1/25/2015 World Cup musings: Do India look like title defenders? - Cricbuzz

http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-series/cricket-news/69585/world-cup-musings-do-india-look-like-title-defenders 1/6

(https://plus.google.com/104502282508811467249)

ICC CRICKET WORLD CUP 2015

(/)

Home

(http://www.cricbuzz.com/)

Series ▼ ( javascript:void(0) )

World Cup 2015 (http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-series/2223/icc-cricket-world-cup-2015)

News ▼ (http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-news) Schedule (http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-schedule/series )

Archive (http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-scorecard-archives) Photos (http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-photo-gallery)

Rankings (http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-stats/icc-rankings)

Fantasy Cricket (https://fantasycricket.dream11.com/IN/?

utm_source=CricbuzzInd&utm_medium=cpa&utm_campaign=CBNavigation)

More ▼

Live Scores

(/cricket-

match/live-

scores)

RSA vs WI - Live (http://www.cricbuzz.com/live-cricket-scores/13619/rsa-vs-wi-4th-odi-west-indies-in-south-africa-

2014-15)

AUS vs IND - Preview (http://www.cricbuzz.com/live-cricket-scores/13850/aus-vs-ind-5th-match-india-and-england-in-

australia-tri-series-2015)

NZ vs SL - NZ Won (http://www.cricbuzz.com/live-cricket-scores/13811/nz-vs-sl-6th-odi-sri-lanka-tour-of-new-zealand-

2014-15)

Other Matches

(/scores-home-

domestic)

Big Bash League 2014-15 ▼ (/scores-home/2302/Big-Bash-League-2014-15)

World Cup musings: Do India look like titledefenders?New Delhi, Sun, Jan 25 2015

Shikhar Dhawan's form remains a big source of worry.

R Ashwin should be the premier spinner while Axar Patel should be persisted with.

The bowling department is India's biggest worry.

(https://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?

u=http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-

news/69585/world-cup-musings-do-

india-look-like-title-

defenders&text=World Cup musings:

Do India look like title defenders?)

(https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?

url=http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-

news/69585/world-cup-musings-

do-india-look-like-title-

defenders&text=World Cup

musings: Do India look like title

defenders?&via=cricbuzz)

(https://plus.google.com/share?

url=http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-

news/69585/world-cup-musings-

do-india-look-like-title-defenders)

1/25/2015 World Cup musings: Do India look like title defenders? - Cricbuzz

http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-series/cricket-news/69585/world-cup-musings-do-india-look-like-title-defenders 2/6

Shikhar Dhawan's poor form at the top is a major concern for India heading into the World Cup. © Agencies

India is definitely not looking the team that is capable of defending its world title. Plagued by injuries and a

rather ordinary bowling attack, there seems to be far too much dependence on Virat Kohli and the batting. Can

the Indians turn the tables in the biggest stage of all and can they salvage some pride in the remaining two

matches of the tri-series? Here's Boria Majumdar and Jamie Alter discussing the teams' chances in one of many

conversations that will continue right through the World Cup.

Boria- It certainly does not look good for a start. The crushing defeat against England has seriously affected

fans' faith. Nothing seems to be working. But you know what, India had a similar build up in 2003. The poor

performances in New Zealand prior to the World Cup acted like a wake up call and India did brilliantly in South

Africa. Do you think such a thing is a realistic proposition this time round?

Jamie- (Laughs). I like your optimism Boria, but I don't intend to think so far back. In fact, I don't look too far

ahead either. I am seriously skeptical that with the bowling attack at our disposal, how India fares in the World

Cup. The bowling doesn't look incisive at all and most of the bowlers are struggling with injuries. Make no

mistake; it is a serious cause for concern.

Boria- I agree but it's ODI cricket and as Rahul Dravid has suggested, three big days from our batsmen and we

can still retain the trophy. The format is such that India will make the quarters. After that, it is a matter of three

games isn't it? Anyway, let's talk about the combination- Shikhar Dhawan isn't getting any runs. In fact, he is

struggling. Would you continue with him or get Rahane and Rohit at the top for the start of the World Cup?

1/25/2015 World Cup musings: Do India look like title defenders? - Cricbuzz

http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-series/cricket-news/69585/world-cup-musings-do-india-look-like-title-defenders 3/6

Jamie- I'd rather get Rohit Sharma and Ajinkya Rahane once Rohit recovers from injury. