View
224
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 148
MEDITERRANEAN PAPER SERIES 2011
TURKEY AND THE ARAB SPRING
IMPLICATIONS FOR TURKISH FOREIGN POLICY
FROM A TRANSATLANTIC PERSPECTIVE
Nathalie Tocci
Oumlmer Taşpınar
Henri J Barkey
Eduard Soler i Lecha
Hassan Nafaa
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 248
copy 2011 Te German Marshall Fund o the United States All rights reserved
No part o this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any orm or by any means without permission in writing
rom the German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF) Please direct inquiries to
Te German Marshall Fund o the United States
1744 R Street NW
Washington DC 20009
1 202 683 2650
F 1 202 265 1662
E inogmusorg
Tis publication can be downloaded or ree at wwwgmusorgpublications Limited print
copies are also available o request a copy send an e-mail to inogmusorg
GMF Paper SeriesTe GMF Paper Series presents research on a variety o transatlantic topics by sta ellows and partners o the German
Marshall Fund o the United States Te views expressed here are those o the author and do not necessarily represent the
views o GMF Comments rom readers are welcome reply to the mailing address above or by e-mail to inogmusorg
About GMF
Te German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF) is a non-partisan American public policy and grantmaking institu-
tion dedicated to promoting better understanding and cooperation between North America and Europe on transatlantic
and global issues GMF does this by supporting individuals and institutions working in the transatlantic sphere by conven-
ing leaders and members o the policy and business communities by contributing research and analysis on transatlan-
tic topics and by providing exchange opportunities to oster renewed commitment to the transatlantic relationship In
addition GMF supports a number o initiatives to strengthen democracies Founded in 1972 through a gi rom Germany
as a permanent memorial to Marshall Plan assistance GMF maintains a strong presence on both sides o the Atlantic In
addition to its headquarters in Washington DC GMF has seven oces in Europe Berlin Paris Brussels Belgrade Ankara
Bucharest and Warsaw GMF also has smaller representations in Bratislava urin and Stockholm
About the Mediterranean Policy ProgramTe Mediterranean Policy Program promotes transatlantic analysis and dialogue on issues aecting Southern Europe North
Arica the Levant and the Mediterranean basin Priority areas include understanding trends in Mediterranean societies
exploring opportunities or south-south cooperation and integration research on key unctional issues aecting Mediter-ranean security and development and strengthening the North American policy debate on the region and transatlantic
cooperation on Mediterranean strategy
About Istituto Affari InternazionaliTe Istituto Aari Internazionali (IAI) ounded by Altiero Spinelli in 1965 does research in the elds o oreign policy
political economics and international security A non-prot organization the IAI aims to disseminate knowledge through
research studies conerences and publications o that end it cooperates with other research institutes universities and
oundations in Italy and abroad and is a member o various international networks More specically the main research
sectors are European institutions and policies Italian oreign policy trends in the global economy and internationalization
processes in Italy the Mediterranean and the Middle East deense economy and policy and transatlantic relations Te IAI
puts out an English-language quarterly (Te International Spectator ) an online webzine ( AfarInternazionali) a series o
research papers (Quaderni IAI) and an Italian oreign policy yearbook (La Politica Estera dellrsquoItalia)
Cover photo Palestinian students hold the pictures o urkish Prime Minister Recep ayyip Erdogan and the urkish andPalestinian fags during rally beckoning him to visit the Gaza Strip at the port in Gaza City on Sep 13 2011
copy Ashra AmraZUMA PressCorbis
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 348
Turkey and the Arab SpringImplications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a
Transatlantic Perspective
Mediterranean Paper Series
october 2011
N T Ouml Tşı H J B3 E S L4 H N5
D I A I (IAI) R
S F T B I W DC
3 B B C P I R L U
4 R F CIDOB (B C I A)
5 P P S C U
F
N T 3
T T M A
Oumlmr Tşpınr 7
C R A R T T A
Hnr J Brky 15
T EU T A S F P A J S
Edurd Sr L 25
T T M M A S
Hssn Nf 35
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 448
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
3
ForewordNathalie Tocci
I NA M E B - A
q ( ) T ( ) - T P ZE A B A E P HM A M A B Y
j
T A S T T
I - A S T E U
(EU) U S T - T O T I S Iq I ( R A G) B T T A S rpk T W T PM T Eğ W H Mrsquo
-J F P A Guuml E S C E I E T T A A S rpk I L T NATOrsquo - x M G
O M 3 T Grsquo L S T P B -A T
W x I E T E T T T B L $5 T 5
T Trsquo I S 877 T-S S ( K q) T - q --
T A S Trsquoldquo rdquo T x S mdash S I L mdash T P M Eğ P A Y ( )
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States4
M I P M S BEğ G ( ) G
F A S Trsquo M E x Trsquo F M ADğrsquo W U S A Iq E x -US T I I S 8 I H 6 8 I M C H F A W A-I
T Trsquo (E S A) (U S) T T - M E ( Iq S W I) x I-A q
I - A S T I - M E T A C W T W M I 99
T S I B ( O) T x M M ET T U S I E U T M E
T A S ( ) S (T) ( E) ( M) ( L S Y B) W M E q T A A T
q US- TE- A I x A x ( x) I q
I T q R -- -W M T S W T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 748
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
5
D ( ) T H N I Ouml Tşı T M T I T O M j T I J D P O
T - T Y B Tşı N T - Eq H B T Trsquo
T A S
T I x T EU U S x T EU U S T EU EU T E S L I EU T
U L T T EU T ( CF S P H R ) WTrsquo () T 7
F EU-T T C F S P (CFSP) T EU T T EU CFSP T T
T ldquo rdquo EU
T T EU U S A S A EU ExA S (EAS) T S L W
EU-T - EU-T-US -
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 948
The Turkish Model and its Applicability
Ouml Tşı
T F P L A S 9
T T M A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1048
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
9
Turkish Foreign Policy in Lightof the Arab Spring1
T A S Trsquo U S I E U
Trsquo T G J mdash I T ( T-A) mdash Trsquo ldquordquo I U N(UN) S C A
