TÜSİAD - Yeni Anayasa Yuvarlak Masa Toplantıları Dizisi (Yeni Anayasanın Beş Temel Boyutu)

8/7/2019 TSAD - Yeni Anayasa Yuvarlak Masa Toplantlar Dizisi (Yeni Anayasann Be Temel Boyutu)

1/58

Bf yv z k {f z Ghjjfw k , Co # := 7::90 Zfpfih / w z hciv lZf l f moc 1 $ 0989 + 9:; 0> 97 Zf l f m ht 1 $ 0989 + 9:; 87 60

Bhyz 9088[h{c Co1 ZWHJ"Z/9088/07/687

[FC HCH[HWH [V]HYLHE BHWH

ZOPLHCZKLHYK JQW1

[FC HCH[HWHCKC IF ZFBFL IO[VZV


2/58

Zb dhelhy wheljy# Iv fwfykc zhbhb {h jh iky ilb,

:880 wh{l [hwh klf jfkke 64:= wh{l MWFE v{hycgh,

evllhclbhqjhc cgf dhe whdkikcjfc 69# Bhjjf{f v{nvc

{hql kqkc hlcbhjeh, dkiky fekl }f {czfblf klfcbfe, ohlzlbhe,

ohlzlb cwdhlhy {h{lbhe, whzlbhe,

ekyhlhcbhe, jc }fyklbfe, zfbwkl fjklbfe, wvcvlbhe,

zfllk/zflwkq {h jh iheh zfecke, wh{whl }f/}f{h flfezyocke

{czfblfylf klfzklbfe wvyfzk{lf evllhclhbhq#

9088, ZWHJ

WW BHZIHHGKLKE PYOB# ZHCKZKB DQ# ZG# LZJ# Z#Fkzkb Bhd# Po{yhq Woe# Co18 J#=7 Ehje{ " WZHCIVLZfl1 $098=+ :60 := 74 Mhew1 $098=+ :60 := 7;

KWIC1 ;>4";;::":06"=;"0

Ehphe Zhwhyb1 Johc Evbo}h


3/58

CWQZWHJ, qfl wfezy zfbwkl fjfc whch{kgk }f khjhblhy zhyhmcjhc 8;>8

{lcjh, Hch{hwhbqc }f Jfycfelfy Ehcvcv.cvc klnklk deblfykcf v{nvc

olhyhe evyvlbv, ehbv {hyhych hlhc iky jfycfe olvp ncll iky wk}kl zoplvbynzjy#

ZWHJ, kcwhc dhelhy f}yfcwfl kleflfykckc, jcgf, kchc }f nkykkb

qnylelfykckc, lhke dveve jf}lfzkckc, ehzlbg jfboeyhwk hclh{cc, lkifyhl

feocobkckc, yfehifzk pk{hwh feocobkwkckc evyvb }f evyhllhycc }f wyjylfiklky

f}yf jfcnfwkckc ifckbwfcjkk iky zoplvbwhl jqfckc olvbhwch }f nflkbfwkcf

ehze whlhbh{ hbhlhy#

ZWHJ, Hzhzye.c cnyj dfjfm }f kleflfy joyvlzvwvcjh, Zyek{f.ckc

hjh v{nhyle jqf{kck {hehlhbh }f hbh hclh{ kkcjf, ehjc"fyefe fkzlkkck

wk{hwfz, feocobk }f fkzkb hwcjhc nqfzfc k kcwhclhycc zoplvbvc cg }f

nkykkbgk iky nyviv oljvv kchcg{lh, {vehyjh wvcvlhc hch nh{fckc

nfyfelfzkyklbfwkck whlhbhe hbhg{lh hlbhlhy nfyfelfzkyky#

ZWHJ, ehbv {hyhych hlhc Zye k jc{hwcc zfbwkl ynz olhyhe,

nkykkbgklfykc f}yfcwfl k hdlhe kleflfykcf v{nvc mhhlk{fz nwzfybfwk {ccjf

hih whym fjfy5 eyfwfllfbf wyfgkcjf Zye yfehifz ngcc }f zoplvbwhl

yfmhdc, kwzkdjhbc, }fykblklkkc, {fcklkeklke ehphwkzfwkckc }f fkzkbkc ehpwhb

}f ehlkzfwkckc wyfelk hyzylbhw {olv{lh {ewflzklbfwkck fwhw hly#

ZWHJ, zoplvbwhl ihy }f vqlhbhcc wyjylj iky oyzhbjh, lefbkqkc

feocobke }f wow{hl ehlecbhwcjh ilnfwfl }f wfezyfl pozhcwk{fllfyk fc k{k fekljf

jffylfcjkyfyfe vlvwhl feocobke polkzkehlhyc olvzvyvlbhwch ehzejh ivlvcvy#

Zyek{f.ckc eyfwfl yfehifz jqf{kcjf zhczbch ehzejh ivlvcvy, H}yvph

Ikylkk $HI+ {flkk wyfgkck jfwzfelfbfe qfyf vlvwlhyhyhw wk{hwhl, feocobke,

wow{hl }f elzyfl klkek, klfzkkb, zfbwkl }f kikylkk hlhycc nflkzkyklbfwk kkc

hlbhlhy {hphy# Vlvwlhyhyhw fczfnyhw{ocv }f fzeklfkbk, ilnfwfl }f {fyfl

nflkbf{k dqlhcjybhe kkc hyhzybh {hphy, ny olvzvyvy, pyoaflfy nflkzkyky

}f iv ehpwhbjh fzekclkelfy jqfclfy#

ZWHJ, Zye k jc{hw hjch, iv fyf}fjf olvhc ny }f cfyklfykck

Zyek{f I{e Bkllfz Bfglkwk.cf $ZIBB+, debfzf, jkfy jf}lfzlfyf, vlvwlhyhyhw

evyvlvlhyh }f ehbvo{vch joyvjhc {h jh jolh{l olhyhe ihwc }f jkfy hyhlhy

hyhgl klf klfzfyfe, {vehyjhek hbhlhy joyvlzvwvcjh jcgf }f dhyfefz

ikylkk olvzvybh{ dfjfmlfy#


4/58

ZWHJ bkw{ocv joyvlzvwvcjh }f mhhlk{fzlfyk fyf}fwkcjf, lef ncjfbkcjf

ivlvchc eocvlhylh klnklk nylfykck iklkbwfl hlbhlhylh jfwzfelf{fyfe ehbvo{vch

jv{vyvy }f iv nylfyjfc dhyfefzlf ehbvo{vcjh zhyzbh plhzmoyblhycc

olvzvyvlbhwc whlhy#

Iv hlbh, ZWHJ.c nkykkbk{lf {fck Hch{hwhcc if cfblk io{vzvcv flfhlbhe qfyf, hehjfbkw{fclfy }f ehchhz cjfylfykckc ehzlb{lh 9 Ehwb 9080"

8 Bhyz 9088 zhykdlfyk hyhwcjh jqfclfcfc {v}hylhe bhwh zoplhczlhycjh

{hplhc zhyzbhlhyjhc ehc wocv yhpoylhyc }f iv zoplhczlhyc f

eooyjkchzylc wzlfcfc Pyom# Jy# Fynvc qivjvc klf Pyom# Jy# Zvynvz

Zhydhcl.cc {oyvb }f jffylfcjkybf yhpoyvcv kfybfezfjky#

ZWHJ, Zyek{f.ckc jfboeyhwk h ivlvcjvvcv, jfboeyhwk hcc

nkjfyklbfwk kkc ehpwhbl iky jfboeyhzkelfbf nkykkbk ihlhbcjh ikyf{ ojhel,

dkiky h{yghlh {fy }fybf{fc, ev}}fzlfy h{yl klefwkckc nffylk oljvv, ovlgv

}f phylhbfczfy wkwzfbk fwhw hlhc {fck iky hch{hwh {hplbhw nfyfkck vqvcgh

iky wyfjky jklf nfzkybfezfjky# Iv hclh{ fyf}fwkcjf ZWHJ.c {fck hch{hwh

kdzk{hgch klkekc jcgflfyk, Ny Jfynkwk.ckc Fekb 9080 wh{wcjh v eflkbflfylf

jklf nfzkyklbkzky#

)Nfykjf iyhezbq yfmfyhcjvb jcfbk jfboeyhzkelfbf wyfgk ihlhbcjh

{fck }f oe cfblk iky f}yfckc khyfzkwk olhyhe ehybqh ebhezhjy# oe

cfblkjky ce yfmfyhcjvb cgfwkcjfek wk{hwk wlvp }f ehbplhzybh hihlhy

iky zhyhmh iyhelywh, yfmfyhcjvb wocvgv, dfb f}fz jk{fclfy dfb jf dh{y

jk{fclfy hwcjhc nfck iky woyvblvlve hlhc {hyhzz, iky {fyjf dfy efwkb efcjkckiv woyvblvlve hlhcch ihlhj# Iv woyvblvlve hlhc, wfbfclfyk jf, WZE.lhy

jh, wk{hwk phyzklfyk jf ihlhbhezhjy# Cfjky iv woyvblvlve hlhc? Zyek{f

Gvbdvyk{fzk }hzhcjhlhycc kle jfmh efcjk zhlfplfyk fyf}fwkcjf, efcjklfykcf

hkz }f wk}kl iky hclh{ klf {fck iky Hch{hwh {hpbhlhy pfywpfezkmkcjf iky wocvgh

vlhbhcc nfyfezkyjkk w{lfb }f f{lfblfyjky# zf iv fyf}f, dfy ikykbkqkc

woyvblvlve hlhcc zhcblhbhezhjy# cfblk olhc, {fck, wk}kl }f ikqf hkz iky

Hch{hwh {hpbh df{fghcc {kzkybfbfe }f bk{opke fekbflfyf bhdhl }fybfjfc

iv df{fghc 98# {q{lh {hey, dhzzh ycfe ckzflkezf iky Hch{hwh dhqylhbh{h

ojhelhcbhezy# Iv df{fghc dk pdfwkq zoplvbvbvqvc hyqv fzzkk dvqvyvc

}f yfmhdc h{ylbhq phyhw ckzflkkcjfjky#)

Zoplhczlhy jkqkwkck jv{vyjvvbvq F{ll 9080 zhykdlk ihwc ilzfckbkqjf

kwf, wfklfc eocvlhy }f wyfzfc ifelfczklfykbkqk v eflkbflfylf kmhjf fzbkzke1

)Zoplvbvbvqjh dfy efwkbkc {fck hch{hwhjhc ifelfczkwkckc mhyel olbhw

}f {fck hch{hwh{h efcjk cgflkelfykcf nyf hclhb {elfbfwk johljy# Hcghe

{fck hch{hwh dfy f{jfc cgf, zb }hzhcjhlhybqc mhyellelhy{lh iky hyhjh


5/58

{hhbh kyhjfwkck zfbwkl fjfc, klfyk jfboeyhwklfyf ycfe zfekl fjfiklfgfe, }hzhcjhlh

klfzkkb ng {ewfe }f {fcklkek iky zoplvb wqlfbfwk ckzflkk zhbhljy#

Zyek{f.ckc {fck hch{hwh{h nkjfc {oljh zoplvbv ilfc woyvclhyc qbfe kkc

ehylel hclh{, fbphzk, jk{hlon }f {hpglh kdzk{hg }hyjy# Zhykdk ihlhbjh

jfboeyhzkelfbf wyfgk 7 hch bfwflf klf wyfelk ehy ehy{h ehlbzy# Ehzlbg

}f vqlhbhg iky wyflf dhqylhchghe 98# {q{lh {hey {fck hch{hwh, {vehyjhiflkyzklfc hch qfllkelfyk zhbhwcc {hccjh, Zyek{f.ckc 7 ilfckck,

7 ikylfzkyfc dhlkcf nfzkybf{f jf dkqbfz fzbflkjky#)

[vehyjhek {helhb fyf}fwkcjf,)7 ikylfzkyfc) olbhw kkc nh{yfz whym

fzzkkbkq, )ekblkelfy), )jkc }f }kgjhc qnyl) }f )ev}}fzlfy h{yl) ihlelhycc

{hc wyh, ){fck hch{hwhcc {hpb {czfbk) }f ){fck hch{hwhcc zfbfl klef,

evyvb }f evyhllhy) ihlelhy klf ikylkezf if hlhc ehpwh{hghe iky {v}hylhe bhwh

zoplhczlhy jkqkwk ihlhzlbzy#

[fck iky hch{hwh {hqbh{ jfkl, {fck hch{hwh{h nkjfc {oljh fc zfbfl

eocvlhyjh mkekylfy jfbfzkck oyzh{h ehybh{ hbhlh{hc iv hlbh, 88 zoplhczjh

zoplhb 99 hehjfbkw{fc }f ehchhz cjfykck iky hyh{h nfzkybkzky#

Ehzlbglhyc iflkylk eocvlhyjh oyzhe nylfyjf ivlvbhw, ihq eocvlhyjh

kwf nylfykc h{ybhw, {v}hylhe bhwh zoplhczlhycc johl iky wocvgv olhyhe

nylbflkjky# ZWHJ zb nylfykc jklf nfzkyklfgfk iky zhyzbh oyzhbch f}

whdkplkk {hpb, lefbkqjf zhyzlhnflfc eocvlhyjh bvzlheh iky mkeky ikylkkcf

}hybhe }f ivcjhc iky {fck hch{hwh zhwlh yfzbfe hbhgc nzbfjfc, {fck

hch{hwhcc dhqyle qfbkckckc {hpg }f ghcl iky jk{hlon oyzhbcjh nflkbfwkcf

ehze wvcbh{ dfjfmlfbkzky#

Iv hjhc, iv yhpoyjh nyfgfkckq mkekylfy }f cfyklfy, lefbkqjf iv hlhcjh

jcfc }f yfzfc qkdkclfykc iky jfylfbfwk olhyhe jffylfcjkyklbflkjky# Iv

jfylfbfckc, ihzh wk{hwk phyzklfy olbhe qfyf, zb f}yflfykc, dhzzh dfy iky

}hzhcjhbqc }f flifzzf ZWHJ.c cbqjfek jcfbjf ih}vyhiklfgfk oe

jffylk iky eh{che olvzvyhgh kchcgcjh{q#

Iv {hpg zhyzbh wyfgkck {fck hch{hwh {hpbch ehjhy fkzlk }hwzhlhylh

ghcl zvzbh woyvblvlvvcv qfykbkqjf dkwwfzbfezf{kq#

ZWHJ [cfzkb Evyvlv, jh}fzkbkqf kghifz fjfyfe zoplhczlhybqjh jffylk

nylfykck jklf nfzkyfc }f {h{cc olvvbvch ehzelhyc fwkynfbf{fc ehzlbglhyh

zffeeylfykck wvchy#

Bhyz 9088


6/58


7/58

CJFELFY

[V]HYLHE BHWH ZOPLHCZKLHYK EHZKLKBGKLHYK########################################################## ;

8# [V]HYLHE BHWH ZOPLHCZKLHYK WOCV YHPOYLHYK #############################################87

8#8# [fck Hch{hwhcc [hpb [czfbk#################################################################################87

8#9# [fck Hch{hwhcc Zfbfl lef, Evyhl }f Evyvblhy ########################################################8=

8#7# Jkc }f ]kgjhc qnyl#############################################################################################9:

8#:# Ekblkelfy ######################################################################################################################9>

8#6# Ev}}fzlfy H{yl #########################################################################################################70

9# F EOOYJCHZYLFYC [OYVB ]F JFFYLFCJYBFLFY ##################################7;


8/58


9/58

8# [fck Hch{hwhcc [hpb [czfbk

Pyom# Jy# Wkifl cgfolv

Pyom# Jy# iyhdkb EhiolvPyom# Jy# Fynvc qivjvc

Pyom# Jy# Bkzdhz Whcghy

[yj# Jo# Jy# Hijvllhd Wfqfy

Pyom# Jy# Zvynvz Zhydhcl

Pyom# Jy# Cvy ]fynkc

Pyom# Jy# Wfyhp [hqg

9# [fck Hch{hwhcc Zfbfl lef,

Evyhl }f EvyvblhyJy# Dhwhc Fywfl


Pyom# Jy# Fywkc Ehlh{golv

Pyom# Jy# Fynvc qivjvc


lzfy Zyebfc

Jo# Jy# Wvlzhc Vqflzye


7# Jkc }f ]kgjhc qnyl

H}# Ehqb Nfc

Pyom# Jy# zhy Nqh{jc



}o Bolkchw



Pyom# Jy# Cvy ]fynkcPyom# Jy# Wfyhp [hqg

Pyom# Jy# Hyvw [vbvl

[V]HYLHE BHWH ZOPLHCZKLHYK EHZKLKBGKLHYK!

