo 0840%fq%>04=6%V]D%flf Mifueog} 0; Akcom >1)>2)40 ^dlo = ia 06 ^dloKM 6;=


5/23

? ia 06

Dldkg# poldpmcovv ia }bo coldc vuaakfkogf{ ia vopqkfo# }bo MGF dgm k}v Fbdkpedg bdm df}udc gi}kfo

ia }bo Dpkxigd dgm }bo kgv}dg} cd|vuk}v d} codv} }|kfo òaipo Hdgudp{ 6>' Dldkg# Moaogvo

fiugvocv dffuvd}kig }bd} }bo ^cdkg}kaav df}om kg `dm adk}b dgm adkcom }i vopqo }bo Moeifpd}kf

Gd}kigdc Fieek}}oo "MGF+ dgm Mo``ko \dvvopedg%Vfbuc}x# fiu~com |k}b dg dffuvd}kig }bd}

^cdkg}kaav kg}ogmom }i mofokqo dg{ fiup}# fdggi} ò vu~~ip}om `{ dg{ podvigd`co d}}ipgo{ d|dpo ia

}bo adf}v dqdkcd`co }i Moaogvo fiugvoc d} }bo }keo bo vklgom dgm akcom Moaogmdg}v ei}kig aip

vdgf}kigv'

\k}b }bkv `dfjlpiugm kg ekgm# }bo akpv} vbi|%fduvo ipmop kvvuom `{ }bo Dpkxigd Fiup}

ZMif'01%4U |dv vke~c{ }bd} fiup}v potuov} }bd} ^cdkg}kaav or~cdkg |bd} cd| vu~~ip}v vopqkfo ia

~pifovv qkd fop}kakom edkc' ^cdkg}kaav pov~igmom# fk}kgl Aomopdc Pucov ia Fkqkc ^pifomupo dgm

Dpkxigd v}d}o cd|' Voo Or'6# DX Pov~' }i Ip' Vbi| Fduvo' ]bo Dpkxigd Fiup} figfcumom }bd} }bo

pucov fk}om `{ }bo ^cdkg}kaav d~~ckom }i kgmkqkmudcv# ù} gi} }i fip~ipd}kigv' ]bo Dpkxigd Fiup}v

figfcuvkig mkm gi} fk}o dg{ ~poqkiuv du}bipk}{ kg vu~~ip} ia k}v figfcuvkig' Voo Or'=' Poldpmcovv#

gok}bop }bkv ipmop gip }bo ^cdkg}kaavpov~igvo# gip }bo fiup}v figfcuvkig# vu~~ip} ip ke~c{ dg{ ia

}bo ekvmoomv dccolom `{ }bo ]GM^ Moaogmdg}v# òfduvo }bkv |dv d vke~co orfbdglo poldpmkgl

coldc vuaakfkogf{ ia vopqkfo'

Moaogvo fiugvocv fk}d}kig }i mifueog}v apie }bo Dpkxigd ck}kld}kig# dgm bkv dffuvd}kigv

poldpmkgl }bo vdeo# kgmkfd}o }bd} bo |dv d|dpo ia }bo }puo gd}upo ia }bo ipmop }i vbi| fduvo# {o}

bo fbivo }i vklg d ei}kig aip vdgf}kigv edjkgl dccold}kigv }bd} dpo fcodpc{ gi} }puo'

humleog} dldkgv} bop bdm }bo po}upg pofok~} òog po}upgom }i }bo ^cdkg}kaav dgm akcom' [o}Moaogmdg} Vfbuc}x adkcom }i pov~igm }i }bd} vueeigv dgm fie~cdkg}' K} |iucm ò odv{ }i dvvueo

}bd} Moaogmdg} Vfbuc}x vieobi| jgo| }bd} }bo po}upg pofok~} |iucm goqop ò akcom' Lkqog }bo

bkv}ip{ ia Figlpovvkigdc dùvo ia }bo îv} Iaakfo# dg dffuvd}kig }bd} Moaogmdg} Vfbuc}x }de~opom|k}b }bo _'V' edkc kv eufb covv d`vupm }bdg }bo dffuvd}kigv dldkgv} d}}ipgo{ Kpkig' Bi|oqop#

d}}ipgo{ Kpkig |kcc gi} edjo vufb d vopkiuv dffuvd}kig |k}biu} mkpof} oqkmogfo'

Fdvo 0840%fq%>04=6%V]D%flf Mifueog} 0; Akcom >1)>2)40 ^dlo ? ia 06 ^dloKM 6;?


6/23

1 ia 06

]bo vofigm ipmop }i vbi| fduvo apie }bo Dpkxigd cd|vuk} |dv ~poed}upo dv }i }bo MGF

òfduvo }bo MGF bdm gi} òog dmmom }i }bo cd|vuk} ug}kc cd}o Hdgudp{' 6 ]bkv |dv ~ikg}om iu} }i

}bo Dpkxigd Fiup} kg }bo ^cdkg}kaav pov~igvo# dgm }bo MGF |dv ~opvigdcc{ vopqom ugmop k}v

~pi~op gdeo huv} md{v cd}op' ^cdkg}kaav pov~igvo }i }bo Dpkxigd Fiup} dcvi or~cdkgom }bd}

Moaogmdg} Vfbuc}x bdm òog vopqom d} bop \dvbkgl}ig MF iaakfo ig Hdgudp{ 6># da}op voqopdc

d}}oe~}v d} mkaaopog} dmmpovvov' ^cdkg}kaav pov~igvo dcvi or~cdkgom }bd} }bo{ bdm gi} {o} po}upgom

}bo vueeigv aip Moaogmdg} Vfbuc}x òfduvo }bo{ |opo d|dk}kgl }bo Dpkxigd Fiup}v figfcuvkig

poldpmkgl vopqkfo qkd fop}kakom edkc ugmop Dpkxigd cd|# dv mkvfuvvom kg ^cdkg}kaav pov~igvo }i }bo

akpv} vbi| fduvo ipmop' Or'?# DX Pov~' }i Ip' Vbi| Fduvo 0'

@i}b vbi| fduvo ipmopv |opo kvvuom eig}bv da}op }bo MGF dgm Vfbuc}x bdm df}udc

jgi|comlo ia }bo Dpkxigd cd|vuk}v' @i}b |opo vke~c{ piu}kgo potuov}v aip kgaiped}kig apie }bo

