The Tao Te Ching was written by Lao Tzu who was he? What was
his book about? Why talk about it in a course on old wars vs. new
wars?
Slide 3
Slide 4
Lao Tzu lived at about the same time as Thucydides at the other
side of the world, i.e., in ancient China rather than ancient
Greece. he is famous as the author of the Chinese classic, the Tao
Te Ching, the oldest copy of which dates back to the last part of
the 4 th century BC. it is very short: about 5,000 characters, in
81 sections, without punctuation. despite its brevity it is one of
the greatest of the works of world literature
Slide 5
According to legend Lao Tzu was Old Long-ears, the keeper of
the Zhou imperial archives; when he was 80 years old he set out for
Tibet; at the border one of the guards asked him to write down his
Teachings so for three days he did:. this is a good story but it is
probably just that - a good story. in fact we do not know who Lao
Tzu was or even if there was someone by that name. nor do we know
what Taoism really means
Slide 6
Slide 7
In addition, many of the ideas in the Tao Te Ching are
ambiguous and many of the nuances get lost in translation; this
said:. so profound is this book it has been translated into Western
languages over 250 times (mostly English, German and French). only
the Bible has been translated more often. some translations are
popular; others scholarly; all try and solve the problems the text
poses
Slide 8
Comparisons of various translations can be found at:.
http://TaoTeChingMe.com/http://TaoTeChingMe.com/. these are only a
few of those available, plus. in my experience translations like
these tell us as much about the translators as they do about the
text. my personal favorite is the one by an American poet, Witter
Bynner, The Way of Life, 1944 (see also the translation by the
Taoist poet Mervyn Peake)
Slide 9
As an example, here is Bynners Verse 49 (p.76): I find good
people good, And I find bad people good If I am good enough; I
trust men of their word, And I trust liars If I am true enough; I
feel the heart-beats of others Above my own If I am enough of a
father, Enough of a son.
Slide 10
Also Bynners version of Verse 17 (p. 46): A leader is best When
people barely know that he exists, Not so good when people obey and
acclaim him, Worst when they despise him. Fail to honor people,
They fail to honor you; But of a good leader, who talks little,
When his work is done, his aim fulfilled, They will all say, We did
this ourselves.
Slide 11
And his version of Verse 39 (p. 69): save for the people, a
leader shall die: Always the low carry the high On a root for
growing by If rim and spoke and hub were not, Where would be the
chariot? Who will prefer the jingle of jade pendants if He once has
heard stone growing in a cliff!
Slide 12
As well as his version of Verse 40 (p. 70): Life on its way
returns into the mist, Its quickness is its quietness again:
Existence of this world of things and men Renews their never
needing to exist
Slide 13
Slide 14
Slide 15
Why talk about Lao Tzu in this course?. first we need to find
out what he says about the politico-strategic dimension to world
affairs, which is where we find most (but not all) talk about the
waging of wars?. in this regard he seems to endorse globalism,
since he seems to assume that people are good. he talks, that is,
about our basic simplicity and purity. this suggests he sees the
world in a hail-fellow- well-met way
Slide 16
. when Taoism was first articulated, however, the key issue was
how to survive in the face of murderously competing powers (see
Ames, The Art of Rulership, 1994, p.7).. this sounds like realism
since it suggests system-level protection is simply not available,
however.. Lao Tzu also shows a preference for small,
self-sufficient polities behaving cooperatively rather than
competitively - this sounds like early internationalism
Slide 17
T here is a prior question, however, and that is: what is
Taoism?, i.e., what does it mean to promote and protect the Tao as
a feature of any kind of world affairs?. this is not easy to say
and Lao Tzu admits this: Existence is beyond the power of words To
define In the beginning of heaven and earth there were no words
From wonder into wonder Existence opens (Bynner, op. cit.,Vse 1,
p.31)
Slide 18
. we face at the outset, in other words, the problem of
describing a fluid whole that defies any attempt to label it
(Graham, Disputers of the Tao, 1989, 219).. n.b. in ancient
Chinese, tao (with a small t) refers to a road or a path while Tao
(with a big T) is much harder to define since it seems to mean the
way the universe works (Waley, The Way and Its Power, 1934,
30)
Slide 19
Slide 20
.. others call the Tao the eternal order of the cosmos and at
the same time its course (Weber, The Religion of China, 1951,
181).. the inherent order that pervades all being (Loewe, The Pride
that was China, 1990, 91).. the still undivided stuff that is
nameless (Graham, op. cit., 221), and.. the Great Clod (Creel, What
is Taoism? 1970, 33)
Slide 21
Slide 22
. definitions of this sort do not, of course, provide a logical
account of world affairs. they do, however, provide an analogical
account, i.e., one that does not describe world affairs in
scientific terms but rather intuits them (as phenomenologists do)
in emotivist terms e.g., in the form of maxims (Graham, op. cit.,
199-200).. n.b. this is to subjectify not objectify and as such it
provides understanding not available to more rationalistic
analysts
Slide 23
Slide 24
Slide 25
. such definitions also promote creative quietism, (c.f. vacant
inaction or passive contemplation).. to modern rationalists reply:
is this going to help state leaders and the like order world
affairs more effectively than Enlightenment pessimism, opportunism
or optimism can, i.e., is a world of war, exploitation,
destitution, and environmental neglect, one best met with either
meditative poise or with passionate engagement (or detached
commitment)?
