Unconscous Oppression and Violence in Paradise

7/30/2019 Unconscous Oppression and Violence in Paradise

1/10

Wmklm{kalw{ Lvvzg{{alm bmh Saligmkg am Vbzbha{g

jq Kngi{gb Cgxkn

Xnzlwenlwx Xlma @lzza{lm{ Vbzbha{g) ul`gm am jlxn xng Klmsgmx bmh Zwjq bzg ljdgkxacagh)

klmxzliigh) bmh bjw{gh jq xng `gm bzlwmh xng` Xng Klmsgmx ul`gm bzg vza`g g~b`vig{ lc xna{? gbkn

nb{ nbh xngaz lum g~vgzagmkg uaxn ngbzxbkng) bjw{g) zbvg) bmh jgxzbqbi Nlugsgz) xng ul`gm lc Zwjq

bzg mlx czgg czl` klmxzli bmh lvvzg{{alm? klmezwgmx uaxn Czgwhabm v{qknlileq) xng `gm lc Zwjq bzg

hzasgm xl hl xngaz jg{x xl hlàmbxg xngaz uasg{ bmh hbwenxgz{ {g~wbiaxq bmh hbaiq iasg{ xl oggv xngaz

lum wmklm{kalw{ beezg{{alm bmh iw{x am kngko Xnzlwen {g~wbi bjw{g bmh lvvzg{{alm) xng `gm lc

Vbzbha{g ljdgkxacq ul`gm bmh zgxbam vbxzabzknbi klmxzli lc xng`{gisg{ bmh xng vglvig bzlwmh xng`

Xng wmklm{kalw{ hzasg gmxalmgh kl`g{ hazgkxiq czl` Czgwhabm v{qknlileq Bkklzhame xl

Czgwh{ Hqmbàk @lhgi) xng àmh a{ jzlogm wv amxl xul vbzx{xng klm{kalw{ bmh xng wmklm{kalw{

.Jzg{{igz 288! Am xna{ jb{ak `lhgi) xng wmklm{kalw{ a{ hzasgm jq xul jb{ak am{xamkx{ Lmg a{ xng {g~wbi

am{xamkx) lz iajahl) bmh xng lxngz a{ xng beezg{{asg am{xamkx .Jzg{{igz 288! Xnlwen Czgwh jgiagsgh xnbx

xng{g xul am{xamkx{ kbm ulzo xlegxngz) `lzg lcxgm xngq ugzg am klmciakx uaxn gbkn lxngz .Jzg{{igz 288-7!

Xnzlwenlwx Vbzbha{g) `bmq lc xng `big knbzbkxgz{ bvvgbz xl cliilu xna{ `lhgi lc Czgwhabm v{qknlileq?

xngq gaxngz g~najax {g~wbi hzasg{ lz saligmkg) w{ame lmg lc gbkn xl ljdgkxacq ul`gm Lm lmg nbmh) xng

ul`gm lc xng Klmsgmx bzg {g~wbiiq ljdgkxacagh? lm xng lxngz nbmh) `l{x `gm lc Zwjq bzg bjig xl klmxzli

xngaz wmklm{kalw{) xnlwen xngaz beezg{{asg am{xamkx{ caixgz xnzlwen) kwiàmbxame am xngaz hgka{alm xl zbah

xng Klmsgmx

Xng Klmsgmx bmh xng ul`gm am ax bzg bii sakxa`{ lc xng wmklm{kalw{ {g~wbi am{xamkx B{ Vgxgz

Ogbziq mlxg{ am na{ bzxakig lm Vbzbha{g) xng ul`gm bzg zghwkgh lz lvvzg{{gh am sbzalw{ ubq{4 @bsa{

a{ zghwkgh xl b kzaàmbi) am{bmg) amcbmx-oaiigz) Ezbkg zghwkgh xl b {iwx) [gmgkb zghwkgh xl b `b{lkna{x)

bmh Vbiib{ zghwkgh xl b hqog am xng vbxzabzknbi ibmewbeg lc mlm-bkkgvxbmkg .2;! Xng Klmsgmx ax{gic a{ b

`bm{alm `bhg xl {bxa{cq lmg `bm{ iw{x- Xnlwen xng mwm{ hah xngaz jg{x xl zah lj{kgmaxag{) namx{ {xaii


2/10

Cgxkn :

zg`bam4 mavvig-xavvgh hllzomlj{) mwhg {xbxwbzq) `big egmaxbiab xnbx nbh lmkg clz`gh cbwkgx{ bmh

omlj{) bmh bibjb{xgz sbeamb{ xnbx {gzsgh b{ b{nxzbq{ .@lzza{lm 5:!- @bmq lc xng{g cbmkacwi bmh gzlxak

bzxacbkx{ bzg iaxgzbiiq ljdgkxacqame ul`gm) b caxxame {q`jli lc unbx nbvvgm{ xl xng ul`gm bx xng