Dpkxigd Fiup}' @i}b |opo ~pi~opc{ pov~igmom }i' Gok}bop povuc}om kg }bo Dpkxigd Fiup} }djkgl

dg{ df}kig dldkgv} }bo ^cdkg}kaav i}bop }bdg mog{kgl d moaduc} ei}kig dgm potukpkgl mkaaopog}

eo}bimv ia vopqkfo' Gok}bop ipmop vu~~ip}v }bo ]GM^ Moaogmdg}v dffuvd}kigv }bd} }bo ^cdkg}kaav

dpo i~opd}kgl kg `dm adk}b' Mif'0? d} 4='

Moaogvo fiugvocv fk}d}kig }i }bo Dpkxigd Fiup}v ipmopv dgm dffuvd}kigv poldpmkgl }bo

Dpkxigd ck}kld}kig vu~~ip}v }bo figfcuvkig }bd} bo jgo| }bd} }bo MGF bdm òog vopqom |oojv

òaipo }bivo ipmopv kvvuom# dgm |oojv òaipo dg{ ei}kig aip moaduc} |dv akcom' [o} bo fbivo }i

vklg d ei}kig akcom |k}b }bkv Fiup} fcdkekgl }bd} }bo ^cdkg}kaav df}om kg `dm adk}b `{ kg}og}kigdcc{

adkckgl }i vopqo }bo MGF dgm k}v Fbdkpedg# dgm }bd} }bo Dpkxigd Fiup} kvvuom d vbi| fduvo ipmop

dldkgv} ^cdkg}kaav aip }bkv ordf} vdeo figmuf}' Moaogvo fiugvocv dvvop}kigv dpo d cko `{

iekvvkig# d} òv}'

6 ^cdkg}kaav fiugvoc dmmom }bo MGF dv viig dv bo òfdeo d|dpo }bd} }bo MGF ed{ gi} ò

daakckd}om |k}b }bo GM^ _VD'



7/23

< ia 06

Moaogvo fiugvocv euc}k~co ekvpo~povog}d}kigv }i }bkv Fiup} gi} igc{ vu~~ip} mogkdc ia

Moaogmdg}v ei}kig aip vdgf}kigv# }bo{ dpo }boevocqov vdgf}kigd`co figmuf}'

KK'

Vdao Bdpìp ^piqkvkigv Gi} Aicci|om

Oqog ka Moaogmdg}v ei}kig |opo gi} akccom |k}b ekvpo~povog}d}kigv }i }bkv

Fiup}# }bokp ei}kig euv} ò MOGKOM òfduvo Moaogmdg}v mkm gi} vopqo ^cdkg}kaav

|k}b d fi~{ ia }bokp ei}kig aip vdgf}kigv ug}kc }bo md{ vdkm ei}kig |dv akcom |k}b

}bkv Fiup}' Moaogmdg}v fiugvoc mkm vopqo d gi}kfo ia }bokp kg}og}}i akco d Puco 44

ei}kig# kg }bo aipe ia d co}}op' Voo Mofc' @oghdekg Ldv}oc Mif'01%4 d} 4 ! =%2'

Bi|oqop# vopqkgl d co}}op%gi}kfo }bd} d ~dp}{ kg}ogmv }i akco d ei}kig kv gi} }bo

vdeo dv vopqkgl }bd} ei}kig ugmop }bo Aomopdc Pucov ia Fkqkc ^pifomupo'

Puco 44 v}d}ov kg pocoqdg} ~dp}8

]bo ei}kig euv} ò vopqom ugmop Puco ?# ù} k} euv} gi} ò akcom ip ò

~povog}om }i }bo fiup} ka }bo fbdccoglom ~d~op# fcdke# moaogvo# fig}og}kig# ip

mogkdc kv |k}bmpd|g ip d~~pi~pkd}oc{ fippof}om |k}bkg 04 md{v da}op vopqkfo ip|k}bkg dgi}bop }keo }bo fiup} vo}v' "oe~bdvkv dmmom+'

]bo 1}b Fkpfuk} bdv figfcumom# ZDUmbopkgl }i }bo puco,v or~ckfk} cdgludlo dgm iqopdcc

v}puf}upo# |o bicm }bd} vdgf}kigv ugmop Puco 44 dpo ugdqdkcd`co ugcovv }bo ei}kigaip vdgf}kigv kv

vopqomig }bo i~~ivkgl ~dp}{ aip }bo aucc }|og}{%igo md{ vdao bdpìp ~opkim òaipo k} kv akcom

|k}b ip ~povog}om }i }bo fiup}'Pkmmop q' Fk}{ ia V~pkglakocm# 4>; A'6m 022# 0;< "1}b

Fkp' 4;;


8/23

2 ia 06

fimo }bd} |opo gi} eog}kigom kg Moaogvo fiugvocv co}}op%gi}kfo ia kg}og} }i akco' Fie~dpo

Mif'0? dgmMif'01%4 d} =%2'

Puco 44v ~cdkg cdgludlo potukpov vopqkfo ia }bo ei}kig 04 md{v ~pkip }i akckgl' Oqog ka

}bd} potukpoeog} |opo gi} }djog }i eodg |bd} k} vd{v# k} fop}dkgc{ potukpov dg i~~ip}ugk}{ }i ò

~povog}om |k}b }bo du}bipk}{ dgm dplueog}v }i ò akcom |k}b }bo fiup}' Moaogmdg}v co}}op%gi}kfo

adkcom }i mi eipo }bdg lkqo gi}kfo ia }bo logopdc lpiugmv u~ig |bkfb }bokp kg}ogmom ei}kig

|iucm ò aiugmom' K} fop}dkgc{ adkcom }i aucakcc Puco 44v vdao bdpìp ~piqkvkig'

KKK' Moaogmdg}v Dccold}kigv dpo Moeigv}pd`c{ AdcvoOqog ka Moaogmdg}v ei}kig |opo gi} akccom |k}b ekvpo~povog}d}kigv }i }bkv Fiup} dgm

Moaogvo Fiugvoc bdm ~pi~opc{ vopqom }bo ^cdkg}kaav 04 md{v òaipo akckgl# Moaogmdg}v ei}kig

|iucm v}kcc adkc òfduvo }bo dffuvd}kigv fig}dkgom |k}bkg vdkm ei}kig dpo moeigv}pd`c{ adcvo'

D' @dfjlpiugm8 Podvigd`co Kgtukp{@dvom u~ig bkv ~po%ck}kld}kig povodpfb# d}}ipgo{ Kpkig podvigd`c{ òckoqom }bd} }bo

Gd}kigdc Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ ia }bo _VD# Kgf' "GM^_VD+ |dv d gd}kigdc ipldgkxd}kig }bd} bdm

polkv}opom }i mi ùvkgovv |k}bkg }bo v}d}o ia ]oggovvoo# dgm }bd} poldpmcovv ia }bo }puo gd}upo ia