T F A j ldquoH-H-I Irdquo
T A S A T E L W T I ldquo Trdquo I T A ldquoT rdquo A
M T E mdash mdash NATO L E S T A A W
Trsquo ME T Arsquo I Y W A q I ET Y L S A
T F ldquoL Irdquo Nw Yrk Tms J5
Trsquo I J D P (AKP)
I Trsquo A W j I-O K S AKP T A TOuml 98 T M I T AKPrsquo P M Eğrsquo A Dğ ldquo rdquo ldquo-rdquo Dğrsquo T M E N A
B E O S Trsquo - - O AKPrsquo ldquo-Ordquo
T -O T O T A T -O AKP
T Trsquo O M N-O T S I I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States10
N-O Trsquo Kq S T -O A K T R K x K R T q
T -O grndur - Trsquo T I -O A x ldquo rdquomdash mdash O T N-O T I
O B E A -O T ldquordquo S q - M
T -O W M L I E A -O J- B Ouml AGuuml Eğ Trsquo I W E I E U
-O
S AKP -O ME B E U T IndashP NATO A UN L O I C AL I Iq S A M E U NATOrsquo I AKPrsquo-O
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
11
The Turkish Model and the Arab Spring
2
T A S x -O T T
T A Y M E FM A Dğrsquo ldquo- rdquo S T - E
T M E A
U AKPrsquo -O A I E A Trsquo W AS Ersquo C
- A G T Trsquo A q
H T A T q T T T A US- I q M B E A Trsquo AKP I T ldquordquo ldquordquo I Y T
q T
I E T - I T A T R - K T 93 T x T H T I T q q T T D x E U U S A
L
T T T I O I O IA ldquordquo S I j T T W ldquorsn drsquoeacute rdquo I I
A TR Auuml
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
I P I T T q I T I T AKP I T I CC I I O
T AKP I S W P 99 NS P 98 C A C S TI
Y T I A I A T T I q Trsquo - 95 S
A 6 T
D I I x q
I I x T I x UldquoI rdquo MB I A T - 95 M A
I
A T x- T
E A I T
- ldquoA rdquo T A A Trsquo M x I S
T x T I
A TI S T TI x T Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 248
copy 2011 Te German Marshall Fund o the United States All rights reserved
No part o this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any orm or by any means without permission in writing
rom the German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF) Please direct inquiries to
Te German Marshall Fund o the United States
1744 R Street NW
Washington DC 20009
1 202 683 2650
F 1 202 265 1662
E inogmusorg
Tis publication can be downloaded or ree at wwwgmusorgpublications Limited print
copies are also available o request a copy send an e-mail to inogmusorg
GMF Paper SeriesTe GMF Paper Series presents research on a variety o transatlantic topics by sta ellows and partners o the German
Marshall Fund o the United States Te views expressed here are those o the author and do not necessarily represent the
views o GMF Comments rom readers are welcome reply to the mailing address above or by e-mail to inogmusorg
About GMF
Te German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF) is a non-partisan American public policy and grantmaking institu-
tion dedicated to promoting better understanding and cooperation between North America and Europe on transatlantic
and global issues GMF does this by supporting individuals and institutions working in the transatlantic sphere by conven-
ing leaders and members o the policy and business communities by contributing research and analysis on transatlan-
tic topics and by providing exchange opportunities to oster renewed commitment to the transatlantic relationship In
addition GMF supports a number o initiatives to strengthen democracies Founded in 1972 through a gi rom Germany
as a permanent memorial to Marshall Plan assistance GMF maintains a strong presence on both sides o the Atlantic In
addition to its headquarters in Washington DC GMF has seven oces in Europe Berlin Paris Brussels Belgrade Ankara
Bucharest and Warsaw GMF also has smaller representations in Bratislava urin and Stockholm
About the Mediterranean Policy ProgramTe Mediterranean Policy Program promotes transatlantic analysis and dialogue on issues aecting Southern Europe North
Arica the Levant and the Mediterranean basin Priority areas include understanding trends in Mediterranean societies
exploring opportunities or south-south cooperation and integration research on key unctional issues aecting Mediter-ranean security and development and strengthening the North American policy debate on the region and transatlantic
cooperation on Mediterranean strategy
About Istituto Affari InternazionaliTe Istituto Aari Internazionali (IAI) ounded by Altiero Spinelli in 1965 does research in the elds o oreign policy
political economics and international security A non-prot organization the IAI aims to disseminate knowledge through
research studies conerences and publications o that end it cooperates with other research institutes universities and
oundations in Italy and abroad and is a member o various international networks More specically the main research
sectors are European institutions and policies Italian oreign policy trends in the global economy and internationalization
processes in Italy the Mediterranean and the Middle East deense economy and policy and transatlantic relations Te IAI
puts out an English-language quarterly (Te International Spectator ) an online webzine ( AfarInternazionali) a series o
research papers (Quaderni IAI) and an Italian oreign policy yearbook (La Politica Estera dellrsquoItalia)
Cover photo Palestinian students hold the pictures o urkish Prime Minister Recep ayyip Erdogan and the urkish andPalestinian fags during rally beckoning him to visit the Gaza Strip at the port in Gaza City on Sep 13 2011
copy Ashra AmraZUMA PressCorbis
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 348
Turkey and the Arab SpringImplications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a
Transatlantic Perspective
Mediterranean Paper Series
october 2011
N T Ouml Tşı H J B3 E S L4 H N5
D I A I (IAI) R
S F T B I W DC
3 B B C P I R L U
4 R F CIDOB (B C I A)
5 P P S C U
F
N T 3
T T M A
Oumlmr Tşpınr 7
C R A R T T A
Hnr J Brky 15
T EU T A S F P A J S
Edurd Sr L 25
T T M M A S
Hssn Nf 35
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 448
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
3
ForewordNathalie Tocci
I NA M E B - A
q ( ) T ( ) - T P ZE A B A E P HM A M A B Y
j
T A S T T
I - A S T E U
(EU) U S T - T O T I S Iq I ( R A G) B T T A S rpk T W T PM T Eğ W H Mrsquo
-J F P A Guuml E S C E I E T T A A S rpk I L T NATOrsquo - x M G
O M 3 T Grsquo L S T P B -A T
W x I E T E T T T B L $5 T 5
