Upload
others
View
4
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
1
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
1© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
An overview of Water Heating Technologies
Mr. Eric Burgis, Energy Solutions Center
Track: Commercial Natural Gas I
Unit #4: Commercial Water Heating
© 2020 Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
2© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Market Overview
Tank Style Water Heaters
Tankless Water Heaters
Booster Water Heaters
Direct Contact Water Heater
Small Boilers
Heat Pump Water Heaters
Commercial Opportunities
Presentation Outline
3© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Electric57%
Oil2%
District heat0.5%
Propane3%
Natural Gas38%
COMMERCIAL WATER HEATING ENERGY SOURCES
Market Overview Commercial BuildingsWater Heating – Fuel Type Used
EIA, CBECS, Table B13. Selected principal building activity
More than 80% of the 5.5M
Commercial Buildings in the U.S. have some type of water
heating capability.
ConversionOpportunities
1
2
3
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
2
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
4© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
System Use
EIA, CBECS, Table B13. Selected principal building activity
0500100015002000250030003500
CentralizedSystem
DistributedSystems
Combination ofCentralized and
DistributedSystems
Water Heating Equipment (# buildings in 1,000’s)
Centralized Water‐Heating System: A type of water‐heating equipment that heats and stores water (for purposes other than space heating) in tanks and then distributes this heated water throughout the building. A residential‐type tank water heater is an example of a centralized water heater.
Distributed Water‐Heating System: A type of system for heating water (for purposes other than space‐heating) that heats water as needed for immediate use near the location where this water is used. It is often called a “point‐of‐use” water heating system, and is usually located in more than one place within a building. Because water is not heated until it is required, this equipment is more energy efficient.
5© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Natural Gas Consumption for Water Heating by Business Activity
Source: EIA CBECS Table 7
Education13%
Mercantile 14%
Office 7%
Health care 15%
Food service 10%
Lodging 27%
Warehouse and storage
2%
Public assembly 1%
Service 5%
Other 1%
Food sales 1%
Public order and safety
4%
6© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
0
200,000
400,000
600,000
800,000
1,000,000
1,200,000
1,400,000
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
North America Tankless Water Heater Sales and Forecasted Sales
Electric Tankless Gas Tankless (standard) Gas Condensing Tankless
Tankless Growth Rates
Tankless ShareofWater Heater
Market
2009 7%
2016 9%
2021 12%
4
5
6
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
3
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
7© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Types of Water Heaters
Tank Style
Tankless
Booster Water Heaters
Direct Contact
Boilers
Gas Heat Pump Water Heater
Applications
Commercial Water Heating
8© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Commercial Type SizeMin Thermal Efficiency for equipment manufactured
after Oct 9, 2015 (%)
Electric Storage All NA
Gas‐fired Storage <= 155,000 Btu/hr 80
Gas‐fired Storage > 155,000 BTU/hr 80
Oil‐fired Storage All 80
Gas‐fired Instantaneous All 80
Packaged Boiler ≥300,000 Btu/hr and ≤2,500,000 Btu/hr
80
Packaged Boiler >2,500,000 Btu/hr 82
Title 10 Code of Federal Regulations, Part 431Commercial Water Heater Efficiency
Units <= 199,000 BTU/Hr are typically use Energy Factor or UEF, while larger inputs use Thermal Efficiency.
9© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Current Residential Water Heater Efficiency
2015 Standards (Residential): GAS – Common Sizes
2015 DOE (Department of Energy) Final Rule Effective April 16th, 2015
Applies to residential water heaters, but these are used in small commercial applications as well.
<= 55 Gallons > 55 Gallons
Calculation EF = 0.675 – (0.0015 x V) DF = 0.8012 – (0.00078 x V)
Rated Storage Volume
Tankless 30 40 50 60 65 75
Older Standard
.62 .61 .59 .58 .56 .55 .53
2015 Standard
.82 .63 .62 .60 .75 .75 .74
Non‐Condensing
Condensing
7
8
9
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
4
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
10© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Commercial Water heater Shipments (U.S.)
