15
Some of our work Baratunde Cola Heat Lab (heat.gatech.edu) NanoEngineered Systems and Transport (NEST) Lab George W. Woodruff School of Mechanical Engineering School of Materials Science and Engineering Institute for Electronics and Nanotechnology Georgia Institute of Technology Sponsors: DARPA, NSF, Georgia Research Alliance, Samsung Students: P. Pour Shahid Saeed Abadi, T.L. Bougher, J. Taphouse, V. Singh, M.K. Smith 10 May 2017 National Science Board Meeting

Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

  • Upload
    ngocong

  • View
    216

  • Download
    3

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

Some of our work

Baratunde Cola Heat Lab (heatgatechedu)

NanoEngineered Systems and Transport (NEST) Lab George W Woodruff School of Mechanical Engineering

School of Materials Science and Engineering Institute for Electronics and Nanotechnology

Georgia Institute of Technology

Sponsors DARPA NSF Georgia Research Alliance Samsung Students P Pour Shahid Saeed Abadi TL Bougher J Taphouse V Singh MK Smith

10 May 2017 National Science Board Meeting

For private discussions only Company proprietary and confidential

Carbon nanotubes (CNT)

Technology - Highlights bull High thermal conductivity bull Billions of aligned nanoscale thermal paths bull Demonstrated gt30 improvement over

alternative solutions

Aluminum foil (layer)

Carbon nanotubes (CNT)

20 μm

Real interface lsquoIdealrsquo interface

Solid 1

Solid 2

Gas gap

Solid 2

k rarr infin

Solid 1

Filler material

Characteristics desired for thermal interface materials

bull High thermal conductivity bull High conformability bull Chemically and mechanically robust in diverse

environments

bull Major challenge soft materials with high thermal conductivity are rare in nature

Slide 3 Bara Cola 582017

10 microm

Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided

bull Resolution enabled by photoacoustic thermal measurement BA Cola et al J Appl Phys 101 054313 (2007)

coppercopper

siliconsilicon

Ag10 microm

Si

Slide 4 Bara Cola 582017

BA Cola et al ASME S

ng Desi

Gold coated CNTs Wax coated CNTs

5 microm

ummer Heat Transfer Conference 2008 R Cross et al Nanotechnology (2010)

Sprayed on Polymer Bondi gner Surface Modifiers

EtO P OEt Si Br rt

EtO i) 130 degC

ii) MeOH H2O (201)

rt

I EtO P O HO P O OEt OH

JH Taphouse et al Advanced Functional Materials 2014

Collaboration with organic chemist Dr Seth Marder (GT)

Growth substrate Bonding substrate

JH Taphouse et al Nanotechnology 24105401 2013

~100 resistance reductions with each approach but reliability and scalability

continues to improve

Slide 5 Bara Cola 582017

CORPORATION

Funding to date gt$2 million grants $14 million in angel and VC funds

PRO TO Y PE SCALE RE S E A RC H

First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer

V Singh et al Nat Nanotecnol (5) 2014

DVR BOX

CELL PHONE TCPoly Plastic

Standard Plastic

Max 48degCMax 74degC LED BULB

PLASTICS FOR COOLER

ELECTRONICS

Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo

Microwave rectenna Solar rectenna (born 1963 Raytheon and Purdue) (proposed 1972)

Demonstrated efficiencies gt 80 Predicted efficiencies gt 80

Slide 9 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Physics (Classical) Cutoff frequency Diode resistance

Diode Junction

e shyV t

V t Diode responsivity

Antenna EM field

Rectenna voltage and power output

Slide 10 Bara Cola 582017

MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail

10 nm 100 nm

Al2O3 coated CNTs

Top metal

1 microm

bull 8 nm conformal alumina coating bull CNT tip field enhancement bull ~ 10 nm junction diameter (C~1 aF) bull CaAl low work function top contact

(semi-transparent ~10 transmission)