Klmsgmx Xna{ {q`jlia{` `bog{ xng Klmsgmx bm bvvzlvzabxg xg`vlzbzq zgcweg kzgbxgh jq bm amkiw{asg)

ha{vbzbxg ezlwv lc ul`gm .Hbg``zakn ::8!-

Gbkn lc xng Klmsgmx ul`gm ub{ {wjdgkxgh xl xng wmjzahigh iw{x lc `gm wmbjig xl klmxzli xngaz

wmklm{kalw{ @bsa{) lzaeambiiq b `bzzagh ul`bm uaxn knaihzgm) ub{ b {ibsg xl ngz nw{jbmh{ uaii- [ng

lcxgm cgix b cb`aiabz czaenx ungm ngz nw{jbmh kia`jgh amxl jgh uaxn ngz) bmh {ng ulzzagh bjlwx `boame

b `gbxilbc vgzcgkx gmlwen xnbx ax uaii vigb{g na` .@lzza{lm :7! Nlugsgz) clz bii ngz ulzo xl vigb{g

na`) Czbmo zbvgh na{ uacg jgclzg elame xl {iggv bx maenx- Jgkbw{g @bsa{ lcxgm ulmhgzgh bjlwx nlu

rwako ng uaii jg xnbx maenx) ax kbm jg b{{w`gh xnbx xna{ a{ mlx xng caz{x xa`g @bsa{ nb{ jggm zbvgh jq ngz

lum nw{jbmh .@lzza{lm :3!- Ibxgz) @bsa{ hg{kzajg{ {g~ uaxn ngz nw{jbmh b{ b zgrwazgh xlzxwzg) ilmegz

jwx mlx `wkn haccgzgmx czl` jgame {ibvvgh lwx lc ngz knbaz .@lzza{lm 252!- Klm{a{xgmx uaxn Czgwhabm

v{qknlileq) Czbmo igx{ @bsa{ jg xng {g~wbi lwxigx lc na{ wmklm{kalw{) ungxngz lz mlx {ng a{ uaiiame Xng

vbzxakwibz maenx uzaxxgm bjlwx am xng jllo a{ xng jzgboame vlamx clz @bsa{? {ng a{ cama{ngh uaxn xng bjw{g

{ng gmhwzg{ czl` ngz nw{jbmh bmh gsgm ngz lum knaihzgm) bmh {ng zwm{ bubq

Xng mg~x lc xng ul`gm xl gmh wv bx xng Klmsgmx) Eaea a{ bi{l bm ljdgkx lc iw{x) bmh xl `lzg xnbm

lmg `bm Gsgm czl` xng caz{x hg{kzavxalm lc Eaea{wvvl{g ngz mbsgi nbh mlx vggogh lsgz xng uba{x lc

ngz dgbm{ lz ngz jzgb{x{ nbh dw{x nw{ngh) nw{ngh clz b cgu {gklmh{{ng a{ ljdgkxacagh b{ b xname lc

sa{wbi vigb{wzg bmh iw{x .@lzza{lm 78! Gsgm Eaea{ rwg{x xl camh xng ilsg`boame klwvigungxngz ax a{ b

zlko clz`bxalm lz b xzgg{nlu{ xnbx {ng a{ {gbzkname clz {l`gxname `lzg xnbm xng w{g bmh bjw{g {ng

zgkgasg{ czl` iqame `gm bmh ilsgig{{ zgibxalm{nav{ Am {nlzx) Eaea ubmx{ xl camh vzllc xnbx xngzg a{ ilsg am

xng ulzih Clz OH) Eaea jgkl`g{ bm lwxigx clz na{ wmklmxzliibjig iw{x ungm Bzmgxxg a{ elmg Ungm Eaea


3/10

Cgxkn ;

cambiiq jzgbo{ lcc xng zgibxalm{nav) O-H-{ wmklm{kalw{ a``ghabxgiq xwzm{ xl saligmkg) naxxame Eaea bmh

kbw{ame xng lxngz Klmsgmx ul`gm xl clzkg OH lwx .@lzza{lm :73!

Amxgzg{xameiq) [gmgkb haccgz{ {iaenxiq czl` xng lxngz Klmsgmx ul`gm [gmgkb a{ sakxa` xl xnzgg

vglvig{ wmklm{kalw{ hzasg{4 Mlz`b{) ngz cl{xgz jzlxngz{) bmh ngz lum Unbx `bog{ [gmgkb{

{axwbxalm haccgzgmx a{ xnbx {ng a{ ljdgkxacagh jq jlxn `gm bmh ul`gm Mlz`b a{ b ul`bm [gmgkb lmiq

omgu clz xnzgg uggo{? xng {xzbmegz vbah [gmgkb xl iasg uaxn ngz) hlame unbxgsgz {ng b{ogh Ax a{ mgsgz

g~vzg{{iq {xbxgh unbx [gmgkb elg{ xnzlwen bx xna{ ul`bm{ nlw{g) lxngz xnbm b sbewg hg{kzavxalm lc

nw`aiabxalm _xnbxP bhg {wzzgmhgz hggv) xgmhgz- Ilme-ib{xame .@lzza{lm 2;5!- Ilme jgclzg xna{)