}bo GM^_VD k} |dv fop}dkgc{ fd~d`co ia d}}oe~}kgl }i fop}ka{ fdgmkmd}o I`ded }i }bo ]oggovvoo

Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}o'

k' Fieeugkfd}kigv |k}b Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}ov Iaakfo^pkip }i akckgl }bo kgv}dg} ck}kld}kig d}}ipgo{ Kpkig v~ijo |k}b d v}daaop d} }bo ]oggovvoo

Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}ov iaakfo poldpmkgl v}dgmdpm i~opd}kgl ~pifomupov aip ^povkmog}kdc ocof}kigv'

Mofc' Qdg Kpkig 0' ]bd} v}daaop kgaipeom d}}ipgo{ Kpkig }bd} }bo Gd}kigdc Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{

dc|d{v vogmv d gi}kfo }i dcc Vofpo}dpkov ia V}d}o fop}ka{kgl }bo gdeo ia }bo ^dp}{v fdgmkmd}o' Km'



9/23

; ia 06

]bd} v}daaop dcvi kgaipeom d}}ipgo{ Kpkig }bd} |k}biu} vufb fop}kakfd}kig apie }bo gd}kigdc ~dp}{

ipldgkxd}kig# }bo Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}o |iucm gi} ~cdfo }bo ^dp}{v fdgmkmd}ov gdeo ig }bo

]oggovvoo `dcci}'Km'

kk' Vodpfb aip Moeifpd}kf Og}k}kovD}}ipgo{ Kpkig }bog vodpfbom }bo ]oggovvoo Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}ov pofipmv aip kgaiped}kig

ig dg{ og}k}{ i~opd}kgl |k}b }bo }opev Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ ip Gd}kigdc Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{' Km'd}

6' Vkgfo dcc og}k}kov mikgl ùvkgovv |k}bkg ip |k}b }bo v}d}o ia ]oggovvoo dpo potukpom }i polkv}op

|k}b }bo v}d}o# d}}ipgo{ Kpkig dvvueom }bd} }bo Gd}kigdc Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ ipldgkxd}kig |iucm ò

polkv}opom' ]bo GM^_VD |dv }bo igc{ og}k}{ }bd} d~~odpom }i ò d gd}kigdc Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{

ipldgkxd}kig'Km'

D fi~{ ia d pofog} vodpfb kv d}}dfbom vbi|kgl }bd} }bo GM^_VD kv }bo igc{ ipldgkxd}kig

}bd} fieov u~ kg d vodpfb aip Gd}kigdc Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{' Or'1' D fi~{ ia dgi}bop pofog} vodpfb

kv d}}dfbom vbi|kgl }bd} Moeifpd}kf Fidck}kig Kgf' dgm Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ ia ]oggovvoo Kgf'

fieo u~ |bog vodpfbkgl aip Moeifpd}kf' Or'04=6%V]D%flf Mifueog} 0; Akcom >1)>2)40 ^dlo ; ia 06 ^dloKM 6;;


10/23

4> ia 06

\bd} Moaogmdg}v mig} poqodc }i }bkv Fiup} kv }bo adf} }bd} GM^_VD bdv akqo mkaaopog}

gdeov polkv}opom |k}b }bo ]oggovvoo Vofpo}dp{ ia V}d}o8 }bkv igo og}k}{ kv jgi|g dv Moeifpd}kf

^dp}{ ia ]oggovvoo Kgf'# Moeifpd}kf Fidck}kig Kgf'# Vboc`{ Fiug}{ Po~u`ckfdg ^dp}{ Kgf'#

Gig%^dp}kvdg Fidck}kig aip @o}}op Liqopgeog}# dgm }bo Gd}kigdc Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ ia }bo

_VD Kgf' Or'2'

Moaogmdg}v dcvi adkc }i ~ikg} iu} }i }bkv Fiup} }bd} }bo Gd}kigdc Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ ia }bo

_VD v}d}ov dv k}v ~up~ivo8 ]i pdkvo augmv# Giekgd}o dgm Ocof} Moeifpd}v kg dcc ?> v}d}ov kg }bo

_gk}om V}d}ov' Voo Mif'01%4# Mofc' Ldv}oc# d} 4?'

Ck`op}{ Coldc Aiugmd}kigv kgqov}kld}ipv bdqo pofog}c{ figakpeom }bd} }bo d~~dpog}

ipldgkxop ia }bo Gd}kigdc Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ ia }bo _VD |dv d polkv}opom Moeifpd} qi}op kg 0>4>'

Mofc' Qdg Kpkig 404=6%V]D%flf Mifueog} 0; Akcom >1)>2)40 ^dlo 4> ia 06 ^dloKM =>>


11/23

44 ia 06

ugfcodp |bi aipeom }bo GM^_VD ip |b{ k} |dv aipeom ip |bd} i}bop og}k}kov k} ed{ ò

dvvifkd}om |k}b' D}}ipgo{ Kpkigv dvvue~}kig }bd} GM^_VD kv daakckd}om |k}b }bo gd}kigdc coqoc ia

}bo Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ kv adp eipo podvigd`co }bdg }bo Moaogmdg}v dvvue~}kig }bd} }bo vdeo

og}k}{ d~~dpog}c{~ivvk`c{~ivvk`c{ ed{ ò d goadpkiuv }pkfj `{ }bo Po~u`ckfdgv'

Fig}pdp{ }i Moaogmdg}v dvvop}kig# }bopo v}kcc kv gi oqkmogfo }bd} |iucm codm d podvigd`co

d}}ipgo{ }i }bo fop}dkg figfcuvkig }bd} }bo Gd}kigdc Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ ia }bo _VD# Kgf' kv gi}

daakckd}om |k}b }bo MGF ip }bo Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ kg dg{ |d{' Mif'02 d} 2' ]bo Moaogmdg}v v}kcc

bdqo ~pimufom gi oqkmogfo }i vu~~ip} vufb d figfcuvkig' ]bo igc{ kgaiped}kig poqodcom voqog

eig}bv da}op }bo akckgl ia }bkv cd|vuk} kv }bd} }bo GM^_VD bdv akqo gdeov dgm }bd} igo ia }bovo

gdeov miov gi} vooe }i ak} |k}b }bo i}bopv# dgm }bd} }bo v}d}om ~up~ivo ia }bo GM^_VD kv }i

pdkvo augmv# Giekgd}o dgm Ocof} Moeifpd}v kg dcc ?> v}d}ov kg }bo _gk}om V}d}ov' ]bkv ~piqov

gi}bkgl i}bop }bdg }bo adf} }bd} }bo Moaogmdg}v dpo |kcckgl }i mofokqo }bkv Fiup} `{ ke~c{kgl }bd}

