Village ElectionsVillage Elections

Grassroots democracy

Political Reforms in 1980sPolitical Reforms in 1980s

• ``Socialist democracy and legal system”

• Correcting the arbitrariness of the Cultural Revolution

• Mobilizing initiatives for economic reform and growth

PRC Constitution of 1982PRC Constitution of 1982

• Article 111. The residents' committees and villagers' committees established among urban and rural residents on the basis of their place of residence are mass organizations of self-governance at the grass-roots level. The chairman, vice-chairmen and members of each residents' or villagers' committee are elected by the residents.

National People’s CongressNational People’s Congress

• The ``Organic Law of Villager’s Committees (for trial implementation)” was passed in 1987 after over a year of debate

• A final revised version of the Organic Law was passed in 1998

                  

  

Party Elders’ SupportParty Elders’ Support

• Peng Zhen, Chair of the 6th NPC Standing Committee (1983 – 1987) pushed the Organic Law through NPC

His Argument 1: CCP TraditionHis Argument 1: CCP Tradition

• In 1930s the ``new democratic government” included non-Communist personages

• ``Mass line” emphasized public participation

• Served the purpose of fighting the Japanese army

His Argument 2:His Argument 2:

• ``Socialist democracy”

• For the leadership, strengthening people’s congresses

• For the masses, villagers’ self-governance and autonomy

• Help to boost democratic consciousness

His Argument 3:His Argument 3:

• Improve cadre-mass relations– ``Some rural leaders had become `local

emperors’”– ``villagers would sooner or later attack our rural

cadres with their shoulder poles”– ``Who supervises rural cadres? Can we

supervise them? No, not even if we had 48 hours a day”

Risk of Rural UnrestRisk of Rural Unrest

• ``People’s communes” were replaced with township governments in early 1980s

• Local cadres lost distributive power– Villagers became more knowledgeable and less

dependent on cadres– Dysfunction and disintegration of local Party

organizations– Incompetence and corruption of cadres

Implementing Village ElectionsImplementing Village Elections

National People’s Congressdebate

Ministry of Civic Affairsimplement

Opposition by local cadres

Popular demands for village elections

Party elders advocate

Opposition to Village ElectionsOpposition to Village Elections

• Provincial misgivings– slow in passing enforcement guidelines

• Lower levels worry about effects on– policy implementation– potential instability

• Opposition has been the most intense from township cadres

Township’s OppositionTownship’s Opposition

• ``Presently villagers don’t know how to govern themselves”

• ``I already have difficulty leading village cadres. I guarantee that guiding them will not work”

• ``Elections at higher levels are all scams, why should village elections be taken any more seriously?”

Popular DemandsPopular Demands

• Some refused to cooperate with township-appointed cadres

• Some confront township leaders on election issues

• Some sought support from higher-level officials

Actual ImplementationActual Implementation

• Enormous local variation in implementation

• Some villages have conducted free and fair elections

• Voting irregularities are often reported

• Some township officials fix or sabotage village elections

• Some party branches controlled nomination

Impact of Village ElectionsImpact of Village Elections

• Elections make cadres more accountable to villagers

• Closer cadre-villager relationship smoothes policy implementation

• Often elected cadres deliver on their pledges and produce material benefits for a community

Party Branch at Village LevelParty Branch at Village Level

• Relationship between villager committee and Party branch– ``Contradictions” between director of village

committee and Party branch secretary– The 1998 version of the Organic Law asserts

the role of the Communist Party in ``guaranteeing that villagers ... directly exercise their democratic rights”

Township and VillageTownship and Village

• Relationship between village committee and township governments– Implementation of unpopular policies, such as

birth control, taxation, and fees

• Village leaders are responsive to both old and newly emerging constituencies– selectorates above (township government)– electorates below (villagers)

New DevelopmentsNew Developments

• ``Two-ballot system” in election of Party branch members

• Experiments with direct election of township officials

• Direct elections of residents’ committees since 1999 in urban areas

• http://www.cartercenter.org