:# Ekblkelfy

Jy# Bnf H{hc Gf{dhc

Pyom# Jy# Hlk hyeolvJy# Zhye Qk{h Fekcgk

bkz Myhz




Mkeyfz Zoewq


Pyom# Jy# Bfdbfz Whlkd [ljyb

6# Ev}}fzlfy H{yl

Pyom# Jy# Hlk hyeolv






;

! [v}hylhe bhwh zoplhczlhycjh bojfyhzyl Mfydhz Ioyhzh} wzlfcbk, yhpoyzylelfyk kwf

[yj# Jo# Jy# Wfcfb H{jc klf Vlh Ehyhc {hpbzy#


10/58


11/58

8I L B

[V]HYLHE BHWH ZOPLHCZKLHYK

WOCV YHPOYLHYK


12/58


13/58


14/58

8:

wh}vcbvzvy# Iv kekcgk nyzfek ehzlbglhy kkcjf kwf, jhdh cgfek hch{hwh jfkkelke zfelkmlfykckc

dhqylhcbhwcjh v{nvlhcb olhc )Phyzklfy Hyhw Vqlhbh Eobkw{ocv) evyvlbhwc cfyfclfy

ivlvcbvzvy# cg iky bojfl kwf, olhhc {hwhbh bfglkwkckc och{ch wvcvlbhewqc, joyvjhc

dhle zhyhmcjhc wfklfc nfck zfbwklf jh{hl iky evyvgv bfglkw zhyhmcjhc Hch{hwhcc {hplbhwc

cfybfezfjky#

K# )Hch{hwh Bfglkwk) Evyvlbhw cfykwk

[hlcqgh {fck hch{hwhcc zhwlhe bfzckcf ojhelhchghe, nyf}k zhwlhe bfzckc dhqylhcbhw klf

woch fyfgfe, yfwbk wmhz dhkq nfkgk iky oynhc evyvlbhljy# Iv oynhcc {flfykckc iflkylfcbfwk

}f hlbh zhyqch klkekc evyhllhy ZIBB.ckc {hphgh iky {hwhl jqfclfbf klf iflkylfcbflkjky#

Iv oynhcc dhqylh{hgh zhwlhe bfzkc, olhhc {hwhbh hhbhlhycjhc nffyfe ehivl }f{h

yfjjfjklfgfezky# [hlcqgh fe iky hhbh olhyhe, ZIBB.jfek ehivl o{v cf olvywh olwvc, {yylf

nkybfwk kkc yfmfyhcjvb {hplbhljy#

Iv oynhcjh nyf} hlhc ekklfykc zhbhbch {hec wfkblf iflkylfcbflkjky# [hlcqgh zoplhb {f

wh{wcc &80.v gk}hycjh iky vqbhc {f{f {fy }fyklbflkjky# Ivyhjhek vqbhc {flfykc jkfy

{hplhyjhc mhye, ehzlblhycc kwzkhyk jfkl, yfwbfc zhccb }f o{ dheech ihlhcb iky ehzlb

olbhwjy# Wk{hwhl phyzklfykc wq eocvwv {hpjhek hyl, fkzlke fwhwch nyf iflkylfcfiklfgfk

nkik, woc wfkblfyjfek o{ oyhcch nyf mhyellhbh{h nkjklbfwk, bfyvk{fz hwcjhc jhdh {fykcjf

iky zfygkd olhiklky#

Hch{hwh{ {fcklfbf nkykkbk, vqvc wolvelv iky hlbh{ nfyfelk elhy# Iv oynhc {hlcqgh {fck

hch{hwh klf klnklk olhyhe }f iflkylk iky wyf fyf}fwkcjf $ycfkc 8"8,6 {l+ hlhghezy# Jolh{w{lh

ZIBB ncjfbkckc {ovclvvcjhc zy {hhchghe nfgkebf }f hewhbhlhy iv oynhc kkc nffylk

olbh{hghe }f evyvgv bfglkwkc whjfgf iv klf}f ojhelhcbhwch }f k polkzke fekbflfyjfc

olhikljkkcgf hq fzeklfcbfwkcf ehze whlh{hghezy#

Nfck iky ehzlblh dhqylhchghe olhc Hch{hwh, izc zoplvb kkc oyzhe ekblke }f vqlhbh

iflnfwk olvzvyhiklky# Ikyf{"hch{hwh hyhw hkjk{fz ih evyvlhiklbfwkckc kle eovlv kwf, ikyf{kc }f

zoplvbvc iv {hpb wyfgkcf ehzlbhw, nycc hlcbhwjy# Nfck zfbwkl, wk{hwhl yfakbkc zfbfl

kleflfyk qfykcjf o{jhbh olvzvybh mywhzc {hyhzbhcc zfwkcjf, Hch{hwhcc {hhb wyfwkck

jf vqhzy# Whjfgf }fekllfykc {hqj iky hch{hwh bfzck, {yylf nkykkckc fyzfwk nccjfc kzkihyfc

zhyzlbhezhc evyzvlhbh{hghezy#

KK# [fck Hch{hwhcc Bf}gvz [czfblfylf [hplbhw cfykwk

[fck hch{hwh bf}gvz hch{hwhl {czfblfylf {hplbhljy# ZIBB.jfek eobpoqkw{ocvc dhlec

kyhjfwkck zfbwkl fjfbf{fgfk {olvcjhek flfzkyklfy, jhdh je iky lef ihyha, dhzzh iky jfmh{h

bhdwvw ihyhawq wfkb {hplbhw nkik zfjikylfylf hlhiklky#


15/58

86

ZIBB.jf jhdh cgf v{nvlhcb olhc Phyzklfy Hyhw Vqlhbh Eobkw{ocv nkik, yfwbk wmhz dhkq

olbh{hc }f phyzklfy hyhwcjh bbec olhc iky vqlhbh{ hyh{hc, mhehz vqlhbh ebhj zhejkyjf

o{ oelvv klf ehyhy hlhiklfgfe iky {hp olvzvyvlhiklky#

ZIBB Hch{hwh Eobkw{ocv, mhyel hlhclhyjhc vqbhclhyc }f ZIBB.jf zfbwkl fjklfbf{fc

wk{hwk fklkblfykc, wk}kl zoplvb ynzlfykckc ehzlb kkc v{nvc {czfblfy nflkzkybflkjky# Hch{hwhEobkw{ocv.cjhek nybflfykc ghcl {h{c nkik ehbvo{v nqfzkbkck hyzzyg {czfblfy jf

evllhclhiklky#

[fck hch{hwhcc {hpb wyfgkckc, bvzlheh nl iky vqlhbh{ nfyfezkyjkk jcgfwkcjfc

eh{chelhchc mhyel bojfl hyh{lhy, hch{hwh {hpbh dfjfmkcf vlhlbhwc nlfzkyfiklfgfezky#

KKK# Nfck Zfbwklf Jh{hl Evyvgv Bfglkw cfykwk

Olhhc {hwhbh bfglkwkcjfc ihbwq, zfbwkl ehiklk{fzk {ewfe iky evyvgv bfglkw $Hch{hwh

Bfglkwk+ evyvlbhljy# Hch{hwh{h fe iky bhjjf eo{vlhyhe }f iky c yfmfyhcjvblh ${hplhgheHch{hwhcc zfbfl kleflfyk iflkyzklbfe eh{j{lh+ {fck iky Hch{hwh {hpbhe kkc iky evyvgv bfglkwkc

{fzeklfcjkyklbfwkcf och{ }fykp }fybf{fgfk dhleh woyvlhyhe, Hch{hwh {hpbhe qfyf iky evyvgv

bfglkw olvzvyvlbhljy#

[fck Hch{hwhcc olhhc {hwhbh bfglkwk zhyhmcjhc {hplbhw dhlkcjf if coezhjh zoplhchiklfgfe

ihq qhhmlhy, cfyklfc iv {czfb klf hlhiklfgfezky# Ikykcgkwk, wfkb wkwzfbkcjfc eh{chelhchc

zfbwkl qhmk{fzk }f jolh{w{lh jfboeyhzke bfyvk{fz woyvcv iv {czfblf hly# ekcgkwk, cmvwvc

{hywc olvzvyhc ehjclhy fc hqcjhc ifllk iky oyhcjh Hch{hwh {hpbch joyvjhc ehzly# cgw,

olhhc {hwhbh oynhccc Hch{hwh{ zbjfc jfkzkybfwk ehywcjh, jfkbfq bhjjflfy cfjfck{lf

oyzh{h ehiklfgfe zyf} evyvgv kezkjhyc wcylhy zhyzbhlhy hlhiklky# Jyjcgw, olhhc {hwhbhbfglkwkcjf {hwhlhyc {hpb wyhwcjh ehiklfgfe ncle wk{hwk fekbflfykc Hch{hwh {hpbh

wyfgkcf {hcwbhw }f efwkczk{f vyhzbhw jh iv {czfblf fcnfllfcfiklky# Ifkcgkwk, iky wyf wcy

eo{vlhyhe, Hch{hwh {hpb wyfgkckc wycgfbfjf iyhelbhw fcnfllfcbk olvy#

800 }f{h 860 ekklke evyvgv bfglkw joyvjhc dhle zhyhmcjhc, dkiky ihyha kfybfewkqkc ckwpk

zfbwkl wkwzfbk klf {hplhghe iky wfkblf iflkylfcbflkjky# Wfkb dfy iky wk{hwk phyzkckc lef hpcjh

hlj o{ oyhccjh zfbwklgk ivlvcjvybhw fwhwch jh{hcbhljy# Hjh{ nwzfybfjf bvdheehe $&

:0c hlzcjh olbh{hghe ikkbjf+ iky ehjc eozhw olbhljy#

Evyvgv bfglkw bhevl iky wyf kkcjf $yc# kek {l+ Hch{hwh{ zhbhblhbh {ebllcjfolbhljy#

[fck Hch{hwh evyvgv bfglkwzf ckzflkelk ovclvelh $zf kek+ ehivl fjklbflkjky# Hch{hwh

Bfglkwkckc jfboeyhzke bfyvk{fzk olhhc {hwhbh bfglkwkcjfc jhdh nl oljvvcjhc, iv Bfglkwzf

ehivl fjklfc Hch{hwh bfzckckc {fckjfc olhhc {hwhbh bfglkwk zhyhmcjhc ehivl fjklbfwkcf

kdzk{h {oezvy#


16/58

8=

8#9# [fck Hch{hwhcc Zfbfl lef, Evyhl }f Evyvblhy

)[fck Hch{hwh.cc Zfbfl lef }f Evyhllhy) {v}hylhe bhwh zoplhczlhycjh, {fck hch{hwhcc

mflwfmfwk, ikkbk, hch{hwhjh dhe }f qnylelfy yfakbk, }hzhcjhlhyc {cfzkbf ehzlbcc whlhcbhw

ihzh olbhe qfyf, ehzlbglhyc ncjfbf nfzkyjkk eocvlhy zhyzlb }f {fck hch{hwhjh dhcnk

klef, evyhl }f evyvblhyc {fy hlbhw nfyfezkkcf jhky nfcfl jffylfcjkybf }f cfyklfyjf

ivlvcvlbvzvy#

Hch{hwhcc Zfbfl Mflwfmfwk

[fck iky hch{hwh dhqylhcbhw kdzk{hgcc, 8;49 Hch{hwhw.cc zfbfl mflwfmfwk{lf klnklk woyvcjhc

eh{chelhcj nq ccjf zvzvlhyhe, {fck hch{hwh jf}lfz ojhel jfkl ikyf{ }f kcwhc ojhel iky

mflwfmf{lf ehlfbf hlcbhljy#

Hch{hwh, bfyv olhc"olbh{hc jcgf h{yb {hpbhbhl }f kjfoloak ihebcjhc zhyhmwqolbhljy# Iv hclh{ fyf}fwkcjf ycfkc, hch{hwhjh iky feocobke bojfl jf ifckbwfcbfbflkjky#

[hplhc pfe oe hyhzybh{h nyf zoplvbvc fc i{e ifelfczkwk olhyhe zfwpkz fjklfc )fkzlke)

}f )hjhlfz) eh}yhblhy, )qnyle)lf ikylkezf hch{hwhcc jffylfy wkwzfbkck olvzvybhljy#

[fck hch{hwh bkllk{fzklkf {fy }fybfbflk, ovlgv iky mflwfmf{f whdkp olbhl }f mhyel ekblkelfyf

dhe zfbfllk {helhbhljy# ]hzhcjhlc zhcblhcbhwcjh )Zyele) eh}yhbch {fy }fyklbfjfc,

}hzhcjhle ih jf}lfzlf ikyf{ hyhwcjhek hch{hwhl iky klkek olhyhe zhcblhcbhljy#

Ihlhcn Ilb

[fck hch{hwhcc Ihlhcn bfzck, 8;49 Hch{hwhw.cc zfywkcf ewh }f {hlc olbhl, kjfoloake

hclhblhy kfyfc kmhjflfyf {fy }fybfbflk, f}yfcwfl iky kfykf whdkp olbhl }f jfboeyhwk, zfbfl

dhe }f qnylelfy, dvevevc wzcl nkik kmhjflfyf }vynv {hpbhljy# Ihlhcn ilb

hch{hwh bfzckcf jdkl olbhbhljy# Ihlhcn bfzckcjf Hzhzye.c hdwk{fzkcf }f zhykdk yolcf

wh{n }f eyhc kfyfc iky kmhjf{lf {fzkcklbflk }f Hzhzyelf kjfoloake }f dvevek hclhblhy

{elf{fc yfmfyhcwlhyjhc ehclbhljy#

Ehzlbglhyc iky ewb, Ihlhcn nkik iky ilbc hch{hwhjh ivlvcbhwcc dvevek iky

nfyfelklke olbhbhw hwcjhc, {fck hch{hwhjh iv ilbc {fy hlbhbhwcc jh jclfiklfgfkckjklf nfzkybkzky#


17/58

Fkzlke lefwk }f H{ybgle [hwh

Fkzlke klefwk }f h{ybgle {hwhch klkekc jqfclfbflfy vlvwlhyhyhw wzhcjhyzlhyh v{vblv dhlf

nfzkyklbflkjky# Ihzh gkcwk{fz }f gkcwfl {cflkb olbhe qfyf zb h{ybgle zfbfllfyk heh

wyhlhcbhljy#

Poqkzkm h{ybgle hclh{c nlfcjkyfgfe jqfclfbflfyf {fy }fyklbflkjky# Kyele, {hihcg

jbhcl }f ifcqfyk {helhblhyc eoyvbh nybf{fgfk }f jf}lfzkc iv eocvlhyh {cflke

hlbh {yzfgfkcf jhky jqfclfbflfy hch{hwhjh ivlvcbhljy#

Zfbfl Dhe }f qnylelfy

[fck hch{hwh zfbfl dhe }f qnylelfyk f}yfcwfl iky hclh{lh jqfclfbflk }f n}fcgf hlzch

hlbhljy# Hch{hwh.jh, )kcwhc dhelhych jh{hchc jf}lfz) klefwk qfllkelf }vynvlhcbhljy# Zfbfl

dhelhy }f qnylelfy, hch{hwhjh iv klef joyvlzvwvcjh jf}lfz zfbfllk jfkl kcwhc/ikyf{ zfbfllk

olhyhe jqfclfcbflkjky# [fck hch{hwhcc, ikyf{kc nyfgf qh{mlcc dveve wh{fwkcjf nkjfyklbfwk

}f ikyf{kc iv hclhbjh nlfcjkyklbfwk hclh{ fyf}fwkcjf, dvevevc wzcl, ikyf{lfykc,

evyvblhyc }f kjhyfckc dfwhp }fyfiklkylkk }f fmmhml eh}yhblhych jh {fy }fybfwk nfyfebfezfjky#

Zfbfl dhe }f qnylelfykc wcylhcbhw yfakbk kcwhc dhelhycc vlvwlhyhyhw wzhcjhyzlhy klf

v{vblv dhlf nfzkyklbflkjky# 8;49 Hch{hwhw.cc 87# bhjjfwkcjf cnylfc bf}gvz wcylhcbh

yfakbk fyf}fwkcjf zfbfl dhe }f qnylelfylf klnklk bhjjflfyjf ekbk qhbhc vlvwlhyhyhw wzhcjhyzlhy

hhc ckzflkezf wcylhcjybh cfjfclfykcf {fy }fyklbk, ihqlhycjh kwf dk iky wcylhbh cfjfckcf

{fy }fyklbfbkzky# Dfy dhe }f qnyle hwcjhc wcylhbh cfjfclfyk vlvwlhyhyhw dveveh v{nvc

iky dhlf nfzkyklbflk }f bf}gvz zvzhywqle oyzhjhc ehljylbhljy#

Zfbfl dhe }f dyyk{fzlfykc ez{f evllhclbhw {hwhc jqfclf{fc qfl iky debf kdzk{h

olbh{hiklky# ce dkiky dhe ez{f evllhclbhe hbhg{lh zhccbhbhezhjy# Iv ihebjhc,

ez{f evllhcbh {hwhcc johw nfyfk olhyhe, dfy dhe }f dyyk{fzkc wcylhy kkcjf {fy hlj

}hywh{lhiklky# Ehzlbglhyc iv {cjfek jcgfwk, 8;49 Hch{hwhwcc ez{f evllhcbh {hwhc

jqfclf{fc 8:# bhjjfwkckc f}yfcwfl wzhcjhyzlhyh h{ey olhyhe, jf}lfzf, dyyk{fzlfyk wcylhbhjh

nfck {fzeklfy zhc{hghe ikkbjf jqfclfcbfwkcjfc eh{chelhcbhezhjy# Ihq ehzlbglhy kwf,

ez{f evllhcbh {hwhcc f}yfcwfl hclhbch v{nvc olhyhe jqfclfcbfwkckc, dyyk{fzlfy yfakbk

hwcjhc n}fcgf whlh{hiklfgfkck iflkyzbkzky# Iv ehzlbglhyh nyf, ez{f evllhcbh {hwhcc,

HDW.ckc 8># bhjjfwkcf phyhlfl olhyhe jqfclfcbfwk, iv {hwhc {hyn ehyhylhych {hcwbhwcjhHDB kzkdhzlhycc fwhw hlcbhw, dyyk{fzlfy kkc cfblk iky n}fcgf wvchiklfgfezky# Zfbfl dhe

}f qnylelfykc, {hyn oynhclhy jcjh eoyvbh bfehckqbhlhy olvzvyvlhyhe eoyvcbhw }f

n}fcgf hlzch hlcbhw whlhcbhljy# [fck hch{hwhjh zfbfl dhe }f qnylelfykc whjfgf jf}lfz

zhyhmcjhc jfkl jf}lfz j hezylfy zhyhmcjhc jh kdlhl fjklfiklfgfk nqfzklfyfe ivch v{nvc

jqfclfbflfy {hplbhljy#

8>


18/58

84

[hhbh dhee ehpwhbcjh n}fclke nlfykcf zhcchc nfck {fzeklfy wcylhcjylbhl }f {hhbh

dhee n}fcgf hlzch hlcbhljy# 8;49 Hch{hwhw.cc 8># bhjjfwk bvlhe kmhjflfyf {fy }fyfyfe

n}fclke nfyfefwk{lf kcwhc dh{hzch bjhdhlf dheec cnybzy# N}fclke nlfykcf }fyklfc

kjjfz evllhclbhwch jhky bf}gvz {fzeklfy zoplvb kfykwkcjf jf kjjfzkc {h{nclhbhwch, olhhc

}f bfyv dhlf nflbfwkcf {ol hbhezhjy# We{cfzkb }f olhhcwz dhl kmhjflfyk {fck hch{hwhcc

{hhbh dheec jqfclf{fc bhjjfwkcjf {fy hlbhbhl }f qoy evllhcbhcc hcghe jvyvbvcnfyfezkyjkk ljf olhiklfgfk iflkyzklbflkjky#

Hch{hwh olhhcwz dhl, we{cfzkb, wh}h }f wfmfyifylke dhllfykcjf zfbfl dhe }f qnylelfykc

ewbfc }f{h zhbhbfc jvyjvyvlbhw v{nvlhbhlhycjh, vlvwlhyhyhw kcwhc dhelhy dvevevcjhc

eh{chelhchc {ebllelfyf h{ey jh}yhclhbh{hghc jhdh wobvz ikkbjf n}fcgf hlzch

hlbhljy# Iv ehpwhbjh dhcnk dhe }f qnylelfykc iv dhllfyjf jhdk hwe{h hlchbh{hgh he