‐
20,000
40,000
60,000
80,000
100,000
120,000
140,000
160,000
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Commercial Storage Water Heater Shipments
Commecial Gas Commercial Electric
http://www.ahrinet.org/statistics
The increase in commercial electric water heaters is likely from the residential market where these are being installed instead of electric heat pump water heaters for anything >= 55 gallons since 4/16/15
11© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
WaterHeating
Technologies
© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Tank Water Heater
Tankless Water Heaters
Booster Water Heaters
Direct Contact Water Heaters
Boilers
Heat Pump Water Heater
Commercial Water Heaters
12
10
11
12
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
5
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Tank Style Water Heaters
Most common
Least expensive
Flexible
13
14© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Tank Style Water Heater
Hot water outlet
Cold water inlet
Pressure /temperaturerelief valve
Vent pipe
Flue tube /heat exchanger
Flue baffle
Anode rod
Insulation
Gas burner
Combustion airopenings
Thermostatand gas valve
15© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Tank Water Heater Offerings
Atmospheric Direct Vent Power Vent
13
14
15
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
6
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
16© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Sizing Commercial – 35 gallons up to 300 gallons (132‐1,135 liters)
Efficiency DOE minimum standard: 67% residential, 80% commercial (apply derate of residential efficiency based on storage volume) Best available technology: 98% residential , 99% commercial
Considerations Standby loss & Recovery Rate First hour rating
Tank Style Water Heater
17© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
399,000 – 2,000,000 BTU Input125, 250, and 300 (473, 946, and 1,135 liters) Gallon TanksUp To 99% Efficiency (low fire)Full Modulation with 10:1 TurndownProgrammable Electronic Control with Digital Temperature ControlCategory IV Venting with CPVC Vent Material10 Year Tank Warranty3 Year Scale Warranty
High Efficiency Storage Water Heater
18© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Microprocessor controls Tank maintain consistent temperatures Integrated mixing devices Allows for storage of hotter water – increasing amount of usable hot water available
Set back controllers Similar to programmable thermostat Leak detection devices Shuts off water if tank leak is detected Atmospheric flue dampers Reduces standby losses
Intelligence for Tank Water Heaters
16
17
18
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
7
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
19© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Advanced Temperature ControlsMicroprocessor constantly monitors and controls burner operation to maintain consistent and accurate water temperature levels
Intelligent Diagnostics Provides diagnostic codes to assist in troubleshooting
Microprocessor Controls
CONTINUED
20© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Self powered Thermopile converts heat energy from the pilot flame into electrical energy to operate the gas valve and electronics
Retrofit replacement Service kits are available for direct replacement on certain units
Microprocessor Controls
21© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Allows water in the tank to be stored at higher temperatures
Increases usable hot water by as much as 50%, while controlling the hot outlet at a lower temperature
Integrated Mixing Device
CONTINUED
19
20
21
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
8
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
22© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Mixed Hot Water Outlet
½” NPT Un‐Mixed Hot
Water Outlet
½” NPT Recirculation Inlet
¼” NPT Cold Water Outlet
Cold Water Inlet
*ASSE and UPC (IAPMO) Certified
Stainless SteelFlexible Connector
Push to TurnHand Wheel
Integrated Mixing Device
23© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Similar user interface as heating/air conditioning thermostats
7 day/4 period programmable display
Battery backup in case of power failure
Can be remotely wired
Hot water capacity indicator; provides an estimate of available hot water in the tank
Energy savings of between 7% to 36%
Set Back Controller
24© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Set Back Controller
22
23
24
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
9
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
25© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Electronic sensor designed to detect leaks Triggers an alarm to alert business when a water heater leak is detected Installs in water heater drain pan Components are re‐usable – can be removed and installed on a new water heater
