Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
www.ecn.nl
Top Sectors, TKI’s and targets Solar energy innovation in Dutch practice and global perspective
Wim Sinke ECN Solar Energy, TKI Solar Energy, University of Amsterdam, FOM-Institute AMOLF and European Photovoltaic Technology Platform Bijeenkomst Vereniging voor Zonnekrachtcentrales UvA, Science Park Amsterdam Solstice 2013
Contents
• New Dutch innovation policy – about Top Sectors, TKI’s and Innovation Contracts
• Innovation Contract & TKI Solar Energy
– a brief history of development – targets and numbers – structure and status
• Photovoltaics
– science, technology and applications at a glance – from niche to terawatts: successes and growing pains – its role for NL
• PV and CSP (and solar fuels): a winning team - a message yet to be conveyed?
2
Contents
• New Dutch innovation policy – about Top Sectors, TKI’s and Innovation Contracts
• Innovation Contract & TKI Solar Energy
– a brief history of development – targets and numbers – structure and status
• Photovoltaics
– science, technology and applications at a glance – from niche to terawatts: successes and growing pains – its role for NL
• PV and CSP (and solar fuels): a winning team - a message yet to be conveyed?
3
Essentials of new innovation policy
• Focus on a limited number of economic sectors (‘Top Sectors’) • Use (shrinking) public funds more efficiently and effectively • Put private sector (SME’s + large companies) in the driver’s seat • For each Top Sector:
– Organise innovation through ‘golden triangle’ (private sector, knowledge sector, government), or rather ‘platinum quadrangle’ (… + NGO’s)
– Appoint Top Team: – 1 SME representative, 1 knowledge sector representative, 1 government
representative, 1 ‘boegbeeld’ (‘sector face’) – Appoint Steering Group – Develop roadmap + implementation plan per subsector (= Innovation
Contract) – Establish (one or more per subsector) Top Consortium Knowledge &
Innovation (TKI) as vehicle for execution of Innovation Contract
4
9 Top Sectors as focus for economic development & innovation
5
• High Tech Systems & Materials • Agro-Food • Water • Energy • Horticulture & Starting Materials • Chemicals • Creative Industries • Logistics • Life-sciences • (Head Offices)
Contents
• New Dutch innovation policy – about Top Sectors, TKI’s and Innovation Contracts
• Innovation Contract & TKI Solar Energy
– a brief history of development – targets and numbers – structure and status
• Photovoltaics
– science, technology and applications at a glance – from niche to terawatts: successes and growing pains – its role for NL
• PV and CSP (and solar fuels): a winning team - a message yet to be conveyed?
6
Meet the Top Team Energy
7
Subsectors Energy (TKI’s)
• Solar Energy TKI Solar Energy • Energy Efficiency in the Built Environment TKI EnerGO • Offshore Wind Energy TKI Wind op Zee • Bio-energy TKI Biobased Economy • Smart Grids TKI Switch2SmartGrids • Energy Efficiency in the Industry TKI ISPT • Gas TKI Gas
8
A brief history of events
• September 2011 : invitation to develop Innovation Contracts (IC’s)
• December 2011: submission vs1; review by Top Team & Steering Group
• February 2012: submission vs2; review by Top Team & Steering Committee budget allocation
• March 2012: submission of Action Plan 2012 (reduced budget)
• April 2012: Minister Verhagen formally signs contracts
• April – Dec 2012: establish TKI’s / from plans to projects
9
Innovation Contract Solar Energy (2012)
10
Targets: • creation of jobs (from 2000 in 2010 to 10,000
in 2020) • generation of sustainable energy (from 100
MWp to 4 GWp in 2020 and >20 GWp in 2030 and beyond)
Features: • Letters of Commitment & Intent 100 M€ over
5 yrs • private/public contributions 45%/55% (required >40%/60%)
Innovation Contract Solar Energy
11
Contents
• New Dutch innovation policy – about Top Sectors, TKI’s and Innovation Contracts
• Innovation Contract & TKI Solar Energy
– a brief history of development – targets and numbers – structure and status
• Photovoltaics
– science, technology and applications at a glance – from niche to terawatts: successes and growing pains – its role for NL
• PV and CSP (and solar fuels): a winning team - a message yet to be conveyed?