Slide 26
Slide 27
Slide 28
.. to this Lao Tzu replies: is objectifying such issues going
to do any more than limit leaders to their basic experience (which
is that of detached individuals); will it give them an antidote to
the distortions involved; will it help compensate for these limits
and distortions?.. consider war: we can either analyze it
rationally and try to resolve it that way, or we can cultivate
meditative watchfulness and try to resolve it that way; which makes
more sense?
Slide 29
Slide 30
. it would certainly be foolish to deal with war in the world
by getting leaders and others to do Taoist-style meditation (e.g.,
to sit quietly and listen for a voice that will say be more
silent).. few would do it and those who did would be afraid of
being attacked by those who did not. it might not be foolish,
though, to heed the advice Lao Tzu provides as a result of his
meditations, since he drew for this on the wells of wordless wisdom
that underpin our day-to-day awareness
Slide 31
Slide 32
. his meditations tell Lao Tzu that to do [is] to be and the
best way to be is to try and order the world by gaining greater
knowledge and understanding of Nature beyond society.. he promotes
as a consequence an active form of pacifism - war does not pay, he
says; it does not get the results those who wage it intend to get -
it also has unintended consequences, like laying waste good
land
Slide 33
Slide 34
. where war cannot be avoided, Lao Tzu says, it should be waged
reluctantly, and if it is won, the victory should not be seen as a
triumph. he says, therefore, that:.. a ruler should oppose every
resort to force because it is likely to rebound; and.. [w]here
armies are, thorns and brambles grow; and.. [a] host that has slain
men [should be] received with rites of mourning
Slide 35
. finally he says: Show me a man of violence that came to a
good end, and I will take him for my teacher. to confirm this key
conclusion he says that: The greatest conqueror wins without
joining issue This is called the power that comes from not
contending [I]t is the way of Heaven not to strive but none the
less to conquer (Lao Tzu, Tao Te Ching, trans. Authur Waley,1997).
C.f. Sun Tzu, who we look at next week
Slide 36
Slide 37
. in offering such advice, does Lao Tzu contradict himself?.
Creel thinks so, drawing attention to the difference between Lao
Tzu wanting to have a political impact and at the same time wanting
to practice contemplation (Creel, op.cit., 45). Ames says there is
no such dichotomy since Lao Tzus ideas are part of his idea of the
universe, and the way politics works are part of the universe too
(Ames, op.cit., 218 fn.23)
Slide 38
. in offering such advice is Lao Tzu merely being impractical,
then?. he is certainly critiqued (and was from the very beginning)
as someone.. nave and primitivist, and who.. totally repudiates
human culture (Ames, op.cit, 219 fin. 34). why, these critics say,
should an active form of pacifism be any more natural than any
other policy?
Slide 39
. Lao Tzus followers say this misses the point. the active
pacifism he promotes, they say, is a particular form of wu-wei
(i.e. no unnatural action). he does not seek to be practical or
impractical (Chan, The Great Asian Religions, 1969, 150). he does
not seek to impose preconceptions. he seeks instead to use subtler
methods of persuasion where things take their own course
Slide 40
. Wu-wei is not easy to understand, e.g., when we are standing
stiff and we are told to relax we tend to imagine the opposite of
stiff and go floppy; not-stiff has another meaning, though, for
which there is no precise English equivalent: flexible, supple,
lithe, (com)pliant, elastic, or plastic; these are all part of this
other meaning. by wu-wei Taoism refers to this other meaning and
not the floppy one
Slide 41
Wu-wei
Slide 42
. likewise, when someone is being too activist in their
state-making and is advised to be more pacifist, we tend to think
they are being asked to be more inactive; this is the same as
thinking the word relax means floppy, which in this case is likely
to be disastrous since an inactive leader would probably not resist
either domestic or foreign enemies for long.. in practice, though,
being more pacifist could mean more intervention (albeit of a more
subtle, that is, not-stiff kind)
Slide 43
. even if we think we understand wu-wei we still have not said
what an unnatural action is and what the difference might be
between a unnatural and an natural one might be. Lao Tzu says the
answer to this question comes from meditation rather than analysis,
i.e., by meditating it is possible to understand that natural
action means rule through te, which is quiet, virtuous power. how
would this stop an armed enemy or traitors?