T Trsquo I S 877 T-S S ( K q) T - q --
T A S Trsquoldquo rdquo T x S mdash S I L mdash T P M Eğ P A Y ( )
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States4
M I P M S BEğ G ( ) G
F A S Trsquo M E x Trsquo F M ADğrsquo W U S A Iq E x -US T I I S 8 I H 6 8 I M C H F A W A-I
T Trsquo (E S A) (U S) T T - M E ( Iq S W I) x I-A q
I - A S T I - M E T A C W T W M I 99
T S I B ( O) T x M M ET T U S I E U T M E
T A S ( ) S (T) ( E) ( M) ( L S Y B) W M E q T A A T
q US- TE- A I x A x ( x) I q
I T q R -- -W M T S W T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 748
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
5
D ( ) T H N I Ouml Tşı T M T I T O M j T I J D P O
T - T Y B Tşı N T - Eq H B T Trsquo
T A S
T I x T EU U S x T EU U S T EU EU T E S L I EU T
U L T T EU T ( CF S P H R ) WTrsquo () T 7
F EU-T T C F S P (CFSP) T EU T T EU CFSP T T
T ldquo rdquo EU
T T EU U S A S A EU ExA S (EAS) T S L W
EU-T - EU-T-US -
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 948
The Turkish Model and its Applicability
Ouml Tşı
T F P L A S 9
T T M A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1048
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
9
Turkish Foreign Policy in Lightof the Arab Spring1
T A S Trsquo U S I E U
Trsquo T G J mdash I T ( T-A) mdash Trsquo ldquordquo I U N(UN) S C A
T F A j ldquoH-H-I Irdquo
T A S A T E L W T I ldquo Trdquo I T A ldquoT rdquo A
M T E mdash mdash NATO L E S T A A W
Trsquo ME T Arsquo I Y W A q I ET Y L S A
T F ldquoL Irdquo Nw Yrk Tms J5
Trsquo I J D P (AKP)
I Trsquo A W j I-O K S AKP T A TOuml 98 T M I T AKPrsquo P M Eğrsquo A Dğ ldquo rdquo ldquo-rdquo Dğrsquo T M E N A
B E O S Trsquo - - O AKPrsquo ldquo-Ordquo
T -O T O T A T -O AKP
T Trsquo O M N-O T S I I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States10
N-O Trsquo Kq S T -O A K T R K x K R T q
T -O grndur - Trsquo T I -O A x ldquo rdquomdash mdash O T N-O T I
O B E A -O T ldquordquo S q - M
T -O W M L I E A -O J- B Ouml AGuuml Eğ Trsquo I W E I E U
-O
S AKP -O ME B E U T IndashP NATO A UN L O I C AL I Iq S A M E U NATOrsquo I AKPrsquo-O
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
11
The Turkish Model and the Arab Spring
2
T A S x -O T T
T A Y M E FM A Dğrsquo ldquo- rdquo S T - E
T M E A
U AKPrsquo -O A I E A Trsquo W AS Ersquo C
- A G T Trsquo A q
H T A T q T T T A US- I q M B E A Trsquo AKP I T ldquordquo ldquordquo I Y T
q T
I E T - I T A T R - K T 93 T x T H T I T q q T T D x E U U S A
L
T T T I O I O IA ldquordquo S I j T T W ldquorsn drsquoeacute rdquo I I
A TR Auuml
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
I P I T T q I T I T AKP I T I CC I I O
T AKP I S W P 99 NS P 98 C A C S TI
Y T I A I A T T I q Trsquo - 95 S
A 6 T
D I I x q
I I x T I x UldquoI rdquo MB I A T - 95 M A
I
A T x- T
E A I T
- ldquoA rdquo T A A Trsquo M x I S
T x T I
A TI S T TI x T Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 348
Turkey and the Arab SpringImplications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a
Transatlantic Perspective
Mediterranean Paper Series
october 2011
N T Ouml Tşı H J B3 E S L4 H N5
D I A I (IAI) R
S F T B I W DC
3 B B C P I R L U
4 R F CIDOB (B C I A)
5 P P S C U
F
N T 3
T T M A
Oumlmr Tşpınr 7
C R A R T T A
Hnr J Brky 15
T EU T A S F P A J S
Edurd Sr L 25
T T M M A S
Hssn Nf 35
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 448
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
3
ForewordNathalie Tocci
I NA M E B - A
q ( ) T ( ) - T P ZE A B A E P HM A M A B Y
j
T A S T T
I - A S T E U
(EU) U S T - T O T I S Iq I ( R A G) B T T A S rpk T W T PM T Eğ W H Mrsquo
-J F P A Guuml E S C E I E T T A A S rpk I L T NATOrsquo - x M G
O M 3 T Grsquo L S T P B -A T
W x I E T E T T T B L $5 T 5
T Trsquo I S 877 T-S S ( K q) T - q --
T A S Trsquoldquo rdquo T x S mdash S I L mdash T P M Eğ P A Y ( )
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States4
M I P M S BEğ G ( ) G
F A S Trsquo M E x Trsquo F M ADğrsquo W U S A Iq E x -US T I I S 8 I H 6 8 I M C H F A W A-I
T Trsquo (E S A) (U S) T T - M E ( Iq S W I) x I-A q
I - A S T I - M E T A C W T W M I 99
T S I B ( O) T x M M ET T U S I E U T M E
T A S ( ) S (T) ( E) ( M) ( L S Y B) W M E q T A A T
q US- TE- A I x A x ( x) I q
I T q R -- -W M T S W T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 748
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
5
D ( ) T H N I Ouml Tşı T M T I T O M j T I J D P O
T - T Y B Tşı N T - Eq H B T Trsquo
T A S
T I x T EU U S x T EU U S T EU EU T E S L I EU T
U L T T EU T ( CF S P H R ) WTrsquo () T 7
F EU-T T C F S P (CFSP) T EU T T EU CFSP T T
T ldquo rdquo EU
T T EU U S A S A EU ExA S (EAS) T S L W
EU-T - EU-T-US -
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 948
The Turkish Model and its Applicability
Ouml Tşı
T F P L A S 9
T T M A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1048
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
9
Turkish Foreign Policy in Lightof the Arab Spring1
T A S Trsquo U S I E U
Trsquo T G J mdash I T ( T-A) mdash Trsquo ldquordquo I U N(UN) S C A
T F A j ldquoH-H-I Irdquo
T A S A T E L W T I ldquo Trdquo I T A ldquoT rdquo A
M T E mdash mdash NATO L E S T A A W
Trsquo ME T Arsquo I Y W A q I ET Y L S A
T F ldquoL Irdquo Nw Yrk Tms J5
Trsquo I J D P (AKP)
I Trsquo A W j I-O K S AKP T A TOuml 98 T M I T AKPrsquo P M Eğrsquo A Dğ ldquo rdquo ldquo-rdquo Dğrsquo T M E N A
B E O S Trsquo - - O AKPrsquo ldquo-Ordquo
T -O T O T A T -O AKP
T Trsquo O M N-O T S I I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States10
N-O Trsquo Kq S T -O A K T R K x K R T q
T -O grndur - Trsquo T I -O A x ldquo rdquomdash mdash O T N-O T I
O B E A -O T ldquordquo S q - M
T -O W M L I E A -O J- B Ouml AGuuml Eğ Trsquo I W E I E U
-O
S AKP -O ME B E U T IndashP NATO A UN L O I C AL I Iq S A M E U NATOrsquo I AKPrsquo-O
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
11
The Turkish Model and the Arab Spring
2
T A S x -O T T
T A Y M E FM A Dğrsquo ldquo- rdquo S T - E
T M E A
U AKPrsquo -O A I E A Trsquo W AS Ersquo C
- A G T Trsquo A q
H T A T q T T T A US- I q M B E A Trsquo AKP I T ldquordquo ldquordquo I Y T
q T
I E T - I T A T R - K T 93 T x T H T I T q q T T D x E U U S A
L
T T T I O I O IA ldquordquo S I j T T W ldquorsn drsquoeacute rdquo I I