}f cfz ikkbjf jqfclfcbflkjky#

cwhc dhelhycc vlvwlhyhyhw wzhcjhyzlhyh v{nvc olhyhe zhccbhw }f eoyvcbhw hbhg{lh, iv

dhelhyh eoyvbh nfzkyfc vlvwlhyhyhw wqlfbflfykc ehcvclhyc qfykcjf oljvv deb

ifckbwfcbflkjky# H{ygh iky ewb oljveh fwek zhykdlk olhc vlvwlhyhyhw kcwhc dhelhy wqlfbflfykcjf

{fy hlhc dhelhy }f qnylelfykc ehpwhb, H}yvph cwhc Dhelhy Bhdefbfwk }f jkfy jfcfzkb

oynhclhy klf ncbqjf oljveh nfcklfbk }f fkzlfcbkzky# Iv jvyvb nq ccjf zvzvlhyhe

kcwhc dhelhych eoyvbh nfzkyfc wqlfbflfykc {oyvbvcjh iv oynhclhyc ehyhylhycc jh vlvwhl

{hyn oynhclhy zhyhmcjhc jkeehzf hlchghch jhky jqfclfbf {hplbhw {fykcjf olhghezy# [fck

hch{hwh, Hch{hwh Bhdefbfwkcf ehcvclhyc, kcwhc dhelhych eoyvbh nfzkyfc vlvwlhyhyhw

wqlfbflfyf v{nvclvvcv jfcfzlfbf {fzekwk zhcbhl, iv jfcfzkb wyfgk kzkyhq {olv klf dhyfefzf

nfkyklfiklbflkjky# I{lfgf, Hch{hwhcc ;0# bhjjfwkcjf {fy hlhc zfbfl dhe }f dyyk{fzlfyf klkekc

vlvwlhyhyhw wqlfbflfykc ehcvclhyc qfykcjf oljvv hclhbch nflfc debc, v{nvlhbhjh

{hyn ehyhylhych {hcwbhbhw pyoilfbk fzekc olhyhe qlfiklfgfezky#

Ehzlbglhyc iky ewb, Hch{hwh Bhdefbfwk.cf ikyf{wfl ih}vyv dheecc ehpwhbcc

nfcklfzklbfwkck cfybkzky# Ivch nyf, ikyf{wfl ih}vyv {olvcv hhc jqfclfbf whjfgf H}yvph

cwhc Dhelhy Wqlfbfwk.cjf {fy hlhc dhelhylh wcyljy, dhlivek bf}gvz Hch{hwh.jh {fy hlhc

dhelhy }f qnylelfy lkwzfwk H}yvph cwhc Dhelhy Wqlfbfwk.cjf {fy hlhc dhelhy }f qnylelfyjfc

nfckzky# Iv wfifplf ikyf{wfl ih}vyv {olvcvc ehpwhb Hch{hwh.jhek zb dhelhy kkcf hlhghe

fekljf nfcklfzklbflkjky# Jkfy ehzlbglhy kwf, ikyf{wfl ih}vyv dheecc wow{hl dhelhy ehpwh{hghe

ljf nfcklfzklbfwkckc, Hch{hwh Bhdefbfwkcf zfbwklk jfboeyhwk }f dveve jf}lfzkckc johw{lh

ihjhbh{hc nfck iky zhejky {fzekwk zhc{hghc cf wybzy# Iv ehzlbglhy, ikyf{wfl ih}vyvdheecc, ivnc oljvv nkik, HDW.jf {fy hlhc deblfylf wcyl olhyhe zhccbhw nycjfjkylfy#


19/58


20/58

90

{hccjh, iky evyvbvc hch{hwhjh {fy hlbhwcc, wq eocvwv evyvbvc fnfbfclke {fzekwkckc

evllhclbhw ehpwhbcjh jffylfcjkyklfbf{fgfkcf jhky fe iky deb eocbhw nfyfezkk

nycjfjky#

Vlvwhlwz evyvlvlhyh {flkkc, ZIBB.ckc hch{hwh{ jfkzkybf ngcf whdkp ckzflkelk

ovclvelh och{lhbhw }f/}f{h dhleo{lhbhwcjh ehivl fjklbfwk jvyvbvcjh nfyfelffiklfgfk}f fnfbfclke {fzekwkckc iv evyvlvlhylh ph{lhlhiklfgfk jqfclfcbflkjky# zf {hcjhc, h{c

bhjjfjf fnfbfclke {fzekwkckc, vlvwlhyhyhw dvevezhc eh{chelhchc klef }f evyhllhylh wcyl

oljvvch jh {fy }fyklbflkjky#

Ehzlb

Wk{hwfzf ehjc ehzlbcc hyzylbhw kkc qfl zfjikylfy hlcbhw {hwh eo{vgvcvc zhejkykcf

iyhelj jvyvblhyjh eocvcvc nybfqlkezfc nflkcfiklfgfk nq ccjf zvzvlhyhe, nfkgk olvblv

clfblfy ehpwhbcjh ihzh eozh olbhe qfyf qoylh{g jqfclfbflfyf hch{hwh jqf{kcjf {fy

}fyklbfwk nfyfebfezfjky# Hcghe, ehjclhyc wk{hwfzf ehzlbcc hyzzylbhw nfyfezkk eocvwvcjh

iky zfyfjjz olbhbhelh ikylkezf, iv hbhgh {cflke evllhclhghe {czfblfy ehpwhbcjh qoylh{g

zfjikylfykc {fykcjflkk eocvwvcjh ehzlbglhy hyhwcjh mkeky ikylkk ivlvcbhbhezhjy#

]hzhcjhlhyc {cfzkbf ehzlbhlhy ihlhbcjh ncjfbf nflfc ihq eocvlhyjh mhyel {helhblhy

wq eocvwvjvy# Iky nyvp ehzlbg, yfmfyhcjvb, nfyk hybh $yfghll+, dhlec {hwh zfelkmk, dhlec

}fzowv nkik {hy"zfbwklk }f{h {hy"joyvjhc jfboeyhwk hyhlhycc {fck hch{hwhjh {fy hlbhwcc

hch{hwh{ jhdh jfboeyhzke iky dhlf nfzkyfgfkck }f ehyhy hlbh bfehckqbhlhycc zhihch joyv

{h{lbhwc whlh{hghc iflkyzbkzky#

Jkfy iky nyvp ehzlbg kwf wh{lhc {czfblfykc bqhefyfgk jfboeyhwk hclh{ klf v{vblv

olbhjc iflkyzfyfe }hzhcjhlhyc fkzlklkkck {hcwzbh{hc olvbwvq wocvlhy jovyhiklfgfkck

kmhjf fzbkzky#

Ehzlbglhyc zhbhb, qfllkelf dhe }f qnylelfyf klkekc jqfclfbflfykc dhleo{vch

wvcvlbhwcc, ovclvev jfboeyhwkckc dhekb oljvv iky bojflk {hyhzhiklfgfk eh{nwc

ph{lhbzy# Iv cfjfclf dhe }f qnylelfyf klkekc jqfclfbflfykc dhleo{vch wvcvlhbh{hgh

eocvwvcjh dfbmkekylfyjky#

Wk{hwk Phyzklfy }f Wfkb

Wk{hwk phyzk {hwhelhy }f ehphzbh {hpzyb

Ehzlbglhyc iky ewb, zqe }f pyonyhbjh {fy hlhc kmhjflfy wfifik{lf joyvjhc joyv{h

ehphzbh {hpzyb v{nvlhcbhbhw nfyfezkk nycjfjky# Iv ehzlbglhyh nyf, zqe }f

pyonyhbjh {fy hlhc kmhjflfy, hcghe iv kmhjflfykc zhjklkcf khyfz fjfc iky v{hycc nfyfkckc {fykcf


21/58

98

nfzkyklbfbfwk qfykcf, ehphzbh jh}hwch eocv olhiklbflkjky# wzflke dhcnk kmhjflfykc jh}h{h fwhw

zfekl fjfgfk eocvwvcjh vlvwlhyhyhw wzhcjhyzlhy l olvzvybhljy# Wk{hwk phyzklfykc mhhlk{fzlfykckc

wcylhycc jh wo{vz deblfy {fykcf oe wobvz kmhjflfylf iflkylfcbfwk, ehphzbh{h wfifp olhghe

eh}yhblhyc hq wh{jh zvzvlbhw }f ]fcfjke Eobkw{ocv.cvc ifckbwfjkk, kjjfzk wh}vchc }f{h

kjjfz {czfblfykcf ih}vyhc phyzklfykc ehphzlhiklfgfk lzcc ehivl fjklbfwk nfyfezkk

wh}vcvlbvzvy# Ehphzbh jh}hwc ZIBB.ckc dhyfefzf nfkybfwk }f iv klfbjfc wocyh [hynzh{Gvbdvyk{fz Ihwh}gw.cc jh}h hhiklbfwk vwvl cfyklbkzky# Iky jkfy cfyk, wk{hwk phyzklfyf

v{nvlhchiklfgfe ehphzbh j {hpzyblhyc fkzlfcjkyklbfwkjky#

Jkfy iky nyvp ehzlbg kwf, zqe }f pyonyhblhyc ehphzbh {hpzybch {ol hhiklfgfk

nyc klfyk wybzy# Iv nyzfek ehzlbglhy, wk{hwk phyzklfykc kjjfzk zf}ke fzbfbfwk }f{h

kjjfzk v{nvlhbhbhw nfyfkckc {hccjh, hbhlhycc }f iv {cjf evllhcj hyhlhyc jh

jfboeyhwk klf v{vblv olbhw nfyfezkkck iflkyzbk }f mhhlk{fzlfykckc wcy olhyhe H}yvph cwhc

Dhelhy Bhdefbfwk.ckc ifckbwfjkk lzlfykc wfklbfwkck cfybkzky# Iv ihlhbjh wk{hwk phyzklfy

fykhz, mhkqbk, jkezhzyl, yel, h{ybgl wh}vchbhbhljy, cfmyfz w{lfbkcf ih}vyhbhbhljy#

Ehphzbh ehyhy }fyklbfjfc cgf v{hy {hplhyhe, wk{hwk phyzkckc zqe }f pyonyhbcjh jfkkelke

{hpbh kbehc }fyklbfwkcf iv nyzfek ehzlbglhy jh ehzlbzy# Ehphzbh jh}hwcc hlbh

vwvlcjf kwf {fzekckc [hynzh{ Gvbdvyk{fz Ihwh}glcjh olbhbhw cfykwkcf ehzlbhelh ikylkezf,

{fzekckc {hyn oynhclhycjh ehlbhw, ycfkc [hynzh{ Gfqh Jhkyflfyk ihehclhycjhc olvhc iky

evyvlh }fyklbfwk cfyklbkzky#

Wk{hwk phyzklfykc ehphzlbhwch ehyhy }fykljkk dhllfyjf ikyf{lfykc wk{hwk {hwhellcc wq eocvwv

olbhbhw eocvwvcjh zb ehzlbglhy dfbmkekyjky#

Phyzklfykc k klf{kk

Ehzlbglhy, phyzk kk jfboeyhwk eocvwvcvc {hwhl jqfclfbflfylf whlhcbhwcc bbec

olbhj jcgfwkcjf mkeky ikylkkcf }hyblhyjy# Hcghe wk{hwk phyzklfy dheecjh qfl iky {hwh{h

kdzk{h jv{vlvp jv{vlbhj dvwvwvcjh mhyel nylfy klfyk wylbzy# Ehzlbglhyc iky ewb,

wk{hwk phyzklfykc wk}kl zoplvb ynzlfcbflfykcjfc oljveh mhyel iky {c oljvvcjhc dhyfefzlf

bvzlheh wk{hwk phyzklfy kkc h{y iky {hwhcc ivlvcbhw nfyfezkkck kmhjf fzbkzky# Jkfy ehzlbglhy

kwf wk{hwk phyzklfylf klnklk qfl iky {hwh{h kdzk{h olbhjc, ycfkc jfycfelfy bf}qvhzch zhik

olhiklfgfelfyk nyc wh}vcbvzvy#

Wk{hwk phyzk mhhlk{fzlfykckc mkchcwbhc

Wk{hwk phyzk mhhlk{fzlfykckc mkchcwbhcch hch{hwhjh bvzlheh jfkcklbflk }f iv hlhc {hwh{lh

h{yczl iky ikkbjf jqfclfbflkjky# Jf}lfz wk{hwk phyzklfyf dheehck{fzf v{nvc iky fekljf bhlk

{hyjbjh ivlvcbhljy# Wk{hwk phyzklfykc bhlk jfcfzkbkcf klkekc bf}gvz fyf}f nlfcjkyklbflkjky#


22/58

99

Wfkblfy

Ehzlbglhy hch{hwhcc {hpb wyfgkcjf evyvgv bfglkw klf}k nyfgfe bfglkwkc olvvbvcjh

dfydhcnk iky wfkb ihyhacc cnylbfbfwk }f i{lfgf iky bfyvk{fz zhyzbhwcc ccf

nfklbfwk nfyfezkk eocvwvcjh vqlhblhyjy#

Hcghe hch{hwh {hpb wyfgk wocyhwcjh nyf} {hphghe bfglkwkc olvvbvcjh wfkb ihyha

eocvwvcjh mhyel {helhblhy oyzh{h ebzy# Iky nyvp ehzlbg{h nyf wfkb wkwzfbkcjf

{cfzkbjf kwzkeyhyjhc oe zfbwkljf hjhlfz klefwkcf {fy }fyklbflkjky# Wfkb ihyha ehljylbhl }f{h

mhyel nylfykc zfbwklkck fcnfllfbf{fgfe ikkbjf hh feklbflkjky#

Ehzlbglhyc jkfy iky ilb kwf wfkblfykc iky mocewk{ocvcvc zfbwkljf hjhlfz, jkfy

mocewk{ocvcvc jh {cfzfiklky iky kezkjhy ehybhe oljvv jcgfwkcjfc dhyfefzlf, wfkb

ihyhacc }hylcc coybhl ehivl fjklfiklfgfkck iflkyzbkzky# Ivcvclh ikylkezf ihyhac fzekwk{lf

johiklfgfe zfbwkl fewkelkkckc, Zyek{f bkllfz}fekllkkckc cnylbfwk {h jh Hlbhc{h, w}f,

Jhckbhyeh nkik leflfyjf nffylk olhc wfkb wkwzfbkcjfek nkik ilnfwfl phyzklfykc jf zfbwklfjklbfwk{lf nkjfyklfiklfgfk iflkyzklbkzky#

[hwhbh, [yzbf }f Ehbv [cfzkbk

[fck hch{hwhjh phylhbfczfy wkwzfb ifckbwfcbflkjky# Gvbdvyihehc ivnc phylhbfczfy

wkwzfbkc qfllkelfykcf v{nvc olbh{hc iky ikkbjf nfck {fzeklfyf whdkpzky5 iv {fzeklfy

wcylhcjylbhljy# Phylhbfczfy yfakb ovlgv dhlf nfzkyklfyfe klfzklbf{f jf}hb fzbflkjky }f

{fck hch{hwhjh bf}gvz wkwzfbkc jovyhiklfgfk olhw zehcelelhy nkjfyfiklfgfe bfehckqbhlhy

cnylbflkjky# Iv coezhjh, nflfgfezf phylhbfczfy wkwzfbjf eklkzlfcbf ykwek jovyhiklfgfkcjfc,

gvbdvyihehccc dhle zhyhmcjhc wfklbfwk vwvlcjfc }hqnfklfyfe phylhbfczo zhyhmcjhcwfklbfwk vwvlcf nfyk jclbfwk ihq ehzlbglhy zhyhmcjhc cfyklbk, jkfy ehzlbglhy kwf

{fzeklfyk hqhlzlb gvbdvyihehccc dhle zhyhmcjhc wfklbfwk vwvlcc jf}hb fzbfwk nfyfezkkck

kmhjf fzbkzky#

Jfboeyhwkckc {fyfl jqf{jf nlfcjkyklbfwk nfyfebfezfjky# Iv {helhb, {fyfl {cfzkblfykc

fzekclke }f }fykblklkkck hyzyhgh nkik, qfllkelf Ncf{jov.{h dhekb olhc Eyz woyvcvcvc }f

jkfy ekblke woyvclhycc qbcf ehze whlh{hiklfgfezky# [fyfllfbfckc hyzzylbhw eovlv{lh

ckzfy {hpcc ncgfl kdzk{hlhyh gf}hp }fyfiklbfwk bbec olwh jh ckzfy jf}lfz klefwkckc

fwcfzklbfwk klf oyzh{h ehc ilnflk jf}lfz {hpw jh zhyzlhiklky#

ekcgk Jc{h Wh}h wocyhwcjh Ikylfbk Bkllfzlfy hyz.cjh )wh}h) zfykbk {fykcf )ev}}fz

evllhcbh) zfykbkckc wfklbfwkcf v{nvc olhyhe, ihyh {cflke hyqv{v jh }vynvlhbhe hwcjhc,

hch{hwhjh )wh}h klhc) kmhjflfykcf {fy }fyklbfbflkjky#

[fck hch{hwh, {cfzkb wlvivcjh jfkkbkc kmhjfwk }f ehbv {cfzkbkckc k{k {cfzkkb klefwk

{ccjf yfmoybf fjklbfwkckc kle hjb olbhljy#


23/58

97

Dveve Jf}lfzk

[fck hch{hwhjh dveve jf}lfzk klefwkck nlfcjkybfe kkc iv klefckc nfyfezkyjkk zb

bfehckqbhlhy ifckbwfcbflkjky# Iv bfehckqbhlhy h{yczl olhyhe jqfclfcbflk }f n}fcgf

hlzch hlcbhljy#

Wow{hl Jf}lfz

[fck hch{hwh, wow{hl jf}lfz klefwkcf }f kcwhc dhelhy eh}yhbcc h{ylbhq phyhw olhc wow{hl

dhelhyh {fy }fybflkjky#

H{ygh ehzlbglhyc iky ewbch nyf, {fck hch{hwh feocobke }f wow{hl dhelhy hlhccjh

jf}lfzkc {ebllelfykck qh{mlhzhc 8;49 Hch{hwhw.cc =6# bhjjfwk nkik iky jqfclfbfckc

{fykcf, jf}lfzf kcwhc {hhbcc zfbfl kdzk{hlhy hyhwcjh {fy hlhc fkzkb }f whle nkik hlhclhyjh

iky jkqk he {ebllelfy nfzkybflkjky#


24/58

9:

