UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW …mdl.law.uga.edu/sites/default/files/2013.09.21%20... · 9/21/2013 · ATTORNEY, LAW OFFICES OF EDWARD HARRINGTON HEYBURN,

Majority Opinion >

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY

In re PLAVIX MARKETING, SALES PRACTICES AND PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION (No. II); UNITEDSTATES et al., ex rel. ELISA DICKSON, Plaintiffs, v. BRISTOL-MEYERS SQUIBB CO., et al., Defendants.

Lead Case No. 13-2418 (FLW) (TJB) Civ. Action No: 13-1039 (FLW) (LHG)

August 22, 2013, Filed August 21, 2013, Decided

For BARBARA A. KENNOVIN, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): EDWARD HARRINGTON HEYBURN, LEADATTORNEY, LAW OFFICES OF EDWARD HARRINGTON HEYBURN, East Windsor, NJ.

For Kenneth Petit, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): DANIEL C. BURKE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOTADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, PARKER WAICHMAN ALONSO LLP, PORT WASHINGTON, NY.

For Marcella Chesney, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): GARY P. FALKOWITZ, LEAD ATTORNEY PARKERWAICHMAN LLP, PORT WASHINGTON, NY.

For Raymond Snyder, Darlene Snyder, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): STEVEN D HAMILTON, LEADATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, HAMILTON LAW FIRM PC, STORM LAKE, IA.

For United States of America, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): BLAIR R. LOOCKE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSELNOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRACEWELL & SIULIANI LLP, HOUSETON, TX; CHRISTOPHER F. CUETO,LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LAW OFFICE OF CHRISTOPHER CUETOLTD., BELLEVILLE, IL; Gerald M. Burke, LEAD ATTORNEY, Assistant U.S. Attorney - Fairview Heights, FairviewHeights, IL; HEATH A. NOVOSAD, TONY L. VISAGE, LEAD ATTORNEYS, BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP,HOUSTON, TX; PHILLIP L. SAMPSON, JR, RALPH D. MCBRIDE, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTEDTO USDC-NJ BAR, BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP, HOUSTON, TX.

For STATE OF ILLINOIS, United States of America, Elisa Dickson, COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS,COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA, STATE OF CALIFORNIA, STATE OF DELAWARE, STATE OF CONNECTICUT,STATE OF COLORADO, STATE OF FLORIDA, STATE OF GEORGIA, STATE OF INDIANA, STATE OF HAWAII,STATE OF MICHIGAN, STATE OF MONTANA, STATE OF NEW HAMPSHIRE, STATE OF NEW MEXICO, STATEOF NEW YORK, STATE OF NEVADA, STATE OF TENNESSEE, STATE OF TEXAS, State of New Jersey, STATEOF RHODE ISLAND, STATE OF OKLAHOMA, STATE OF WISCONSIN, STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA, STATE OFMINNESOTA, CITY OF CHICAGO, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): BLAIR R.LOOCKE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRACEWELL & SIULIANI LLP,HOUSETON, TX; CHRISTOPHER F. CUETO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR,LAW OFFICE OF CHRISTOPHER CUETO LTD., BELLEVILLE, IL; HEATH A. NOVOSAD, TONY L. VISAGE, LEADATTORNEYS, BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP, HOUSTON, TX; PHILLIP L. SAMPSON, JR, RALPH D. MCBRIDE,LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP, HOUSTON,TX.

United States ex rel. Dickson v. Bristol-Meyers Squibb Co. (In re Plavix Mktg., Sales Practices & Prods. Liab. Litig.), No. 13-2418

© 2016 The Bureau of National Affairs, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Service // PAGE 1

http://www.bna.com/terms-of-service-subscription-products

For Rita Touriac, Walter Olivier, ANNA MARTIN, Janice Olivier, Cheri Olivier, Joseph Olivier, Mary D Oliver, CalvinOlivier, Betty Tarver, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE, LEAD ATTORNEY,COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE DUGAN LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA; ROBERT BRENTCUERIA, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, CUERIA LAW FIRM LLC, NEWORLEANS, LA.

For Eugene Thomas, Sr, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): ANITA TERRY TYE, LEAD ATTORNEY H L PENICK &ASSOCIATES PC, BIRMINGHAM, AL; Henry L Penick, LEAD ATTORNEY, PENICK & ASSOCIATES PC,Birmingham, AL.

For Robert J Budz, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): SCOTT J. SCHAUB, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOTADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, KULLA RONNAU SCHAUB & CHAMBERS PC., LINCOLN CITY, OR.

For Bill H. Thomas, Barbara J. Thomas, Deceased - 13-1188, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): BRENT J.MCINTOSH, LEAD ATTORNEY COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BILBO LAW OFFICE PC,CLEVELAND, TN; DANIEL C. CLANTON, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TOUSDC-NJ BAR, BILBO LAW OFFICE PC, CLEVELAND, TN; JIMMY W. BILBO, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOTADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BILBO LAW OFFICES, CLEVELAND, TN.

For DEROTHA LITTLE, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): CHRISTOPHER R. LOPALO, LEAD ATTORNEY,NAPOLI KAISER BERN & ASSOC. LLP, GREAT RIVER, NY; W. STEVEN BERMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL,NAPOLI, KAISER & BERN, LLP, MARLTON, NJ.

For JUDY BROWN, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): W. STEVEN BERMAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, NAPOLI,KAISER & BERN, LLP, MARLTON, NJ.

For STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA ex rel. DARRELL V. McGRAW, JR., ATTORNEY GENERAL, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): CARL N. FRANKOVITCH, MARK A. COLANTONIO, LEAD ATTORNEYS, COUNSEL NOTADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, FRANKOVITCH ANETAKIS COLANTONIO & SIMON, WEIRTON, WV; CLAYTON J.FITZSIMMONS, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, FITZSIMMONS LAW FIRMPLLC, WHEELING, WV; Frances A. Hughes, LEAD ATTORNEY, Office of the Atty. General - WV, Charleston, WV;ROBERT P. FITZSIMMONS, LEAD ATTORNEY COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, FITZSIMMONSLAW OFFICES, WHEELING, WV; ROBERT LYLE SALIM, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TOUSDC-NJ BAR, SALIM-BEESLEY LLC, NATCHITOCHES, LA; Teresa C. Toriseva, LEAD ATTORNEY, WexlerToriseva Wallace, Wheeling, WV.

For Sharon Hawley, Karla Hawley, Kimberley Atkins, Hershel Hawley, Eldon Hawley, Khristopher Hawley, Plaintiffs(3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): Brian D Chase, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Newport Beach, CA; Travis K Siegel, LEADATTORNEY, Maples & Associates, Edmond, OK.

For Wilbur Black, Patsy Black, Carolyn Sue Buckley, Sue Frisbee-Peek, Ernesto Releford, Gerald Waldrop, WandaWaldrop, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): DOUGLAS ROBERT PLYMALE, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOTADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THE DUGAN LAW FIRM, NEW ORLEANS, LA; Jeffrey D. Guerriero, LEADATTORNEY Guerriero & Guerriero, Monroe, LA.

For John C. Taylor, Deborah Sue Taylor, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): SETH SHARROCK WEBB, LEADATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BROWN AND CROUPPEN PC, ST. LOUIS, MO.

For Ravy Vanny, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): Mark E. Burton, Jr., Nancy Hersh, LEAD ATTORNEYS, MDL,Hersh & Hersh, San Francisco, CA; Michael Miller, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, The Miller Firm, LLC, Orange, VA.

For Roger Pearman, Kay Webb, Robert A. Hanson, Deloris Rising, Evelyn L. Gillespie, Adolf Stehle, Joyce Layne,




Anne Beasley, James Dowdell, Cecil Shaw, Cannatella Rosie, ELIZABETH TAYLOR, Lois Hembree, Ronald Heilman,LYNN WILLIAMS, Loreen V. Mathias, Mary L. Cauthen, Roland Griffen, Sr., Betty Greenburg, Delia Gaitan, PaulWoods, Veryl Manion, GARY ROBERTS, Zora Jackson, CLYDE REECE, Barbara Ross, Neil Vader, ROBERTBROWN, Shirley J. Hampton, Joanne Bryant, Benjamin Hellard, Brenda Maddox-Dolan, Thomas Bourrette, NancyWade, THERESA THOMAS, Paul O'Neal, Emmitt E. Montgomery, Alfred Massotti, Roger Dove, Jewel I. Taylor, DavidM. Mintzer, Sally Cooksey, Phyllis Rosenthal, Jimmy D. Phillips, Odell E. Clements, BERNARD WALKER, JerrySloan, Jerry Eidson, Frank Fambrough, Criag Lynn, Larry Haas, Myra S. Moglowski, Marilyn McQuiniff, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): Mark E. Burton, Jr., LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Hersh & Hersh, San Francisco, CA.

For Michael A. Arnold, Vicky Arnold, David E. Bowles, Dee Bowles, Richard W. Brewer, Lena B. Brewer, JackieBrown, Kenneth H. Burgess, Wesley Butts, Judy Butts, Glen R. Copeland, Cathy M. Copeland, Rose Costello, AndrewCrivello, Tamarah A. Davidson, Patricia Desch, Archie Dickerson, Joyce Dickerson, Eric P. Dopkowski, Lisa M.Dopkowski, Michael R. Easley, Dorothy E. Feil, Maria Gietz, Suzanne E. Halsey, Lois P. Hammond, Donnell E. Harris,Glenda Harris, Doris A. Hayes, John T. Hayes, Gail B. Heller, Leonard Heller, John M. Herbst, Teresa Herbst, Irma I.Hughes, Oscar D. Jackson, Betty N. Jackson, Richard S. Maged, Trissa Lori, Gary H. Mallit, Martha K. Roberts,Raymond M. Tandle, Elaine Ziegler, Arthur Ziegler, Linda W. Garrett, Andres Betanzos, Robbie F. Betanzos, JamesW. Calhoun, Sr., Robert Dorrell, Debbie A. Durrell, Richard K. Evans, Grace I. Firisak, Gary Hand, Sylvia Hand,Barbara A. Harper, George Harper, John E. Hrisak, Betsy P. Hunter, Rufus M. Hunter, Jr., Stacey L. Kruel, William L.Kruel, Hector Laos, Lilian Laos, Jerry McMackin, Sandra McMackin, Eugene Melhorn, Mary H. Melhorn, Lori B.Millard, Irving K. Arenberg, Yvonne B. Craig, as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Evelyn Brown, andindividually 13-3614, Jeff Eckerman, as heir of Marilyn J. Eckerman/ 13-3614, Michael Eckerman, as heir of Marilyn J.Eckerman/ 13-3614, Steven Eckerman, as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Marilyn J. Eckerman, andindividually / 13-3614, Ann Kanoy, as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Burrell E. Kanoy, andindividually/ 13-3614, Claude Parkes, Carl I. Porter, Eloise K. Porter, Eugene Russell, Ruby K. Russell, Marylou M.Seymore, Dolores M. Tischbein, Virginia Toler, Lynne Vander Kamp, as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estateof Doris Giuliani, and individually/ 13-3614, Reabon Walker, as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of StellaM. Walker/ 13-3614, Jeanette Walters, Donald A. Wiatrowski, Lynda Wiatrowski, Eileen Zabinsky, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK, LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK LLP, NEWYORK, NY; Kelly Ann McMeekin, LEAD ATTORNEY MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik & Associates LLP, ElSegundo, CA; Marissa Christina Langhoff, LEAD ATTORNEY MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik and Associates LLP,Ladera Ranch, CA.

For Karima Norrise, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): Charles Allan Davis, LEAD ATTORNEY Law Office of CharlesA. Davis, Petaluma, CA; ROBERT LYLE SALIM, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR,NATCHITOCHES, LA.

For DOROTHY BROWN, Diane Belinda, John Belinda, Lynda Bodoh, Perry G. Bodoh, Cecilia D. Box, Jerald J. Box,Thelma M. Branson, Joseph Caraco, Lucy C. Caraco, James S. Dalton, Francis M. Deshazo, Vi Deshazo, Eddie Diaz,Judi L. Flatt, Lee R. Flatt, Barbara A. Flick, Johnny K. Freeman, Sheila A. Goodwin, Donald Gunner, Jeanita Gunner,Antonio M. Hall, Jess A. Hoak, Rebecca Hoak, Angelina Honra, Eduardo Honra, Tina Howell, Cielo Orlandi, CephusPansy, Blaik Darst, Rhoden A. Fitzroy, Billy R. Howell, John Kilpatrick, Sr., Peggie N. Kilpatrick, Mindy L. Knight,Debra C. Lamendola-Darst, Daniel Leahy, Delores Lemaster, Laverna N. Louis, Charles McIntosh, Eula Mae Mitchell,James . Mitchell, Robert W. Owens, Ruth V. Owens, ZENAIDA PEREZ, Franciso Perez, Donald F. Rathgaber,Katheryn Rathgaber, Mary A. Reitz, Clifton I. Searle, Loise D. Searle, Kathleen E. Selig, Grace D'ambrosio, assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Norman D'Ambrosio, and individually 13-3613, Grace D'ambrosio, assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Norman D'Ambrosio, and individually 13-3613, Christopher Dotson, assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Sherry F. Dotson, and individually 13-3613, Joseph Miick, assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Rose M. Miick, and individually 13-3613, Arthur Selig, Joseph R. Sigai,Judy A. Skorik, Kenneth P. Skorik, Catherine D. Smith, Cherrie Stephens, Zon G. Stephens, Frank Swenson, assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Albert F. Swenson, and individually 13-3613, Phyllis I. Taylor, WilliamM. Taylor, Carlton D. Thompson, Jacqueline J. Thompson, Gracie Waddell, as successor-in-interest on behalf of theEstate of William Waddell 13-3613, Delores P. Whitner, Debra E. Wylie, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): HUNTER




J. SHKOLNIK, LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK LLP, NEW YORK, NY; Kelly Ann McMeekin,LEAD ATTORNEY MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik & Associates LLP, El Segundo, CA.

For Donald A. Wiatrowski, 13-3614, Lynda Wiatrowski, 13-3614, Eileen Zabinsky, 13-3614, Harry S. Zabinsky,13-3614, Robert G. Bare, 13-3647, Sandra L. Kinney, 13-3647, Sharon A. Lewis, 13-3647, Linda Bare, 13-3647,Bobby W. Bearden, 13-3647, Harry W. Bell, 13-3647, Marth J. Bell, 13-3647, Amos C. Bridges, 13-3647, EvelynBridges, 13-3647, James J. Cody, 13-3647, Judith Cody, 13-3647, Bula Daw, 13-3647, Kenneth E. Daw, 13-3647,Robert H. Dill, 13-3647, Yvonne F. Dill, 13-3647, Minnie L. Evans, 13-3647, Richard E. Evans, 13-3647, DeborahFields, 13-3647, James G. Fields, 13-3647, Stanley A. Guden, 13-3647, Linda S. Hass, 13-3647, Steven Hass,13-3647, Glenn T. Higginbotham, 13-3647, Diane Hudson, 13-3647, Jared W. Hudson, 13-3647, WILLIAMJOHNSON, 13-3647, PATRICIA JONES, 13-3647, Gayle A. Johnson, 13-3647, Wilbur M. Jones, 13-3647, WandaLack, 13-3647, William L. Lack, 13-3647, Bobby Lakes, 13-3647, Emma LeDonne, 13-3647, Carla Beckmann,13-3647, Ruth E. Cooper, 13-3647, Kathy Dalena, 13-3647, Dorothy K. Horner, 13-3647, Roberta N. Lockhart,13-3647, Donald M. Marino, 13-3647, Margaret Marino, 13-3647, Melody A. McFarland, 13-3647, Michael McFarland,13-3647, Sharon A. Melton, 13-3647, Hubert D. Noel, 13-3647, Steve A. Panas, 13-3647, Tamam Panas, 13-3647,Anthony C. Pierre, 13-3647, Gwendolyn Pierre, 13-3647, Patricia Pinckley, 13-3647, Willie D. Pinckley, 13-3647,Melody C. Regan, 13-3647, Vicky Rice, 13-3647, Gerald L. Rounds, 13-3647, Dianna E. Russell, 13-3647, Mary Sain,13-3647, Wayne D. Sain, 13-3647, Clemie N. Sexton, 13-3647, Edith Sexton, 13-3647, Lisa Sheets, 13-3647, CarlStamper, 13-3647, Patricia Stamper, 13-3647, Michael P. Stewart, 13-3647, Barbara E. Tabellion, 13-3467, Robert P.Tabellion, 13-3647, Larry Tatum, 13-3647, Terry Tatum, 13-3647, Cheryl S. White, 13-3647, David T. Whitham,13-3647, Chester A. Williams, 13-3647, Jewell C. Williams, 13-3647, Bennie Burman, 13-3648, Wanda Burman,13-3648, Tracy L. Clemens, 13-3648, James Clemens, 13-3648, Theresa M. Cuomo, 13-3648, James Desmond,13-3648, Sandra Desmond, 13-3648, Jackie L. Esteppe, 13-3648, Joyce Esteppe, 13-3648, Alice Eubanks, 13-3648,David V. Eubanks, 13-3648, Dianne Evert, 13-3648, Joseph Evert, III, 13-3648, John Cuomo, 13-3648, Herschel N.Frost, 13-3648, Katherine Frost, 13-3648, Juan R. Garza, 13-3648, Jeanette George, 13-3648, Titus M. George,13-3648, Lenore Goldstein, 13-3648, Melvin Goldstein, 13-3648, Annie Green, 13-3648, Will Green, 13-3648, WilliamB. Hendrix, 13-3648, Douglas D. Howard, 13-3648, Dorothy J. Hunter, 13-3648, Marcus J. Hunter, 13-3648, MelvinJeffrey, 13-3648, Diane Joneson, 13-3648, Robert E. Joneson, 13-3648, Gregg S. King, 13-3648, Arnold R. Knight,13-3648, Linda M. Knight, 13-3648, John L. Lockhart, 13-3648, Delores Lounsberry, 13-3648, Bettie A. Martin,13-3648, Magnolia C. McFarland, 13-3648, Michael McFarland, 13-3648, Betty J. Milum, 13-3648, Omib D. Milum,13-3648, Delores Mitchell, 13-3648, Ulious J. Mitchell, 13-3648, Orelia W. Moore, 13-3648, Raymond A.Mothersbaugh, 13-3648, Shirley A. Mothersbaugh, 13-3648, Wesley T. Mullenax, 13-3648, Lonza Crudele, 13-3648,Dorothy McDivitt, 13-3648, Shirley Millenax, 13-3648, Lawrence Nelson, 13-3648, Ida Nelson, 13-3648, Ray M.Nutter, Jr., 13-3648, CArmelita A. Oberacker, 13-3648, William J. Oberacker, 13-3648, Charlie Patterson, 13-3648,Christopher A. Patterson, 13-3648, Hattie P. Patterson, 13-3648, Linda Pruitt, 13-3648, Luther V. Pruitt, 13-3648,EDWARD REYNOLDS, 13-3648, Margaret F. Reynolds, 13-3648, Beth H. Robertson, 13-3648, Timothy L. Robertson,13-3648, Kevin Samuels, 13-3648, Amy Schulz, 13-3648, Daniel R. Schulz, 13-3648, Eugene W. Seagle, 13-3648,Michael A. Stevenson, 13-3648, Jody Sudduth, 13-3648, Shane Sudduth, 13-3648, Angel Swartz, 13-3648, Claude K.Swartz, 13-3648, Alex N. Tashman, 13-3648, JOSEPH WILLIAMS, 13-3648, JOSEPH WILLIAMS, JR., 13-3648,LAMAR WILLIAMS, 13-3648, Todd Williams, 13-3648, Plaintiff: HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK, LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLIBERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK LLP, NEW YORK, NY; Kelly Ann McMeekin, Marissa Christina Langhoff, LEADATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik & Associates LLP, El Segundo, CA.

