Unbalanced Faults

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    1/44

    This document is the exclusive property of Alstom Grid and shall not betransmitted by any means, copied, reproduced or modified without the priorwritten consent of Alstom Grid Technical Institute. All rights reserved.

    GRIDTechnical Institute

    Analysis of Unbalanced Faults

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults2

    Fault Types

    Line - Ground (65 - 70%)

    Line - Line - Ground (10 - 20%)

    Line - Line (10 - 15%)

    Line - Line - Line (5%)

    Statist ics publi shed in 1967 CEGB Report , but are similar todayall over the world .

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    2/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults3

    Fault Incidence

    85% of faults are overhead line faults.

    50% of these due to ligh tning strikes.

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults4

    Unbalanced Faults (1)

    In three phase fault calculations, a single phaserepresentation is adopted

    3 phase faults are rare

    Majori ty of faults are unbalanced faults

    UNBALANCED FAULTS may be classified intoSHUNT FAULTS and SERIES FAULTS

    SHUNT FAULTSLine to GroundLine to LineLine to Line to Ground

    SERIES FAULTSSingle Phase Open CircuitDouble Phase Open Circuit

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    3/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults5

    Unbalanced Faults (2)

    LINE TO GROUNDLINE TO LINELINE TO LINE TO GROUND

    Causes :

    1) Insu lat ion Breakdown

    2) Lightning Discharges and other Overvoltages3) Mechanical Damage

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults6

    Unbalanced Faults (3)

    OPEN CIRCUIT OR SERIES FAULTS

    Causes :

    1) Broken Conductor 2) Operation of Fuses3) Maloperation of Single Phase Circuit Breakers

    DURING UNBALANCED FAULTS, SYMMETRY OF SYSTEMIS LOST

    SINGLE PHASE REPRESENTATION IS NO LONGER VALID

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    4/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults7

    Unbalanced Faults (4)

    Analysed using :-

    Symmetrical Components

    Equivalent Sequence Networks of Power System

    Connection of Sequence Networks appropriate to Typeof Fault

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults8

    Symmetrical Components

    Fortescue discovered a property of unbalanced phasors

    n phasors may be resolved into :-

    (n-1) sets of balanced n-phase systems of phasors, each sethaving a different phase sequence

    plus

    1 set of zero phase sequence or unidi rectional phasors

    V A = V A1 + V A2 + V A3 + V A4 - - - - - V A(n-1) + V AnVB = VB1 + VB2 + VB3 + VB4 - - - - - VB(n-1) + VBnVC = VC1 + VC2 + VC3 + VC4 - - - - - VC(n-1) + VCnVD = VD1 + VD2 + VD3 + VD4 - - - - - VD(n-1) + VDn- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -Vn = Vn1 + Vn2 + Vn3 + Vn4 - - - - - Vn(n-1) + Vnn

    (n-1) x Balanced 1 x ZeroSequence

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    5/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults9

    Unbalanced 5-Phase System of Voltages (1)

    This can be resolved into :-

    First Set of Balanced Second Set of Phasors Balanced Phasors

    V A1

    2VE1

    VD1 VC1

    VB1

    V A2

    VC2

    VE2 VB2

    VD2

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults10

    Unbalanced 5-Phase System of Voltages (2)

    Third Set of Balanced Fourth Set of Phasors Balanced Phasors

    4

    3

    V A4

    VB4

    VC4 VD4

    VE4

    V A3

    VD3

    VB3 VE3

    VC3

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    6/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults11

    Unbalanced 5-Phase System of Voltages (3)

    Fifth Set of ZeroSequence Phasors V A5

    VB5

    VD5VE5

    VC5

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults12

    Unbalanced 3-Phase System of Voltages (1)

    This can be resolved into : -

    First Set of Balanced Second Set of Phasors Balanced Phasors

    V A1

    VC1

    120

    VB1

    V A2

    VB2 VC2

    240

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    7/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults13

    Unbalanced 3-Phase System of Voltages (2)

    Third Set of ZeroSequence Phasors

    V A3VB3

    VC3

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults14

    Unbalanced 3-Phase System (1)