[gmgkb a{ xng sakxa` lc ngz cl{xgz jzlxngz{ hg{azg{- B{ ng xllo ngz kilxng{ lcc xl zbvg ngz) ng bkkahgmxiq

kwx{ ngz) kbw{ame jlxn lc na{ wmklm{kalw{ am{xamkx{ lc iw{x bmh beezg{{alm xl ulzo xlegxngz xl cggh na{

bkxalm{ .@lzza{lm :36! Amkahgmxbiiq) xna{ bi{l jgeam{ [gmgkb{ bjw{g lc ngz{gic? xna{ kwx kbw{gh ngz

wmklm{kalw{ beezg{{asg hg{azg{ xl amciwgmkg ngz amxl kwxxame ngz{gic Am xng gmh) [gmgkb {xlv{ kwxxame

ngz{gic) jwx ngz beezg{{asg wmklm{kalw{ {xaii gmklwzbeg{ ngz xl `bzo xng lvgm jlhq iqame lm xng kgiibz

cillz .@lzza{lm :37!-

B{ clz Vbiib{) xng `bm {ng xnamo{ a{ ngz jlqczagmh w{g{ ngz Kbzil{) clz bii na{ knbz` bmh

egmxig`bmiq bkxalm{) a{ hzasgm jq na{ wmklm{kalw{) wixa`bxgiq jgxzbqame Vbiib{ jq {iggvame uaxn ngz lum

`lxngz Ng hlg{ xna{ gsgm bcxgz xgiiame ngz xnbx xngq {nlwih ubax clz `bzzabeg xl nbsg {g~ .@lzza{lm

235! Jgkbw{g Vbiib{ xwzm{ lwx xl jg vzgembmx) bmh {ng mgsgz zgsgbi{ xng cbxngz lc ngz knaih) ax kbm gaxngz

jg vzg{w`gh xnbx Kbzil{ wixa`bxgiq nbh {g~ uaxn ngz) lz xnbx {ng ub{ zbvgh unaig naxknnaoame Gaxngz

ubq) Vbiib{) iaog xng lxngz Klmsgmx ul`gm) nb{ jggm w{gh b{ bm ljdgkx lc `gm{ iajahl- Vbiib{ haccgz{

czl` Bzmgxxg) xng lmiq lxngz eazi xl {nlu wv bx xng Klmsgmx vzgembmx) jgkbw{g {ng hgkahg{ xl oggv bmh

ilsg ngz knaih am{xgbh lc egxxame zah lc na`

[a`aibz xl unbx nbvvgm{ xl Vbiib{) Klm{libxb a{ {g~wbiiq w{gh jq {l`glmg {ng ilsg{ [ng bmh

Hgbklm @lzebm nbsg b ilme-xa`g bccbaz) `ggxame gsgzq Czahbq xl `bog ilsg .@lzza{lm :;6! Klm{libxb a{


4/10

Cgxkn 8

mlx zbvgh? b{ b `bxxgz lc cbkx) {ng {gg`{ xl xzwiq ilsg Hgbklm Nlugsgz) ungm {ng jgeam{ xl `bog ilme-

xgz` vibm{ bmh {nbzg xng` uaxn na`) iaog ngz {weeg{xalm xnbx ng sa{ax{ ngz am b {`bii zll` am xng kgiibz

lz b nl`g bubq czl` nl`g ungzg xngq kbm bi`l{x jg b cbàiq) Hgbklm jzgbo{ lcc xng bccbaz .@lzza{lm

:;5! Wixa`bxgiq) Hgbklm w{gh Klm{libxb b{ bm lwxigx clz na{ {g~wbi hzasg) unakn ng bhàx{ xl Zgsgzgmh

@a{mgz) {vgboame lc b ul`bm ng nbh w{gh? nlu ng nbh xwzmgh wv na{ ml{g bx ngz jgkbw{g ngz ill{g bmh

gb{q ubq{ ebsg na` iakgm{g xl hzlv bmh hg{va{g ngz .@lzza{lm ;6:!-

Xnlwen `bmq lc xng `gm xng Klmsgmx ul`gm gmklwmxgzgh bzg vza`bzaiq hzasgm jq xngaz

wmklm{kalw{ {g~wbi hg{azg{) xng `gm lc Zwjq bzg sgzq haccgzgmx Xnlwen xngzg bzg {l`g g~kgvxalm{

OH bmh Hgbklm) clz g~b`vig`bmq lc Zwjq{ `big{ {xzweeig {ligiq uaxn xngaz beezg{{asg am{xamkx{

Amezah Hbg``zakn `bog{ bm g~kgiigmx vlamx am uzaxame xnbx xng mlsgi lvgm{ uaxn `big beezg{{alm .:;!

Wmiaog xng sakxaàtgz{ lc xng Klmsgmx ul`gm) unl ugzg wmbjig xl klmxzli xngaz {g~wbi am{xamkx{) xng `gm

lc Zwjq bzg `wkn `lzg klmxzliigh bmh vzbkxakgh Xngq ulzo nbzh mlxxl igx xngaz saligmx {wjklm{kalw{

amciwgmkg xng`? bx igb{x) mlx am ubq{ xnbx ulwih nbz` bmlxngz vgz{lm Am xng gmh) nlugsgz) hg{vaxg

xngaz bxxg`vx{ xl oggv xngaz beezg{{alm am kngko) mamg `gm `bog b hgka{alm xl `b{{bkzg ul`gm) b

knlakg ml hlwjx amciwgmkgh jq xngaz wmklm{kalw{

OH bmh Hgbklm) b{ `gmxalmgh gbziagz) jlxn {wjàx xngaz {g~wbi am{xamkx{) bx igb{x clz b unaig