Leak Detection
CONTINUED
26© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Mounts on water heater inlet Shuts off the inlet water after a leak is detected and confirmed Requires electrical power to actuate valve Easily installed with provided bushings
Leak Detection Inlet Shut Off Valve
27© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Reduces stand‐by loss resulting in less gas consumption and higher EF Ratings
Damper blade opens and closes automatically during operation and stand‐by mode
Requires power to control damper
Atmospheric Flue Damper
25
26
27
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
10
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
28© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Commercial Fire Tube Condensing
CombustionChamber
Removable dual heat exchangers
Four passes of combustion gases through the water
PVC venting
Low NOx burners available
© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Tankless Water Heaters
Standard Models Condensing Models
29
30© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
(Internal View) Temperature is set via the controller
Water tap opens & water begins to flow
Turbine spins & sends signal to PC Board
PCB determines water flow, firing rate & temperature
Combustion fan motor starts
Burner is ignited by direct electronic ignition and unit fires then modulates to match input with hot water flow
When hot water tap is turned off – The unit returns to standby mode
How it Works
Filter
GASWATERINLET
HOT WATEROUTLET
28
29
30
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
11
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
31© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
The difference of the incoming ground water and the tankless water heater’s set point temperature is known as Delta T (∆T) Delta T determines the flow rate of the tankless water heater
What is a Delta T (∆T)?
EXAMPLE:The Tankless temperature is set at = 120°Subtract the incoming temperature from the water heater’s set temperature for ∆T:120° ‐ 57° = 63° ∆T
32© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Understanding Flow Rate
EXAMPLE (from previous page)
Subtract the incoming ground water temperature from the water heater’s set temp. for ∆T 120° ‐ 57° = 63 °
The maximum GPM flow rate for any given ∆T can be found at the intersecting points along each model’s specific flow curve
The tankless water heater’s first priority is to provide the set point temperature to the user. Based on the ∆T, the tankless product may regulate flow to ensure it can provide the selected temperature.
63
If incoming water is 57° and requested temperature is 120°, ∆T is 63° and gpm flow rate is 5.1 gpm
Colder Inlet Water
33© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Sizing Up to 380,000 Btu/hr
Efficiency DOE minimum standard: ~82% Best available technology: 98%
Benefits Higher flow rates than electric Compact size Long‐life – 20 years or more Easy to service and repair
Gas Piping Requirements – ¾” gas line 5.0 inches wc minimum (12.7 centemeters)
Tankless Water Heaters
31
32
33
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
12
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
34© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Typical Manifold Installation Options
140140
Expansion TankCold WaterSupply
Gas SupplyTo Hot Water Supply
Remote Control
35© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Recirculation Pumps
140
ExpansionTank
Cold WaterSupply
LOADS
Hot Water Supply
RECIRCULATION LOOPPump
Check Valve(Required)
Controlled by an Aquastat, Timer and/or both
Sized to maintain circulation loop temperature
Sized to overcome pressure loss through water heater supply and return plumbing
36© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Typical Commercial Manifold with Direct Recirculation
140140
ExpansionTank
Cold WaterSupply
Gas Supply
To HotWaterSupply
RemoteControl
140
ManifoldController
Heavy Duty Heaters
Pump
ReturnCirculation Line
34
35
36
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
13
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
37© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Tankless models fit in a variety of commercial applications such as: Restaurants Hotels Multi‐family housing
Government buildings such as schools
Car washes Coin laundries Gyms
Others
Good applications for Tankless Water Heaters in the Commercial Market
© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Booster Water Heaters
38
39© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Designed to heat rinse water for better cleaning with fewer spots – especially on glassware
Heats hot water from 120°‐140°F (48.8‐60°C) up to 180°F (82.2°C) water
Improves cleaning and sanitizing of dishes
Shortens drying time
Less wear & tear on dishwashing equipment and dishware
Eliminates need for chemical rinse aids