    V A = V A1 + V A2 + V A0VB = VB1 + VB2 + VB0

    VC = VC1 + VC2 + VC0

    Posit ive Sequence Negative Sequence

    V A1

    VC1

    120

    VB1

    V A2

    VB2 VC2

    240

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    8/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults15

    Unbalanced 3-Phase System (2)

    Zero Sequence

    V A0VB0

    VC0

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults16

    Symmetrical Components

    Phase Positive + Negative + Zero

    V A V A1 + V A2 + V A0VB VB1 + VB2 + VB0

    VC VC1 + VC2 + VC0

    V A

    VB

    VC

    + +

    VB1

    VC1

    V A1

    VB2

    VC2

    VC0VB0V A0V A2

    VB1 = a 2 V A1 VB2 = a V A2 VB0 = V A0VC1 = a V A1 VC2 = a 2 V A2 VC0 = V A0

    =

    ==

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    9/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults17

    Converting from Sequence Componentsto Phase Values

    V A = V A1 + V A2 + V A0

    VB = VB1 + VB2 + VB0 = a 2V A1 + a V A2 + V A0

    VC

    = VC1

    + VC2

    + VC0

    = a V A1

    + a 2V A2

    + V A0

    V A0

    VC1

    VC

    V A2

    V A1

    V A

    VC0

    VC2

    VB2

    VB0VB1

    VB

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults18

    Converting from Phase Valuesto Sequence Components

    V A1 = 1/3 {V A + a V B + a 2VC}

    V A2 = 1/3 {V A + a 2VB + a V C}

    V A0 = 1/3 {V A + VB + VC}

    VC3V A0

    VB

    V A0

    V A

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    10/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults19

    Add V A , VB, VC vectorially

    V A = V A1 + V A2 + V A0VB = a 2V A1 + a V A2 + V A0VC = a V A1 + a 2V A2 + V A0

    V A + VB + VC = 0 + 0 + 3V A0

    V A0 = 1/3 (V A + VB + VC )

    Add V A , aV B and a 2VC vectorially

    V A = V A1 + V A2 + V A0a V B = V A1 + a 2V A2 + a V A0a 2VC = V A1 + a V A2 + a 2V A0

    V A + aV B + a 2VC = 3V A1 + 0 + 0

    V A1 = 1/3 (V A + a V B + a 2 VC )

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults20

    Add V A, a2VB and aV C vectorially

    V A

    = V A1

    + V A2

    + V A0

    a 2VB = a V A1 + V A2 + a2V A0

    a V C = a2V A1 + V A2 + a V A0

    V A + a2VB + VC = 0 + 3V A2 + 0

    V A2 = 1/3 (V A + a2VB + aV C )

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    11/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults21

    V A = V A1 + V A2 + V A0

    VB = a2 V A1 + a V A2 + V A0

    VC = a V A1 + a2 V A2 + V A0

    I A = I A1 + I A2 + I A0

    IB = a2 I A1 + a I A2 + I A0

    IC = a I A1 + a2 I A2 + I A0

    V A1 = 1/3 {V A + a V B + a2 VC }

    V A2 = 1/3 {V A + a2 VB + a V C }

    V A0 = 1/3 {V A + VB + VC }

    I A1 = 1/3 { I A + a I B + a 2 IC }I A2 = 1/3 { I A + a

    2 IB + a I C }

    I A0 + 1/3 { I A + IB + IC }

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults22

    Residual Current

    Used to detect earth f aults

    * I RESIDUAL is zero for :- * I RESIDUAL is present for :-

    Balanced Load /E Faults3 Faults //E Faults/ Faults

    I A

    IRESIDUAL = I A + IB +IC

    = 3 I0

    IB

    IC

    E/F

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    12/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults23

    Residual Voltage

    Used to detect earth f aultsResidual voltage is measured from Open Delta or Broken Delta VT

    secondary windings.VRESIDUAL is zero for: -

    Healthy unfaulted systems

    3 Faults

    / Faults

    VRESIDUAL is present for:-

    /E Faults

    //E Faults

    Open Circuits (on supp ly

    side of VT with earthed source)

    VRESIDUAL

    = V A + VB +VC= 3V 0

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults24

    Example

    Evaluate the posi tive, negative and zero sequence componentsfor the unbalanced phase vectors :

    V A = 10

    VB = 1.5 -90

    VC = 0.5 120

    VC

    V A

    VB

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    13/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults25