A TR Auuml
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
I P I T T q I T I T AKP I T I CC I I O
T AKP I S W P 99 NS P 98 C A C S TI
Y T I A I A T T I q Trsquo - 95 S
A 6 T
D I I x q
I I x T I x UldquoI rdquo MB I A T - 95 M A
I
A T x- T
E A I T
- ldquoA rdquo T A A Trsquo M x I S
T x T I
A TI S T TI x T Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 448
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
3
ForewordNathalie Tocci
I NA M E B - A
q ( ) T ( ) - T P ZE A B A E P HM A M A B Y
j
T A S T T
I - A S T E U
(EU) U S T - T O T I S Iq I ( R A G) B T T A S rpk T W T PM T Eğ W H Mrsquo
-J F P A Guuml E S C E I E T T A A S rpk I L T NATOrsquo - x M G
O M 3 T Grsquo L S T P B -A T
W x I E T E T T T B L $5 T 5
T Trsquo I S 877 T-S S ( K q) T - q --
T A S Trsquoldquo rdquo T x S mdash S I L mdash T P M Eğ P A Y ( )
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States4
M I P M S BEğ G ( ) G
F A S Trsquo M E x Trsquo F M ADğrsquo W U S A Iq E x -US T I I S 8 I H 6 8 I M C H F A W A-I
T Trsquo (E S A) (U S) T T - M E ( Iq S W I) x I-A q
I - A S T I - M E T A C W T W M I 99
T S I B ( O) T x M M ET T U S I E U T M E
T A S ( ) S (T) ( E) ( M) ( L S Y B) W M E q T A A T
q US- TE- A I x A x ( x) I q
I T q R -- -W M T S W T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 748
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
5
D ( ) T H N I Ouml Tşı T M T I T O M j T I J D P O
T - T Y B Tşı N T - Eq H B T Trsquo
T A S
T I x T EU U S x T EU U S T EU EU T E S L I EU T
U L T T EU T ( CF S P H R ) WTrsquo () T 7
F EU-T T C F S P (CFSP) T EU T T EU CFSP T T
T ldquo rdquo EU
T T EU U S A S A EU ExA S (EAS) T S L W
EU-T - EU-T-US -
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 948
The Turkish Model and its Applicability
Ouml Tşı
T F P L A S 9
T T M A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1048
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
9
Turkish Foreign Policy in Lightof the Arab Spring1
T A S Trsquo U S I E U
Trsquo T G J mdash I T ( T-A) mdash Trsquo ldquordquo I U N(UN) S C A
T F A j ldquoH-H-I Irdquo
T A S A T E L W T I ldquo Trdquo I T A ldquoT rdquo A
M T E mdash mdash NATO L E S T A A W
Trsquo ME T Arsquo I Y W A q I ET Y L S A
T F ldquoL Irdquo Nw Yrk Tms J5
Trsquo I J D P (AKP)
I Trsquo A W j I-O K S AKP T A TOuml 98 T M I T AKPrsquo P M Eğrsquo A Dğ ldquo rdquo ldquo-rdquo Dğrsquo T M E N A
B E O S Trsquo - - O AKPrsquo ldquo-Ordquo
T -O T O T A T -O AKP
T Trsquo O M N-O T S I I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States10
N-O Trsquo Kq S T -O A K T R K x K R T q
T -O grndur - Trsquo T I -O A x ldquo rdquomdash mdash O T N-O T I
O B E A -O T ldquordquo S q - M
T -O W M L I E A -O J- B Ouml AGuuml Eğ Trsquo I W E I E U
-O
S AKP -O ME B E U T IndashP NATO A UN L O I C AL I Iq S A M E U NATOrsquo I AKPrsquo-O
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
11
The Turkish Model and the Arab Spring
2
T A S x -O T T
T A Y M E FM A Dğrsquo ldquo- rdquo S T - E
T M E A
U AKPrsquo -O A I E A Trsquo W AS Ersquo C
- A G T Trsquo A q
H T A T q T T T A US- I q M B E A Trsquo AKP I T ldquordquo ldquordquo I Y T
q T
I E T - I T A T R - K T 93 T x T H T I T q q T T D x E U U S A
L
T T T I O I O IA ldquordquo S I j T T W ldquorsn drsquoeacute rdquo I I
A TR Auuml
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
I P I T T q I T I T AKP I T I CC I I O
T AKP I S W P 99 NS P 98 C A C S TI
Y T I A I A T T I q Trsquo - 95 S
A 6 T
D I I x q
I I x T I x UldquoI rdquo MB I A T - 95 M A
I
A T x- T
E A I T
- ldquoA rdquo T A A Trsquo M x I S
T x T I
A TI S T TI x T Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
3
ForewordNathalie Tocci
I NA M E B - A
q ( ) T ( ) - T P ZE A B A E P HM A M A B Y
j
T A S T T
I - A S T E U
(EU) U S T - T O T I S Iq I ( R A G) B T T A S rpk T W T PM T Eğ W H Mrsquo
-J F P A Guuml E S C E I E T T A A S rpk I L T NATOrsquo - x M G
O M 3 T Grsquo L S T P B -A T
W x I E T E T T T B L $5 T 5
T Trsquo I S 877 T-S S ( K q) T - q --
T A S Trsquoldquo rdquo T x S mdash S I L mdash T P M Eğ P A Y ( )
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States4
M I P M S BEğ G ( ) G
F A S Trsquo M E x Trsquo F M ADğrsquo W U S A Iq E x -US T I I S 8 I H 6 8 I M C H F A W A-I
T Trsquo (E S A) (U S) T T - M E ( Iq S W I) x I-A q
I - A S T I - M E T A C W T W M I 99
T S I B ( O) T x M M ET T U S I E U T M E
T A S ( ) S (T) ( E) ( M) ( L S Y B) W M E q T A A T
q US- TE- A I x A x ( x) I q
I T q R -- -W M T S W T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 748
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
5
D ( ) T H N I Ouml Tşı T M T I T O M j T I J D P O
T - T Y B Tşı N T - Eq H B T Trsquo
T A S
T I x T EU U S x T EU U S T EU EU T E S L I EU T
U L T T EU T ( CF S P H R ) WTrsquo () T 7
F EU-T T C F S P (CFSP) T EU T T EU CFSP T T
T ldquo rdquo EU
T T EU U S A S A EU ExA S (EAS) T S L W
EU-T - EU-T-US -
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 948
The Turkish Model and its Applicability
Ouml Tşı
T F P L A S 9
T T M A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1048
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
9
Turkish Foreign Policy in Lightof the Arab Spring1
T A S Trsquo U S I E U
Trsquo T G J mdash I T ( T-A) mdash Trsquo ldquordquo I U N(UN) S C A
T F A j ldquoH-H-I Irdquo
T A S A T E L W T I ldquo Trdquo I T A ldquoT rdquo A
M T E mdash mdash NATO L E S T A A W
Trsquo ME T Arsquo I Y W A q I ET Y L S A
T F ldquoL Irdquo Nw Yrk Tms J5
Trsquo I J D P (AKP)
I Trsquo A W j I-O K S AKP T A TOuml 98 T M I T AKPrsquo P M Eğrsquo A Dğ ldquo rdquo ldquo-rdquo Dğrsquo T M E N A
B E O S Trsquo - - O AKPrsquo ldquo-Ordquo
T -O T O T A T -O AKP
T Trsquo O M N-O T S I I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States10
N-O Trsquo Kq S T -O A K T R K x K R T q
T -O grndur - Trsquo T I -O A x ldquo rdquomdash mdash O T N-O T I
O B E A -O T ldquordquo S q - M
T -O W M L I E A -O J- B Ouml AGuuml Eğ Trsquo I W E I E U
-O
S AKP -O ME B E U T IndashP NATO A UN L O I C AL I Iq S A M E U NATOrsquo I AKPrsquo-O
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
11
The Turkish Model and the Arab Spring
2
T A S x -O T T
T A Y M E FM A Dğrsquo ldquo- rdquo S T - E
T M E A