Environmentally friendly
Booster Water Heaters
37
38
39
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
14
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
40© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Does not effectively remove food and soil, resulting in a dish that is not visibly clean and may need re‐washing 140°F (60°C) water temperature does not melt fats or proteins such as lipstick If water hardness is over 6‐7 grains, spotting of dishware occurs Chemical effect on metals & etching of glasses and china Longer drying times due to low rinse temperatures
Low Temp Dishwashing
41© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
High temperature cleans better, especially on lipstick and grease residues. Dishes flash dry with high temperature giving you quicker turnaround and less water on the floor. High temperature units reduce chemical, water and sewer usage. Labor reduction & increased production (Reduce re‐washing dishes) Safety in the workplace (Less water on floor means less slip and fall injuries)
Other Booster Water Heater Advantages
© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Direct Contact Water Heaters
42
40
41
42
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
15
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
43© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Stainless steel rings promote 99% efficient heat
transfer
Cold water inlet
Hot water outlet
City water pressure through an engineered nozzle creates a specific spray pattern
Market Opportunities
Laundries Foodservice
Facilities
Not intended for installations where water is re‐circulated
44© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
City water pressure feeds cold water into a vertical tower The cold water falls by gravity through an area filled with stainless steel packing rings The burner provides hot combustion gases to the vertical tower of the heater – where the hot gases come into direct contact with the falling water Rings increase the available surface area inside the tower to transfer heat and also keeps the water broken into smaller droplets
Direct Contact Water Heaters
CONTINUED
45© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Droplets have a smaller diameter, enabling them to take on heat with nearly 100% efficient heat transfer
As the combustion gases rise through the unit they transfer heat to the water falling in the opposite direction and are cooled until they exit through the stack
Exhaust gases are close to the same temperature as the temperature of the water spraying through the top nozzle and are at near 100% relative humidity
Direct Contact Water Heaters
CONTINUED
43
44
45
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
16
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
46© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
The heated water falls down into the reservoir or storage area at the bottom
A distribution pump, will deliver the hot water, on demand or continuously at the needed discharge pressure and desired temperature
Direct Contact Water Heaters
47© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Direct‐Contact Heater ‐ Thermal Efficiency100
90
80
70
60
50
4060 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180
Exhaust Gas Exit Temperature
Therm
al Efficiency
Typically, direct contact water heaters have an exhaust temperature about 10‐20°F (‐12 to ‐6.6 °C)
above the incoming water temperature
Quikwater presentation, June 2011
15.5 21.1 26.6 32.2 37.7 43.3 48.8 54.4 60.0 65.5 71.1 76.6 82.2 Deg. CDeg. F
48© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Large Commercial Use Savings Example
$236,503$265,051
$303,683
$0
$50,000
$100,000
$150,000
$200,000
$250,000
$300,000
$350,000
Direct Contact Direct Steam Indirect Steam
Annual Gas Costs For Water Heating SystemsBased on 60 to 140 F; 250,000 gallons/day use
Quikwater presentation, June 2011
Annual Gas Costs for Water Heating SystemBased on 60 to 140°F (60°C); 250,000 Gallons (946,352 Liters) / Day Use
46
47
48
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
17
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Boilers for Larger Hot Water Needs
49
50© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Contains multiple cast sections
Unit sizing up to 150 hp New Condensing Boilers available Efficiencies approaching 97%
Sectional Boilers
51© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
The furnace/burner section is a single large‐diameter tube with many small diameter tubes connected to it
The small‐diameter tubes are arranged above the burner section to provide a larger heating surface area to heat the water
Burner and tubes are contained entirely within an outer boiler shell that contains the water being heated
Sizes ranges from 100 to 1200 horsepower
Small Fire Tube Boilers
49
50
51
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
18
