Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
WORKFORCE MANAGEMENTAND PRODUCTIVITYTHREE HABITS OF HIGHLY PRODUCTIVEORGANIZATIONS
Kevin Prouty, Sr VP, Research and Operations, Aberdeen GroupData courtesy of Ms. Michael M. Moon, Research Director,
Human Capital Management, Aberdeen Group
Ken Madley, Productivity Consultant, Kronos Incorporated
2
PACE: How we collect our research
!
PRESSURES ACTIONS CAPABILITIES ENABLERS
External and internalforces that impact anorganization’s market
position,competitiveness, orbusiness operations.
The strategicapproaches that an
organization takes inresponse to industry
pressures.
The businesscompetencies(organization,
process, etc…)required to executecorporate strategy.
The key technologysolutions required to
support theorganization’s
business practices.
What are Best-in-ClassCompanies doing
differently?
What pitfalls are theyavoiding?
Why are they achievinggreater success?
What technologies andservices are enabling
them to succeed?
3
ABERDEEN MATURITY CLASS FRAMEWORKDEFINING THE BEST-IN-CLASS
Selected PerformanceCriteria (KPI)
Organizational Goals
Employee Performance
Bench Strength
TotalRespondents
- Top 20%
- Middle 50%
- Bottom 30%Respondents are scoredindividually across KPI
Best-in-Class
IndustryAverage
Laggard
4
DEMOGRAPHICS - GLOBAL
• Role – 32% HR, 37% Ops, 21% Fin other
• Level – 10% Exec, 72% Manager/Dir, 8% Staff/Other
• Size (employees) - 31% <100, 32% 100-1000, 23% 1000-10,000, 14% >10,000
• Vertical – 34% Service (Software, Consulting, Facilities,AEC firms, etc.), 29% Manuf, 14% Retail, 8% Public,13% Other (real Estate, Utilities, Insurance, etc.)
5
FINDINGS…THREE HABITSLeaders tend to balance the metrics they use tomanage productivity
WFM business process automation is what tendsto separate Leaders from Followers
Leaders look at technology as a multiplier toautomating their processes
Bonus - Leaders tend to use scheduling, absencemanagement and forecasting to overcomechallenges, especially ACA
THE ENVIRONMENT
7
WHAT DRIVES ORGANIZATIONS WHENMANAGING THEIR WORKFORCE
•Top Driver – Operational Efficiency
•Second Driver – Workforce Flexibility
•Third Driver – Access to labor data
•Fourth Driver – An oldie, but a goodie…labor costs
“We struggle with managing labor costs becauseour systems and processes are not flexible or agileenough to cope with our daily business changes…”~ Store Operations Manager - $1B Wholesaler/Retailer in US
PRODUCTIVITY ANALYSIS
9
Metrics Summary Leaders Followers
Workforce Capacity Utilization 97% 89%
Unplanned Overtime as % of all
overtime 5% 8%
Customer Satisfaction 97% 91%
Change in Revenue/FTE over last
year 18% 9%
Change in Profit/FTE over last year 17% 4%
Percent that made Sales Quota in
last year 91% 91%
ProductivityLeaders Lead and Haters Hate
10
PRODUCTIVITY PERFORMANCE
• Leaders Lead in almost every category
• Small differences in workforce utilization lead tobig differences in organizational performance.
• Workforce utilization linked to unplannedovertime
• Revenue and profits track well with leaders, butprofits lag revenue in Followers
11
MEASURING PRODUCTIVITYLeaders tend towards a balanced approach
12
MEASURING PRODUCTIVITY
• Top metric used – Revenue/FTE
• Leaders – Profit and Revenue almost equal
• A service economy – Service level is also key
• Sales Quota usage depends on type oforganization
13
MEASURING PRODUCTIVITY…ADEEPER LOOK
• Manufacturing and Utilities– Revenue/FTE,Profit/FTE
• Retail and Distribution– Profit/FTE, Service Level
• Government – Service Level, Mean-time toResolution
• Service – Profit/FTE, Service Level
Operational companies tend to use Revenue/FTEand service companies use profit
ENABLERS AND AUTOMATION
15
AUTOMATED LABOR MANAGEMENTPROCESSES
16
AUTOMATION OF WFM PROCESSES
• Time and Attendance is almost universal
• Big performance differentiator is scheduling andabsence management
• Analytics and forecasting are a coupleprocesses where Leaders think a little moreout-of-the-box.