13
First Solar Helianthos Würth Solar
Cell & module technologies Commercial
14
Flat plate: wafer-based silicon (>85%) - monocrystalline - multicrystalline & quasi mono Module efficiencies 14 ∼ 21%
Toyota City of the Sun (NL)
Concentrator (
Concepts & technologies Lab and pilot production
• super-high-efficiency concepts (nanotechnology at km2 area)
– full use of all light colors – advanced light management & concentration
• super-low-cost concepts (& technologies for new applications)
– very fast and non-vacuum processing – low-cost materials & low material use
15
Example: spectrum conversion using
quantum dots (Univ. of Amsterdam)
Example: polymer solar cell (Solliance)
www.nrel.gov/ncpv/images/efficiency_chart.jpg
Commercial module efficiencies (selection) History + short-term projections (announced)
wafer Si IBC
wafer Si IBC
wafer Si mono wafer Si HIT
wafer Si multi CdTe
CIGS
tf a/µcSi
tf aSi
wafer Si IBC
M.J. de Wild-Scholten SmartGreenScans
Commercial module efficiencies History + long-term projections (simplified estimates)
Building blocks: system approaches
19
• milliwatts to gigawatts • grid-connected, stand-alone • integrated, add-on, ground-based / buildings, infrastructure, field • electricity only, multifunctional (incl. PV-T) • fixed orientation, sun tracking • and more
Sharp Corp. Mun. Heerhugowaard Enel Phoenix Solar
Historic market growth - global Annual installations and cumulative capacity (MWp)
Source: EPIA (2013) Data 2012 preliminary
100 GWp (0.1 TWp)
Contributions of renewables to electricity consumption in Germany
21 Bron: Fraunhofer ISE (2013)
EU total: 2,5%
Great expectations Possible contributions PV (Germany)
22
15-30% PV
Grid integration Germany explores (and shifts) the frontiers
23
M. Lippert,
SAFT
Source: Fraunhofer ISE (2013)
Grid integration Effect on peak electricity prices
24
Gaëtan Masson EPIA,
@ EU PVTP GA 2012
Installed capacity NL: what did we achieve so far?
Correction: end 2011 145 MWp End 2012: ≈340 MWp (polderpv.nl)
Towards impact: the first step National Action Plan: 4 GW in 2020
• Action Plan: 4 GW in 2020 2,5-3% of NL electricity consumption
• EU-average 2012: 2,5% • Germany 2012: 5,7% (2020: 9-12%?) • Realistic range NL 2020: 4-8 GW 5-6% of electricity consumption = 1% of energy end-use = half of increase of target 14% 16% • Technical potential NL: >100 GW (>300 PJe)
PV rooftop system prices Germany (10-100 kWp)
Source: FhG ISE (2012)
x ⅓
Price-experience curve PV modules Effects of volume and innovation
28 Fraunhofer ISE (2013)
Price-experience curve PV modules Effects of volume and innovation
29 Fraunhofer ISE (2013)
≈2020
Great expectations Global market potential 2020
Breyer et al. @EUPVSEC 2011
Towards impact: 20 GW in 2030 (re: EU PV GRID project)
• Produced electricity: 15 – 18 TWh (using A ánd B locations)
• Electricity consumption 2012: 120 TWh
• Electricity consumption 2030: 150 TWh?
20 GW PV contributes 10 – 12% to total consumption (if overall losses can be kept small)
20 GW: what does it imply?
• @ 10 ∼ 40% module efficiency: – 50 ∼ 200 km2 net area (up to 500 km2 gross area) – 2 ∼ 8 million “family house roof equivalents” high efficiency is key for large-scale use
• Integration:
1. electrical: grid (>100% penetration) 2. societal: you cannot hide 20 GW of PV 3. physical: buildings, infrastructure and landscape
Public support: the horror case PV shoved down the throat
33 33
Oh my God, please help our country and send us a terrific and destructive hailstorm!
Courtesy Michael Marčák
Opportunities missed (or: threat?) PV as technology only
34 34
The opportunity (or: necessity?) PV as technology ánd design
35 35
RidderSolar
ECN’s Black Beauty
Beyond design and yield PV as statement
36
Utrecht CS
Zadar Coast, Croatia
Kaohsiung, Taiwan Green Pix; Beijing, China
Columbuskwartier, Almere
Total quality (assurance) Necessity for GW-scale use
• Components, systems, installers, production processes, etc.
