UI GreenMetric World University Rankings · EC3 Renewable Energy Produce Inside Campus 300 EC4 The Ratio of Total Electricity Usage Towards Campus ... Examples of Completed university

Prof. Dr. Riri Fitri Sari, M.Sc., MM

Chairperson of UI GreenMetric

[email protected]

The First International Conference on Green University

Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Iran

6 February 2018

The Role of UI GreenMetric World University Rankings

as a Supporting Tool for Campus Sustainable

Development in Global Universities

UI GreenMetric

World University Rankings

UI GreenMetric World University Rankings 2018

Chairperson

Prof. Dr. Riri Fitri Sari, M.Sc., MMSecretary

Dr. Nyoman Suwartha, S.T., M.T.,

M.Agr

Expert Member

Prof. Dr. Ir. Tommy Ilyas,

M.Eng.

Expert Member

Junaidi, S.S., M.A.

Expert Member

drg. Baiduri Widanarko, MKKK.,

PhD

Expert Member

Dr. Budi Hartono, S.Si,

M.K.M.

Communication and

Administration

Hastin Setiani, S.Si

Communication and

Administration

Arsy Imanda N.R., S.Si

Analyst and

International

Communication

Sabrina Hikmah R., S.Si

Programmer

Andri Setyawan,

S.Kom

Programmer

Rinoto Cahyo, S.Tr

UI GreenMetric Team

“• President of Ferdowsi University of Mashad, Prof. Dr.

Mohammad Kafi.

• The executive chair of the 1st Int Conference on Green

Universities, Dr. Fatemeh Tabatabaei.

• President of Zanjan University, Prof. Dr. Mohsen Najafian

• National Coordinator for UI GreenMetric World University

Ranking Network, Prof. Dr. Esmail Karamidehkordi

Thank You


Iran Universities in UI GreenMetric 2017

National

Ranking

Identity University World

Ranking

1 znu.ac.ir University of Zanjan 47

2 kashanu.ac.ir University Of Kashan 108

3 ui.ac.ir University Of Isfahan 197

4 shirazu.ac.ir Shiraz University 228

5 um.ac.ir Ferdowsi University of Mashhad 280

6 srbiau.ac.ir Islamic Azad University, Science and Research

Branch (SRBIAU)286

7 aut.ac.ir Amirkabir University of Technology 311

8 guilan.ac.ir University of Guilan 327

9 ut.ac.ir University of Tehran 414

10 alzahra.ac.ir Alzahra University 459


Endorsement of Related Ministries, Unesco Nat

Commision, etc to encouraged participations of Iranian

Universities

◍ Achievement of Universities in Green Management

(+exhibitions) Evidence for UI GreenMetric

Submissions

◍ Lesson learnt from universities presentations in

Mashad

1. Tarbiat Modarres University

2. Sharif University of Technology

3. University of Neyshabur

4. Bu-Ali Sina University of Hamedan

5. University of Mohaghegh Ardabili

6. University of Jahrom

“Outline

Introduction

Methodology and Trendsin UI GreenMetric Rankings

Conclusion


UI GreenMetric Rankings

– the 8th year


What is UI GreenMetric?


Why joining UI GreenMetric?

Overview

◍ UI GreenMetric World Universitiy Ranking: established in April 2010

◍ Strengths: Openness for global participation, accessibility for all HEIs in both the developed and developing world

◍ It contributes to academic discourse on sustainability in education and the greening of campuses

◍ It encourages university-led social change in the areas of sustainability

◍ Identify important issues; are calculable and comparable; move beyond eco-efficiency; measure process and motivations; and stress on comprehensibility.