}bo GM^_VD bdv igc{ }|i gdeov' K} fop}dkgc{ miov gi} figfcuvkqoc{ ~piqo }bd} }bo GM^_VD kv

gi} daakckd}om |k}b }bo MGF ip Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ kg dg{ |d{'

@dvom ig }bo kgaiped}kig dqdkcd`co dìu} }bo GM^_VD k} |iucm ò huv} dv podvigd`co }i

dvvueo }bd} }bo Moaogmdg}v vo} u~ }bo GM^_VD dv d }pd~ aip ug|dp{ d}}ipgo{v d}}oe~}kgl }i vuo

}bo gd}kigdc coqoc ia }bo Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{' ]bo dffuvd}kigv dldkgv} d}}ipgo{ Kpkig dpo dv

ugpodvigd`co dgm ugvu~~ip}om dv dg dffuvd}kig }bd} }bo kgv}dg} ei}kig aip vdgf}kigv kv }bo povuc}

ia d vfboeo `{ }bo Moaogmdg}v }i dffuvo ug|dp{ d}}ipgo{v ia ficcumkgl |k}b d vbde ipldgkxd}kig

|bkfb }bo Moaogmdg}v vo} u~ }boevocqov'

MGF' Mofc' Kpkig d} 1' Ka }bopo kv gi vufb dvvifkd}kig ò}|oog }bovo ipldgkxd}kigv# d moaduc}

humleog} |iucm bdqo migo gi}bkgl }i fup}dkc }bo df}kqk}kov ia }bo MGF' Ka }bopo kv dg dvvifkd}kigò}|oog }bovo ipldgkxd}kigv# }bo MGF |iucm bdqo òog aipfom }i moaogm }bo GM^_VD' ]bo

ei}kig aip moaduc} |dv kg}ogmom }i ò d tukfj dgm vke~co eo}bim }i vo} dvkmo }bkv kvvuo' Km'

Fdvo 0840%fq%>04=6%V]D%flf Mifueog} 0; Akcom >1)>2)40 ^dlo 44 ia 06 ^dloKM =>4


12/23

40 ia 06

D}}ipgo{ Kpkig edjov gi vufb |kcm dffuvd}kigv òfduvo d}}ipgo{ Kpkig bdv gi mkpof}

oqkmogfo }i vu~~ip} vufb dffuvd}kigv' Ia fiupvo }bo Moaogmdg}v bdqo gi oqkmogfo }i vu~~ip}

}bokp dffuvd}kigv ok}bop# òfduvo }bokp dffuvd}kigv dpo fie~co}oc{ adcvo'

F' Moaogmdg}v Dffuvd}kig ]bd} D}}ipgo{ Kpkig D}}oe~}om }i Joo~ }bo Kgv}dg}Cd|vuk} d Vofpo} apie }bo MGF kv ^piqd`c{ Adcvo

Igo iaMoaogmdg}v dffuvd}kigv kv }bd} d}}ipgo{ Kpkig vieobi| jgo| }bd} }bo Gd}kigdc

Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ ia }bo _VD# Kgfip~ipd}om "GM^_VD+ kv d vbde ipldgkxd}kig# dgm }bd} d}}ipgo{

Kpkig mofkmom }i }djo dmqdg}dlo ia }bkv kgaiped}kig `{ gdekgl GM^_VD kg ipmop }i lo} d moaduc}

humleog} dldkgv} GM^_VD' Mif'0? d} 46%4=' Moaogmdg}v ei}kig dvvop}v }bd} d}}ipgo{ Kpkig

kg}og}kigdcc{ mocd{om vopqkfo ia }bo vueeigv dgm fie~cdkg} u~ig Moaogmdg}v MGF dgm k}v

fuppog} fbdkpedg# Moaogmdg} Vfbuc}x# kg ipmop }i dcci| d}}ipgo{ Kpkig }i akco dg ugi~~ivom

ei}kig aip moaduc} humleog} dldkgv} GM^_VD# òaipo }bo MGF ip Vfbuc}x jgo| dìu} }bo

kgv}dg} cd|vuk}'Km'

]bo adf}v d} bdgm ~piqo }bkv }i ò adcvo'

k' ]kekgl ia Vopqkfo D}}oe~}v Mkv~piqo Moaogmdg}v Dffuvd}kigIg Mofoeòp 1}b d}}ipgo{ Kpkig d}}oe~}om ~opvigdc vopqkfo u~ig Moaogmdg} GM^_VD `{

~opvigdcc{ mockqopkgl d fi~{ ia }bo vueeigv dgm fie~cdkg} }i }bo iaakfo ia }bo Dpkxigd

Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ kg ^biogkr'?

Mofc' Kpkig d}


13/23

46 ia 06

}bo akpv} gdeom moaogmdg}' Km' ]bo edgdlop ia }bd} iaakfo v~ijo dìu} }bo vueeigv dgm

fie~cdkg} |k}b d}}ipgo{ Kpkig# ^cdkg}kaa Mueeo}}# dgm ^cdkg}kaa Mueeo}}v fde~dklg edgdlop'

Km' ]bkv d}}oe~} d} ~opvigdc vopqkfo |dv qkmoi%}d~om dgm ~iv}om ig [iu]uò Mof 4=# 0>44' Km':

Voo [iu]uò qkmoi d} b}}~8))|||'{iu}uò'fie)|d}fb9q5e6uFb}fQf_D "cdv} qkvk}om Ed{ 00#

0>40+ "vbi|kgl }bo Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ v}daaop dfjgi|comlkgl }bo cifd}kig dgm d}}ipgo{ Kpkig

v}d}kgl }bd} }bo cd|vuk} kv dldkgv} }bo Gd}kigdc Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{# dgm vbi|kgl }bo iaakfo

edgdlop edjkgl dg i`vfogo lov}upo d} }bo fdeopd+'

Ka Moaogmdg}v dffuvd}kigv |opo }puo# }bd} d}}ipgo{ Kpkig |dg}om }i joo~ }bo kgv}dg}

cd|vuk} d vofpo} apie }bo MGF# d}}ipgo{ Kpkig |iucm gi} bdqo ~opvigdcc{ mockqopom d fi~{ ia }bo

vueeigv dgm fie~cdkg} }i dg iaakfo ia }bo Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ md{v da}op akckgl'