For Stanley Billingslea, 13-3649, Audrey Clayton, 13-3649, Sallie Connor, 13-3649, Viola Edith Cowles, 13-3649,MARIA DIAZ, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Reymundo Diaz/ 13-3649, GeorgeDerdak, 13-3649, Roger Dorff, 13-3649, Felisha Gibson, 13-3649, Nelson Heflin, 13-3649, Lillie Holmes, 13-3649,Samuel, Jr. Ireland, 13-3649, Walter Kehler, 13-3649, JAMES MATTHEWS, 13-3649, Ione Rose Marshall, 13-3649,Frances Nicholson, 13-3649, Marie Opatz, 13-3649, Wauneta Raynor, 13-3649, Celestine Schull, 13-3649, ROBERTTUCKER, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Charles Tucker/ 13-3649, KennethTessmer, 13-3649, Sharon Tolbert-Glover, 13-3649, Betty Ann Tucker, 13-3649, Louis Wimer, 13-3649, JOHNBRADLEY, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Erma Bradley/ 13-3649, WendyBarnick, 13-3649, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Murray Casserly/ 13-3649, Leroy




Biczkowski, 13-3649, Yvonne Casserly, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of MurrayCasserly/ 13-3649, Janice Coverston, 13-3649, Kathy Dayton, 13-3649, Jacqueline Earl, 13-3649, Aubrey Hineman,13-3649, Shirley Holub, 13-3649, Alfred Horton, 13-3649, Harold Hutchings, 13-3649, Carolyn Logston, 13-3649,Barrie Mason, 13-3649, Angela Mount, 13-3649, Barbara Nixon, 13-3649, Steven Pepin, 13-3649, Alta Pearl Reed,13-3649, Elza Alvin Reed, 13-3649, Helen Sowers, 13-3649, Martha Steinman, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Charles Steinman/ 13/3649, Terry Stevens, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Asa Stevens/ 13-3649, Leo Testerman, 13-3649, Clyde Woodworth, 13-3649, DavidWylie, 13-3649, Evelyn Arrington, 13-3649, Willie, Jr. Ashmore, 13-3649, Percy Blackmon, 13-3649, Betty CollenBrown, 13-3649, THOMAS COLEMAN, 13-3649, JOHN COOK, 13-3649, Janie Click, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Robert Click/ 13-3649, William Duncan, 13-3649, Alma Harvey, individually, andas successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Fanni Burgess/ 13-3649, Margurita Hawkins, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Guy Hawkins/ 13-3649, Jo Ann Hoggatt, 13-3649, Josie Hudson,13-3649, Virginia Jarrell, 13-3649, Irma Jenkins, 13-3649, Leste Jones, 13-3649, Calvin, Jr. McCown, 13-3649, JamesRickie Mitchell, 13-3649, Jimmy Harold Moore, 13-3649, John Parmegiani, individually, and as successor-in-intereston behalf of the Estate of Gwendolyn Parmegiani/ 13-3649, Alta Pearl Reed, individually, and as successor-in-intereston behalf of the Estate of Harold Vernon Reed/ 13-3649 Stanley Schmitt, 13-3649, Charles Sims, 13-3649, RoySingleton, 13-3649, Kenneth Earl Smith, 13-3649, Shirley Threadgill, 13-3649, Earl Stanley Waeltz, 13-3649, GaylonWatson, 13-3649, Opel Williams, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Opal Jackson/13-3649, Peter Bassett, 13-3651, SUSAN CHAPMAN, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of theEstate of Larry Steve Chapman/ 13-3651, Shelby Dellinger, 15-3651, Donald Dilday, 13-3651, Elem Dudley, 13-3651,Keith John Farley, 13-3651, Helen Grainger, 13-3651, Robert Higdon, 13-3651, Terri Snyder Jackson, individually,and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Carolyn Snyder/ 13-3651, William Kirkpatrick, 13-3651, RoseMcNeil, 13-3651, Robert John Reis, 13-3651, Dorothy Waddell, 13-3651, Shirley Washington, 13-3651, Melissa DawnWood, 13-3651, Martha Bonesteel, 13-3651, Barbara Chanis, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf ofthe Estate of Stanley Chanis/ 13-3651, Anthony Cisco, 13-3651, William Colbert, 13-3651, Rita Collins, 13-3651,Dorothy Finch, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of William Finch/ 13-3651, JamesFoster, 13-3651, Chester Hearn, 13-3651, Erma Hobdy, 13-3651, Luciano Lueder, 13-3651, DANIEL MORGAN,13-3651, Dale Masters, 13-3651, Jeffrey Charles Merritt, 13-3651, Igor Mosenkis, 13-3651, Vickie Nelson, 13-3651,Marie Pabian, 13-3651, William Pollock, 13-3651, JAMES ROPER, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalfof the Estate of Carol Ann Roper/ 13-3651, Peggy Reeder, 13-3651, Leeiller Smith, 13-3651, Stevi Thompson,13-3651, DAVID WARD, 13-3651, HOWARD WILSON, 13-3651, Walter Lee Wooten, 13-3651, Diana Ash, 13-3651,Bagdasar Bagdasarian, 13-3651, Eleanor Busch, 13-3651, Mazie Collins, individually, and as successor-in-interest onbehalf of the Estate of Patrick Collins/ 13-3651, Sheryl Connor, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf ofthe David Connor/ 13-3651, Kris Courtney, 13-3651, Patricia Coy, 13-3651, Charles Crawford, 13-3651, MengestuDejene, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Lolita Dejene/ 13-3651, Howard Evans,13-3651, Bruce Feagins, 13-3651, Ron Feiman, 13-3651, Richard Goodrum, individually, and as successor-in-intereston behalf of the Estate of Nita Goodrum/ 13-3651, Tom Grachek, 13-3651, Richard Gross, 13-3651, Theresa Harris,13-3651, Daisie Jones, 13-3651, Myra Jones, 13-3651, Brenda Matesic-Little, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Virginia Matesic/ 13-3651, Stewart Merritt, 13-3651, Luis Montero, 13-3651, LarryMurray, 13-3651, Wilma Palmer-Joseph, 13-3651, Betty Severns, 13-3651, Walter Sharp, 13-3651, Sally Tassone,13-3651, Lula Wilson, 13-3651, Jullian Winoker, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofJeffrey Spitalnik/ 13-3651, Jami McDaniel Youngblood, 13-3651, Plaintiff: Mark E. Burton, Jr., LEAD ATTORNEY,MDL, Hersh & Hersh, San Francisco, CA.

For Jed Grisham, 13-3775, Rhonda Grisham, 13-3775, Plaintiff: LISA LANELL CAUSEY-STREETE, LEADATTORNEY, SALIM-BEASLEY LLC, NATCHITOCHES, LA.

For GEORGE ROBINSON, 13-3651, Wanda Duke, 13-3652, Kenneth Evans, 13-3652, Susie Gonzalez, 13-3652,Lucinda Henson, 13-3652, Kathaleen Jones, individually,and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofDianna Jones/ 13-3652, Phyllis Kintz, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of ThomasKintz/ 13-3652, RICHARD MANN, 13-3652, BRUCE MILLER, 13-3652, Mary McMahan, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Marily Meehan/ 13-3652, Iris Meeks, 13-3652, Karen Ogden,




individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Dolores Little/ 13-3652, Darrell Penennell,13-3652, Fred Tate, Jr., 13-3652, Paula Van Slyke, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofAlbert Van Slyke/ 13-3652, Marcella Buck, 13-3652, Melinda Cantrall, individually, and as successor-in-interest onbehalf of the Estate of Jean Cantrell/ 13-3652, Barbara Elliott, 13-3652 Altheria Griffin, 13-3652, Julida Helton,13-3652, John Hope, 13-3652, Steven Messer, 13-3652, Ada Moore, 13-3652, ELIZABETH PALMER, 13-3652, SylviaPacker, 13-3652, Glenn Pardon, 13-3652, Sammy Retton, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of theEstate of Stephen Retton/ 13-3652, Calvin Schra, 13-3652, Joananne Terwilliger, 13-3652, John Wilkerson, 13-3652,Glenn Wrestler, Sr., 13-3652, Henry Baker, 13-3652, Amy Ballard, 13-3652, Harold Bentley, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Heida Slone Bentley/ 13-3652, Mary Alice Bowles, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Ralph Bowles/ 13-3652, Virginia Crouch, 13-3652, Richard Cuzick,13-3652, Lavette Sherod Jacobs, 13-3652, CHIEF ROBERT MOORE, 13-3652, Nannie May McCoy, 13-3652,Edward Phillips, 13-3652, CAROL ROTH, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of DorothyPorter/ 13-3652, William Thompson, 13-3652, Donald Ray Begley, 13-3652, Pauline Boudreaux, 13-3652, AlexanderBowman, 13-3652, Mary Conrad, 13-3652, DONNA DANIELS, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf ofthe Estate of Dorothy Thompson/ 13-3652, Fern David, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of theEstate of Nolan David/ 13-3652, Bridget Dinvaut, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofRudolph Dinvaut/ 13-3652, Gregory Dobbins, 13-3652, Richard Faulkner, 13-3652, Charles Gass, 13-3652, RalphGiglio, 13-3652, Plaintiff: Jeffrey A. Travers, Michael Miller, LEAD ATTORNEYS, MDL, The Miller Firm LLC, Orange,VA; Mark E. Burton, Jr., Nancy Hersh, LEAD ATTORNEYS, MDL, Hersh & Hersh, San Francisco, CA.

For Herbert Gordon, 13-3652, Teresa Henson, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofEthel Henson/ 13-3652, Juanita Kilgore, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of NellieCrawford/ 13-3652, BETTY MARSHALL, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of CharlesMarshall/ 13-3652, Margie Melcher, 13-3652, Gloria Newton, 13-3652, John Nunan, 13-3652, Joseph Oakley,13-3652, JAMES PETERS, 13-3652, Rose May Roy, 13-3652, Patricia Shadoan, 13-3652, Regina Short, 13-3652,Verl Sowder, Sr., 13-3652, Shirley Treaudo, 13-3652, Betty Tucker, 13-3652, Delores Waggoner, 13-3652, Henry LeviWest, 13-3652, June Wigglesworth, 13-3652, James Wilkes, 13-3652, Frederick Williams, 13-3652, Gail Babcock,13-3655, Victoria Beitia, 13-3655, James Bell, 13-3655, Lonny Breyman, 13-3655, Linda Bridge, 13-3655, Rena Clary,13-3655, Eve Daniels, individually, and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Rena Aaronson/ 13-3655,Julia Daniels, 13-3655, George Dillard, 13-3655, Holly Gentry, 13-3655, Tana Gilbert, individually, and as successor ininterest on behalf of the Estate of Donna Beasley/ 13-3655, Feliz Gonzalez, 13-3655, Patricia Hobbs, individually, andas successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Clinton Vaulz/ 13-3655, Mary Alice Jones, 13-3655, MARY LEWIS,13-3655, Nettie Long, 13-3655, George Millak, III, individually, and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate ofGeorge Millak/ 13-3655, Donald Pohaski, 13-3655, JAMES SWEENEY, 13-3655, Elizabeth Siegel, 13-3655, TheresaSimonds, 13-3655, Mary Thomas, 13-3655, Raymond Triglia, 13-3655, Kirk Wescoe, 13-3655, JAMES BLOCKER,13-3655, James Baker, 13-3655, RICHARD COOK, 13-3655, Sara Carroll, 13-3655, Sidney Christian, 13-3655, GaryCobb, 13-3655, William Cowick, 13-3655, Drema Craddock, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of theEstate of Arthur Cox/ 13-3655, Jessica Edwards, 13-3655, Doris Gazaille, 13-3655, Laureen Heath, 13-3655, JaniceHoque, 13-3655, Sharon Korkow, 13-3655, Carolyn Laprad, 13-3655, Keith Marshall, 13-3655, Maude Meadows,13-3655, Ruby Moore, 13-3655, Katherine Mylek, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofRichard Mylek/ 13-3655, Paul Ott, 13-3655, Nancy Preston, individually, and as successor in interest on behalf of theEstate of Clifford Merritt/ 13-3655, Linda Sowinski, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofRobert Sowinski/ 13-3655, Donna Stephenson, 13-3655, Delma Taylor, 13-3655, Bobby Terry, 13-3655, LoretThacker, 13-3655, Marian Van Eyk, 13-3655, SUSAN WILLIAMS, 13-3655, Wanda Bunch, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Leroy Bunch/ 13-3655, Judy Bustamante, 13-3655, Franklin Cole,13-3655, Eric Fondriest, 13-3655, Patsy Gibson, 13-3655, Thelma Hollingsworth, 13-3655, Marilyn Jones, 13-3655,Glennie Joyner, 13-3655, Tommy Ketcham, 13-3655, Barbara Mend, 13-3655, Robert Mitchell, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Robert E. Mitchell/ 13-3655, Jean Montgomery, 13-3655, Gene Myers,13-3655, Robert Osborne, 13-3655, Thomas Parker, 13-3655, Brenda Pierce, 13-3655, Mary Riezinger, 13-3655,CATHERINE SIMPSON, 13-3655, Bobby Leon Searcy, 13-3655, Todd Andrews, 13-3655, Yoland Stafford,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Maggie Shaw/ 13-3655, Rosemarie Walsh,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of John Walsh/ 13-3655, Gary Wayne Ward,




13-3655, Billy West, 13-3655, Leona Byrd, 13-3656, Connie Coleman, 13-3656, JAMES HERRING, 13-3656, RobertHendrix, 13-3656, MARY JOHNSON, 13-3656, Ila Jordan, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of theEstate of Harold Jordan/ 13-3656, Cecil Kelsey, 13-3656, Teresa Lundy, 13-3656, Herlinda Martinez, 13-3656, LauraMurphy, 13-3656, Willy Niedt, Jr., 13-3656, Edna Parnell, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of theEstate of Eddie Robinson/ 13-3656, Melanie Robinson, 13-3656, Mavis Sanders, Nancy Lee Warthan, 13-3656,Rodney Stevens, Sr., 13-3656, Bruce Seaver, 13-3656, JUAN REYES, 13-3656, Sylvia Long, 13-3656, GrahamLelliott, 13-3656, Rosemarie Kessler-Hafer, 13-3656, Donald Hodges, 13-3656, Alice Hodes, 13-3656, JohnHelldorfer, 13-3656, Francesca Hawthorne, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofNichols Margot/ 13-3656, Alicia Gonzalez, 13-3656, Robert Dosier, 13-3656, Priscilla Damante, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Salvatore Damante/ 13-3656, Officer #615 Thomas Burke, 13-3656,Eugene Radza, 13-3656, Eldor Mickelson, 13-3656, Frisco Marshbanks, Jr., 13-3656, Randall Logsdon, 13-3656,Cynthia Walker, 13-3656, John Tucker, 13-3656, LAWRENCE THOMPSON, 13-3656, Lori Staley, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Ben Staley/ 13-3656, David Smith, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Sandra Smith/ 13-3656, Claudia Serviss, 13-3656, Jeffry Seaton, 13-3656, MariaSeals, 13-3656, George Rhynedance, III, 13-3656, Barbara Prince, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalfof the Estate of Gloria Frost/ 13-3656, Nancy Neal, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofJohn Neal/ 13-3656, William Metzger, 13-3656, Elaine Madkins, 13-3656, Chandra Kishor, 13-3656, WilliamKinsinger, 13-3656, Katie Jones, 13-3656, CAROLYN JOHNSON, 13-3656, Andrew Harris, 13-3656, Wade Hampton,13-3656, Shobna Desai, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Amrish Desai/ 13-3656,Harold Leon Crain, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Donna Marie Crain/ 13-3656,JOHN CRAWFORD, Plaintiff individually and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Pamela Crawford/13-3656, Marjorie Ann Buell, 13-3656, Lucette Brenton, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of theEstate of Charles Brenton/ 13-3656, Harriet Blye, 13-3656, Marsha Bates, 13-3656, Nancie Rossinow, 13-3656,Beatrice Mills, 13-3656, NORMAN JOHNSON, 13-3656, Mary Emigh, 13-3656, James Lee Daley, 13-3656, RochelleBegoun, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Harley Begoun/ 13-3656, Lillie Baldovino,13-3656, Rosella Walker, 13-3656, Virgil Walden, Jr., 13-3656, ROBERT WEAVER, 13-3656, Rebecca Turman,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Charles Turman/ 13-3656, Ronald Thompson,13-3656, William Thomas, 13-3656, Vickie Steward, 13-3656, 3-3656, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): Jeffrey A.Travers, Michael Miller, LEAD ATTORNEYS, MDL, The Miller Firm, LLC, Orange, VA; Mark E. Burton, Jr., NancyHersh, LEAD ATTORNEYS, MDL, Hersh & Hersh, San Francisco, CA.