~ 6 CNT walls

Slide 11 Bara Cola 582017

How the Tunneling Diode Works e-

MWCNT tunneling diode

~ 5 ev MWCNT work function

φCNTrsquo φMrsquo

EF EF

After contact

FE

e-φCNTrsquo

EF φMrsquo

EF

Forward bias

φMrsquo

φCNTrsquo

e -EF

EF

Reverse bias

Slide 12 Bara Cola 582017

29 ev WF

43 ev WF

Device Capacitance Length and time scale for

rectification cutoff frequency is different from length and time

scale of device operation

Fermi velocity lt 106 ms so

R( tasymp10-15 s) = infin

R(t) R(t)

Slide 13 Bara Cola 582017

Impedance Matching

Poor impedance matching in a single junction is compensated by larger number of junctions

which allows power production

Collective antenna effects reduce coupling

resistance to single CNT antenna

R(t) R(t)

Collective CNT antenna array ndash approximately in phase

Phys Rev B 87 161401(R) 2013

Slide 14 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse
Page 2: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

For private discussions only Company proprietary and confidential

Carbon nanotubes (CNT)

Technology - Highlights bull High thermal conductivity bull Billions of aligned nanoscale thermal paths bull Demonstrated gt30 improvement over

alternative solutions

Aluminum foil (layer)

Carbon nanotubes (CNT)

20 μm

Real interface lsquoIdealrsquo interface

Solid 1

Solid 2

Gas gap

Solid 2

k rarr infin

Solid 1

Filler material

Characteristics desired for thermal interface materials

bull High thermal conductivity bull High conformability bull Chemically and mechanically robust in diverse

environments

bull Major challenge soft materials with high thermal conductivity are rare in nature

Slide 3 Bara Cola 582017

10 microm

Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided

bull Resolution enabled by photoacoustic thermal measurement BA Cola et al J Appl Phys 101 054313 (2007)

coppercopper

siliconsilicon

Ag10 microm

Si

Slide 4 Bara Cola 582017

BA Cola et al ASME S

ng Desi

Gold coated CNTs Wax coated CNTs

5 microm

ummer Heat Transfer Conference 2008 R Cross et al Nanotechnology (2010)

Sprayed on Polymer Bondi gner Surface Modifiers

EtO P OEt Si Br rt

EtO i) 130 degC

ii) MeOH H2O (201)

rt

I EtO P O HO P O OEt OH

JH Taphouse et al Advanced Functional Materials 2014

Collaboration with organic chemist Dr Seth Marder (GT)

Growth substrate Bonding substrate

JH Taphouse et al Nanotechnology 24105401 2013

~100 resistance reductions with each approach but reliability and scalability

continues to improve

Slide 5 Bara Cola 582017

CORPORATION

Funding to date gt$2 million grants $14 million in angel and VC funds

PRO TO Y PE SCALE RE S E A RC H

First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer

V Singh et al Nat Nanotecnol (5) 2014

DVR BOX

CELL PHONE TCPoly Plastic

Standard Plastic

Max 48degCMax 74degC LED BULB

PLASTICS FOR COOLER

ELECTRONICS

Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo

Microwave rectenna Solar rectenna (born 1963 Raytheon and Purdue) (proposed 1972)

Demonstrated efficiencies gt 80 Predicted efficiencies gt 80

Slide 9 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Physics (Classical) Cutoff frequency Diode resistance

Diode Junction

e shyV t

V t Diode responsivity

Antenna EM field

Rectenna voltage and power output

Slide 10 Bara Cola 582017

MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail

10 nm 100 nm

Al2O3 coated CNTs

Top metal

1 microm

bull 8 nm conformal alumina coating bull CNT tip field enhancement bull ~ 10 nm junction diameter (C~1 aF) bull CaAl low work function top contact

(semi-transparent ~10 transmission)