Dmmk}kigdcc{# eipo }bdg d eig}b òaipo d}}ipgo{ Kpkig akcom d ei}kig aip moaduc} humleog}

dldkgv} GM^_VD bo vog} qkd fop}kakom edkc d fi~{ ia }bo vueeigv dgm akpv} dgm vofigm

fie~cdkg}v# }i }bo MGF d} k}v \dvbkgl}ig MF iaakfo'1

Mofc' Kpkig d} ;' ]bivo mifueog}v |opo

pofokqom `{ }bo MGF òaipo Mofoeòp 00# 0>44' Km': Voo dcvi Or'4' Ka Moaogmdg}v dffuvd}kigv

|opo }puo# }bd} d}}ipgo{ Kpkig |dg}om }i joo~ }bo kgv}dg} cd|vuk} d vofpo} apie }bo MGF# d}}ipgo{

Kpkig |iucm gi} bdqo vog} d fi~{ ia }bo vueeigv dgm fie~cdkg} }i }bo MGFeipo }bdg d eig}b

òaipo bo akcom d ei}kig aip moaduc} humleog}'

Dcvi# |bog D}}ipgo{ Kpkig akcom d ei}kig aip moaduc} humleog} dldkgv} GM^_VD bo

edkcom d fi~{ ia }bd} ei}kig dgm dcc }bpoo fie~cdkg}v }i }bo fuppog} fbdkpedg ia }bo MGF#

Moaogmdg} Vfbuc}x# d} bop Figlpovvkigdc iaakfo kg \dvbkgl}ig MF' Mofc' Kpkig d} 4>' ]bivo

mifueog}v |opo pofokqom `{ Moaogmdg} Vfbuc}x ig Hdgudp{ 6>' Km':Or'0'

1]bo adf} }bd} d}}ipgo{ Kpkig vog} fi~kov ia }bo Fie~cdkg}v dgm vueeigv dldkgv} }bo GM^_VD

}i }bo MGFv \dvbkgl}ig MF iaakfov dcvi ~piqov }bd} d}}ipgo{ Kpkig òckoqom d} }bd} }keo }bd} }boGM^_VD |dv }bo og}k}{ }bd} fiipmkgd}ov }bo Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{v gd}kigdc ipldgkxd}kig'

Fdvo 0840%fq%>04=6%V]D%flf Mifueog} 0; Akcom >1)>2)40 ^dlo 46 ia 06 ^dloKM =>6
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m3uChtcVcUAhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m3uChtcVcUA


14/23

4= ia 06

Dldkg# ka }bo Moaogmdg}v dffuvd}kigv |opo }puo d}}ipgo{ Kpkig |iucm gi} bdqo vog} d fi~{

ia }bo ei}kig aip moaduc} humleog} }i }bo fuppog} fbdkpedg ia }bo MGF# Moaogmdg} Vfbuc}x#

keeomkd}oc{ da}op }bd} ei}kig |dv akcom'

kk' ^povv Pocodvo dgm Eomkd Fiqopdlo Gold}o Moaogmdg}v Dccold}kigKg If}iòp# keeomkd}oc{ da}op akckgl }bo akpv} fie~cdkg}# d}}ipgo{ Kpkig vog} d ~povv pocodvo

}i dcc ia bkv eomkd fig}df}v# kgfcumkgl voqopdc v}daaopv d} Air Go|v dgm d v}daa |pk}op aip \ipcm

Go} Mdkc{ "\GM+' Mofc' Kpkig d} 44: Or';%4>' Ep' Kpkig bdv d~~od pom ig Air Go|v Lpo}d Qdg

Vuv}pog Vbi| dgm Apoomie \d}fb |k}b Dgmpo| Gd~ick}dgi' Mofc' Kpkig d} 44: voo dcvi

b}}~8))ckòp}{coldcaiugmd}kig'ipl)' ]bopoaipo d}}ipgo{ Kpkig or~of}om }bd} Air Go|v |iucm fiqop

}bo kgv}dg} cd|vuk}'

]bo \ipcm Go} Mdkc{ |pk}op# @i` _gpub# polucdpc{ |pk}ov dìu} Ckòp}{ Coldc

Aiugmd}kigv "CCA+ oaaip}v dgm bdv |pk}}og voqopdc }keov dìu} CCAv ocklk`kck}{ cd|vuk}v' Mofc'

Kpkig d} 40' \GM kv podm `{ ekcckigv ia Deopkfdgv' Gi}o }bd} }bo o%edkc vog} }i Ep' _gpub `{

d}}ipgo{ Kpkig bdm d fi~{ ia }bo fie~cdkg} gdekgl GM^_VD dv }bo akpv} gdeom moaogmdg}

d}}dfbom }i k}' Or';' Ep' _gpub bd`k}udcc{ kgfcumov fi~kov ia vufb mifueog}v dv ~dp} ia bkv

dp}kfcov aip \GM' Mofc' Kpkig d} 40' D}}ipgo{ Kpkig kgfcumom }bo mifueog} òfduvo bo |dv

d|dpo ia Ep' _gpubv ~pdf}kfo'Km' ]bo vu`votuog} dp}kfco |dv ~u`ckvbom igckgo ig Giqoeòp 2#

0>44 d} b}}~8))|||'|gm'fie)0>44)44)61>246)' Or' 44'

Bdm d}}ipgo{ Kpkig òog d}}oe~}kgl }i joo~ }bo kgv}dg} cd|vuk} d vofpo} apie }bo MGF# dv

}bo Moaogmdg}v dvvop}# bo |iucm gi} bdqo vog} iu} ~povv pocodvov }i gd}kigdc eomkd iu}co}v }bd}

bdqo polucdpc{ fiqopom bkv df}kqk}kov kg }bo ~dv}'

]bo oqogkgl òaipo d}}ipgo{ Kpkig ~opvigdcc{ vopqom }bo fie~cdkg} d} }bo Dpkxigd

Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{v iaakfo kg ^biogkr bo d~~odpom d} d ]od ^dp}{ eoo}kgl |k}b Vbopkaa Hio Dp~dki

Fdvo 0840%fq%>04=6%V]D%flf Mifueog} 0; Akcom >1)>2)40 ^dlo 4= ia 06 ^dloKM =>=
http://libertylegalfoundation.org/http://libertylegalfoundation.org/


15/23

4? ia 06

}i mkvfuvv }bo cd|vuk}' Mofc' Kpkig d} 2: Mofc' Mueeo}} d} 6' Mo}dkcv |opo mkvfuvvom |k}b

eoeòpv ia }bo eomkd d} }bo eoo}kgl' Mofc' Kpkig d} 2' Fiqopdlo ia }bkv oqog} fdg ò aiugm d}

b}}~8))|||'ordekgop'fie)dp}kfco)ckòp}{%coldc%aiugmd}kig%vopqov%mgf%|k}b%i`ded%ocklk`kck}{%

fie~cdkg}'Voo Or' 40' ]bkv dp}kfco dcvi figakpev }bd} d}}ipgo{ Kpkig òckoqom d} }bd} }keo }bd} }bo