8#7# Jkc }f ]kgjhc qnyl

[v}hylhe bhwh zoplhczlhycjh ehzlbglhy {fck hch{hwhjh jkc }f }kgjhc qnylcc

flf hlc dheecjh nfcfl jffylfcjkybflfy }f cfyklfyjf ivlvcbvlhyjy#

Hch{hwhl fyf}f

Zyek{f.jfek lhkelke hclh{, bjhdhlfgk ehyhezfyk }f jf}lfzkc jkclfyf, bfqdfplfyf }f kchcwqlh

fkz bfwhmfjf eocvblhcbhb olbhw jolh{w{lh Ihz zkpk lhkelkezfc h{ybhezhjy# Iv ehpwhbjh

8;49 Hch{hwhw.cc jkc }f }kgjhc qnylcc ez{f evllhclbhw {hwhc jqfclf{fc 9:#

bhjjfwkckc woc meyhw, jkck kchcgc dfy zyl wow{hl nycbc {hwhelhbh{h bwhkz olbhw

cfjfck{lf {fck hch{hwhjh {fy hlbhbhljy# Iv debc {fykcf cwhc Dhelhy H}yvph Wqlfbfwkckc

;# Bhjjfwkcjf {fy hlhc kchc qnylcf klkekc wcylhbh cfjfclfyk ehivl fjklfiklky#

Jkck H{ybglc clfcbfwk

Cmvw ezlhycjh jkc dhcfwk ivlvcbhbhljy# Ivcvc v{nvlhbhjh nfyfelfbfwk kkc

Hch{hwh.jhek bf}gvz debc joyv olhyhe {oyvblhcbhw {fzfylk oljvv dhljf, {hwhbh }f {hyn

oynhclhy zhyhmcjhc iv fekljf {oyvblhcbhbhezhjy# Iv cfjfclf cmvw ezlhycjh jkc dhcfwk

ivlvcbhwc olhchewqlhzyhghe iky kihyfckc Hch{hwh.jh ivlvcbhw jclfiklky#

[fck hch{hwhjh jf}lfzkc, poqkzkm iky {eblle olhyhe nfyfe Loqhc Hclhbhw.cjh zf{kz fjklbk

olhc kchc nyvplhycc nfyfewf iv hclhbhjh iflkyzklbfbk olhc kchc nyvplhycc jkc }f }kgjhc

dyyk{fzkck nfyfezkk nkik {fykcf nfzkybflfykck eolh{lhzyhghe zfjikylfy hlbhelh {ebl oljvv

kmhjf fjklbflkjky# Ivch jkck yfcbf }f yfzbf dyyk{fzkckc {hc wyh jkc hjhb {fzkzkybf

dyyk{fzk jf jdkljky# [fck hch{hwhjh Loqhc Hclhbhw qfl olhyhe iflkyzklfyfe, Zyek{f.ckclefwkcjfek nh{ykbwlkb hqclelhyh Loqhc Hclhbhw klf wzlfcjkk ifllk dhelhych wh{n nwzfybf

}f ivcv {fykcf nfzkybf {ebllcf hch{hwhlle jffyk ehqhcjylbhljy#

Obivjwbhcle bfwwfwfwk fkzlk vcwvylhyjhc bzffeekl olhyhe olvzvyvlhiklky }f ikykblfykcjfc

ikyk kchc zfbflkcjfek h{ybglelhy jfcfzlfbfe qfyf jqfclfcfiklky#

Jk{hcfz lfyk Ihehcl

Jk{hcfz lfyk Ihehcl.cc }hylch }f {hpwch klkekc nylfy mhyelle nwzfybfelf ikylkezf,

ehzlbglhyc zhbhb Jk{hcfz lfyk Ihehcl.cc bf}gvz eocvbvcv, lhkelke klefwkcf }f jkc }f

}kgjhc qnylcf h{ey ivlbhezhjy#


25/58

96

Ehzlbglhyc ovclvv, Jk{hcfz lfyk Ihehcl.cc ehbv dkqbfzk nyfc iky evyvb olhyhe

bvdhmhqh fjklbfwk hcghe efcjkck dekb kchc hclh{ jcjh nyfc jkfy kchc f}yflfykckc

jf zfbwklk whlhchghe fekljf {fckjfc jqfclfcbfwk nfyfezkkck jklf nfzkybklfyjky# Iv nyf

nyf, evyvbvc {fckjfc {hplhcjylbhwcjh dhe zfbfllk iky hclh{ fyf}fwkcjf eocv{h

{helhlhyhe, efcjkck dekb kchc hclh{ jcjh nyfc mhyel kchc nyvplhycc jcgflfykckc

hlcbhw nfyfebfezfjky# H{ygh Jk{hcfz lfyk Ihehcl ic{fwkcjf zfbwkl fjklbfe kwzfbf{fckchc nyvplhycc jh phyhlfl evyvlvlhy evybhwcc ccjfek {hwhl fcnfllfy ehljylbhl }f wq

eocvwv qnyle vlvwlhyhyhw wzhcjhyzlhyh phyhlfl olhyhe hcghe ehbv n}fclkk, ehbv jqfck,

ehbv whl, ehbv hdlhe {h jh ihehlhycc zfbfl dhe }f qnylelfykck eoyvbhe kkc nfyfelk

llfy kfykwkcjf wcylhcjylbhljy#

Jk{hcfz lfyk Ihehcl.cc bvdhmhqh fjklbfwk nycf ehzlhc ehzlbglhyc iky ewb,

evyvbvc nflky eh{chcc kdzk{hyk }fynklfcjkybf olbhwc cfybkzky# Ivyhjhek nfyfef, Jk{hcfz

lfyk Ihehcl.ch izfjfc h{ylhc ph{c ikyjfc mhqlh ihehcle izfwkckc zoplhbcjhc jhdk

mhqlh olbhw }f ihq ekk }f nyvplhyc qfllkelf jf kchcbh{hclhyc evyvbvc dkqbfzlfykcjfc dkiky

ikkbjf mh{jhlhcbh olhwl olbhj dhljf mkchcwbhcch ehzejh ivlvcv{oy olbhlhyjy# Iv

cfyk{f ehy ihq ehzlbglhy kwf, ehbv dkqbfzlfykckc mkchcwbhcch }fynk {olv{lh ehzlbh

klefwkcjfc dhyfefzlf }fynk befllfmlfykckc }fynk{lf mkchcwf fjklfc ehbv dkqbfzlfykckc zbcjfc

{hyhylhcbhjc iflkyzbkzky#

Ehzlbglhyc iky ewb Jk{hcfz lfyk Ihehcl.cc lh}fjklbfwkcf klkekc ny ikljkybkzky#

Iv ny ihlhbcjh, jf}lfzkc jkclfyf fkz bfwhmfjf jvybhw klefwk v{hycgh, jf}lfzkc jkck mkchcwf

fzbfbfwk, jkck fkzkb"yfzkbf jhdkl olbhbhw }f jkck fekllfcjkybfbfwk nfyfezkk wh}vcvlbvzvy#

Jkc Fkzkb }f yfzkbk

Jkc fkzkbkcf klkekc qfl jqfclfbflfyjf vlvwlhyhyhw wzhcjhyzlhy fwhw hlcbhljy# H}yvph

cwhc Dhelhy Wqlfbfwk.cjf fkzkb dheec jqfclf{fc pyozoeolc 9# bhjjfwk }f Ikylfbk

Bkllfzlfy Feocobke, Wow{hl }f Elzyfl Dhelhy Wqlfbfwk.ckc 8:# bhjjfwk v{hycgh dk ekbwf

fkzkb dheecjhc {oewvc iyhelhbhq# Jf}lfz, fkzkb }f yfzkb hlhccjh {elfcfgfk nyf}lfykc

{fykcf nfzkyklbfwkcjf hccf }f ihihcc iv fkzkb }f yfzkbkc efcjk jkck }f mflwfmk kchclhych

nyf {hplbhwc whlhbh dhelhych wh{n nwzfyky# Wq eocvwv dhelhy ehpwhbcjh, jkc elzy

}f hdlhe iklnkwk jfywkckc kleyfzkb oevllhycjh qoyvclv jfyw olhyhe {fy hlbhw deb {fck

hch{hwhjh {fy hlbhbhljy#

Ehzlbglhy, qoyvclv jkc jfywk v{nvlhbhwcc ehljylbhw nfyfezkkcjf mkeky ikylkkcf }hyblhyjy#

Ehzlbglhyc iky ewb, iv cfykckc zfwkcf nffyfe ync fkzkbjf jkc jfywk }fyklbfbfwkck

cfybk5 jkfy ehzlbglhy kwf, jkc jfywkckc wfbflk jfywlfy dh}vqvcjh {fy hlbhwc cfybkzky#


26/58

9=

Jkc jfywlfykckc ync fkzkbjfc zhbhbfc ehljylbhw jvyvbvcjh, jkc fkzkbkckc dhcnk

{czfblf }fyklfiklfgfk eocvwvcjh mhyel nylfy jklf nfzkyklbkzky# Jkc fkzkbkck jf}lfz hyhgl{lh

kbhb dhzkp oevllhy, klhdk{hz mhelzflfyk }f jhdh hlz jqf{jfek Evyhc evywlhy klf jf}hb fjfiklfgfk,

hcghe wq eocvwv evyvblhyjh }fyklfc fkzkbkc Wcck wlhb yfzkwk{lf wcyl olbhw cfjfck{lf

jkck fkzkbkc wk}kl zoplvb evyvlvlhych jh iyhelhiklfgfk cfyklbkzky# Iv nyf ehyle ihq

ehzlbglhy, jkc fkzkbkckc wk}kl zoplvbh iyhelbhw nfyfezkkck iflkyzbk mhehz iv jvyvbvcjh,jkc fkzkbkck whlh{hc evyvlvlhyc wk{hwk }f qfllkelf kjjfzf {cflke iky ynz olvzvybhwc

clf{fgfe iky jf}lfz jfcfzkbkckc cfbkcf jkeehz febkzky# Dfy dhlehyjh wq eocvwv qnylc

wcylhcjylbhwcc, vlvwlhyhyhw wzhcjhyzlhyh phyhlfl olhyhe hcghe ehbv n}fclkk, ehbv jqfck,

ehbv whl, ehbv hdlhe {h jh ihehlhycc zfbfl dhe }f qnylelfykck eoyvbhe kkc nfyfelk

llfy kfykwkcjf {hplhiklfgfk }vynvlhcbzy#

Jkck Zoplvlvelhyh Zqfl Ekklke Zhccbhw

]fcfjke Eobkw{ocv.cjh jh ncjfbf nflfc jkck gfbhhzlfyf zqfl ekklke zhccbhw eocvwv

zhyzlb }f ihzh blek{fz dhee }f jh}h fdlk{fzk olbhe qfyf whlh{hgh mh{jhlhy cfjfck{lf

pyfcwkpzf olvblv ivlvcbhelh ikylkezf ivyhjhek pyhzke dvevek nlelfyf jkeehz feklbk }f jkfy

lef bojfllfykckc kcgflfcbfwkcjf mh{jh nylbzy# Ihq ehzlbglhy, jkc }f }kgjhc qnyl

ehpwhbcjh jkck gfbhhzlfykc ynzlfcbf qnylcc }f qfyelkelfykckc jf [fck hch{hwhjh

n}fcgf hlzch hlcbhw nfyfezkkck }vynvlhbzy#


27/58

9>

8#:# Ekblkelfy

)Ekblkelfy) ihlel {v}hylhe bhwh zoplhczlhycjh ehzlbglhy {fck hch{hwhjh ekblkelfykc flf

hlc dheecjh nfcfl jffylfcjkybflfy }f cfyklfyjf ivlvcbvlhyjy#

Hch{hwhjh Ekblke

Vlvw eh}yhb dvevek ckzflke zhbhjcjhc, Hch{hwh.jh )Zye Bkllfzk) }f{h bkllk{fzklkf hzm

{hphc kmhjflfy }f fzcke hyb olhc }vynvlhy {fy hlbhbhljy# ]fcfjke Eobkw{ocv.cvc yhpoylhy,

H}yvph cwhc Dhelhy Bhdefbfwk $HDB+ kzkdhzlhy }f Ikylfbk Bkllfzlfy $IB+ Bfjfck }f Wk{hwk

Dhelhy Wqlfbfwk zfbfl hlchyhe, }hzhcjhle zhcb iky fzcke nyvih {h jh vlvwh ncjfybf

{hpbhjhc jqfclfcbflk }f }hzhcjhle iky dhe olhyhe iv fekljf n}fcgf hlzch hlcbhljy#

Ihq ehzlbglhy, )Hzhzye lef }f celplhy) kmhjfwkcf, wq eocvwv eh}yhbc jfboeyhzke dhe

}f qnylelfyk ewzlhbh{h {cflke olhyhe {oyvblhchiklfgfk eh{nw{lh [fck Hch{hwh.jh {fy}fyklbfbfwkck cfybkzky#

Elzyfl Dhelhy }f H{ybglc clfcbfwk

Hch{hwhjh eolfezkm dhe wzhzwc jf kfyfgfe fekljf )elzyfl dhelhy) ihlel iky dhe

ehzfnoykwkckc {fy hlbhw nfyfebfezfjky# Ihlhcn bfzckcjf {h jh klnklk iheh iky ilbjf,

elzyfl ovlgvlvh wh{n{ kfyfc iky kmhjf{f {fy }fyklbflkjky#

[fck hch{hwhjh h{ybgl {hwhelh{hc kmhjflfyf {fy }fyklkyefc, h{ybgle whjfgf ye, fzcke

eefc {h jh kchc zfbflkcjf jfkl, LNIZZ ikyf{lfyk jhdkl zb nyvplhy }f mhyel dh{hz zhyqlhycjh ehpwh{hghe fekljf {hwhelhcbhl }f iv jqfclfbfjf ncbqc kcwhc dhelhy wzhcjhyzlhycjh

iky h{ybgle {hwh kmhjf fjklbflkjky# H{ybglh ehy eoyvbh whjfgf bhjjk dveve jfkl, vwvl

dvevev hwcjhc jh ncjfbf nflbflk }f ikyf{kc h{ybglh ehy iv fekljf n}fcgf hlzch

hlcbhw whlhcbhljy#

Hchjklkcjf Fkzkb }f Hchjklkc yfckbk

Hchjklkcjf fkzkb }f hchjklkc yfckbk eocvlhycjh jc{hjhek bf}gvz bojfllfy hyhzylhyhe

Zyek{f.{f fc v{nvc bojflkc ifckbwfcbfwk nfyfebfezfjky# Iv hlhcjhek vlvwlhyhyhw v{nvlhbhlhy,

zhbhbfc hchjkljf fkzkb {hplbhwcjhc, kwzfe qfykcf o jklkc fkzkbkcf mhyel bojfllfy kkcjf{fy }fyklbfwkcf ehjhy vlhhiklfc nfck iky {flphqf{k ehpwhbhezhjy# Hchjklkcjf fkzkb }f hchjklkc

yfckbk eocvlhycjh hjb hzlbhw kkc nfyfelk zoplvbwhl }f pfjhnoake $yfzbfc {fzkzkyklbfwk,

bmyfjhz dhqylhcbhw }i#+ hlz{hpcc olvzvyvlbhwch klkekc zfjikylfy hlcbhljy#

Iv hlhcjh, H}yvph Eocwf{k Ilnfwfl }f Hqcle Jkllfyk Wzhcjhyj hyz Bfzck }f Ikylfbk

Bkllfzlfy Bfjfck }f Wk{hwk Dhelhy Wqlfbfwk $Zyek{f.ckc fekcgf eo{bv oljvv 9># Bhjjf


28/58

94

jf jdkl olbhe qfyf+ zfbfl hlcbhl, elzyfl dhelhy fyf}fwkcjf nfyfefc zfjikylfykc hlcbhw

}f nflkzkyklbfwkcf jh{hl iky dhe fyf}fwkcf ozvyzvlbhljy#

Iv ihlhbjh, fkzkb dheech klkekc hch{hwhl jqfclfbfjf, hch fkzkb jklkckc Zyef oljvv,

Zyef.jfc iheh jkllfyjf fkzkbkc }f iv jkllfykc yfzkbkckc jfboeyhzke zoplvb }f elzyfl

ovlgvlve nfyfelfykcf v{nvc olhyhe ehcvclh jqfclfcfgfk kmhjf fjklfiklky#

[fyfl [cfzkb Yfmoybv

Zyek{f ihlhbcjh nl iky ekblke zhlfplfyk io{vzvcv jh kfybfezf olbhwcjhc zy {fyfl

{cfzkblfy yfmoybv iv ihle hlzcjh flf hlcbzy# Ivcvclh ikylkezf ekblke zhlfplfyk io{vzvcv

hhc iky fekljf eocv zb {clfyk klf zhyzlbzy#

[fck hch{hwh klf {fyfl {cfzkblfyjf {hplbhw nfyfefc yfmoybvc jfzh{lhych nfbfjfc cgf,

bf}gvz hch{hwhl wcylhy kkcjf {hplhiklfgfe ihq jfkkelkelfy oljvv zfwpkz fjklbkzky1 Ivch

nyf, dhyghbhlhyc bfyefqk debfz }f {fyfl ikykblfy hyhwcjhek ph{lhb oyhc, }hlklfykc kl qfl

{cfzkblfykcjfek fzekwk, Ehlecbh Hahcwlhy.cc qfyelkk nkik eocvlhyc hch{hwhl jfkkelke

olbhjhc jh nfyfelfzkyklfiklfgfk iflkyzklbkzky#

[fyfl {cfzkblfy yfmoybv, H}yvph Eocwf{k.ckc H}yvph [fyfl [cfzkb qfyelke hyz, Vlvwhl

Hqclelhyh lkekc fyf}f Wqlfbf }f Ilnfwfl }f [fyfl Jkllfy hyz zfbfl hlchyhe

nfyfelfzkyklbflkjky# Iv ehpwhbjh [fyfl [cfzkb qfyelke hyz.ch eo{vlbv olhc fekcgflfy

ehljylbhl, Vlvwhl Hqclelhyh lkekc fyf}f Wqlfbf klf Ilnfwfl }f [fyfl Jkllfy hyz

och{lhcbhljy# [fyfl ikykblfykc {fzeklfyk, vlvwlhyhyhw k{k ycfelfyk oyzh{h ehyzhc iky wzhcjhyj

v{nvlhbh {helhb fyf}fwkcjf hyzylbhl, h{c qhbhcjh {fyfl {cfzkblfyjf fmmhmle }f dfwhp

}fyfiklkylke poqkw{ocv nflkzkyklbflkjky#

[fyfl {cfzkb yfmoybv ehpwhbcjh {fyfl ikykblfy, cmvwvc wow{oloakwk }f goyhmk jhlb nq

ccjf ivlvcjvyvlhyhe ikyeh klkc ikylfbfwkcjfc bf{jhch nflfgfe ilnflfy felkcjf jqfclfcfiklky#