U AKPrsquo -O A I E A Trsquo W AS Ersquo C
- A G T Trsquo A q
H T A T q T T T A US- I q M B E A Trsquo AKP I T ldquordquo ldquordquo I Y T
q T
I E T - I T A T R - K T 93 T x T H T I T q q T T D x E U U S A
L
T T T I O I O IA ldquordquo S I j T T W ldquorsn drsquoeacute rdquo I I
A TR Auuml
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
I P I T T q I T I T AKP I T I CC I I O
T AKP I S W P 99 NS P 98 C A C S TI
Y T I A I A T T I q Trsquo - 95 S
A 6 T
D I I x q
I I x T I x UldquoI rdquo MB I A T - 95 M A
I
A T x- T
E A I T
- ldquoA rdquo T A A Trsquo M x I S
T x T I
A TI S T TI x T Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States4
M I P M S BEğ G ( ) G
F A S Trsquo M E x Trsquo F M ADğrsquo W U S A Iq E x -US T I I S 8 I H 6 8 I M C H F A W A-I
T Trsquo (E S A) (U S) T T - M E ( Iq S W I) x I-A q
I - A S T I - M E T A C W T W M I 99
T S I B ( O) T x M M ET T U S I E U T M E
T A S ( ) S (T) ( E) ( M) ( L S Y B) W M E q T A A T
q US- TE- A I x A x ( x) I q
I T q R -- -W M T S W T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 748
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
5
D ( ) T H N I Ouml Tşı T M T I T O M j T I J D P O
T - T Y B Tşı N T - Eq H B T Trsquo
T A S
T I x T EU U S x T EU U S T EU EU T E S L I EU T
U L T T EU T ( CF S P H R ) WTrsquo () T 7
F EU-T T C F S P (CFSP) T EU T T EU CFSP T T
T ldquo rdquo EU
T T EU U S A S A EU ExA S (EAS) T S L W
EU-T - EU-T-US -
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 948
The Turkish Model and its Applicability
Ouml Tşı
T F P L A S 9
T T M A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1048
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
9
Turkish Foreign Policy in Lightof the Arab Spring1
T A S Trsquo U S I E U
Trsquo T G J mdash I T ( T-A) mdash Trsquo ldquordquo I U N(UN) S C A
T F A j ldquoH-H-I Irdquo
T A S A T E L W T I ldquo Trdquo I T A ldquoT rdquo A
M T E mdash mdash NATO L E S T A A W
Trsquo ME T Arsquo I Y W A q I ET Y L S A
T F ldquoL Irdquo Nw Yrk Tms J5
Trsquo I J D P (AKP)
I Trsquo A W j I-O K S AKP T A TOuml 98 T M I T AKPrsquo P M Eğrsquo A Dğ ldquo rdquo ldquo-rdquo Dğrsquo T M E N A
B E O S Trsquo - - O AKPrsquo ldquo-Ordquo
T -O T O T A T -O AKP
T Trsquo O M N-O T S I I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States10
N-O Trsquo Kq S T -O A K T R K x K R T q
T -O grndur - Trsquo T I -O A x ldquo rdquomdash mdash O T N-O T I
O B E A -O T ldquordquo S q - M
T -O W M L I E A -O J- B Ouml AGuuml Eğ Trsquo I W E I E U
-O
S AKP -O ME B E U T IndashP NATO A UN L O I C AL I Iq S A M E U NATOrsquo I AKPrsquo-O
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
11
The Turkish Model and the Arab Spring
2
T A S x -O T T
T A Y M E FM A Dğrsquo ldquo- rdquo S T - E
T M E A
U AKPrsquo -O A I E A Trsquo W AS Ersquo C
- A G T Trsquo A q
H T A T q T T T A US- I q M B E A Trsquo AKP I T ldquordquo ldquordquo I Y T
q T
I E T - I T A T R - K T 93 T x T H T I T q q T T D x E U U S A
L
T T T I O I O IA ldquordquo S I j T T W ldquorsn drsquoeacute rdquo I I
A TR Auuml
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
I P I T T q I T I T AKP I T I CC I I O
T AKP I S W P 99 NS P 98 C A C S TI
Y T I A I A T T I q Trsquo - 95 S
A 6 T
D I I x q
I I x T I x UldquoI rdquo MB I A T - 95 M A
I
A T x- T
E A I T
- ldquoA rdquo T A A Trsquo M x I S
T x T I
A TI S T TI x T Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 748
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
5
D ( ) T H N I Ouml Tşı T M T I T O M j T I J D P O
T - T Y B Tşı N T - Eq H B T Trsquo
T A S
T I x T EU U S x T EU U S T EU EU T E S L I EU T
U L T T EU T ( CF S P H R ) WTrsquo () T 7
F EU-T T C F S P (CFSP) T EU T T EU CFSP T T
T ldquo rdquo EU
T T EU U S A S A EU ExA S (EAS) T S L W
EU-T - EU-T-US -
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 948
The Turkish Model and its Applicability
Ouml Tşı
T F P L A S 9
T T M A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1048
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
9
Turkish Foreign Policy in Lightof the Arab Spring1
T A S Trsquo U S I E U
Trsquo T G J mdash I T ( T-A) mdash Trsquo ldquordquo I U N(UN) S C A
T F A j ldquoH-H-I Irdquo
T A S A T E L W T I ldquo Trdquo I T A ldquoT rdquo A
M T E mdash mdash NATO L E S T A A W
Trsquo ME T Arsquo I Y W A q I ET Y L S A
T F ldquoL Irdquo Nw Yrk Tms J5
Trsquo I J D P (AKP)
I Trsquo A W j I-O K S AKP T A TOuml 98 T M I T AKPrsquo P M Eğrsquo A Dğ ldquo rdquo ldquo-rdquo Dğrsquo T M E N A
B E O S Trsquo - - O AKPrsquo ldquo-Ordquo
T -O T O T A T -O AKP
T Trsquo O M N-O T S I I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States10
N-O Trsquo Kq S T -O A K T R K x K R T q
T -O grndur - Trsquo T I -O A x ldquo rdquomdash mdash O T N-O T I
O B E A -O T ldquordquo S q - M
T -O W M L I E A -O J- B Ouml AGuuml Eğ Trsquo I W E I E U
-O
S AKP -O ME B E U T IndashP NATO A UN L O I C AL I Iq S A M E U NATOrsquo I AKPrsquo-O
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
11
The Turkish Model and the Arab Spring
2
T A S x -O T T
T A Y M E FM A Dğrsquo ldquo- rdquo S T - E
T M E A
U AKPrsquo -O A I E A Trsquo W AS Ersquo C
- A G T Trsquo A q
H T A T q T T T A US- I q M B E A Trsquo AKP I T ldquordquo ldquordquo I Y T
q T
I E T - I T A T R - K T 93 T x T H T I T q q T T D x E U U S A
L
T T T I O I O IA ldquordquo S I j T T W ldquorsn drsquoeacute rdquo I I
A TR Auuml
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
I P I T T q I T I T AKP I T I CC I I O
T AKP I S W P 99 NS P 98 C A C S TI
Y T I A I A T T I q Trsquo - 95 S
A 6 T
D I I x q
I I x T I x UldquoI rdquo MB I A T - 95 M A
I
A T x- T
E A I T
- ldquoA rdquo T A A Trsquo M x I S
T x T I
A TI S T TI x T Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 948
The Turkish Model and its Applicability
Ouml Tşı
T F P L A S 9
T T M A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1048
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
9
Turkish Foreign Policy in Lightof the Arab Spring1
T A S Trsquo U S I E U
Trsquo T G J mdash I T ( T-A) mdash Trsquo ldquordquo I U N(UN) S C A
T F A j ldquoH-H-I Irdquo
T A S A T E L W T I ldquo Trdquo I T A ldquoT rdquo A
M T E mdash mdash NATO L E S T A A W
Trsquo ME T Arsquo I Y W A q I ET Y L S A
T F ldquoL Irdquo Nw Yrk Tms J5