GM^_VD |dv }bo gd}kigdc ipldgkxkgl og}k}{ aip }bo Moeifpd}kf ^dp}{ dgm }bd} k} bdm iaakfov kg

oqop{ v}d}o8 Qdg Kpkig dgm Mueeo}} vopqom }bo MGF d} k}v iaakfo kg ^biogkr ig ]uovmd{' Km'

"movfpk`kgl d}}ipgo{ Kpkigv v}d}oeog}v }i }bo ]od ^dp}{ lpiu~+'

Bdm d}}ipgo{ Kpkig òog d}}oe~}kgl }i joo~ }bo kgv}dg} cd|vuk} d vofpo} apie }bo MGF# dv

}bo Moaogmdg}v dvvop}# bo |iucm gi} bdqo dggiugfom }bo cd|vuk} }i }bo eomkd dgm mixogv ia

eoeòpv ia }bo ~u`ckf kg odpc{ Mofoeòp'

Keeomkd}oc{ u~ig akckgl }bo akpv} fie~cdkg} Ckòp}{ Coldc Aiugmd}kig ~iv}om }bo

fie~cdkg} ig k}v |o` vk}o dgm vog} dg o%edkc eovvdlo }i k}v iqop 6>#>>> eoeòpv |k}b d ckgj }i

}bo fie~cdkg}' Mofc' Kpkig d} 46: voo dcvi b}}~8))ckòp}{coldcaiugmd}kig'ipl)|~%

fig}og})u~cidmv)0>44)4>)FFD%DX%4v}%Dem'%Fie~c'%akcom'~ma' D}}ipgo{ Kpkig kv d|dpo ia }bo

adf} }bd} d} codv} igo fuppog} \bk}o Biuvo v}daaop bdv vklgom u~ ig Ckòp}{ Coldc Aiugmd}kigv o %

edkc edkckgl ckv} kg ipmop }i eigk}ip CCAv df}kqk}kov' Mofc' Kpkig d} 4='

Dldkg# ka d}}ipgo{ Kpkig bdm òog d}}oe~}kgl }i joo~ }bo kgv}dg} cd|vuk} d vofpo} apie }bo

MGF# dv }bo Moaogmdg}v dvvop}# bo |iucm gi} bdqo ~iv}om bkv df}kqk}kov ig CCAv |o` vk}o dgm

vog} iu} polucdp o%edkcv }i iqop 6>#>>> Deopkfdgv# kgfcumkgl d} codv} igo \bk}o Biuvo v}daaop'

]bo Moaogmdg}v dvvop}kig }bd} d}}ipgo{ Kpkig d}}oe~}om }i joo~ }bo kgv}dg} cd|vuk} vofpo}

apie }bo MGF kv d`vupm'

Fdvo 0840%fq%>04=6%V]D%flf Mifueog} 0; Akcom >1)>2)40 ^dlo 4? ia 06 ^dloKM =>?
http://www.examiner.com/article/liberty-legal-foundation-serves-dnc-with-obama-eligibility-complainthttp://www.examiner.com/article/liberty-legal-foundation-serves-dnc-with-obama-eligibility-complainthttp://www.examiner.com/article/liberty-legal-foundation-serves-dnc-with-obama-eligibility-complainthttp://www.examiner.com/article/liberty-legal-foundation-serves-dnc-with-obama-eligibility-complaint


16/23

41 ia 06

M' D}}ipgo{ Kpkigv Euc}k~co D}}oe~}v }i Vopqo GM^_VD Dcc Adkcom# ^piqkgl]bd} Bo Bdv Gi Kgvkmo Kgaiped}kig Dìu} ip Daakckd}kig |k}b GM^_VD

Moaogmdg}v }boip{# }bd} d}}ipgo{ Kpkig jgo| GM^_VD |dv d vbde ipldgkxd}kig# potukpov

dg dvvue~}kig }bd} d}}ipgo{ Kpkig bdm vieo fig}df} |k}b ip jgi|comlo ia }bo ipldgkxopv ia

GM^_VD' Bi|oqop# dg{igo |k}b vufb jgi|comlo |iucm dcvi jgi| bi| }i vuffovvaucc{ vopqo

}bo ipldgkxd}kig' [o} d}}ipgo{ Kpkigv d}}oe~}v }i vopqo GM^_VD d} k}v ]oggovvoo iaakfo |opo dcc

po}upgom dv ugmockqopd`co'> ekcov apie Vboc`{ Fiug}{' D}}ipgo{

Kpkig bdv goqop ~pdf}kfom gip bdm dg{ i}bop fig}df} |k}b dg{ Fiup} ip Fiup} v ~opvigdc kg Vboc`{

Fiug}{ ~pkip }i }bo kgv}dg} cd|vuk}' Gok}bop Ckòp}{ Coldc Aiugmd}kig gip d}}ipgo{ Kpkig bdqo

oqop ~pdf}kfom òaipo dg{ fiup} kg Gdvbqkcco# kgfcumkgl }bo Ekmmco Mkv}pkf} ia ]oggovvoo# |k}b }bo

orfo~}kig ia igo @dgjpu~}f{ fdvo }bd} ogmom adqipd`c{ aip d}}ipgo{ Kpkigv fckog}v }|i {odpv dli'

]bo ^cdkg}kaav mkm gi} ~opaipe dg{ povodpfb poldpmkgl }bo ~ick}kfdc codgkglv# ip dg{ i}bop

fbdpdf}opkv}kfv ia dg{ humlo kg ekmmco ip |ov}opg ]oggovvoo ~pkip }i akckgl }bo kgv}dg} vuk}'

Kg vbip}# }bo ^cdkg}kaav bdm# dgm bdqo# gi ei}kqo }i ov}d`ckvb qoguo kg Vboc`{ Fiug}{# gip

mi }bo{ bdqo dg{ ei}kqo }i dqikm Mdqkmvig Fiug}{'2

]bo ^cdkg}kaav akcom vuk} kg Vboc`{ Fiug}{

aip }bo vke~co podvig }bd} }bo GM^_VD kmog}kakom Eoe~bkv dv }bo cifd}kig ia k}v ]oggovvoo

iaakfo dgm k}v dlog} aip vopqkfo ia ~pifovv';

A' Moaogvo Fiugvoc \dv D|dpo ]bd} Bkv Dffuvd}kigv \opo Adcvo]bkv }keockgo ia }bovo oqog}v kv fcodp kg }bo pofipm dgm Moaogvo fiugvoc kv |occ d|dpo ia