Ehlecbh hahcwlhy nlfcjkyklfyfe ilnf kjhyflfykcf ihl olhyhe mhhlk{fzlfykck wyjyfiklky, kl

}hlklfykckc {fzeklfyk wcylhcjylhiklky#

Ilnflfykc nflkylfyk ewbfc bfyefqk izfjfc h{ylhghe moclhylh, ewbfc jf wq eocvwv

ilnfckc }fynklfcjkybfwk{lf fljf fjklfgfe nflkylfyjfc ehylhchiklky }f ikyoe dkqbfz $whle,

fkzkb, ih{cjyle, elzy }w#+ vlvwlhyhyhw ycfelfyjfc dhyfefzlf iflkylk llfyjf ilnf kjhyfwkcfiyhelhiklky# Ilnflfy, izc lef hpcjhek bkllk fkzkb pyonyhbch fe olhyhe efcjk ilnflfykckc

elzylfykckc qfllkelfykcf nyf fkzkb wkwzfbkcf ihq felfbflfy {hphiklky# Iv hyhjh bfzyopollfy

kkc qfl kbeclhy whlh{hghe ikyzheb jqfclfbflfyf jf {fy }fyklfiklky# Ihq ehzlbglhy,

}fynklfcjkybf polkzkehw ehpwhbcjh iflkylk iky ilnfjf zoplhchc }fynkckc mhyel ilnflfyjf jf

dhyghcbhwc whlh{hghe iky wkwzfbkc evyvlbhwcc }f iv wkwzfbf bfyvk{fz ehqhcjylbhwcc

ilnflfy hyhw mhyellelhyc nkjfyklbfwk hwcjhc cfblk yol o{ch{hghc }vynvlhbzy#


29/58

Ehzlbglhyc iky ewb, {fyfl {cfzkb yfmoybvcjh klf}wfllkkc cfbkckc nq hyj fjklbfbfwkck,

{hlcqgh ekblke zhlfplfykcf {hcz }fybfe whkek{lf yfmoyb {hplhbh{hghc jklf nfzkybk, {fyfl

{cfzkb yfmoybvcjh ikyf{kc dhelhyc eoyvbh{, mywhz fkzwkqlkkck nkjfybf{k, h{ybgl oyzhjhc

ehljybh{, yfehifzk eoyvbh{ dfjfmlfyefc evyvbwhl iky hyhjh hlhiklbf qfykcf jf jclbfwk

nfyfezkkck kmhjf fzbklfyjky# Ivch nyf, dkqbfzkc zefzkgkwk klf dkqbfzk wvchc hyhwcjh iky kdzklhm

oljvvcjh {fyfl jqf{jfek ihwe jhdh nl olhyhe dkwwfjklfiklky }f ivcv ifyzhyhm fjfgfeikyzheb zfjikylfykc hlcbhw nfyfebfezfjky#

[fyfl {cfzkblfykc nlfcjkyklbfwkck jqfclf{fc {fck hch{hwh debcjf dhe fewfclk iky

{helhbc ifckbwfcbfwkckc {hc wyh obivjwbhcle bfwwfwfwk kkcjf jf {fyfl {cfzkblfyjfc

woyvblv iky ikykb olvzvyvlhyhe iv evyvbh fzekclke ehqhcjylhiklky#

Ekblke }f Ilnflfykc Zfbwklk

Ev}}fzlk iky ekblke io{vzv jh ivlvchc zfbwkljf hjhlfz woyvcvc nkjfyklfiklbfwk kkc &80.lve

wfkb ihyhacc jylbfwk nfyfebfezfjky#

Ehzlbglhyc iky ewb, phylhbfczo wfkblfykcjf dhlfc v{nvlhcbhezh olhc kl ihql zfbwkl

{fykcf CVZW wkwzfbkcf jh{hl olhyhe olvzvyvlhghe ilnflfykc zfbwklk {czfbkcf nfklbfwkck

cfybkzky# Iv cfyk{f nyf, CVZW wkwzfbk fwhw{lh iflkylfcfc ilnflfy, zfbwklkc zfbflk dhlkcf

jczylfyfe ckwpklke hyzylhiklky }f ilnflfy hyhw zfbwkl hjhlfzk whlhchiklky# Jkfy ehzlbglhyh

nyf kwf, ilnf wkwzfbkckc ifckbwfcbfwk jvyvbvcjh ilnflfykc kkcjf jhy wfkb f}yflfyk

olvzvyvlhyhe zfbwkljf hjhlfz hyzylhiklky#

9;


30/58

70

8#6# Ev}}fzlfy H{yl

)Ev}}fzlfy H{yl) {v}hylhe bhwh zoplhczlhycjh {hwhbh, {yzbf }f {hyn oynhclhycc {hpw

}f hyhlhycjhek klkek zhyzlb }f ehzlbglhy zhyhmcjhc nfcfl jffylfcjkybf }f cfyklfyjf

ivlvcvlbvzvy#

Debfz Wkwzfbk

Ihehcle wkwzfblfykcjf dhlec wfzkk ihehc, {yzbf ngcc {fncf whdkikjky# Iv kwf,

ihehcc wk{hwhl wkwzfbkc fc nl hezy oljvv kqlfckbkck v{hcjybhezhjy# O{wh iky ihehc,

zhhddz fzzkk polkzkehlhy kqlf{fiklbfe kkc, iv polkzkehlhyc nfyfezkyjkk ehcvclhyc ehivlc

whlhbhe hbhg{lh, {hwhbh bfcwvplhyc kech fzbfe qoyvcjhjy# Ihehclh, {hwhbh{h dekb

olhc ovclvvc mhyel wk{hwk fklkblfyjf olbhw, iv kech wyfgkck kbehcwqlhzyhiklbfezf, jf}lfz

dh{hzcc eklkzlfcbfwk wocvgvcv {hyhzhiklbfezfjky# Iv zhilocvc HIJ.jf oyzh{h ebhbhw,

Hbfykehc polkzkehwcc efcjkcf qn qfllkelfykckc ycjy# Dfy f{jfc cgf, HIJ.jf kekphyzklk iky wkwzfb bf}gvzzvy# Iv phyzklfy hyhwcjh evzvplhbh{h jcfgfe ny h{ylelhy

{hhcbhbhezhjy# zf {hcjhc, wkwzfbkc bfyv vcwvyv olhc loik kyefzlfyk, {hwhbh }f {yzbf

oynhclhy hyhwcjhek eklkzlfcbflfyk ifyzhyhm fjfc cfblk iky mhezyjy# O{wh Lhzkc Hbfykeh.cc

ihehcle wkwzfblfyk, iv zy eklkzlfcbflfykc we we {hhcjc nwzfyfc ycfelfyjky# H{ygh iv

leflfyjf wkwzfbkc ozoykzfylfbf fklkbk nwzfyjkkck jf dhzylhbhe nfyfeky#

H{ygh ihehcle wkwzfbkcf nfk cfykwkckc nfyfeflfykcjfc ikyk olhc )nl {yzbf) zfqk

jf, kek hjhc v{nvc nylbfbfezfjky# Ikykcgkwk, Zyek{f.jf bf}gvz wkwzfbjfek ihihehc dfb

{hwhbh dfb jf {yzbf oynhcch dhekb olhyhe ihehcle yfakbkcjfek iky ihehcjhc jhdh mhqlh

{fzek{f whdkpzky# HIJ.jf ihehclhy whclj nkik wpfy {fzeklk }f oe nl jfkljky# H{ygh{yzbf{k jhdh jh nlfcjkyfgfe dfy hjb, 8;49 Hch{hwhw.cc {yzbf oynhcc nlfcjkybf

hclh{ klf h{c joyvlzvjh olhghe }f {fck hch{hwhcc 8;49 Hch{hwhw.cjhc eopvv kmhjf fzbfwk

kjjkhwc jh fzekwkq elhghezy#

Ihehcle wkwzfbkcf nfk, kjhyfckc }f {yzbf oynhccc {hpwcc iv wkwzfbf v{hylhcbhwc

nfyfezkybfezfjky# Iv, ehpwhbl }f {llhy hlhghe iky wyfzky }f lefckc zfbfl ikyoe woyvcvc

qbc kekcgk plhch hzhiklfgfe }f fyzflf{fiklfgfe ckzflkezfjky#

[fck hch{hwh phylhbfczfy wkwzfbk ifckbwfbflkjky# 8;49 Hch{hwhw.cc {yzbf{k nlfcjkybf

hclh{ joyvlzvwvcjh Gvbdvyihehcch elhwke phylhbfczfy yfakbjf olhhc olhc {fzeklfykc

zfwkcjf {fzeklfy zhccbzy5 iv {fzeklfykc jhyhlzlbhw nfyfeky# Bf}gvz wkwzfbkc }fyjkk nfck

{fzeklfykc qfykcf, dhleo{v{lh wfklfgfe olbhwcc whlh{hgh wk{hwk nlf ikylkezf, Gvbdvyihehc

wk{hwfzf jhdh mhqlh bjhdhlf fjfiklfgfe, nl iky wk{hwk hezy dhlkcf nflfiklfgfezky# Iv coezhjh

qfllkelf debfz klf mhyel wk{hwk nylfyjfc nflfc iky Gvbdvyihehc.cc wkwzfbkc klf{kkck

eklkzlf{fc iky mkny olbhw olhwl {ewfezky#


31/58

Gvbdvyihehc wfkb vwvlcf klkekc ehzlbglhyc {helhb mhyelle nwzfybfezfjky#

Ehzlbglhyc iky ewb, dhle zhyhmcjhc wfklfc Gvbdvyihehc.cc nl bfyvk{fzkcf jh{hchyhe

phylhbfczfy wkwzfbkc qcf h{ey iky ikkbjf {fzek evllhcbhe kwzf{fgfkcjfc dhyfefzlf

Gvbdvyihehc.cc dhleo{v{lh wfklbfwk vwvlcjfc ZIBB zhyhmcjhc wfklbfwk vwvlcf

jclbfwkck cfybkzky# Jkfy ehzlbglhy kwf wfbiolke {fzeklfyf whdkp olbhwch yhbfc

gvbdvyihehccc dhle zhyhmcjhc wfkljkk leflfykc ivlvcjvvcjhc dhyfefzlf, dhleh zhcchciky {fzekckc nfyk hlcbhwcc v{nvc olbh{hghc jh iflkyzfyfe, {fzeklfyk hqhlzlb Gvbdvyihehc.cc

dhle zhyhmcjhc wfklbfwk vwvlcc jf}hb fzbfwk nfyfezkkck kmhjf fzbkzky#

[hwhbh Oynhc

Ehzlbglhyc iky ewb, {fck hch{hwhjh {hwhbh oynhccc zfe bfglkwlk olbhw nfyfezkkck jklf

nfzkybklfyjky# [hwhbh oynhccc kek bfglkwlk olbhwcc h}hczhal {clfyk ivlvcwh jh {hwhbh

wyfgkckc {h}hlhbhw, h{c wk{hwk phyzk ovclvvcvc dhekb oljvv jvyvbjh klf}kck {fykcf

nfzkyfbfbfwk }f ozobhzke och{ bfehckqbhw dhlkcf nflbfwk nkik iky jkqk jfqh}hczha jh

ivlvcbhezhjy# Dfy cf ehjhy zhl{h, wphc{h }f Myhcwh nkik leflfyjf kek bfglkwlk iky {hwhbh

oynhc ivlvcwh jh Zyek{f.jf nfbk jfcf{kblfy cjh {fck hch{hwhjh kek bfglkwlk iky {hwhbh

oynhcch kdzk{h ivlvcbhbhezhjy# Ivch ehy ihq ehzlbglhy kwf iv eocvjh ehzfnoyke iky

{helhb kkcjf olvcbhbhwc dfy kek zy {hwhbh oynhccc jh ihq h}hczhalhy }f jfqh}hczhalhy

olhiklfgfkcf jkeehz febklfyjky#

ZIBB zq {fck hch{hwh klf ifyhify {fckjfc flf hlcbhljy# ZIBB Zq jhdh oe

{yzbfckc fzekclkkcf cfb }fyklfyfe dhqylhcbzy# ZIBB.ckc klf{kkcjf bvdhlfmfzkc eocvbv

nlfcjkyklbflk }f bfglkw kk jfcfzkb vwvllfyk jhdh fzekc dhlf nfzkyklbflkjky# [hwhbh wyfgkcf

wk}kl zoplvb ynzlfykckc fzekc ehzlbc hyzzyhghe clfblfy bvdheehe hlcbhljy#

Ehzlbglhy, wfkb ihyha eocvwvcjh mhyel nylfy jklf nfzkybkzky# Ehzlbglhyc iky ewbch

nyf, wfkb wkwzfbk {cfzkbjf kwzkeyhyjhc oe zfbwkljf hjhlfz klefwkcf {fy }fybflkjky# Wfkb

ihyha ehljylbhl }f{h mhyel nylfykc zfbwklkck fcnfllfbf{fgfe ikkbjf hh feklbflkjky#

Jkfy ehzlbglhy kwf wfkblfykc iky mocewk{ocvcvc jh {cfzfiklky iky kezkjhy ehybhe oljvv

jcgfwkcjfc dhyfefzlf, wfkb ihyhacc }hylcc coybhl ehivl fjklfiklfgfkck iflkyzbkzky#

Ivcvclh ikylkezf ihyhac fzekwk{lf johiklfgfe zfbwkl fewkelkkckc, Zyek{f bkllfz}fekllkkckc

cnylbfwk {h jh Hlbhc{h, nffylk olhc wfkb wkwzfbkcjfek nkik ilnfwfl phyzklfykc jf zfbwkl

fjklbfwk{lf nkjfyklfiklfgfk iflkyzklbkzky#

Wk}kllfbf

Hwefy"wk}kl klkeklfykckc jfboeyhzke bojflk, hwefyk ozoykzfckc, wfklbk oynhclhyc ehyhylhych

zhik olbhwc nfyfezkybfezfjky# Hwefyk bjhdhlflfyk zhekp fjfc hch{hwh {hpb wyflfykcjf,

hwefyk bhehblhyh nfck hch{hwhl {fzek }f h{yghlelhy wvcvlbvzvy# Iv h{yghlelhyc iky ewb,

78


32/58

79

woc oc {ljh ehivl fjklfc hch{hwh yfmoyblhy{lh hcghe ewbfc zhwmk{f fjklbkzky# Zyek{f.jf

wk}kllfbf{k zf}ke fjfgfe {fck hch{hwh jfkkelkelfykcf kdzk{h jv{vlbhezhjy# Ehzlbglhy,

wk}kllfbf yfmoyblhycc ehpwhbch klkekc olhyhe, hhjhek dvwvwlhyjh vqlhbh whlhblhyjy#

Bkllk N}fclke Evyvlv hch{hwhl iky evyvb olbhezhc ehylbhl, {fckjfc {hplhcjylbhl, {f

eobpoqkw{ocv jfkzkyklbflk }f nyf} hlhc cfz kqnklfylf iflkylfcbflkjky# Bkllk n}fclke eh}yhb{fckjfc zhcblhcbhljy# Bkllk N}fclke Evyvlv.cvc {fckjfc {hplhcjylbhw wyfgkcjf {fzek

hlhc whjfgf wh}vcbh klf wcyl zvzvlbhl, zfdjkz, n}fclke nkik bvlhe eh}yhblhyc fyf}fwk

kqklbflkjky# Evyvlvc kwbk jf {fck {hpw }f nyf}lfyk fyf}fwkcjf jfkzkyklbflkjky#

Gvbdvyihehclcc wfbiolke iky bhehb olbhw nfyfkcjfc dhyfefzlf Evyvl.h Ihihehc

ihehcle fzbflkjky#

Hwefyk ozoykzfckc wfklbk oynhclhyh ihl mhhlk{fz {yzbfwkcf jhky jfboeyhzke klefckc fzekc

klf{kkckc, whjfgf {hpwhl iky jfkkelkelf whlhchbh{hghc ehivl fzbfelf ikylkezf, wk}kllfbf

ehpwhbcjh nfyfelk iky hjb olhyhe, Nfcflevybh{ Ihehcl Bkllk Wh}vcbh Ihehcl.ch

ihlhcbhljy#

Wh}vcbh dhyghbhlhycc jfcfzkbk Wh{zh{ zhyhmcjhc fzekc iky ikkbjf {fykcf nfzkyklbflkjky#

Wh}vcbh dhyghbhlhycc qfllkkcjfc eh{chelhchghe }f olhhc nylfiklfgfe nkqlklke clfblfykckc

hlcbhw klf ikylkezf, wh}vcbh dhyghbhlhy ZIBB Plhc }f Izf Eobkw{ocv zhyhmcjhc jh we

iky ikkbjf kcgflfcbflk }f jfcfzlfcbflkjky#

[ewfe eobvzh ehjfbfwkcf hzhbhlhy Zye Wklhdl Ev}}fzlfyk.ckc nwzfyfgfk ifllk wh{jh hjh{

hyhwcjhc wk}kl ozoykzf zhyhmcjhc nfyfelfzkyklbflkjky# [ewfe eobvzh ehjfbfwkcjf hzhbh {fzekwk

wklhdl ev}}fzlfy }f wk}kl ozoykzf hyhwcjh ph{lhlbhljy# Ehzlbglhyc iky ewb, [ewfe Hwefyk

vyh.cc hch{hwhl iky oynhc olbhezhc ehylbhwc cfybkzky#

jhyk {fzeklfykc i{e ljf hwefyk bhehblhyh nfzkk we{cfzkb ifcqfyk yfakb jqfclfbflfykcf

{fy }fyklbfbflkjky# Olhhcwz dhlkc ehpwhbc hhc }f wklhdl ev}}fzlfykc evllhclbhwc nfyfezkyfc

jvyvblhyjh eoczyolc wk}kl ozoykzfjf ivlvcbhw }f wklhdl ev}}fzlfyjfc {hyhylhclbhw jhdh v{nvc

olhghezy#

Dveve Jf}lfzk }f [hyn Oynhclhy

[hyncc Zhyhmwql }f Ihbwql

Dveve jf}lfzk, ehbv bhehblhycc zb f{lfb }f klfblfykcjf dveveh v{nvc olbhlhyc

nfyfezkyky# Iv kwf, {hwhbh }f {yzbf oynhclhy{lh kjhyk bhehblhyc, dfy zy f{lfb }f klfbkckc

dveveh v{nvclvelhy {ccjfc, {hyn jfcfzkbkcf zhik elcbhw{lh whlhchiklky# Iv cfjfclf,

dveve jf}lfzkckc fc cfblk vcwvyv {hyn ngjy# Hcghe, {hyncc efcjkwkcjfc ifelfcfc

{ebll {fykcf nfzkybfwk, iv oynhcc, evyvbwhl }f ikyf{wfl olhyhe zhyhmwqle }f ihbwqlcc


