1
ALEKSANDRA DIMOVA M.D. PhD Contact: [email protected] | www.sinn-evaluation.at Looking at the traditional model (Fig.1), the following questions arise: 1. What happens in the timespan between the moment of assessment of a threat and the manifestation of the mentioned symptoms? 2. Is there another explanatory model which reasonably clarifies the double nature of the ANS, HPA and HPT Axis. e way to the answers starts from the symptoms observed in stress: tensed muscles and the F/F response, and goes backwards. MODEL ASSUMPTION e same symptoms observed in stress are also observed in the cold shock. (Fig 2) From the point of view of thermoregulation, the function of these symptoms is an achievement of a positive heat balance and regain of the body temperature set-point. FACTUM There is no change of physiological functioning level, without priory dis- turbed homeostasis, and priory change of the body temperature. e equality of the observed symptoms in stress and in cold shock must have the same function: increasing the dropped body temperature. It means that the stress caused a real loss of body heat and brought the body in stress induced hypothermia. e reason for that lies in the act of assessment of the event as threat. All the above mentioned symptoms have common genesis: one primary cen- tral GABAergic hypofunction (stress induced GABAergic hypofunction). Under GABAergic hypofunction, the serotonin (5-HT), norepinephrine (NE) and dopamine (DA), all controlled by GABA, manifest one secondary hyperfunction. (Fig 3) e relationship between stress (threat), mental, and physical disorders has been well documented. e physiological responses to the stress, the activa- tion of the autonomic nervous system (ANS) with its “fight-or-flight” response (F/F response) and the activation of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) and thyroid axis (HPT) (Fig.1) are the traditional concept of the stress–individual interaction. e F/F response one has been especially seen as existential for survival of the individual faced with one threatening event. THE PROBLEM OF THE TRADITIONAL CONCEPT e F/F response, activated HPA and HPT Axis change their function toward the body during a time - from protector to destroyer - starting to ruin the body in form of physical disorders, shortening the lifespan of the indi- vidual exposed to the stress. CONCLUSION e changed physiological function level observed by a stress (threat) is in duty of keeping the set point of the body temperature, exploiting the energy reserves of the individual until the set point is reached. THE NEW IN THIS MODEL 1. Assessment of one event as a threat caused one real, stress induced hypothermia. 2. e stress induced hypothermia leads to primary central GABAergic hypofunction and secondary hyperfunction of 5-HT, NA and DA. Physi- ological and behavioral responses observed in stress (threat) are just adaptive reactions to one real loss of body temperature. 3. Comorbidity: the psychological/psychiatric responses are just “a part of the game”, a collateral damage in the trial of the body to regain the set point of the body temperature, which was decreased with assessment of one event as a threat. IMPACT OF THE NEW MODEL 1. In the prevention: the threatening events (stress factors) have to be very early recognized as such. Keeping in mind that stress induced hypothermia will influence the psycho-physical condition on a long run, supportive actions should be provided as early as possible. 2. In the general treatment of comorbid disorders: a) e psychotherapeutic treatment has to be the first choice of treatment, focused on a positive reframing of the threatening events for a person, resource winning oriented. b) e pharmacological treatment has to be focused on regaining the dis- turbed balance GABA/5-HT, NA, which play the main role in the etiology of the stress induced mental and physical disorders. 3. In the research: the observed psycho-physiological reactions on assessed threat are one more proof about the influence of the consciousness over quantum mechanical phenomena. UNDERSTANDING THE COMORBIDITY OF STRESS, DEPRESSIVE AND SOMATIC DISORDERS ONE NOVEL MULTI-DIMENSIONAL MODEL Aleksandra Dimova Information induced hypothermia of the body of assessor Primary, central GABAergic hypofunction Symptoms of primary GABAergic hypofunction and secondary 5-HT, NE, DA hyperfunction CENTRAL MOTOR SYSTEM HYPOTHALAMUS Increased activity of Sympathicus Stimulation of HPA and HPT Axis Immediate Psychological answer Fear Immediate answer Peripheral Vasocon- striction Piloerection Increased heart rate Delayed answer Stimulation of Adrenal medulla High blood pressure Diabetes mellitus etc. Increased cortisol level •Metabolic syndrome •Osteoporosis etc. Delayed answer •PTSD •Adjustment disorder •Psychosomatic disorders etc. OTHER CNS REGIONS Tensed muscle Dyspnoe Shivering Delayed answer Chronic Fatique syndrome Fibromialgia COMORBIDITY EVENT CNS: ASSESSMENT OF TREAT COMORBIDITY Increased activity of Sympathicus Dysfunction of HPA and HPT Axis Immediate Psychological answer Fear Immediate answer Peripheral Vasoconstriction Piloerection Increased heart rate Delayed answer Stimulation of Adrenal medulla High blood pressure Diabetes mellitus etc. Increased cortisol level •Metabolic syndrome •Osteoporosis etc. Delayed answer •PTSD •Adjustment disorder •Psychosomatic disorders etc. OTHER CNS REGIONS EVENT CNS: ASSESSMENT OF TREAT ? Tensed muscles + activated ANS Cold shock Treat Fig. 1: Traditional concept of the stress – individual interaction Fig 2. Equality between cold shock and stress (threat). Fig. 3. Multi-disciplinary model of event-individual interaction (A. Dimova) Missing Link Traditional Concept

UNDERSTANDING THE COMORBIDITY OF STRESS, DEPRESSIVE …

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: UNDERSTANDING THE COMORBIDITY OF STRESS, DEPRESSIVE …

ALEKSANDRA DIMOVA M.D. PhDContact: [email protected] | www.sinn-evaluation.at

Looking at the traditional model (Fig.1), the following questions arise:1. What happens in the timespan between the moment of assessment of a threat and the manifestation of the mentioned symptoms? 2. Is there another explanatory model which reasonably clari�es the double nature of the ANS, HPA and HPT Axis. �e way to the answers starts from the symptoms observed in stress: tensed muscles and the F/F response, and goes backwards. MODEL ASSUMPTION�e same symptoms observed in stress are also observed in the cold shock. (Fig 2) From the point of view of thermoregulation, the function of these symptoms is an achievement of a positive heat balance and regain of the body temperature set-point.