}bovo adf}v# {o} bo kgvkv}om u~ig dffuvkgl d}}ipgo{ Kpkig ia i~opd}kgl kg `dm adk}b' Mif'0? d} 4='

2]bkv vbiucm gi} ò }djog dv dlpooeog} `{ }bo ^cdkg}kaav }i d fbdglo ia qoguo d} }bkv }keo' Gi|

}bd} }bkv fdvo bdv òog ov}d`ckvbom kg }bo \ov}opg Mkv}pkf} }bopo kv gi podvig }i eiqo k}' Dg{ vufbfbdglo ia qoguo |iucm dceiv} fop}dkgc{ fduvo uggofovvdp{ mocd{v kg ck}kld}kig';

Moaogmdg}v gi}o }bd} ]'F'D' =2%4>4%?>0 oroe~}v ~ick}kfdc ~dp}kov apie }bd} fbd~}opv

polkv}pd}kig potukpoeog}v' Bi|oqop# }bkv oroe~}kig miov gi} ~pibk`k} vufb polkv}pd}kig' Gip miovk} edjo d vodpfb ia }bovo polkv}pd}kigv ugpodvigd`co' Gip miov k} edjo gdekgl dg d~~dpog}

~ick}kfdc ~dp}{ }bd} bdv# kg adf} polkv}opom ugpodvigd`co'

Fdvo 0840%fq%>04=6%V]D%flf Mifueog} 0; Akcom >1)>2)40 ^dlo 4< ia 06 ^dloKM =>


18/23

42 ia 06

]bo oqkmogfo codqov gi ~ivvk`kck}{ }bd} Moaogmdg}v dffuvd}kigv dldkgv} d}}ipgo{ Kpkig dpo

}puo' ]bokp ei}kig aip vdgf}kigv ig }bovo lpiugmv euv} ò MOGKOM'

KQ'

Gig%Apkqiciuv Fcdke

D' ]bo Kgv}dg} Fdvo kv Mkv}kglukvbd`co ig }bo V}dgmkgl Kvvuo DcigoMoaogmdg}v ei}kig |kccaucc{ klgipov }bo fpk}kfdc mkaaopogfo ò}|oog }bo kgv}dg} cd|vuk}

dgm oqop{ i}bop cd|vuk} fbdccoglkgl I`dedv figv}k}u}kigdc tudckakfd}kigv }i bicm }bo iaakfo ia

^povkmog}' V~ofkakfdcc{# }bo kgv}dg} fdvo kgqicqov d ^cdkg}kaa }bd} kv d fdgmkmd}o dldkgv} Ep' I`ded

kg }bo u~fiekgl logopdc ^povkmog}kdc ocof}kig' Mov~k}o Moaogmdg}v mofo~}kqo v}d}oeog}v kg d

pofog} akckgl# fdgmkmd}o%v}dgmkgl kv |occ ov}d`ckvbom' ]bkv gi}kig ia fie~o}k}kqo v}dgmkgl bdv

òog pofilgkxom `{ voqopdc fkpfuk}v' Mpdjo q' I`ded# 11= A'6m >1+: dgm Vfbucx q' \kcckdev# == A'6m =2# ?6 "0gm

Fkp' 4;;=+'

]bo eiug}dkg ia fdvo cd| poaoppom }i kg Moaogmdg}v ei}kig dgm fk}om kg }bokp Orbk`k}

D |opo dcc mkvekvvom aip cdfj ia v}dgmkgl' \k}b }bo orfo~}kig iaMpdjo q' I`ded# |bkfb |dv

mkvekvvom ig eii}govv lpiugmv òfduvo ^povkmog} I`ded bdm dcpodm{ }djog iaakfo# gigo ia }bo

fdvov fk}om `{ }bo Moaogmdg}v kgqicqom d fie~o}k}kqo fdgmkmd}o dv ~cdkg}kaa' ]bkv mkaaopogfo

mkv}kglukvbov }bo kgv}dg} fdvo apie dcc vkekcdp fdvov }i md}o'4>#44

4>Moaogmdg}v ei}kig v}d}ov d} codv} }|kfo }bd} }bo d}}ipgo{ kg Jopfbgop q' I`ded |dv vdgf}kigom

`{ }bo 6pm

Fkpfuk} aip `pkglkgl apkqiciuv fcdkev fbdccoglkgl I`dedv tudckakfd}kigv' Voo Mif'0?

d} 4># fk}kgl 140 A'6m 0>= "6pm

Fkp' 0>44+' ]bkv kv kgfippof}' ]bo 6pm

Fkpfuk} kvvuom dg ipmop }i

vbi| fduvo# ù} u~ig pofokqkgl }bo d}}ipgo{v pov~igvo }i }bd} ipmop# }bo Fiup} mkm gi} kvvuo

vdgf}kigv'44

Moaogmdg}v fk}o d v}d}o fiup} fdvo apie Kgmkdgd# Dpjog{ q' Liqopgip# dv podfbkgl }bovu`v}dg}kqo Dp}kfco KK kvvuo ~povog}om kg }bo kgv}dg} fdvo' ;41 G'O'0m 1


19/23

4; ia 06

@' ^pooe~}kig dgm Apoomie }i Dvvifkd}o Kvvuov Dcpodm{ Dmmpovvom]i }bo molpoo }bd} Moaogmdg}v ei}kig aip vdgf}kigv dccumov }i ~pooe~}kig dgm apoomie

}i dvvifkd}o dplueog}v# }bo ^cdkg}kaav bdqo dcpodm{ dmmpovvom }bivo kvvuov kg }bokp i~~ivk}kig }i

Moaogmdg}v ei}kigv }i mkvekvv' ]bo ^cdkg}kaav kgfip~ipd}o `{ poaopogfo# bopo# }bokp ~poqkiuv

pov~igvov }i vdkm dplueog}v'

F' ]bo Ekgip Fiup}v Moakgk}kig ia Gd}updc @ipg Fk}kxog kv @kgmkgl ^pofomog} D vke~co podmkgl iaEkgip q' Bd~~opvo}}edjov k} kv fcodp }bd} }bo Fiup} moakgom gd}updc

`ipg fk}kxog# dv k} d~~odpv kg dp}kfco KK ia }bo Figv}k}u}kig# dv ~dp} ia k}v bicmkgl' 22 _'V' 410#

