34
TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR BUSINESS MEETING NEDERLAND COMMUNITY CENTER 750 Hwy 72 Nederland, CO 80466 September 23, 2015 - 7:00 P.M. AGENDA _________________________________________________________________________________ A. CALL TO ORDER B. ROLL CALL C. APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM July 22, 2015 D. PUBLIC COMMENT E. INFORMATION ITEMS F. ACTION ITEMS G. DISCUSSION ITEMS 1. EPA Final Next Steps Presentation by Alexander Armani-Munn 2. 2015 Planning Commission Work Plan Update a. Short term rentals VRBO, Airbnb, Bed and Breakfast b. Prioritized housing items for consolidated code update c. GIS suitability analysis for #NedZero items pertaining to housing and commercial redevelopment and preservation potential H. OTHER BUSINESS I. ADJOURNMENT

TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

TOWN OF NEDERLAND

PLANNING COMMISSION

REGULAR BUSINESS MEETING

NEDERLAND COMMUNITY CENTER

750 Hwy 72 Nederland, CO 80466

September 23, 2015 - 7:00 P.M.

AGENDA _________________________________________________________________________________

A. CALL TO ORDER

B. ROLL CALL

C. APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM July 22, 2015

D. PUBLIC COMMENT

E. INFORMATION ITEMS

F. ACTION ITEMS

G. DISCUSSION ITEMS

1. EPA Final Next Steps Presentation by Alexander Armani-Munn

2. 2015 Planning Commission Work Plan Update

a. Short term rentals – VRBO, Airbnb, Bed and Breakfast

b. Prioritized housing items for consolidated code update

c. GIS suitability analysis for #NedZero items pertaining to housing and

commercial redevelopment and preservation potential

H. OTHER BUSINESS

I. ADJOURNMENT

Page 2: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

TOWN OF NEDERLAND

PLANNING COMMISSION

REGULAR BUSINESS MEETING NEDERLAND COMMUNITY CENTER

750 Hwy 72 Nederland, CO 80466

July 22, 2015 - 7:00 P.M.

MINUTES _________________________________________________________________________________

A. CALL TO ORDER

Chairman Cornell called the meeting to order at 7:13 pm.

B. ROLL CALL

Present: Chairman Roger Cornell, and Commissioners Timmy Duggan, Stephanie

Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at

7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review of the first item.

Absent: Vice Chairman Steven Williams and Commissioner Greg Guevara.

Also in attendance: Town Administrator Alisha Reis, Deputy Clerk Cynthia Bakke,

and Administrative Intern Alexander Armani-Munn.

C. APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM June 24, 2015

Motion to approve the minutes made by Commissioner Seavers, seconded by

Commissioner Herring, with 3 in favor, and abstention from Commissioner

Wendy Williams who was not yet approved to be on the Commission.

D. PUBLIC COMMENT

There was no public comment.

E. INFORMATION ITEMS

There were no information items.

F. ACTION ITEMS

1. Consideration of Special Review Use (SRU) application for a Multiple-Use

Development to include Marijuana cultivation at 0 E 1st Street for Katherine

Hormel and Gregory Miller

Reis introduced the item and noted the medical marijuana cultivation use triggers the

Special Review Use requirement. She referenced a typo in the applicants’ submitted

packet materials, with correction submitted to the Commissioners’ dyas.

Applicants Katherine Hormel and Gregory Miller of Nederland introduced themselves.

Page 3: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Miller gave a slide presentation providing an overview of the project. Hormel said the

building’s most visible west side, will contain the herbal apothecary, with the east side

to contain the marijuana business. She highlighted the street-front greenhouse, to

reduce energy use and carbon footprint, provide green space in winter, and educational

opportunities.

Hormel said she is part of an herbal production company called Dynamic Roots, and

desires to have an FDA-compliant laboratory for integration of direct-to-consumer

sales, and to increase production. She highlighted benefits such as sustainably sourced

products and cost reduction using locally-grown and wild harvested herbal medicines.

Miller presented aspects of the medical marijuana spaces, with local builder Jeff Fruth,

the greenhouse designer and electrician available for technical questions. Miller said

the onsite dispensary will eliminate product transport, with soil-based cultivation to

reduce waste, and induction lighting offset by roof-mounted solar photovoltaics. He

said a charcoal filtration system vented through the central HVAC system to mitigate

odor, with cultivation contained in grow tents to reduce the light pollution and waste.

Miller said they can accommodate 11 parking spaces, with intention for shared use of

the adjacent Town-owned lot. Reis said the Downtown Development Authority’s (DDA)

forthcoming master plan update will address parking and traffic, with upcoming

meetings to be announced.

Chairman Cornell opened the Public Comment portion of the meeting.

Teresa Robinson of Nederland, expressed her concerns about potential odor, security

requiring police surveillance, and CBD oil production. She asked if this is the image of

the community that Nederland would like to project.

Miller said CBD production is prohibited in the downtown. He said the cultivation and

dispensary will surpass state regulations for surveillance, with multiple charcoal filters

for odor reduction. Reis noted that odor compliance is an aspect of annual review for

marijuana licensing, with any complaints regarding the business to be presented to the

licensing authority.

Sue McDonough of Nederland, asked about pedestrian safety with the increased traffic.

Hormel said that they have discussed safety aspects with Architect Debbie Davenport,

and will retain a walkway along the west-side with a parallel parking spot for employee

use. Miller said they are aware of the congestion of business unloading areas and

general area traffic.

Ron Mitchell of Nederland, said he is pleased overall with the project, and outreach by

the applicants to discuss the project.

Chairman Cornell closed the public comment portion of the hearing.

Commissioner Herring asked about security issues noted from the long-established

marijuana businesses. Reis responded that commercial businesses have not seen the

Page 4: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

security issues more common with residential cultivations due to state requirements.

Reis noted that the applicants’ have addressed concerns by Public Works regarding

byproducts entering town treatment systems. As well, she said that Police Department

concerns about traffic and parking will be monitored.

Commissioner Herring asked the applicants to address the comment about community

messaging brought up by Robinson. Miller said normalization with a professional

establishment can help to assist those in opposition, with further focus on marijuana as

medicine. Hormel said that as an educator and herbalist they teach appropriate use of

all plant-based medicines, not normalizing beyond medically-appropriate use. Hormel

responded to a question about seeking recreational marijuana allowance stating that

there is no intention to do so at this location.

Commission discussion unanimously commended the applicants’ well organized

presentation and professionalism.

Reis clarified Commission concerns regarding parking noting that this will require a

joint use parking agreement, the beginning of town-owned parking on this lot. She said

the Board of Trustees would prefer a solid parking plan versus proposal of payment to

the parking fund due to overall congestion in the area. Hormel noted the building’s

predominant daytime use, allowing other businesses to utilize parking in the evening.

Chairman Cornell asked if they had reached out to the owner and/or renter of the

nearby cabin. The applicants said that the renter has expressed enthusiasm about the

project. Hormel said they are willing to work with the renter regarding parking, and to

accommodate expansion for increase of employees, as well as promote public transport

from Boulder for workshops. Chairman Cornell suggested flagging the corners prior to

review by the Board of Trustees.

