Upload
marian-e-boquiren
View
221
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
1/23
PORK SUBSECTOR:
KEY RECOMMENDATIONS FORPROJECT INTERVENTIONS AT THERETAIL LEVEL
TASK ORDER NO. 04
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
2/23
CAMBODIA MSME 2/BEEPROJECTPORK SUBSECTOR: KEY RECOMMENDATIONS FOR PROJECT
INTERVENTIONS AT THE RETIAL LEVEL
TASK ORDER NO. 04
Program Title: Strengthening Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises in Cambodia
Sponsor ing USAID Office: USAID/Cambodia
Contract Number: EEM-I-00-07-00009-00/04
Contractor: DAI
Date of Publication: July 2009
Author: Marian E. Boquiren
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
3/23
TABLEOFCONTENTS
CONTENTS PAGENO.
I. COMPETITIVENESS OF CAMBODIA PORK AT LOCAL MARKET 1
II. INTERVENTION DIRECTIONS/STRATEGIC FRAMEWORK 2
III.UPGRADING OF FOOD SAFETY AND QUALITY COMPLIANCE OF PORKRETAIL STALLS IN WET MARKETS
4
IV.MARKETING CAMPAIGN TO IMPROVE CONSUMER ATTITUDE ANDPERCEPTION TOWARDS PORK
12
V. INDICATIVE IMPLEMENTATION PLAN 14
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
4/23
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
5/23
I. COMPETITIVENESSOFCAMBODIAPORKATLOCALMARKET
1. Consumption of Cambodian pork has come under increasing pressure from imports of live pigsfrom Thailand and Vietnam. Four private firms import 800 pigs from Thailand daily for local
consumption (Phnom Penh Post, 21 May 2009). According to the Cambodia Pig Raisers
Association, many of the smaller operators have closed down while others opted to slow down
in their operations due to shrinking profits. In 2008, share of local pork to total market supply
was estimated at 60%. In 2009, market share decreased to 40%.
Local pig production is dominated by smallholders and has a cyclical trend of expanding and
contracting triggered by changes in market opportunities, coupled with movements in the costof animal feed and utilities. Because of smallholders lower level of investment, they find it easy
to move in and out of the business when market conditions, and/or the cost/profitability of
production, change in an adverse direction. This cyclical local pig production has contributed to
the gradual crowdingout of local pig raisers in the distribution system. Slaughterhouses
increasingly prefer imported pigs than locally raised pigs because of stable availability and lean
meat content. A predictable supply of slaughter pigs makes an optimum use of slaughter
capacity and supply to the market possible.
2. Majority of the traders and slaughterhouses display little or no loyalty to pork produced fromlocally raised pigs. Main purchase determinants are profitability (lowest price per kilogram
meat output; % yield of lean meat) and consistent availability at sufficient volumes. Local
breeds generally yield lower percentages of lean meat and are, therefore, less attractive to
traders/slaughterhouses especially those that are involved in distribution to urban markets (i.e,
Phnom Penh). At the traders/slaughterhouses level, Cambodian pork costs more than imported
pork due to difference in total meat output. To be able to sell to traders/slaughterhouses, local
pig raisers decreased price of local pig to 6,000 to 7,000 riels per kilo. Retail prices of
Cambodian and imported pork are generally the same.
3. Pork is the third preferred protein
source after fish and beef. Productsubstitution in rising price
environment is possible due to
higher consumer preference for
fish and beef.
The January 2009 survey
LivePigWeight MeatOutput
Cambodia Live Pig 100 kg 73
Imported Live Pig 100 kg 83Source: Interviews with Traders and Cambodia Pig Raisers Association
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
6/23
incidence of bargaining for certain items, or decreased spending on household items, among the
majority of consumers. Poor households were most negatively affected as they could not easily
compensate high food prices by shifting nonfood parts of their expenditures to food (as theyspent already 80% on food CSES 2004). They reduced quantity of food or shifted to lower
value food (e.g., imported low cost products). Consumers are increasingly seeking value for
money.
4. Urban and tourism markets increasingly favor lean pork/low fat content, but majority of thesmallscale producers raise breeds and use feed options that do not yield the leaner market
demanded by the market. Imported pork is generally leaner compared to local meat. The
village and provincial markets are less demanding in terms of fat content.
5. Restaurants generally prefer imported meat because it does not shrink as much as the localpork during cooking (low drip loss), low fat content, and reliable sourcing.