~ 6 CNT walls

Slide 11 Bara Cola 582017

How the Tunneling Diode Works e-

MWCNT tunneling diode

~ 5 ev MWCNT work function

φCNTrsquo φMrsquo

EF EF

After contact

FE

e-φCNTrsquo

EF φMrsquo

EF

Forward bias

φMrsquo

φCNTrsquo

e -EF

EF

Reverse bias

Slide 12 Bara Cola 582017

29 ev WF

43 ev WF

Device Capacitance Length and time scale for

rectification cutoff frequency is different from length and time

scale of device operation

Fermi velocity lt 106 ms so

R( tasymp10-15 s) = infin

R(t) R(t)

Slide 13 Bara Cola 582017

Impedance Matching

Poor impedance matching in a single junction is compensated by larger number of junctions

which allows power production

Collective antenna effects reduce coupling

resistance to single CNT antenna

R(t) R(t)

Collective CNT antenna array ndash approximately in phase

Phys Rev B 87 161401(R) 2013

Slide 14 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse
Page 3: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

Real interface lsquoIdealrsquo interface

Solid 1

Solid 2

Gas gap

Solid 2

k rarr infin

Solid 1

Filler material

Characteristics desired for thermal interface materials

bull High thermal conductivity bull High conformability bull Chemically and mechanically robust in diverse

environments

bull Major challenge soft materials with high thermal conductivity are rare in nature

Slide 3 Bara Cola 582017

10 microm

Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided

bull Resolution enabled by photoacoustic thermal measurement BA Cola et al J Appl Phys 101 054313 (2007)

coppercopper

siliconsilicon

Ag10 microm

Si

Slide 4 Bara Cola 582017

BA Cola et al ASME S

ng Desi

Gold coated CNTs Wax coated CNTs

5 microm

ummer Heat Transfer Conference 2008 R Cross et al Nanotechnology (2010)

Sprayed on Polymer Bondi gner Surface Modifiers

EtO P OEt Si Br rt

EtO i) 130 degC

ii) MeOH H2O (201)

rt

I EtO P O HO P O OEt OH

JH Taphouse et al Advanced Functional Materials 2014

Collaboration with organic chemist Dr Seth Marder (GT)

Growth substrate Bonding substrate

JH Taphouse et al Nanotechnology 24105401 2013

~100 resistance reductions with each approach but reliability and scalability

continues to improve

Slide 5 Bara Cola 582017

CORPORATION

Funding to date gt$2 million grants $14 million in angel and VC funds

PRO TO Y PE SCALE RE S E A RC H

First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer

V Singh et al Nat Nanotecnol (5) 2014

DVR BOX

CELL PHONE TCPoly Plastic

Standard Plastic

Max 48degCMax 74degC LED BULB

PLASTICS FOR COOLER

ELECTRONICS

Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo

Microwave rectenna Solar rectenna (born 1963 Raytheon and Purdue) (proposed 1972)

Demonstrated efficiencies gt 80 Predicted efficiencies gt 80

Slide 9 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Physics (Classical) Cutoff frequency Diode resistance

Diode Junction

e shyV t

V t Diode responsivity

Antenna EM field

Rectenna voltage and power output

Slide 10 Bara Cola 582017

MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail

10 nm 100 nm

Al2O3 coated CNTs

Top metal

1 microm

bull 8 nm conformal alumina coating bull CNT tip field enhancement bull ~ 10 nm junction diameter (C~1 aF) bull CaAl low work function top contact

(semi-transparent ~10 transmission)

~ 6 CNT walls

Slide 11 Bara Cola 582017

How the Tunneling Diode Works e-

MWCNT tunneling diode

~ 5 ev MWCNT work function

φCNTrsquo φMrsquo

EF EF

After contact

FE

e-φCNTrsquo

EF φMrsquo

EF

Forward bias

φMrsquo

φCNTrsquo

e -EF

EF

Reverse bias

Slide 12 Bara Cola 582017

29 ev WF

43 ev WF

Device Capacitance Length and time scale for

rectification cutoff frequency is different from length and time

scale of device operation

Fermi velocity lt 106 ms so

R( tasymp10-15 s) = infin

R(t) R(t)