◍ Self assessment and online survey – http://greenmetric.ui.ac.id


◍College Green Report Card (www.greenreportcard.org)

◍Green League (https://peopleandplanet.org/university-league)

◍Green Cool University (http://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/coolschools-2015)

◍Sustainability Tracking Assessment and Rating System (STARS) – (https://stars.aashe.org/)

◍The Holcim Sustainability Awards,◍GREENSHIP◍Berlin Principles

UI GreenMetric©2016UI GreenMetric World University Ranking 2017

Referred established models


http://www.greenreportcard.org/

https://peopleandplanet.org/university-league

http://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/coolschools-2015

https://stars.aashe.org/

Source: University of Oxford 2016 Report

Current Comparison (UI GM, ISCN, STARS AASHE)

UI GreenMetric World University Ranking 2017UI GreenMetric World University Rankings 2018

Top 20 UI GreenMetric World Ranking 2017

UI GreenMetric©2016

Rank University Id Country

1 Wageningen University & Research wageningenur.nl Netherland

2 UAniversity of Nottingham nottingham.ac.uk UK

3 University of California Davis ucdavis.edu USA

4 University of Bradford brad.ac.uk UK

5 Nottingham Trent University ntu.ac.uk UK

6 University of Oxford ox.ac.uk UK

7 University of Connecticut uconn.edu USA

8 Bangor University bangor.ac.uk UK

9 University College Cork ucc.ie Ireland

10Hochschule Trier - Umwelt-Campus

Birkenfeldumwelt-campus.de Germany

11 University of Groningen rug.nl Netherland

12 Universitat fur Bodenkultur Wien boku.ac.at Austria

13 University of North Carolina Chapel Hill unc.edu USA

14North Carolina Agricultural & Technical

State Universityncat.edu USA

15 Dublin City University dcu.ie Ireland

16 Universidad de Alcala uah.es Spain

17 Keele University keele.ac.uk UK

18 Georgia Institute of Technology gatech.edu USA

19 Newcastle University Newcastle upon Tynencl.ac.uk UK

20 University of Sussex sussex.ac.uk UK


“The Ranking Process


Setting and

InfrastuctureThe aim is to trigger the

participating university to

provide more space for

greenery and in safeguarding

environment, as well ad the

development of sustainable

energy

Energy and Climate

Change With this indicator, universities

are expected to increase the

effort in energy efficiency on their

building and to care more about

nature and energy resource

WasteSome programs and waste treatments

should be among the concern of the

university, i.e. recycling program, toxic

waste recycling, organic waste treatment,

inorganic waste treatment, sewerage

disposal, policy to reduce the use of

paper and plastic in campus

WaterThe aim is that universities

can decrease water usage,

increase conservation

program, and protect the

habitat

TransportationTransportation policy to limit

the number of motor vehicles

in campus, the use of

campus bus and bicycle will

encourage a healthier

environment

EducationThis expansion of the criteria based

on the thought that university has

an important role in creating the

new generation concern with

sustainability

Criteria and Indicators


Criteria and Indicator of UI GreenMetric

No Categories & Indicators Points

1 SETTING & INFRASTRUCTURE 15%

SI 1 The ratio of open space area towards total area 300

SI 2 The ratio of open space area towards campus population 300

SI 3 Area on campus covered in forest 200

SI 4 Area on campus covered in planted vegetation 200

SI 5 Area on campus for water absorbance 300

SI 6 University budget for sustainable effort 200




2 ENERGY & CLIMATE CHANGE 21%

EC 1 Energy efficient appliances usage 200

EC 2 Smart building implementation 300

EC 3 Renewable energy produce on campus 300

EC 4 The ratio of total electricity usage towards campus

population

300

EC 5 The ratio of renewable energy produce towards energy usage 200

EC 6 Element of green building implementation 300

EC 7 Greenhouse gas emission reduction program 200

EC 8 The ratio of total carbon footprint towards campus population 300




3 WASTE 18%

WS 1 Program to reduce the use of paper and plastic in campus 300

WS 2 Recycling program for university waste 300

WS 3Toxic waste handled

300

WS 4Organic waste treatment

300

WS 5Inorganic waste treatment

300

WS 6Sewerage disposal

300




4 WATER 10%

WR 1 Water conservation program 300

WR 2 Water recycling program 300

WR 3 The use of water efficient appliances 200

WR 4 Piped water consumed 200




5 TRANSPORTATION 18%

TR 1 The ratio of vehicles (cars and motorcycles) towards campus population 200

TR 2 The ratio of shuttle services towards campus population 200

TR 3 The ratio of bicycles towards campus population 200

TR 4 Parking Area Type 200

TR 5 Transportation initiatives to decrease private vehicles on campus 200

TR 6 Parking area reduction for private vehicle over the last 3 years (from 2014 to