Trsquo I J D P (AKP)
I Trsquo A W j I-O K S AKP T A TOuml 98 T M I T AKPrsquo P M Eğrsquo A Dğ ldquo rdquo ldquo-rdquo Dğrsquo T M E N A
B E O S Trsquo - - O AKPrsquo ldquo-Ordquo
T -O T O T A T -O AKP
T Trsquo O M N-O T S I I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States10
N-O Trsquo Kq S T -O A K T R K x K R T q
T -O grndur - Trsquo T I -O A x ldquo rdquomdash mdash O T N-O T I
O B E A -O T ldquordquo S q - M
T -O W M L I E A -O J- B Ouml AGuuml Eğ Trsquo I W E I E U
-O
S AKP -O ME B E U T IndashP NATO A UN L O I C AL I Iq S A M E U NATOrsquo I AKPrsquo-O
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
11
The Turkish Model and the Arab Spring
2
T A S x -O T T
T A Y M E FM A Dğrsquo ldquo- rdquo S T - E
T M E A
U AKPrsquo -O A I E A Trsquo W AS Ersquo C
- A G T Trsquo A q
H T A T q T T T A US- I q M B E A Trsquo AKP I T ldquordquo ldquordquo I Y T
q T
I E T - I T A T R - K T 93 T x T H T I T q q T T D x E U U S A
L
T T T I O I O IA ldquordquo S I j T T W ldquorsn drsquoeacute rdquo I I
A TR Auuml
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
I P I T T q I T I T AKP I T I CC I I O
T AKP I S W P 99 NS P 98 C A C S TI
Y T I A I A T T I q Trsquo - 95 S
A 6 T
D I I x q
I I x T I x UldquoI rdquo MB I A T - 95 M A
I
A T x- T
E A I T
- ldquoA rdquo T A A Trsquo M x I S
T x T I
A TI S T TI x T Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 948
The Turkish Model and its Applicability
Ouml Tşı
T F P L A S 9
T T M A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1048
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
9
Turkish Foreign Policy in Lightof the Arab Spring1
T A S Trsquo U S I E U
Trsquo T G J mdash I T ( T-A) mdash Trsquo ldquordquo I U N(UN) S C A
T F A j ldquoH-H-I Irdquo
T A S A T E L W T I ldquo Trdquo I T A ldquoT rdquo A
M T E mdash mdash NATO L E S T A A W
Trsquo ME T Arsquo I Y W A q I ET Y L S A
T F ldquoL Irdquo Nw Yrk Tms J5
Trsquo I J D P (AKP)
I Trsquo A W j I-O K S AKP T A TOuml 98 T M I T AKPrsquo P M Eğrsquo A Dğ ldquo rdquo ldquo-rdquo Dğrsquo T M E N A
B E O S Trsquo - - O AKPrsquo ldquo-Ordquo
T -O T O T A T -O AKP
T Trsquo O M N-O T S I I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States10
N-O Trsquo Kq S T -O A K T R K x K R T q
T -O grndur - Trsquo T I -O A x ldquo rdquomdash mdash O T N-O T I
O B E A -O T ldquordquo S q - M
T -O W M L I E A -O J- B Ouml AGuuml Eğ Trsquo I W E I E U
-O
S AKP -O ME B E U T IndashP NATO A UN L O I C AL I Iq S A M E U NATOrsquo I AKPrsquo-O
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
11
The Turkish Model and the Arab Spring
2
T A S x -O T T
T A Y M E FM A Dğrsquo ldquo- rdquo S T - E
T M E A
U AKPrsquo -O A I E A Trsquo W AS Ersquo C
- A G T Trsquo A q
H T A T q T T T A US- I q M B E A Trsquo AKP I T ldquordquo ldquordquo I Y T
q T
I E T - I T A T R - K T 93 T x T H T I T q q T T D x E U U S A
L
T T T I O I O IA ldquordquo S I j T T W ldquorsn drsquoeacute rdquo I I
A TR Auuml
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
I P I T T q I T I T AKP I T I CC I I O
T AKP I S W P 99 NS P 98 C A C S TI
Y T I A I A T T I q Trsquo - 95 S
A 6 T
D I I x q
I I x T I x UldquoI rdquo MB I A T - 95 M A
I
A T x- T
E A I T
- ldquoA rdquo T A A Trsquo M x I S
T x T I
A TI S T TI x T Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1048
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
9
Turkish Foreign Policy in Lightof the Arab Spring1
T A S Trsquo U S I E U
Trsquo T G J mdash I T ( T-A) mdash Trsquo ldquordquo I U N(UN) S C A
T F A j ldquoH-H-I Irdquo
T A S A T E L W T I ldquo Trdquo I T A ldquoT rdquo A
M T E mdash mdash NATO L E S T A A W
Trsquo ME T Arsquo I Y W A q I ET Y L S A
T F ldquoL Irdquo Nw Yrk Tms J5
Trsquo I J D P (AKP)
I Trsquo A W j I-O K S AKP T A TOuml 98 T M I T AKPrsquo P M Eğrsquo A Dğ ldquo rdquo ldquo-rdquo Dğrsquo T M E N A
B E O S Trsquo - - O AKPrsquo ldquo-Ordquo
T -O T O T A T -O AKP
T Trsquo O M N-O T S I I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States10
N-O Trsquo Kq S T -O A K T R K x K R T q
T -O grndur - Trsquo T I -O A x ldquo rdquomdash mdash O T N-O T I
O B E A -O T ldquordquo S q - M
T -O W M L I E A -O J- B Ouml AGuuml Eğ Trsquo I W E I E U
-O
S AKP -O ME B E U T IndashP NATO A UN L O I C AL I Iq S A M E U NATOrsquo I AKPrsquo-O
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
11
The Turkish Model and the Arab Spring
2
T A S x -O T T
T A Y M E FM A Dğrsquo ldquo- rdquo S T - E
T M E A
U AKPrsquo -O A I E A Trsquo W AS Ersquo C
- A G T Trsquo A q
H T A T q T T T A US- I q M B E A Trsquo AKP I T ldquordquo ldquordquo I Y T
q T
I E T - I T A T R - K T 93 T x T H T I T q q T T D x E U U S A
L
T T T I O I O IA ldquordquo S I j T T W ldquorsn drsquoeacute rdquo I I
A TR Auuml
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
I P I T T q I T I T AKP I T I CC I I O
T AKP I S W P 99 NS P 98 C A C S TI
Y T I A I A T T I q Trsquo - 95 S
A 6 T
D I I x q
I I x T I x UldquoI rdquo MB I A T - 95 M A
I
A T x- T
E A I T
- ldquoA rdquo T A A Trsquo M x I S
T x T I
A TI S T TI x T Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
9
Turkish Foreign Policy in Lightof the Arab Spring1
T A S Trsquo U S I E U
Trsquo T G J mdash I T ( T-A) mdash Trsquo ldquordquo I U N(UN) S C A
T F A j ldquoH-H-I Irdquo
T A S A T E L W T I ldquo Trdquo I T A ldquoT rdquo A
M T E mdash mdash NATO L E S T A A W
Trsquo ME T Arsquo I Y W A q I ET Y L S A
T F ldquoL Irdquo Nw Yrk Tms J5
Trsquo I J D P (AKP)
I Trsquo A W j I-O K S AKP T A TOuml 98 T M I T AKPrsquo P M Eğrsquo A Dğ ldquo rdquo ldquo-rdquo Dğrsquo T M E N A
B E O S Trsquo - - O AKPrsquo ldquo-Ordquo
T -O T O T A T -O AKP
T Trsquo O M N-O T S I I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States10
N-O Trsquo Kq S T -O A K T R K x K R T q
T -O grndur - Trsquo T I -O A x ldquo rdquomdash mdash O T N-O T I
O B E A -O T ldquordquo S q - M
T -O W M L I E A -O J- B Ouml AGuuml Eğ Trsquo I W E I E U
-O
S AKP -O ME B E U T IndashP NATO A UN L O I C AL I Iq S A M E U NATOrsquo I AKPrsquo-O
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
11
The Turkish Model and the Arab Spring
2
T A S x -O T T
T A Y M E FM A Dğrsquo ldquo- rdquo S T - E
T M E A
U AKPrsquo -O A I E A Trsquo W AS Ersquo C
- A G T Trsquo A q