Slide 44
. on the one hand modernists see the idea that it could ever do
so as irrational - even ridiculous. on the other Lao Tzu thinks
there is no reason to expect that te (quiet, virtuous power),
gained and used the Taoist way, would not work; indeed, he thinks
there is every reason to expect it will work (hence the Tao Te
Ching)
Slide 45
. What, then, is natural action?. firstly, Lao Tzu thinks it is
what happens when we act in a free and spontaneous way
Slide 46
free and spontaneous way
Slide 47
. secondly, Lao Tzu thinks that natural actions are those that
are.. caring (not indifferent).. humble (not proud).. frugal (not
profligate).. yielding (not assertive).. wise (not learned).. most
likely to take from those who have too much (and give to those
without enough).. most likely to spare lives (not take them)
Slide 48
caring (not indifferent)
Slide 49
humble (not proud)
Slide 50
frugal (not profligate)
Slide 51
yielding (not assertive)
Slide 52
wise (not learned)
Slide 53
taking from those who have too much (and giving to those
without enough)
Slide 54
... sparing lives (not taking them)
Slide 55
in addition, Lao Tzu thinks, natural actions.. leave people
alone (rather than interfere with them, e.g., by trying to teach
them too much so they become confused).. are timely, dealing with
issues while still small (rather than waiting until they become too
big).. teach being content, self-understanding, and self-control
(rather than dissatisfaction, lack of awareness, and lack of
inhibition)
Slide 56
dealing with issues while small (rather than waiting until they
become too big), e.g. F.A.S.T.
Slide 57
natural actions, Lao Tzu says, also.. do not foster fame,
riches, ritual or the the overt use of power (they are used to keep
the states sharpest weapons where none can see them).. do not
portray such weapons as lovely (they depict them as ugly instead)..
oppose all conquest by force of arms (they do not promote it)..
know the male (and the female both)
Slide 58
keeping the states sharpest weapons where none can see
them
Slide 59
knowing the male (and the female too)
Slide 60
natural actions, Lao Tze says, are finally those that.. do not
oppress ordinary people (instead, they seek to better peoples
welfare, while seeing and hearing as they do).. do not stimulate
the desire for products that are hard to get (they do not
advertise).. do not legislate kindness or morality (they are
helpful and childlike instead, while still valuing profound
thoughts, gentle friendships, true words, good government, due
regulation, and effective deeds)
Slide 61
not advertising
Slide 62
not legislating morality
Slide 63
gentle friendships
Slide 64
good government
Slide 65
. now: there are many undefined universals built in to Lao Tzus
approach, for example:.. what is wisdom?.. what is kindness?.. what
is a true word?.. what is a profound thought?.. what is good
government?.. what is an effective deed?.. what does knowing the
male and the female involve?
Slide 66
. this said, wu wei can be seen at work in the practice of a
martial art like tai chi chuan.. here the power of an opponent is
returned or re-directed.. the defender prevails by yielding and
neutralizing the offender rather than by using countervailing
force
Slide 67
tai chi chuan
Slide 68
. this said: it is one thing to re-direct a punch to the face
or a kick to the stomach; it is quite another to re-direct an
invading army. yet the techniques of all guerrilla war - rural or
urban - are basically those of wu wei. we will look at this later
in the course. at this point it is simply worth noting how this is
one way in which old forms of war are manifest in new contexts
Slide 69
guerrilla war
Slide 70
. In brief: guerrillas avoid wars of position; they do not like
to risk face-to-face fighting for fear of defeat. they prefer to
undermine their enemy and to wait for the right moment to apply
direct force. Lao Tzu supports this strategy but he goes a step
further by suggesting that any conflict is best dealt with when the
risk of losing it is small and when strategic intervention is
likely to preempt the need for conflict altogether
Slide 71
. the same logic is found in aikido, a Japanese martial art
that manifests Taoist principles. aikido is a non-violent form of
self-defense whose founder, Morihei Uyeshiba, wanted to create a
martial art of harmony and love, not discord and hate. its purpose
is not to fight, i.e., to try and win. it is to harmonize ourselves
with the movement of the universe and [to] bring ourselves into
accord with the universe itself
Slide 72
. winning under these circumstances means winning over the mind
of discord in [one]self. aikido is not just a martial art since its
principles can be applied in daily life, up to and including the
practice of global affairs. it has been called, for example, a
germane metaphor for describing and explaining the international
relations of Japan (Hook et al, Japans International Relations,
2001)
Slide 73
aikido
Slide 74
. the collaborative nature of the aikido/Taoist approach is
very different from the dog-eat- dog competitiveness that is the
basis for world affairs realism or the tit-for-tat cooperativeness
that is the basis for inter- nationalism. at the same time it is
not globalism, despite the suggestion at the start that it might
be. indeed, it has nothing to do with this rationalist,
pessimistic/opportunistic/optimistic spectrum
Slide 75
. it promotes instead positive collaboration of the kind that
self-realization means. what, then, does Lao Tzu have to say to the
white, Western, competitive, state-obsessed men who dominate world
affairs today (should they ever shut up long enough to listen to
him). as noted as the start global politico-strategics are usually
read in military and diplomatic terms, i.e., in terms of the
changing balance of power and challenges to state and interstate
security
Slide 76
. less conventionally they are seen in politico- economic,
-social, -cultural and -sacral terms. this is not what we find in
the media, though; there we descriptions of terrorism, trade and
financial issues, gender, resource, pollution and population issues
and, of course, wars. the sheer diversity of such concerns, and
their global reach today, is what inspired Kaldor to try and expand
the disciplines focus from an old war one to a new war one
Slide 77
. to the mainstream analyst, Lao Tzu offers wu wei, or the
concept of no unnatural action. he recommends:.. acting freely and
spontaneously.. sparing lives by using overt force reluctantly (and
avoiding it altogether when possible).. keeping force minimal when
it is unavoidable.. planning ahead for regional/global challenges..