    Solution

    V A1 = 1/3 (V A + aV B + a 2VC)

    = 1/3 [ 1 + (1 120) (1.5 -90)

    + (1 240) (0.5 120) ]

    = 0.965 15

    V A2 = 1/3 (V A + a 2VB + aV C)

    = 1/3 [ 1 + (1 240) (1.5 -90)

    + (1 120) (0.5 120) ]

    = 0.211 150

    V A0 = 1/3 (V A + VB + VC)

    = 1/3 (1 + 1.5 -90 + 0.5 120)

    = 0.434 -55

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults26

    Positive Sequence Voltages

    VC1 = aV A1

    15

    V A1 =

    0.965 15

    VB1 =a 2V A1

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    14/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults27

    Zero SequenceVoltages

    Negative Sequence

    Voltages

    V A0 = 0.434 -55VB0 = -VC0 = -

    -55 VC2 = a2 V A2

    150

    VB2 = a V A2

    V A2 =0.211 150

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults28

    Symmetrical Components

    VC1

    V A1

    VB1

    VC2

    V A2

    VB2

    VC0

    V A0

    VB0

    V A2VC2

    VB2

    VC

    V A

    V0

    VB

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    15/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults29

    Example (1)

    Evaluate the phase quantities I A , I B and I C from thesequence components

    I A1 = 0.6 0

    I A2 = -0.4 0

    I A0 = -0.2 0

    Solution

    I A = I A1 + I A2 + I A0 = 0

    IB = a2I A1 + a I A1 + I A0

    = 0.6240 - 0.4 120 - 0.2 0 = 0.91 -109

    IC = a I A1 + a 2I A2 + I A0= 0.6120 - 0.4 240 - 0.2 0 = 0.91 +109

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults30

    Example (2)

    IC

    IB

    109

    109

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    16/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults31

    POSITIVE

    I A1

    NEGATIVE

    IB1IC1

    I A2

    IB2

    IC2

    IC1

    IB1

    I A1

    I A2

    IB2

    IC2

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults32

    PHASE

    ZERO

    I A0

    IB0

    IC0

    IB

    IC

    IC

    IB

    I A0IB0IC0

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    17/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults33

    Sequence Components (1)

    Any 3 phase system o f vector s may be represent ed as t he sum o f3 sets of symmetrical vectors :-

    3 PHASEVECTORS

    EQUIVALENT SYMMETRICAL COMPONENTS

    POSITIVE PHASESEQUENCE (PPS) ZERO PHASESEQUENCE

    I2

    BALANCED LOAD

    OR 3-PHASE FAULT/I A/ = / IB/ = / IC/ = IF

    I0 = 0I2 = 0I1 = IF

    NEGATIVE PHASESEQUENCE (NPS)

    I1

    I A

    IC IB

    I0

    I A1

    IC1 IB1

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults34

    Sequence Components (2)

    PHASE-PHASEFAULT / I A/=/IB/ = IF

    I A

    IB

    I0 = 0

    I A1

    IC1

    IB1

    I A2

    IC2

    IB2I1 = IF

    3

    I2 = IF3

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    18/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults35

    Sequence Components (3)

    PHASE-EARTHFAULTS/I A/ OR / IC/ = IF

    I A

    IC

    IB2

    IC2 I A2

    I A0 IC0IB0I A1

    IC1 IB1

    I A2

    IB2 IC2

    I A1

    IC1 IB1

    I1 = IF3

    I2 = IF3

    I0 = IF3

    I A0 IC0IB0

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults36

    Sequence Networks

    It can be shown that provid ing the system impedances arebalanced from the points o f generation r ight up to the fault, each

    sequence current causes voltage drop of its own sequence only.

    Regard each sequence current flowing within its own networkthro impedances of its own sequence only, with nointerconnection between the sequence networks r ight up to thepoint of fault.

