54
UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRNILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Division Washington DC 20530-0001 July 5, 2012 MEMORANDUM Criminal Chiefs and Appellate Chiefs 1 FROM: Patty Merkamp Stemler /,s/ PMS Chief, Criminal Appellate Section SUBJECT: Guidance Regarding the Application of United States v. Jones, 132 S. Ct. 945 (2012), to Additional Investigative Techniques \ THE MATERIAL IN THIS DOCUMENT CONSISTS OF ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT· AND SHOULD NOT BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE. CRM-DOC7-1 (b)(5) (b)(7)(E)

U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRNILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

U.S. Department of Justice

Criminal Division

Washington DC 20530-0001

July 5, 2012 MEMORANDUM

Criminal Chiefs and Appellate Chiefs1

FROM: Patty Merkamp Stemler /,s/ PMS Chief, Criminal Appellate Section

SUBJECT: Guidance Regarding the Application of United States v. Jones, 132 S. Ct. 945 (2012), to Additional Investigative Techniques

\

THE MATERIAL IN THIS DOCUMENT CONSISTS OF ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT· AND SHOULD NOT BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE.

CRM-DOC7-1

(b)(5)

(b)(7)(E)

Page 2: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold in Full

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONF1DENTIAL (b )(5)

(b )(7)(E)

2

CRM-OOC7-2

Page 3: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED 1/ LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

3

CRM-OOC7-3

d in Full

(b)(5)

(b)(7)(E)

Page 4: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

4

CRM-OOC7-4

Page 5: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

5

CRM-DOC7-5

Page 6: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

6

CRM-OOC7-6

Withho in Full

(b)(5)

(b)(7)(E)

Page 7: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

7

CRM-OOC7-7

Withhold in Full

(b)(7)(E)

Page 8: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

hold

UNCLAsSIFIED /1 LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND ,.., ...... ~.TT.>TY~-r",..T'~T

8

CRM-OOC7-8

Page 9: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

9

CRM-OOC7-9

Page 10: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

(b)(7)(E)

10

CRM-OOC7-10

Page 11: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

11

CRM-OOC7 -11

With in Full

(b)(5)

(b)(7)(E)

Page 12: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

in Full

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL (b )(5)

(b)(7)(E)

12

CRM-OOC7-12

Page 13: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL in Full

(b)(7)(E)

13

CRM-OOC7 -13

Page 14: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

14

CRM-OOC7-14

Withhold in Full

Page 15: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

,-'

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVIL,EGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

15

CRM-DOC7-15

old in Fuil

(b)(5)

(b)(7)(E)

Page 16: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold in Full

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL (b)( 5)

(b)(7)(E)

CRM-DOC7-16

Page 17: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

17

CRM-OOC7-17

Withhold in Full

(b)(5)

(b)(7)(E)

Page 18: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold in Full

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

(b)(5)

(b)(7)(E)

18

CRM-OOC7 -18

Page 19: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

thhoid

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

19

CRM-DOC7-19

Page 20: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL in Full

(b)(7)(E)

20

CRM-OOC7 -20

Page 21: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold in Full

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

21

CRM-OOC7-21

(b)(5)

(b)(7)(E)

Page 22: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL Withhold in Full

(b )(7)(E)

22

CRM-OOC7 -22

Page 23: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

old

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

.23

CRM-OOC7 -23

Page 24: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

ithhold

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

24

CRM-OOC7 -24

Page 25: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE- PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

7)(E)

25

CRM-DOC7 -25

Page 26: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL in Full

(b)(7)(E)

26

C'RM-DOC7 -26

Page 27: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

hold

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVIL.EGED AND CONFIDENTIAL in Full

27

CRM-OOC7 -27

Page 28: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL in Full

28

CRM-OOC7 -28

(b)(5)

(b)(7)(E)

Page 29: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL in Full

29

CRM-OOC7 -29

Page 30: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL in Full

(b)(7)(E)

30

CRM-OOC7 -30

Page 31: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

old UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

31

CRM-OOC7-31

Page 32: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL in Full

(b)(5)

(b )(7)(E)

32

CRM-OOC7 -32

Page 33: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

33

CRM-OOC7 -33

Withhold in Full

(b)(5)

(b)(7)(E)

Page 34: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

old

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL in Full

34

CRM-OOC7 -34

Page 35: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold in Full

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

35

CRM-OOC7 -35

(b )(5)

(b)(7)(E)

Page 36: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

36

CRM-DOC7 -36

Page 37: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL in Full

)(7)(E)

37

CRM-DOC7-37

Page 38: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED liLA W ENFORCEMENT SgNSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL ~i~~~IO!d

(b)(7)(E)

38

CRM-DOC7 -38

Page 39: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRNILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

39

CRM-OOC7 -39

Page 40: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL in Full

40

CRM-OOC7 -40

(b)(5)

(b)(7)(E)

Page 41: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhold in Full

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

(b)(7)(E)

41

. CRM-OOC7 -41

Page 42: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Wit old UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL in Full

7)(E)

42

CRM-DOC7 -42

Page 43: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

hold UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

43

CRM-OOC7 -43

Page 44: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

44

CRM-OOC7 -44

Withhold in Full

(b )(5)

(b)(7)(E)

Page 45: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

-45

CRM-OOC7 -45

Page 46: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFillD II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

46

CRM-OOC7 -46

Page 47: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

47

CRM-DOC7 -47

Page 48: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

d UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL in Full

48

CRM-OOC7 -48

Page 49: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Withhol UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL in Full

CRM-OOC7 -49

(b)(5)

(b)(7)(E)

Page 50: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

old

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

50

CRM-OOC7 -50

Page 51: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED lILA W ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

51

CRM-OOC7-51

Page 52: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Ithhold

UNCLASSIFIED liLA W ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL \

52

CRM-OOC7 -52

Page 53: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

UNCLASSIFIED II LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

53

CRM-OOC7 -53

Page 54: U.S. Department of Justice Criminal Divisioncrm-doc7-37 . unclassified lila w enforcement sgnsitive - privileged and confidential ~i~~~io!d (b)(7)(e) 38 crm-doc7 -38 . unclassified

Ithhold in Full

UNCLASSIFIEDffLAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE-PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL (b)(5)

(b)(7)(E)

54

CRM-OOC7-S4