For Patricia Nason, 13-3654, Jack Olmstead, 13-3654, Lloyd Cashion, 13-3657, Robert Christianson, 13-3657,William Clifford, 13-3657, Billie Douglass, 13-3657, Joseph Dziubak, 13-3657, SANTIAGO GARCIA, 13-3657, LoisGaines, 13-3657, Alberto Garcia, 13-3657, Marquise Garrett, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of theEstate of Abdul Muhammad/ 13-3657, Margaret Ginglewood, 13-3657, Boyce Glenn, 13-3657, Carolyn Graham,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Marvin Eugene Graham, Sr./ 13-3657, SharronGail Haden, 13-3657, George Hearn, 13-3657, Ronda Hillman, 13-3657, Harry Holland, 13-3657, Margie Huckabee,13-3657, Glenn Nelson Jenkins, 13-3657, Jerry Don Mask, 13-3657, James Radke, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Berry Radke/ 13-3657, Anita Richards, 13-3657, Tamara Rowe, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Helen Elizabeth Rowe/ 13-3657, Gail Vaughan, 13-3657, RodneyWashington, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of Estate of John Washington/ 13-3657, VioletBeckwith, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of John Beckwith/ 13-3657, RaymondBerke, 13-3657, Sherry Brown, 13-3657, James Clouse, 13-3657, Joseph Colucci, 13-3657, Debra Comer,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Walter Goodpaster/ 13-3657, Daniel Craig,13-3657, James Daniel, 13-3657, Claud Easton, Jr., 13-3657, Maria Ferguson, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Sylvia Voltolin/ 13-3657, Margaret Geddes, 13-3657, Harry Hayes, 13-3657,Trevelle Lucambio, 13-3657, ALICE MORRIS, 13-3657, Lucius McCain, 13-3657, Lauretta Reedy, 13-3657, JeffreyRohrer, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Denise Rohrer/ 13-3657, LatonyaSamuels, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Elray Wiseman, Jr./ 13-3657, JosephineShorter, 13-3657, James Stephen Spraker, 13-3657, Leon White, 13-3657, Mary Becker, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of John Henry Becker, Jr./ 13-3657, Virginia Brewer, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Juanita Morgan/ 13-3657, Louise Conn, 13-3657, Paul Daddario,




individually, and a successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Paul Daddario, Sr./ 13-3657, Jennie Dziennik,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of John Dziennik/ 13-3657, Helen DorothyFahrenkrug, 13-3657, Judy Fogarty, individually and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Ross Fogarty/13-3657, Marguerite Gustafson, 13-3657, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): Mark E. Burton, Jr., Nancy Hersh,LEAD ATTORNEYS, MDL, Hersh & Hersh, San Francisco, CA.

For Irwin Bayarsky, 13-3654, Richard Bohle, 13-3654, Elaine Bonner, 13-3654, Jerry Day, 13-3654, LucindaFrangiamore, 13-3654, Denise Glenn, 13-3654, Rob Gogliettino, 13-3654, Evie Guy, 13-3654, Verdie Harrington,13-3654, William Homsany, 13-3654, Bonnie Hoyle, 13-3654, Delores Lathan, 13-3654, Berta Lee, 13-3654, JosephEdward Marinacci, Sr, 13-3654, Michael Lynne Mayo, 13-3654, Samuel Metz, Sr, 13-3654, Joseph Morabito, 13-3654,George Nocke, 13-3654, Dianne Plants, 13-3654, Eugene Pyles, 13-3654, Jane Regan, 13-3654, Lois Reid-Gayle,13-3654, Susan Shoemaker, 13-3654, Catherine Ealy Simon, 13-3654, Kirby Smith, 13-3654, ALEX BROWN,13-3654, Patricia Beck, 13-3654, Anthony Bland, 13-3654, Roger Bowen, Sr, 13-3654, Gloria Coakley, 13-3654, KellyComboni, 13-3654, Dawna Dale, 13-3654, Virginia Davis, 13-3654, Robert Edward Fears, 13-3654, Anna Galloway,13-3654, Roy Gordon, 13-3654, KATHERINE HERNANDEZ, 13-3654, John Harden, III, 13-3654, Elsie Hays,13-3654, Judy Holford, 13-3654, Edwin Human, 13-3654, Jeanne Jones, 13-3654, Ruth Kilburn, 13-3654, MichaelKingsbury, 13-3654, Robert Lee, 13-3654, Robert Maciaszek, 13-3654, John Majewski, 13-3654, Timothy Marler,13-3654, Douglas Paulsen, 13-3654, Betty Richardson, 13-3654, Betty Roland, 13-3654, Roger Schultz, 13-3654,Katherine Sell, 13-3654, Jareld Shilling, 13-3654, Lonnie Shoemaker, 13-3654, Donald Staton, 13-3654, Dewey Teal,13-3654, Karen Tipton, 13-3654, Jake Tyre, 13-3654, Carla Williams, 13-3654, Marolyn Wright, 13-3654, FrancesYoung, 13-3654, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): Mark E. Burton, Jr., LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Hersh & Hersh,San Francisco, CA.

For Dana Hamilton, 13-3657, Bruce Hammons, Sr., 13-3657, Geraldine Hatfield, 13-3657, Dorald James, 13-3657,Damon Kaluza, Sr., 13-3657, Mary Jeanne Kisby, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofElwood Leo Kisby/ 13-3657, Ethel Kocourek, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of RalphKocourek/ 13-3657, Fredrick Perazzo, 13-3657, Gail Rajchel, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf ofthe Estate of John Rajchel/ 13-3657, Roderick Shaughnessy, 13-3657, Bertha Ann Smith, 13-3657, Genevieve Sturn,13-3657, Mary Williams, 13-3657, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): Mark E. Burton, Jr., Nancy Hersh, LEADATTORNEYS, MDL, Hersh & Hersh, San Francisco, CA.

For Maggie Brewer, 13-3658, Willie Butler, Jr., 13-3658, Betty Cate, 13-3658, Louis Cayia, 13-3658, Vertus Corkerin,13-3658, Keith Dominguez, 13-3658, Betty Ruth Gragg, 13-3658, Paula Hague, 13-3658, Andrew Harris, individually,and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Edna Harris/ 13-3658, Lacey Holton, 13-3658, StevenJacobson, 13-3658, John M. Lemoine, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of John D.Lemoine/ 13-3658, Gregory McDaniel, 13-3658, Vernon Medlock, 13-3658, Dennis Oster, 13-3658, Felisha Owens,13-3658, John Pineau, 13-3658, Mary Schawb, 13-3658, Linda Stewart, individually,and as successor-in-interest onbehalf of the Estate of Myrtle Cooper/ 13-3658, Susan Stewart, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf ofthe Estate of Lupe Williams/ 13-3658, SUSAN WILLIS, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of theEstate of Regina Tankersley/ 13-3658, Clarence Zaborowski, 13-3658, Elvin Bowman, 13-3658, Earline Brown,13-3658, Bernard Clark, 13-3658, Ruth Coffey, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofSusie Canady/ 13-3658, Donald Dade, 13-3658, Charles Ellis, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf ofthe Estate of Ruby Ellis/ 13-3658, Charles Frazer, 13-3658, Sam Hall, 13-3658, Hal Horton, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Henry Horton, Sr./ 13-3658, BARBARA KING, 13-3658, FranciscoLynnoel, 13-3658, Jimmy Morris, 13-3658, Dan Myers, 13-3658, Daniel Ross, 13-3658, DIANE SMITH, 13-3658,Pearlie Sykes, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Jack Sykes/ 13-3658, HermanTurner, 13-3658, James Wegscheider, 13-3658, Dorothy Bell, 13-3658, Jerry Blocker, 13-3658, Virginia Burke,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Sam Burke/ 13-3658, Pam Carter, individually, andas successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Madeline Shrewsbury/ 13-3658, Luis Davila, 13-3658, David Dixon,13-3658, Andrew Evans, 13-3658, Andrew Evans, 13-3658, MARTHA FAIR, 13-3658, MARY FOSTER, 13-3658,Dorothy D. Gibson, 13-3658, Cecil Hale, Sr., 13-3658, Otis Hall, 13-3658, James Harwood, 13-3658, Clara Hatcher,13-3658, Barbara Lowry, 13-3658, George Marcin, 13-3658, Imogene McFatridge, 13-3658, Claire McNeely, 13-3658,




James Moore, 13-3658, Edward Murnane, 13-3658, Jeffrey Noble, individually and as successor-in-interest on behalfof the Estate of Elgie Noble/ 13-3658, Joan Pawlik, 13-3658, Beverly Renne, 13-3658, WILLIAM SMALLWOOD,13-3658, NOEL SMITH, 13-3658, Laura Shaffer, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofJason Shaffer/ 13-3658, Readie Shelton, 13-3658, Ethel Smith, 13-3658, Andrew Sutor, 13-3658, Donna Thatcher,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of John Thatcher/ 13-3658, Frank Ungerland,13-3658, Gilbert Vega, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Gilberto Vega-Cajigas/13-3658, MARGARET WEBB, 13-3658, PATRICIA WILSON, 13-3658, Delbert Amos, 13-3658, Delmer White,13-3658, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): Jeffrey A. Travers, Michael Miller, LEAD ATTORNEYS, MDL, The MillerFirm LLC, Orange, VA; Mark E. Burton, Jr., Nancy Hersh, LEAD ATTORNEYS, MDL, Hersh & Hersh, San Francisco,CA.

For Pogai M. Amosa, 13-3732, Saimona S. Amosa, 13-3732, Betty L. Bannister, 13-3732, Kenneth L. Black, 13-3732,Eleanor F. Brown, 13-3732, Janice Curry, 13-3732, Mary Ann Dennis, 13-3732, Louis Dennis, Jr., 13-3732, Judith A.Doherty, 13-3732, Howard J. Doherty, 13-3732, Jim D. Douglas, 13-3732, Jack L. Doyle, 13-3732, Kathleen N. Doyle,13-3732, Barbara A. English, 13-3732, Joyce M. Fields-Sansing, 13-3732, Alton R. Free, 13-3732, Junrae L. Free,13-3732, David E. Gause, 13-3732, Kathy Gause, 13-3732, James G. Grissom, 13-3732, Norma S. Grissom,13-3732, Jane Honeycutt, 13-3732, Larry B. Honeycutt, 13-3732, Martin Jachter, 13-3732, William W. Key, 13-3732,Linda J. Loving, 13-3732, Kathy L. Madden, 13-3732, Roger D. Martin, 13-3732, John E. Meurer, 13-3732, TerrySansing, 13-3732, CHERYL MILLS, 13-3732, David H. Mills, 13-3732, Averzinda V. Morgan, 13-3732, MarvinMorgan, 13-3732, Claire E. Morris, 13-3732, O'Neal W. Morris, 13-3732, Gary C. Of, 13-3732, Lynne H. Of, 13-3732,Ollie L. Pittman, 13-3732, Russell Pittman, 13-3732, Darrell Reese, 13-3732, Cecil C. Roberts, 13-3732, Nellie S.Roberts, 13-3732, Julius Schoettle, 13-3732, Patricia A. Schoettle, 13-3732, Pamela Settles, 13-3732, William E.Settles, 13-3732, Connie L. Shockey, 13-3732, Kenneth Bowling, Jr. as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estateof Kenneth Bowling/ 13-3732, Dawn D'Agostino as heir of Donald W. Elder/ 13-3732, Celeste Delgado as successor-in-interest on behalf of Estate of Manuel Delgado/ 13-3732, Manuel Delgado, Jr. as heir of Manuel Delgado/ 13-3732,Joyce N. Elder as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Donald W. Elder/ 13-3732, Allen Hansen assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Margaret D. Hansen/ 13-3732, Betty Kessler as successor-in-intereston behalf of the Estate of Murray Kessler/ 13-3732, Mark Kessler as heir of Murray Kessler/ 13-3732, Stephanie ElderParkin as heir of Donald W. Elder/ 13-3732, Joanna Schlageter as heir of Kenneth Bowling/ 13-3732, Melissa Shelton-Bell as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Teddy L. Shelton/ 13-3732, Fred H. Shook, Jr. as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Fred H. Shook, Sr./ 13-3732, Donald G. Smith, 13-3732, Debra A. Smith-Matthews,13-3732, Ralph R. South, 13-3732, Luann Speakman, 13-3732, Carrie M. Thigpen, 13-3732, Gary Turner, 13-3732,Ronald J. Van Bibber, 13-3732, Diana Vanmeter, 13-3732, Tina Villalpando as heir of Fred H. Shook, Jr./ 13-3732,Christina Warner, 13-3732, Larry D. Warner, 13-3732, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK,LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK LLP, NEW YORK, NY; Kelly Ann McMeekin, LEADATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik & Associates LLP, El Segundo, CA; Marissa Christina Langhoff, LEADATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik and Associates LLP, Ladera Ranch, CA.

For Ardean Lowery, 13-3941, Lottie Luckett, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of WillieLuckett/ 13-3941, Barbara Lyton, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Paul Lyton/13-3941, William Manning, 13-3941, William Masters, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estateof Anastacia Masters/ 13-3941, Edward J. McCoy, 13-3941, Jamie McGuire, 13-3941, Lon R. McLillan, 13-3941,Clarence Jr. McNabb, 13-3941, Victoria Merryman, 13-3941, Joseph Miller, 13-3941, Anna Mourney, 13-3941, GussE. Myers, 13-3941, Freda Newman, 13-3941, Donald Noe, 13-3941, Robert L. Noggle, 13-3941, Michaelle Orozco,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Ghislaine Bouchereau/ 13-3941, NANCY PEASE,13-3941, Rebecca Parvin, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Floyd Harrison/13-3941, Carol S. Perella, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Dorothy Perko/ 13-3941,Linda Perko, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Dorothy Perko/ 13-3941, JohnPetticrew, 13-3941, Ester Pope, 13-3941, James Powell, 13-3941, Armando Purefoy, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Amanda Purefoy/ 13-3941, Linda Rash, 13-3941, Alice Raynor, 13-3941, MaryRodel, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Mary Bohm/ 13-3941, Richardo Rodriquez,13-3941, Carl Rowell, 13-3941, Margaret J. Scott, 13-3941, Ralph Scott, 13-3941, Tyrone Shazier, 13-3941, Laticia




Shimodor, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Rosario Reyes/ 13-3941, Joseph M.Sipocz, 13-3941, Lucien Skeels, 13-3941, Charlene Slawinski, 13-3941, Melvin Bernstein, 13-3941, Judy Fogarty,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Ross Fogarty/ 13-3941, Stay Fogle, individually,and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Christa Fogle/ 13-3941, Patricia Smith, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Patrick Smith/ 13-3941, Robert Sosnoski, 13-3941, Jack Stanley,13-3941, Maryann Stathis, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Gregory Stathis/13-3941, Robert Styzinski, 13-3941, Virgella Terry, 13-3941, Joseph Thompson, 13-3941, Leonard Urban, 13-3941,Brian Venn, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Albert Venn/ 13-3941, WANDAWILLIAMS, 13-3941, KATHLEEN WILSON, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofDorothy McKeever/ 13-3941, Jose M. Wilkins, 13-3941, Annie Wills, 13-3941, Benita Wills, 13-3941, Andy Wilson,13-3941, Keith Woodson, 13-3941, Warren Woodworth, 13-3941, Mark Yezzi, 13-3941, MICHAEL FARMER,13-3942, Jean Farmer, 13-3942, Lindie Hendrix, 13-3942, Sammie Hendrix, 13-3942, Fred Sharpe, 13-3942, PhyllisSharpe, 13-3942, Robert Blessman, 13-3942, Earnest Bryant, 13-3942, Kenneth Burket, 13-3942, Anthony Burkley,13-3942, Ida Bush, 13-3942, Joe Bush, 13-3942, Diane Carlyle, 13-3942, Marsha Crews, 13-3942, Allen Fredrickson,13-3942, MARY HUBBARD, 13-3942, David Harp, 13-3942, Martha Harp, 13-3942, Lorenzo Herndon, 13-3942, CecilHubbard, 13-3942, NURSE REGINA JONES, 13-3942, Ronald Jones, 13-3942, Brian Keith, 13-3942, Joyce Popwell,13-3942, PTL. ANDREW RUSSO, 13-3942, Patrick Taylor, 13-3942, JAMES WEBB, 13-3942, BARBARA WILLIAMS,13-3942, Ronald Williams, 13-3942, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): JOSHUA CALEB EZRIN, LEADATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR, AUDET & PARTNERS, SAN FRANCISCO, CA;WILLIAM M. AUDET, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR, AUDET & PARTNERS,LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA.

For Therese Andrezewski, 13-4213, Arthur Lee Archer, 13-4213, Winnie Ash, 13-4213, Curtis Aucoin, 13-4213,Joseph E. Beatty, 13-4213, Kathleen Beaugrand, 13-4213, Tina Becker, individually, and as successor-in-interest onbehalf of the Estate of Louise Casshie/ 13-4213, Martha Blome, 13-4213, Kathleen Boardley, 13-4213, HargusBrewer, Jr., 13-4213, Christopher L. Brown, 13-4213, Shirley A. Brown, individually, and as successor-in-interest onbehalf of the Estate of Larry O. Brown/ 13-4213, Buhl Boyd, 13-4213, Ila Burton, 13-4213, Jennie Carey, 13-4213,onald Clark, 13-4213, Manuel Cobos, Jr., 13-4213, Addie P. Corley, 13-4213, Alfonzo Correale, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Patricia Correale/ 13-4213, Alice Cowen, 13-4213, Gary Culp,13-4213, Norman H. Currin, 13-4213, Bettie Davis, 13-4213, Lucy M. Deaton, 13-4213, Herbert Delk, Jr., 13-4213,James L. Diem, 13-4213, Charles C. Edwards, Jr., 13-4213, Wanda L. Ellis, 13-4213, Donald Fain, 13-4213, LeonFarley, Jr., 13-4213, Susie Farmer, 13-4213, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): JOSHUA CALEB EZRIN, LEADATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR, AUDET & PARTNERS, SAN FRANCISCO, CA;Jeffrey A. Travers, Michael Miller, LEAD ATTORNEYS, MDL, The Miller Firm, LLC, Orange, VA; WILLIAM M. AUDET,LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR, AUDET & PARTNERS, LLP, SANFRANCISCO, CA.