Chairman Cornell asked the applicants about exterior lighting, and interior light

mitigation. Miller stated that the greenhouse will only utilize natural lighting, with

exterior lighting to be downcast. He said the building is being designed to consider

future use, although all windows into cultivation area are to be blacked out.

Reis said that future parking accommodation and continuation of the sidewalk will be

included within the SRU Agreement draft, as well as an additional parking spot for the

resident of Lot 4, and a specific drainage plan.

Motion to approve the SRU for multi-use at 0 E 1st Street by Katherine Hormel

and Gregory Miller was made by Commissioner Herring, seconded by

Commissioner Duggan, with 4 in favor.

G. DISCUSSION ITEMS

1. Consideration of a Concept Review application for a Wedding Chapel at

the Caribou Ridge Subdivision for David Nassar

Page 5: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Applicant David Nassar and son Zachary Nassar of Erie, own the Caribou Ridge

subdivision and construction company building 3 homes in the subdivision. David

Nassar gave the background of his acquisition of the Caribou Ridge subdivision. He

presented a slide show of the mountain homes constructed at Copper Mountain, and

highlighted green elements.

Nassar said the economic downturn spawned an unexpected vacation rental by owner

business that benefitted Copper Mountain to establish a Hotel Occupancy Tax for

increased revenue. He said he’d like to propose the vacation rental concept along with

a wedding chapel, and some larger homes to accommodate the concept. Nassar

requested the Commission’s feedback.

Reis said the concept was originally proposed for Outlot D as contained in the packet.

After further legal consideration, she said the applicants will instead propose a lot line

dissolution for lots 2 and 4. She also clarified that Trustee Donahue can hear the

application due to the concept status.

Chairman Cornell opened the meeting to public comment.

Gregory Miller of Nederland, said he appreciates the proposal as a neighbor.

Nassar said the wedding chapel is proposed for lots 2 and 4, with a lot line dissolution

proposed to create one building envelope, with parking on the cul de sac. He said lots 3

and 5 would be undeveloped to determine reception of the wedding chapel concept.

Commissioner Seavers said he supports the sustainable elements and walk-ability.

Nassar said they re-use “antique wood” from reclaimed barns, and include passive solar

design and radiant floor heating.

Commissioner Herring expressed concern about increased traffic in a residential area.

Nassar said there would be an approximate 125-person maximum for weddings and/or

corporate events. He specified that potential home buyers have been amendable to the

wedding business proposal, and VRBO-rentals concept, to be included in the HOA.

Nassar said the homes will be in the 3000-3500sf range with a price point of $1million

and under, with the wedding chapel/event center to be a larger footprint for events.

Herring asked Nassar to specify the general lot sizes. Nassar said the smallest lots are

about 4500 square feet, with common outlots surrounding the parcels. He said the

previous subdivision master planning would be retained, and include the wedding

chapel concept, to keep the look without an overall density increase. Nassar said he’d

like to abolish the private restriction on Outlot D to encourage public usage.

Chairman Cornell provided the history of the Caribou Ridge Subdivision.

Commissioner Herring noted the ongoing discussion regarding the lack of affordable

housing. Nassar said that this would require smaller footprints and/or higher density,

with change to the established PUD. Chairman Cornell said this would have required

preliminary planning, during the single-family housing boom in the 1990’s and 2000’s.

Page 6: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Nassar indicated the desire to create VRBO opportunities throughout the subdivision,

and he’d like to be part of the discussion to create VRBO regulations for Nederland.

Chairman Cornell indicated the need for further review of rental regulations. Nassar

said the lodge will have a liquor license and provide short term rental for 25-40 people,

along with VRBO home rentals by homeowners. Cornell noted impacts to neighbors

outside of the subdivision with Commissioner Herring noting the proximity of the

Elementary School. Trustee Donahue noted the need to address decibel levels for

sound, and ensure downcast lighting when the item is presented to the Trustees.

Reis indicated that PUD Agreements can be amended to include commercial elements,

with approval and change to the plat.

2. GIS Prioritization for #NedZero items

Reis introduced the item, and noted discussion at the June 24 meeting with request for

staff prioritization. Reis indicated that items such as pathways and safe routes were

combined, with PROSAB as the lead organization. She said an update will be

forwarded when finalized.

Reis said Lex Ivey has been educating town staff to do work in-house with existing

data. She suggested a focus on the built-environment to map properties by infill

suitability analysis, for an approximate cost of $1000. She said staff can guide

developers to infill opportunities, allowing a more thorough and expedient analysis.

H. OTHER BUSINESS

Armani-Munn provided an update on the EPA workshop held earlier in the month. He

said the community meeting was well attended, with ensuing conversation that

reflected many long standing beliefs. He indicated a forthcoming draft memo, followed

by a final memo after the draft memo concerns are addressed.

I. ADJOURNMENT

Motion to adjourn was made by Commissioner Herring, seconded by Trustee

Donahue, with all in favor (6). Meeting adjourned at 10:00 pm.

Approved by the Planning Commission,

___________________________________________

Roger Cornell, Chairman, Planning Commission

ATTEST: ___________________________________________

Cynthia Bakke, Deputy Clerk

Page 7: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

AGENDA INFORMATION MEMORANDUM TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION

Meeting Date: Wednesday, September 23, 2015

Initiated By: Alisha Reis

Dept: Town Hall Action Discussion x

AGENDA ITEM: Discussion on the EPA Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Final Next Steps Memorandum

SUMMARY: A team of EPA-led consultants was in Nederland on July 9 and 10 for a workshop with local elected officials, town staff, and community stakeholders focusing on updating and revising municipal codes to support the community’s goals for affordable housing, efficient public infrastructure, renewable energy, and protection of natural habitats and ecosystems. As the champion of the 2013 Comprehensive Plan Update, the Planning Commission plays a critical role in the administration of the technical assistance granted through this program. At the September 23, 2015 meeting, Administrative Intern Alexander Armani-Munn will present a report on the EPA’s next steps memo and convene a discussion with the planning commissioners on moving forward with recommendations related to the memo.

HISTORY AND PREVIOUS COMMISSION ACTION: There are 13 items included in the Planning Commission’s 2015 Work Plan that were identified as appropriate topics of discussion for the EPA technical assistance workshop. Those items are contained in a spreadsheet attached to this AIM. In April and May, Planning Commission members Roger Cornell and Topher Donahue joined members of the Town staff in preliminary conference calls with the EPA team and also helped administer a self-assessment of current Town codes. The conference calls and self-assessment served to inform the EPA team on Nederland’s goals for sustainable development. Several commissioners actively participated in the July 9 and 10 EPA workshops as well.

RECOMMENDATIONS: Discuss actionable steps for implementing recommendations from the next steps memo

Page 8: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

ATTACHMENTS:

1. Planning Commission Work Plan spreadsheet for EPA items 2. EPA Final Next Steps Memo

FINANCIAL CONSIDERATIONS: Budget request for 2016 includes $2500 for code updates.

Page 9: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

SAP ID (Trello)

SAP Section

Team Name STAR Action BOT Avg

Funding Comp Plan

Timefram

Work Plan

TimelineSource

Lead Organizat

ion

Support Org.

Minimum Metrics EPA? Action

Category

5X-01 5. Economy and Jobs

X. Resilient Economy

EJ-1 Work with Planning Commission, Town Staff and Board of Trustees to study revisions to the municipal code, specifically the mixed use zoning requirements that may present a barrier to redevelopment or infill in the Downtown Core.

1.29 Funded Short-term Comp Plan

PC BOT Implemented? (Y/N)

Yes Codes

7B-04 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

BE-5 Update Zoning and development regulations to align with Comp Plan (prioritizing Public zoning & reg's).

3.86 Funded Short-term Comp Plan

PC BZA, PC Yes Codes

7B-01 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

BE-1 Dark Sky Initiative: Update and enforce the Municipal Code as it relates to downward indirect lighting in residential and commercial districts.

4.71 Funded Comp Plan

PC Town Yes Codes

7B-02 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

BE-4 Update Town Municipal Code to encourage development and redevelopment of mixed-use and multifamily housing per Comp Plan

10.00 Funded Short-term Comp Plan

PC Town Staff

Yes Codes

7B-09 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

CE-5 Review Town Municipal Code for any barriers to high-efficiency building materials/measures. ADD: Consider change to Muncipal Code to require new construction over a certain size to include alternative energy generation on site.

12.43 2015 Funding

Short-term Comp Plan

PC BOT Yes Codes

3W-02 3. Our Water

W. Storm Water System

NS-5 Investigate, identify and pass an ordinance protecting water ways from new development and regulating what type of construction can occur proximate to waterways for existing developments

12.71 Funded N/AP Town Staff

PC Buffer width, regulations in

l ?

Yes Codes

7B-03 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

BE-4 Explore creative housing concepts to meet the community's affordable housing needs, including small-scale housing (e.g. cabin zoning concepts), accessory dwelling units, multi-generational development, etc. Review the Town zoning code to prepare for changes to allow for such concepts. (Rental housing licensing update, roll-out).

13.43 Funded Short-term Comp Plan

PC Town Yes Codes

7B-06 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

BE-5 Review and revise the Municipal Code to ensure that it allows for impact analysis for proposed development.

17.86 2015 Funding

Short-term Comp Plan

PC Town Yes Codes

7B-07 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

CE-5 Move towards net-zero energy in all building codes 28.71 2015 Funding

N/AP BoCo Sustainability Plan

Mayor's Task Force on Building

PC Yes Codes

2J-02 2. Community Fabric

J. Sustainable

BE-3 Update Muncipal Code Chapter 16, Article VIII, Off-Street Parking and Loading to reflect recommendations of Town Board Ordinance 707

30.86 Identify Funding

Short-term Comp Plan

PC Town, BOT

Adopted? (Y/N)

Yes Codes

3P-05 3. Our Water

P. Source Water Protection

BE-2 Incorporate into land use plans review analysis against Source Water Protection Plan, water availability, infrastructure capacity, and other resource limitations.

42.14 Identify Funding

Comp Plan

PC Town Process Developed

Yes Process

7B-05 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

BE-5 Revisit and update the Town's Design Guidelines so that they constantly evolve and reflect the design objective of the community.

46.57 2015 Funding

Comp Plan

PC BOT Yes Codes

ADD Review Use Group Chart for possible update to formatting, categories. N/AP PCTown Staff Yes

Codes

Page 10: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

1

Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas BUILDING BLOCKS FOR SUSTAINABLE COMMUNITIES

Nederland, Colorado

Next Steps Memorandum

September 10, 2015

Page 11: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

2

INTRODUCTION The core mission of U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is to protect human health and the environment. EPA’s Office of Sustainable Communities (OSC)—or the Smart Growth Office— helps to support this mission by working with communities to reach development goals that create positive impacts on air, water, public health, economic vitality and quality of life for residents. OSC created the Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities program to provide quick, targeted technical assistance on specific smart growth development topics by bringing subject matter experts to communities. Communities request this technical assistance through a competitive application process.

The Building Blocks process is designed to move a community through a process of assessment, convening, and action planning—helping learn about a given topic and create plan to move forward on implementation. The program helps a community identify potential challenges, as well as realize opportunities that already exist to make progress. It includes a series of pre-and post-workshop conference calls, a self-assessment, and an on-site convening of stakeholders to discuss issues, next steps, and actions related to advancing the communities’ specific goals. These efforts help a given community gain a deeper understanding of a particular smart growth issue and identify specific steps necessary to move them closer to implementation. The diagram below outlines the typical flow of the Building Blocks technical assistance program.

THREE STAGES OF TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE (CREDIT: RENAISSANCE PLANNING)

This memo documents the key outcomes of the technical assistance for Nederland, Colorado with the Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas tool and identifies key community issues,

Page 12: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

3

prioritized goals, and specific actions to achieve smart growth development in its downtown and surrounding neighborhoods.

COMMUNITY CONTEXT Nederland is a small town of about 1,500 people nestled in the mountains of Colorado’s Front Range. It is situated at the base of the Continental Divide, about 20 miles west of the city of Boulder. Its proximity and mountain town lifestyle, have made Nederland a popular bedroom community for commuters that work in the Boulder area. In 2015, the town finds itself in the midst of a growth spurt, intensified by Colorado’s legalization of marijuana, which has generated several new controversial businesses.

A major challenge facing the community is the affordable housing shortage that Nederland’s growth and popularity has been creating. Housing supply has not kept pace with demand, resulting in rents that are unaffordable for most middle and low income households, and a leading to a general lack of available rental properties. Town officials recognize the importance of this issue and are looking for ways to increase the supply of affordable housing through incentives and regulatory tools. The location of new housing is also important to town officials. Nederland planners and housing officials want to build within its existing footprint, meeting the town’s housing needs by redeveloping underutilized or vacant lots near downtown.

There is tension, however, between the town’s desire to provide more affordable housing, and to preserve its unique character. Many people are wary of additional development and the traffic and environmental harm it might bring. The town is also finding it difficult to entice owners of vacant and underutilized properties to redevelop them and lacks funds to buy and redevelop the properties on its own. Meanwhile, many lots outside of the immediate downtown area have steep slopes that are unsuitable for development, and some do not have the preferred proximity to the core of town to meet other environmental goals. These obstacles have made it difficult for Nederland to meet the latent demand for housing. However, Nederland has an impressive set of plans and policies for a town of its size. Nederland completed a

NEDERLAND IS NESTLED BETWEEN THE BARKER RESERVOIR AND THE CONTINENTAL DIVIDE (CREDIT: RENAISSANCE PLANNING)

NEDERLAND IS KNOWN FOR ITS UNIQUE LOCAL CULTURE (CREDIT: RENAISSANCE PLANNING)

Page 13: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

4

new comprehensive plan in 2013, and has a sustainability action plan, called #NedZero, which supports its goal of becoming the country’s most sustainable small town.