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
52© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Water circulates inside tubes heated externally by the burner
Fuel is burned inside the furnace, creating hot gas which passes over the water tubes, heating the water in the tubes
Typically larger than Fire Tube boilers
Small Water Tube Boilers
53© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Water passes through boiler tubes while combustion gases remain on the shell side passing over the boiler tube surfaces
Unlike conventional water tube boilers, the tubes are fitted with fins that increase the area available to transfer heat to the water
Finned Tube Boilers
54© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Ultra‐High Efficiency Condensing Technology –up to 98% Thermal Efficient (95%+ AFUE)
Stainless Steel Heat Exchanger
Ultra Low NOx emissions ‐ SCAQMD approved
Designed for low maintenance and easy serviceability
Fully adjustable outdoor reset technology with the sensors available
Domestic Hot Water has Priority over hot water used to provide space heat
Condensing Wall Mounted Boiler
52
53
54
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
19
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Commercial Heat Pump Water Heater
55
56© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Heat is extracted from the environment
A Natural Gas engine replaces the electric motor to drive the system compressor
The Engine also produces waste heat that is recovered to supplement the heat supplied by the heat pump
The Engine drives a small electrical generator to provide electricity for fan motors, pump and controls
Efficiencies up to twice that of a gas‐fired boilers
Natural Gas Engine‐Driven Heat Pump Water Heater
57© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Commercial Heat Pump Water HeaterAmbient Outdoor Temperature: 75°F (23.8°C)Hot Water Delivery Temperature: 120°F (48.8°C)COP = 586,000 / 292,000 = 2.0
55
56
57
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
20
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
58© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
400,000‐600,000 BTU/Hour (4‐6 Therms) Ford 2.3 L 4 Cylinder Engine (<50 bhp) Ultra Low Emissions Small 5 kW generator for parasitic load Next‐generation control system – Internet‐Based Touch‐screen display Advanced communications (CAN) Efficient, low‐pressure, HFC‐134a refrigerant Open‐drive reciprocating compressor Custom evaporator coil design Compact brazed plate condenser
Gas Heat Pump Water Heater Specifications
© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Electric Heat Pump Water Heater
Hot water outlet
Cold water inlet
Pressure /temperaturerelief valve
ResistanceElements
Anode rod
Insulation
Drain
Upper Thermostat
Lower Thermostat
FanCompressor
Evaporator
Condenser
59
60© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Requires installation in locations that remain in the 40°–90°F (4.4°–32.2°C) range year‐round
Install them in a space with excess heat such as a furnace room
Generally cost 2X that of a Gas tank water heater ($1660 versus $850 for gas unit installed)
Only save about $30/Year over a gas tank unit, or about 50% over electric tank unit
Electric Heat PumpWater Heating Systems
58
59
60
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
21
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
61© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Gas Heat Pump Water Heater
1.6 Average Cycle COP
EF: 1.3 First Hour: 60 – 80 gallons Heating Output: 10,000 ± Btu/hr (3 kW) Emissions: SCAQMD Compliant
GHPWH
Simple
Savings Consumer Installation Installed Payback Market
Capacity EF $/yr $/yr Cost Cost Cost [yrs] Size
Electric Heat Pump 50 gal 2.00 $271 $129 $1,100 $600 $1,700 6.2
Electric Resistance 50 gal 0.95 $570 $428 $375 $400 $775 4.0
Gas Heat Pump 65 gal 1.30 $142 $1,800 $700 $2,500 Base Case
Condensing Gas Storage 50 gal 0.82 $225 $83 $1,600 $800 $2,400 1.2
700,000Condensing Gas Tankless 199 kbth 0.90 $205 $63 $1,200 $1,000 $2,200 4.76
Non‐Condensing Tankless 199 kbth 0.82 $225 $83 $900 $1,200 $2,100 4.8
Power Vent Gas Storage 50 gal 0.67 $276 $134 $1,000 $600 $1,600 6.7
Standard Gas Storage 50 gal 0.62 $298 $156 $550 $500 $1,050 9.3 4+ million
* Data from June 2015 TMAF presentation
Opportunity
© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Gas vs Electric Water Heater Comparisons
Tank Style Water Heaters
First Hour Rating
Recovery rate
Water Heater Cost Comparisons
Energy
Installed Costs
Life Cycle Costs
Emissions62
63© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Gas vs. Electric Tank Water Heater
GPH Recovery at 90 Deg F = 20.7GPH Recovery at 90 Deg F = 40.5
Source: Lowes.com
Whirlpool 40 Gallon Gas, .67 EF Whirlpool 40 Gallon Electric, .92 EF
First Hour RatingGas 67 gallons
Electric 50 gallons
Gas unit provides 34% more hot water in the first hour.