For Kim Brannon, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Willie B. Lackland/ 13-4213,Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): JOSHUA CALEB EZRIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TOUSDC - DNJ BAR, AUDET & PARTNERS, SAN FRANCISCO, CA; Jeffrey A. Travers, Michael Miller, LEADATTORNEYS, MDL, The Miller Firm, LLC, Orange, VA.

For Verna Fields, 13-4213, Kenneth A. Flynn, 13-4213, KAREN GARCIA, individually, and as successor-in-interest onbehalf of the Estate of Judy Madrid/ 13-4213, Marguerite Harmon, 13-4213, Elloise Heckmon, 13-4213, Barbara Hind,13-4213, Dwayne Hobson, 13-4213, Barbara Hopewell, 13-4213, Cynthia Howard, 13-4213, Susan Lynn Howlett,13-4213, Debra D. Hunter, 13-4213, Larry E. Ingram, Sr., 13-4213, Bill Johnston, 13-4213, Garry Jonston, 13-4213,Joseph Karczewski, 13-4213, Wilma L. King, 13-4213, Alice Kotrha, 13-4213, Diana Krameison, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Samuel Krameison/ 13-4213, Lena Krist, 13-4213, Gail Launis,13-4213, Francis Leake, 13-4213, Gerald Lee, Jr., 13-4213, Donna Leeper, 13-4213, Darlene Long, 13-4213, MattieLovelace, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Clarance E. Greer/ 13-4213, Plaintiffs(3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): JOSHUA CALEB EZRIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC -DNJ BAR, AUDET & PARTNERS, SAN FRANCISCO, CA; Jeffrey A. Travers, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, The Miller




Firm LLC, Orange, VA; Michael Miller, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, The Miller Firm, LLC, Orange, VA; WILLIAM M.AUDET, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR, AUDET & PARTNERS, LLP, SANFRANCISCO, CA.

For Joan Curi, 13-3654, Markiva Grant, 13-3654, JOHN JOHNSON, 13-3654, James Napier, 13-3654, CharlottePatterson, 13-3654, Annie Calhoun, 13-3654, Sheron Cavanaugh, 13-3654, Virginia Galloway, 13-3654, EDWARDWILLIAMS, 13-3654, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): Mark E. Burton, Jr., LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Hersh &Hersh, San Francisco, CA.

For Joy Whitfield, 13-4517, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): SETH SHARROCK WEBB, LEAD ATTORNEY,COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BROWN AND CROUPPEN PC, ST. LOUIS, MO.

For Richard Conklin, 13-4520, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): LINDA LAURENT THOMAS, MICHELLE WYMAEWAN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, THOMAS & WAN LLP, HOUSTON, TX.

For DOROTHY ACETI, 13-4516, Deborah Ayers, 13-4516, MARY F. BAILEY, 13-4516, Ted Bailey, 13-4516, John O.Banks, 13-4516, Lavelle Billip, 13-4516, Mary Jo Bolton, 13-4516, Ralph E. Bolton, 13-4516, PETER ACETI, 13-4516,ALICE AARON, 13-4516, PHILLIP D. AARON, 13-4516, DARNELLA ABRAMS, 13-4516, BOBBY AGEE, 13-4516,CAROLE BOONAR, 13-4516, RICHARD BOONAR, 13-4516, Elease Brooks, 13-4516, GERARD CANTWELL,13-4516, JUDITH A. CASEY, 13-4516, AMY COLEMAN, 13-4516, WILLIE COLEMAN, 13-4516, CHRISTINEDESTEFANO, 13-4516, WILLIAM J. DESTEFANO, 13-4516, LINDA L. DUVAL, 13-4516, CATHERINE ELDERKIN,13-4516, JACK W. ELDERKIN, 13-4516, GEORGE ANN FARLEY, 13-4516, SHIRLEY FRANKS, 13-4516, ROBERTM. GIBBS, 13-4516, FLORENCE V. GLOVER, 13-4516, GOLDA L. GREENAWAY, 13-4516, RONALD W.GREENAWAY, 13-4516, DEAN L. GUTTERIDGE, 13-4516, TAMMY M. GUTTERIDGE, 13-4516, JEFFREY D. HALE,13-4516, LILLIE HALE, 13-4516, RALPH T. HARDEN, 13-4516, ANGELA L. HARDY, 13-4516, RONALD V. HARRIS,13-4516, LOUIS LEE, 13-4516, LINDA C. LEWIS, 13-4516, CONSUELO LIGHTNER, 13-4516, KAREN L. LIPSKY,13-4516, MARK A. LIPSKY, 13-4516, YOLANDA LOPEZ, 13-4516, JAMES E. LYTLE, 13-4516, JOY D. LYTLE,13-4516, GLORIA J. MCCOIN, 13-4516, WILLIAM L. MCCRADIC, 13-4516, DON MCILWAIN, 13-4516, NELVAMCILWAIN, 13-4516, BRYAN L. O'LEARY, 13-4516, LINDA A. O'LEARY, 13-4516, DOMINIC MOFFRE, 13-4516,HOPE E. MONROE, 13-4516, PEGGY MOORE, 13-4516, VERNON C. MOORE, 13-4516, PHILLIP D. MORT,13-4516, ALICE F. NEWTON, 13-4516, ROENA C. PATTERSON, 13-4516, RAYMUNDO PENA, 13-4516, CANDIDOC. PEREZ, 13-4516, FRIEDA PIERCY, 13-4516, CARRIE M. PLANKS, 13-4516, KEITH G. PRICE, 13-4516, SYEDQAMER, 13-4516, LUCY A. RANDOLPH, 13-4516, DANIEL RIEDLE, 13-4516, WINIFRED W. RIEDLE, 13-4516,MYRTLE I. RIORDAN, 13-4516, MARY E. ROSS, 13-4516, MILDRED ROZIER, 13-4516, LANNY S. SHANE,13-4516, RONIT SHANE, 13-4516, ZENIADA F. HARRIS, 13-4516, BETTY HARRISON, 13-4516, FRANCESHILTNER, 13-4516, WILLIAM F. HILTNER, 13-4516, DOLORES R. SEIBERT, 13-4516, SHARON SIEDEL, 13-4516,KENNETH E. SWEET, 13-4516, TAMMY L. SWEET, 13-4516, GRACE HUCKABAY, 13-4516, JACQUELINEHYMAN, 13-4516, ALLAN D. JARED, 13-4516, MARIAN A. JARED, 13-4516, MARIE E. JIMENEZ, 13-4516,THEODORE R. JIMENEZ, 13-4516, KATHRYN KAPPLER, 13-4516, JOHN D. LADSON, 13-4516, CLEO J.LASITER, 13-4516, PATRICIA A. LASITER, 13-4516, SYNIA QUANTRICE LAURENCE, 13-4516, BONNIELAUTERS, 13-4516, DONALD LAUTERS, 13-4516, BETTY SUE LEE, 13-4516, GREGORY TALLEY, 13-4516,JOYCE A. TALLEY, 13-4516, SARAH R. THOMAS, 13-4516, ANN TINGLER, 13-4516, SAMUEL L. TINGLER,13-4516, MICHAEL TRIPLETT, 13-4516, FRED R. UMAYMAN, 13-4516, ELMERINA UMAYMANN, 13-4516, LINDAL. WARD, 13-4516, BARBARA WARREN, 13-4516, ROY A. WARREN, 13-4516, TERRI L. WEIR, 13-4516, GEORGEE. WESTON, 13-4516, SANDRA WHITEHEAD, 13-4516, ARTHUR D. WILHELM, 13-4516, FRANK D. WILLIAMS,13-4516, LINDA G. WILLIAMS, 13-4516, ANNA A. ACOSTA, 13-4518, ADRIEN L. ADAMS, 13-4518, ANNIE ADAMS,13-4518, HARLAN F. ADDINGTON, 13-4518, CAROL CHAIKEN, 13-4518, IRWIN CHAIKEN, 13-4518, ROBERT E.BARLAGE, 13-4518, SHARON BARLAGE, 13-4518, JIMMY BARNES, 13-4518, GRANT L BENNETT, 13-4518, GAILS BISHOP, 13-4518, GEORGE F BISHOP, 13-4518, MILTON R BRADSHAW, 13-4518, IDRISSA R BURCH,13-4518, RUBY M BURT, 13-4518, ANTHONY P CARFANO, 13-4518, CAROLYN CARFANO, 13-4518, IMOGENE MCOFFMAN, 13-4518, DIANE L COLVIN, 13-4518, J. C. CONNER, 13-4518, BARBARA CRISWELL, 13-4518, KELLYCRUMB, 13-4518, ANDREW A DAGLIERO, 13-4518, IMOGENE DAGLIERO, 13-4518, MATTIE L DAVIS, 13-4518,




ANN M DREW, 13-4518, CLARENCE DREW, 13-4518, JANIS L ELDERS, 13-4518, ROBERT E ELDERS, 13-4518,JOSEPH A EMMETT, 13-4518, YVONNE P EMMETT, 13-4518, ROBERT T ENSLEY, 13-4518, ELIZABETHFERRENTINO, 13-4518, ROBERT FERRENTINO, 13-4518, CAROL A FROST, 13-4518, GEORGE F FROST,13-4518, WILMA J GATES, 13-4518, JACKIE GEDEON, 13-4518, CHARLES E GILL, 13-4518, CAROLYN LILLY,13-4518, ROBERT N MADDEN, 13-4518, GLORETTA V MAGEE, 13-4518, ELFRIEDE MALENKY, 13-4518,RICHARD P MASON, 13-4518, BRENDA MASTERS, 13-4518, CHARLES R MASTERS, 13-4518, SHIRLEEMCCULLOUGH, 13-4518, JERRY G MCCURDY, 13-4518, ROBERT L MCGRIFF, 13-4518, JAMES MILUM,13-4518, KATHRYN MYERS, 13-4518, RONALD P MYERS, 13-4518, ROBERT L NOLAND, 13-4518, VIRGINIA LNOLAND, 13-4518, GEORGE E OXFORD, 13-4518, DONALD J PARKIN, 13-4518, MAUREEN J PATT, 13-4518,ROBERT J PATT, 13-4518, JOHN T PETROVICH, 13-4518, PATRICIA PETROVICH, 13-4518, GARY PHELPS,13-4518, NANCY L PHELPS, 13-4518, GESI F RAUENHORST, 13-4518, WILLIAM J RAUENHORST, 13-4518,BRIAN R REDMOND, 13-4518, SUSAN G REDMOND, 13-4518, LINDA D REHMERT, 13-4518, PAUL E REHMERT,13-4518, WILLIE J ROBERSON, 13-4518, MARK A SCHARNOWSKE, 13-4518, CORNELIUS SEAWRIGHT,13-4518, SYLVIA SEAWRIGHT, 13-4518, CHARLES SHOWERS, 13-4518, TRINA SHOWERS, 13-4518, DELORESM GILL, 13-4518, GLORIA GLAZE, 13-4518, JOHN GLAZE, 13-4518, MARY B GREMPLER, 13-4518, THOMAS RHAMMONDS, 13-4518, ANDREW W SMITH, 13-4518, JOYCE SMITH, 13-4518, ROY V STONE, 13-4518, KARENSUTTON, 13-4518, SHARON L HAMMONDS, 13-4518, JACKIE HARRISON, 13-4518, LENORA HOLMES, 13-4518,GLORIA HORTON, 13-4518, RANDALL E HORTON, 13-4518, ROSALIND D HOSLER, 13-4518, BUDDY HOWELL,13-4518, GEORGE KOHLHEPP, 13-4518, JOAN KOHLHEPP, 13-4518, DAVID N KUIPERS, 13-4518, EDWIN LKUNTZ, 13-4518, JUNE M KUNTZ, 13-4518, JOHN F LECOUMPTE, SR., 13-4518, SHARON LECOUMPTE,13-4518, KEN SWISHER, 13-4518, BARBARA M THORPE, 13-4518, BLANCE TREZEK, 13-4518, JAMES PTREZEK, 13-4518, KRISTI TRIPP, 13-4518, HAZEL VEST, 13-4518, JOHN VEST, 13-4518, CHRISTINE GWEBSTER, 13-4518, DOROTHY E WHITE, 13-4518, PATRICIA WHITTAKER, 13-4518, ELIJHA WILLIAMS,13-4518, MAE BELL WILLIAMS, 13-4518, WILLIAM J WILLIAMS, 13-4518, BONSOOK WITTE, 13-4518, EDGAR AWITTE, 13-4518, PHILLIP J WOODS, 13-4518, CLYDE E WORKMAN, 13-4518, ELIZABETH A WORRELL, 13-4518,WILLIAM H WORRELL, 13-4518, JAMES L. ADDINGTON, 13-4519, HARVEY ALLEN, SR., 13-4519, HELGA ALLEN,13-4519, MAVIS K. ARFMAN, 13-4519, EUGENE E. VOSE, 13-4519, SERAPHENE BARASH, 13-4519, MARGARETBARNES, 13-4519, NORMAN BARNES, 13-4519, THOMAS C. BEECHER, 13-4519, ROY D. BLAND, 13-4519,SUSAN L. BLAND, 13-4519, MILDRED D. BOSTICK, 13-4519, RILLA BOWLES, 13-4519, ROGER L. BOWLES,13-4519, WENDY BRASCH, 13-4519, ELIZABETH BURKETT, 13-4519, WILLIAM J. BURKETT, 13-4519, BETTYBURRELL, 13-4519, BEVERLY E. BURRELL, 13-4519, BEVERLY BURTON, 13-4519, MICHAEL BURTON, 13-4519,JOHN G. CAMARRE, 13-4519, ERIC COHEN, 13-4519, PATRICIA COHEN, 13-4519, ARMAND B. COMO, 13-4519,JUDITH COMO, 13-4519, ELLA J. COX, 13-4519, DELORES A. DIGILIO, 13-4519, JOSEPH B. DIGILIO, 13-4519,CATHERINE E. DUNN, 13-4519, SRINIVASAN DURAIRAJ, 13-4519, JAMES D. FALLON, 13-4519, VICKIE FALLON,13-4519, MARGARET K. FEES, 13-4519, MARIA M. GARCIA, 13-4519, CHRISTINE GARDNER, 13-4519, EMILYGAREY, 13-4519, RICKY D. GARRISON, 13-4519, JOYCE A. GOGLEY, 13-4519, RONALD D. GOGLEY, 13-4519,DONALD D. GORDON, 13-4519, ANN T. HAWKES, 13-4519, ROBERT J. HAYNES, 13-4519, SARAH M.HAZELTON, 13-4519, ALYSSA C. HUNLEY, 13-4519, DAVID HUNLEY, 13-4519, DEBRA IZZO, 13-4519, RALPHIZZO, 13-4519, LINDA JOHNSON, 13-4519, FRANCIS JONES, 13-4519, JOHN JONES, 13-4519, MARIANNEJONES, 13-4519, ROSE JOSEPH, 13-4519, JAMES J. KEY, 13-4519, SHEILA KEY, 13-4519, BARBARA A.KRAKLIO, 13-4519, WALLACE R. KRAKLIO, 13-4519, SHIRLEY K. LAFLEUR, 13-4519, CYNTHIA M. LANE,13-4519, WILLA D. LEONARD, 13-4519, CLARA LEWIS, 13-4519, JELLEST LEWIS, 13-4519, CHERYL LEYLAND,13-4519, KATHLEEN M. LIEBERMAN, 13-4519, DAVID G. LINDENMUTH, 13-4519, JOYCE A. LINDENMUTH,13-4519, TAMMIE MARTINEZ, 13-4519, NANETTE MASSEY, 13-4519, ERNEST G. MAULDIN, 13-4519, RHONDAF. MAULDIN, 13-4519, CAROL E. MILNIKEL, 13-4519, ALBERT MIMS, 13-4519, MATTIE M. MIMS, 13-4519,MARCY MORATELLI, 13-4519, BRADLEY MORTICHESKY, 13-4519, JACKIE MORTICHESKY, 13-4519, GLORIA A.MUMM, 13-4519, ANNABELLE PEREZ, 13-4519, DORINDA J. POLLOCK, 13-4519, KATRINA V. ROBINSON,13-4519, KATRINA V. ROBINSON, 13-4519, CHLYDE ROLLIE, 13-4519, DAVID P. ROSE, 13-4519, SHANNONROSE, 13-4519, CAROLYN ROSSI, 13-4519, DENNIS P. SAUNDERS, 13-4519, TERESA G. SAUNDERS, 13-4519,CATHY I. SCHACKEL, 13-4519, MICHAEL F. SCHACKEL, 13-4519, GREGORY L. SLATER, 13-4519, CHARLENESMITH, 13-4519, FELICIA SMITH, 13-4519, HERMAN D. SMITH, 13-4519, RAYMOND D. SMITH, 13-4519,VALERIE SMITH, 13-4519, THOMAS B. SQUIRES, 13-4519, SANGEETHA SRINIVASAN, 13-4519, DAVID