2016)

200

TR 7 Shuttle service 300

TR 8 Bicycle and pedestrian policy on campus 300




6 EDUCATION 18%

ED 1 The ratio of sustainability courses towards total courses/modules 300

ED 2 The ratio of sustainability research funding towards total research funding 300

ED 3 Sustainability publications 300

ED 4 Sustainability events 300

ED 5 Sustainability student organizations 300

ED 6 Sustainability websites 300


Tools - UI GreenMetric Online Questionnaire

http://greenmetric.ui.ac.id

General Results

UI GreenMetric World Rankings 2017

*average (%) of all universities


0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

Setting and Infrastructure

Energy and Climate Change

Waste

Water

Transportation

Education

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

SI1

SI2

SI3

SI4

SI5

SI6

Setting and Infrastructure

Indicator Score

SI1

The Ratio of Open

Space Area Towards

Total Area300

SI2

The Ratio of Open

Space Area Towards

Campus Population300

SI3Area on Campus

Covered in forest200

SI4

Area on Campus

Covered in Planted

Vegetation200

SI5Area on Campus for

Water Absorbance300

SI6University Budget for

Sustainable Effort200

🏰



0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

SI1

SI2

SI3

SI4

SI5

SI6

0

20

40

60

80

100SI1

SI2

SI3

SI4

SI5

SI6

Energy and Climate Change

Indicator Score

EC1Energy Efficient Appliances

Usage200

EC2Smart Building

Implementation300

EC3Renewable Energy Produce

Inside Campus300

EC4

The Ratio of Total Electricity

Usage Towards Campus

Population 300

EC5

The Ratio of Renewable

Energy Produce Towards

Energy Usage200

EC6Element of Green Building

Implementation300

EC7Greenhouse Gas Emission

Reduction Program200

EC8

The Ratio of Total Carbon

Footprint Towards Campus

Population300

🔌



0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

EC1

EC2

EC3

EC4

EC5

EC6

EC7

EC8

01020304050607080

EC1

EC2

EC4

EC5

EC6

EC7

EC8

Waste

Indicators Score

WS1

Program to Reduce

the Use of Paper

and Plastic in

Campus

300

WS2Recycling Program

for University Waste300

WS3Toxic Waste

Handling300

WS4Organic Waste

Treatment300

WS5Inorganic Waste

Treatment300

WS6 Sewerage Disposal 300



0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

WS1

WS2

WS3

WS4

WS5

WS6

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70WS1

WS2

WS3

WS4

WS5

WS6

Water

Indicators Score

WR1

Water

Conservation

Program300

WR2

Water

Recycling

Program300

WR3

The Use of

Water Efficient

Appliances200

WR4Piped Water

Consumed200



0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

WR1

WR2

WR3

WR4

0

10

20

30

40

50

60WR1

WR2

WR3

WR4

Methodology and Trends

in UI GreenMetric Rankings


Increasing Number of Participants

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

2009 2011 2013 2015 2017

Nu

mb

er

Year

Number of universities particapated

Number countries particapated

Number of universities particapatedfrom Indonesia

2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017

Number of universities

participated 95 178 215 301 360 407 515 619

Number of countries

participated 35 42 49 61 62 75 10 76

Number of universities

participated from

Indonesia22 25 26 28 28 49 49 57


Examples of Completed university Programs

• Installed 10 water refilling stations on campus (over 250000 refills)

• Installed convenient, colourfull recycle bins

• Installed a rain water collection system

• Geothermal HVAC system installed

• Installation of pumps to use creek water for lawn irrigation

• Installation of a pervious pavement parking lot

• Planting of native grasses and wildlife foot plots, and creation of hiking trains

• Installation of electric vehicle charging stations on campus

• Installation of building dashboards in 2 building to monitor gas and electric use, and energy saving

equipment

• Installation of new high efficiency chillers

• Indoor lighting replacement projects: Classroom upgrade, corridor lighting, occupancy sensors.

• Installation of high efficiency LED parking lot and roadway lighting

• Install new LED exterior building lighting.

• Tune-up steam boilers.

