12
TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL COLLABORATION: an E-Government Application in Transportation Service Sayuri Egaravanda*, Lukito Edi Nugroho*, Teguh Bharata Adji*, Ahmad Munawar** * Electrical Engineering and Information Technology Department, ** Civil and Environmental Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering, Gadjah Mada University, Jl. Grafika No. 2 Kampus UGM, Yogyakarta 55581, Email: [email protected] , [email protected] , [email protected] , [email protected] ABSTRACT This paper proposes a collaboration model among user, government and transportation services. User involvement is put into focus and gain more significant role in decision making in transport management. This is done by transforming information processing carried in a Traveler Information System (TIS) system operated by government. We develop Smart-ATIS, ATIS with two- way communication system that allows user feedback for more effective and efficient traffic management. In the e- government framework, Smart-ATIS opens up opportunities of citizen participation in urban transportation management. Keywords: Transformational System, Virtual Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart- ATIS. 1 INTRODUCTION In the era of technological advancement, numerous new information and communication technologies (ICTs) innovation has been introduced to the public sector [1]. An important phase of e-Government implementation is the transformation of government and government organizations to provide better services. E-Government era implies fundamental knowledge redistribution and requires a careful rethinking of the management of information resources and knowledge bases [2]. Within e-Government, the focus of managing information resources is predominantly on the management of interactions among the government, citizens or business [21]. In the transportation area, the concept of Intelligent Transportation System (ITS) grows out of the need to enhance the efficiency and safety of the current transportation system. [5,6,7,8]. Typically ITS solution involves three major functions: Monitoring, Automated Analysis and Action. Based on analysis, ITS allows us to make many changes that affect real transportation services, for example: changing of traffic signal timing, posting a message to overhead changeable message signs, modifying transit schedules and rerouting buses, dispatching emergency services, providing information to the media and public electronically, plowing and salting a roadway [9]. Providing information in transportation area is not enough, it is imperative that this delivery satisfies customers of government services [24]. In order to provide various service levels and to meet rising expectations, government needs to utilize recent advances in technological development [23]. In the near future, technology will permeate almost every business practice. By embedding microprocessors and sensors in materials and physical devices, Organizations will also be able to create objects that respond to their internal or external environment [4]. The services not only have the function as an information provider but also indirectly increase the user involvement of public services. User satisfaction can be achieved by providing opportunities for user involvement related to traffic management decision-making, in this case illustrated by Area Traffic Control System (ATCS). ATCS is the system that focuses on traffic signals, ramp metering, and the dynamic message signs. Generally, traffic light settings depend on traffic counting and traffic surveillance. Providing information based on real time condition, occasionally not suitable with the real condition when traveler passed that intersection, because of the differences time. This paper tries to describe the new model which enables intervention of ATCS by processing user information. In this paper we propose a model in which improve collaboration among user and government in transportation services. The idea is to inject an intervention to the system that creates a communication channel for common users to participate in the traffic management system (represented by ATCS), which in 5-07 Transforming G2c/c2g Relations Through Virtual Collaboration: An E-government Application In Transportation Service 147

TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL ...€¦ · Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart-ATIS. 1 INTRODUCTION

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL ...€¦ · Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart-ATIS. 1 INTRODUCTION

TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL

COLLABORATION: an E-Government Application in Transportation

Service

Sayuri Egaravanda*, Lukito Edi Nugroho*, Teguh Bharata Adji*, Ahmad Munawar**

* Electrical Engineering and Information Technology Department,

** Civil and Environmental Engineering Department,

Faculty of Engineering, Gadjah Mada University,

Jl. Grafika No. 2 Kampus UGM, Yogyakarta 55581,

Email: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]

ABSTRACT

This paper proposes a collaboration model among

user, government and transportation services. User

involvement is put into focus and gain more significant

role in decision making in transport management. This is

done by transforming information processing carried in a

Traveler Information System (TIS) system operated by

government. We develop Smart-ATIS, ATIS with two-

way communication system that allows user feedback for

more effective and efficient traffic management. In the e-

government framework, Smart-ATIS opens up

opportunities of citizen participation in urban

transportation management.

Keywords: Transformational System, Virtual

Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport

System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart-

ATIS.