STOKES, 13-4519, ROBERT L. TAYLOR, 13-4519, ROZANNE TAYLOR, 13-4519, HELEN M. TELFORD, 13-4519,PATRICK M. TELFORD, 13-4519, JAMES THOMAS, 13-4519, MARGARET THOMAS, 13-4519, DONALD A.VANRANDALL, 13-4519, PAT VANRANDALL, 13-4519, IRENE S. VILLEGAS, 13-4519, PATRICIA M. WATKINS,13-4519, LASONYA WILBURN, 13-4519, RANDALL D. WILLIS, 13-4519, ROBERT WINSTEAD, 13-4519,SHERRON P. WINSTEAD, 13-4519, DONNA M. YARBOROUGH, 13-4519, CHARLES YOUNG, 13-4519,CLAUDETTE YOUNG, 13-4519, NELLIE YOUNGBLOOD, 13-4519, GARY ARMANTROUT, 13-4521, NANCY K.ARMANTROUT, 13-4521, BRENDA A. BAKER, 13-4521, ICEL M. BARTLEY, 13-4521, MAX L. BARTLEY, 13-4521,JERRY J. BASS, 13-4521, CLARENCE A. BELVINS, 13-4521, HOLLY BELVINS, 13-4521, CHESTER L. BIRT,13-4521, VIRGINIA M. BIRT, 13-4521, MARION BOULE, 13-4521, THEODORE A. BOULE, 13-4521, A. MARGOBRANDT, 13-4521, CHESTER BRANDT, 13-4521, MARY I. BUCK, 13-4521, MARY I. BUCK, 13-4521, ALBERTBUGAL, 13-4521, SHIRLEY M. BUGAL, 13-4521, CLAUDE A. BUGBEE, 13-4521, CYNTHIA CLEVENGER, 13-4521,MICHAEL CLEVENGER, 13-4521, STEVEN D. COCHRAN, 13-4521, JOSEPH P. CONNORS, 13-4521, LEON R.DORSEY, 13-4521, SHIRLEY DORSEY, 13-4521, DOROTHY J. ERB, 13-4521, WARREN ERB, 13-4521,NERLANDE ETIENNE, 13-4521, JUAN L. FARRAN, 13-4521, SANDRA FARRAN, 13-4521, LORETT FENT,13-4521, ROBERT J. FENT, 13-4521, GARY A. FRAKER, 13-4521, JACQUELYN L. FRAKER, 13-4521, RAIFORD L.GRIGSBY, 13-4521, BARBARA GRINKOVICH, 13-4521, JOE L. HAILE, 13-4521, CHARLES HENDERSON,13-4521, DEBRA HENDERSON, 13-4521, CATHY HEYSHAM, 13-4521, GEORGE M. HEYSHAM, 13-4521,WILLIAM HITE, individually and as the proposed special administrator of Virgie M. Flatt, deceased/ 13-4521, DONNAJ. HOPKINS, 13-4521, ROGER D. HOPKINS, 13-4521, CHESTER L. HOUZE, 13-4521, CLAUDINE W. HOUZE,13-4521, PHILIP HOYT, 13-4521, SHARON HURST, 13-4521, WILLIAM HURST, 13-4521, JEANNETTE IRBY,individually and as the proposed special administrator of Clyde Gallion, deceased/ 13-4521, PEGGY JACOBS,13-4521, JERRY D. JONES, 13-4521, THEODORE R. JORDAN, 13-4521, WANDA JORDAN, 13-4521, SHEROLYNKELLER, 13-4521, TERRY C. KELLER, 13-4521, JERI KLEIN, 13-4521, ARIAN KROHNFELT, 13-4521, JUANITALANDRUM, individually and as proposed special administrator of Harold Landrum, deceased/ 13/4521, DIANALEDESMA, 13-4521, JOSE LEDESMA, 13-4521, BILLY V. LEWIS, 13-4521, GAIL A. LINDBLOM, 13-4521, DEBRAA. LIVELY, 13-4521, PHILIP D. LIVELY, 13-4521, JOY A. LONG, 13-4521, MARY LOVEDAY, 13-4521, DONALD R.MABES, 13-4521, REBECCA J. MABES, 13-4521, GEORGE MAVRONIS, individually and as proposed specialadministrator of Irene Mavronis, deceased/ 13-4521, PAMELA D. MCMANN, individually and as the proposed specialadministrator of Kenneth R. McMann, deceased/ 13-4521, CONNIE MCMULLEN, 13-4521, RONALD R. MCMULLEN,13-4521, ANDREA S. MICHAUD, 13-4521, HENRY R. MICHAUD, 13-4521, BERNARD E. MILOWITZ, 13-4521,JAMES MONTGOMERY, 13-4521, DENNIS MOORE, individually and as the proposed special administrator ofCharles L. Moore, deceased/ 13-4521, ELIZABETH L. MOSLEY, 13-4521, RONALD E. NEWSOME, 13-4521,PATRICIA L. PAIRAN, 13-4521, MARIE M. PERRIN, 13-4521, RONALD PIOTEREK, individually and as the proposedspecial administrator of Linda C. Pioterek, deceased/ 13-4521, GENEVA POOL, 13-4521, NANCY RENSHAW,13-4521, DOMINICK J. RICCIARDI, 13-4521, IVEN B. ROBINSON, 13-4521, LAWRENCE B. ROBINSON, 13-4521,PETER C. SERUBO, 13-4521, LEE B. SHAW, 13-4521, CHARLES D. SKILLING, 13-4521, DEBRA SKILLING,13-4521, BETTY A. SMITH, 13-4521, CHRISTOPHER A. SMITH, 13-4521, JAMES C. SMITH, 13-4521, BERNICE M.STANLEY, 13-4521, WILLIAM J. STANLEY, 13-4521, ALAN M. STEARNS, 13-4521, ALLAN L. STEPHENSON,13-4521, ANNA STEPHENSON, 13-4521, BARRY STICKER, 13-4521, JAMES D. STONE, 13-4521, SHARLA S.STONE, 13-4521, KATHERINE TOSCANO, 13-4521, NICOLAS TOSCANO, 13-4521, DEBORAH A. VALERI,13-4521, EUGENE R. VIGIL, 13-4521, BARBARA WEBBER, 13-4521, STEPHEN L. WEBBER, 13-4521, BRENDA A.ARRINGTON, 13-4521, AMANDA C. BAKER, 13-4521, CLARENCE A. BLEVINS, 13-4521, HOLLY BLEVINS,13-4521, JIMMY R. POOL, 13-4521, ANN RICCIARDI, 13-4521, JULIAINE VIGIL, 13-4521, ANNETTE WILLIAMS,13-4521, CHARLES WOODS, 13-4521, MARY YARBER, individually and as the proposed special administrator ofFranklin B. Yarber, deceased/ 13-4521, NOBLE YEOMAN, 13-4521, PAUL E. ZAPPALA, 13-4521, CAROLINE S.ZERBE, 13-4521, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): Steven M. Aroesty, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli BernRipka Shkolnik & Associates LLP, Edwardsville, IL.

For JAMES AIKEN, 13-4516, VIRGINIA E. AIKEN, 13-3732, ANA ALBU, 13-3732, PAUN ALBU, 13-3732, JoseMorrero, 13-4815, MARILYN A. BOBO, 13-4780, RAY V. BOBO, 13-4780, NANCY L. BUNN, 13-4780, NEEDHAM O.BUNN, 13-4780, PAUL M. COLLINS, 13-4780, BONITA L. ERIE, 13-4780, DALE GUINN, 13-4780, BONNIE R.O'NEAL, 13-4780, MARY E. SALERNO, 13-4780, THOMAS H. SANDERS, 13-4780, ANN M. WEST, 13-4780,




EDWIN D. WEST, 13-4780, ORA WHITING, 13-4780, LILLIAN M. ANDERSON, as successor-in-interest on behalf ofthe estate of Truman L. Anderson, and Individually/ 13-4780, LOIS A. ANDREWS, 13-4780, GERALD ARANAYDO,13-4780, LORRAINE ARANAYDO, 13-4780, ROBERT L. BIGGIAM, 13-4780, RANDY L. FOX, 13-4780, ROBERT A.GRAINGER, 13-4780, WENDY S. GRAINGER, 13-4780, CALVIN HARGROVE, 13-4780, DEBRA HINTON, 13-4780,FOY C. HINTON, 13-4780, AUDREY C. MATTHEW, 13-4780, LARRY J. MCCAULEY, 13-4780, PAMELAMCCAULEY, 13-4780, MAURICE MILLER, 13-4780, ROBERT E. MILLS, 13-4780, LIZ MURPHY, 13-4780, THOMASMURPHY, 13-4780, MELISSA NEAL, as successor-in-interest on behalf of the estate of Katie M. Robinson, andIndividually/ 13-4780, DORIS OLSON, as successor-in-interest on behalf of the estate of Richard O. Olson, andIndividually/ 13-4780, CHARLIE S. OVERBY, 13-4780, DONNA ROACH, 13-4780, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK, LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK LLP, NEW YORK, NY; KellyAnn McMeekin, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik & Associates LLP, El Segundo, CA; MarissaChristina Langhoff, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik and Associates LLP, Ladera Ranch, CA.

For JEAN ALLBEE, 13-3942, RICHARD ALLBEE, 13-3942, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): JOSHUA CALEBEZRIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR, AUDET & PARTNERS, SANFRANCISCO, CA; WILLIAM M. AUDET, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR,AUDET & PARTNERS, LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA.

For ELIZABETH ABNEY, 13-4213, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): JOSHUA CALEB EZRIN, LEAD ATTORNEY,COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR, AUDET & PARTNERS, SAN FRANCISCO, CA; Jeffrey A.Travers, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, The Miller Firm LLC, Orange, VA; Michael Miller, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, TheMiller Firm, LLC, Orange, VA.

For HOYT LEON ALEXANDER, 13-3657, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): Mark E. Burton, Jr., Nancy Hersh, LEADATTORNEY, MDL, Hersh & Hersh, San Francisco, CA.

For CARL ROMANO, 13-3658, CHARLES ALLARD, 13-3658, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): Jeffrey A. Travers,LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, The Miller Firm LLC, Orange, VA; Mark E. Burton, Jr., Nancy Hersh, LEAD ATTORNEY,MDL, Hersh & Hersh, San Francisco, CA; Michael Miller, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, The Miller Firm, LLC, Orange, VA.

For Sheila Austin, 13-4775, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): CLAY JOSEPH GARSIDE, LEAD ATTORNEY,COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, WALTZER WIYGUL & GARSIDE LLC, NEW ORLEANS, LA; Joel R.Waltzer, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Waltzer & Associates (Harvey), Harvey, LA.

For Kenneth R. Howell, 13-4783, Dennis S. Johnson, 13-4783, Randall K. Ritchey, 13-4894, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK, LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK LLP, NEW YORK, NY;Jessica You Lee, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik & Associates LLP, Ladera Ranch, CA; KellyAnn McMeekin, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik & Associates LLP, El Segundo, CA; MarissaChristina Langhoff, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik and Associates LLP, Ladera Ranch, CA.

For HELEN VIGIL, 13-4780, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK, LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLIBERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK LLP, NEW YORK, NY; Kelly Ann McMeekin, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern RipkaShkolnik & Associates LLP, El Segundo, CA; Marissa Christina Langhoff, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern RipkaShkolnik and Associates LLP, Ladera Ranch, CA.

For JOSE V. VIGIL, 13-4780, JIMMIE WRIGHT, 13-4780, PATRICIA BOULRIS, 13-4784, RONALD T. BOULRIS,13-4784, JANE L. BUTLER, 13-4784, LAMAR W. BUTLER, 13-4784, GEORGE W. DAVIS, 13-4784, EDMUND B.DWYER, 13-4784, KAREN DWYER, 13-4784, CYNTHIA E. FORD, 13-4784, DUANE P. FORD, 13-4784, GEORGEV. LOCKWOOD, JR., 13-4784, DEBRA A. PERSON, 13-4784, JASPER PERSON, 13-4784, RONALD P. RICO, assuccessor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Dolores Rico and individually/ 13-4784, ANN SPENCER, 13-4784,HARVEY C. SPENCER, 13-4784, ANNA J. TINGLEY, 13-4784, DAVID W. WEAVER, 13-4784, MARY E. WEAVER,13-4784, EDNA G. WILSON, 13-4784, GLORIA WILSON, as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Lorenzo




S. Wilson and individually/ 13-4784, RICHARD A. WILSON, 13-4784, ALEX W. ASBLE, 13-4784, BOBBY BAKER,13-4784, JAMES BURTON, 13-4784, MARY O. BURTON, 13-4784, EZRA K. CASSIDY, 13-4784, JOHN DELOACH,13-4784, VICKI DELOACH, 13-4784, WAYNE A. GARNER, 13-4784, JOHN GIARDINA, 13-4784, ELIZABETHJERNIGAN, 13-4784, KENNETH W. KELLY, 13-4784, LIESELOTTE I. MCLAIN, 13-4784, GRACE PEDRICK, assuccessor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Earl F. Pedrick and individually/ 13-4784, SANDRA PILARSKI, assuccessor in interest on behalf of the Estate of James M. Pilarski and individually/ 13-4784, GAIL M. SLAGLE,13-4784, THOMAS S. SLAGLE, 13-4784, DOROTHY WILLIAMS, 13-4784, HEZEKIAH WILLIAMS, SR., 13-4784,IRENE E. WILLIAMS, 13-4784, M.D. THOMAS A. WILLIAMS, 13-4784, GENEVA K. BELLINGER, 13-4784, LARRYD. BELLINGER, 13-4784, RICHARD J. BENNETT, 13-4784, EDNA A. BROWN, 13-4784, PATSY S. BURCH,13-4784, LEONARD B. CANTRELL, 13-4784, DAVID J. CLARK, JR., 13-4784, DEBRA L. CLARK, 13-4784, JOHN K.DEGOLIER, 13-4784, LORETTA J. DEGOLIER, 13-4784, CALLIE H. DELOATCH, 13-4784, HENRY DELOATCH,13-4784, NANCY M. GLENN, 13-4784, JUDY GODLEY, 13-4784, RONALD GODLEY, 13-4784, MARILYN LADSON,13-4784, CAROL A. LAFLEUR, 13-4784, FRANCIS J. MITCHELL, 13-4784, LILLIAN MITCHELL, 13-4784, JESSIE J.OLIVER, 13-4784, NINA F. OLIVER, 13-4784, FLORENCE A. ORTIZ, 13-4784, GILBERT ORTIZ, 13-4784, MARYLOU SCHULZE, 13-4784, ROBERT J. SCHULZE, 13-4784, RONALD D. TAYLOR, 13-4784, SHIRLEY A. TAYLOR,13-4784, KARL TESKE, as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Dorothy Teske and individually/ 13-4784,NORMAN H. YEOMANS, 13-4784, MARY D. YORK, 13-4784, WILLIAM C. BARNES, a citizen of the State ofAlabama/ 13-4785, STANLEY J. BARNETT, a citizen of the State of Arkansas/ 13-4785, RALPH A. BRODIE, a citizenof the State of North Carolina/ 13-4785, ROY E. BROWN, successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Wanda L.Brown, a citizen of the State of Ohio/ 13-4785, ARTHUR F. FACIANE, a citizen of the State of Florida/ 13-4785,BRENDA L. FACIANE, 13-4785, DOROTHY G. GIBSON, 13-4785, MARY HICKS, 13-4785, WALTER R. HICKS, JR.,a citizen of the State of Pennsylvania/ 13-4785, LUTHER E. JOHNSON, a citizen of the State of Arkansas/ 13-4785,PATRICIA A. JOHNSON, 13-4785, JEANETTE N. KROMIS, a citizen of the State of Alabama/ 13-4785, MARY K.MANNING, a citizen of the State of Alabama/ 13-4785, JOSEPH OCETNIK, 13-4785, MARY S. OCETNIK, a citizen ofthe State of Pennsylvania/ 13-4785, NELSON PEREZ, a citizen of the State of North Carolina/ 13-4785, STEPHANIEPEREZ, 13-4785, DARNESE SMITH, 13-4785, DOROTHY J. SMITH, a citizen of the State of Mississippi/ 13-4785,TIMOTHY SMITH, 13-4785, TINA R. SMITH, a citizen of the State of West Virginia/ 13-4785, HERMAN A. WILCOX, acitizen of the State of Florida/ 13-4785, BARBARA BRODIE, 13-4785, ELIZABETH GRANT, a citizen of the State ofTennessee/ 13-4785, SUE E. HEARON, a citizen of the State of Mississippi/ 13-4785, PERRY V. MCGRECK, assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Elizabeth A. McGreck, a citizen of the State of Wisconsin/ 13-4785,BETTY S. SHAFFER, a citizen of the State of North Carolina/ 13-4785, LETHA BUTCHER, a citizen of the State ofWest Virginia/ 13-4785, TRACY BUTCHER, 13-4785, ROBERT PENDERGAST, a citizen of the State of NewHampshire/ 13-4785, FREDERICK L. PLETKA, a citizen of the State of Arizona/ 13-4785, JOSEPH SHAFFER,13-4785, JANICE SWEET, 13-4785, LEON SWEET, a citizen of the State of Alabama/ 13-4785, EMILY C. URIOT, acitizen of the State of Massachusetts/ 13-4785, FLORA BECKER, successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofAllen Becker, a citizen of the State of Maryland/ 13-4785, MECHELLE B. BLACKWELL, a citizen of the State of NorthCarolina/ 13-4785, BARBARA M. BROUSSARD, a citizen of the State of New Mexico/ 13-4785, TAMME FORD, acitizen of the State of New Mexico/ 13-4785, MARY JO JENKINS, a citizen of the State of South Carolina/ 13-4785,JOHN D. JESSE, a citizen of the State of South Carolina/ 13-4785, LOUISE E. JESSE, 13-4785, JOY MILLS,13-4785, ROBERT E. MILLS, a citizen of the State of South Carolina/ 13-4785, VALERIE H. PETTIE, successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Mason H. Pettie, a citizen of the State of Virginia/ 13-4785, THERESE M. PLETKA,13-4785, BILLY J. SNYDER, a citizen of the State of Ohio/ 13-4785, RITA C. SNYDER, 13-4785, BOBBIE SPENCER,13-4785, HOWARD SPENCER, a citizen of the State of Mississippi/ 13-4785, BRUCE C. SWIKERT, a citizen of theState of Wisconsin/ 13-4785, MARY K. SWIKERT, 13-4785, BELENDA M. BUCHANAN, successor-in-interest of theEstate of Samuel R Buchanan, a citizen of the the State of Missouri/ 13-4785, KENNETH F. CREUTZ, a citizen of theState of Florida/ 13-4785, BARRY GORREVICH, a citizen of the State of Florida/ 13-4785, PHOEBE HENRY,successor-in-interest of the Estate of Ella F. Henry, a citizen of the State of Missouri/ 13-4785, WILLA F. HOUSTON,a citizen of the State of Missouri/ 13-4785, ZIZO CARABALLO, a citizen of the State of Florida/ 13-4785, ANTHONYCUNNINGHAM, a citizen of the State of Maryland/ 13-4785, DEBORAH L. CUNNINGHAM, 13-4785, HELEN F.HOLMES, a citizen of the State of Maryland/ 13-4785, JANET S. HUTCHINS, a citizen of the State of North Carolina/13-4785, LORNA H. LEE, 13-4785, TIMOTHY R. LEE, a citizen of the State of Arkansas/ 13-4785, ARVILLIA B.MONTGOMERY, a citizen of the State of Florida/ 13-4785, SHERRY A. RAY, a citizen of the State of Arkansas/