• Upgrade HVAC system in main IT server room

• New energy efficient welders in welding lab to save energy

• Extensive roof replacement project and insulated rooving

• Full campus electrical energy metering installed


Report on environmental

Performance

• Carbon and energy management – continuous improvement

• Sustainable buildings

• Transport

• Biodiversity

• Water management

• Material Resources and waste reduction program

• Communication and engagement


Problems of in Excellence in Campus Sustainability

Source: Lombard 2016, True Green Univ

Example:

Source: University of Oxford 2016 Report


Energy Audit and Monitoring System

Source: University of Keele 2013 Report


“


1. Wageningen University & Research


Wageningen University & Researchhttp://www.wur.nl/en/About-Wageningen/Sustainability.htm


2. University of Nottingham


University of Nottingham

www.nottingham.ac.uk/sustaianability


6. Universiti Putra Malaysia3. University of California, Davis


619 universities

Participating institutions located on the

dynamic, and diverse Asia, Europe,

Africa, Australia, America and Oceania.

76 countries


UI GreenMetric World University Ranking Network 2017

Distribution of Participants (2017)

UI GreenMetric©2016

🌏Regions

No.

Univ

Asia 251

Africa 11

Amerika 149

Europe 202

Oceania 6

Total 619


“• Leadership has been shown by 247 universities that

submitted evidence • The majority are dedicated to having their university

become more sustainable.• The most significant constraints to moving toward

sustainability: - financial predicaments- lack of understanding and awareness of

sustainability issues amongst the universitypopulation a resistance to change.

• All university stakeholders should have a common understanding of the term sustainable development.

Trend and findings


UI GreenMetric Network Events in 2017


The National Workshop on

UI GreenMetric World

University Rankings

(IWGM) in

University of El

BosqueColombia

On 24-25 August, 2017

46 Participants from 11

Universities

National Workshop on UI GreenMetric


The National Workshop

on UI GreenMetric World

University Rankings

(IWGM) in

University of Sao

Paulo (USP)Brazil

On 27-28 August 2017


Universities




on UI GreenMetric World

University Rankings

(IWGM) in

University of Bologna Italy

On 29 September, 2017


Universities



The National Workshop on

UI GreenMetric World

University Rankings

(IWGM) in

Aalborg University Denmark

On 3 October, 2017


Universities




on UI GreenMetric

World University

Rankings (IWGM) in

People’s Friendship

University (RUDN)Moscow, Russia

On 24 November, 2017


Universities



The UI GreenMetric World

University Rankings Session in

collaboration with NPUST and

NCKU at

The 3rd General

Assembly Green

University Union of

Taiwan (GUUT) 2017Nantau, Taiwan

on 22 September 2017


Universities


UI GreenMetric Session

12013 and 2016

University of Indonesia

Depok, Indonesia

2017

Istanbul University

Bulent Ecevit University

Istanbul, Turkey

2018

Universitas Diponegoro

Semarang, Indonesia

2019

University College Cork

Ireland

2020

University of Zanjan

Iran

2021

Universiti Utara Malaysia

Malaysia

2022

National Pingtung University

of Science and Technology

Taiwan

International Workshop on UI GreenMetric (IWGM) 2013-2022

2

3

4

5

6

7


“◍ In order to make make better impact to achieving SDGs, university need to put more efforts on the UI GM six criteria, particularly on ‘energy and climate change’.◍ Higher education has a crucial role to play in addressing these challenge:

- Smart building implementation.

- Renewable energy.

- Carbon footprint evaluation.

- Green Building Certification/Acknowledgement

◍ Report on SDGs effort achievement

Conclusion

UI GreenMetric©2016UI GreenMetric World University Rankings 2018

The 4th International Workshop on UI GreenMetric World University

Rankings (IWGM) 2018

in collaboration with Diponegoro University Semarang on 8-11 April

2018

Please visit

http://iwgm.ui.ac.id to register

Email: [email protected]


2018 International Workshop on UI GreenMetric (IWGM)

Documents

UI GreenMetric World University Rankings · EC3 Renewable Energy Produce Inside Campus 300 EC4 The Ratio of Total Electricity Usage Towards Campus ... Examples of Completed university