Clz OH) xng xul vza`lzhabi am{xamkx{ ulzo b{ gmgàg{ lc gbkn lxngz) lmg biubq{ `lzg amciwgmxabi xnbm

xng lxngz Gsgm bx xng jgeammame lc xng mlsgi) OH {xzweeig{ uaxn na{ iajahl bmh saligmx xgmhgmkag{

Hg{kzajgh b{ b nbmh{l`g `bm) OH a{ mlx xng knb{xg) nbzh-ulzoame qlwme `bm na{ wmkig{ ulwih iaog na`

xl jg Am{xgbh) ng ulwih `lzg xnbm iaogiq jg kbiigh b ibhag{ `bm- Vgznbv{ O-H-{ amkzgb{gh iajahl nb{

{wkn amciwgmkg lsgz na` jgkbw{g ng mgsgz ub{ b àiaxbzq `bm) b{ Dgcc Ciggxullh ilsg{ xl zgàmh na`?

xngzg ub{ ml saligmkg clz na{ beezg{{asg am{xamkx xl cggh lm) {l na{ {g~wbi am{xamkx xllo lsgz .@lzza{lm

273!- Unbxgsgz xng zgb{lm) O-H- nb{ vzlvl{axalmgh Jaiiag Hgiab jgclzg bmh bcxgz na{ xname uaxn Bzmgxxg)


5/10

Cgxkn 7

nb{ elxxgm Bzmgxxg vzgembmx) nbh bm bii-{g~ zgibxalm{nav uaxn Eaea) bmh knb{gh bmq hzg{{ unl{g ugbzgz

ub{ wmhgz cacxq .@lzza{lm 27:!-

Jwx) gsgm O-H-{ xul wmklm{kalw{ am{xamkx{ bzg bx ubz uaxn gbkn lxngz? ng mlx lmiq vwjiakiq {ibv{

Bzmgxxg) {vwzzame b xgm{g zasbizq jgxuggm xng @lzebm{ bmh xng Ciggxullh{ xnbx jgegx{ `lzg saligmx

bkxalm{) jwx ng bi{l {xzaog{ Eaea .@lzza{lm 77) :73! Cambiiq) jgkbw{g OH xbog{ b vbzx am xng Klmsgmx

zbah) na{ hg{xzwkxasg am{xamkx wixa`bxgiq uam{ lsgz Gbkn xa`g lmg lc O-H-{ am{xamkx{ amciwgmkg{ na`) ng

nwzx{) w{g{) bmh ljdgkxacag{ bx igb{x lmg ul`bm) unakn klwih vbzbiigi na` xl gbkn lc xng `gm unl nwzx)

jgxzbq) bmh zbvg xng Klmsgmx ul`gm Jgkbw{g lc na{ uaiiamemg{{ xl {g~wbiiq w{g bmh vnq{akbiiq bjw{g

ul`gm) xng qlwme `bm ljsalw{iq hlg{ mlx vgzkgasg ul`gm b{ grwbi xl `gm

[a`aibz xl na{ mgvngu) Hggo @lzebm klmciakx{ uaxn jlxn na{ {g~wbi am{xamkx bmh na{ beezg{{asg

am{xamkx Hgbklm{ bccbaz uaxn Klm{libxb {nlu{ xnbx ng nb{ xzlwjig klmxzliiame na{ {g~wbi wmklm{kalw{

Ungm Klm{libxb jaxg{ na{ iav) xng hgkahame vlamx clz Hggo xnbx xng bccbaz a{ lsgz) xng {axwbxalm a{ {a`aibz xl

ungm [gmgkb{ cl{xgz jzlxngz clzkg{ na`{gic wvlm ngz- Klm{libxb) bx caz{x) a{ g~kaxgh jq ngz za{oq bkxalm

lc hzbuame jillh czl` ngz ilsgz) dw{x b{ xng cl{xgz jzlxngz ezgu g~kaxgh ungm ng bkkahgmxiq kwx [gmgkb

Hgbklm) am{xgbh lc jgame hzasgm jq na{ lum beezg{{asg wmklm{kalw{ iaog [gmgkb) a{ caz{x {xbzxigh) xngm

zgslixgh bx unbx Klm{libxb nb{ hlmg .@lzza{lm :;1!- B ubz sgxgzbm) Hgbklm a{ mlx b {xzbmegz xl

saligmkg Bcxgz xna{ vlamx) Hgbklm hlg{ na{ jg{x xl xzq bmh klmxzli na{ wmklm{kalw{) xnlwen ng hlg{ mlx

kl`vigxgiq {wkkggh Xng beezg{{asg am{xamkx {xaii amciwgmkg{ Hggo) unl egx{ wv gbziq am xng `lzmame xl

nwmx{ rwbai xl oggv na{ lum _ngbhP czl` g~vilhame .@lzza{lm 268!- Gsgm xnlwen ng xnamo{ bjlwx ax b{

b mgkg{{bzq xngzbvq) ng {xaii egx{ {bxa{cbkxalm omluame xnbx ibxgz xlhbq) rwbai uaxnlwx xngaz jzbam{ ulwih

`gix am na{ `lwxn .@lzza{lm 265!-

Hggo{ xuam) [xgubzh) a{ bmlxngz g~b`vig lc b `bm {xzweeiame uaxn na{ wmklm{kalw{ wzeg{