13-4785, ERNEST ROGERS, a citizen of the State of Mississippi/ 13-4785, RAE ROGERS, 13-4785, DOUGLAS T.STOLAR, a citizen of the State of Wisconsin/ 13-4785, PATRICIA M. STOLAR, 13-4785, MARY V. ADAMS, 13-4786,ARTHUR H. BURSEY, 13-4786, ROBERT L. GREEN, 13-4786, FLOYD RODGERS, JR., 13-4786, DIXIE ROSS,13-4786, LARRY D. ROSS, 13-4786, SHARON R. BAILEY, 13-4786, JUDITH C. CHANEY, 13-4786, ROGER L.COLLINSON, 13-4786, CRAIG J. HERWIG, 13-4786, ALVA L. HOWELL, 13-4786, AMBER HOWELL, 13-4786,RICHARD C. HUEBNER, 13-4786, PEGGY A. JONES, 13-4786, VALERIE D. JONES, 13-4786, WALTER E. JONES,13-4786, ALLEN S. KOHLLMAN, 13-4786, SARAH S. KOHLLMAN, 13-4786, MAVIS F. MARLOWE, 13-4786,TERESA PELHAM, 13-4786, LEVESTER WALLACE, 13-4786, RUTH F. WHEELER-COLLINSON, 13-4786, JEAN E.ALLBEE, 13-4786, RICHARD F. ALLBEE, 13-4786, TIMOTHY R. LONG, 13-4786, KEVIN J. MARTIN, 13-4786,ROBIN L. MARTIN, 13-4786, BRUCE A. MCINTIRE, 13-4786, LYNNETTE L. MCINTIRE, 13-4786, CHARLOTTETOOMEY, 13-4786, JASPER M. TOOMEY, 13-4786, SANDRA CLAY, 13-4786, TONEY J. CLAY, 13-4786, ROBERTE. FEINSILVER, 13-4786, SARA JANE FEINSILVER, 13-4786, LINDA JONES, 13-4786, MARK A. JONES, 13-4786,LINDA R. PAUL, 13-4786, ROBERT L. PAUL, 13-4786, CAROL ROBERTSON, 13-4786, DANIEL L. ROBERTSON,13-4786, ELEANOR SCHNELL, 13-4786, SIDNEY SCHNELL, 13-4786, BRENDA R. CROMAS, 13-4786, RICHARDE. CROMAS, 13-4786, LARRY B. LEE, 13-4786, ANGELA M. MARPLES, 13-4786, EDWARD C. MARPLES,13-4786, VIOLET R. NORDBY, 13-4786, FELIX SANCHEZ, 13-4786, AUTRY J. TAYLOR, 13-4786, WYNELLA P.WILSON, 13-4786, ANNIE BLAIR, 13-4786, JAMES E. BLAIR, 13-4786, KATHY B. BOX-GUILLOTTE, 13-4786,ARCHIE BROOKS, 13-4786, JOHN L. DAHLQUIST, 13-4786, JUDITH A. DAHLQUIST, 13-4786, EARL GUILLOTTE,13-4786, JOSE M MARTINEZ, 13-4786, RICHARD CHIND, 13-4786, BUDDY B. CUMBER, 13-4786, VANESSA L.CUMBER, 13-4786, LORETTA A. HULL, 13-4786, GENEVA JOHNSON, 13-4786, LARRY E. JOHNSON, 13-4786,BILLIE D. MARTIN, 13-4786, EDGAR L. MCLAUGHLIN, 13-4786, LISA M. MCLAUGHLIN, 13-4786, LEE P. SOX,13-4786, FLOYD E. STAI, 13-4786, MARGARET A. STAI, 13-4786, Plaintiffs: HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK, LEADATTORNEY, NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK LLP, NEW YORK, NY; Kelly Ann McMeekin, LEAD ATTORNEY,MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik & Associates LLP, El Segundo, CA; Marissa Christina Langhoff, LEAD ATTORNEY,MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik and Associates LLP, Ladera Ranch, CA.

For ALFRED T. BOUTWELL, 13-4780, AUDREY C. BOUTWELL, 13-4780, FLORENCE BOYCE, 13-4780, LEWIS S.BOYCE, 13-4780, EDNA L. BURGE, 13-4780, DANIEL E. NOBLE, 13-4780, JUDITH C. NOBLE, 13-4780, SANDRAPRISBY, 13-4780, ANTHONY M. RICCARDI, PATRICIA RICCARDI, 13-4780, Plaintiffs: HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK,LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK LLP, NEW YORK, NY; KELLY MCMEEKIN, LEADATTORNEY. Marissa Christina Langhoff, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik and Associates LLP,Ladera Ranch, CA.

For BERNICE L. ARMSTEAD, 13-4780, Plaintiff: HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK, LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI BERN RIPKASHKOLNIK LLP, NEW YORK, NY; KELLY MCMEEKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY; Marissa Christina Langhoff, LEADATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik and Associates LLP, Ladera Ranch, CA.

For EDMUND J. PRISBY, 13-4780, Plaintiff: HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK, LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI BERN RIPKASHKOLNIK LLP, NEW YORK, NY; KELLY MCMEEKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY., LEAD ATTORNEY. Marissa ChristinaLanghoff, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik and Associates LLP, Ladera Ranch, CA.

For EDMUND J. PRISBY, 13-4780, Plaintiff: HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK, LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI BERN RIPKASHKOLNIK LLP, NEW YORK, NY; KELLY MCMEEKIN, LEAD ATTORNEY., LEAD ATTORNEY. Marissa ChristinaLanghoff, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik and Associates LLP, Ladera Ranch, CA.

For KATHY STRAUSSER, as successor-in-interest on behalf of the estate of Alice Morgan, and Individually/ 13-4780,FRANKLIN ADDISON, 13-4782, Plaintiffs: JOSHUA CALEB EZRIN, WILLIAM M. AUDET, LEAD ATTORNEY,COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR AUDET & PARTNERS, SAN FRANCISCO, CA.

For Peggy Sue Boatright, 13-5309, Plaintiff: JOSHUA CALEB EZRIN, WILLIAM M. AUDET, LEAD ATTORNEY,COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR AUDET & PARTNERS, SAN FRANCISCO, CA; LEADATTORNEY Jeffrey A. Travers, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, The Miller Firm LLC, Orange, VA; Michael Miller, LEAD




ATTORNEY, MDL, The Miller Firm, LLC, Orange, VA.

For Pamela M. Harris, 13-5316, Plaintiff: JOSHUA CALEB EZRIN, WILLIAM M. AUDET, LEAD ATTORNEY,COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR AUDET & PARTNERS, SAN FRANCISCO, CA; Jeffrey A. Travers,LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, The Miller Firm LLC, Orange, VA.

For DORIS ALLEN, 13-5311, LEONARD ALLEN, 13-5311, JENNIFER ASAD, 13-5311, JERRY BALLARD, 13-5311,WILLIAM BOHRER, 13-5311, ROBERT BRANDEWIE, 13-5311, JOSEPH BRANNIGAN, 13-5311, RHUENETTEBROWN, 13-5311, JUDY CARADINE, 13-5311, BARBARA CROW, 13-5311, VERNEL GOODSON-BALLARD,13-5311, FRANCES MCGUIRE, 13-5311, GORDON CURL, 13-5311, HELENA DOCKERY, 13-5311, DONALDDRIVER, 13-5311, ROLAND EAGLIN, 13-5311, JANET EPSTEIN, 13-5311, JOANNE FRANKLIN, 13-5311, KARENGREENWELL, 13-5311, CHARMAINE HOFFMAN, 13-5311, JOYCE HOLLOWELL, 13-5311, BETTY HOWSER,13-5311, RONALD JACKSON, 13-5311, GERALDINE KEETON, 13-5311, GEORGE LOWE, 13-5311, JAMES MAHL,13-5311, ALLEN MAYVILLE, 13-5311, MARGARET MAYVILLE, 13-5311, JAMES MCCAULEY, 13-5311, JERRIMCCOY, 13-5311, MARTIN MCCOY, 13-5311, DEBORAH MORGAN-EAGLIN, 13-5311, VANESSA PAUL, 13-5311,CIDRIC STARR, 13-5311, MISTY MICHELLE BERRYHILL, as Representative of the estate of Mary Looney/ 13-5311,GAIL LIEBMAN, as Representative of the estate of Anne Makufka/ 13-5311, JAMES QUISENBERRY, 13-5311,VIRGINIA RIST, as Representative of the estate of Paul Rist/ 13-5311, ARTHUR SANDELLI, 13-5311, BENJAMINSAYLOR, 13-5311, ROGER STARNES, 13-5311, NANCY WRIGHT, 13-5311, JOYCE YOHO, 13-5311, LEE ZENO-GEORGE, 13-5311, MAUREEN A. BARTNICKI, 13-5276, EDITH DOBERSTEIN, 13-5276, IRVING EPSTEIN,13-5276, KIM B. LOPEZ, 13-5276, ROBERT C. LOUGH, 13-5276, RUTH LOYD, 13-5276, ELEANOR MALAM,13-5276, JAMES MARTIN, 13-5276, JAMIE MATTILA, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estateof Margaret Bartnicki/ 13-5276, MAUREEN A. MCCOY, 13-5276, IMOGENE MCCURLEY, 13-5276, ANNMCGOVERN, 13-5276, LEON ROBERSON, 13-5276, MAGGIE BREWER, 13-5276, MICHAEL MILLER, 13-5276,JESSE MOORE, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Polly Moore/ 13-5276, FRANKMORMUR, 13-5276, KENNETH MORRILL, 13-5276, MARY C. MOXLEY, 13-5276, VALMORE NADIN, 13-5276,WALTER NAGORSKI, 13-5276, ALEX NAHORNEY, 13-5276, CAROL A. NEBEL, 13-5276, WILLIAM NEWMAN,13-5276, MARY NIET, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Frank Niet/ 13-5276, LARRYNOBLE, 13-5276, LINDA NOELL, 13-5276, JOHN NORMAN, 13-5276, HAROLD OAKS, 13-5276, REBECCAPAYNE, 13-5276, HANS J. PFEIFFER, 13-5276, AUDREY PUGH, individually and as successor in interest on behalfof the Estate of Robbie Lee Pugh/ 13-5276, JUDITH RANDALL, 13-5276, NEIL REDDINGTON, 13-5276, DAVIDRIPPER, 13-5276, GEORGE SELLERY, 13-5276, Plaintiff: JOSHUA CALEB EZRIN, WILLIAM M. AUDET, LEADATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR AUDET & PARTNERS, SAN FRANCISCO, CA.

For AUDREY PUGH, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Robbie Lee Pugh/ 13-5276,JUDITH RANDALL, 13-5276, NEIL REDDINGTON, 13-5276, DAVID RIPPER, 13-5276, GEORGE SELLERY,13-5276, FRANK SHABAZIAN, 13-5276, SHERWIN SILVERMAN, 13-5276, ALMAJEAN SMITH, 13-5276, BARBARASMITH, 13-5276, DALE SNOW, 13-5276, MARLYN STREET, 13-5276, RONALD F. SWANSON, 13-5276, DIANATAYLOR, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the State of Don Smart/ 13-5276, WILMA J. TAYLOR,13-5276, PEGGY A. TETEN, 13-5276, ANNETTE THOMAS, 13-5276, ELIZABETH TOMPKINS, individually and assuccessor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Douglas Smith/ 13-5276, LEROY TURCHIN, 13-5276, RENEVILLARREAL, 13-5276, EDWARD WALKER, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of MaryWaller/ 13-5276, JIMMY WALKER, 13-5276, CONNIE WAPP, individually d as successor in interest on behalf of theEstate of William Whitesell/ 13-5276, JUNE MILLER RUBY, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of theEstate of Helen Miller/ 13-5276, SAM SALUZZI, 13-5276, ROGER SCHULSTAD, 13-5276, JOHN SCHWEGMAN,13-5276, RUTH SEEBER, 13-5276, CHARISSE M. ALDRIDGE, 13-5314, JAMES ALDRIDGE, 13-5314, MICHAELANDERSON, 13-5314, SALLINA ANDERSON, 13-5314, JERRY BODINE, 13-5314, MARY BODINE, 13-5314, JOHNBRYANT, 13-5314, ELLEN CARR, 13-5314, LOUIS CLARK, 13-5314, WILLIAM COLLINS, 13-5314, HOWARDDIAMOND, 13-5314, WILLY REBECCA DIAMOND, 13-5314, FELIX FAIRLEY, 13-5314, JOYCE FOSS, 13-5314,SHER KHAN, 13-5314, CYNTHIA GATHRIGHT, 13-5314, JAMES W. GATHRIGHT, 13-5314, GEORGE GORCHEFF,13-5314, CHARLES GREEN, 13-5314, JANE GREEN, 13-5314, ELIZABETH HESS, 13-5314, WILLIAM HESS,13-5314, LEE LAMBERT, 13-5314, MARY LAMBERT, 13-5314, DOROTHY MARTIN, 13-5314, EDWARD MARTIN,




13-5314, RICK MILLER, 13-5314, CLYDE MORGAN, 13-5314, DOROTHY MORGAN, 13-5314, GILBERT PARKER,13-5314, ORVILLE PATT, 13-5314, NORMAN ROGERS, 13-5314, JENNY ROZHON, 13-5314, RAYMONDROZHON, 13-5314, RUBY SANDERS, 13-5314, RONALD SCHULTZ, 13-5314, PAUL SMITH, 13-5314, CARIETHASTEELE, 13-5314, EDWARD STEELE, 13-5314, WILLIAM TOLAND, 13-5314, LUCY TURNER, 13-5314, BARBARAURBAN, 13-5314, ROBERT URBAN, 13-5314, ALEXANDER WEINRUB, 13-5314, CARL WHITMIRE, 13-5314,EDDIE WILLIAMS, 13-5314, MILTON WILLIAMS, 13-5314, JAMES WORTHY, 13-5314, DELLA YARBROUGH,13-5314, JOHNNIE YARBROUGH, 13-5314, RONALD SCHULTZ, 13-5314, KENNETH ANDRUS, 13-5327, ALBERTBELL, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Ellen Norman/ 13-5327, NORMAN B. BORK,13-5327, TALMADGE H. BRAXTON, 13-5327, ARTHUR R. BROOKS, SR., 13-5327, EUGENE R. BUNYAN,13-5327, CEASAR CABRERA, III, 13-5327, EZRA CADDIDY, 13-5327, EDDIE KESSEL, 13-5327, ASA TUCKER,individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Jeanne Tucker/ 13-5327, SHELBY WARHURST,13-5327, CHARLES CHAMBERLIN, 13-5327, LAWRENCE E. CHAPLIN, 13-5327, ALONZO COBURN, 13-5327,BARBARA A. COLEMAN, 13-5327, HOWARD L. CROSSMAN, 13-5327, HERMAN F. FORSYTH, 13-5327,CHRISTINE GODFREY, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Paul Pichezzi/ 13-5327,WILLIAM GODFREY, 13-5327, TIMOTHY F. HOLLAND, 13-5327, OKEY HOLT, 13-5327, CAROLYN HOOKER,13-5327, BETTY C. HOPKINS, 13-5327, FLLOYD IRVING, 13-5327, ANNA JOHNSON, 13-5327, FANNIE M.JOHNSON, 13-5327, GENNETT JONES, 13-5327, JUNE M. KLEIN, 13-5327, JAMES LADDECK, 13-5327, JANETMANDEL, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Vida Cohen/ 13-5327, GLORIAMANNING, 13-5327, JACK W. MAYS, 13-5327, JAMES MCCORD, 13-5327, MARIA K. MCCORMACK, 13-5327,PATRICIA MESSINA, 13-5327, ROBERT ORR, 13-5327, JUDITH M. PARENTEAU, 13-5327, CHRISTINA PARRISH,13-5327, SHIRLEY PASCARELLA, 13-5327, HARLEY PHILLIPS, 13-5327, ROGER W. POLLOCK, 13-5327,RONNIE L PONDER, 13-5327, JOAN PRESTON, 13-5327, REGINA REED, individually and as successor in intereston behalf of the Estate of William Powell/ 13-5327, EVELYN C. ROBERTS, 13-5327, BRUCE RONEY, 13-5327,STANLEY RUBEN, 13-5327, PHV ROBERT SCHAFFER, 13-5327, JACKIE SCOTT, 13-5327, SUSAN SPENGLER,13-5327, LOUIS STROBEL, 13-5327, STAN TATE, 13-5327, ZETTIE THOMPSON, 13-5327, BERNARD WALKER,13-5327, GRETCHEN WILLIAMS, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Marian Williams/13-5327, MITIZIE J. MILNER, 13-5327, DANIEL MOSS, 13-5327, MARY LYNN MURPHY, individually and assuccessor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Johnny Murphy/ 13-5327, GEORGE MYERS, 13-5327, SHIRLEYESTER, Individually and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Freggie Mack/ 13-5414, REBECCA FARR,as Representative of the Estate of Jessie Jenkins/ 13-5414, BERNICE FIKES, 13-5414, NADER GHAIDI, 13-5414,DONNIE GREEN, 13-5414, MARY JOE GRIFFIN, 13-5414, PATRICIA HOUGH, 13-5414, ROSEMARIE LOWE,13-5414, PHYLLIS MILLER, 13-5414, IKE MORRIS, 13-5414, HAYDEN RICHARDSON, 13-5414, RON ROBERTS,13-5414, TINA ROMERO, 13-5414, FELICIA THOMAS, individually and as successor-in-interest on behalf of theEstate of Dolly Thomas/ 13-5414, SEMETRA THOMAS, 13-5414, PATRICK VIGIL, 13-5414, RAY WHORTON,13-5414, MANDA WILLIAMS, 13-5414, CHARLES WRIGHT, 13-5414, DIANA ALBERTSEN, 13-5413, CARL O.BROWN, 13-5413, ORLANDO CUDAL, 13-5413, WILLIAM DESILVA, individually, and as successor-in-interest onbehalf of the Estate of Michael D. McEver/ 13-5413, JUANITA ELLIOTT, 13-5413, BETTY GARRINGER, 13-5413,TOMASINA JONES, 13-5413, BEVERLY P. MAGGI, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estateof Lawrence Maggi/ 13-5413, RAY MOTLEY, 13-5413, DAVID WILKERSON, 13-5413, CESAR CABRERA, III,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Cesar O.Cabrera/ 13-5413, EMORY JACKSON,13-5413, THOMAS KILGALLON, 13-5413, JANIS MAHLER, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of theEstate of Evelyn Niemann/ 13-5413, MONICA PRAWL, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of theEstate of Israel Anderson/ 13-5413, ROBERT B. PRICE, 13-5413, ROBERT J. ROWE, 13-5413, GRACE SCHAAR,13-5413, LISA TOLLISON, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Johnny Tollison/13-5413, DANNY TURNER, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Barbara Turner/13-5413, MAGGIE BEWER, 13-5413, BEVERLY ANN LOMBARDO, 13-5413, JON MANGLES, 13-5413, JAMIEMCGUIRE, 13-5413, ANN MILLS, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Norma Philbrick/13-5413, GERROLD PARRISH, 13-5413, JAMES PRESLEY, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf ofthe Estate of Luther Presley/ 13-5413, BARBARA WILHELM, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf ofthe Estate of Bill Taylor/ 13-5413, MILDRED I. WILL, 13-5413, CHRISTOPHER BIBBS, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Mary Bibbs/ 13-5413, CHRISTOPHER BIBBS, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Mary Bibbs/ 13-5413, SUNDRIA JOHNSON, 13-5413, GARY




