4/21/2015
Whyisn'taSolenoidmotorbasedonnormalpistonenginesstillnotputintodailyuse?Isthereadifferenceintorque/speed?Quora
http://www.quora.com/WhyisntaSolenoidmotorbasedonnormalpistonenginesstillnotputintodailyuseIsthereadifferenceintorquespeed
1/3
Twitter
Facebook
Google+
CultureandSociety
Culture(socialscience)
MaterialCulture
ConsumerProductsandServices
CarsandAutomobiles
SHAREQUESTION
RELATEDTOPICS
1ANSWER
Whyisn'taSolenoidmotorbasedonnormalpistonenginesstillnotputintodailyuse?Isthereadifferenceintorque/speed?Whyisn'tthereanydevelopementfromHugeCarfirmslikeBMW,GM,AUDIetc.Couldsomeonepleaseprovideanyinformationonthis.Here'salinkSolenoidEngineby7thCrook
Writeananswer
RelatedQuestions
SIGNINTOREADALLOFQUORA.
ContinuewithGoogle
ContinuewithFacebook
BycontinuingyouindicatethatyouhavereadandagreetotheTermsofService.
SignUpwithEmail
RELATEDQUESTIONS
Whatisthedifferencebetweenthespeedandthetorqueofamotor?
Whyisn'tthereanymagneticbasedpistonsmotoraround?
Whycan'twegenerateelectricitybyusingcombustionpistonassolenoidinreverse,tosimplifythemechanics?
InternalCombustionEngines:Whatwouldhappenifyouputmotoroilinthegastankofacar?
MotorControl(engineering):WhatarethedrawbacksofaVFD(variablefrequencydrive)?
SoundEngineering:Wherearehighcurrentlinearregulatorsarestillusedtosuppressnoise?
ElectricalEngineering:Howarethevoltages/currentsuseddifferentbetweendefibrillatorsandECT?
ElectricMotors:Howdospeedregulatorsofcommonfansathome&officesoperate?
Whydidn'ttherotaryenginereplacethepistonengine?
Engines:Whatisthedifferencebetweenacylinderandabarrel?
WantAnswers 2
Downvote Comments 1+
Written1Jan.167views.
IwouldliketosharewhatIfeelmaybethereason.
FirstletusseethebenefitsofusualmotoroverInternalCombustionengines
1.
Amotorhasveryfewmovingparts.23comparedtomanyincaseofengine.Thisensureslesserplacesoffailureandalsoensureshighefficiency.Byandlargeitisverysimple.
2.
Sinceitisrunningonelectricity,itcanbeprogrammedortunedasperneeds.
Nowtheproblemwithmotoristhatitrunsonelectricityandsothebatteryneedstobechargedwhichtakesalotoftime.
Nowthedesigngiveninthelinkhastheissuethatithasalotofmovingcomponents.Thisscrapsoutoneoftheadvantagesofamotor.Furtheritwillrunonelectricitysoitdoesnotsolvetheproblemwithmotor.
NowhereisanotherthingthatIthinkthoughIcan'tproveitverywell.Theforcedevelopedbyasolenoidpullingtherodinbetweenwillbequitelessasitisbasedoninducedmagneticfield.Ontheotherhandmotorwillproducegreaterforce.
Seeitthisway.Incaseofasolenoid,themagneticfieldisquitedispersedattheendsandtherodishalfoutsidewherefieldisverylesssoalargepartisgettingwasted.Thiswillnotbethecaseinrotarymotorasthecurrentcarryingwireisalwaysinsidethefield.
ByandlargeIthinkthesolenoidenginewillhavelesserpowertoweightratiocomparedtousualmotorandalsohasnumerousmovingparts.
Otherproblemswillalsocomelikethatoflubricationtofacilitatelinearmotionoftherodbuttheyaresecondary.
Ihopethisanswersthequestionasked.Ifyoufeelsomethingiswrongorunclear,letmeknow.
GaganMakhija,MechanicalEngineeringstudent2upvotesbyArijitMukherjeeandSanidhyaGupta.