41


20/23

0> ia 06

gd}updc%ìpg fk}kxog apie odpckop kg }bo vdeo ~dpdlpd~b' @ofduvo ì}b ia Epv' Ekgipv ~dpog}v

|opo _'V' fk}kxogv d} }bo }keo vbo |dv ìpg# dgm vbo |dv ìpg kg }bo _'V'# vbo |dv d gd}updc ìpg

fk}kxog' @ofduvo dcc gd}updc ìpg fk}kxogv dpo dcvi |k}bkg }bo `pidmop fd}olip{ fk}kxog# Epv'

Ekgip |dv d fk}kxog' ]bkv kv |b{ }bo Fiup} mkm gi} goom }i povicqo miu`}v dìu} }bo iu}op ckek}v

ia }bo }ope fk}kxog' Epv' Ekgip |dv d fk}kxog òfduvo vbo |dv fcodpc{ |k}bkg }bo gdppi|op

fd}olip{ ia gd}updc%ìpg fk}kxog'

]boEkgipFiup}v mofkvkig }i ov}d`ckvb }bd} Epv' Ekgip |dv d fk}kxog òfduvo vbo |dv d

gd}updc ìpg fk}kxog aicci|om }bo |occ%ov}d`ckvbom mif}pkgo ia humkfkdc pov}pdkg}' Humkfkdc pov}pdkg}

potukpom }bo EkgipFiup} }i dqikm kg}op~po}kgl }bo fk}kxogvbk~ fcduvo ia }bo 4=

}b

Deogmeog} ka

}bo fkpfuev}dgfov ~povog}om kg }bo fdvo d} bdgm mkm gi} potukpo }bo Fiup} }i figv}puo }bo 4=}b

deogmeog}v fk}kxogvbk~ fcduvo kg ipmop }i podfb k}v bicmkgl' ]bo adf}v ~povog}om mkm gi} potukpo

vufb dg kg}op~po}d}kig# vi }bo Fiup} mkm gi} podfb }bo 4= }bdeogmeog}v fk}kxogvbk~ fcduvo' @u}

}bkv pov}pdkg} mkm potukpo }bo Fiup} }i figfcumo }bd} Epv' Ekgip |dv d fk}kxog qkd k}v moakgk}kig ia

gd}updc%ìpg fk}kxog dgm k}v figfcuvkig }bd} dcc gd}updc%ìpg fk}kxogv dpo |k}bkg }bo `pidmop

fd}olip{ ia fk}kxogv' ]bkv kv |b{ }boEkgipfiup} edmo }bo v}d}oeog} Aip }bo ~up~ivov ia }bkv

fdvo k} kv gi} gofovvdp{ }i vicqo }bovo miu`}v' K} kv vuaakfkog} aip oqop{}bkgl |o bdqo gi| }i

figvkmop }bd} dcc fbkcmpog ìpg ia fk}kxog ~dpog}v |k}bkg }bo hupkvmkf}kig dpo }boevocqov fk}kxogv'

Km' d} 412' Kg i}bop |ipmv# }bo Ekgip Fiup}v moakgk}kig ia gd}updc ìpg fk}kxog |dv

~kqi}dc }i podfbkgl k}v bicmkgl'

]bo Fiup} }bog mkvfuvvom voqopdc i}bop }{~ov ia fk}kxogvbk~ dv logopdc orde~cov ia k}v

figfcuvkig }bd} |ieog fiucm ò fk}kxogv' Bi|oqop# k} }bog po}upgom }i }bo v~ofkakf fdvo ia Epv'

Ekgip# figfcumkgl8 ]bo aiup}oog}b deogmeog} mkm gi} daaof} }bo fk}kxogvbk~ ia |ieog dg{

eipo }bdg k} mkm ia eog' Kg }bkv ~dp}kfucdp# }bopoaipo# }bo pklb}v ia Epv' Ekgip mi gi} mo~ogm u~ig

Fdvo 0840%fq%>04=6%V]D%flf Mifueog} 0; Akcom >1)>2)40 ^dlo 0> ia 06 ^dloKM =4>


21/23

04 ia 06

}bo deogmeog}' Vbo bdv dc|d{v `oog d fk}kxog apie bop `kp}b# dgm og}k}com }i dcc }bo ~pkqkcolov

dgm keeugk}kov ia fk}kxogvbk~'Km' d} 4'

@ofduvo }boEkgipFiup}v moakgk}kig ia gd}updc `ipg fk}kxog |dv ~kqi}dc }i podfbkgl k}v

bicmkgl# }bo Fiup}v moakgk}kig kv ~dp} ia k}v bicmkgl dgm kv# }bopoaipo# dcvi ~pofomog}' Voo@cdfjv

Cd| Mkf}kigdp{


22/23

00 ia 06

}bo Ekgip Fiup} ov}d`ckvbkgl }bd} }bo 4=}b

Deogmeog} mkm gi} fpod}o dg{ go| ~pkqkcolov dgm

keeugk}kov' Voo ? _'V' 46


23/23

Pov~of}aucc{ vuèk}}om ig }bo 42}b

Md{ ia Vkqdg# kg }bo {odp ia iup Cipm 0>40 "d'j'd' Hugo

2# 0>40+'

Yv)Qdg P' KpkigYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Qdg P' Kpkig "]G@^P&>0=?4;+Ckòp}{ Coldc Aiugmd}kig

;>=> Orofu}kqo ^dpj Mpkqo# V}o' 0>>

D}}ipgo{ aip ^cdkg}kaav"=06+ 0>2%;;?6

FOP]KAKFD]O IA VOPQKFOK} kv bopo`{ fop}kakom }bd} ig 42}b Md{ ia Vkqdg# [odp ia iup Cipm 0>40 "d'j'd' Hugo 2#

0>40+# d fi~{ ia ^cdkg}kaav Pov~igvo kg I~~ivk}kig }i Moaogmdg}v Ei}kigv aip Vdgf}kigv |dvakcom ocof}pigkfdcc{' ^dp}kov ed{ dffovv }bkv akckgl }bpiulb }bo Fiup}v ocof}pigkf akckgl v{v}oe' D

fi~{ ia }bkv ei}kig |kcc dcvi ò vopqom u~ig }bo Moaogmdg}v qkd edkc'

Yv)Qdg P' KpkigYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Qdg P' KpkigCkòp}{ Coldc Aiugmd}kig

;>=> Orofu}kqo ^dpj Mpkqo# V}o' 0>>

D}}ipgo{ aip ^cdkg}kaav"=06+ 0>2%;;?6

Fdvo 0840%fq%>04=6%V]D%flf Mifueog} 0; Akcom >1)>2)40 ^dlo 06 ia 06 ^dloKM =46

Documents

TN 2012-06-08 - (WDTN - LLF - PLANTIFFS’ RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS’ MOTION FOR SANCTIONS