PLYLER, 13-5413, ANTHONY D. PRYOR, 13-5413, FRED AMSTER, 13-5413, WILLIAM BENSON, 13-5413, CARLH. DONDORFER, III, 13-5413, LINDA HARPER, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofJewel Blackwell/ 13-5413, TED L. HOFFMAN, Individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofSandra L. Hoffman/ 13-5413, JANICE KIRKLAND, Individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofVivian Blocker/ 13-5413, CLEO KITCHEN, 13-5413, RUBY JUNE MILLER, individually, and as successor-in-intereston behalf of the Estate of Helen Miller/ 13-5413, MARVIN O. MODEEN, 13-5413, MARIANNE OTTE, 13-5413,JOYCE PHILLIPS, 13-5413, GERALD PRIMER, 13-5413, PETER PULLANO, 13-5413, HAZEL D. RAY, 13-5413,JOHN ALBERTS, 13-5413, JOHN M. BAILEY, 13-5413, LORI BREDA, Individually, and as successor-in-interest onbehalf of the Estate of Barbara Katana/ 13-5413, NILDA T. CORTES, Individually, and as successor-in-interest onbehalf of the Estate of Theresa Cortes/ 13-5413, CORA A. HENDERSON, 13-5413, IVA IBARRA, 13-5413, VICKIENEAL, 13-5413, PAUL PARKS, Individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Bessie Parks/13-5413, PATRICIA A. POWELL, 13-5413, WILLIE PRESLEY, 13-5413, FRANCIS PULEO, Individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Patricia Puleo/ 13-5413, JOVITO RAMOS, 13-5413, BARBARASHULER, Individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Michael Carson/ 13-5413, LAWRENCEVAUGHT, 13-5413, RICHARD K. WILLIAMS, 13-5413, Plaintiffs: JOSHUA CALEB EZRIN, WILLIAM M. AUDET,LEAD ATTORNEYS, SAN FRANCISCO, CA.

For LYNN FAYE BANKS, 13-5313, ROSS G. ANDERSON, JR., 13-5313, LETICIA ARROTO, individually, and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Felix Ramos/ 13-5313, HAROLD H. CHALKINE, 13-5313, BETTYCUMMINGS, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Charles Cummings/ 13-5313,ROGER DEMERS, 13-5313, KIMBERLY DOUGLAS, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estateof Elnora J. Eccles/ 13-5313, CAROL DOWE, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of SueGrant/ 13-5313, DANIEL J. ESCAJEDO, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of LoisEscajeda/ 13-5313, BETTY FAYNE, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Fred Fayne/13-5313, WILLIAM FIORINI, 13-5313, LOYCE FISHER, 13-5313, PATRICIA A. HOLLIMON, 13-5313, BARBARA A.HOUSE, 13-5313, KAREN HUBERT, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of RosemarieRainer/ 13-5313, MAYRA MATA, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Pedro Mata/13-5313, MARY E. MCMILLAN, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Lan R. McMillan/ 13-5313,LAURA H. MORGAN, 13-5313, PEARLIE MORGAN, 13-5313, WILLIAM MUTCHER, 13-5313, RICHARD O'BRIEN,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of John O'Brien/ 13-5313, PEARLEAN PAGE,13-5313, GLENDA SUE WHITTON, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of ThomasWhitton/ 13-5313, BRIAN IMMERMAN, 13-5313, ELEANOR MAZZIO, individually, and as successor-in-interest onbehalf of the Estate of Richard Mazzio/ 13-5313, ANDREA MCDONALD, individually and as successor-in-interest onbehalf of the Estate of Evelene McDonald/ 13-5313, JACKIE MCPHAIL, 13-5313, SUSAN MAW MICHAEL,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Myrtle Michael/ 13-5313, CAROL PANGBURN,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of John Pangburn/ 13-5313, SUSAN PERRY,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Ralph Perry/ 13-5313, SANDRA E. PULIDO-DAVALOS, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Victoriano Alvarado/ 13-5313,MICHAEL RAYANO, 13-5313, JOSEPH A. REISER, 13-5313, DARRELL C. ROBERTS, 13-5313, CATHY SCIARA,as power of attorney for Anita Dorei/ 13-5313, MARTHA SHAW, individually, as successor-in-interest on behalf of theEstate of Ruby Shaw/ 13-5313, HEDE A. SHOPE, 13-5313, DORA THOMAS, 13-5313, CHARLES THORSON,13-5313, KRISTIN TOUT, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of James Tout/ 13-5313,CHARLES E. TOWE, 13-5313, RUTHIE D. WHITE, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estateof J. B. White/ 13-5313, JUANITA WYMOLA, 13-5313, LONNIE BARRINGER, 13-5313, HELEN BARTRUM,individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Louis Edwards/ 13-5313, JAMES BELCHER,13-5313, LISA BRADFORD, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Euginia Emile/13-5313, GLENDA CARTER, 13-5313, BARBARA EDMONDS, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofFrankie Edmons/ 13-5313, JIMMIE BEATRICE FELKNER, 13-5313, ANTHONY GABOR, 13-5313, JANYCEJORDAN, 13-5313, ASHA PARKASH, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of VedParkash/ 13-5313, VIRGINIA PARRY, individually, and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of William L.Parry/ 13-5313, GARY RAYMAN, 13-5313, RUSSELL G. RICE, 13-5313, MARY SENATORE, 13-5313, RICHARDSHELBY, 13-5313, BETTY SIMS, 13-5313, MICHELLE THORNBURG, individually, and as successor-in-interest on




behalf of the Estate of Warren Thornburg/ 13-5313, Plaintiffs: JOSHUA CALEB EZRIN, WILLIAM M. AUDET, LEADATTORNEYS, SAN FRANCISCO, CA; Jeffrey A. Travers, Michael Miller, LEAD ATTORNEYS, The Miller Firm LLC,Orange, VA.

For James Poinsett, 13-5575, Plaintiff: JOSEPH D. KLENOFSKY, LEAD ATTORNEY, MEYERKORD & MEYERKORDLLC, ST. LOUIS, MO.

For Jim Hood, 13-5910 - Attorney General of the State of Mississippi, ex rel. The State of Mississippi, Plaintiff:Fletcher V. Trammell, LEAD ATTORNEY, PRO HAC VICE, BAILEY PERRIN BAILEY, Houston, TX; George W.Neville, LEAD ATTORNEY, OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, Jackson, MS; Meredith McCollum Aldridge,LEAD ATTORNEY, MISSISSIPPI ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE, Jackson, MS; ROBERT W. COWAN, LEADATTORNEY, BAILEY PEAVY BAILEY PLLC, HOUSTON, TX; Samuel Martin Millette, III, LEAD ATTORNEY,MISSISSIPPI ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE - 220, Jackson, MS; W. Howard Gunn, LEAD ATTORNEY, W.HOWARD GUNN & ASSOCIATES, Aberdeen, MS.

For Larry J. Douglas, 13-5912, DELON HALL, 13-5944, ROSIE HALL, 13-5944, HILTON H. HOOVER, 13-5944,BRENDA J. HOWARD, 13-5944, HOWARD W. JONES, 13-5944, ANCILLE KINNARD, 13-5944, THOMAS M.KINNARD, 13-5944, EDDIE J. MCCLAIN, 13-5944, JOYCE A. MONTGOMERY, 13-5944, FREDDIE E. PARKER, JR.,as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Shirley R. Buckner and individually/ 13-5944, MICHAEL C. SMITH,13-5944, RUTH A. SMITH, 13-5944, WENDY B. WISEMER, 13-5944, RACHEL V. MCCLAIN, 13-5944, DENNY L.ESTES, 13-5944, MICKEY J. ESTES, 13-5944, RICKY H. JARRARD, 13-5944, RUSSELL R. KEEGAN, 13-5944,SHIRLEY M. ROBERTS-JARRARD, 13-5944, JACKIE T. SIMMONS, 13-5944, ALFRED SIRAGUSA, 13-5944,JOANNE SIRAGUSA, 13-5944, BONNA STOAKES, 13-5944, CHARLES R. STOAKES, 13-5944, BOBBIETOLEFREE, 13-5944, LEON TOLEFREE, 13-5944, JERRY D. WILSON, 13-5944, LEIGH A. WILSON, 13-5944,BENNY C. GRIMES, 13-5944, PAULA GRIMES, 13-5944, DANIEL KLINK, 13-5944, LESSIE E. PERRIGO, 13-5944,SYBLE A. HAMILTON, 13-5944, WILLIAM L. PERRIGO, 13-5944, MICHELE PIEL, 13-5944, JOHN H. PORTER,13-5944, ROSS W. TARR, 13-5944, DENNIS N. WOJTON, 13-5944, ROSEMARY R. WOJTON, 13-5944, KATIEHOWARD, 13-5944, PATRICIA BROWN, 13-5944, LOUIS A. CSOKA, 13-5944, Plaintiffs: HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK,LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK LLP, NEW YORK, NY; Jessica You Lee, LEAD ATTORNEY,Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik & Associates LLP, Ladera Ranch, CA; Marissa Christina Langhoff, LEAD ATTORNEY,Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik and Associates LLP, Ladera Ranch, CA.

For NIKKI CSOKA, 13-5944, Plaintiff: HUNTER J. SHKOLNIK, LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIKLLP, NEW YORK, NY; Jessica You Lee, Marissa Christina Langhoff, LEAD ATTORNEYS, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik& Associates LLP, Ladera Ranch, CA.

For LIAM KENNY, 13-5944, PATRICIA KENNY, 13-5944, PHILLIP OGLESBY, JR., as successor-in-interest on behalfof the Estate of Phillip B. Oglesby, and individually/ 13-5944, DONALD L. SEESE, 13-5944, LOUELLA SEESE,13-5944, JOHN A. FRANKLIN, 13-5944, FREDERICK RADICS, as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate ofJulius A. Radics, and individually/ 13-5944, EARLUS J. VALENTINE, 13-5944, SOPHIE M. VALENTINE, 13-5944, D.SUZETTE WARREN, 13-5944, RONNIE W. WARREN, 13-5944, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): HUNTER J.SHKOLNIK, LEAD ATTORNEY, NAPOLI BERN RIPKA SHKOLNIK LLP, NEW YORK, NY; Jessica You Lee, LEADATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik & Associates LLP, Ladera Ranch, CA; Marissa Christina Langhoff,LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik and Associates LLP, Ladera Ranch, CA.

For Edward Beals, 13-7237, Wanda Berry, 13-7237, Bennie Best, 13-7237, Rosalyn Boyle, 13-7237, Hershel Brewer,13-7237, Sylvester Collie, 13-7237, Bella Docks, 13-7237, Fred Docks, 13-7237, Judith Galvan, 13-7237, NANCYGRIFFIN, 13-7237, Roland Griffin, Jr., 13-7237, Retta Halbrook, 13-7237, Ronald Halbrook, 13-7237, Richard Herrin,13-7237, Angras Hogg, 13-7237, Joshua Kiehl, 13-7237, Lois Laikin, 13-7237, Jimmie McCary, 13-7237, GuymonMcCullough, 13-7237, Shirley Castaneda, 13-7237, Mark Isabelle, 13-7237, Conseulo Madrid, 13-7237, Joseph P.McKinnon, 13-7237, Max Mogul, 13-7237, Ruth Mogul, 13-7237, PATRICK O'BRIEN, 13-7237, Fred Pike, 13-7237,Ricky Pope, 13-7237, Belinda Riggins, 13-7237, Mary Sewell, 13-7237, Lisa Thomas, 13-7237, David Tkacik,




13-7237, Dorothy Watson, 13-7237, Robert Weatherholt, 13-7237, Ruth Weatherholt, 13-7237, Glenda Wilcox,13-7237, Melvin Willoughby, 13-7237, KYLE L. ANDERSON, 13-7664, KARL ANDRADE, 13-7664, MICHAELARRIGOTTI, 13-7664, MARTHA ASHTON, 13-7664, PRINCESS BARKSDALE, individually and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Margie Barksdale/ 13-7664, CLARICE BLAND, 13-7664, DONALD BLUE, 13-7664,WILLIAM E. BOGDONOVICH, 13-7664, THOMAS BOURRETTE, individually and as successor-in-interest on behalfof the Estate of Sandra Bourrette/ 13-7664, GLENDA BOWERS, individually and as successor in interest on behalf ofthe Estate of Jean Gurthrie/ 13-7664, BOBBY D. BRADLEY, 13-7664, JIM BRYANT, 13-7664, JOETTA BUELL,individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Dorothy Allen/ 13-7664, RONALD BURCH,13-7664, MARY CARDWELL, 13-7664, LOUISE CASCELLA, 13-7664, LAURA CHRISTIANSON, 13-7664, WILLIECLAY, 13-7664, MARTHA CLAYBORN, 13-7664, DAVID E. COLLINS, 13-7664, GEORGE J. COSTA, SR., 13-7664,ROBERT J. EVANS, 13-7664, JOSEPH F. MEGLINO, SR., 13-7664, MINNIE MUNSON, 13-7664, MARTHA T.WEBB, 13-7664, MULDROW WEBB, 13-7664, JOSEPH WHITE, 13-7664, JOAN T. WILLETTE, 13-7664, CHARLIEWILLIAMS, 13-7664, DONALD WISSMAN, 13-7664, LYNNE S. WOLFF, 13-7664, HELEN YUAN, individually and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Dan Yuan/ 13-7664, GEORGE ZACKSCHEWSKI, 13-7664, ERIKAZWAGA, 13-7664, RITA J. CURRY, 13-7664, FAYE DAVIS, 13-7664, VIRGIN DELEON, 13-7664, CAROLYN DILLA,13-7664, REA EARLEEN DUNCAN, 13-7664, JOYCE ENGLISH, 13-7664, AUGUST D. FERRUIGA, 13-7664,DONALD FOXWELL, 13-7664, MONZOLA D. GAYTEN, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of theEstate of Robert White/ 13-7664, JACKIE GREGORY, 13-7664, THERESA GRUENER, 13-7664, DAVID HARBET,13-7664, LINDA HENDERSON, 13-7664, PATRICK D. HENRY, 13-7664, DOROTHY HOLLEY, 13-7664, SANDRAHOWARD, 13-7664, JIMMY C. HUDSON, 13-7664, ROBERT H. HUMPHREYS, 13-7664, JANET R. JACKSON,individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of David Jackson, Sr., / 13-7664, PEDRO JIMENEZ,13-7664, RICHARD L. JUNG, 13-7664, BARBARA KENNEDY, 13-7664, JAMES A. KERTZ, 13-7664, LOVELACEKIDD, 13-7664, JAMES A. LAWSON, 13-7664, TIMOTHY LEWEY, 13-7664, YOLANDA ACOSTA, 13-7749, LOVEYARNETTE, 13-7749, JERRY DEMOCKO, 13-7749, CLAIRE DESMARAIS, 13-7749, MARIETTE DORSEY, 13-7749,HATTIE GLENN, 13-7749, SHARON GRANGRUTH, 13-7749, KATHY HALCOMB, 13-7749, BONARD HUGHINS,13-7749, VALEESA JOHNSON, 13-7749, PHILIP LOPRESTI, 13-7749, ERLINDA LUCCA, as Representative of theEstate of Amirka Lucca, deceased/ 13-7749, KENNETH NEAL, JR., as Representative of the Estate of Kenneth Neal,deceased/ 13-7749, EUGENE NELSON, 13-7749, DEBORAH PARTAIN, 13-7749, ORVILLE PATT, 13-7749,YVONNE PORCHE, 13-7749, JOHN REED, 13-7749, BARBARA SHACKLEFORD, 13-7749, EDWARD TOMCHIN,13-7749, VONDELL BANKERT, 13-7750, CAROLYN CAHILL, 13-7750, VIRGIL L. LIENHARD, 13-7750, NORMALOTTINGER, 13-7750, JOSEPH MANN, 13-7750, WILLIE MASSEY, 13-7750, BARBARA MAYO, 13-7750, MARY M.MCALLISTER, 13-7750, TONI MCELVEEN, individually and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of TonyLicas/ 13-7750, JIM MERRITT, 13-7750, HELEN MEYER, 13-7750, BERNICE MORMAN, 13-7750, KATHY MORRIS,13-7750, ROBERT OSERES, 13-7750, MARK OTTO, 13-7750, HELEN PATACCA, 13-7750, DONALD L. PIERCE,13-7750, DARRYN PITMAN, 13-7750, ANTHONY C. PRICE, 13-7750, VERNA REESE, 13-7750, ROBERT ROSS,13-7750, ALBERT SCHIEBER, 13-7750, EARNESTINE SMITH, 13-7750, DONALD SNYDER, 13-7750, THOMASSTASIAK, 13-7750, GWENDOLYN STATEN, 13-7750, HILARION TERRONES, 13-7750, THOMAS J. TOWEY,13-7750, BETTY TROENDLY, 13-7750, EUGENE C. WARREN, 13-7750, MELBA D. WILEY, 13-7750, LOISWILLIAMS, 13-7750, ROSALINE WISE, 13-7750, WILLIAM WOLDT, 13-7750, SUSAN COX, 13-7750, LINDA D.DELPIANO, 13-7750, JANE C. GORDON, 13-7750, SUSAN GREENFIELD, individually and as successor-in-intereston behalf of the Estate of Robert Woodard/ 13-7750, ANNETTE F. HUNTER, 13-7750, EUNICE MURPHY, 13-7750,DANIEL OGNIAN, 13-7750, LOIS E. PELLETIER, 13-7750, FRANK PROBST, 13-7750, MABLE RANDALL, 13-7750,SAM REED, individually and as successor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Clare Reed/ 13-7750, XAVIERREYES, 13-7750, CYRUS SEE, 13-7750, JERRY T. STEWART, 13-7750, SANDRA TUCKER, individually and assuccessor-in-interest on behalf of the Estate of Howard Tucker/ 13-7750, LORI VEST, 13-7750, GEORGE T. YORK,13-7750, DR. WILLIAM YOUNG, 13-7750, EDDIE BARKSDALE, 13-7883, GLENNA BAYS, 13-7883, EDWARDBUSTAMANTE, 13-7883, SHIRLEY CRAWFORD, 13-7883, DEBORAH DIETERLE, 13-7883, EDWARD DIETERLE,13-7883, HARRY EHN, 13-7883, SHARON EHN, 13-7883, AVIS GEMMILL, 13-7883, WILLIAM GEMMILL, 13-7883,JOHN HEARY, 13-7883, VERONICA HEARY, 13-7883, DARRELL HUNSAKER, 13-7883, LAWRENCE PEDREGON,13-7883, KYLE CARTER, as representative of the estate of Moses Carter, deceased/ 13-7883, LAWRENCE DRAKE,13-7883, ANTONIA GARCIA, 13-7883, TALMADGE GUE, 13-7883, MUNIR HISHME, 13-7883, LAILA HISHMEH,13-7883, SUE HOEFLER, 13-7883, REGINA JACKSON, 13-7883, ELISHA JONES, 13-7883, JOAN JONES,