6. Consumers prefer the taste of Cambodian pork than Thai and Vietnam pork. It is also perceivedto be safer (no antibiotics, growth promotants, etc.) than imported product.
7. Decrease in pork sales due to the H1N1 outbreak was higher in the cities than in rural areas.
Supermarkets selling pork products (chilled/frozen meat) reported higher drop in sales thanvendors in wet markets. Consumers perceive pork from locally raised pig to be safer to eat than
imported pork since there is no reported H1N1 virus incidence in Cambodia.
8. Fresh pork is generally marketed in wet markets in a generic manner, without reference toeither its geographic or slaughterhouse origin. There is though a growing interest among
consumers on product origin. However, there is presently no clear value proposition or story
that conveys a clear compelling reason why the consumer would choose to select Cambodian
pork as a product of choice.
9. Cambodians traditionally consume fresh pork sold at traditional wet markets. Chilled pork hasbeen introduced in supermarkets but, to date, accounts for an insignificant percentage of the
market. Aside from leanness, an important factor that consumers consider when they buy pork
is Freshness. Freshness is also seen as a measure to avoid the risk that may be brought about by
the unsanitary food and risky effects from food.
The current distribution and retail systems of pork meat need improvement in terms of
compliance to food safety. The products are generally exposed to elements that accelerate
deterioration of quality. Remaining inventory of meat during the afternoon is automatically
classified as of lower product quality and sold at discounted prices. Products that are not sold
during the day are usually bought by processors or by small food service outlets at lower prices.
Noncompliance to food safety standards does not only pose health hazards to consumers but
also contribute to shrinkage of profit margins of retailers.
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
7/23
a) Upgrading Food Safety and Quality Compliance of Pork Retail Outlets/Stalls in Wet Markets
to Better Serve the Pork Industry and Consumersb) Promotion Campaigns to Improve Consumer Attitude and Perception towards Cambodian
Pork
The local pork industry has little or no image within the Cambodian marketplace. The H1N1virus outbreak is further hurting consumer confidence on the safety of eating pork. It is in the
interest of all industry players to work together and invest in a program to address consumer risk
perceptions and undertake market promotion based on concrete unique selling proposition/s.
Growth in consumption of local pork will rest primarily on educating the average Cambodianconsumer about the positive eating and safe attributes of local pork and to reflect these
characteristics at the point of sale.
ProductionUgrading
alignedtomarket
requirements/GoodH
usbandryPractices
IncreaseMarketShareof
LocalPork
BuildPurchasingLoyaltyforLocalPorkamongSlaughter
Houses
Strengthen Preference of Consumers for Local Pork by
visibly communicating at point of purchase its origin,
su erior ualit , and food safet inte rit
UpgradingofFoodSafetyand
QualityCompliance
of
Pork
RetailStallsinWetMarketsto
betterserveIndustryand
Consumers
PromotionalCampaignsto
ImproveConsumer
Attitude
andPerceptiontowards
CambodianPork
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
8/23
shift of slaughterhouses and consumers from imported to local pigs, raisers have to resolve major
meat production issues (leanness, low fat content, wellmarbled, low drip loss). Likewise, players
need to work together to ensure chain wide food safety and address the need for collaborativemechanisms to ensure better synchronizing of production and marketing activities between pig
raisers, traders, and slaughter houses.
III.UPGRADINGOFFOODSAFETYANDQUALITYCOMPLIANCEOFPORKRETAILSTALLSINWETMARKETS
A. Rationale
The wet market is the most important marketing channel for local pork. About 95% of the pork
consumed in Cambodia is purchased in wet markets. Majority of the pork retailers in the wet
market generally carry both imported and local meat except those that are directly related (e.g.,
wives) to smallscale traders/slaughterhouses participating in the MSME program who are
specialized in local pork. The pork retailers form an integral part of the local pork industry by
linking consumers and producers through business and social relationships. A key remedial
measure done by retailers to respond to growing preferences for Cambodia pork and lean meat is
to trim down the fats from the local pork. Through this simple measure, the retailers are able to
provide temporary solution to the current lack of capacity of raisers to produce pigs that can
provide the quality of meat demanded by consumers as well as maintain sales for local pork.
Before a purchase, quality expectations of consumers are formed based on extrinsic and quality
cues that are present in the shopping situation. Intrinsic quality cues comprise the physical
characteristics of a products such as cut, color, and visible fat content of the meat. Extrinsic quality
cues refer to everything else info on production system, distribution, outlet, price, etc. Quality
expectations will only influence purchase decision to the degree that they are salient in the
CambodianPorkinWetMarket
Fats sold
separately
at lower
price
For
Cambodian
pork to be at
par with
imported
meat,
retailers trim
down the fat.