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    19/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults37

    Unbalanced Voltages and Currents acting onBalanced Impedances

    ZSI AV A

    ZMZMZSIBVB

    ZMZSICVC

    V A = I AZS + I BZM + I CZM

    VB = I AZM + I BZS + I CZM

    VC = I AZM + I BZM + I CZS

    In matrix form

    V A ZS ZM ZM I A

    VB = ZM ZS ZM I B

    VC ZM ZM ZS I C

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults38

    Resolve V & I phasors into symmetrical components

    1 1 1 V 0 ZS ZM ZM 1 1 1 I 01 a 2 a V 1 = ZM ZS ZM 1 a 2 a I 11 a a 2 V2 ZM ZM ZS 1 a a 2 I 2

    Multiply by [A] -1

    V0 1 1 1 Z S ZM ZM 1 1 1 I 0V1 = 1 a 2 a Z M ZS ZM 1 a 2 a I 1V2 1 a a 2 ZM ZM ZS 1 a a 2 I 2

    V0 1 1 1 Z S ZM ZM 1 1 1 I 0V1 = 1/3 1 a a 2 ZM ZS ZM 1 a 2 a I 1V2 1 a 2 a Z M ZM ZS 1 a a 2 I 2

    V0 ZS + 2Z M ZS + 2Z M ZS + 2Z MV1 = 1/3 Z S - ZM ZM + a Z S + a 2 ZM ZM + aZ M + a 2 ZS

    V2 ZS - ZM ZM + a 2 ZS + a Z M ZM + a 2 ZM + a Z S

    1 1 1 I 01 a 2 a I 11 a a 2 I2

    -1

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    20/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults39

    V0 ZS + 2Z M 0 0 I 0V1 = 0 Z S - ZM 0 I 1V2 0 0 Z S - ZM I 2

    V0 Z0 0 0 I 0V1 = 0 Z 1 0 I 1V2 0 0 Z 2 I 2

    The symmetrical component impedance matrix is adiagonal matrix if system is symmetrical.

    The sequence networks are independent of each other.

    The three isolated sequence networks are

    interconnected when an unbalance such as a fault o runbalanced loading is introduced.

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults40

    Phase Sequence Equivalent Circuits (1)

    Positive Sequence Impedance

    E

    QPa 2E

    aE

    Z1

    = E/IQ1P 1

    I

    a 2 I

    aI

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    21/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults41

    Phase Sequence Equivalent Circuits (2)

    Negative Sequence Impedance

    For static non-rotating plant :- Z 2 = Z 1

    E

    QP

    a 2E

    aE

    Z2 = E/IQ 2P 2

    I

    a 2 I

    aI

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults42

    Phase Sequence Equivalent Circuits (3)

    Zero Sequence Impedance

    I

    I

    I3IE QP

    Z0 = E/IP 0 Q0

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    22/44

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    23/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults45

    Example

    V1 = Positive sequence /N voltage at fault point

    I 1 = Positive sequence phase current flowing into F 1V1 = E 1 - I 1 (ZG1 + Z T1 + Z L1)

    E1F1I1ZL1

    ZG1 ZT1N1

    (N1)

    V1

    LineF

    N

    E

    R

    Generator Transformer

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults46

    Negative Sequence Diagram

    1. Star t wi th neu tr al point N 2- All generator and load neutrals are connected to N 2

    2. No EMFs included

    - No negative sequence voltage is generated!

    3. Impedance network

    - Negative sequence impedance per phase

    4. Diagram f inishes at fault point F 2

    Z2N2 F2

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    24/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults47

    Example

    V2 = Negative sequence /N voltage at fault point

    I 2 = Negative sequence phase current flowing into F 2

    V2 = -I2 (ZG2 + Z T2 + Z L2)

    F2I2ZL2ZG2 ZT2N2

    (N2)

    V2

    Line FN

    E

    R

    Generator Transformer

    System Single LineDiagram

    Negative Sequence Diagram

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults48

    Zero Sequence Diagram (1)

    For In Phase (Zero Phase Sequence) currents to flow in eachphase of the system, there must be a four th connection (this istypically the neutral or earth connection).