1 INTRODUCTION

In the era of technological advancement, numerous

new information and communication technologies (ICTs)

innovation has been introduced to the public sector [1].

An important phase of e-Government implementation is

the transformation of government and government

organizations to provide better services. E-Government

era implies fundamental knowledge redistribution and

requires a careful rethinking of the management of

information resources and knowledge bases [2]. Within

e-Government, the focus of managing information

resources is predominantly on the management of

interactions among the government, citizens or business

[21].

In the transportation area, the concept of Intelligent

Transportation System (ITS) grows out of the need to

enhance the efficiency and safety of the current

transportation system. [5,6,7,8]. Typically ITS solution

involves three major functions: Monitoring, Automated

Analysis and Action. Based on analysis, ITS allows us to

make many changes that affect real transportation

services, for example: changing of traffic signal timing,

posting a message to overhead changeable message signs,

modifying transit schedules and rerouting buses,

dispatching emergency services, providing information to

the media and public electronically, plowing and salting a

roadway [9].

Providing information in transportation area is not

enough, it is imperative that this delivery satisfies

customers of government services [24]. In order to

provide various service levels and to meet rising

expectations, government needs to utilize recent

advances in technological development [23]. In the near

future, technology will permeate almost every business

practice. By embedding microprocessors and sensors in

materials and physical devices, Organizations will also be

able to create objects that respond to their internal or

external environment [4].

The services not only have the function as an

information provider but also indirectly increase the user

involvement of public services. User satisfaction can be

achieved by providing opportunities for user involvement

related to traffic management decision-making, in this

case illustrated by Area Traffic Control System (ATCS).

ATCS is the system that focuses on traffic signals, ramp

metering, and the dynamic message signs. Generally,

traffic light settings depend on traffic counting and traffic

surveillance. Providing information based on real time

condition, occasionally not suitable with the real

condition when traveler passed that intersection, because

of the differences time. This paper tries to describe the

new model which enables intervention of ATCS by

processing user information.

In this paper we propose a model in which improve

collaboration among user and government in

transportation services. The idea is to inject an

intervention to the system that creates a communication

channel for common users to participate in the traffic

management system (represented by ATCS), which in

5-07 Transforming G2c/c2g Relations Through Virtual Collaboration: An E-government Application In Transportation Service

147

Page 2: TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL ...€¦ · Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart-ATIS. 1 INTRODUCTION

2

turn improves better decision making in traffic

management and information provision for users.

2 RELATED RESEARCH

ITS is a state-of-the-art approach based on

information, communication and satellite technologies in

mitigating traffic congestion, enhancing safety, and

improving quality of environment [3] and is mandatory to

provide access based on human spontaneous

communication ability [15].

In the early days of ITS deployment, Advanced

Traveler Information System (ATIS) was used to provide

basic information for travelers (e.g., routes). ATIS is an

integral component of ITS. It carries out data collection,

aggregation and processing, communications and

operates with traveler interface devices to improve both

of safety and efficiency of existing transportation system

[10]. ATIS delivers data directly to travelers or citizens,

empowers them to make better choices about alternate

routes or modes of transportation. Researchers classified

articles into 5 classes of ATIS’s, These Five categories

were: In-Vehicle Routing and Navigation Systems, In-

Vehicle Motorist Services Information Systems, In-

Vehicle Safety Advisory and Warning Systems, In-

Vehicle Signing Information Systems and Commercial

Vehicle Operations specific Funtions[9].

The important aspects of information are the content

and the type of information. Information in ATIS can be

categorized as (a) historical, real-time, or predictive, (b)

qualitative and quantitative, and (c) accurate, timely,

relevant, and reliable. Huang et al further investigated

from their view point of evaluation; the ATIS’s affects in

saving driver’s travel times and the travelers dynamic

responses, like purchasing the ATIS services and

believing the ATIS advice. According to J.L Adler,

model of Intelligent Traveller Information System

provides ITIS in which artificial intelligence techniques

Involvement of users in current ATIS improves their

confidence in using freeways and it is not only an

effective method of information presentation but also

allows more efficient navigation and less off-route, lost

time, and driver exposure [8]. Several models for

estimating link travel times on basis of individual data

sources (i.e. detectors, probe vehicles and driver reports)

was implemented to anticipate the problem based on

current conditions [14]. Users are generally appreciative

of traffic information that gives them a choice to make

decisions regarding their travel behavior as long as they

perceive the information to be accurate, timely and in-

expensive [11].