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
9/23
- The need to present consumers with a set of differentiated product and merchandisingattributes to gain a competitive advantage especially with the increasing numbers of imported
products available in the market- The need for increased awareness creation on the importance of safety and quality of local pork
and improvement of retailers capability to assure consumers of safe food at all times
- The need to further strengthen governance in the pork retail supply chain includingestablishment of marketbased standards in an inclusive way and upheld by all players.
- The need to improve access of vendors to affordable services that would enable them to acquirethe resources and skills to improve quality and safety of fresh produce as well as strengthen
entrepreneurial skills which are all necessary for the sustainability of both their own operations
and the Cambodian local pork industry.
B.Objectives
This component is aimed at facilitating the commercial upgrading of pork retail outlets particularly
their capabilities to meet food safety and quality standards as a means of improving their incomesand sustainability of their livelihoods and that of the local pig raisers. Specific objectives of the
component are:
a. To facilitate the development of differentiation factors and Pork Retail Quality Systemencompassing basic quality and food safety standards that would establish a
special/distinct statement that the pork retailers can introduce and sustain as a marketing
proposal to improve perceived value and salability of local pork
b. To develop providers and services/products that would facilitate the upgrading of retailersparticularly the acquisition of capacities and capabilities to meet basic food safety and
quality standards parallel to development of systems to ensure sustained and equitable
access to these services
c. To support the strengthening of pork retail supply chain governance and the promotion ofpublicprivate alliances as bases for the upgrading initiatives with social responsibility and
sustainable business growth as framework for collaboration.
Proposed intervention strategies to achieve above objectives are discussed in the next sections.
The indicative implementation plan is presented in the Annex.
C. ProposedIntervention
and
Implementation
Strategies
1. SelectionofPilotstoInitiatetheChange/UpgradingProcess
Below are the three possible options for the pilots and each has its own implications to
implementation The Cambodia MSME Program may opt to have a pilot for each of the option to test
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
10/23
Options Description/TargetGroups PossibleImplications
consisting of local pork number of retailerclients in selected
markets), which will also reduce risks ofmarket distortion. It may also require
parallel facilitation of retailerslaughter
house linkages. Buyin to change initiative
may not be easy to get ownership of
process is spread out thinly among a range
of players/ slaughterhouses. But, it may
also motivate them to join so as not to be
left out by peers. Program may also want to explore possible
collaboration with Mong Reththy
development of retailers in preparation for
market launching of his companys
products in 2010.
Work with 1 to 2
major
slaughterhousesand their pool ofretailers
Target groups will consist of
retailers that regularly source
from the 2 partner slaughterhouses and willing to increase% of locally raised pigs in
outlets
Retailers may be spread out
in various markets in Phnom
Penh and neighbouring
provinces.
Stall specific changes spread out in various
markets. Potential to highlight local pork
dominant retail outlets islands ofexcellence May be easier to forge partnership with 1 to
2 slaughter houses but initial outreach in
terms of retailers may be small. There may
be an increased willingness by slaughter
house partners to invest in upgrading of
their retailers to establish their leadership
in the industry Higher risk of promoting market distortion
but can be mitigated by ensuring that
Program makes deliberate efforts to
promote the participation of other
slaughterhouses in the program
If successful, high potential to induce
participation of other slaughter houses
Can potentially lead to branding initiatives
by slaughter housesWork with
Cambodia
National Pig
Raisers
Associations and
Target groups will be retailer
members of the association.
Per discussion, target markets
are: Phnom Penh Market,
Kandal Town Market, and
Assurance that retailers are carrying 100%
local pork
Retailer outreach may be low as association
is still in the process of recruiting members
and starting their slaughter house
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
11/23
Options Description/TargetGroups PossibleImplications
and quality standards in their own
operations
Should program opt to focus on specific wet markets, the selection process should be similar to
subsector selection consisting of the following steps:
Participatory Definition of Selection Criteria: Criteria for selection may include the following: a)
scope for increasing volume of local pork traded in the market; b) significant number of pork
retailers committed to allocating specific percentage for local pork; c) Existence of partners to
collaborate with and readiness for change; d) Progressive area/With good % of lowmedium tomedium end consumers; e) Active Health Promotion Units/Village Health Promotion Units; and f)
With some basic market infrastructure, conducive framework conditions, and clear presence of
some incentives for players to invest in upgrading.