    I A0 + IB0 + IC0 = 3 I A0

    I A0N

    IB0

    IC0

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    25/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults49

    Zero Sequence Diagram (2)

    Resistance Earthed System :-

    3 A0

    N

    E

    R

    Zero s equence vol tage between N & E given by

    V0 = -3 A0 . RZero sequence impedance of neutral to earth path

    Z0 = V0 = 3R

    - A0

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults50

    Transformer Zero Sequence Impedance

    QP

    ZT0aa

    QP

    bb

    N0

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    26/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults51

    General Zero Sequence Equivalent Circuitfor Two Winding Transformer

    SecondaryTerminal'a' 'a'

    PrimaryTerminal

    'b' 'b'

    N0

    ZT0

    On appropriate side of transformer :

    Earthed Star Winding - Close link a

    Open link b

    Delta Winding - Open link aClose link b

    Unearthed Star Winding - Both links open

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults52

    Zero Sequence EquivalentDy Tx (1)

    3I0

    No zero sequencein line connectionon side

    I 0

    I 0

    I0

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    27/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults53

    Zero Sequence EquivalentDy Transformer (2)

    sideterminal

    sideterminal ZT0

    N0(E0)

    I0

    Thus, equivalent s ingle phase zero sequence diagram :-

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults54

    Zero Sequence Equivalent Circui ts (1)

    S 0ZT0

    N0

    P 0

    P S

    aa

    b b

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    28/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults55

    Zero Sequence Equivalent Circui ts (2)

    S 0ZT0

    N0

    P 0

    P S

    aa

    b b

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults56

    Zero Sequence Equivalent Circui ts (3)

    S 0ZT0

    N0

    P 0

    P S

    aa

    b b

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    29/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults57

    Zero Sequence Equivalent Circui ts (4)

    S 0ZT0

    N0

    P 0

    P S

    aa

    b b

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults58

    Zero Sequence Diagram

    V0

    = Zero sequence PH-E voltage at fault point

    I 0 = Zero sequence current flowing into F 0V0 = -I 0 (ZT0 + Z L0 + 3R T)

    F0I 0ZL0ZG0 ZT0N0

    N0

    V0

    Line FN

    E

    R

    Generator Transformer

    System Single Line

    Diagram

    Zero Sequence Network

    3R

    E0

    3R T

    RT

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    30/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults59

    Zig-Zag Earthing Transformers (1)

    Positive (and negative) sequence impedance is very high.

    Equivalent Circu it :

    P

    N

    E

    R

    P 1

    N1

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults60

    Zig-Zag Earthing Transformers (2)

    Zero sequence impedance is very low.

    Equivalent Circu it P0

    ZT0

    3R

    N0(E0)

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    31/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults61

    Summary of Sequence Diagrams (1)

    System Single Line Diagram

    R

    E

    N

    GENERATOR TRANSFORMERLINE F

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults62

    Summary of Sequence Diagrams (2)

    Positive Sequence

    (N1)

    V1

    F1

    ZL1ZT1ZG1E1N1

    I1

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    32/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults63

    Summary of Sequence Diagrams (3)

    Negative Sequence

    (N2)

    V2

    F2ZL2ZT2ZG2N2 I2

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults64

    Summary of Sequence Diagrams (4)

    Zero Sequence

    E0(N0)

    V0

    F0ZL0ZT0ZG0

    3R

    N0 I0

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    33/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults65

    Interconnection of Sequence Networks

    Consider sequence networks as blocks with fault terminals F & N forexternal connections.

    F1

    POSITIVESEQUENCENETWORK

    N1F2

    NEGATIVESEQUENCENETWORK

    N2F0

    ZEROSEQUENCENETWORK

    N0

    I2

    V2

    I0

    V0

    I1

    V1

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults66

    Interconnection of Sequence Networks

    For any given fault t here are 6 quantities to be cons idered at the fault point

    i.e. V A VB VC I A IB IC

    Relationsh ips between these for any type of fault can be converted into anequivalent relationship between sequence components

    V1, V2, V0 and I1, I 2 , I 0

    This is possible if :-

    1) Any 3 phase quantities are known (provided they are not allvoltages or all currents)

    o r 2) 2 are known and 2 o ther s are known to have a spec if icrelationship.

    From the relationsh ip between sequence Vs and Is, the manner inwhich the isolation sequence networks are connected can be determined.

    The connection of the sequence networks prov ides a single phaserepresentation (in sequence terms) of the fault.

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    34/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults67

    To derive the system cons traints at the fault terminals :-

    I A

    V A

    IB IC

    VB VC

    F

    Terminals are connected to represent the fault.