Nlugsgz) [xgubzh a{ haccgzgmx xnbm Hggo) OH) lz xng lvvzg{{lz{ lc xng Klmsgmx ul`gm) jgkbw{g na{

wmklm{kalw{ am{xamkx{ bzg mlx klmciakxame uaxn lmg bmlxngz- Zbxngz) [xgubzh{ beezg{{asg am{xamkx {gg`{


6/10

Cgxkn 3

xl jg xng lmg biubq{ amciwgmkame na` Am klmxzb{x uaxn na{ xuam) [xgubzh a{ `wkn `lzg slkbi bmh czbmo

ungm {l`gxname vzlslog{ na{ beezg{{asg am{xamkx{ Ungm Hgiab) b iaenxgz-{oammgh ul`bm) ub{ caz{x

amxzlhwkgh xl xng xlum) [xgubzh ub{ xng caz{x xl {vgbo) {bqame Ng{ _@gmw{P jzamame bilme xng hwme ug

igbsame jgnamh .@lzza{lm :62!- Ungm Zgsgzgmh @a{mgz bxxg`vx{ xl zba{g `lmgq clz jibko jlq{

uzlmecwiiq a`vza{lmgh) [xgubzh zgcw{g{ xl easg `lmgq xl iaxxig aiigebi maeegz{ uaxn ewm{ bmh ml nl`g

xzbamame .@lzza{lm :63!- Nlugsgz) [xgubzh a{ xng lmg unl kbzzag{ b ewm bmh g`jlhag{ b {vazax lc

àiaxbzq beezg{{alm .Ogiigz 81!- B{ b `bxxgz lc cbkx) [xgubzh {gg`{ xl jg xng am{xaebxlz lc xng mamg `gm

unl zbah xng Klmsgmx) bmh a{ bi{l xng caz{x lmg xl vwii xng xzaeegz Ng bmh na{ jzlxngz bzg) bcxgz bii) mlx

lmiq xng xlum lc Zwjq{ kasak igbhgz{ jwx ax{ cambmkabi igbhgz{ b{ ugii .Dgmoam{ :>8!- [xgubzh vgznbv{

w{gh xna{ wvvgz nbmh xl vgz{wbhg xng lxngz `gm Ilmg mlxg{ nlu [xgubzh {ggxngh bx xng xnlwenx lc

xnbx jbzgiq bsgzxgh jgxzbqbi lc bii xngq lugh bmh vzlà{gh xng Lih Cbxngz{) zgcgzzame xl [xgubzh{

omluigheg lc na{ jzlxngz{ bccbaz uaxn Klm{libxb .@lzza{lm :51! Clz qgbz{) [xgubzh nb{ igx bmegz bmh

beezg{{alm jwaih am{ahg na`) wmxai bii _ngP mggh{ xl {gg bzg ngz {gm{wbi bvvzba{ame gqg{ xl vwii xng xzaeegz

bebam .@lzza{lm :>7!-

Bii xng `gm xboame vbzx am xng zbah g~vgzagmkg jlxn vbzx{ lc xngaz {wjklm{kalw{ ulzoame

nbz`lmalw{iq bx xnbx vlamx- Lmkg xng caz{x ul`bm a{ {nlx) xngq bzg {xbzxigh) jwx mlx hgxgzzgh czl`

{xgvvame lsgz ngz) xngm jgeam clmhiame xngaz ugbvlm{) cggiame {whhgmiq {l qlwme bmh ellh xngq bzg

zgàmhgh xnbx ewm{ bzg `lzg xnbm hgklzbxalm) amxaàhbxalm lz kl`clzx .@lzza{lm :>7!- Xng{g iamg{

vlamx xl jlxn `big jlmhame bmh xng {g~wbi zw{n lc ubz) saligmkg) bmh vlugz) zg{wixame am bm amciwgmkg

czl` jlxn vza`lzhabi am{xamkx{ .Ogiigz 7:! Jgame bm g~kiw{asg `big ezlwv) jlmhame b{ ac {lihagz{ am wmax)

{gvbzbxg{ xng` czl` xng ul`gm) ngivame xng `gm hgxbkn xng`{gisg{ czl` xng a``lzbiaxq lc xng

aiileakbi bkx xngq bzg vgzclzàme

Cwzxngz`lzg) xng xlum lc Zwjq a{ wmhgz b vbxzabzknbi klmxzli Xng `gm lc xng xlum) hgvakxgh b{

mbxwzbiiq) azzghgg`bjiq {g~a{x bmh saligmxiq hlàmggzame klmxzli xngaz uasg{) unl bzg zgebzhgh b{


7/10

Cgxkn 5

{aigmx) {wvvlzxasg vbzxmgz{) jwx xng knaihzgm lc xng xlum b{ ugii .Zgbh 7:5) Hbg``zakn ::7! Xng

Lsgm a{ bm g~kgiigmx g~b`vig? unbx lmkg ugzg ulzh{ xl xnzgbxgm xnl{g unl ha{biilugh Zwjq{ kaxatgm{

nb{ gslisgh am amxgmxalm xl mlu `gbm Jgubzg xng Bmegz lc lwz Vbxzabzkn{ .Ogiigz 76!- Bmq {lzx lc

knbmeg lz zgjgiiame am xng qlwmegz egmgzbxalm a{ sagugh b{ {wjsgz{asg jq xng `gm am klmxzli