13-7883, LATANYA KING, 13-7883, VIRGINIA LOCKHART, as representative of the estate of Albert Lockhart/13-7883, HARRY LOWE, 13-7883, LETICIA MCCLAIN, 13-7883, NANCY MCINTYRE, 13-7883, DANIELMULVEHILL, 13-7883, JOHN PEKALA, 13-7883, JUDITH PFEIFFER, 13-7883, WILLIAM PFEIFFER, 13-7883, JOHNRICE, 13-7883, DONALD RODGERS, 13-7883, SHIRLEY RODGERS, 13-7883, ANNA SAUERWINE, 13-7883,LARRY SEGLER, 13-7883, LISA SEGLER, 13-7883, WILLIAM THEEL, 13-7883, SARAH THOMAS, 13-7883, GARYTHOMPSON, individually and as representative of the estate of Margaret Thompson/ 13-7883, RUSSELLALEXANDER, 13-7882, SAM BENDER, 13-7882, BERTHA BENNETT, 13-7882, ROBERT BERNAL, 13-7882, CARLBULLOCK, 13-7882, DAVID BURLESON, 13-7882, TAMMY BURLESON, 13-7882, ROSALYN CAPPS, 13-7882,LEON CHAMBERS, 13-7882, JOSEPH COOPER, 13-7882, JOHN COUSINS, 13-7882, ROBERT COVINGTON,13-7882, NANCY CUMMINGS, 13-7882, ALBERT DENNISON, 13-7882, PATRICIA GNEWUCH, 13-7882, ROBERTGNEWUCH, 13-7882, FLOYD HATTON, 13-7882, LARRY HELLER, 13-7882, MARY MATHIS, 13-7882, JOSEPARIS, 13-7882, SHANE PHIPPS, 13-7882, TRACI PHIPPS, 13-7882, ANGIERENE JACKSON, 13-7882, HELENJORDAN, 13-7882, PAUL JORDAN, 13-7882, DARRYL KERSEY, 13-7882, DALE E. KOHOUT, 13-7882, FRANKKUREN, 13-7882, LORRIE LYNAM, 13-7882, DIANE MCCORMICK, 13-7882, PATRICK MCCORMICK, 13-7882,GERTESTINE MCFERSON, 13-7882, HYON O'CONNOR, 13-7882, KEVIN O'CONNOR, 13-7882, NORMARAGSDALE, 13-7882, LEIGH RICHARDSON, 13-7882, LAWRENCE RIGGO, 13-7882, JACKIE ROGERS, 13-7882,RANDALL SAMPLES, 13-7882, SUSAN SZIGETI, 13-7882, DAVID J. BAILEY, Representative of the Estate of PhyllisChandler, deceased/ 13-7882, SANDRA J. BENSING, Individually and as Representative of the Estate of WilliamBensing, deceased/ 13-7882, DONALD DEY, as Representative of the Estate of Jean Dey, deceased/ 13-7882,JAVIER GARCIA, 13-7882, MARIA GARZA, as Representative of the Estate of Tomasa Balley, deceased/ 13-7882,JOHN MASSEY, Individually and as Representative of the Estate of Joyce Massey, deceased/ 13-7882, JEFFREYMONGILLO, as Representative of the Estate of Donald Mongillo, deceased/ 13-7882, LYNDA JOYCE RUSSELL, asRepresentative of the Estate of Rodney Russell, deceased/ 13-7882, LITA SHAW, as Representative of the Estate ofHarley Hughes, deceased/ 13-7882, EDWARD TODD, 13-7882, ARIUS TROTTIER, 13-7882, RONALDWHITEHEAD, 13-7882, FRED BAIRD, 14-637, BARBARA BARNWELL, 14-637, WILLIE CALLAWAY, 14-637,DOROTHY CARTER, 14-637, FRANCES CLABOUGH, 14-637, GLORIA CORREA, 14-637, GREGORY COX,14-637, RICHARD A. DERABASSE, 14-637, KAREN DEVITO, 14-637, MICHAEL DEVITO, 14-637, DOREENFURMAN, 14-637, IRENE GARCIA, JAMES GERARD, 14-637, KAREN GERARD, 14-637, EDWIN HEWITT, 14-637,PATRICIA HEWITT, 14-637, JOHN JACOBS, 14-637, MARY KIRKPATRICK, 14-637, WILLIE LEVETT, 14-637,MICHAEL MILEHAM, 14-637, FAYE MUSE, 14-637, EMMA NEVAREZ, 14-637, FREDA PITTS, 14-637, ROBERTRAFFERTY, 14-637, RANDY RASOR, 14-637, CAROLYN ROACH, 14-637, KATHLEEN ROE, individually and asRepresentative of the Estate of Kieran Roe, deceased/ 14-637, LILLIAN ROE, 14-637, JEROME SACHS, 14-637,MARY SACHS, 14-637, MARIA SALINAS, 14-637, ELVIN STEVENSON, 14-637, DARLENE STRONG, 14-637,DONALD STRONG, 14-637, FAYE TEAGUE, as Representative of the Estate of Donald Teague, deceased/ 14-637,LAWRENCE WALKER, 14-637, YOLANDA WILKINS, as Representative of the Estate of Delores Wilkins, deceased/14-637, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): JOSHUA CALEB EZRIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOTADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR, AUDET & PARTNERS, SAN FRANCISCO, CA; WILLIAM M. AUDET, LEADATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR, AUDET & PARTNERS, LLP, SAN FRANCISCO,CA; JOSEPH SCHOCH, as Representative of the Estate of Terri Schoch, deceased/ 13-7749, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB), Pro se.

For MARK SIMPSON, 14-634, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): MARTIN P. SCHRAMA, LEAD ATTORNEY,STARK & STARK, PC, LAWRENCEVILLE, NJ.

For ELIZABETH ALMODOVAR, 14-748, GLADYS BOWDITCH, 14-748, RHONDA BROWN, 14-748, LOUISCANDLER, III, 14-748, SEBASTIAN CICERO, 14-748, JOHN COCHRAN, 14-748, LEOLA COTTON, 14-748,THADDEUS CZARNECKI, 14-748, VINCENT FAUCI, 14-748, RUTH FEINERMAN, 14-748, OLEVIA GIBBS, 14-748,ZELDA JUSTICE, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Kennis Justice/ 14-748,CAROLYN LEWIS, 14-748, GAETANO LOCOCO, 14-748, BARBARA ROSS, individually and as successor in intereston behalf of the Estate of Johnny Ross/ 14-748, DARRELL D SHEPHERD, 14-748, GLENN VAUSE, 14-748, SUSANWHEELER, 14-748, JO ANN BAKER, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of WorthingtonBaker/ 14-748, JERRY CARR, 14-748, LYNNOEL FRANCISCO, 14-748, MICHAEL A. GASPERI, 14-748, FRANCINE




HARRINGTON, 14-748, DANIEL JEFFRIES, 14-748, BEVERLY LEIGHTON, 14-748, STEVEN D. MARTINEZ,14-748, LONNIE D. MCGUIRE, 14-748, BERNADINE PASKE, power of attorney for JPHN Krupa/ 14-748, WILLIAMC. WASHBURN, 14-748, LEO WOITH, 14-748, DOMINIC AGOSTINO, 14-748, ROSIE E. AUSTIN, 14-748, DAISY R.BROWN, 14-748, ANNA E. BRYANT, 14-748, HOWARD L. BURT, 14-748, MYLES CARTER, 14-748, AUDREYESTRADA, Legal Guardian of Ruth Jones/ 14-478, JOHN D. GARDNER, 14-748, BERTHA JACKSON, 14-748, RAYE. JONES, 14-748, TERRANCE MCULLOCH, 14-748, MAXINE NELSON, 14-748, CARRIE RIZZOTTI, 14-748,CAROL S. RUSTAN, 14-748, MAXINE A. STOOKEY, 14-748, DONNA L. THOMPSON, 14-748, GEORGE ZANELLA,14-748, DIANE COX, individually and as successor in interest on behalf of the Estate of Marvin Balance/ 14-748,WILLIAM DIXON, 14-748, CLIFFORD S. GADYE, 14-748, SHIRLEY L. HAMPTON, 14-748, THOMAS H. HENLEY,14-748, JACK HOOVER, 14-748, DENNIS KNOTT, 14-748, LEE W. LILLY, 14-748, CATHE LYNCH, individually andas successor in intrest on behalf of the Estate of Charles T. Greer/ 14-748, JUDY TYREE, individually and assuccessor in interest on behalf of the Estate of JimmyTyree/ 14-748, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): JOSHUACALEB EZRIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR, AUDET & PARTNERS, SANFRANCISCO, CA; Mark Etheredge Burton, Jr., LEAD ATTORNEY, Audet and Partners, LLP, San Francisco, CA.

For PAUL LANE, 14-748, KATHERINE YOUNG, 14-748, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): JOSHUA CALEBEZRIN, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC - DNJ BAR, AUDET & PARTNERS, SANFRANCISCO, CA; Mark E. Burton, Jr., LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, Hersh & Hersh, San Francisco, CA.

For REBA SACCO, 14-748, Plaintiff (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): Mark Etheredge Burton, Jr., LEAD ATTORNEY,Audet and Partners, LLP, San Francisco, CA; WILLIAM M. AUDET, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTEDTO USDC - DNJ BAR, AUDET & PARTNERS, LLP, SAN FRANCISCO, CA.

For BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB COMPANY, SANOFI-AVENTIS U.S. LLC, SANOFI-SYNTHELABO INC., SANOFI USSERVICES INC., Defendants (3:13-cv-02418-FLW-TJB): DANIEL S. PARISER, LEAD ATTORNEY, MDL, ARNOLD &PORTER, LLP, WASHINGTON, DC; DAVID L. HARRIS, LEAD ATTORNEY, LOWENSTEIN SANDLER PC,ROSELAND, NJ; MONICA NICOLE KAMISON, REBECCA BETH VISVADER, LOWENSTEIN SANDLER, PC,ROSELAND, NJ.

For United States of America, ex rel., Plaintiff (3:13-cv-01039-FLW-TJB): CHRISTOPHER F. CUETO, LEADATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LAW OFFICE OF CHRISTOPHER CUETO LTD.,BELLEVILLE, IL; ROBERT LYLE SALIM, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR,SALIM-BEESLEY LLC, NATCHITOCHES, LA; BLAIR R. LOOCKE, PHILLIP L. SAMPSON, JR, RALPH D. MCBRIDE,COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP, HOUSTON, TX; Gerald M. Burke,Assistant U.S. Attorney - Fairview Heights, Fairview Heights, IL; HEATH A. NOVOSAD, TONY L. VISAGE,BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP, HOUSTON, TX.

For State of Illinois, ex rel., Elisa Dickson, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-01039-FLW-TJB): CHRISTOPHER F. CUETO, LEADATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LAW OFFICE OF CHRISTOPHER CUETO LTD.,BELLEVILLE, IL; ROBERT LYLE SALIM, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR,SALIM-BEESLEY LLC, NATCHITOCHES, LA; BLAIR R. LOOCKE, PHILLIP L. SAMPSON, JR, RALPH D. MCBRIDE,COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP, HOUSTON, TX; HEATH A.NOVOSAD, TONY L. VISAGE, BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP, HOUSTON, TX.

For COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS, ex rel, COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA, ex rel, State of California,ex rel, State of Delaware, ex rel, STATE OF CONNECTICUT, ex rel, STATE OF COLORADO, ex rel, State of Florida,ex rel, State of Georgia, ex rel, State of Indiana, ex rel, State of Hawaii, ex rel, STATE OF MICHIGAN, ex rel, STATEOF MONTANA, ex rel, State of New Mexico, ex rel, STATE OF NEW YORK, ex rel, State of Nevada, ex rel, State ofTennessee, ex rel, State of Texas, ex rel, STATE OF NEW JERSEY, ex rel, State of Rhode Island, ex rel, State ofOklahoma, ex rel, State of Wisconsin, ex rel, STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA, ex rel, STATE OF MINNESOTA, ex rel,CITY OF CHICAGO, ex rel, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, ex rel, Plaintiffs (3:13-cv-01039-FLW-TJB): ROBERT LYLESALIM, LEAD ATTORNEY, COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, SALIM-BEESLEY LLC,




NATCHITOCHES, LA; BLAIR R. LOOCKE, PHILLIP L. SAMPSON, JR, RALPH D. MCBRIDE, COUNSEL NOTADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP, HOUSTON, TX; CHRISTOPHER F. CUETO,COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, LAW OFFICE OF CHRISTOPHER CUETO LTD., BELLEVILLE, IL;HEATH A. NOVOSAD, TONY L. VISAGE, BRACEWELL & GIULIANI LLP, HOUSTON, TX.

For BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB COMPANY, SANOFI-AVENTIS U.S. L.L.C., Sanofi US Service Inc., also known asSANOFI-AVENTIS U.S. INC., SANOFI-SYNTHELABO INC., Defendants (3:13-cv-01039-FLW-TJB): Theodore J.MacDonald, Jr., LEAD ATTORNEY, HeplerBroom LLC, St. Louis, MO; DAVID D. FAUVRE, DREW A. HARKER,COUNSEL NOT ADMITTED TO USDC-NJ BAR, ARNOLD & PORTER, WASHINGTON, DC; MONICA NICOLEKAMISON, LOWENSTEIN SANDLER, PC, ROSELAND, NJ; W. Jason Rankin, HeplerBroom LLC - Edwardsville,Edwardsville, IL.

Freda L. Wolfson, U.S.D.J.

Freda L. Wolfson

ORDERTHESE MATTERS having been opened to the Court by Plaintiff-Relator Elisa Dickson ("Relator"), through her counselChristopher F. Cueto, Esq., on a motion for suggestion of remand to the United States District Court for the SouthernDistrict of Illinois, and by Defendants, through their counsel Monica N. Watson, Esq., on a motion for reconsiderationof portions of the transferor court's January 30, 2013 decision granting in part and denying in part Defendants' motionto dismiss the Second Amended Complaint ("SAC"); the parties, respectively, having filed opposition and reply briefsin both matters; it appearing that counsel for both parties appeared before the Court on August 21, 2013, at whichtime the Court heard oral argument in support of and opposition to each party's motion; the Court having consideredthe parties' papers and oral argument, for the reasons set forth on the record on April 21, 2013, and for good causeshown,

IT IS on this 21st day of August, 2013,

ORDERED that Relator's motion for suggestion of remand is DENIED; and it is further

ORDERED that Defendants' motion for reconsideration of parts of the transferor court's January 30, 2012 decision isGRANTED; and it is further

ORDERED that the prior decision to deny Defendants' motion to dismiss with respect to Relator's False Claims Actclaims under Medicaid and Medicare Part D is VACATED; and it is further

ORDERED that Defendants' motion to dismiss the False Claims Act claims in the Second Amended Complaint withrespect to Medicaid and Medicare Part D is GRANTED; and it is further

ORDERED that Relator is granted leave to file a Third Amended Complaint within 30 days of the date of this Order.

/s/ Freda L. Wolfson

Freda L. Wolfson, U.S.D.J.




General Information

Related Docket(s) 3:13-cv-02418 (D.N.J.); 3:13-cv-01039 (D.N.J.);

Court United States District Court for the District of New Jersey

Parties In re PLAVIX MARKETING, SALES PRACTICES ANDPRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION (No. II);; UNITED STATESet al., ex rel. ELISA DICKSON, Plaintiffs, v. BRISTOL-MEYERSSQUIBB CO., et al., Defendants.

Date Filed 2013-08-21 00:00:00




Documents

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW …mdl.law.uga.edu/sites/default/files/2013.09.21%20... · 9/21/2013 · ATTORNEY, LAW OFFICES OF EDWARD HARRINGTON HEYBURN,