1
ANZOS 2013 abstracts e99 180 What health literacy interventions are effective in the primary healthcare settings in weight loss management—–A systematic review Nighat Faruqi 1,, Chandni Joshi 1 , Sarah Dennis 2 , Jane Lloyd 1 , Jane Taggart 1 , Catherine Spooner 1 , Mark Harris 1 1 University of New South Wales, UNSW, NSW, Australia 2 The University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia To assess the effectiveness of health literacy interventions in achieving weight loss in adults with overweight or obesity. Studies were obtained from searches of 17 elec- tronic bibliographic databases, hand searching, relevant websites, and personal communication. Intervention studies using experimental or quasi-experimental methods conducted in primary healthcare (PHC) or by a PHC professional outside the PHC setting with a minimum 6 months follow- up, published in the English language between 1989 and June 2013 in one of the OECD member countries. Studies where patients had any chronic disease were excluded. Three authors extracted data and one indepen- dently assessed trial quality. Nineteen studies were included with 3747 participants (71% females). Of these, 15 were patient-focussed, one provider-focussed and three studies addressed both. Three studies included ele- ments of functional, 15 of interactive and one of critical health literacy. All targeted lifestyle (diet and physical activity). Fourteen studies were randomised trials with nine showing significant between-group weight loss differences over a period of 6—12 month follow up. All five non- randomised trials showed significant weight losses over a period of 6—18 month follow up. Five studies included patients from a disadvan- taged background. Participants in 11 studies were at a high risk of developing diabetes. Duration of studies was <6 month (5), 6—9 months (6) and >9 months (8). The intervention was delivered indi- vidually (4), group sessions (9), mixed group and individual (3), internet only (1), mixed telephone and internet (1), and mixed telephone and individ- ual (1). The intervention was delivered by diabetes edu- cators, dieticians, health promotion and internet counsellors, lay leaders, medical practitioners, nurses, physiotherapists, physical activity special- ists, psychologists, traditional wellness coordi- nators, and the Internet. The results of this review show the effectiveness of a variety of health literacy-focussed lifestyle modification programs, incorporating physical activity and dietary changes, in achieving weight loss. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.orcp.2013.12.679 181 Insulin sensitivity, body composition and macronutrient intake in adolescents with pre-diabetes; RESIST a randomised control trial Sarah P. Garnett 1,2,, Megan Gow 1,2,, Mandy Ho 1,2,, Louise A. Baur 2 , Helenn J. Woodhead 3 , Kerryn Chisholm 1 , Jocelyn Halim 1 , Kate Steinbeck 4 , Manny Noakes 5 , Chris T. Cowell 1,2 1 Institute of Endocrinology and Diabetes, The Children’s Hospital at Westmead, Sydney, NSW, Australia 2 The Children’s Hospital at Westmead Clinical School, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia 3 Department of Paediatrics, Campbelltown Hospital, Campbelltown, NSW, Australia 4 Academic Department of Adolescent Medicine, Sydney Medical School, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia 5 Food and Nutritional Sciences, CSIRO, Adelaide, SA, Australia Context: A higher protein to carbohydrate ratio in the diet may potentiate weight loss, improve body composition and cardiometabolic risk, includ- ing glucose homeostasis. Objective: To determine the efficacy of two structured lifestyle interventions, differing in dietary protein and carbohydrate composition, on insulin sensitivity and body composition. We hypothesized that a moderate-carbohydrate, increased-protein diet would be more effective in improving outcome measures in obese, insulin resis- tant adolescents. Design: Randomised control trial, known as RESIST, in two hospitals in Sydney, Australia.

What health literacy interventions are effective in the primary healthcare settings in weight loss management—A systematic review

  • Upload
    mark

  • View
    212

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: What health literacy interventions are effective in the primary healthcare settings in weight loss management—A systematic review

ANZOS 2013 abstracts e99

180

What health literacy interventionsare effective in the primaryhealthcare settings in weight lossmanagement—–A systematic review

Nighat Faruqi 1,∗, Chandni Joshi 1,Sarah Dennis 2, Jane Lloyd 1, JaneTaggart 1, Catherine Spooner 1, MarkHarris 1

1 University of New South Wales,UNSW, NSW, Australia2 The University of Sydney, Sydney,NSW, Australia

To assess the effectiveness of health literacyinterventions in achieving weight loss in adults withoverweight or obesity.

Studies were obtained from searches of 17 elec-tronic bibliographic databases, hand searching,relevant websites, and personal communication.

Intervention studies using experimental orquasi-experimental methods conducted in primaryhealthcare (PHC) or by a PHC professional outsidethe PHC setting with a minimum 6 months follow-up, published in the English language between1989 and June 2013 in one of the OECD membercountries. Studies where patients had any chronicdisease were excluded.

Three authors extracted data and one indepen-dently assessed trial quality.

Nineteen studies were included with 3747participants (71% females). Of these, 15 werepatient-focussed, one provider-focussed and threestudies addressed both. Three studies included ele-ments of functional, 15 of interactive and oneof critical health literacy. All targeted lifestyle(diet and physical activity). Fourteen studies wererandomised trials with nine showing significantbetween-group weight loss differences over aperiod of 6—12 month follow up. All five non-randomised trials showed significant weight lossesover a period of 6—18 month follow up.

Five studies included patients from a disadvan-taged background. Participants in 11 studies wereat a high risk of developing diabetes. Duration ofstudies was <6 month (5), 6—9 months (6) and >9months (8). The intervention was delivered indi-vidually (4), group sessions (9), mixed group andindividual (3), internet only (1), mixed telephoneand internet (1), and mixed telephone and individ-ual (1).

The intervention was delivered by diabetes edu-cators, dieticians, health promotion and internetcounsellors, lay leaders, medical practitioners,

nurses, physiotherapists, physical activity special-ists, psychologists, traditional wellness coordi-nators, and the Internet.

The results of this review show the effectivenessof a variety of health literacy-focussed lifestylemodification programs, incorporating physicalactivity and dietary changes, in achieving weightloss.

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.orcp.2013.12.679

181

Insulin sensitivity, bodycomposition and macronutrientintake in adolescents withpre-diabetes; RESIST a randomisedcontrol trial

Sarah P. Garnett 1,2,∗, MeganGow 1,2,∗, Mandy Ho 1,2,∗, Louise A.Baur 2, Helenn J. Woodhead 3, KerrynChisholm 1, Jocelyn Halim 1, KateSteinbeck 4, Manny Noakes 5, Chris T.Cowell 1,2

1 Institute of Endocrinology andDiabetes, The Children’s Hospital atWestmead, Sydney, NSW, Australia2 The Children’s Hospital atWestmead Clinical School, Universityof Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia3 Department of Paediatrics,Campbelltown Hospital,Campbelltown, NSW, Australia4 Academic Department ofAdolescent Medicine, Sydney MedicalSchool, University of Sydney, Sydney,NSW, Australia5 Food and Nutritional Sciences,CSIRO, Adelaide, SA, Australia

Context: A higher protein to carbohydrate ratioin the diet may potentiate weight loss, improvebody composition and cardiometabolic risk, includ-ing glucose homeostasis.

Objective: To determine the efficacy of twostructured lifestyle interventions, differing indietary protein and carbohydrate composition,on insulin sensitivity and body composition.We hypothesized that a moderate-carbohydrate,increased-protein diet would be more effective inimproving outcome measures in obese, insulin resis-tant adolescents.

Design: Randomised control trial, known asRESIST, in two hospitals in Sydney, Australia.