3 THE PROPOSED MODEL : SMART-

ATIS

3.1 The role of ATIS

Some information which are required by travelers are:

the current state of the network based on real-time

information across all transports modes, where

congestion exist and any particular conditions (such as

weather or incidents) and travel option.

Yurdaer, R., et.al, states that ATIS plays an important

role because the quality of the defined routes has an in-

depth impact on the performance of whole transport

system. ATIS highlights existing conditions on our

transportation system that we act on. It also highlights

historical patterns used for planning the system and leads

to travel choices for the traveler. Advanced Traveler

information involves the traveler into the decision

process [16].

Actually, the impact of ATIS in traffic pattern and

network performance is controversial for several reasons

[18]:

1. Even if all users had a perfect knowledge of the travel

cost associated to each available path and user

equilibrium was achieved, this could be very far from

an optimum configuration of the whole network in

terms of total cost sustained by all users;

2. Even if we find how to distribute traffic on the

different paths and over time in order to minimize the

total network cost, and provide the appropriate

information what will the driver reactions be to our

suggestions?

3. How will the proportion of equipped and not equipped

drivers with ATIS impact the network performance?

4. An overreaction can occur if too many drivers respond

to the information.

The new model will provide information in the

context of transportation system that requiring

correspondence between user expectation and the

information. Virtual collaboration explains interaction

among government, citizen and government services

(ATIS). Advanced technology will assist to get

information about users need and process with analytical

tools. Analytical tool associated with data modeling and

predictive analytics.

The Proceedings of The 7th ICTS, Bali, May 15th-16th, 2013 (ISSN: 9772338185001)

148

Page 3: TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL ...€¦ · Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart-ATIS. 1 INTRODUCTION

3

3.2 Virtual Collaboration in Advanced

Traveler Information System

The essence of virtual collaboration is to break up the

unity of time, location and trade using information and

communication technology application.

In our model of ATIS we identify three typologies of

collaboration: government rules, context of system, and

user needs. Government rules are related to list of

activities, context of system is related processing process

and user needs is related output of ATIS (Table. 1).

Transformation process in government also relates to

collaboration between stakeholders. The idea of

collaboration corresponds with the concept of an

organization which includes collectiveness. It is obvious

that these collaboration instances have some benefits:

saves time or money, increases quality, innovating or

provides decision support ease of access to experts on

subject matter [13].

Table 1 ATIS as Information Service Provider

N

o Activities

Information

Processing Output

1

Collect, process,

store, and

dessiminate

transportation

information

Provide General

data warehouse

function

Collecting

information from

transportation

system operator

Route Choice

Prediction of

travel time, etc

2

2

Deliver of

traveler

information to

citizen

Provide realtime

traffic condition

Transit schedule

information

Ride maching

information

Parking

Information

Route

Guidance

Multimodal

Choice in

Trip Planning

Parking area

and capacity

Figure 1. Collaboration Environment

Fig. 1 illustrated common interaction between Traffic

Management System which represents Government (c),

Advanced Traveler Information System (ATIS)

representing Government product (a) and User (b).

Each component possesses a relevant description of

subject (ATIS), task (activities of ATIS), owner

(government) and output (information service of ATIS).

In existing model of ATIS, every component has its

own specific purpose in collaboration. Intersections

between sets illustrate that collaboration occurs. ATIS

(a) will interact with government, represented by ATCS

(c) in process of presenting related information about

route selection and guidance. c serves as a source of data

for a in describing existing traffic condition, based on

output of information processing in ATCS. a can give b

(users) an advice about path selection, related paths, and

estimated travel time through web based application

interfaces. b can then use the information to decide his or

her trips.

Our proposed model transforms the interactions

among a, b, and c. Intervention of advanced technology

(x) in the processing information will lead to changes the

business process. The intervention will be conducted by

addicting the function of a (ATIS), not only as an

information provider, but also as intelligent tool.