Upvote 2
Searchforquestions,people,andtopics Login SignUp
4/21/2015
Whyisn'taSolenoidmotorbasedonnormalpistonenginesstillnotputintodailyuse?Isthereadifferenceintorque/speed?Quora
http://www.quora.com/WhyisntaSolenoidmotorbasedonnormalpistonenginesstillnotputintodailyuseIsthereadifferenceintorquespeed
2/3
Whatisthedifferencebetweenthespeedandthetorqueofamotor?
Whyisn'tthereanymagneticbasedpistonsmotoraround?
Whycan'twegenerateelectricitybyusingcombustionpistonassolenoidinreverse,tosimplifythemechanics?
InternalCombustionEngines:Whatwouldhappenifyouputmotoroilinthegastankofacar?
MotorControl(engineering):WhatarethedrawbacksofaVFD(variablefrequencydrive)?
SoundEngineering:Wherearehighcurrentlinearregulatorsarestillusedtosuppressnoise?
ElectricalEngineering:Howarethevoltages/currentsuseddifferentbetweendefibrillatorsandECT?
ElectricMotors:Howdospeedregulatorsofcommonfansathome&officesoperate?
Whydidn'ttherotaryenginereplacethepistonengine?
Engines:Whatisthedifferencebetweenacylinderandabarrel?
HowcanIcalculatetheinstantaneoustorqueproducedbyagivenpistonforceaboutthecrankshaftofapistonengine?
EngineeringinSiliconValley:WhatarethedifferentcircuitscanImakeusing(optional)IC741?It'smyminiproject.
TeslaMotors(carcompany):Whatistheadvantageofusingmanysmallbatteriesoveralargebatterytopowertheelectricvehicles?
AerospaceandAeronauticalEngineering:CanVirginGalactic'sSpaceShipTwobeusedforpointtopointtravel?Woulditrepresentasignificantspeedincreaseoverexistingairliners?...(continue)
Whichmotorusedinrailwayelectricengine?
TeslaMotors(carcompany):CouldthefreepublicreleaseofTesla'stechnicalengineeringdocumentsultimatelyleadtotheirfinancialsuccess?
Whydoesn'tWeMouseasolidstaterelayinsteadofmagneticsolenoidrelay?
ElectronicsEngineering:Howcanasteppermotorcontrolledbymicrocontroller8051?
Whatistherelationbetweentorque,slip,andspeedininductionmotors?
AutoParts:Whatdifferenttypesofcarmotors/enginesarethere?
TopStories
Wouldhumanbloodbeahealthydrinkforhumans?
Humanbloodwouldbeaterribledrinkforhumans.Notonlywouldithaveanexcellentchanceofspreadingdisease,ithasverylittlenutritionandcontainstoxiccomponents.Ithinkthediseaseconcernisobvious.Anybloodbornedisease(hepatitisC,hepatitisB,HIV,manymore)wouldhavethepotentialforspreadingthisway.Asfor
IanYork,Virologist,immunologist,biologist
549upvotesbyCatarinaDeMarchiAssuncao(brazilianmedicaldoctor,neurologyresident),SunilSati(PediatricianatLadyHardingeMedicalCollege,...(more)),LiangHaiSie(Retiredgeneralinternist,formerintensivecar...(more)),(more)
WhataresomelesserknownGmailtipsandhacks?
Thesearedefinitelylesserknownhackssincenonehasmentionedabove.1.'Dotblind'hackGmailis'dotblind'[email protected][1]:Gmaildoesn'trecognizedotsascharacterswithinusernames,youcanaddorremovethedotsfromaGmailaddresswithoutchangingtheactualdestinationaddressthey'llallgotoyourinbox,and...
AdityaLesmana846upvotesbyGauravJha(Software
EngineerIIIatGoogleIndia),VickySirwani(Googler),JoshSiegel,(more)
Whatisthegreatestmathematicaldiscoveryofalltime?
DavidJoyce,ProfessorofMathematicsatClarkUni...(more)
2.6kupvotesbyOriGurelGurevich(Level17Mathematician),MichalForiek(Ph.D.intheoreticalComputerScience),JeffNelson(InventedChromebook.FormerMathPhDstudent.),JensAdlerNielsen(),(more)