COMMUNITY CONVENING EPA contractors from Renaissance Planning and Herd Planning & Design, with support from EPA staff, facilitated an on-site workshop in Nederland on July 9 and 10, 2015. The purpose of the workshop was to bring together key local stakeholders to identify potential solutions to the town’s affordable housing and infill development challenges. Town administration staff served as key local partners who coordinated all of the events.

Site Tour The workshop began with a tour of Nederland that helped familiarize the project team with local conditions. The tour also provided the town staff and officials with an opportunity to showcase areas where they hoped to encourage development and protect valuable natural resources. The site tour included several stops in the downtown area and a brief driving tour of neighborhoods on the outskirts of town. The tour highlighted several key sites and facilities downtown including the following:

• Town Hall Parking Lot - Nederland is interested in transforming the surface lot into a multi-purpose space for community events, such as a farmers market and concerts.

• Barker Reservoir - The town is interested in providing a performance space along the shore. • Middle Boulder Creek –The town’s Downtown Development Authority is looking to improve

connect the creek to downtown by building a River Walk behind 1st Street. • Underutilized Properties – The east side of downtown contains several vacant, underutilized, or

blighted properties that the town would like to see developed, which could include affordable or market rate housing.

• Downtown Housing Proposal Site – The town recently considered a proposal for housing on a vacant lot on 1st Street downtown. The proposal stalled over disagreements on design and financial concessions requested by the developer.

• Public Works Facility – Nederland owns an outdated public works facility on 5th Street. Once a new facility is built, the town plans to transition the property to affordable housing.

• Proposed Annexation Site – Owners of a 17 acre parcel just southwest of town petitioned Nederland to annex their property. The owners plan to build housing, and the project is under review at Boulder County.

Community Meeting The first workshop event was a community meeting on the evening of July 9. The meeting featured a presentation on the benefits of smart growth development and facilitated discussion about the challenges and opportunities facing Nederland. More than 30 people attended, including the project team, town staff and elected officials, key stakeholders, and interested residents.

Page 14: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

5

Technical Workshop The technical workshop on Day 2 allowed for more in-depth discussions on goals, challenges, and opportunities related to affordable housing and infill development. It featured a pair of three-hour work sessions attended by about 30 representatives of key stakeholders, the project team, town staff, and elected officials. The facilitators presented the top challenges and opportunities that were highlighted during the community workshop before presenting several strategies that could help Nederland address them. EPA’s Smart Growth Self-Assessment for Rural Communities was the primary source for these strategies. Of the 11 topics covered by the assessment, facilitators focused on strategies for the 3 that were most closely aligned with Nederland’s primary issues. These were:

1. Meet Housing Needs for Different Ages and Incomes

2. Revitalize Village and Town Centers 3. Provide Transportation Choices

By the conclusion of the morning work session, the workshop attendees had agreed to prioritize four strategies:

1. Refresh Nederland’s zoning ordinance to be in alignment with Vision 2020, #NedZero, and the Comprehensive Plan.

2. Engage more Nederland residents in planning efforts, and set benchmarks for the town’s high priority goals in order to track progress and increase understanding and support for action.

3. Prepare conceptual plans for key catalyst sites and facilities. 4. Facilitate the construction of additional attainable workforce housing to meet surging

demand.

The afternoon work session yielded a set of next steps for action in support of each strategy.

KEY COMMUNITY ISSUES The project team facilitated a discussion about the strengths, challenges, and opportunities facing Nederland, with an emphasis on affordable housing and infill development. The key points of that discussion are described in this section, starting with a summary of the town’s strengths.

MORE THAN 30 PEOPLE ATTENDED A COMMUNITY MEETING TO KICK OFF THE WORKSHOP (CREDIT: RENAISSANCE PLANNING)

WORKSHOP ATTENDEES IDENTIFIED NEXT STEPS DURING SMALL GROUP DISCUSSIONS (CREDIT: RENAISSANCE PLANNING)

Page 15: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

6

Strengths Nederland has a number of strengths related to its quality of life that are attracting people to move to the town.

• Natural Setting: Nederland is located in a beautiful setting, with views of the Continental Divide to the west and Barker Reservoir to the east, clean mountain air and opportunities for outdoor recreation.

• Proximity to Boulder and the Front Range: Nederland’s location provides residents and visitors relatively easy access to Boulder and the rest of the Front Range from town. The Denver and Boulder metropolitan areas are experiencing a growth spurt, most recently spilling over into communities in the foothills, where residents choose a longer commute for the benefit of living in the mountains. Nederland is close enough to the Front Range to attract some of this growth.

• Nederland “Vibe”: The town has a reputation for being culturally unique, which is reflected in its people, politics, and businesses. Residents largely embrace this reputation, although some workshop attendees expressed concern with the growing legal marijuana industry. People are also concerned about how growth could alter and dilute the community’s unique character.

Nederland’s popularity is driven by its natural beauty, proximity to the Front Range, and its unique vibe. These assets are also contributing to its diminishing stock of affordable housing, though, which is a challenge for the community.

Challenges A large portion of the workshop was dedicated to exploring the challenges facing Nederland and its community. This was an important part of the technical assistance process, as it enabled attendees to identify strategies for overcoming these challenges.

• Affordable Housing: The affordable housing shortage in Nederland was the most pressing topic during the workshop. Due to a lack of affordable units, the town is having trouble attracting and retaining vital civil servants, including teachers and police officers. The increasing cost of housing also makes it difficult for seniors to remain in the town as they age, especially since many necessary services are located down in Boulder. The lack of high-paying jobs in the retail sector – which is a major source of employment for those working in Nederland – creates a high demand for affordable housing from workers. On the other hand, the town’s topography (with many steep slopes that are unsuitable for housing) makes supply costly and often impossible.

• Defining “Affordable Housing:” Affordable housing means different things to different people. Some view it as housing for low income people, while others view it as housing for the working class, such as teachers or police officers, who can’t afford higher priced, larger homes. The debate over the term “affordable housing” during the workshop made it clear that this is a potential stumbling block to putting forward town-wide initiatives or plans, and that it may be helpful to create a definition before taking next steps.

• Outdated Zoning: Another factor constraining the supply of affordable housing is the town’s zoning ordinance. The ordinance is more than 30 years old and would benefit from a “refresh” – a strategic update. The zoning ordinance makes it difficult or impossible to use many tools for

Page 16: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

7

affordable housing including accessory dwelling units, small lot residential development, and higher density.

• Consolidated Land Ownership: Nederland has several sites close to downtown that present good opportunities for infill development. Yet these properties are held by only two owners that are content to hold them in their present state. One owner has a redevelopment vision that is mismatched with the town’s vision for the use and height of development on the property. Seeing these properties returned to a productive use is a top priority of the town.