Figure 2 illustrates the establishment of a new model

of virtual collaboration. In our model, a, b, and c

intersect each other by means of advanced technology

intervention (x). Variable x identified as transformational

process in processing information caused by advanced

technology.

Figure 2. Future Collaboration Environment

The transformation produces two types of output,

route guidance and route prediction, without changing the

interacting participants. x will contains set of new rule in

processing information.

Future COLLABORATION

x COLLABORATION ENVIRONTMENT

5-07 Transforming G2c/c2g Relations Through Virtual Collaboration: An E-government Application In Transportation Service

149

Page 4: TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL ...€¦ · Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart-ATIS. 1 INTRODUCTION

4

Variable x is the application that is associated with

advanced technologies and this application can be

adaptive to the current context and the user context. The

applications have tools to acquiring and representing the

current context (location, traffic conditions, and thus

sensors sometimes needed. Also, the application needs to

acquire and represent the next condition in path network

to get additional inputs in order to facilitating the new

scenario in managing of traffic system. The application

has value added that become autonomous and proactive

which can free users from initiating processes and tuning

them to suit the current context and current interest. In

this system x also has a function as analytical tools.

The next parts of this paper describes the detail of the

proposed model of ATIS, providing travel time

prediction and route choices and also process the

information with analytical tool, in order to predict traffic

condition. The result of forecasting information will be

handed over to ATCS for further decision on the timing

of traffic lights. The new scenario will causes a change in

Traffic Management System autonomously.

Future model experiencing transformation model in

processing information which allow the process of

collaboration between user (community), government

application (ATIS) and Government services (Traffic

Management System ) to describe the process of creating

a virtual communities supported by advanced technology.

The proposed model is Smart-ATIS.

3.3 Framework of SmartATIS with Dual

Engine

Smart-ATIS uses Dual Engine, Route Selection

Engine (RSE) and Route Prediction Engine (RPE). RSE

is working together with ATIS to provide optimum route

alternatives for traveler. RPE provides traffic forecasting

based on routes accepted by the traveler, determine

where traffic congestion will occur, and then sends the

intervention message to ATCS for pre-emptive

countermeasures.

Figure 4 explained conceptual framework of Smart-

ATIS. When traveler accesses route selection in Smart

ATIS, (1) RSE will calculate several optimum routes (a

route is composed of several path) based on current

traffic information available from ATCS data sources),

then presented back to the traveler (step 2). If traveler

accepts one of the recommended routes (step 3), RSE

will store and accumulate paths in storage. This storage is

part of RSE. Each path has a lifetime, only stored during

a definite period of time; this is called an active path.

Each route has estimated travel time (step 4); this will be

the path's lifetime. The collection of active path is then

processed by RPE (step5).

Figure 4. Framework of Smart-ATIS with dual Engine

RPE continuously performs forecasting based on the

collection of active path from the storage. During

forecasting, each path would have a new information

attribute, which is the future estimation of traffic load

(named “future traffic load”). This information then

compared to the threshold value indicating the maximum

traffic load on each path. If a path's future traffic load is

beyond threshold value, then a path can be determined as

congested (this attribute is named “future traffic state”).

Future traffic state value can be “congested” or “normal”.

The output of forecasting is a collection of path along

with the future traffic state attribute, transferred to ATCS

(step 6,7,8). Based on this feedback information, ATCS

can adjust the duration of traffic light on each path

according to the value of future traffic state in attempt to

achieve an optimal traffic flow state.

3.4 Implementation Architecture

We have so far discussed business process of

Smart-ATIS as a new paradigm in processing

information. To further understand the transformation

model of Smart-ATIS, it is helpful to view a Smart-ATIS

as special case and implemented in the real condition. In

order to acquire Smart-ATIS intervention, a pilot testing

should be done to districts/municipalities which already

have implemented ATIS and ATCS, for example

Jogjakarta Special Region. Existing ATCS in Jogjakarta

operates based on input from traffic surveillance and

traffic counting sensors.