Gas unit recovers twice as fast as the electric unit once cold.
61
62
63
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
22
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
64© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Canadian EnerGuide Labeling System
Canadian EnerGuide System
Gas Label Electric Label
65© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Life Cycle Cost Analysis
Years
New System Water Heating System
installed year 1Annual Costs include: Capital Cost Energy Cost Tank replacement in year 12 for all tank models Assume 24 year Life for tankless model
1 23
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11121314
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
2324
Tank Replacement
66© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Life Cycle Costs
Electric TankWater Heater
GasWater Heater (Power Vent)
Standard Gas Tankless
Water Heater
Condensing Gas Tankless Water Heater
Installed Cost Yr 1 $750 $1,200 $1,800 $2,500
Tank Replacement Yr 12 $750 $1,200 $0 $0
Year 1 Operating Costs $574 $238 $195 $166
12 Year Life Cycle Cost $8,030 $4,056 $4,140 $4,492
24 Year Life Cycle Cost $16,983 $8,112 $6,480 $6,484 * Assumes that electric pricing increases 1% a year, and that gas prices will hold stable for the foreseeable future.
The payback on the initial tankless investment alone does not do justice for this technology. Simple paybacks do not account for the longer lifespan of the tankless water heater or the comparison to larger gas tank models for larger usage
Life Cycle Costing
64
65
66
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
23
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
67© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Uses less energy – costing about ½ as much to operate versus electric
Rapid recovery – 3 times faster than electric tank units
Style and sizes to fit most installations
Tank style
Tankless – Never run out of hot water
Long life – 20 years or more with tankless
Benefits of Natural Gas Water Heating
68© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Commercial Opportunities –Water Heater Applications
69© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
15 GPM (56.7 LPM) at 165°F (73.8°C) to fill Zamboni storage tank at ½‐1 hour intervals
Prior system was gas fired tanks lasting 1.5‐2 years
Monthly fuel savings realized by tankless is $3,000
Ice Rink – Zamboni Filler
67
68
69
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
24
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
70© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved 70
Eat‐In Restaurant Application
New Installation
Multi‐temp system meeting all kitchen & public washroom requirements
71© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Hotel Tankless Application
Hotel tankless system Providing over 100 GPM (378.5 LPM) / 4,400 GPH (16,655.8 LPH) Retrofitted to old boiler room location
72© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Residential – Condo Application
33 Story ‐ 387 Unit Condominium 3 condensing boilers for domestic hot water and base load heating 3 Boilers for retail hot water 3 condensing boilers for domestic hot water in recreation facility
70
71
72
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
25
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
73© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Elementary School – LEED Building
LEED building 75,000 ft2 (6,967.7 m2) facility Two A.O. Smith Cyclone XHE® gas water heaters rated at 94% thermal efficiency
74© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Fitness Center Conversion
10 tankless water heaters replaced (2) 2,000,000 BTU boilers and 1,800 gallons (6,813.7 liters) of storage This system runs 42 showers and 10 lavatories
75© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Drive‐In Restaurant
Installing tankless water heaters in all new construction restaurants
Restaurant
73
74
75
© Energy Solutions Center Inc.No portion of this material may be reproduced without the expressed written consent of the Energy Solutions Center Inc.
26
Commercial 1 TrackUnit 4 – Commercial Water Heating
© Copyright Energy Solutions Center Inc. – All Rights Reserved
Thank you …
76
76