H T A T q T T T A US- I q M B E A Trsquo AKP I T ldquordquo ldquordquo I Y T
q T
I E T - I T A T R - K T 93 T x T H T I T q q T T D x E U U S A
L
T T T I O I O IA ldquordquo S I j T T W ldquorsn drsquoeacute rdquo I I
A TR Auuml
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
I P I T T q I T I T AKP I T I CC I I O
T AKP I S W P 99 NS P 98 C A C S TI
Y T I A I A T T I q Trsquo - 95 S
A 6 T
D I I x q
I I x T I x UldquoI rdquo MB I A T - 95 M A
I
A T x- T
E A I T
- ldquoA rdquo T A A Trsquo M x I S
T x T I
A TI S T TI x T Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States10
N-O Trsquo Kq S T -O A K T R K x K R T q
T -O grndur - Trsquo T I -O A x ldquo rdquomdash mdash O T N-O T I
O B E A -O T ldquordquo S q - M
T -O W M L I E A -O J- B Ouml AGuuml Eğ Trsquo I W E I E U
-O
S AKP -O ME B E U T IndashP NATO A UN L O I C AL I Iq S A M E U NATOrsquo I AKPrsquo-O
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
11
The Turkish Model and the Arab Spring
2
T A S x -O T T
T A Y M E FM A Dğrsquo ldquo- rdquo S T - E
T M E A
U AKPrsquo -O A I E A Trsquo W AS Ersquo C
- A G T Trsquo A q
H T A T q T T T A US- I q M B E A Trsquo AKP I T ldquordquo ldquordquo I Y T
q T
I E T - I T A T R - K T 93 T x T H T I T q q T T D x E U U S A
L
T T T I O I O IA ldquordquo S I j T T W ldquorsn drsquoeacute rdquo I I
A TR Auuml
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
I P I T T q I T I T AKP I T I CC I I O
T AKP I S W P 99 NS P 98 C A C S TI
Y T I A I A T T I q Trsquo - 95 S
A 6 T
D I I x q
I I x T I x UldquoI rdquo MB I A T - 95 M A
I
A T x- T
E A I T
- ldquoA rdquo T A A Trsquo M x I S
T x T I
A TI S T TI x T Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
11
The Turkish Model and the Arab Spring
2
T A S x -O T T
T A Y M E FM A Dğrsquo ldquo- rdquo S T - E
T M E A
U AKPrsquo -O A I E A Trsquo W AS Ersquo C
- A G T Trsquo A q
H T A T q T T T A US- I q M B E A Trsquo AKP I T ldquordquo ldquordquo I Y T
q T
I E T - I T A T R - K T 93 T x T H T I T q q T T D x E U U S A
L
T T T I O I O IA ldquordquo S I j T T W ldquorsn drsquoeacute rdquo I I
A TR Auuml
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
I P I T T q I T I T AKP I T I CC I I O
T AKP I S W P 99 NS P 98 C A C S TI
Y T I A I A T T I q Trsquo - 95 S
A 6 T
D I I x q
I I x T I x UldquoI rdquo MB I A T - 95 M A
I
A T x- T
E A I T
- ldquoA rdquo T A A Trsquo M x I S
T x T I
A TI S T TI x T Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States12
I P I T T q I T I T AKP I T I CC I I O
T AKP I S W P 99 NS P 98 C A C S TI
Y T I A I A T T I q Trsquo - 95 S
A 6 T
D I I x q
I I x T I x UldquoI rdquo MB I A T - 95 M A
I
A T x- T
E A I T
- ldquoA rdquo T A A Trsquo M x I S
T x T I
A TI S T TI x T Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
13
FGuuml A x EU T F - K q j EU T T
T x T
A T ldquordquo A T A A G su gnrs T A x
I T A q Y T A W A S T EU U S ET M J Y
U Trsquo EU Y EU U S W T O (WTO) NATOrsquoP P U M (UM)
A - T M G8 $ A S j T S - C EU T EU-T
T A S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1748
Coordinating Responses to the 2011 Arab RevoltTurkey and the Transatlantic Alliance
H J B
I 7
T M 8
T P M
3 T L
4 W C D C R D B 3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 1948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
17
T A rsquo T
I A T M E J D Prsquo (AKP) P M R T Eğ A Dğ
A
I T x x q x T T Eğ x ldquo
rdquo Trsquo F S j I x ()
T T - ldquo- rdquo T L S q ldquo rdquo x A L S
N T M EC M E q A mdash mdash I q W H Trsquo
I
T x Trsquo T ME A
Introduction
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States18
Turkey as a Model
1
O A T - x T AKP T x T
Trsquo M E x T - S A I Iq AKP - K R G(KRG) K Iq
T
AKPrsquo - rsquo T T T T
I Trsquo
M E - T T I AKP T rsquo
F J D P (AKP)
W rsquo I I EU- 4 I UN S C 3 US
Iq - T AKP K T 93
B 7 AKP T q TAKP Trsquo I-
S L H R I-H I AKPrsquo I T Eğ M E
A - T H - x- 98 T Ouml T T rsquo 6 G A x I I T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
19
NATO EU I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States20
K T E M K Auuml 938 K I F N W W II S U T -
T j W M R mdash 946 95 mdash NATO
T T 96 x
ldquordquo T 96 Prsquo x I I F ( ) T 96
T
A T j E C E U q T K
A T R T
I ME x AKP I T mdash mdash E-W C T A
T q T C T T su gnrs Trsquo - - q x x A M
T 98 N T
W Trsquo I T W W II CW S T 979 q 98- rsquoeacute T Oumlrsquo T 997 ldquo-rdquo E K -
The Path and the Model
2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
21
rsquo A 7 - FM A Guumlrsquo j AKP Eğ T A A
O T T 98 j T T j
T E j EU I T E T I K ME
T - 979 T T 98 Ouml T T Ouml T 98 99 Y T Ouml T T T
I A- - T AKPrsquo T Oumlrsquo AKP
Oumlrsquo rsquo T I AKP T 997 IW P- - T P P j I Eğ T AKP Trsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States22
B x T 98 x $ x I -x
T T x 8 A
T T T E x U S NATO EU E x T Ersquo T T U S
T T A
T T j x
H T x T T M ldquordquo T -AKP T
E T E 95
x
I E q G A Nrsquo
q W E J E T A S K x G S Trsquo x x
x x
I T E
The Lessons
3
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
23
Trsquo
T EU I Ersquo I
N - - x - x
M T T R D B A E U S E T - T eacutemgreacute
I T I x - -A
T T j T T () x T
What Can be Done Contemplatinga Regional Development Bank4
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2648
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2748
The EU Turkey and the Arab SpringFrom Parallel Approaches to a Joint Strategy
E S L
I 7
A C N P A 8
F EUrsquo C G 9
3 U Trsquo Z-P A 3
4 T N C D D R 3
5 P S J-A 3
6 C 34
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 2948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
27
A q ldquoASrdquo N A M E T
E U (EU) T A susqu n A Cq E T q x
W T EU j - - I A B E x
H T EU A
I EU-T A x
S D N Gouml ldquoErsquo N- C T Irdquo On Turky srs GMFUS M 8 C G ldquoA EUrdquoCnr fr Eurpn Rfrm Py Brf M KB ldquoW EU T N C TF Prdquo Crng Endwmn fr Inrnn PC A 3 H G SUuml ldquoT rdquo Eurpn V A
Introduction
EU-T EU-T T EU-T EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States28
A Common NeighborhoodParallel Approaches1
B EU T x M F
M EU T EU M M E
MM T ME I
- ldquo- rdquo Trsquo
E T Trsquo
Ursquo -E H T EU A
T A S T EU x T A x
T EU rsquo T
S x EUrsquo EN P Frsquo ( Z E-A BArsquo Lrsquo ) Trsquo S W T EU - F S T F j
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
29