Existing ATIS in Jogjakarta mainly provides

shortest route selection without considering real time

traffic conditions. Therefore, the existing ATIS needs to

be enhanced with a Route Prediction Engine which will

3 4

8

5

7 6

ATIS Route Selection Engine (RSE)

Forecasting

Route Prediction Engine (RPE)

ATCS

Accumulation

of active path

Real-time

accumulation of all

active path

1

2

The Proceedings of The 7th ICTS, Bali, May 15th-16th, 2013 (ISSN: 9772338185001)

150

Page 5: TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL ...€¦ · Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart-ATIS. 1 INTRODUCTION

5

capture user preferred route selections, provide traffic

load forecasting on preferred routes, and then handover

the forecasting information to ATCS for further decision

on the timing of traffic lights. (Fig. 5).

Our proposed model illustrated a collaboration model

in government application in transportation represented

transformation process while a (ATIS), b (user),and c

(ATCS) affected each other. Intervention of advanced

technology (x) as analytical tool in the processing

information will lead to changes ATCS automatically.

3.5 Implementation Architecture

4 CONCLUSION

We have discussed transformational of existing

services to create virtual collaborations among

government-operated system (ATCS), transportation

services (ATIS) and users. Smart-ATIS allows

government to provide traffic information which suits

user needs, based on real-time traffic condition. At the

same time, the system also allows users to give feedback

to the ATCS system to be used for optimizing traffic

management in a specific area. In our future research, we

will develop traffic light simulation that models the

mechanism of Smart-ATIS.

REFERENCE

[1] Maria, A.Wimmer, Codognone,C., Xiofeng, Ma,

“Developing an E-Government Research Roadmap:

Method and Example from E-Govt, RTD, 2007.

[2] T.C. Hsia, “Simple Robust Schemes for Space

Control of Robot Manipulators”, Int’l. J. of Robotics

and Automation, 9(4), 1994, 167- 174.

[3] http://www.accenture.com/xd/xd.asp?it=enweb&xd=i

ndustries\government\gove_thought.xml

[4] Rivard, S., Aubert, A. Benoit., Patry, M., Pare,

G.Smith, A, Heather,” Information Technology and

Organizational Transformation”, Elsevier, 2004.

[5] Cheslow, M., Hatcher, S., and H sin V. J.,

"Communication, Storage, and Processing Load

Requirements of Alternative Intelligent Vehicle

Highway Systems Architectures”, MITRE, 1993.

[6] Cheslow, M., Hatcher, S.,Mc Gurrin, and M. Mertig,

A., "Alternative IVHS Architectures", MITRE, April

1992.

ATIS

ADVANCED TRAVELER

INFORMATION SYSTEM

Improving the performance of

transportation networks and

Quality of Travel

1. assist traveler in making

pre trip

2. enroute travel choices

decision

1.Depature time

2. route

3.travel mode

4. cost

5. travel time

6. Destination

Information processing

Implement structural mechanism

and data processing capability to

enhance the dataflow (reduce

uncertainty)

Decision to

aquire

information

Constrain:

Time,effect,money,

modes

Benefit:

Potential to help make

right choices given

applied strategy

Trip context:

Complexity of the

choices situation,

time presure

Information Service:

Availability, price,

ease of use,

reliability,relevance,

resourcefullness

1.Traveler Knowledge

2.Decision strategy

1. Alternative

2. Availibility

3. Potential

atractiveness

Understand travel challenge

What information traveler needs and wants

Which information would be presented to the traveler

Where the traveler would want the information presented

Communications and traveler

interface devices

OPERATIONAL DATA

Route Selection Planning

ANALYTICAL TOOLS

(INTELLEGENCE

ANALYSIS)

Raoute Prediction palnning

Ge

ne

rate

ACTION

POINT

Autonomous Traffic

Management

System

Data

Sources

ATCS

USER NEEDS

USER

INTERVENTION

Figure 5 .Implementation Model of Smart-ATIS

5-07 Transforming G2c/c2g Relations Through Virtual Collaboration: An E-government Application In Transportation Service

151

Page 6: TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL ...€¦ · Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart-ATIS. 1 INTRODUCTION

6

[7] Cheslow, M., Hatcher, G., and Patel V., "An initial

Evaluation of Alternative Intelligent Vehicle Highway

Systems Architectures", MITRE, April 1992.

[8] Yurdaer N. Doganata, Denos C. Gazis, and Asser N.