• Infrastructure Condition: Two pressing infrastructure issues in Nederland are the lack of sidewalks and the prevalence of unpaved roads. The lack of sidewalks make the elementary school, which sits on the edge of town, inaccessible by foot. Unpaved roads are an issue throughout the town, even in the downtown area. Many of the unpaved roads are rough and ridden with pot holes. During wet months the pot holes can become filled with stagnant water, and the streets a large source of dust during the summer. Many streets also lack adequate drainage and send stormwater directly into waterways. The town’s infrastructure and services are also stretched by out-of-town users. Nederland has plans for a range of infrastructure upgrades, but the cost of improvements is a challenge in itself.

• Marijuana Industry: Some people at the workshop viewed the marijuana industry as an opportunity because of the jobs that it can bring and because it legalized what has supposedly been an underground industry in the mountains for several decades. Other people expressed concern that the industry is causing residential and commercial spaces to be converted into “grow houses,” exacerbating the affordable housing and retail space shortage.

THIS RECENT INFILL DEVELOPMENT NEAR DOWNTOWN DEMONSTRATES THE STRONG MARKET FOR INFILL (CREDIT: RENAISSANCE PLANNING)

2ND STREET NEAR DOWNTOWN IS UNPAVED, LIKE MANY STREETS IN THE TOWN (CREDIT: RENAISSANCE PLANNING)

Page 17: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

8

These challenges are all substantial obstacles to building more affordable housing and attracting more infill development. Overcoming them will be a community effort that extends to more than just development and equitable policies for housing.

Opportunities There are also several trends and assets that represent opportunities for Nederland to attract the type of development it desires. Top opportunities described during the workshop include high demand, available lots, and existing planning and policy efforts.

• Demand for Small Units: During the workshop, a property manager stated that in her opinion she could rent 25 small apartments (1-bedroom, 1,000 square feet) immediately if she could build them. The demand for that product is strong and represents an opportunity for developers.

• Demand for Retail Space: Nederland also has high demand for retail space. The town had no vacant commercial space as of July 2015 and, according to people at the workshop, several businesses are operating out of private homes due to the lack of available space in the traditional downtown. Again, this demonstrates the strong demand for real estate and opportunities for development.

• Vacant Lots: Although the town’s vacant lots are listed as a challenge, they also represent an opportunity should the ownership change hands or the current owners decide to build housing or other uses in response to the strong demand for real estate in Nederland.

• Downtown Development Authority: Nederland created its Downtown Development Authority (DDA) in 2005 for the purpose of improving infrastructure to support development. The DDA is funded through a property tax of five mills (0.5%) and through tax increment financing. The DDA provides a mechanism for financing and planning improvements to the downtown area that will promote infill development.

• Existing Plans: Nederland has an impressive set of plans and studies for a town of less than 1,500 people. The town has a comprehensive plan; design standards; a downtown development plan; a community vision (Vision 2020); a parks, recreation, open space, and trails master plan; and a master infrastructure plan. These plans call on Nederland to take several actions, but the town’s staff is very small. So Nederland decided in 2014 to develop #NedZero, which is the town’s sustainability action plan. It provides a road map for the town to implement actions in each of the aforementioned plans with the goals of making Nederland the most sustainable small town in the United States.1

These opportunities demonstrate that despite the challenges that are present, Nederland has many of the pieces necessary to nurture affordable housing and infill development. It has strong real estate demand, thoughtful plans, and a downtown development authority that can take a lead role in implementation.

1 Learn more about #NedZero by visiting the project’s web page: http://nedzero.co/.

Page 18: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

9

NEXT STEPS In the course of the technical workshops, the project team posed questions to the participants designed to foster discussions and draw out community members’ observations and opinions about strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities, summarized in the section above. The project team introduced several strategies that have worked well in other small towns in rural areas with similar goals. The strategies presentation and facilitated discussion focused on two key topics of affordable housing and infill development. Through the discussion of common strategies, four in particular emerged as the highest priorities in Nederland. These were:

1. Refresh Nederland’s zoning ordinance to be in alignment with Vision 2020, #NedZero, and the Comprehensive Plan.

2. Engage more Nederland residents in planning, and set benchmarks for the town’s high priority goals in order to track progress and increase support for action.

3. Prepare conceptual plans for catalyst sites and facilities. 4. Build more attainable workforce housing to meet surging demand.

Each strategy is described in detail in the tables below, which were developed jointly with workshop participants. These tables contain next steps Nederland and its partners can take to implement each strategy.

Refresh Nederland’s zoning ordinance to be in alignment with Vision 2020, #NedZero, and the Comprehensive Plan Through its existing plans, Nederland has laid a strong policy foundation for dealing with the challenges and opportunities related to affordable housing and infill development. For example, the comprehensive plan calls for promoting a range of affordable housing types and building more mixed use development near downtown. Yet goals and policies alone are insufficient to create the desired changes. The town also needs its zoning and development codes to be aligned with its policy intentions so that the policies can be smoothly implemented. This strategy is about achieving this consistency, while also ensuring that existing code provisions are enforced.

Supporting Implementation Steps

Why is this important? Timeframe Lead Role Support

Cost & Implementation

Resources

Improve code enforcement

Code enforcement has been underfunded. But it’s critical for ensuring that codes have the intended effect.

Mid-term (6 months to 1 year)

Town Staff Board of Trustees

Medium to high cost depending on the extent. Town budget.

Clean up the definition and allowances for home-based businesses to reflect their growing importance in the local

More people are working from home due to fundamental changes in

Mid-term (6 months to 1 year)

Board of Trustees

Planning Commission and Town Staff

Staff time, plus investigate resources that may be available from

Page 19: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

10

economy, but recognizing and addressing negative impacts on neighborhoods

technology and the economy, as well as the undersupply of commercial space in town. Home-based businesses are important, but careful consideration of standards to limit the impacts and proper locations is important

DOLA (Colorado Department of Local Assistance)

Update ordinances to increase the supply of affordable housing within the existing town limits. Priority techniques include accessory dwelling units with appropriate standards, tiny homes (1 bedroom and <1,000 square feet), and multi-family housing (to achieve higher net densities)

Housing prices have been increasing rapidly in Nederland, and exceed the level considered affordable by the typical household income. Part of the issue is a lack of supply, especially of smaller units.

Mid-term (6 months to 1 year)

Board of Trustees

Town Staff and Planning Commission

Staff time, plus investigate resources that may be available from DOLA

Consider a new mixed-income housing zoning district

The zone could include incentives for building affordable workforce housing and could involve voluntary deed restrictions or covenants to ensure long-term affordability

Mid-term (6 months to 1 year)

Board of Trustees

Town Staff and Planning Commission

Staff time, plus investigate resources that may be available from DOLA

Examine and consider changes to creek setback requirements

Preserving natural resources and water quality is very important to the community

Mid-term (6 months to 1 year)

Board of Trustees

Town Staff and Planning Commission

Staff time, plus investigate resources that may be available from DOLA

Page 20: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

11

Engage more Nederland residents in planning efforts, and set benchmarks for the town’s high priority goals in order to track progress and increase understanding and support for action Town officials recognize that more champions are needed to push for implementation of Nederland’s plans. This need helped inspire #NedZero, which aims to get more people involved in pushing for implementation of the different actions needed to make Nederland “the most sustainable small town in the United States.” This strategy also responds, however, to the town’s struggles to follow through on its plans. Performance measures also play an important role in this strategy. Setting benchmarks for key measures of sustainability and tracking progress towards targets is a good way to rally support for the town’s goals. Nederland has already taken an important step in this direction by joining the national STAR (Sustainability Tools for Assessing and Rating Communities) program. The STAR program will help Nederland identify key sustainability performance measures and establish a baseline for them. The next steps described in the following table will help integrate the #NedZero plan and performance measurement into public discourse and town operations.