Profiling of Shortlisted Markets based on Selection Criteria: This will involve the collection of
information and analysis of shortlisted markets based on selection criteria. The preliminary
assessment will then lead to the next step of taking the decision to select market/s to implement
the pilots.
Prioritization and Selection of Pilot Markets: Ranking and prioritization of wet markets are best
conducted through workshops with the various stakeholders to ensure objectiveness and promote
ownership of results.
2. PromotionofInter-firmCooperation/ImprovementofSupplyChainGovernance
a) Facilitate formation of publicprivate sector alliance or multisectoral working group
PoolofProvidersand
Trainors
AccreditationandMonitoring
Committee
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
12/23
The pursuit of common upgrading objectives among the diverse stakeholders can be facilitated
through the formation of multisectoral teams or working groups consisting of the following (haveto be adapted to specific context and pilot setup):
PorkRetailQualitySystemWorkingGroup/TaskForce:Central body for planning, implementing and
monitoring the project. It is proposed that the Working Group should include the following: a)
governor/representative of governor; b) market administrator or manager; c) representatives ofpork retailers, slaughter houses, and pig raisers; d) consumer group representative; e)
Camcontrol/MAFF; f) Media; g) Academe; and h) Health Promotion Center
Accreditationand
Monitoring
Committee: Incharge of accreditation or of formally recognizing
retailers that have met agreed food safety, quality, merchandising display standards. The group is
also incharge of regularly monitoring continued compliance to standards by accredited vendors.
ProvidersPool:Providers of a range of services and resources to facilitate upgrading of vendors.
b) Promotion of Common Understanding of Standards and Norms and Accountability
This will involve the following: i) Development of Wet Market/Pork Retail Outlet Working Vision;
ii) Elaboration of Standards (as per Anukret 47 and food safety guidelines for meat retailers) and
Range of LowCost Implementation Measures; iii) Formulation of Implementation Plan; and iv)Dissemination of standards and implementation plan to all stakeholders
3. BusinessDevelopmentServicesforPorkRetailOutlets
Program Support
Identification of potential catalysts
Initiate the formation of the Pork Retail Quality System working group Organizational/Institutional Development Support
Capability Building Food Safety and Quality Standards in Pork Retailing
Who will do it: Pork Retail Quality System Working Group, core group of retailers with the
participation of government, industry players, and other stakeholder groups
Program Support:
Workshop facilitation/Guidance in the development of implementation plan
Technical assistance in the elaboration of standards and parameters Support to dissemination of standards and implementation
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
13/23
b) Development of services
Training may cover the following topics: i) food safety and quality; b) visual merchandising; iii)
enterprise/ financial management; and iv) semiprocessing of meat to prolong shelflife. Training
should be aligned to the lowcost implementation measures identified in collaboration with the
players themselves. The training sessions should start with easy low cost changes. It is also
recommended that all services follow the Learning/ Training Application/ Mentoring Income/Sales Feedback/Coaching cycle. The objective is to allow vendors to immediately apply
new skills and experience tangible benefits of training.
To facilitate identification of
lowcost solutions and, at the
same time, promote
experimental learning and
innovation among retailers,
competitions can be conducted
on food safety and qualitystandards compliance. The
viable lowcost solutions can
then be integrated in the
training modules. The
competitions would also
provide retailers the
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
14/23
c) Financial viability schemes
Based on interviews conducted, it is unlikely that retailers would be willing to pay upfront fees for
training. As such, services have to be provided as part of business transactions. The following are
the possible financial viability schemes:
i) Cost of training bundled in stall paymentii) Cost of training covered from markups sale of packaging materials, apron, hair net,
signage, pointofpurchase materials indicating origin and product attributes, etc.
iii) Embedded services value added services provided by slaughter houses to their retailers
iv) Bundled with payment for business license renewalv) Bundled with membership fees Cambodia Pig Raisers Association
d) Promotion of MicroFranchising/Branding
As per interview, the
Cambodian National Pig Raisers
Association is set to start soon
an upgrading program forretailers to support its
slaughter operations.
Upgrading package that will be
provided to retailers include
training on food safety and
hygiene. They also intend to
assist retailers upgrade their
stalls. Given these plans and
developments, the Cambodia
MSME program may also want
to explore with slaughter
houses or commercial scale pig
farms (i.e. Mong Reththy) or the
Cambodia National Pig Raisers
Association the possibilities of
a microfranchising scheme with retailers.