Tantawi, “A communication Network Architecture

for Transportation Information System”, IBM

Research Division, 1995.

[9] Anonymous, “Intelligent Infrastructure: Delivering

the Competitiveness Benefits an Enterprise

Opportunities, Fortas Publication, 2011.

[10] David Levinson, “The Value of advanced traveler

information system for route choice”, Transportation

Research Part C11, 2003 pp. 75-79

[11] Noonan, J. Shearer,O., “ Intelligent Transportation

System Fields Operational Test Cross-Cutting Study

Advance Traveler Information System, Booz Allen &

Hamilton Inc, 2008.

[12] Zigurs,I. and Buckland, B. K., “A Theory of

Task/Technology Fit and Group Support Systems

Effectiveness,” MIS Quarterly (22:3), 1998, 313-

334.

[13] Coleman D., Levine S., "Collaboration 2.0:

Technology and best practices for successful

collaboration in a web 2.0 world", ISBN 160005-

071-9, California, USA, 2008.

[14] H.Bruce and Gudapati, R., “Estimating link Travel

times for advanced Traveller Information Systems”,

University of Waterloo, Canada, 2000.

[15] Petriu, E.M., Patry G, Whalen, T.E., Al-dhaher, A,

Groza, V.Z., “Intelligent robotic sensor agents for

environment monitoring”, Visms 2002 int Symp on

Virtual and Intelligent Measurement System, 18-20

May 2002.

[16] J. C. Q. Dias, J. M. F. Calado, A. L. Osório and L. F.

Morgado, "Intelligent Transport System Based on

RFID and Multi-Agent Approaches", International

Federation for Information Processing, Volume 283,

Pervasive collaborative Networks, (Boston:

Springer), 2008, pp. 533–540.

[17] Singh,V., Kumar, P., “Web based ATIS for

Developing Countries”, Journal of Transportation

Engineering, 2010.

[18] D.Buscema, M. Ignaccolo, G. Inturri, A. Pluchino,

A. Rapisarda, C. Santoro, and S. Tudisco, “The

impact of real time information on transport network

routing through intelligent agent-based simulation,”

in Science and Technology for Humanity (TIC-

STH), IEEE Toronto International Conference,

Sept, 2009, pp. 72–77

[19] J.L. Adler, Victor, J. Blue, “Toward the design of

Intelligent traveler information systems”,

Transportation Research Part C, Vol 6, June 2006.

[20] Hai-Jun Huang, William, H, K, Lam, “A Multi-Class

Dynamic User Equilibrium Model for Queuing

Networks with Advanced Traveler Information

Systems”, Journal of Mathematical Modeling and

Algorithms, 12-2003, Vol.2, pp 349-377.

[21] Wagner,C., Cheung,K., Lee,F., Rachael IP.,

“Enhancing E-government in Developing Countries:

Managing Knowledge Through Virtual

Communities”, The Electronic Journal of

Developing Countries, 2003.

[22] W.Eric,W., H.Charles,C., “Internet use, transparency

and interactivity effects on trust in Government,

Proceedings of the 36th Annual Hawaii

International Conference on System Sciences, 2003.

[23] T.A Horan, T.A Raghiuvira, “Assessing user

satisfaction of E-Government Services:

Development and testing of quality-in-use

satisfaction with Advanced Traveler Information

System (ATIS)”, Proceeding of the 39th Hawaii

International Conference on System Sciences, 2006.

The Proceedings of The 7th ICTS, Bali, May 15th-16th, 2013 (ISSN: 9772338185001)

152

Page 7: TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL ...€¦ · Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart-ATIS. 1 INTRODUCTION
Page 8: TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL ...€¦ · Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart-ATIS. 1 INTRODUCTION
Page 9: TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL ...€¦ · Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart-ATIS. 1 INTRODUCTION
Page 10: TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL ...€¦ · Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart-ATIS. 1 INTRODUCTION
Page 11: TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL ...€¦ · Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart-ATIS. 1 INTRODUCTION
Page 12: TRANSFORMING G2C/C2G RELATIONS THROUGH VIRTUAL ...€¦ · Collaboration, E-Government, Intelligent Transport System, Advanced Traveler Information System, Smart-ATIS. 1 INTRODUCTION