Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
What’s in the box?Getting to know your research resources
Robin HarrisLIS 740 Social Sciences/Information Literacy11/11/14
MAC-532 Professional, Legal & Ethical Issues: Research Paper Write a research paper focused on an ethical issue of your
choice related to psychology or counseling.
Expectations:◦ Follow current APA guidelines. ◦ A minimum of five peer-reviewed references will be acceptable
for this assignment. ◦ The final body of this paper will be 10–12 pages.
The paper should cover the following areas:◦ Research an area of professional development and ethics. Provide a
description of the topic and why it is a topic that should be examined.
◦ Write a brief literature review examining the area of interest. Describe what has been done, the general findings, and implications.
◦ Self-reflection about your learning and insights regarding your own professional development and ethics. What are your strengths in this area? What are areas in which you believe you need growth?
Where are you going to look first?Library?
Internet?
Database?
Today we’re going to look at Google Scholar, Academic Search Complete, and PsycINFO to see what they have to
offer
Google ScholarProvides a simple way to broadly search for
scholarly literature. Many disciplines and sources: articles,
abstracts, dissertations, books, court opinions and patents.
From academic publishers, professional societies, online repositories, universities and other web sites.
Often can only see an abstract and the citation details, and have to pay a fee to access the entire article.
Not all journals allow access by Google Scholar.
Academic Search CompleteMulti-disciplinary database providing full text for
more than 8,500 full-text periodicals, including more than 7,300 peer-reviewed titles.
Subject coverage includes (but is not limited to) animal science, anthropology, area studies, astronomy, biology, chemistry, civil engineering, electrical engineering, ethnic & multicultural studies, food science & technology, general science, geography, geology, law, materials science, mathematics, mechanical engineering, music, pharmaceutical sciences, physics, psychology, religion & theology, veterinary science, women’s studies, zoology, and many other fields.
PsycINFODefinitive database for psychology,
psychiatry, and related mental health disciplines (including social, behavioral, and health sciences).
Contains nearly 2.3 million citations and summaries of scholarly journal articles, book chapters, books, and dissertations.
98% of the covered material is peer-reviewed.
Same search, different boxes
“professional ethics”* and
“duty to warn”**
*Course objective: Foundation for the ethical practice of professional counseling
**Exception to a client’s right to confidentiality when a therapist thinks he may harm himself or others
What’s in the box?1. Is the content of the box addressing your
research topic? Is it relevant? How can you tell?2. Is the information scholarly? Peer-reviewed? How
can you tell?3. Can you access the resource for free? Is there a
pay wall?4. Is there any information (subject terms, subject
headings, links, etc.) provided to help you find similar resources?
5. What else can you tell from the results in the box?6. Overall, how useful do you think this particular
resource is for your assignment?7. What resource do you think your box is?
Google Scholar resultsEthics, tuberculosis and globalizationProfessional ethics in genetic testingDuty to warn guidelines for counselorsEthics in the militaryBook on Ethics for AdversariesEthics in bankruptcy law and practice, $$Counseling and values worksheet, $$Environmental health research on hazards
in the home and duty to warn, $$HIV prevention and duty to warnThyroid cancer and duty to warn
Academic Search Complete resultsDisclosure obligations in
gambling-related theftDuty to warn/blood transfusion
risksDuty to warn/genetic testingPsychology/counselingMedical/genetic testing/HIVNewspapers and periodicals
PsycINFO resultsEthical issues in mental health
background checks Protecting victims of violent patients
while protecting confidentialityConfidentiality/therapeutic
relationshipsMental illness/risk of harming othersHIV/genetics, but with
counseling/psych angleAll peer-reviewed
In general…Google Scholar=BIG box, tons of
results, lots of “filler,” logins/pay walls. Hard to tell if peer-reviewed.
Academic Search Complete=mid-size box, some “filler,” broad but not that deep in individual fields. Something on everything. 85% peer-reviewed.
PsycINFO=smaller box, almost no “filler,” all related to psychology and mental health. 98% peer-reviewed.
Best bet? PsycINFO!Most relevant informationAlmost all peer-reviewed (and limiters
can be set for that in advanced searching)
None of the information is behind a pay wall
Subject headings can be used to look for similar information
Saves time by not having to dig through a lot of irrelevant search results