33/58

77

whlhcbhw{lh bbecjy# [hyncc zhyhmwql }f ihbwqlcc whlhcbhw kwf, iv oynhch

wk{hwk hezylfy }f dhzzh {hyncc efcjk kkcjfc nflbfwk bvdzfbfl dfy zy ihwe }f bjhdhlfckc

fcnfllfcbfwkck nfyfezkyky#

Hch{hwh Bhdefbfwk

Dveve jf}lfzkcf jh{hchc iky hch{hwh jqfckckc kchwcjh fc cfblk mhezylfyjfc ikyk,

ehcvclhyc hch{hwh{h v{nvclve jfcfzkbkck {hpbhelh {fzeklk iky hch{hwh bhdefbfwkckc

{hyhzlbhwjy# Hch{hwh bhdefbfwkckc hwl klf}k, hch{hwh{h h{eylc zfwpkz fzzkk ehcvclhyc

kpzhlkcf debfzbfe, i{lfgf hch{hwhcc wzclc eoyvbhezy# Iv fyf}fjf Hch{hwh

Bhdefbfwkckc {hpwch klkekc jqfclfbfjf dfb jfboeyhzke bfyvk{fz dfb jf ovlgvlve

cfb ehqhcy# Iv cfjfclf, ehcvclhyc hch{hwh{h v{nvclve jfcfzkbkcjf qfl {fzeklk iky hch{hwh

bhdefbfwkckc }hylc ehivl fjfc jfboeyhzke leflfyjf, hch{hwh bhdefbfwk {flfykckc zb

}f{h iky ilbcc phylhbfczolhy zhyhmcjhc ckzflkelk ovclvelh wfkbk vwvl ifckbwfcbkzky#

[fck hch{hwhjh, Hch{hwh Bhdefbfwk {flfykckc cfblk iky ewbc $ihq ehzlbglhyh nyf

{hy{h {hecc+ wfbf {fzekwk ZIBB.{f zhccbhl5 ZIBB iv {fzek{k, hjh{lhy ehbvo{vch

{fzfykcgf zhczhghe iky wyfgk zhekifc, ckzflkelk ovclve o{v klf $ihq ehzlbglhy ivcvc ZIBB

{f zhb wh{wcc 9/7cjfc hq olbhbhwc qoyvclv nybfezfjky+ evllhcbhljy# Ivch fe olhyhe

{fck hch{hwh, jkfy Hch{hwh Bhdefbfwk {flfykckc wfkbk {fzekwkck Gvbdvyihehcch jfkl,

[hynzh{, Jhczh{ }f Ihyolhy Ikylkk nkik fkzlk evyvblhyh zhcbhljy#

Dhekblfy }f Wh}glhy [ewfe Evyvlv $DW[E+

DW[E.cc {hpw }f {fzeklfyk vlvwlhyhyhw wzhcjhyzlhylh v{vblv dhlf nfzkyklbflkjky# [hyncc

ihbwql }f zhyhmwqlcc whlhcbhwcjh Evyvl.vc olvvbv }f {fzeklfyk cfb ehqhcbhezhjy#

9080 {lcjh {hplhc hch{hwh jfkkelkelfyk{lf iv hlhcjh ewbk iky klfylfbf whlhcbzy# Hcghe

vlvwlhyhyhw wzhcjhyzlhyh v{nvc iky evyvl kkc iky jkqk hjb jhdh hzlbhw nfyfebfezfjky1

Whjfgf bfwlfezfc kdyh ehyhylhycc jfkl evyvlvc zb ehyhylhycc {hyn jfcfzkbkcf he

olbhw nfyfelkjky# Gfqh ckzflkkcjf cnylfc {fy jfkzkybflfy jcjh jkfy {fy jfkzkybf

v{nvlhbhlhych woc }fyklbflk }f{h iflkylk iky wyf $ycfkc if {l+ kkcjf {hyn }f{h wh}gcc

yqhw hlcbhewqc iheh iky bhdefbf{f hzhchbh{hgh n}fcgf hlzch hlcbhljy# [yzbfjfc

ihbwqlc whlhcbhw hwcjhc, evyvlvc zoplhcz zhykd }f ncjfblfykckc, Nfcfl Wfeyfzfykckc

iflkylfcbfwkcjf, dhekb }f wh}glhylh klnklk woyvzvybh kqck }fyklbfwkcjf Hjhlfz Ihehc.cc {fzekwkqdhlf nfzkyklbfwk }f {fykcf dhekb }f{h wh}g ckzflkkcjfek ekklfykc woyvzvybh eocvwvcjh {fzeklk

olbhw cfyklbfezfjky# Ihq {flfy kwf, 9080 Hch{hwh jfkkelkk klf iv jfkkelkkc hyjcjhc

ehivl fjklfc DW[E.{h klkekc {fck Ehcvcvc, {hyn bfcwvplhycc jkwkplkc woyvzvybhlhycjh

{fzfylk zfbkchz whlhj, Hjhlfz Ihehc }f Bwzfhycc zoplhczlhyc ncjfbkck iflkylfbfjfek

{fzekwkck wcylhjc }vynvlhblhyjy# Dhekb }f wh}glhyc pfymoybhcwlhycc jffylfcjkyklbfwkcjf

{ewfe {hyncc coz }fybfwk }f DW[E.{h ihl bmfzzklfy zhyhmcjhc dhl ehzlhycc joljvyvlbhw


34/58

7:

vwvllfykcjf cfwcfl wzhcjhyzlhyh {fy }fyklbflkjky# Evyvl ehyhylhy ehbv{h hlbhl }f iv eocvjh

fmmhmle whlhcbhljy# le jfyfgf {hyn oynhclhycjhc wfklfgfe Evyvl {flfykckc wfkbkcjf

jfboeyhzke vwvllfykc n}fcgf hlzch hlcbhw nfyfebfezfjky#

Ihq ehzlbglhy, Evyvl.vc whjfgf bfwlff ehivl jfkl, hjh{lh ehivljf jf zfe wq whdkik

olbhw }f iv joyvlzvjh dhekb }f wh}g hjh{ hlbcjh {hplhc wch}lhyc Hjhlfz Ihehclic{fwkcjf jfkl Evyvl ic{fwkcjf nfyfelfbfwkck cfybkzky Iv nyf nyf, {hyn ihbwql

ihebcjhc hjlk eollvvc evyvlbhw jh cfb hyq fzbfezfjky# Woyvzvybhlhyc {yzbfckc

eoczyol hlzcjh olhc eollve ng zhyhmcjhc jfkl wh}gle bhehbch ihl hjlk eollve ng

zhyhmcjhc {hplbhw woyvzvybhlhyc cfwcfl {yzlfiklbfwk }f hjkl iky wocvgh }hylbhw ihebcjhc

qoyvclv nylbfezfjky#

DW[E qfye iky evyvb olhyhe jqfclfcfyfe {hwhbh, {yzbf }f {hyn oynhclhych ehy

ihbwql whlhcbhljy# {flfykckc ovclvv dfy jqf{jf {hyn oynhccjhc nflbflk hcghe

qfllkelf dhekb }f wh}g olbh{hc {flfy jf evyvl kkcjf {fy hlbhljy# Iv coezhjh Gvbdvyihehcl

zhyhmcjhc Evyvl.h {f wfkbk v{nvlhbhwch woc }fyklbfwk, {hyn eefclk olbh{hc {flfykc ZIBB

zhyhmcjhc ckzflkelk ovclvelh $ihq ehzlbglhyh nyf iv oyhc fc hq 9/7 olbhljy+ wfklbfwk

}f ZIBB zhyhmcjhc wfklfc {flfykc wh{wcc hyzylbhw v{nvc olhghezy#

Hjhlfz Ihehc }f Ihehcle Bwzfhycc {flkk dheecjh kwf ehzlbglhy mhyel nylfy jklf

nfzkybklfyjky# Ehzlbglhyc iky ewb, Evyvl.vc {yzbfjfc zhb hclhb{lh ihbwq olbhw

nfyfezkk nycjfjky# Iv nyzfek ehzlbglhy, Myhcwh nkik ihq leflfyjf woc {llhyjh ehivl

fjklfc yfmoyblhylh, {yzbf oynhccjhc nflfc Gvbdvyihehc }f Hjhlfz Ihehc nkik ekklfykc

Evyvl {flkkcf klkekc fwhwc zfye fjkljkk, i{lfgf Evyvlvc {yzbfjfc zb{lf ihbwq dhlf

nfzkykljkkck iflkyzbklfyjky# Ihq ehzlbglhy kwf, ]fcfjke Eobkw{ocvcvc )[hynwhl Hzhbhlhy)

ihlel yhpoyv{lh kmhjf fjkljkk nkik, Evyvljh {yzbf{k zfbwkl fjfc {flfyf {fy }fyklbfwkckc,

zfe ihch woyvc {hyhzbh{hghc }vynvlhblhyjy# zf {hcjhc iv ehzlbglhy, 9080 Hch{hwh

jfkkelkk klf ivcvc hyjcjhc ehivl fjklfc DW[E.{h klkekc Ehcvcvc, Hjhlfz Ihehc }f Bwzfhycc

Evyvljhek {fzeklfykck i{e ljf wcylhjch jfkcbklfyjky#

jhyfckc [hynwhl Jfcfzkbk

9080 {lcjh {hplhc hch{hwh jfkkelkk{lf [ewfe Hwefyk vyh.cc bfwlfezfc kdyh ehyhylhych

ehy {hyn jfcfzkbk cnylbzy# [fck hch{hwhjh [ewfe Hwefyk vyh.cc zb ehyhylhych

{hynwhl jfcfzkb cnylbflkjky# Bf}gvz jqfclfbf dveve jf}lfzk klefwk hwcjhc jh woyvcjovybhezhjy# Iv coezhjh kjhyk {hyncc {fykcjflke jfcfzkbk {hphbh{hgh ehivl fjkljkk kkc

[ewfe Hwefyk vyh ehyhylhycc dveveklke jfcfzkbkckc fcnfllfcbfwk v{nvc nqebfbfezfjky#

jhyfckc {hyn oynhclhycc ehyhylhyc {fykcf nfzkybfbfwk ehywcjh fzekc zfjikylfy cnylbflkjky#

Iv eocvjh qkdck{fz jfkkelkk klf ifyhify {fck hch{hwhjh ihq evyvbwhl n}fcgflfykc jf {fy

hlbhw v{nvc olhghezy#


35/58

76

Hwefyk [hyn

Hwefyk bhdefbflfy, hwefyk jkwkplkc wvlhy }f bcdhwyhc hwefyk wvlhylh {fzeklk olbhljy#

Jc{hjh dfydhcnk iky ycfk olbh{hc Hwefyk [ewfe jhyf Bhdefbfwk }f Hwefyk [hynzh{ nkik

{ewfe {hyn oynhclhy kkc iky nfyfelklke bf}gvz jfkljky# Iv cfjfclf, Hwefyk [ewfe jhyf

Bhdefbfwk klf Hwefyk [hynzh{.c klnhw cfyklbkzky# Hwefyk [ewfe jhyf Bhdefbfwkckc nyf}hlhcch nkyfc v{vbhqlelhyjh, f}}flgf oljvv nkik Jhczh{.c, Hwefyk [hynzh{.c nyf} hlhcch

nkyfc v{vbhqlelhyjh kwf, [hynzh{.c qfl iky jhkyfwkckc {fzeklfcjkykljkk, nfyfekywf iv jhkyfjf

hwefyk iky dhekbf jf {flke wzhzwcc wvcvljvv iky bojflkc ifckbwfcbfwk v{nvc olhghezy#

H{ygh hwefyk bhdefbflfyjf wk}kllfykc {hynlhcbhwcc ccf nfbf{f {cflke nfbkzf

ifckbwfcfc {helhb jf}hb fzzkyklbflkjky#

[hynwhl H{yghlelhy

[hwhbh woyvbwvqlvvch jhky jqfclfbflfy eoyvcbhl, ivch ehyle {hwhbh joevcvlbhqlcc

ehpwhbcjh jfkkelkf nkjklbflkjky# [hwhbh joevcvlbhql, {q eqhyzg wvlhy olhyhe hclhc

ifllk wv zkplfyk kkc nffylk olbhbhljy# [hwhbh joevcvlbhqlcc vwvl hwcjhc wcy kwf,

dyyk{fzk ihlh{g gfqh zfjikylfyk }f gfqhlhy olbhljy# ycfkc iky bkllfz}feklk {hehlhchbhbhl,

zvzvelhchbhbhljy# Joevcvlbhqlc ehljylbhw dhlkcjf {hynlhbh, [hynzh{ zhyhmcjhc

nfyfelfzkyklbflkjky#

8;49 Hch{hwhw, joevcvlbhqle n}fcgfwkckc kwzkwchw olhyhe kek jvyvb cnybzy# Ivclhyjhc

ikyk, hy gfqh{ nfyfezkyfc wvwz dhllfykcf klkekcjky# Iv deb, {fck hch{hwhjh bvdhmhqh

fjklbflkjky# Ivch ehyle, woyvzvybhwch wfkblfyjfc cgf ihlhchc, Hch{hwhcc 8:# bhjjfwk

ehpwhbcjhek mkkllfy kkc cnylfc kwzkwch deb zfye fjklbflkjky# Hclhc debc hzmzh ivlvcjvv

8:# bhjjfckc bpdfb }f bvlhe eh}yhblhyh {fy }fybfwk, iv kwzkwchcc klnhwc nfyfezkybfezfjky#

[fck hch{hwh 8;49 Hch{hwhw.cjh jqfclfcbfbk olhc Gvbdvyihehc.cc joevcvlbhql

eocvwvcv helh eh}vzvybhl }f Gvbdvyihehc.ch {hwhbh joevcvlbhqlch jfce iky

joevcvlbhqle zhccbhljy#

[hwhbh joevcvlbhqlcc ewzlhcbhw cfykwk{lf h{c joyvlzvjh olhyhe, ehbv nyf}lkwk

olhc pfe oe bfwlfe nyvivch zhcchc {hynwhl h{yghlelhy ehljylbhl }f{h ewzlhcbhljy#

Jkfy Ihq Evyvblhy

Jf}lfz {cfzkbkcf dvevevc wzcl klefwkck dhekb elbhe hbhg{lh, {fck hch{hwh{lh

{hynwhl jfcfzkb bfehckqbhlhycc fzekclke }f }fykblklkkckc whlhcbhw {hccjh, ehbv jfcfzklkk

evyvbv jh jqfclfcfyfe, kjhyfckc dveveh v{nvclvv ehjhy, dheehck{fzf v{nvclvv jh zf}ke

fjklbflkjky# Ehbv jfcfzklkk evyvbvcvc, Ihz.jhek fbwhllfyk jkeehzf hlchyhe jqfclfcbfwk,


36/58

7=

iv evyvbh dyyk{fzlfykc eoyvcbhw }f h{ybglc clfcbfwk eocvwvcjh qfl iky klf}

ehqhcjyhiklfgfezky# I{lfgf ehbv jfcfzklkk, kjhyk {hyn{ zhbhblh{hc iky yol wzlfcfiklfgfezky#

Cf }hy ek, ehbv jfcfzkwkckc ehyhylhy, kjhyk {hyn ehyhylhy nkik kgyhk jfkl, {ol nwzfykgkjky#

Ehyhylhycc dvevek {hpzybjhc oe bhcf}k hyl oljvv jcljcjf zoplvb zhyhmcjhc

wh{ncl ehivl fjklfc iky ehbv jfcfzkwkckc ZIBB zhyhmcjhc wfkbkcjf ckzflkelk ovclve

cnylbfwk nfyfebfezfjky# Ehbv jfcfzklkk nkik qfye evyvblhyc ihefczzf {fy hlbhw {fykcflefckc mhyel {fylfykcjf {fylfke olhyhe hlbhwcc {hwhbh, {yzbf }f {hyn oynhclhycjhc

ihbwqle coezhwcjh wfbiolke iky hclhb olhiklfgfezky# Ehbv jfcfzklkk evyvbv Ehbv Ih

Jfcfzkwkckc {fzekwk hlzcjh hlhc, mhyel eocvlhyjh vqbhclhhc {hyjbglhycjhc olvbhljy#

zf {hcjhc iv evyvb, mhyel zfbfllfyjf oyzh{h ehc h{ybgle kdlhllfykck jfcfzlf{fgfe qfl

jhkyflfy dhlkcjf mhhlk{fz nwzfybflkjky#

Gvbdvyihehccc yolcc phylhbfczfy wkwzfbf v{hylhcbhw fyf}fwkcjf, Jf}lfz Jfcfzlfbf

Evyvlv ehljylbhljy#

[ewfeyfzkb Evyvlv {fykcf, ck}fywkzflfy hyhw plhclhbh }f eooyjkchw{ocjhc woyvblv {fck

iky {hp evyvlbhljy# Iv ehpwhbjh hehjfbke qnylelfy }f ck}fywkzflfykc qfyelkk n}fcgf

hlzch hlcbhljy#

8;49 Hch{hwhwcjh jqfclfcfc ehbv evyvbv ckzflkkcjfek bfwlfe evyvlvlhych jhky

jqfclfbflfy {fck hch{hwhjh qnygf ynzlfcbf fwhwch jh{hcbhl }f iv evyvblhy qfykcjfek

kjhyk }fwh{fzf woc }fyklbflkjky#


37/58

9I L B

F EOOYJCHZYLFYC [OYVB ]F

JFFYLFCJYBFLFY


38/58


39/58

7;

9# F EOOYJCHZYLFYC [OYVB ]FJFFYLFCJYBFLFY

ZWHJ.c nkykkbk klf ihlhzlhc )[fck Hch{hwh [v}hylhe Bhwh Zoplhczlhy) 9 Ehwb 9080 "

8 Bhyz 9088 zhykdlfyk hyhwcjh 88 zoplhcz felkcjf nfyfelfbkzky# Iv hlbhlhyh zoplhb 99hehjfbkw{fc }f ehchhz cjfyk ehzlbzy# Dfy zoplhcz{h ehzlhclhyc kwkblfyk }f zoplhczlhyjh

jklf nfzkyklfc nylfykc qfzlfyk, iv {h{cc ihcjh }f 8# ilbcjfek zoplhcz wocv yhpoylhycjh

jhdh h{yczl fekljf {fy hlbhezhjy# Wyfgkc f eooyjkchzylfyk Pyom# Jy# Fynvc qivjvc }f