    A

    B

    C

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults68

    I A

    V A

    IB IC

    VB VC

    Phase to Earth Fault on Phase A

    At fault poin t :-

    V A = 0VB = ?VC = ?

    I A = ?I B = 0I C = 0

    A

    B

    C

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    35/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults69

    Phase to Earth Fault on Phase A

    At fau lt po in t

    V A = 0 ; I B = 0 ; I C = 0

    but V A = V1 + V2 + V0

    V1 + V2 + V0 = 0 ------------------------- (1)

    I 0 = 1/3 ( I A + I B + I C ) = 1/3 I A

    I 1 = 1/3 ( I A + a I B + a 2I C) = 1/3 I A

    I 2 = 1/3 ( I A + a 2I B + a I C) = 1/3 I A

    I 1 = I 2 = I 0 = 1/3 I A ------------------------- (2)

    To comply with (1) & (2) the sequence networks must be connected in series :-

    I1 F1

    N1

    V1

    +veSeqN/W

    I2F2

    N2

    V2-veSeqN/W

    I0F0

    N0

    V0ZeroSeqN/W

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults70

    Example : Phase to Earth Fault

    SOURCE LINE F

    132 kV2000 MVAZS1 = 8.7

    ZS0 = 8.7

    A - GFAULTZL1 = 10

    ZL0 = 35

    Total impedance = 81.1 I1 = I2 = I0 = 132000 = 940 Amp s

    3 x 81.1IF = I A = I1 + I 2 + I0 = 3 I0 = 2820 Amps

    IF

    8.7 10 I1 F1

    N1

    8.7 10 I2 F2

    N2

    8.7 35 I0 F0

    N0

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    36/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults71

    I A

    V A

    IB IC

    VB VC

    Earth Fault with Fault Resistance

    At fault point : -

    V A = I AZF

    VB = ?

    VC = ?

    I A = ?

    I B = 0

    I C = 0

    ZF

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults72

    Earth Fault with Fault Resistance

    At fault poin t

    V A = I AZF ; I B = 0 ; IC = 0

    I0

    = 1/3 (I A

    + IB

    + IC)

    =1/3 I

    A

    I 1 = 1/3 ( I A + a IB + a 2IC) = 1/3 I A

    I 2 = 1/3 ( I A + a 2IB + a IC) = 1/3 I A

    I 1 = I2 = I 0 ------------------------- (1)

    Since V A = I AZF :-

    V1 + V2 + V0 = (I 1 + I 2 + I 0) ZF

    = 3 I 0ZF

    V1 + V2 + V0 = 3 I 0ZF ------------ (2)

    F1POSITIVESEQUENCENETWORK

    N1F2

    NEGATIVESEQUENCENETWORK

    N2F0

    ZEROSEQUENCE

    NETWORKN0

    I2

    V2

    I0

    V0

    I1

    V1

    3Z F

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    37/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults73

    I A

    V A

    IB IC

    VB VC

    Phase to Phase Fault :- B-C Phase

    At faul t po in t : -

    V A = ?

    VB = VC

    I A = 0

    I B + I C = 0

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults74

    Phase to Phase Fault :- B-C Phase

    At fau lt po int

    VB = VC ; I A = 0; I B + I C = 0

    I 0 = 1/3 ( I A + I B + I C ) = 0

    I 0 = 0 ---- (1)

    I 1 = 1/3 ( I A + a I B + a 2I C ) = 1/3 (a - a 2 )I B

    I 2 = 1/3 ( I A + a2

    I B + a I C) = -1/3 (a - a2

    )I B I 1 + I 2 = 0 ------- (2)

    V1 = 1/3 (V A + aV B + a 2VC ) = 1/3 (V A - VB)

    V2 = 1/3 (V A + a 2VB + aV C ) = 1/3 (V A - VB)

    V1 = V2 ------------------------ (3)

    From equations (1), (2) and (3) the positi ve and negative sequence networks areconnected in parallel and the zero sequence network is unconnected.

    I1F1

    N1

    V1+ve

    SeqN/W

    I2F2

    N2

    V2

    -ve

    SeqN/W

    I0F0

    N0

    V0

    ZeroSeqN/W

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    38/44

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    39/44

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    40/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults79

    I A

    V A

    IB IC

    VB VC

    Phase to Phase to Earth Fault :- B-C-E

    At fault poin t : -

    V A = ?VB = 0VC = 0

    I A = 0

    I B = ?