Supporting Implementation Steps

Why is this important? Timeframe Lead Role Support

Cost & Implementation

Resources

Engage and train all town staff and advisory boards on #NedZero

Integrating #NedZero in all town operations provides a foundation for community-wide implementation and ensures that the program does not become obsolete

Mid-term (6 months to 1 year)

Town staff Interns

Staff time with support coming largely from interns

Engage residents, community organizations, and business owners in #NedZero

#NedZero requires adequate buy-in to be successful. The goal is to have more than 300 people know about #NedZero. The tool will be ineffective without this action

Mid-term (6 months to 1 year)

Elected officials

Champions in the business community, among residents, and community groups

Staff time with support coming largely from interns

Implement #NedZero community wide.

#NedZero expands the town’s capacity for implementation by engaging and empowering residents in

Long-term (1 to 2 years and ongoing)

Board of Trustees

Town Staff, volunteers, and community groups as appropriate

Staff time with support largely from interns with volunteer support.

Page 21: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

12

solutions to the issues that impact the entire community

Establish a long-term plan for #NedZero

Ensures #NedZero becomes standard procedure in our local government and becomes engrained in our local culture

Long-term (more than 1 year)

Town staff Entire community

Staff time with support coming largely from interns

Prepare conceptual plans for key catalyst sites and facilities Nederland recognizes that its vacant sites, particularly near downtown, are opportunities. Yet the town and residents have been unable to inspire owners to redevelop their properties, despite the surging demand for real estate development, and the town’s vision for mixed use infill and affordable housing development. One strategy that emerged during the workshop is to prepare conceptual plans for sites in and near downtown that could inspire property owners to develop their properties. This entails creating conceptual plans not just for key privately held underutilized sites, but also for town-owned facilities that could generate excitement and further build the market for infill development. Four specific actions steps in support of this strategy are listed in the table below.

Supporting Implementation Steps

Why is this important? Timeframe Lead Role Support

Cost & Implementation

Resources

Convene land owners and potential developers of the downtown area to share the results from a recent DCI technical assessment that provided options for redevelopment of some key sites in town

The town, through its Downtown Development Authority, has already developed some conceptual plans for underutilized spaces and community facilities

Short-term (less than 6 months)

DDA

Town Staff, Katmandu Owner (champion for downtown), property and business owners in downtown

Staff time to organize a meeting. DOLA planning and capital assistance for implementation with possible support of HUD CDBG funding

Green up the town parking lot behind the visitor’s center and transform it into a multi-purpose community gathering space. Include this in the DDA’s Plan of Development

Parking is important to downtown business. But there are ways in which the town can continue to use this space as parking while also using it for stormwater retention and filtration and as a

Short-term for the planning and inclusion in the Plan of Development. Long-term (more than 1 year) for

DDA and Board of Trustees

Town Staff and active members of the local foods and arts community

High cost with implementation resources possibly coming from DDA (special assessment and TIF), USDA (for market pavilion), DOLA, and HUD’CDBG program

Page 22: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

13

space for community events, such as festivals and a farmers market. Floyd, VA offers a good example of a parking lot with a multi-use pavilion2

implementation

Construct a performance space (such as band shell or pavilion with stage) at Town-owned property on Barker Reservoir

The reservoir offers spectacular views of the Divide. The land is town owned and targeted for a community facility. But it is currently underutilized. There is great potential to connect the future Town Square (parking behind visitors center) with the downtown business district, and the reservoir

Mid-term to finish planning and design (up to a year). Long-term to construct (More than 1 year)

DDA and Board of Trustees

Town staff, PROSAB, and City of Boulder (own land near reservoir and use it for drinking water)

High cost. Explore US EPA Section 319 Wetlands Program Development Grants, USDA-RD Community Facilities, and HUD’s CDBG program

Finish evaluation, design and construct the Middle Boulder Creek Path

This project would relocate the trail along the town’s creek from the south to the north side. This would restore sensitive riparian areas on the south side, create a treasured public space, improve creek access, and create access to and new retail opportunities on the back side of 1st Street buildings

Long term (more than 1 year)

DDA and Board of Trustees

Wild Bear, PROSAB, Town Staff, and Colorado DOT

High cost. Explore Colorado DOT Bike/Ped Program, USDA-RD low interest loans

2 To learn more about the Floyd, VA example, visit here: https://www.facebook.com/floydartisanmarket/info?tab=overview

Page 23: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

14

Facilitate the construction of additional attainable workforce housing to meet surging demand Creating new attainable workforce housing was the most prominent challenge discussed during the workshop. However, through the workshop it became apparent that not all Nederland residents are in agreement about what constitutes affordable housing. So an important first action step, described in the table below, is to define what people are talking about and clarify the goal. Once there is a workable consensus around that question, the town can move on to implementing specific action steps in two main areas – building affordable housing and setting incentives and codes that will encourage the private provision of affordable housing. The former entails the town acting as a partner to build affordable housing on land it owns. The latter entails providing an environment conducive to the private construction of compatible affordable housing.

Supporting Implementation Steps

Why is this important? Timeframe Lead Role Support

Cost & Implementation

Resources

Define affordable housing

There are varying ideas about what kinds of housing are included in the term “affordable housing.” As a first step, the town can define the term, providing a shared language and making it easier to establish benchmarks, revise codes, and set incentives policy. A key theme during discussions was the need for “workforce” housing, e.g. school teachers.

Short-term (6 months or less)

Planning Commission

Builders, realtors, tenants, and elected officials

Time commitment and food to attract people to participate in meetings

The town becomes a more active and effective partner for building affordable workforce housing

The development community is in need of assistance to make affordable workforce housing viable. The town needs new tools to be an effective partner

Short-term (less than 6 months) and ongoing

Town Staff and Board of Trustees

Group leading the zoning refresh, Planning Commission, and potential funding partners at regional, state, and

Will require significant investment of time and money (for incentives)

Page 24: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

15

federal levels

Town develops an incentive policy for affordable workforce housing. Possible incentives discussed include fee waivers, parking waivers, and density bonuses.