.Hbg``zakn ::7! Bcxgz bii) ungm xng qlwxn lc xng xlum {weeg{x ax jg knbmegh) [xgubzh xnzgbxgm{

zbxngz saligmxiq ac qlw) bmq lmg lc qlw) aemlzg) knbmeg) xbog bubq) lz bhh xl xng ulzh{ am xng `lwxn lc

xnbx Lsgm) A uaii jilu qlwz ngbh lcc dw{x iaog qlw ub{ b nllh-gqg {mbog .@lzza{lm >5!-

B{ bmlxngz g~b`vig) Bzmgxxg) unl gmh{ wv vzgembmx czl` OH) zw{ng{ lcc xl xng Klmsgmx xl

bjlzx ngz{gic uaxn xng ew{xl bmh amxgmxalm lc b zbjah `big .@lzza{lm :76!- Clz xng Ciggxullh{)

Bzmgxxg{ vzgembmkq bzg hggviq {nb`gcwi) wm`bmiq cbaiame{ bmh ngz cgbz bx cbkame ngz cbxngz) jzlxngz)

bmh xng xlum b{ bm wmugh `lxngz hzasg ngz xl oaii ngz lum knaih .Zgbh 7;;! Xnlwen ml lmg lzhgz{

Bzmgxxg xl egx zah lc ngz knaih) {ng bvvbzgmxiq clwmh ax mgkg{{bzq xl camh b `gbm{ xl ha{vl{g lc axbmh

jib`g ngz bkxalm{ lm xng Klmsgmx) dw{x xl jg bjig xl `bzzq OH bmh klmxamwg iasame am Zwjq uaxnlwx xng

{xae`b lc jgame xng cb{xg{x eazi am xlum bmh {vgghame wv jq xng {gklmh) iaog Jaiiag Hgiab .@lzza{lm 71!-

Bkklzhame xl Zgbh) Bzmgxxg{ vzlà{kwaxq am vbzx a{ xng cbwix lc ngz jzlxngz bmh cbxngz) unl nbsgmx easgm

Bzmgxxg xb{o{ klm{ahgzgh xl jg bvvzlvzabxg cg`big jgnbsalz) igbsame ml lvvlzxwmaxq clz a``lzbi

bkxasaxq .7;3!- Xnlwen xng `gm lc xng xlum g~gzx {l `wkn gmgzeq xzqame xl oggv xngaz uasg{ bmh

hbwenxgz{ czl` xng xg`vxbxalm lc vzlà{kwaxq) xng {b`g zwig{ ljsalw{iq hl mlx bvviq xl xng`) {amkg

Hgbklm bmh OH jlxn nbsg `wixavig {g~wbi vbzxmgz{ Gsgm jgclzg xna{) xng vbxzabzkn{ lc Zwjq lsgzzwig

xng ul`gm bmh biilu Hgiab xl hag {a`viqjgkbw{g ngz {oam zgvzg{gmx{ zbkabi xb`vgzame) unakn

zgàmh{ xng >-zlko{ mlx lc amxzbzbkabi jgxzbqbi jwx lc amxgzzbkabi lvvzg{{alm .Dgmoam{ :5>!- Jgclzg xng

Klmsgmx ul`gm nbh kl`g) xng `gm ugzg bizgbhq uaiiame xl {bkzacakg b iacg

Lsgzbii) Vbzbha{g a{ b sgzq amxgzg{xame bmh kl`viakbxgh mlsgi) uaxn `bmq haccgzgmx xng`g{ bmh

amxgzvzgxbxalm{ B{ `bmq kzaxak{ bmh cgàma{x{ bzg ulmx xl vlamx lwx) xng mlsgi a{ zavg uaxn gsahgmkg lc


8/10

Cgxkn >

{g~a{`) amkiwhame b klmxzliiame) vbxzabzknbi {xzwkxwzg am Zwjq) {wj`a{{asg bmh {aigmx uasg{) bmh sbzalw{

clz`{ lc zbvg bmh bjw{g b`lme{x xng Klmsgmx ul`gm Jlxn xng `gm lc Zwjq bmh xng `gm xng Klmsgmx

ul`gm gmklwmxgz nbsg vbzx{ am ljdgkxacqame ul`gm) bmh g~gzxame {l`g {lzx lc klmxzli lsgz xng` am

zg{vlm{g xl xngaz wmklm{kalw{ amciwgmkg{ W{ame Czgwh{ Hqmb`ak @lhgi) xng wmklm{kalw{ amciwgmkg{ lc

xng {g~wbi am{xamkx bmh beezg{{asg am{xamkx ngiv bkklwmx clz `l{x lc xng saligmkg bmh bjw{g vgzclz`gh jq

xng `gm am xng mlsgi


9/10

Cgxkn 1

Ulzo{ Kaxgh,Bmmlxbxgh Jajialezbvnq

Jzg{{igz) Knbzig{ G Iaxgzbzq Kzaxaka{`4 Bm Amxzlhwkxalm xl Xnglzq bmh Vzbkxakg 8xn gh Wvvgz [bhhig