    I C = ?

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults80

    Phase to Phase to Earth Fault :- B-C-E

    At fau lt poin t

    VB = 0 ; V C = 0 ; I A = 0

    V1 = 1/3 (V A + aV B + a 2VC ) = 1/3 V A

    V2 = 1/3 (V A + a 2VB + aV C ) = 1/3 V A

    V0 = 1/3 (V A + VB + VC ) = 1/3 V A

    V1 = V2 = V0 = 1/3 V A -------------------- (1)

    I A = I 1 + I 2 + I 0 = 0 ------------------------------- (2)

    From equations (1) & (2) the sequence networks are connected in parallel.

    I1F1

    N1

    V1+veSeqN/W

    I2F2

    N2

    V2-veSeqN/W

    I0F0

    N0

    V0

    ZeroSeqN/W

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    41/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults81

    I A

    V A

    IB IC

    VB VC

    Phase to Phase to Earth FaultB-C-E with Fault Resistance

    At fault poin t : -

    V A = ?VB = (I B + I C) ZFVC = (I B + I C) ZF

    I A = 0I

    B= ?

    I C = ?IB + I C

    ZF

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults82

    Phase to Phase to Earth FaultB-C-E with Resistance

    At fau lt poin t

    I A = 0 ; V B = VC = ( I B + IC)ZF

    I A = I 1 + I 2 + I0 = 0 --------------------- (1)

    I0 = 1/3 ( I A + IB + I C) = 1/3 ( IB + I C)

    I B + I C = 3 I0

    V1 = 1/3 (V A + aV B + a 2VC ) = 1/3 [V A + (a 2 + a)V B] = 1/3 (V A - VB)

    V2 = 1/3 (V A + a 2VB + aV C ) = 1/3 [V A + (a 2 + a)V B] = 1/3 (V A - VB)

    V1 = V2 --------------------- (2)

    V0 = 1/3 (V A + VB + VC ) = 1/3 (V A + 2V B)

    V0 - V1 = 1/3 (V A + 2V B ) - 1/3 (V A - VB)

    = VB = (IB + IC)ZF = 3I 0ZF

    V1 = V0 - I0 (3Z F) --------------------- (3)

    I1F1

    N1

    V1+veSeqN/W

    I2F2

    N2

    V2-veSeqN/W

    I0F0

    N0

    V0ZeroSeqN/W

    3ZF

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    42/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults83

    4-wire Representation of/E Fault (1)

    Consider an earthed source.

    Total sequence impedances to fault

    = Z1, Z2, Z 0 i.e. Source + line

    E A

    EB

    ECC

    B

    AZ1, Z2, Z0

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults84

    4-wire Representation of /E Fault (2)

    Sequence Networks

    I1Z1

    I2

    I0

    Z2

    Z0

    E

    3 ZZ

    Z

    E

    3 ZZ

    Z

    3 Z2Z

    3 ZZZ

    E

    3

    )ZZ(Z E

    101

    A

    101A

    01A

    021A

    1021A

    0211

    +=

    +=

    +=

    ++=

    =++=++=

    4 Wire Equivalent Circu it

    E A

    EB

    EC

    Z1

    Z1

    Z1

    ZN = Z 0 - Z13

    10

    N

    N1

    AF

    3Z-Z

    Z

    where ZZ

    E I I

    =

    +

    ==

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    43/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults85

    3 Versus 1 Fault Level (1)

    XgXTE

    Xg XT

    E Z1 IF

    3

    1TgF Z

    E XX

    E +=

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults86

    3 Versus 1 Fault Level (2)

    Z0

    IF

    1 Xg1 XT1

    E

    Z2 = Z 1

    Z1

    Xg2 XT2

    Xg0 XT0

    I = +3E

    F 2Z Z1 0

  • 8/10/2019 Unbalanced Faults

    44/44

    > Analysis of UnbalancedFults87

    3 Versus 1 Fault Level (3)

    LEVEL FAULT 3 LEVEL FAULT 1

    Z Z IF

    Z2Z3E

    LEVEL FAULT 1

    Z2Z3E

    3Z3E

    ZE

    LEVEL FAULT 3

    10

    01

    1111

    >