Slide 13 Bara Cola 582017

Impedance Matching

Poor impedance matching in a single junction is compensated by larger number of junctions

which allows power production

Collective antenna effects reduce coupling

resistance to single CNT antenna

R(t) R(t)

Collective CNT antenna array ndash approximately in phase

Phys Rev B 87 161401(R) 2013

Slide 14 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse
Page 4: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

10 microm

Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided

bull Resolution enabled by photoacoustic thermal measurement BA Cola et al J Appl Phys 101 054313 (2007)

coppercopper

siliconsilicon

Ag10 microm

Si

Slide 4 Bara Cola 582017

BA Cola et al ASME S

ng Desi

Gold coated CNTs Wax coated CNTs

5 microm

ummer Heat Transfer Conference 2008 R Cross et al Nanotechnology (2010)

Sprayed on Polymer Bondi gner Surface Modifiers

EtO P OEt Si Br rt

EtO i) 130 degC

ii) MeOH H2O (201)

rt

I EtO P O HO P O OEt OH

JH Taphouse et al Advanced Functional Materials 2014

Collaboration with organic chemist Dr Seth Marder (GT)

Growth substrate Bonding substrate

JH Taphouse et al Nanotechnology 24105401 2013

~100 resistance reductions with each approach but reliability and scalability

continues to improve

Slide 5 Bara Cola 582017

CORPORATION

Funding to date gt$2 million grants $14 million in angel and VC funds

PRO TO Y PE SCALE RE S E A RC H

First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer

V Singh et al Nat Nanotecnol (5) 2014

DVR BOX

CELL PHONE TCPoly Plastic

Standard Plastic

Max 48degCMax 74degC LED BULB

PLASTICS FOR COOLER

ELECTRONICS

Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo

Microwave rectenna Solar rectenna (born 1963 Raytheon and Purdue) (proposed 1972)

Demonstrated efficiencies gt 80 Predicted efficiencies gt 80

Slide 9 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Physics (Classical) Cutoff frequency Diode resistance

Diode Junction

e shyV t

V t Diode responsivity

Antenna EM field

Rectenna voltage and power output

Slide 10 Bara Cola 582017

MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail

10 nm 100 nm

Al2O3 coated CNTs

Top metal

1 microm

bull 8 nm conformal alumina coating bull CNT tip field enhancement bull ~ 10 nm junction diameter (C~1 aF) bull CaAl low work function top contact

(semi-transparent ~10 transmission)

~ 6 CNT walls

Slide 11 Bara Cola 582017

How the Tunneling Diode Works e-

MWCNT tunneling diode

~ 5 ev MWCNT work function

φCNTrsquo φMrsquo

EF EF

After contact

FE

e-φCNTrsquo

EF φMrsquo

EF

Forward bias

φMrsquo

φCNTrsquo

e -EF

EF

Reverse bias

Slide 12 Bara Cola 582017

29 ev WF

43 ev WF

Device Capacitance Length and time scale for

rectification cutoff frequency is different from length and time

scale of device operation

Fermi velocity lt 106 ms so

R( tasymp10-15 s) = infin

R(t) R(t)

Slide 13 Bara Cola 582017

Impedance Matching

Poor impedance matching in a single junction is compensated by larger number of junctions

which allows power production

Collective antenna effects reduce coupling

resistance to single CNT antenna

R(t) R(t)

Collective CNT antenna array ndash approximately in phase

Phys Rev B 87 161401(R) 2013

Slide 14 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse
Page 5: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

BA Cola et al ASME S

ng Desi

Gold coated CNTs Wax coated CNTs

5 microm

ummer Heat Transfer Conference 2008 R Cross et al Nanotechnology (2010)

Sprayed on Polymer Bondi gner Surface Modifiers

EtO P OEt Si Br rt

EtO i) 130 degC

ii) MeOH H2O (201)

rt

I EtO P O HO P O OEt OH

JH Taphouse et al Advanced Functional Materials 2014

Collaboration with organic chemist Dr Seth Marder (GT)