• Broad lack of understanding; many urban legends
• (Desperate) need for coordination, information and communication
• High priority in R&D and industry
37
?
Sustainability Materials
38 38
2011
Sustainability Materials
• introduction of new materials driven by (potential) scarcity or price risks, e.g.: silver copper or indium zinc-tin
39
x7 in 7 years
Contents
• New Dutch innovation policy – about Top Sectors, TKI’s and Innovation Contracts
• Innovation Contract & TKI Solar Energy
– a brief history of development – targets and numbers – structure and status
• Photovoltaics
– science, technology and applications at a glance – from niche to terawatts: successes and growing pains – its role for NL
• PV and CSP (and solar fuels): a winning team - a message yet to be conveyed?
40
IEA Solar Energy Perspectives Scenario “Testing the Limits” – total energy
41
IEA Solar Energy Perspectives Mainstreaming of solar electricity
42
Shell Lens Scenarios - 03 2013
43
www.shell.com/ global/future-energy/ scenarios.html
Shell Lens Scenarios
44
Shell Lens Scenarios (Oceans)
45
The future at a glance
46
Current 2020 Long-term potential
Commercial module efficiency flat plate/concentrator (%) 6∼21 / 25∼30 10∼25 / 30∼35 20∼40+
Turn-key system price (flat plate) (€/Wp)
1∼4
0.8∼3
0.6∼1.5
Cost of electricity (LCoE, €/kWh)
0.05∼0.40
0.04∼0.30
0.03∼0.15
Energy pay-back time (yrs) 0.5∼2 0.25∼1 0.25∼0.5
Installed capacity (TWp) 0.1 0.5∼1 10-50
The future at a glance
47
Current 2020 Long-term potential
Commercial module efficiency (%) 5∼20 / 25∼30
(Si: 12∼20)
10∼25 / 30∼35
(Si: 16∼24)
20∼40+
(Si: 20∼30+)
Turn-key system price (flat plate) (€/Wp)
1.2∼5
0.8∼3
0.6∼1.5
Cost of electricity (LCoE, €/kWh)
0.06∼0.50
0.04∼0.30
0.03∼0.15
Energy pay-back time (yrs) 0.5∼2 0.25∼1 0.25∼0.5
Installed capacity (TWp) 0.1 0.5∼1 10-50
x 2∼3
x ½∼⅓ x 100+
48 City of the Sun, Municipality of Heerhugowaard, NL
Top Sectors, TKI’s and targetsContentsContentsEssentials of new innovation policy9 Top Sectors as focus for economic development & innovationContentsMeet the Top Team EnergySubsectors Energy (TKI’s)A brief history of eventsInnovation Contract Solar Energy (2012)Innovation Contract Solar EnergyContentsCell & module technologies �CommercialConcepts & technologies �Lab and pilot productionDianummer 16Commercial module efficiencies (selection)�History + short-term projections (announced)Commercial module efficiencies�History + long-term projections (simplified estimates)Building blocks: system approachesHistoric market growth - global�Annual installations and cumulative capacity (MWp)Contributions of renewables to�electricity consumption in Germany Great expectations�Possible contributions PV (Germany)Grid integration�Germany explores (and shifts) the frontiersGrid integration�Effect on peak electricity prices�Installed capacity NL:�what did we achieve so far?Towards impact: the first step �National Action Plan: 4 GW in 2020PV rooftop system prices Germany�(10-100 kWp)Price-experience curve PV modules�Effects of volume and innovationPrice-experience curve PV modules�Effects of volume and innovation Great expectations�Global market potential 2020Towards impact: 20 GW in 2030�(re: EU PV GRID project)20 GW: what does it imply?Public support: the horror case�PV shoved down the throatOpportunities missed (or: threat?)�PV as technology onlyThe opportunity (or: necessity?)�PV as technology ánd designBeyond design and yield�PV as statementTotal quality (assurance)�Necessity for GW-scale use�Sustainability�MaterialsSustainability�MaterialsContentsIEA Solar Energy Perspectives�Scenario “Testing the Limits” – total energyIEA Solar Energy Perspectives Mainstreaming of solar electricityShell Lens Scenarios - 03 2013Shell Lens ScenariosShell Lens Scenarios (Oceans)The future at a glanceThe future at a glanceDianummer 48