not putting weapons on public display, and.. intervening earlier
rather than later
Slide 78
. to others he offers the same general advice plus:.. not
stimulating the desire for goods that are hard to get.. not
legislating morality (is this possible?).. using Robin Hood tactics
to distribute wealth.. again, always acting in a timely way, and..
acknowledging the male but connecting with the female too
Slide 79
As an example, how would Lao Tzus ideas apply to global and
regional security in the light of the rise of China?. its large
military forces certainly suggest that there is a Chinese threat.
China has long played a central role in regional affairs as well.
as China recovers from the effects of 19 th c. imperialism there is
no reason to think it will not play this role again
Slide 80
Slide 81
. some analysts actively fear Chinas rise. other see it doing
no more than taking its rightful place again as a major world
power. yet others see the likely outcome as being a complex
politico-strategic tango as Chinese leaders make various military
and diplomatic moves and the rest of the world responds. Chinas
leaders themselves talk of being open and peaceful while noting
on-going issues like the U.S., the Taiwan, and the island ones
Slide 82
Slide 83
. Chinas rapid economic development has strategic implications
of its own, e.g.,.. the need to protect the shipping lanes along
which vital raw materials come in (like oil) and manufactured goods
(like clothing) go out. much turns here upon assessments of Chinas
strategic intentions, since as noted already. if its leaders have
no intention of using their power, then the latter is of little
significance
Slide 84
Slide 85
. a benign China may mean no more than it wants to continue
developing as fast as it can and that it needs the security
environment that allows it to maximize its productive potential. it
might also mean that it has its own strategic culture and this is
different from the Euro- American one.. there is a problem, in the
latter case, with parachuting Euro-American perceptions into the
Asia-Pacific region
Slide 86
. Chinese leaders may use Western words about world affairs
while promoting their own civilization. it is worth noting,
however, that China is.. not expansionist.. understands that
conflict is avoidable, and.. is only likely to use force -
defensively - minimally and - righteously (Johnston, Cultural
Realism, 1995, 24)
Slide 87
. this is, in part, Taoist. it helps explain why the Chinese
think in such terms as.. contingency planning.. strategic
restraint.. the need to better the welfare of the people, and..
being prudent not arrogant (despite becoming strong),
therefore
Slide 88
any conclusion about China as a rising threat has to include
the extent to which its leaders think in Taoist terms, i.e., the
extent to which it might be an exception to the realpolitik rule.
to treat it otherwise might be to bring about the very response
that Euro-American leaders fear
Slide 89
As another example of applied Taoism, how does it apply to the
modernist/rationalist culture that is the cultural context to all
world affairs today? In short:. modernist/rationalism limits and
distorts our understanding of world affairs. as noted earlier,
however, Taoism can compensate for this As to old wars and new
ones
Slide 90
Lao Tzu, like Thucydides, lived long before the age of
globalization; his idea of old wars was pre-modernist and he could
not be expected to have known about new wars in Kaldors sense. this
said, his ideas are highly subversive of the logic of old wars as
this applied in his day, e.g., he knew about standing armies (i.e.
old war forms) but he thought these should be kept out of sight,
used reluctantly, and their victories mourned not celebrated
(wu-wei)
Slide 91
. he also does not endorse how new wars interfere with the
lives of ordinary people by displacing them, for example, or by
making wars a matter of identity rather than territory.. in that
respect he is not likely to have supported either old wars or new
ones.. he has his own approach wu wei