Growth substrate Bonding substrate

JH Taphouse et al Nanotechnology 24105401 2013

~100 resistance reductions with each approach but reliability and scalability

continues to improve

Slide 5 Bara Cola 582017

CORPORATION

Funding to date gt$2 million grants $14 million in angel and VC funds

PRO TO Y PE SCALE RE S E A RC H

First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer

V Singh et al Nat Nanotecnol (5) 2014

DVR BOX

CELL PHONE TCPoly Plastic

Standard Plastic

Max 48degCMax 74degC LED BULB

PLASTICS FOR COOLER

ELECTRONICS

Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo

Microwave rectenna Solar rectenna (born 1963 Raytheon and Purdue) (proposed 1972)

Demonstrated efficiencies gt 80 Predicted efficiencies gt 80

Slide 9 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Physics (Classical) Cutoff frequency Diode resistance

Diode Junction

e shyV t

V t Diode responsivity

Antenna EM field

Rectenna voltage and power output

Slide 10 Bara Cola 582017

MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail

10 nm 100 nm

Al2O3 coated CNTs

Top metal

1 microm

bull 8 nm conformal alumina coating bull CNT tip field enhancement bull ~ 10 nm junction diameter (C~1 aF) bull CaAl low work function top contact

(semi-transparent ~10 transmission)

~ 6 CNT walls

Slide 11 Bara Cola 582017

How the Tunneling Diode Works e-

MWCNT tunneling diode

~ 5 ev MWCNT work function

φCNTrsquo φMrsquo

EF EF

After contact

FE

e-φCNTrsquo

EF φMrsquo

EF

Forward bias

φMrsquo

φCNTrsquo

e -EF

EF

Reverse bias

Slide 12 Bara Cola 582017

29 ev WF

43 ev WF

Device Capacitance Length and time scale for

rectification cutoff frequency is different from length and time

scale of device operation

Fermi velocity lt 106 ms so

R( tasymp10-15 s) = infin

R(t) R(t)

Slide 13 Bara Cola 582017

Impedance Matching

Poor impedance matching in a single junction is compensated by larger number of junctions

which allows power production

Collective antenna effects reduce coupling

resistance to single CNT antenna

R(t) R(t)

Collective CNT antenna array ndash approximately in phase

Phys Rev B 87 161401(R) 2013

Slide 14 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse
Page 6: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

CORPORATION

Funding to date gt$2 million grants $14 million in angel and VC funds

PRO TO Y PE SCALE RE S E A RC H

First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer

V Singh et al Nat Nanotecnol (5) 2014

DVR BOX

CELL PHONE TCPoly Plastic

Standard Plastic

Max 48degCMax 74degC LED BULB

PLASTICS FOR COOLER

ELECTRONICS

Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo

Microwave rectenna Solar rectenna (born 1963 Raytheon and Purdue) (proposed 1972)

Demonstrated efficiencies gt 80 Predicted efficiencies gt 80

Slide 9 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Physics (Classical) Cutoff frequency Diode resistance

Diode Junction

e shyV t

V t Diode responsivity

Antenna EM field

Rectenna voltage and power output

Slide 10 Bara Cola 582017

MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail

10 nm 100 nm

Al2O3 coated CNTs

Top metal

1 microm

bull 8 nm conformal alumina coating bull CNT tip field enhancement bull ~ 10 nm junction diameter (C~1 aF) bull CaAl low work function top contact

(semi-transparent ~10 transmission)

~ 6 CNT walls

Slide 11 Bara Cola 582017

How the Tunneling Diode Works e-

MWCNT tunneling diode

~ 5 ev MWCNT work function

φCNTrsquo φMrsquo

EF EF

After contact

FE

e-φCNTrsquo

EF φMrsquo

EF

Forward bias

φMrsquo

φCNTrsquo

e -EF

EF

Reverse bias

Slide 12 Bara Cola 582017

29 ev WF

43 ev WF

Device Capacitance Length and time scale for

rectification cutoff frequency is different from length and time

scale of device operation

Fermi velocity lt 106 ms so

R( tasymp10-15 s) = infin

R(t) R(t)