Pyom# Jy# Zvynvz Zhydhcl.cc {oyvb }f jffylfcjkybflfykck kfyfc ilb hhjhjy#

K# [czfb

hlbhlhybqjh, qfllkelf kek jfkke hch{hwh {hpb bojflk qfykcjf jvyvlbvzvy# Ivclhy,

ewhghw, {fck hch{hwhcc wym iv hbhlh evyvlhghe iky hch{hwh bfglkwk zhyhmcjhc dhqylhcp jhdh

wocyh olhhc hch{hwh {hpb wyfgkcjfc nfkyklbfwk, jkfyk jf 9088 wfkblfyk klf olvhgheZIBB.ckc iv mocewk{ocv joyvjhc joyv{h wzlfcbfwkjky# Dfy kek ny kfykwkcjf jf, fe

hlbh yhpoylhycjh nylfgfk nkik, hlz hlzfychzkmlfy bf}gvzzvy# F eooyjkchzylfy olhyhe nybq,

{fck hch{hwhcc olhhc ZIBB zhyhmcjhc {hplbhwcc, hhjhek nfyfeflfylf, jhdh v{nvc

olhghjy#

$h+ Olhhc ZIBB.ckc {fck iky hch{hwh {hpbhw ccjf dveve iky fcnfl {oezvy# Jfboeyhzke

iky yfakbjf hwl evyvgv kezkjhyc {fncf whdkik dhlezy }f dhle, iv evyvgv kezkjhyc wfyifwzf

wfklbk zfbwklgklfyk flk{lf dfy qhbhc evllhchiklky# [fck iky hch{hwhcc, hcghe hch{hwhl wyfzf

iky efwkczk olbhw dhlkcjf {hplhiklfgfk ny, bhczelh }f wow{oloake nfyfelkelf ihjhbhbhezhjy#

$i+ Olhhc {hwhbh mhhlk{fzlfyk klf bfnvl olhghe ZIBB.ckc {hccjh, whlz hch{hwh {hpb

hlbhlhyc {yzfgfe h{y iky bfglkwkc evyvlbhw, jc{h v{nvlhbhwcjh dfbfc dk yhwzlhcbh{hc

iky {czfb oljvv nkik, kek bfglkwkc h{c hcjh mhhlk{fzzf ivlvcbhlhy iky {fzek ehynhhwch {ol

hhiklfgfezky#

$g+ Hch{hwh bfglkwkckc dhqylh{hgh zhwhycc, jhdh wocyh ZIBB zhyhmcjhc olhhc vwllfylf

ehcvclhzylbhw cnyljcf nyf, ZIBB.ckc iv zhwhy{ och{lhbhbhw dhlkcjf zb iv

hihlhy wocvwvq ehlb }f ihlhcn coezhwch jclb olhghezy#

$+ Hch{hwh bfglkwkcjf, vqbhclhy nkik ifllk oyhcjh jh olwh, dhleh wfklbfbk {flfykc }hyl,

iv bfglkwkc jfboeyhzke bfyvlvvcv nlnflf{fgfezky#

$j+ Bf}gvz hch{hwh deblfyk kfykwkcjf, ZIBB.ckc hch{hwh{ {hpbh }f{h jfkzkybf kezkjhyc,

ewbfc jhdk olwh, iheh iky oynhch jf}yfjfiklbfwk bbec nycbfbfezfjky#


40/58

:0

zf {hcjhc, iv eocv{lh klnklk zhyzbh zoplhczwcjh, {fck Hch{hwhcc olhhc ZIBB zhyhmcjhc

{hplbhw jvyvbvcjh, iv bfglkwkc zfbwkl ehyhezfykck }f hch{hwh {hpb wyfgkckc bqhefyfgk

}f ehzlbg ckzflkkck nlfcjkyfgfe iky jkqk zfjikykc jkeehzf hlcbhwcjh {hyhy nylbfezfjky1

$h+ ZIBB.ckc, qfllkelf hch{hwh {hpb wyfgkcjfek zfbwkl ehiklk{fzkck hyzzybhe qfyf, {qjf

oclve lef wfkb ihyhacc bfwfl {qjf if nkik jhdh bevl iky oyhch jylbfwk, lefhpcjhek lkwzflfyjfc ihyhawq ckwi zfbwkl {czfbk{lf wfklfgfe ifllk wh{jh Zyek{f bkllfz}fekllkkckc

kdjhw fjklbfwk, ifllk wh{jh wfkb f}yfwkcjf ikykcgk phyzk olhc phyzklfykc lef ihyhacjhc bvhm

zvzvlbhw nkik fkzlk {czfblfy jclfiklky#

$i+ [fck wfklfgfe ZIBB.jf hch{hwh {hpb hlbhlhycc kle hhbhwc olvzvybhe qfyf,

jhdh cgf oljveh ihhyl fekljf v{nvlhcb ivlvchc, iky )Phyzklfy Hyhw Vqlhbh Eobkw{ocv)cvc

evyvlbhw {fykcjf olhghezy# Hch{hwhcc zoplvbjh bbec oljvvcgh nl iky o{jhbh{h

jh{hcbhw, pdfwkq, hch{hwhcc jfboeyhzke bfyvlvvcv }f kwzkeyhyc fzeklf{fc cfblk iky

mhezyjy# Iv Eobkw{och ZIBB.jf nyviv ivlvchc izc phyzklfy fkz wh{jh zfbwklgk klf ehzlbhl

}f hlbhlhyc zhbhblhbhw kkc, ifllk iky wyf }fyklbflkjky# Eobkw{ocjh o{ikylkk evyhl

v{nvlhcbhbhl }f Eobkw{ocvc vlhz wocvlhy ZIBB Nfcfl Evyvlv hwcjhc ihlh{g

olbhbhljy# Hewk dhljf, hlbhlhyc, {fck iky hch{hwh {hpb klf jfkl, bf}gvz hch{hwhjh

ckwpfzfc zlk ikyzheb eoqbfzke jfkkelkelfylf wocvlhcbhw zfdlkefwk bf}gvzzvy#

$g+ hlbhlhyh, ZIBB.jf zfbwkl fjklbf{fc wk{hw phyzklfykc, wk}kl zoplvb evyvlvlhycc }f

vqbhclhyc ehzlbhw, jhdh nfck iky zoplvbwhl vqlhbh }f o{jhbhcc whlhcbhw hwcjhc

cfblkjky# Eobkw{oclhyjh vqbhclhyc }f jkfy klnklklfykc jkclfcbfwk, ivnc jf qhbhc qhbhc

nylfc iky v{nvlhbh olbhelh ikylkezf, eocvcvc cfbk }f qfllkk cfjfck{lf, Phyzklfy Hyhw V{vb

Eobkw{ocv }f Hch{hwh Eobkw{ocv hlbhlhycjh iv v{nvlhbhcc oe jhdh nfck hpzh

nfyfelfzkyklfiklbfwk kkc, ZIBB zqcf iv {oljh deblfykc felfcbfwk {hyhyl olhghezy#

$+ ZIBB.jfek ehivl ovclvv cf olvywh olwvc, ehivl fjklfc bfzckc dhleo{lhbhwch

wvcvlbhw, ocvc jfboeyhzke bfyvlvvcvc nlfcjkyklbfwk hwcjhc nfyfelkjky#

$j+ Hch{hwh {hpb wyfgkckc nfyfe hclhbjh dy }f jfboeyhzke iky oyzhbjh {yzlfiklbfwk

kkc, ihwc, kmhjf }f wk{hw ynzlfcbf dyyk{fzlfyk qfykcjfek hjh f}yfcwfl jfboeyhzke coyblhyh

h{ey ewzlhbhlhy, {fck ZIBB.ckc mhhlk{fzf nfbfwk{lf ikylkezf, wyhzlf ehljylbhljy# Wk{hw

phyzklfyf klkekc {hwhelhyh hhjh h{ygh jfkcklfgfezky#

KK# [fck Hch{hwh{h Dekb Olbhw Nfyfefc Zfbfl leflfy

[fck Hch{hwh{h dekb olbhw nfyfefc zfbfl kleflfy ikkb }f kfyke ihebcjhc jffylfcjkyklfiklky#

Ikkb hwcjhc Ihlhcn }f jfkzkyklfbfq bhjjf deblfykcf, kfyke hwcjhc klnklk zfbfl

kleflfy ihebcjhc iky jffylfcjkybf {hpbhe bbecjy#


41/58

:8

Ihlhcn $Jkihgf+

[fck Hch{hwhjh iky Ihlhcn ilbcf {fy }fyklbfwk dhlkcjf, ivcvc, kfyke ihebcjhc

bf}gvz 8;49 Hch{hwhwcc Ihlhcn bfzckcjfc zhbhbfc mhyel }f dhzzh 8;=8 Hch{hwhwcc

Ihlhcn bfzckcjfc jf jhdh mhyel iky kfykf whdkp olbhw hyzzy# Iv jfkkelke, {fck Hch{hwhcc,

nfyfezfc .{fck. olbh wmhzcc jh cfblk vcwvylhycjhc ikykck olvzvyhghezy#

[fck Hch{hwhcc zfbfl mflwfmfwkck, jf}lfzk olvzvyhc kcwhc vcwvyvcvc qnygf efcjk nflfgfkck

zh{kc fzbfwkcf }vynv {hphc iky qfbkcjf zhcblhbhe, 8;49 Hch{hwhwcjh {hplj nkik, jf}lfzkc

}f jf}lfz h{nzlhycc evzwhll, {gflkk {h jh n}fclkk fwhwch jh{hchc iky {cflkbjfc

vqhelhbhe kkc cfblk iky ihlhcn dhzz olvzvyhghezy# Iv ihlhbjh, Hch{hwhcc, kcwhc ocvyv

}f ikyf{kc qfyelkk hclh{ kkcjf, kcwhc dhe }f qnylelfykckc eoyvcbhwc hbhlh{hc iky

fwhwh jh{hcjcc Ihlhcn ewbcjh }vynvlhcbhw, cgfek Hch{hwhlhylh hyhwcjhek iv

zfbfllfcjkybf mhyellc kmhjf fzbfckc hch vcwvylhy hyhwcjh ehivl fjklbflkjky#

Iv ewbjh, dfydhcnk iky kjfoloak yfmfyhcwcjhc ehclbhw, dhe }f qnylelfyf jh{hchc

kcwhc dhelhy yfakbk ehjhy jfboeyhwk kleflfyk ihebcjhc jh nfyfelkjky# Iv ihlhbjh olbhe

qfyf, iky .bkllk{fzklke. hzm, chwl zhcblhcywh zhcblhcwc, Hch{hwhcc }f jf}lfzkc ckzflkelfykcf

klkekc kjfoloake iky ehivl eocvwv olbhbhl, i{lf iky wocvgh {h jh hln{h {olhhiklfgfe iky

zfygkd, jkl }f zfybkcoloakckc, Hch{hwh.cc Ihlhcn bfzck }f bhjjf deblfyk hyhwcjh {fy

hlbhbhwch qfc nwzfyklbflkjky# Iv {helhb, Ihlhcn bfzckckc, mhyel fwhw }f zhcblhyh hzmfc

jlh{g {h jh zoplvbwhl ilcbf hlnw {hyhzhghe iky jklk zfygkd fzbfwk {fykcf eh}yh{g iky jklk

}vynvlhbhwcc, jfboeyhzke iky zoplvbjh hwl hyqv fjklfc dfjfm olbhw ihebcjhc jh cfb

zhy# H{c ihlhbjh, Ihlhcn bfzckcjf, Hzhzyelf iky }vynv {hplbhwcjhc qk{hjf, Bvwzhmh

Efbhl Hzhzye.c hdwk{fzkcf {cflke iky eyhc {h jh bkccfz kmhjfwk }f{h Gvbdvyk{fz.kc evyvlv

wyfgkcf jhky iky }vynv klf {fzkcklbfwk iv fwhwlh zflkmk ehikl wh{lhiklky#

Ihlhcn bfzckcjf, kcwhc dhelhy, jfboeyhwk }f dvevevc wzcl nkik jffylfykc f}yfcwfl

iky jkllf kmhjf fjklbfwk, {fck iky Hch{hwhcc .{fcklke. wmhzch whdkp olbhw hwcjhc jh cfb

zh{hghe iky dvwvwzvy# Ivnc, hyze joh }f f}yfckc eoyvcbhw khycc jh, ekk dhe }f

qnylelfyk hwcjhc oljvv ehjhy jf}lfzkc evyvgv vcwvylhycc zbcc oyzhe ph{jhwc

olvzvyhc iky jffy olhyhe, Hch{hwhcc Ihlhcn ewbcjh {fy ivlbhw nfyfeky#

fykk i{lf iky klefwfl fyf}fjf iflkylfcfc Ihlhcn bfzckckc }fgkq }f ewh olbhw,

jfboeyhzke iky zfhbl {hcwzz ehjhy, Hch{hwhcc, hwl bhjjf deblfykcjf }hyle ivlbhwifelfcfc, hch n}jfwkck nlnfjf iyhebh{hghe iky wk{hwk }f dvevek zfygkdkc kmhjfwk olbh

ehyhezfyk{lf jf helhchiklky# [fck Hch{hwhjh, Ihlhcn ewbcc Hch{hwh bfzckcf jdkl olbhw

nkik iky debf {fy }fyklbf{fiklky#


42/58

:9

Jfkzkyklfbfq Bhjjf Deblfyk

Hch{hwhlhyjh, klfykjf bvzlheh jfkzkyklfbf{fgfe ckzflkezf bhjjf deblfykcf {fy }fybfe

nkik iky evyhl ivlvcbv{oy# Hcghe, ivch klkekc mhyel lef ycfelfykcjf jf oljvv nkik, Hch{hwhlhyjh

iv wzhz{f whdkp bhjjf deblfykcf jf {fy }fyklfiklk{oy# Iv eocvjh, Zyek{f ihebcjhc hwl

cfb zh{hc dvwvw, bf}gvz Hch{hwhjhek )Zyek{f Jf}lfzk iky Gvbdvyk{fzzky) ikkbkcjf kmhjffjklfc )Jf}lfzkc felk) ihlel jfkzkyklfbfq bhjjf debcc $b# 8+ h{cfc eoyvcbhwjy#

Zfbfl leflfy

[fck Hch{hwh{h dekb olbhw nfyfefc zfbfl kleflfy eocvwv, {vehyjh zfbhw fjklfc ikkbf

klkekc ihq ihlelhyh phyhlfl olhyhe, kfyke ihebcjhc jh jffylfcjkyklfiklky# Iv eocv{h klkekc

iky ewbch Ihlhcn bfzck ihlhbcjh jh {fy }fyklfc }f ikyfy zfbfl klef eocvwv olhc

jffylfcjkybflfyf $ycfkc lhkelke }f ekblke eocvlhy+, iv hlbhcc jkfy ihlelhy hlzcjh

jhdh h{yczl olhyhe {fy }fykljkk kkc ivyhjh h{ygh jffylfcjkyklbf{fgfezky# Hcghe, .Zfbfl

leflfy. ihlhbcjh ewhgh, v fwhwlhy jhdklkcjf iky fyf}f kqklbfwk bbecjy1 Hch{hwhcc,

kcwhc ocvyv }f ikyf{kc qfyelkk hclh{ kkcjf, dfyefwkc ikyf{wfl {h jh eollfezkm olhyhe evllhclhghe

dhelhy wh{fwkcjf efcjk nflfgfkck qnygf iflkylf{fiklfgfk iky kcwhc dhelhych jh{hchc jf}lfz

khych whdkp olbhw, lhkelke fwhwch v{nvc iky jqfc cnybfwk, dveve jf}lfzk {h jh dvevevc

wzcl klefwkck fwhw hlbhw, ev}}fzlfy h{yl fwhwch jh{hchc ovlgv }f jhdh ehzlbg iky

phylhbfczfy yfakbk nlfcjkybf{k dfjfmlfbfwk, kjhyfckc k{k {cfzkkb $nooj no}fychcgf+ kleflfykcf

v{nvc iky klf{k jqfckcf whdkp olbhwc }vynvlhbhw }f dhe hlhclhych wh{n{ nlfcjkykgk iky

wow{hl jf}lfz bojflkck khy fjkcbfwk, {fck Hch{hwhcc whdkp olbhw nfyfefc zfbfl kleflfykc

hchdhzlhyc kmhjf fjfy#

[fck Hch{hwhcc Ihlhcn ewb }f jfkzkyklfbfq bhjjf deblfyk ihlhbcjh jh ewbfc

zfbhw fjkljkk nkik, ikyf{wfl }f eollfezkm dhe }f qnylelfy wh{fwkcjf jf}lfzk olvzvyhc kcwhc

vcwvyvcvc efcjk nflfgfkck qnygf zh{kc fjfiklfgfk ikkb }f kfykezf iky Hch{hwh jcgfwk,

dhqylhchghe {fck Hch{hwh bfzckcjf fwhw hlcbhljy# Iv wh{fjf, ikyf{kc qfyelke hlhccc, jf}lfz

h{nzlhy ehywcjh oljvv ehjhy jf}lfz j hezylfyjfc eh{chelhchiklfgfe zfdjkzlfyf ehy jh

eoyvcbv olbhw, ivncc kcwhc dhelhy jcgfwkckc jf fwhwc olvzvyvy# Ivcv }vynvlh{hyhe,

jf}lfzkc ckzflkelfykcf klkekc bhjjf debcjf, .kcwhc dhelhych jh{hchc iky jf}lfz. olbh khycc

{fckjfc ghclhcjylbhw }f .dvevevc wzclcf jh{hchc. iky jf}lfz olbh khycc kwf jhdh

fzeklk elcbhw nfyfeky# [fck Hch{hwhjh {fy }fyklfgfe zfbfl dhe }f qnylelfyf klkekc dvevek

fyf}fckc ehpwhb, hhjh h{y iky ihle hlzcjh, jhdh h{yczl olhyhe flf jffylfcjkyklfgfezky#

[fck Hch{hwhjh, Hch{hwh eo{vgvcvc zfygkd fzzkk {cjf, ifllk iky feocobke bojfl zhcb