Zasgz4 Vgbz{lm Ghwkbxalm) Amk) :665 Vzamx

Am {vgkacak) A uaii jg w{ame Knbvxgz 3) unakn a{ bjlwx v{qknlbmbiqxak kzaxaka{` Jb{akbiiq) Jzg{{igz

easg{ b sgzq hgxbaigh na{xlzq bmh g~vibmbxalm lc sbzalw{ kzaxaka{`{ Clz v{qknlbmbiq{a{) A uaii jg clkw{ame

lm Czgwh- Clz `q vbvgz) A amxgmh xl clkw{ lm Czgwh{ Hqmb`ak @lhgi lc xng nw`bm v{qkng) xl {nlu xnbx

xng `gm am Zwjq bzg wmklm{kalw{iq hzasgm jq beezg{{alm bmh b {g~wbi hzasg

Hbg``zakn) Amezah Vbzbha{g bmh [xlzqxgiiame4 Amxgzklmmgkxame Egmhgz) @lxac) bmh Mbzzbxasg [xzwkxwzg-

Mbzzbxasg 22: .:66;!4 :2;-:;; Vzldgkx @w{g 3 Hgk :626

Hbg``zakn{ bzxakig bmbiqtg{ xng `lxac{ bmh kiakn{ lc `l{x {xlzag{) mlsgi{) bmh mbzzbxasg{

hgbiame uaxn vbzbha{g [ng jgeam{ uaxn b ilme hg{kzavxalm lc xng `lxac{ lc xng{g xqvg{ lc {xlzag{)

jgeammame uaxn Ezggo @qxnlileq) bmh bmbiqtg{ xng sbzalw{ egmhgz {xgzglxqvg{ bmh {q`jlia{`

xnzlwenlwx bii lc xng` Xng bzxakig kl`vbzg{ Zwjq bmh xng Klmsgmx b{ xul {gvbzbxg vbzbha{g{) xnw{vaxxame xng xul klmciakxame sa{alm{ lc vbzbha{g bebam{x gbkn lxngz [ng kl`vbzg{ xng vbxzabzknbi bmh zaeah

{xzwkxwzg lc xng xlum xl xng xg`vlzbzq ul`gm{ nbsgm xnbx a{ xng klmsgmx) klmxzb{xame xng `lxasbxalm{

lc xng `gm lc Zwjq uaxn xng ul`gm [ng hlg{ mlx easg sgzq `bmq hgxbai{ lz xg~xwbi {wvvlz) mlz hlg{

{ng ha{kw{{ Vbzbha{g xnzlwenlwx) jwx xng amclz`bxalm {ng hlg{ nbsg bjlwx egmhgz `lxac{ uaii jg sgzq

w{gcwi xl `q vbvgz) g{vgkabiiq ungm A kl`vbzg xng xul egmhgz{ bmh xngaz {g~wbiaxq A kbm gsgm w{g ax xl

ngiv {wvvlzx xng v{qknlbmbiqxak b{vgkx lc `q ulzo

Ogiigz) Hgilzg{ B *Xlma @lzza{lm%{ [gz`lm lm @bmnllh4 Elh am xng Nbmh{ lc Mamg Bmezq [ammgz{*

@ahug{x Rwbzxgziq722 .:661!4 87-73 GJ[KL @gebCAIG GJ[KL Ugj 5 Hgk :626Xna{ bzxakig clkw{g{ lm xng `gm lc Zwjq) {vgkacakbiiq Hgbklm bmh [xgubzh Ogiigz kbii{Vbzbha{g b

{gz`lm lm `bmnllh) kl`vbzame ax xl Dlmbxnbm Ghubzh{ [ammgz{ am xng Nbmh{ lc bm Bmezq Elh

{gz`lm Jgkbw{g xng bwxnlz vzlsahg{ vigmxq lc hgxbai bjlwx unbx `aenx nbsg hzasgm xng `gm lc Zwjq xl

oaii xng Klmsgmx ul`gm) b{ ugii b{ xngaz lvvzg{{asg bxxaxwhg{ xlubzh{ xng Klmsgmx ul`gm) xna{ bzxakig a{

sbiwbjig ungm ha{kw{{ame b v{qknlbmbiqxak bvvzlbkn xl xng `gm{ saligmx jgnbsalz- Ogiigz jzagciq

`gmxalm{ xnbx xng mamg `gm amsbhame xng Klmsgmx g~vgzagmkg b {lzx lc {g~wbi gmgzeq bx xng xnlwenx lc

a`vgmhame saligmkg .7:!) unakn vzlsahg{ vaslxbi {wvvlzx clz `q vbvgz Xna{ bzxakig) nlugsgz) hlg{ iaxxig

xl xbio bjlwx xng ul`gm am Zwjq bmh xngaz zgibxalm{nav{ xl xng `gm

@lzza{lm) Xlma Vbzbha{g Mv4 Caz{x Viw`g Vzamxame) 2111 Vzamx

Zgbh) Bmhzgu- B{ Ac Ulzh @beak Nbh Bmqxname xl Hl uaxn xng Klwzbeg ax Xllo xl Jg b @bm4 Jibko

@b{kwiamaxq am Xlma @lzza{lm{ Vbzbha{g-Bczakbm B gzakbm Zgsagu;18 .:667!4 7:5-76

GJ[KLnl{x Ugj :; Mls :626


10/10

Cgxkn 26

Xna{ bzxakig elg{ sgzq am-hgvxn uaxn unbx `b{kwiamaxq `gbm{ am xng xlum lc Zwjq) bmh xng sbzalw{

ubq{ xng `gm lc Zwjq xzq xl `ggx xng {xbmhbzh{ lc lxngz{ Clz g~b`vig) Zgbh kl`vbzg{ xng ubq xng