Slide 13 Bara Cola 582017

Impedance Matching

Poor impedance matching in a single junction is compensated by larger number of junctions

which allows power production

Collective antenna effects reduce coupling

resistance to single CNT antenna

R(t) R(t)

Collective CNT antenna array ndash approximately in phase

Phys Rev B 87 161401(R) 2013

Slide 14 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse
Page 7: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

PRO TO Y PE SCALE RE S E A RC H

First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer

V Singh et al Nat Nanotecnol (5) 2014

DVR BOX

CELL PHONE TCPoly Plastic

Standard Plastic

Max 48degCMax 74degC LED BULB

PLASTICS FOR COOLER

ELECTRONICS

Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo

Microwave rectenna Solar rectenna (born 1963 Raytheon and Purdue) (proposed 1972)

Demonstrated efficiencies gt 80 Predicted efficiencies gt 80

Slide 9 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Physics (Classical) Cutoff frequency Diode resistance

Diode Junction

e shyV t

V t Diode responsivity

Antenna EM field

Rectenna voltage and power output

Slide 10 Bara Cola 582017

MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail

10 nm 100 nm

Al2O3 coated CNTs

Top metal

1 microm

bull 8 nm conformal alumina coating bull CNT tip field enhancement bull ~ 10 nm junction diameter (C~1 aF) bull CaAl low work function top contact

(semi-transparent ~10 transmission)

~ 6 CNT walls

Slide 11 Bara Cola 582017

How the Tunneling Diode Works e-

MWCNT tunneling diode

~ 5 ev MWCNT work function

φCNTrsquo φMrsquo

EF EF

After contact

FE

e-φCNTrsquo

EF φMrsquo

EF

Forward bias

φMrsquo

φCNTrsquo

e -EF

EF

Reverse bias

Slide 12 Bara Cola 582017

29 ev WF

43 ev WF

Device Capacitance Length and time scale for

rectification cutoff frequency is different from length and time

scale of device operation

Fermi velocity lt 106 ms so

R( tasymp10-15 s) = infin

R(t) R(t)

Slide 13 Bara Cola 582017

Impedance Matching

Poor impedance matching in a single junction is compensated by larger number of junctions

which allows power production

Collective antenna effects reduce coupling

resistance to single CNT antenna

R(t) R(t)

Collective CNT antenna array ndash approximately in phase

Phys Rev B 87 161401(R) 2013

Slide 14 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse
Page 8: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

DVR BOX

CELL PHONE TCPoly Plastic

Standard Plastic

Max 48degCMax 74degC LED BULB

PLASTICS FOR COOLER

ELECTRONICS

Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo

Microwave rectenna Solar rectenna (born 1963 Raytheon and Purdue) (proposed 1972)

Demonstrated efficiencies gt 80 Predicted efficiencies gt 80

Slide 9 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Physics (Classical) Cutoff frequency Diode resistance

Diode Junction

e shyV t

V t Diode responsivity

Antenna EM field

Rectenna voltage and power output

Slide 10 Bara Cola 582017

MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail

10 nm 100 nm

Al2O3 coated CNTs

Top metal

1 microm

bull 8 nm conformal alumina coating bull CNT tip field enhancement bull ~ 10 nm junction diameter (C~1 aF) bull CaAl low work function top contact

(semi-transparent ~10 transmission)

~ 6 CNT walls

Slide 11 Bara Cola 582017

How the Tunneling Diode Works e-

MWCNT tunneling diode

~ 5 ev MWCNT work function

φCNTrsquo φMrsquo

EF EF

After contact

FE

e-φCNTrsquo

EF φMrsquo

EF

Forward bias

φMrsquo

φCNTrsquo

e -EF

EF

Reverse bias

Slide 12 Bara Cola 582017

29 ev WF

43 ev WF

Device Capacitance Length and time scale for

rectification cutoff frequency is different from length and time

scale of device operation

Fermi velocity lt 106 ms so

R( tasymp10-15 s) = infin

R(t) R(t)