Who will do it- Delivery and Coordination of Services:
Pork Retail Quality System Working Group, pool of providers, slaughter houses
Program Support:
C bili b ildi f id
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
15/23
4. StimulationofDemandforServices
a) Advocacy Campaign on the Benefits of Upgrading and Food Safety and Quality Compliance
The campaign should be oriented to the objectives and needs of people who are directly involved
and whose actions and behavior will determine the success of the upgrading initiative. Activities
may include: i) orientation of industry players on the benefits of upgrading and food safety
compliance with a focus on income generation, customer relations, and health benefits for
themselves and their workers; and ii) Safe Pork campaign directed to consumers.
b) Regular conduct of consumer feedback survey
The consumer feedback survey can serve a twofold purpose: i) as basis for iterative planning; and
ii) provide motivation for pork retailers to pursue and sustain upgrading. This may be done via aDot Survey. It is simple but effective data collection method in which a limited number of questions
are posted on an easel or board and consumers indicate their responses using colorful labels/dots.
In our experiences in Costa Rica, these are wellliked by consumers and adds to the market
atmosphere. Results should be analyzed together with the retailers and other stakeholders.
Positive results may be disseminated to the media to encourage other industry players to enroll in
the upgrading initiative
c) Recognition and Accreditation
Recognition from the program, government or individuals respected by the actors can help
maintain momentum and spread interest among the resistant group. Interest from the media may
also help keep activities from stalling. Activities may include: i) Search for Model Retailers voted by
consumers and peers; ii) trimedia dissemination of success stories; iii) simple accreditation system
which can be conducted until end of program
Who will do it: MAFF, Camcontrol, Pork Retail Quality System Working Group, Media
Program Support:
Support to development and conduct of advocacy campaigns
Who will do it: Collaboration between Program and Pork Retail Quality System Working Groupand with the support from media
Program Support:
Support to development and conduct of consumer feedback survey including analysis
Dissemination of positive results to media
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
16/23
IV.MARKETING CAMPAIGN TO IMPROVE CONSUMERATTITUDEAND PERCEPTIONTOWARDSPORK
A. Objectives
To date, there is no serious and sustained local campaign to give Cambodian pork prominence in
consumer consciousness. Although it is claimed that Cambodians generally prefer local pork due to
its better taste and lower risks of contamination, these positive attributes do not translate to
increased market shares. In the absence of labels of origin, it may be possible that imported pigs are
passed off as local pork since a higher percentage of the meat supplied to retailers are from
imported pigs. Interviews indicate that it was not easy for ordinary consumers to distinguish
product attributes of local pork from the Thai and Vietnamese meat. Since branding cannot be
implemented at the shortterm, a remedial measure is to educate consumers on how to distinguish
local pork from imported meat through visual appearance (color, marbling, etc.). Likewise,
Cambodian pork has certain quality disadvantages over imported meat which requires production
changes that cannot be achieved in the shortterm. It is, therefore, important for the industry to
reinforce positive associations/imagery of Cambodian pork as a shortterm response. This is also
the most opportune time to conduct a marketing campaign given that consumers generally perceive
local pork to be safer than imported pork since there is no reported incidence of H1N1 virus
outbreak. Specific objectives of the marketing campaign are to:
a. Develop and promote a unique selling proposition and other attributes for Cambodianfresh pork and ensure that these are passed to consumers and those who influence
consumer decision makingb. Increase pork volume and menu placement in food service outletsc. Increase value along the different links in the chain
B.Description
Storyline Possible Theme:
We Love our Pork The Flavor of Cambodia
Cambodia Pork: You Can See and Taste the Difference!
Cambodian Pork The Taste is Worth It!
Key Messages: Reddish pink color of Cambodian pork more tender and flavorful.
Specially bred for flavor and taste naturally moist with no water
chemicals
Highly marbled for maximum natural juiciness and taste
Hogs are bred, born, and raised on family farms naturally raised
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
17/23
traders.