`gm lc Zwjq bkx xl xng {xgzglxqvakbi B`gzakbm Hzgb` unaxg `big- Xng bzxakig bi{l ha{kw{{g{

{xgzglxqvg{ bmh wm{vlogm zwig{ am Zwjq- Cwzxngz`lzg) Zgbh ha{kw{{g{ xng lwxjwz{x{ lc saligmkg xng

`gm lc Zwjq ha{vibq) bmh xng vbxzabzknbi hg{azg xl klmxzli xng ul`gm{ {g~wbi iasg{- A uaii w{g xna{ xl

ngiv {wvvlzx `q kiba`{ lm xng `amh{gx lc xng `gm) bmh xngaz wmklm{kalw{ hzasg xlubzh{ saligmkg Xng

ahgb lc xng `gm klmxzliiame Zwjq ul`gm{ {g~wbiaxq a{ bi{l b sgzq amxgzg{xame klmkgvx xnbx A kbm xag amxl

`q xng{a{ bmh xng Czgwhabm bmbiq{a{

Ogbziq) Vgxgz Z *Xlma @lzza{lm%{ Vbzbha{g bmh xng Vliaxak{ lc Kl``wmaxq* Xng Dlwzmbi lc B`gzakbm

Kwixwzg :;: .:666!4 1-23 G-Dlwzmbi{ GJ[KL Ugj :; Mls :626

Ogbziq{ vza`bzq vwzvl{g am xna{ bzxakig a{ xl bmbiqtg Vbzbha{g bmh gmklwzbeg zgbhgz{ unl `bq

nbsg {nwmmgh xng mlsgi xl xbog b {gklmh illo Xna{ bzxakig easg{ b haccgzgmx illo bx unq `gm klmxzli xng

{lkagxq am Zwjq Xng bwxnlz xbio{ bjlwx `gm klmxzliiame zgiaealm am bii lc na{xlzq) bmbiqtg{ `a{leqmq am

xng xlum{ kwixwzg) bmh amxgzg{xameiq xbio{ bjlwx xng ul`gm{ bxxaxwhg{ xlubzh{ `gm- Xng bwxnlzha{kw{{g{ ileak) amkiwhame xng `gm{ ileak lc klmxzli bmh vwma{n`gmx) bmh xng Klmsgmx ul`gm{ ileak lc

ngbiame bmh {g~wbi g~vzg{{alm amhgvgmhgmx lc `big bwxnlzaxq G{vgkabiiq lm vbeg 2;) Ogbziq bmbiqtg{ xng

{g~wbi bjw{g xng Klmsgmx ul`gm nbsg {wccgzgh) bmh ha{kw{{g{ xng v{qknlileq lc bm bjw{gh ul`bm A

kbm w{g xna{ xl mlx lmiq cwzxngz g~vibam xng `big klmxzli lc xng xlum) jwx ha{kw{{ nlu xng ul`gm lc

Zwjq bmh xng Klmsgmx zgbkx xl xng xzgbx`gmx xngq zgkgasg Xng {w``bzatbxalm Ogbziq easg{ lc xng {g~wbi

bjw{g xng ul`gm nbsg {wccgzgh uaii mlx lmiq jg b ellh zgcgzgmkg) jwx bi{l vzlsahg{ mgu ahgb{

Dgmoam{) Kbmhakg *Vwzg Jibko4 Kib{{) Klilz) bmh Amxzbzbkabi Vliaxak{ am Xlma @lzza{lm%{ Vbzbha{g* @C[

@lhgzm Cakxalm [xwhag{ 7:: .:663!4 :56-13 Vzldgkx @W[G Ugj :; Mls :626

Xna{ bzxakig ha{kw{{g{ zbkg bmh xng ahgb lc bm bii-jibko {lkagxq Xngzg bzg `bmq g~b`vig{ lc xng

Jillh Zwig lc Zwjq) b{ ugii b{ mlxame xng bkxalm{ lc iaenxgz-klilzgh jibko{ bmh unaxg{ xnbx bvvgbz am xng

mlsgi Xnlwen xng bzxakig clkw{g{ lm zbkg) mlx egmhgz) Dgmoam{ hlg{ vlamx lwx sbzalw{ egmhgz haccgzgmkg{

am Zwjq) g{vgkabiiq vbeg{ :5>->6 Unbx `bog{ xna{ bzxakig b ezgbx b{{gx xl `q g{{bq a{ xnbx ax ha{kw{{g{

{g~a{` am xgz`{ lc klilz? xng ubq knbzbkxgz{ bzg {nwmmgh bmh hgg`gh b{ ig{{ a`vlzxbmx mlx lmiq clz

xngaz {g~ jwx jgkbw{g xngq bzg mlx >-zlko{- Lm vbeg :>6) Dgmoam{ bi{l `gmxalm{ bmh bmbiqtg{ xng

b{{w`gh {g~wbi hgvzbsaxq lc ul`gm unl bzg iaenxgz-{oammgh) unakn uaii ngiv {wvvlzx `q kiba` xnbx xng

ul`gm lc Zwjq bzg {g~wbiiq bjw{gh am ubq{ lxngz xnbm vnq{akbi b{{bwix bmh zbvg

Documents

Unconscous Oppression and Violence in Paradise