FACTUMThere is no change of physiological functioning level, without priory dis-turbed homeostasis, and priory change of the body temperature. �e equality of the observed symptoms in stress and in cold shock must have the same function: increasing the dropped body temperature. It means that the stress caused a real loss of body heat and brought the body in stress induced hypothermia. �e reason for that lies in the act of assessment of the event as threat.All the above mentioned symptoms have common genesis: one primary cen-tral GABAergic hypofunction (stress induced GABAergic hypofunction). Under GABAergic hypofunction, the serotonin (5-HT), norepinephrine (NE) and dopamine (DA), all controlled by GABA, manifest one secondary hyperfunction. (Fig 3)

�e relationship between stress (threat), mental, and physical disorders has been well documented. �e physiological responses to the stress, the activa-tion of the autonomic nervous system (ANS) with its “�ght-or-�ight” response (F/F response) and the activation of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) and thyroid axis (HPT) (Fig.1) are the traditional concept of the stress–individual interaction. �e F/F response one has been especially seen as existential for survival of the individual faced with one threatening event.

THE PROBLEM OF THE TRADITIONAL CONCEPT�e F/F response, activated HPA and HPT Axis change their function toward the body during a time - from protector to destroyer - starting to ruin the body in form of physical disorders, shortening the lifespan of the indi-vidual exposed to the stress.

CONCLUSION�e changed physiological function level observed by a stress (threat) is in duty of keeping the set point of the body temperature, exploiting the energy reserves of the individual until the set point is reached.

THE NEW IN THIS MODEL1. Assessment of one event as a threat caused one real, stress induced hypothermia.2. �e stress induced hypothermia leads to primary central GABAergic hypofunction and secondary hyperfunction of 5-HT, NA and DA. Physi-ological and behavioral responses observed in stress (threat) are just adaptive reactions to one real loss of body temperature.

3. Comorbidity: the psychological/psychiatric responses are just “a part of the game”, a collateral damage in the trial of the body to regain the set point of the body temperature, which was decreased with assessment of one event as a threat.

IMPACT OF THE NEW MODEL 1. In the prevention: the threatening events (stress factors) have to be very early recognized as such. Keeping in mind that stress induced hypothermia will in�uence the psycho-physical condition on a long run, supportive actions should be provided as early as possible.2. In the general treatment of comorbid disorders: a) �e psychotherapeutic treatment has to be the �rst choice of treatment, focused on a positive reframing of the threatening events for a person, resource winning oriented.b) �e pharmacological treatment has to be focused on regaining the dis-turbed balance GABA/5-HT, NA, which play the main role in the etiology of the stress induced mental and physical disorders.3. In the research: the observed psycho-physiological reactions on assessed threat are one more proof about the in�uence of the consciousness over quantum mechanical phenomena.

UNDERSTANDING THE COMORBIDITY OF STRESS, DEPRESSIVE AND SOMATIC DISORDERS

ONE NOVEL MULTI-DIMENSIONAL MODELAleksandra Dimova

Information induced hypothermia of the body of assessor

Primary, central GABAergic hypofunction

Symptoms of primary GABAergic hypofunction andsecondary 5-HT, NE, DA hyperfunction

CENTRAL MOTOR SYSTEM

HYPOTHALAMUS

Increased activity of Sympathicus

Stimulation of HPA and HPT Axis

Immediate Psychological answer•Fear

Immediate answer•Peripheral Vasocon-striction•Piloerection•Increased heart rateDelayed answer•Stimulation of Adrenal medulla •High blood pressure•Diabetes mellitus etc.

Increased cortisol level•Metabolic syndrome•Osteoporosisetc.

Delayed answer•PTSD•Adjustment disorder•Psychosomatic disorders etc.

OTHER CNS REGIONS

Tensed muscleDyspnoeShivering

Delayed answer•Chronic Fatique syndrome•Fibromialgia

COMORBIDITY

EVENT

CNS: ASSESSMENT OF TREAT

COMORBIDITY

Increased activity of Sympathicus

Dysfunction of HPA and HPT Axis

Immediate Psychological answer•Fear

Immediate answer•Peripheral Vasoconstriction•Piloerection•Increased heart rate

Delayed answer•Stimulation of Adrenal medulla •High blood pressure•Diabetes mellitus etc.

Increased cortisol level•Metabolic syndrome•Osteoporosisetc.

Delayed answer•PTSD•Adjustment disorder•Psychosomatic disorders etc.

OTHER CNS REGIONS

EVENT

CNS: ASSESSMENT OF TREAT

?

Tensed muscles + activated ANSCold shock Treat

Fig. 1: Traditional concept of the stress – individual interaction

Fig 2. Equality between cold shock and stress (threat).

Fig. 3. Multi-disciplinary model of event-individual interaction (A. Dimova)

Missing Link Traditional Concept