Slide 13 Bara Cola 582017

Impedance Matching

Poor impedance matching in a single junction is compensated by larger number of junctions

which allows power production

Collective antenna effects reduce coupling

resistance to single CNT antenna

R(t) R(t)

Collective CNT antenna array ndash approximately in phase

Phys Rev B 87 161401(R) 2013

Slide 14 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse
Page 9: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo

Microwave rectenna Solar rectenna (born 1963 Raytheon and Purdue) (proposed 1972)

Demonstrated efficiencies gt 80 Predicted efficiencies gt 80

Slide 9 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Physics (Classical) Cutoff frequency Diode resistance

Diode Junction

e shyV t

V t Diode responsivity

Antenna EM field

Rectenna voltage and power output

Slide 10 Bara Cola 582017

MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail

10 nm 100 nm

Al2O3 coated CNTs

Top metal

1 microm

bull 8 nm conformal alumina coating bull CNT tip field enhancement bull ~ 10 nm junction diameter (C~1 aF) bull CaAl low work function top contact

(semi-transparent ~10 transmission)

~ 6 CNT walls

Slide 11 Bara Cola 582017

How the Tunneling Diode Works e-

MWCNT tunneling diode

~ 5 ev MWCNT work function

φCNTrsquo φMrsquo

EF EF

After contact

FE

e-φCNTrsquo

EF φMrsquo

EF

Forward bias

φMrsquo

φCNTrsquo

e -EF

EF

Reverse bias

Slide 12 Bara Cola 582017

29 ev WF

43 ev WF

Device Capacitance Length and time scale for

rectification cutoff frequency is different from length and time

scale of device operation

Fermi velocity lt 106 ms so

R( tasymp10-15 s) = infin

R(t) R(t)

Slide 13 Bara Cola 582017

Impedance Matching

Poor impedance matching in a single junction is compensated by larger number of junctions

which allows power production

Collective antenna effects reduce coupling

resistance to single CNT antenna

R(t) R(t)

Collective CNT antenna array ndash approximately in phase

Phys Rev B 87 161401(R) 2013

Slide 14 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse
Page 10: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

Rectification Physics (Classical) Cutoff frequency Diode resistance

Diode Junction

e shyV t

V t Diode responsivity

Antenna EM field

Rectenna voltage and power output

Slide 10 Bara Cola 582017

MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail

10 nm 100 nm

Al2O3 coated CNTs

Top metal

1 microm

bull 8 nm conformal alumina coating bull CNT tip field enhancement bull ~ 10 nm junction diameter (C~1 aF) bull CaAl low work function top contact

(semi-transparent ~10 transmission)

~ 6 CNT walls

Slide 11 Bara Cola 582017

How the Tunneling Diode Works e-

MWCNT tunneling diode

~ 5 ev MWCNT work function

φCNTrsquo φMrsquo

EF EF

After contact

FE

e-φCNTrsquo

EF φMrsquo

EF

Forward bias

φMrsquo

φCNTrsquo

e -EF

EF

Reverse bias

Slide 12 Bara Cola 582017

29 ev WF

43 ev WF

Device Capacitance Length and time scale for

rectification cutoff frequency is different from length and time

scale of device operation

Fermi velocity lt 106 ms so

R( tasymp10-15 s) = infin

R(t) R(t)

Slide 13 Bara Cola 582017

Impedance Matching

Poor impedance matching in a single junction is compensated by larger number of junctions

which allows power production

Collective antenna effects reduce coupling

resistance to single CNT antenna

R(t) R(t)

Collective CNT antenna array ndash approximately in phase

Phys Rev B 87 161401(R) 2013

Slide 14 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse
Page 11: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail

10 nm 100 nm

Al2O3 coated CNTs

Top metal

1 microm

bull 8 nm conformal alumina coating bull CNT tip field enhancement bull ~ 10 nm junction diameter (C~1 aF) bull CaAl low work function top contact

(semi-transparent ~10 transmission)

~ 6 CNT walls

Slide 11 Bara Cola 582017

How the Tunneling Diode Works e-

MWCNT tunneling diode

~ 5 ev MWCNT work function

φCNTrsquo φMrsquo

EF EF

After contact

FE

e-φCNTrsquo

EF φMrsquo

EF

Forward bias

φMrsquo

φCNTrsquo

e -EF

EF

Reverse bias

Slide 12 Bara Cola 582017

29 ev WF

43 ev WF

Device Capacitance Length and time scale for

rectification cutoff frequency is different from length and time

scale of device operation

Fermi velocity lt 106 ms so

R( tasymp10-15 s) = infin

R(t) R(t)

Slide 13 Bara Cola 582017

Impedance Matching

Poor impedance matching in a single junction is compensated by larger number of junctions

which allows power production

Collective antenna effects reduce coupling

resistance to single CNT antenna

R(t) R(t)

Collective CNT antenna array ndash approximately in phase

Phys Rev B 87 161401(R) 2013

Slide 14 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse
Page 12: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

How the Tunneling Diode Works e-

MWCNT tunneling diode

~ 5 ev MWCNT work function

φCNTrsquo φMrsquo

EF EF

After contact

FE

e-φCNTrsquo

EF φMrsquo

EF

Forward bias

φMrsquo

φCNTrsquo

e -EF

EF

Reverse bias

Slide 12 Bara Cola 582017

29 ev WF

43 ev WF

Device Capacitance Length and time scale for

rectification cutoff frequency is different from length and time

scale of device operation

Fermi velocity lt 106 ms so

R( tasymp10-15 s) = infin

R(t) R(t)

Slide 13 Bara Cola 582017

Impedance Matching

Poor impedance matching in a single junction is compensated by larger number of junctions

which allows power production

Collective antenna effects reduce coupling

resistance to single CNT antenna

R(t) R(t)

Collective CNT antenna array ndash approximately in phase

Phys Rev B 87 161401(R) 2013

Slide 14 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse
Page 13: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

Device Capacitance Length and time scale for

rectification cutoff frequency is different from length and time

scale of device operation

Fermi velocity lt 106 ms so

R( tasymp10-15 s) = infin

R(t) R(t)

Slide 13 Bara Cola 582017

Impedance Matching

Poor impedance matching in a single junction is compensated by larger number of junctions

which allows power production

Collective antenna effects reduce coupling

resistance to single CNT antenna

R(t) R(t)

Collective CNT antenna array ndash approximately in phase

Phys Rev B 87 161401(R) 2013

Slide 14 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse
Page 14: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

Impedance Matching

Poor impedance matching in a single junction is compensated by larger number of junctions

which allows power production

Collective antenna effects reduce coupling

resistance to single CNT antenna

R(t) R(t)

Collective CNT antenna array ndash approximately in phase

Phys Rev B 87 161401(R) 2013

Slide 14 Bara Cola 582017

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse
Page 15: Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola · PDF fileCompany proprietary and confidential ... RE S E A RC H PRO TO Y PE SCALE ; ... Waterman Award Presentation - Baratunde Cola

Rectification Photoresponse

Predicted physics

J Phys D Appl Phys 46 (2013) 135106

Slide 15 Bara Cola 582017

  • Slide Number 1
  • Slide Number 2
  • Slide Number 3
  • Resolving CNT Interfaces One-Sided
  • Slide Number 5
  • Slide Number 6
  • First Thermally Conductive Amorphous Polymer
  • Slide Number 8
  • Rectifying Antenna or lsquoRectennarsquo
  • Rectification Physics (Classical)
  • MWCNT Rectenna Structural Detail
  • How the Tunneling Diode Works
  • Device Capacitance
  • Impedance Matching
  • Rectification Photoresponse