Developers are not providing affordable workforce housing in the absence of incentives. Yet the town is unable to provide housing that is affordable to teachers and police officers and risks high turnover of these critical employees as a result

Mid-term (9 months to 1 year)

Town Administrator and Planning Commission

Landowner, realtors, and builders

High cost. Requires staff time to establish and funding to implement. Look into regional, state, and federal sources of financial incentives, including USDA—RD programs

Actively engage large property owners and builders to determine what type of incentives would be needed to build affordable workforce housing

The market is not providing sufficient affordable, workforce housing. Also, the town has a good amount of vacant or underutilized land consolidated in a small number of owners. Engaging these owners to find out how these lands can be used for affordable, workforce housing is important to Nederland’s future

Short-term (less than 6 months) and ongoing

Town Administrator and elected officials

Planning Commission,DDA, Boulder County Housing, and Community Members (make engagement open and transparent)

Staff time and food (to encourage participation in meetings)

Engage with the county to share concerns about its annexation policies and set annexation policies that will allow for expansion of the town on its boundaries as infill opportunities are maxed out

The county’s policies deter annexation. This can support infill development, but the town may need to annex some land for additional housing as it grows

Long-term, as additional development space is needed

Town Administrator and elected officials

Boulder County Commissioner, and Planning Commission

Staff time

Page 25: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

16

APPENDIX The self-assessment completed by the community and the workshop presentations are attached.

Additional Resources U.S. EPA Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities: http://www.epa.gov/dced/buildingblocks.htm

Workshop Attendees Name Affiliation Alex Armani-Munn Town of Nederland Dawn Baumhover Town of Nederland Linda Bukatte Nederland resident Paul Carrill Nederland Police Department Cindy Cody US EPA Region 8 Roger Cornell Planning Commission Chairman Topher Donahue Board of Trustees Jill Dreves Wild Bear Mountain Ecology Center Jim Elder Nederland resident Stacey Eriksen US EPA Region 8 Kayla Evans Ranch owner Laura Farris US EPA Region 8 Adam Fels Nederland Middle Senior High School Principal Joe Gierlach Nederland Mayor Linda Glasser Nederland resident Clarissa Guy US EPA Region 8 Barbara Hardt Tebo Properties Witt Harlin Boulder County Public Health Katrina Harms Downtown Development Authority Dan Heine Goodacre & Company Real Estate Guadalupe Herrera US Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Sustainable Communities

Officer Justine Irwin Nederland resident May Jarril Nederland resident Serene Karplus Nederland Area Seniors Human Services Task Force Keith Larsen Nederland resident Liz McGuire Eldora resident Atashnaa Medicine Shield

Nederland resident

Anne Miller Colorado Department of Local Affairs Annette Mitchell Downtown property owner representative Alvin Mites Ned Compost Wendy Monroe Victory Gardens

Page 26: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities Sustainable Strategies for Small Cities and Rural Areas

Nederland, Colorado

17

Dale Porter Gillespie House Museum Alisha Reis Nederland Town Administrator James Reis Nederland resident Kris and Bill Renno Nederland residents Susan Schneider Centennial Bank Jeanette Smith Nederland resident Patti Snidow US Department of Agriculture – Rural Development Lee Stadele Nederland resident Elliot Steele Nederland resident Ian Swallow Boulder County Housing Aimee Tomlinson Nederland resident Camille Thorson Nederland Sustainability Advisory Board member Frank Vincek Nederland resident Elise Waldron Coldwell Banker Wendy Williams Nederland resident, Planning Commission member Charles Wood Board of Trustees

Page 27: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

1

AGENDA INFORMATION MEMORANDUM

NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION

Meeting Date: September 23, 2015

Prepared By: Cynthia Bakke

Dept: Planning & Zoning

Information ______ Action__ ___ Discussion ___X___

______________________________________________________________________

AGENDA ITEM:

Discussion of 2015 Work Plan Housing elements for implementation regarding

short term rentals:

a) Vacation Rental by Owner (VRBO), Airbnb, Bed and Breakfast;

b) Housing elements as identified in #NedZero Action Plan;

c) GIS suitability analysis for housing and commercial property

redevelopment and preservation.

SUMMARY:

Planning Commission will continue discussion of prioritized 2015 Work Plan

housing elements, which begin in March, and as discussed at the December 3, 2014

Work Session and January 28 regular PC meeting. Housing items were identified

among the top priorities to address within the #NedZero Action Plan.

ATTACHMENTS:

1) 2015 PC Work Plan Matrix update

2) Infill GIS analysis for #NedZero Action Plan

Page 28: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

SAP ID (Trello) SAP Section Team Name STAR Action BOT Avg

Funding Comp Plan Timeframe

Work Plan

TimelineSource Lead

OrganizationSupport

Org.Minimum Metrics EPA? STATUS Action Category

6G-02 6. Climate and Energy

G. GIS Database & Land Use Data

CE-3 In conjunction with the Land Use element of the Comprehensive Plan, identify and map locations within town that would be ideally suited for the siting of alternative energy generation and conservation demonstration sites, such as solar arrays, wind turbines, water collection/re-use, and community gardens.

10.71 Identify Funding

Short-term GIS Contract

Comp Plan

SAB PC, Town Locations and SF identified

No Encourage SAB to identify potential grant funding

Mapping

1G-04 1. Ecosystem Relationships

G. GIS Database & Land Use Data

NS-3 Map riparian corridors, areas of higher biodiversity and other areas that feature important ecosystem functionalities (i.e., alpine meadows, wetland system, etc.) to accompany the Town/ FLU Map. Work to develop better guidelines for development within creek corridors, based research asst. on this inventory of the town's natural resources and functions.

23.57 2015 Funding Short-term GIS Contract

Comp Plan

DDA PC, Town Staff

Created (Y/N) No DDA Master Plan Update process

Mapping

7G-01 7. Built Environment

G. GIS Database & Land Use Data

BE-5 Map properties with highest redevelopment potential and preservation potential 33.43 2015 Funding Moderate GIS Contract

Comp Plan

PC NDDA, Historical Society

No PC to recommend for 2016 Budget

Mapping

2G-02 (Combine w/2G-05, -03

2. Community Fabric

G. GIS Database & Land Use Data

BE-2 Identify opportunities for informal pathways and connections in neighborhoods; secure easements where appropriate and identify opportunities to create more permeable neighborhoods in the GIS

41.29 Identify Funding

Ongoing GIS Contract

PROSAB PC

NoPROSAB Trails Plan update

Mapping

2G-05 (Combine w/2G-02,-

2. Community Fabric

G. GIS Database & Land Use

BE-7 Create a "Bike and Ped Friendly Nederland" map that describes safe bike routes and locations of bike parking in Nederland, including walking trails between neighborhoods and central town.

45.86 Identify Funding

Long-term GIS Contract

Comp Plan

PROSAB PC NoPROSAB Trails Plan update

Mapping

2G-03 (Combine w/2G-02, -05)

2. Community Fabric

G. GIS Database & Land Use Data

BE-7 Create Safe Routes GIS layer (Identify safe routes throughout Town, including to the Library and schools; map and install appropriate signage to promote knowledge of those routes.)

47.00 Identify Funding

Short-term GIS Contract

Comp Plan

PROSAB PC No

PROSAB Trails Plan update

Mapping

5X-01 5. Economy and Jobs

X. Resilient Economy

EJ-1 Work with Planning Commission, Town Staff and Board of Trustees to study revisions to the municipal code, specifically the mixed use zoning requirements that may present a barrier to redevelopment or infill in the Downtown Core.