• ACA challenges most impacted by automatingthe scheduling processes and forecasting
17© KRONOS INCORPORATED
ACA and Productivity
Pay or Play
Current FT/PTStaff with
Production Mix?
Measure andMonitor
Don’t Wait
Plan and EngageManagement
Reinforce GoodScheduling Habits
Timekeeping
Payroll
HR
Reporting
Current Strategy Act Now Integrated Data
1 2 3
When it comes to ACA administration, spreadsheets, home-grownreports, and manual calculations will do little to simplify a highlycomplex process with potentially significant financial consequences
18
AUTOMATION – IMPACT ON PRODUCTIVITY% = DIFFERENCE IN PERFORMANCE BETWEEN ORGANIZATIONS THAT AUTOMATED A
PROCESS AND THOSE THAT DIDN’T
* - Very little measureable difference or too few responses
** - Time & Attendance is almost universal in usage so no way to accurately measure impact
Productivity MeasuresSchedule
ManagementTime &
AttendanceAbsence/Leave
Management
What is the approximate current level of workforce capacityutilization within your company or organization?
3.0% N/A** 2.0%
What percent of your organization's annual overtime costs areunplanned / unbudgeted?
N/A* N/A** -33%
How has your organization's revenue per full-time equivalent (FTE*)CHANGED in the last 12 months?
15% N/A** 7.0%
How has your organization's profit per full-time equivalent (FTE*)CHANGED in the last 12 months?
N/A* N/A** 29%
What percent of your organization’s total sales quota for the last 12months was achieved?
1.5% N/A** 2.4%
What percent of your customer or constituent's concerns or issuesare resolved after their first inquiry?
N/A* N/A** 7.2%
19
AUTOMATION IMPACT
•Automation of all three critical businessprocesses has significant impact on revenue orprofit per FTE
•Automation of Schedule Management and Time& Attendance have a large impact on ACAchallenges
•Automation of Absence Management has avery positive impact on unscheduled overtimeand service levels.
TECHNOLOGY STRATEGIES
21
TECHNOLOGY AND WFM
Leaders lead in using technology to extendautomation
Leaders Followers
Integration between WFM
solutions70% 57%
Using or Plan on Using
Cloud59% 42%
Mobility in WFM 92% 69%
22
LEADING WITH TECHNOLOGY
•Leaders tend to realize that having siloed WFMsystems is not a good thing…big impact onanalytics and forecasting
•Leaders are also more likely to be lookingbeyond the usual data center approach totechnology and automation…cloud
•Mobility is almost universal amongst Leaders
!
WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT…
24
FINDINGS…THREE HABITSLeaders tend to balance the metrics they use tomanage productivity
WFM business process automation is what tendsto separate Leaders from Followers
Leaders look at technology as a multiplier toautomating their processes
Bonus - Leaders tend to use scheduling, absencemanagement and forecasting to overcomechallenges, especially ACA
25
WHAT YOU SHOULD DO… 3 STEPS TO TAKE
Automate as much of your WFM processes asyou can
Use a balanced scorecard approach likeLeaders…don’t focus on individual productivitymetrics
Use scheduling and absence management toaddress the challenges of ACA
Integrate your WFM systems and get at all thedata in those systems for decision-making
1
2
3
BONUSTIP:
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES
For more information on this or other researchtopics, please visit www.aberdeen.com
[email protected] /[email protected]
www.twitter.com/HCMEssentialsABG
www.linkedin.com/in/KevinProuty