{hplbhw v{nvc olbh{hghezy# Qkyh, lefjfek feocobke jqfckc zfygkdk eocvwv jh, hwlcjh

lefjf {hh{hc kcwhc zoplvlvvcvc efcjk nflfgfkckc zh{kck ihlhbcjh jffy zh{hc iky

dvwvwzvy# Iv cfjfclf, iky dhe }f qnyle eocvwvjvy# Hcghe, iv qnyle yfakbkckc jfboeyhzke

iky zoplvbjh }hyl zhyzlbh{hghe fekljf, fkzlke }f hjhlfz kleflfyk cjh jffylfcjkyklbfwk

jf hyzzy#


43/58

:7

[fck Hch{hwhjh, phylhbfczfy yfakbjfc }hqnfklbfbflkjky# Phylhbfczfy yfakb, ihehcle }f

{hy"ihehcle yfakblfykcf chqhyhc, jhdh klfy iky jfboeyhwkckc dh{hz ivlbhwch mywhz }fyky# [fck

Hch{hwhcc, 8;49 Hch{hwhwcjhc mhyel olhyhe, jhdh ovlgv iky phylhbfczfy yfakbk nfyfelfzkybfwkcf

fl}fyklk jfkkelkelfykc {hplbhw hyzzy#

[fck Hch{hwhjh, jf}lfzkc zfbfl oynhclhy hyhwcjh ev}}fzlfy h{yl klefwkckc eoyvcbhw hyzzy#8;49 Hch{hwhwcc {yzbf }f kjhyf{k, jf}lfzkc jkfy oynhclhy ehywcjh hjfzh jhdh wzc elhc

iky nyf} }f {fzek jhlbch whdkp olbhw {fck Hch{hwhjh {fckjfc jqfclfcbf{f bvdzh iky

eocvjvy# Ehlj ek, {fck iky Hch{hwhcc, 8;49 Hch{hwhwcjhc fwhwfc jhdh mhyel iky jqfc

cnybfwkckc fc cfblk {hpwhl vcwvylhycjhc ikykwk jf iv {cjf iky jfkkb olhghezy#

8;49 Hch{hwhw, Gvbdvyihehccc nyf} }f {fzeklfykck phylhbfczfy iky yfakblf ihjhbh{hghe

ljf nfcklfzbkzky# Gvbdvyihehccc joyvjhc joyv{h dhle zhyhmcjhc wfklbfwkcf olhche

}fyfc jfkkelkezfc wocyh jhdh jh nlfcfc Gvbdvyihehcl bhehb, klfykjf bvdzfbfl iky

wk{hwk ivchlbc ebhwc jh clfbfe nfyfefwk{lf, {fck Hch{hwhjh phylhbfczfy iky yfakbf

v{nvc nyf} }f {fzeklfyf whdkp elcbhljy#

Ev}}fzlfy h{yl klefwkckc klfylke ehqhcbhwcjh cfblk iky mocewk{ocv {fykcf nfzkyfc )jfcnf

}f jfcfzkb) $gdfgew hcj ihlhcgfw+ bfehckqbhlhych {fck Hch{hwhjh jh {fy }fyklbfwkcjf mh{jh

}hyjy# Iv wh{fjf, ev}}fzlfy h{yl fwhwch jh{hchc iky jfboeyhwkjf, jf}lfzkc zfbfl oynhclhy

hyhwcjhek klkeklfykc }f klf{kkc jfcfzkbk, whjfgf {hyncc {fzek hlhcch iyhelbhelh {fzkcklbfbk

olvy# Iv {helhblh, jf}lfzkc oynhclhy hyhwcjh oljvv ehjhy ikyf{lfy }f kjhyf hyhwcjh jh

v{vbhqlelhyc qb klf}kck {fykcf nfzkyfc hlzfychzkm {ollhy }f {hplhy olvzvyvlbhwcjh mh{jh

}hyjy# Dhlfc {hwhbh wyfgkcjf ivlvchc Ehbv Jfcfzklkk Evyvbv, Vlvwhl cwhc Dhelhy Evyvbv

}f{h h{ybglelh bghjflfckc zhekik }f jfcfzkbkcf klkekc {hplhy jh h{c fyf}fjf jffylfcjkyklbfwk

bbec klf}lfy {fykcf nfzkykylfy# Hcghe, iv nkik {hplhyc {fck iky Hch{hwhcc efcjk klefwfl

izcl kkcjfek eocvblhy, zfeklzlhcbh }f klf{k ikkblfykcf jhky fwhwlhy }f ivclhyc klnklk

vlvwlhyhyhw dveve wzhcjhyzlhych v{nvc iky ikkbjf zhwhylhcb olbhlhy ehjhy, dhqylhchghe

{fck Hch{hwhcc zfbfl kleflfyk{lf v{vb kkcjf olbhlhyc jh nfyfezkyky# Iv hbhlh, cgflkkc

{fck Hch{hwh dhqylhcbhwch }fyklbfwk }f iflkyzklfc dvevek jqfclfbflfykc jhdh wocyh Hch{hwh

bfzck{lf v{vblv iky ikkbjf dhqylhcbhw nkik iky polkzkehcc ifckbwfcbfwk jhdh v{nvc olhghezy#

Ifcqfyk iky whecgh jvyvbv iheh hjhc jh efcjkck nwzfyfiklky1 [fck iky Hch{hwhcc

dhqylhcbhw {ccjf iky zoplvbwhl zhlfp }f ifelfczkckc wq eocvwv oljvv iky jcfbjf, nfcfl

olhyhe, ihq oynhcke ehcvclhyc ehivl fjklbfwk nkik iky {hwhbh polkzkehwcc wyjylbfwk, klfykjf{fck Hch{hwhcc dhqylch jhky hlbhlhyc ihlhbhw }f Hch{hwhcc ehivl dhlkcjf, dvevek

}f wk{hwk pyqlfykc jobhwch cfjfc olhiklfgfezky#

Iklnk fjkcbf dhee, 9080 {lcjh {hplhc Hch{hwh jfkkelkk{lf Hch{hwhl iky dhe olhyhe

zhccbzy# Ivcvc }f jkfy ikyf{wfl dhe }f jfcfzkb bfehckqbhlhycc klfylkk ihebcjhc cfb


44/58

::

zh{hc, kjhyfckc dhcnk vwvlk fwhwlhyh ihl olhyhe mhhlk{fzzf ivlvchghch jhky dvwvwlhy iky {hwhl

jqfclfbfckc eocvwvcv olvzvyvy# Hcghe, k{k {cfzkkb klefwkcf jffy }fyfc hjh ehbv

{cfzkbk polkzkehlhy joyvlzvwvcjh, kjhyfckc fmmhml }f dfwhp }fyfiklkylkk nkik v{nvlhbhlhyh

n ehqhcjyhghe jfboeyhzke fwhwlhyh jh {fck Hch{hwhjh {fy }fyklbfwk nfyfeky#

jhyfckc evyvlv }f nyf}lfyk ihlhbcjh, {fykcjfc {cfzkb $hjfb"k bfyefqk{fz+ fwhwccivncecf chqhyhc jhdh nlfcjkyklbfwk, hjh jfboeyhwklfyf qn iky ehbv {cfzkbk bojflk

olbhwcc {hc wyh, {fyfl ehzlb nlfcjkyfc iky dhe eocvwv olhyhe jh jffy zhbhezhjy# Iv

eocv, h{ygh, hqcle"ovclve klkeklfykcf ihl ekblke polkzkehlhy ihlhbcjh jh cfb zh{hc,

iv polkzkehlhyc jfboeyhzke iky zoplvbjh {yzlbfwkckc {hpwhl vcwvylhycjhc ikykwkjky# [fck

Hch{hwhjh iv {cjf {hplhghe iky jfkkelkkc iv dvwvwv jh jkeehzf hlbhwcjh mh{jh }hyjy#

[fck Hch{hwhjh dveve jf}lfzk {h jh dvevevc wzcl klefwkcf whje ehlcbhw nfyfeky#

Iv ihlhbjh, kjhyfckc dfy zyl klfb }f f{lfbkckc {hyn jfcfzkbkcf zik olbhw fwhwcc, 8;49

Hch{hwhwcjh {fy }fyklfc kwzkwchlhy ehljylhyhe {h{nclhzylbhw }f nlfcjkyklbfwkcf kdzk{h

}hyjy# jhyfckc {hyn ehyhylhyc {fykcf nfzkybfwkcjf, iv fwhw fzeklk elbh{h {cflke ihq dvevek

zfjikylfyf Hch{hwhjh {fy }fyklbfwk nfyfeky#

Wow{hl jf}lfz klefwkcf {fck Hch{hwhjh {fy }fyklbfwk hyzzy# Hcghe, wow{hl jf}lfz klefwkckc,

wow{hl }f feocobke dhelhyc zhccbhwch jhky Hch{hwhl dhe }f qnylelfy ehzfnoykwk cjh

}f iv dhe ehzfnoykwkcf klkekc vlvwlhyhyhw kcwhc dhelhy wzhcjhyzlhy jkeehzf hlchyhe, dhcnk dvevek

}f mkklk nlfcjkybf $fbpo~fybfcz+ bfehckqbhlhy wh{fwkcjf dh{hzk{fz ehqhchgh dvwvwv jh

helelh iflkyzklbflkjky#

KKK# Zfbfl Dhe }f qnylelfy

[fck Hch{hwhcc, kcwhc ocvyv }f ikyf{kc qfyelkk hclh{ kkcjf, kcwhc dhe }f qnylelfykckc

eoyvcbhwc hbhlh{hc iky fwhwh jh{hcj debcf {fy }fyklbfwk, Hch{hwhjh {fy }fyklfgfe

dhe }f qnylelfy yfakbk ihebcjhc cfblk iky ihlhcn dhzz olvzvyhghezy# Iv ihle hlzcjh

kcgflfcbfwk nfyfefc ihq eocvlhy $Jkc }f ]kgjhc Dyyk{fzk, Ekblke Woyvclhy, Wk{hwk Phyzklfy

Yfakbk+ jh, woc zhdlkljf zfbfl dhe }f qnylelfy ihl hlzcjh jffylfcjkyklfiklky# Hcghe, o

eocvlhyh, iv hlbhjh h{y ihlelhy hlzcjh {fy }fyklbfwk jhdh v{nvc ivlvcbvzvy#

Iky zfykb eocvwvch zfbhw fjfyfe ihlhbhe nfyfekywf, .zfbfl dhe }f qnylelfy. zfykbkckc

evllhclbhw cfjfck{lf, dhe }f qnylelfy hyhwcjh .zfbfl ckzflkezf olhc. }f .zfbfl ckzflkezfolbh{hc. nkik iky h{yb {hplj kqlfckbk jobhbhljy# Qkyh, Zyek{f.ckc jf jdkl oljvv

vlvwlhyhyhw kcwhc dhelhy yfakbk fyf}fwkcjf, zb dhe }f qnylelfy h{c jffyjf iky izcjy,

hyhlhycjh iky cgflke {h jh wzcle klkekwk {oezvy }f ehylel iky fzeklfkbf whdkp oljvelhy

hclh{ch v{nvc olhyhe, iky izcwfllke kkcjf wh{n nwzfyklfyfe v{nvlhcbhljy#


45/58

:6

Zfbfl Dhe }f qnylelfykc Dvevek Hclhb

Ikylfbk Bkllfzlfy jqfckckc evyvlbhw klf ikylkezf, dfyefwkc zfbfl dhe }f qnylelfyjfc fkz

olhyhe mh{jhlhcbhw klefwkckc zhccbhw }f v{nvlhcbhw iky .kcwhc dhelhy yfakbk. ihlhbcjh

}hyle ivlbvzvy# I{lf iky yfakbkc bhcz, ekkckc oe mhyel mhezylfyf ihl olhyhe oyzh{h

ehiklfgfe nyfgf qh{mlcc dveve wh{fwkcjf nkjfyklbfwk }f dfy zy klkeklfykcjf, ocvc ikyekk olhyhe eocvbvcvc .nlfcjkyklbfwk. $fbpo~fybfcz+ fwhwch jh{hcy# Ivnc, kcwhc dhelhy

dvevevcvc zfbfl eocv }f hbhg jh iv fwhw qfykcf ikch fjklbk ehivl fjklky# Iv cfjfclf, {fck

Hch{hwhjh {fy }fyklfgfe zfbfl dhe }f qnylelfykc i{lf iky dvevek }f wk{hwk kyhjfckc wocvgv

oljvv, Hch{hwh bfzckcjf pdf nfyfezkybf{fgfe iky helezh oyzh{h eocvlbhljy#

Zfbfl Dhe }f qnylelfykc Zhccbhw }f Zhwckmk

Hch{hwhcc Ihlhcn }f jfkzkyklfbfq bhjjf deblfyk ihlhbcjh jh oljvv nkik, zfbfl

dhe }f qnylelfyf }fyklfc jffykc }vynvlhcbhw cfblk iky Hch{hwhl jfkkb vcwvyv olhghezy#

I{lf iky ihlhcn dhzzcjhc dhyfefzlf, ivnc kcwhc dhelhy dvevevcvc zfbfl vcwvylhyc kmhjf

fjfc iky dvevek fyf}fjf, dhe }f qnylelfykc zhccbhw, eoyvcbhw, nflkzkyklbfwk }f ivclhyh

{fy }fyfc Hch{hwh }f jkfy dveve coyblhych ykh{fz fjklbfwk jwzvyv {fck Hch{hwhjh jh {fy

ivlbhljy#

Zyek{f.ckc woc kek Hch{hwhwcjh {fy }fyklfc dhe }f qnylelfy, iky jfkkelke kdzk{hg efwkc

olbhelh ikylkezf, bfjfck, wk{hwk, wow{hl }f feocobke dhe ehzfnoyklfykckc zhccjc oyzh{h eo{hy#

Zyek{f, ivclhyh phyhlfl olhyhe, elzyfl dhelhyh jh {fy }fyfc ihq vlvwlhyhyhw kcwhc dhelhy

hcjlhbhlhych jh zhyhm olbv, hcghe nfyfe 8;49 Hch{hwhwcjh nfyfe {hplhc Hch{hwh

jfkkelkelfykcjf iv dhelhyh klkekc qfl iky jfkkelke debcf jf {fy }fyklbk jfkljky# Iv

cfjfclf, {fck Hch{hwhjh, iv dhe ehzfnoykwkcf jf {fy }fyklbfwk kle efq wq eocvwv olhghezy#

Iv dhe ehzfnoykwk ihlhbcjh {fy hlhc dhelhyc, h{c qhbhcjh Zyek{f.ckc hqcle }f ovclve

polkzkehlhy ihlhbcjh ihnwzfyfc ihq zfbfl wow{hl }f wk{hwk woyvclhy{lh ihlhczl eocvlhyh

klkekc oljvv jh iky nfyfezky# Iv cfjfclf, iv woyvclhyc qbcjf cfblk dvevek fcwzybhclhy

olhiklbflfyk olhwl jh jkeehzf hlchyhe, iv ehzfnoyk dhelhyh jh Hch{hwhjh {fy }fyklbfwk jhdh

jh cfb ehqhcbzy#

zf {hcjhc, ivnc dhqylhchghe iky Hch{hwhjh {fy }fyklfgfe dhelhyc whjfgf vlvwlhyhyhw

kcwhc dhelhy hcjlhbhlhycc iky kqjb olbhw {h jh whjfgf jhdh cgfek Hch{hwhlhybqjh

zhccb dhe }f qnylelfylf wcyl ehivl fjklbfwk nkik iky {helhbjhc ehclbhwcjh jh {hyhy}hyjy# Dhe }f qnylelfyf klkekc vlvwlhyhyhw hlhcjh zhccb dveve wzhcjhyzlhy, ikyfy bkckbvb

wzhcjhyz ckzflkkcjf dveve evyhllhyjy# Jolh{w{lh, zhcchc }f eoyvchc bfcmhhzf klkekc hwnhyk

lcc bkckbvb wcyc iflkyzkylfy# Mhehz iv wcyc qfykcjf iky eoyvbh zhcb {hpbhe ehjhy,

dhe }f qnylelfy {flphqfwkck nfcklfzkgk iky wk{hwk kyhjf{k oyzh{h eo{bhe jh jf}lfzlfykc kezkjhy

jdklkcjfjky# Ehlj ek, ivnc, jfboeyhzke iky zoplvb olbh lz klf ihjhy ckzflkezf .{fck.


46/58

:=

iky Hch{hwh dhqylhcbhwcjh, jkfy vcwvylhyc }hylc nqfzbfckc {hc wyh, i{lf iky kyhjf{f

}vynv {hpljc oyzh{h eo{bhcc jh jffyk i{ezy#

Iv ihlhbjh, f}yf dhee, fmmhm iky kjhyk klf{kzfc {hyhylhcbh }f k{k {cfzkkb dhee, ivncc

kmhjf }f klfzkkb olhchelhy cjh iky jcgf }f kmhjf qnyl, }kgjhck yfz dhee, ogvvc

dhelhy, hqcle dhelhy, wow{hl }f feocobke dhelhyc eyfwfllfbfckc fzekwk hlzcjh olbhlhy ehjhyh{c qhbhcjh ikyfy zfbfl dhe }f qnyle olbh ehyhezfylfyk jf nqccjf zvzvlhyhe whjfgf

pk{hwh eovllhych ihl iky jqfc zhcb kkcjf zhccbhbhw, }i# nkik zfbfl dhe }f qnyle

hlhclhych }f {helhbch jh Hch{hwh hzw hlzcjh {fy }fybfckc dh{hzk cfbk nqccjf

zvzvlbhljy#

I{lf iky kyhjfckc {fck Hch{hwhjh {fy ivlbhw, zhyb }f dh{}hcglc eoyvcbhw, fwchm }f

whchzeylhyc eoyvcbhw, nfclkkc eoyvcbhw, wpoyvc nflkzkyklbfwk, whchzc }f whchzcc

eoyvcbhw, oybhc e{lwcc eoyvcbhw, eoopfyhzkmklkkc nflkzkyklbfwk, }i# ckzflkezf .eoyvbh.

deblfykcf {fck Hch{hwhjh jh {fy }fyklbfwk hclhbch nflbfbfezfjky# Iv wh{lhc }f{h ifcqfyk

eocvlhyjhek hwl .eoyvbh. hbhgcc, iv mhhlk{fzlfyf klkekc zfbfl dhe }f qnylelfy hlhccc

nl }f fzeklk iky ikkbjf eoyvcv{oy olbhw klf whlhchghcc jkeehzf hlcbhw nfyfeky#

H{c {helhb zhyq, 8;49 Hch{hwhwcjhek kmhjfwk{lf, )Jf}lfzkc kezkwhjk }f wow{hl jf}lfykckc

wcylhy) $b# =6+ ihl

Documents

TÜSİAD - Yeni Anayasa Yuvarlak Masa Toplantıları Dizisi (Yeni Anayasanın Beş Temel Boyutu)