1.29 Funded Short-term Housing Comp Plan

PC BOT Implemented? (Y/N)

Yes EPA Review, draft TK

Codes

2A-02 2. Community Fabric

A. Housing Needs

BE-4 Meet regularly with County Housing and Human Services group to identify needs and resources for affordable housing in Nederland (Social Service)

7.14 Funded Ongoing Housing Comp Plan

Community County HHS, IMA

Meetings held, resources identified

No Ongoing Opportunities

7B-02 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

BE-4 Update Town Municipal Code to encourage development and redevelopment of mixed-use and multifamily housing per Comp Plan

10.00 Funded Short-term Housing Comp Plan

PC Town Staff

Yes EPA Review, draft TK

Codes

7B-03 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

BE-4 Explore creative housing concepts to meet the community's affordable housing needs, including small-scale housing (e.g. cabin zoning concepts), accessory dwelling units, multi-generational development, etc. Review the Town zoning code to prepare for changes to allow for such concepts. (Rental housing licensing update, roll-out).

13.43 Funded Short-term Housing Comp Plan

PC Town Yes EPA Review, draft TK

Codes

7B-04 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

BE-5 Update Zoning and development regulations to align with Comp Plan (prioritizing Public zoning & reg's).

3.86 Funded Short-term Priority Comp Plan

PC BZA, PC Yes EPA Review, draft TK

Codes

7B-09 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

CE-5 Review Town Municipal Code for any barriers to high-efficiency building materials/measures. ADD: Consider change to Muncipal Code to require new construction over a certain size to include alternative energy generation on site.

12.43 2015 Funding Short-term Priority Comp Plan

PC BOT Yes EPA Review, draft TK

Codes

ADD Review Use Group Chart for possible update to formatting, categories. N/AP Priority PCTown Staff Yes

EPA Review, draft TK

Codes

7B-01 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

BE-1 Dark Sky Initiative: Update and enforce the Municipal Code as it relates to downward indirect lighting in residential and commercial districts.

4.71 Funded Comp Plan

PC Town Yes EPA Review, draft TK

Codes

7J-01 7. Built Environment

J. Sustainable Logistics

NS-1 Develop a set of measurable criteria for evaluating development projects in terms of sustainability, including environmental, social, and economic.

9.57 Funded Comp Plan

SAB PC Incorporated into official process? (Y/N)

No Process

Page 29: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

SAP ID (Trello) SAP Section Team Name STAR Action BOT Avg

Funding Comp Plan Timeframe

Work Plan

TimelineSource Lead

OrganizationSupport

Org.Minimum Metrics EPA? STATUS Action Category

3W-02 3. Our Water W. Storm Water System

NS-5 Investigate, identify and pass an ordinance protecting water ways from new development and regulating what type of construction can occur proximate to waterways for existing developments

12.71 Funded N/AP Town Staff PC Buffer width, regulations in palce? (Y/N)

Yes EPA Review, draft TK

Codes

7B-06 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

BE-5 Review and revise the Municipal Code to ensure that it allows for impact analysis for proposed development.

17.86 2015 Funding Short-term Comp Plan

PC Town Yes EPA Review, draft TK

Codes

7E-01 7. Built Environment

E. Energy Efficiency Incentives

CE-3 Identity incentives for improving energy efficiency (e.g., new windows, solar panels, etc.), including amending code to encourage optimal use of passive solar in both new construction and additions.

21.14 Funded Annually Comp Plan

Town Staff Boulder Co., BOT, SAB

Incentives linked properly on Town webpages (Y/N)

No Process

2R-01 2. Community Fabric

R. Local Resources

NS-1 Explore grant opportunities to improve town (rec & community) facilities and programming

21.14 FundedQuarterly, or as needed

Comp Plan

Town Staff PC, partner orgs

Grants awarded ($, #)

No Ongoing Opportunities

2M-04 2. Community Fabric

M. Walkable Scale Mobility

BE-7 Work with NedPeds project to create safe non-motorized pathways connecting important nodes in Town

24.29 Funded Summer 2014

Comp Plan, DDA Plan of Dev.

DDA Town Staff

Project complete (Y/N)

No To re-bid in August 2015 (no bids in July)

Opportunities

3W-03 3. Our Water W. Storm Water System

NS-5 Look at alternative paving options that treat stormwater for appropriate streets in town

27.43 2015 Funding N/AP MIP Town Staff PC, NDDA, BOT

No Ongoing Review

7B-07 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

CE-5 Move towards net-zero energy in all building codes 28.71 2015 Funding N/AP BoCo Sustainability Plan

Mayor's Task Force on Building Code Updates

PC Yes Codes

2J-02 2. Community Fabric

J. Sustainable Logistics

BE-3 Update Muncipal Code Chapter 16, Article VIII, Off-Street Parking and Loading to reflect recommendations of Town Board Ordinance 707

30.86 Identify Funding

Short-term Comp Plan

PC Town, BOT

Adopted? (Y/N) Yes EPA Review, draft TK

Codes

3P-05 3. Our Water P. Source Water Protection

BE-2 Incorporate into land use plans review analysis against Source Water Protection Plan, water availability, infrastructure capacity, and other resource limitations.

42.14 Identify Funding

Comp Plan

PC Town Process Developed

Yes Ongoing Process

7B-05 7. Built Environment

B. Update Building Code

BE-5 Revisit and update the Town's Design Guidelines so that they constantly evolve and reflect the design objective of the community.

46.57 2015 Funding Comp Plan

PC BOT Yes EPA Review, draft TK

Codes

Page 30: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

GIS in the NedZero Action Plan

Nederland Planning Commission

Page 31: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Preservation Potential

Redevelopment Potential

Parcel/Assessor Database

SAP ID: 7G-01, SAP Section 7. Built Environment Action: map properties with highest redevelopment potential and preservation potential

Zoning (map and code)

Query building age, and

architectural style

Density/FAR analysis (existing

vs. allowed)

Estimated Fee Range: $1000 - $1200

Output Inputs GIS Processes

Proximity to downtown,

transit, parking Estimated Fee Range: $600 - $800

Page 32: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Infill suitability analysis

Build-out analysis of existing zoning—commercial floor space capacity

Potential commercial floor space (ft2)

Page 33: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Infill suitability analysis

Build-out analysis of existing zoning—dwelling unit capacity

Dwelling units per acre

Page 34: TOWN OF NEDERLAND PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR … Herring, Jesse Seavers, and Wendy Williams; Commissioner Timmy Duggan arrived at 7:18pm. Trustee Topher Donahue arrived after review

Infill suitability analysis

Build-out analysis of existing zoning--summary

Floor Area

0

10000000

20000000

30000000

40000000

50000000

60000000

70000000

80000000

Existing (2009) Additional Total Build-Out

Dwelling Units

0

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

12000

14000

16000

18000

Existing (2009) Additional Total Build-Out