Filling the EUrsquos Credibility Gap
2
T EU T E
I E L EU j L x UNS C 973 ldquo Erdquo T F I x
EU E 3
A E E ldquo rdquo EN P (ENP) T C Ex A S
(euro ) EU 4 I EU
T B () ldquoA S E Srdquo BEPA Mny Brf I 46 A
3 D K () ldquoC M Ersquo A Srdquo Eurpn Cun n Frgn R-ns M
4 T E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enm nd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgn A Prnr-sp fr Dmry nd Srd Prspry w Surn
Mdrrnn COM () E C- () Jn Cmmunn Eurpn Cun Eurpn Prmn Cun Eurpn Enmnd S Cmm nd Cmm f Rgns A nwrspns ngng Ngburd Brusss M 5 COM () 33
C S F E E D D C FT A D MM S EU M P
A EUrsquo ldquoM Prdquo x 5 T Crsquo x x EUrsquo H U -
S - x E C J3-4
A S I EU G Ursquo S I EU Crsquo EUrsquo A S x M
5 S N T () ldquoT EU A S A (M) O R E N Prdquo EurMSCBrf R B () ldquoT A S M EU rdquoEurpn Py Cnr brf J E S L E V () ldquoR E N- P rdquoNs Inrnns CIDOB 36 B CIDOB
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States30
Updating Turkeyrsquos Zero-ProblemApproach3
I EU Trsquo E T -
T E Mrsquo T Trsquo A Trsquo 6 I - E T
L S AKP G A T T - - T 7
I Arsquo L S S Trsquo
I L 5 T L Arsquo A T q NATO M F F-T Prsquo LN T C
6 O T A M
Aışı () ldquoT A Prdquo Frgn PySrs I TESEV Aışı A T A ldquo A T A rdquo M A T
7 S P T ldquoH S L G B Trsquo Hrdquo TIME A 3
T L
T S x S Trsquo M E O T S
H L Trsquo A rsquo S Trsquo A T T S S T Eğ Guuml T T - A A
ldquo- rdquo AKPrsquo x 8 I Eğrsquo J T T Trsquo 9
8 S Ouml Tşı ldquoZ P W TSrdquo Tdyrsquos Zmn A 5
9 S S Guuml ldquoM rdquoT Nw Yrk Tms J 6
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
31
The Need for Cooperation Despitea Difficult Relationship4
T EU T T
j A EU V EU T B EU T
j T EU-T
EU-T A C F P Trsquo T Trsquo EU C EU-P x
M C L I I T EU EU - T
F - T EU M E B EU-Trpprmn EU-NATO EU C S D
T C T AT x EU EU-W B
P M N M E EU T j A B ( P B) -
U ldquoB rdquo T NATO EU C S D P Trsquo j C EU-NATO EU-NATO
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States32
Pushing for Specific Joint-Actions
5
W EU-T
EU T MR T ldquo rdquo EUrsquo j Trsquo EU ( Ex A S) T q-
T EU CU
E EU T Trsquo T Trsquo EU T
bull d - Trsquo ( S)
bull - Trsquo E D A T EU T - EU-NATO
bull
S E EU M Trsquo M F A F T j
B Loacute EU A
bull DEVCO-EA TIKA (T C A) P P U TIKA E C
bull T CS F E E
D Trsquo Trsquo A T EU I
F EU T
bull j EUH R C F S P (CFSP) TF A M B L C Srsquo T B S Eğrsquo
I K T P M ldquoT A Srdquo (Tdyrsquos Zmn M 3) Trsquo A ldquo M B- E -Nd M T H P rdquo ldquoA- E T rdquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
33
bull
j ( S)
bull L Trsquox Iq T EU
j Lrsquo R Lrsquo j L
bull j S S R - x T EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States34
Conclusion
6
T EU T j
MT x - -
C x EU-T E-M T EU-T j M E R q x H
EU T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3748
The ldquoTurkish Modelrdquoin the Mirror of the Arab Spring1
H N
I 37
T A ldquoT Mrdquo 39
T A S P D 4
3 T T M Wrsquo I C E
R 43
T A E G D
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3848
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 3948
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
37
Introduction
T A Z E-A B A T H
M E M G L T x A S Y W A G T x
A
Y A A x S rsquo I
q A S I T A I J D P (AKP) T
G U S EU T I
W q T A W
B q ldquordquoI - I I - W E x
S - j ldquordquo I x
I x I
AKPrsquo x T lsquorsquo A U AKPrsquo x T N x x lsquorsquo lsquorsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4048
The German Marshall Fund of the United States38
I AKPrsquo x A ) AKPrsquo x ) A AKPrsquo x ) U S EU T x A
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4148
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
39
The Appeal of the ldquoTurkish modelrdquo
1
S O E q W-
-I T H AKP T - j T Trsquo AKP j
bull Stabilityanddemocracy P T x rsquo S T x 96 97 98 997 NE S- j
AKP T rsquo T Trsquo - E I- Trsquo j
j
bull Identityandalienation F T
T - E I- -I T AKP Trsquo I x j
bull Developmentandmodernization Trsquo H AKP G N P $3 $75 8 $33 $ A T T
6
6
Ebull Dependencyandanonautonomousrole
T W I Trsquo - AKPrsquo T T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4248
The German Marshall Fund of the United States40
U A T T
A Z E-A B A I E G Ersquo rsquo H Mrsquo G A T
A LY B S
D A W A W
A S Ersquo A E J 5R
TheEgyptianRevolutionasaModel
I E
bull T E - - q T
Ersquo ldquo rdquo I
bull A D -
K 4 (
) ldquoN x rdquo A6 ( ) M rsquo A6 8 E C AS 9 j ldquo--rdquo
NA C F E-Brsquo E T J 5 ldquoW A K Srdquo F ER
bull T j j T E R Mrsquo E T
The Arab Spring and the Prospectsfor Democratization2
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4348
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
41
E j
bull I I j
bull T j T S
- N j
F E j
bull
rsquo
bull rsquo N D P (NDP) j
bull j
- Ersquo q
S x
T ldquo rdquo D I
T W I
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4448
The German Marshall Fund of the United States42
A q T I q mdash I j
W ldquoC Frdquo I ldquoEFrdquo x T rsquo j ) )
N j M I M
T - NDP D NDP A rsquo
T D
F S C A F(SCAF) TSCAF ) rsquo ) W SCAF
GM lsquorsquo
T x SCAF T
SCAF T SCAFrsquo
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4548
Turkey and the Arab Spring
Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy From a Transatlantic Perspective
43
The Turkish model between the WestrsquosInterest and the Concerns of theEgyptian Revolution
3
T Wrsquo T T
I I W I T W A H T
x I q x A W ErsquoI M B J D P (AKP) T I
T T Ersquo I
W -I T ) I ) E T x I j
T E I E S
I E T Ersquo I T T M B S S T AKP I mdash S A
M Brsquo J F P E
I Ersquo I T Trsquo Trsquo A-I A x AKP
T A Trsquo B Trsquo T
I T W Trsquo
j E C T EU I EU x
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4648
The German Marshall Fund of the United States44
T x j
D NATO - U S T j US q Iq 3 I A Iq Irsquo A W U S T R C W C A T A j Aj
Trsquo A-I A
x T I T I W T I S x Irsquo T S
S A Ersquo D WE F S P T Trsquo
I Irsquo T Mv Mrmr G
Ersquo lsquoT rsquo - Irsquo W Trsquo H x T I T A rsquo Trsquo A-I Trsquo I j M E T W TW T A I j A-I q
IW Trsquo E W T A T I W T A j P q W A x T
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4748
832019 Turkey and the Arab Spring Implications for Turkish Foreign Policy from a Transatlantic Perspective
httpslidepdfcomreaderfullturkey-and-the-arab-spring-implications-for-turkish-foreign-policy-from-a 4848
OFF I C E S