Communication Strategy Pointofpurchase materials (in retail stalls) showing the physical
characteristics of Cambodian pork and key messages
Select other media that would: i) Showcase pork's appetite appeal; ii)
Build a strong emotional connection between pork and Cambodian
family traditions (?) and local economy; iii) Deliver education and
information on local pork's safety and healthfulness and
distinguishing features visvis imported pork
Enlist support of culinary writers/gurus to attest on superior taste ofCambodian Pork
Enlist newspapers/radio/tv to feature recipes using local pork
Healthy Pork Recipe/Culinary competitions that would showcase
versatility of pork and allow sampling. Target Participants:
restaurants/food service outlets
Who will do it Cambodia Pig Raisers Association
Mong ReththySlaughter Houses at start of campaign, enlist those using at least
60% local pigs as they may be more receptive
Pork Retail Quality Working Groups
MAFF
Program Support TA in the development of promotional campaign
Capacity building on how to manage and run promotional campaign
key stakeholder groups that will eventually continue the campaign
Support to pilot run of campaign
Facilitation of linkages with potential sponsors
Monitoring of results of promotional campaign
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
18/23
14
IV. ANNEX
PORKSUBSECTOR:
RETAIL 2009 2010 2011 2012
ACTIVITIES 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
PilotSection
MappingofSlaughter
housesandtheir
retailersincluding
marketlocations
Discuss
with
potential
partnersviabilityof
differentoptions
Briefoverviewsof
potentialwetmarkets
constraintsand
opportunities
Workshopwith
stakeholderson
marketselection
criteria
Profilingofshortlisted
markets
Workshopwitn
stakeholdersforfinal
selectionofpilot
markets
PublicPrivateAlliances/SupplyChainGovernance(forpilots)
Identificationof
catalysts
Initiateformationof
workinggroups
Orientationonfood
safetyandquality
standardsandpork
retailmarketing
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
19/23
15
PORKSUBSECTOR:
RETAIL 2009 2010 2011 2012
ACTIVITIES
7
8
9
10
11
12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Facilitatedevof
working
vision/implementation
plan
TAoninitial
elaborationof
standardsandlow
costimplementation
measures
Disseminationof
implementationplan
andstandardtokey
stakeholders
Organizational
Dev/Institutional
Dev/Interfirm
Cooperation
Strengthening
BusinessDevServicesforPorkRetailSector(forpilots)
Identificationof
potentialproviders
ParticipatoryDevof
TrainingModules
CapabilityBuildingof
Trainors
TAduring
pilot
run
of
trainingmodules
TA devofinitial
financialviability and
delivery
schemes/business
plansforservices
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
20/23
16
PORKSUBSECTOR:
RETAIL 2009 2010 2011 2012
ACTIVITIES
7
8
9
10
11
12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Developmentofother
servicesincluding
financialviability
schemes/Business
Plansforservices
Facilitateconductof
competitionsto
identifyemerging
goodpractices/
low
costsolutions
Facilitateparticipatory
updating/ofservices
andmodules
MonitoringandTA
operationalizationof
services
MicroFranchising/Branding
(if
there
is
an
interest
from
commercial
farms/slaughter
houses/associations)
Promoteconceptto
potentialenterprises/
toPigRaisers
Associaiton
TA Developmentof
businessmodels
includingbusiness
plans
TAPilot
run
of
businessmodels
paralleltofurther
development
TA Promotionof
microfranchising
amongporkretail
outlets(existingand
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
21/23
17
PORKSUBSECTOR:
RETAIL 2009 2010 2011 2012
ACTIVITIES
7
8
9
10
11
12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
potential)
Promotionand
downloadingtoother
slaughter
houses/interested
parties
TAto
new
micro
franchisors
Promoteconceptto
MFIsespforsmall
scaleslaughterhouses
Monitoringand
evaluation/iterative
planning
Stimulationof
Demand
for
Services
(pilots)
SupportAdvocacy
CampaignonBenefits
ofFoodSafetyand
Quality
Compliance/Upgrading
TA Devofsimple
consumerfeedback
surveymechanism
Supportconduct
of
consumerfeedback
survey
Supportto
participatoryanalysis
ofconsumersurvey
results
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
22/23
18
PORKSUBSECTOR:
RETAIL 2009 2010 2011 2012
ACTIVITIES
7
8
9
10
11
12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Supportto
disseminationof
consumersurvey
results
TA devof
competition
mechanisms(Model
PorkRetailOutlet,
etc.)
Supporttoconductof
porkretailoutlet
competitions
TA developmentof
accreditationsystem
Supportto
operationalizationof
accreditationsystem
Scalingup/ReplicationofPorkRetailOutletUpgrading
Industrywide
promotionofconcept
andresults
Downloading/support
toimplementationto
newentrants(same
activitiesaspilotsbut
lesson
dev
of
systems)
PorkMarketingCampaign
Identificationof
potential
partners/coregroups
toworkwith
TA developmentof
promotionalcampaign
8/10/2019 Value Chain Analysis of the Pork Retail Chain
23/23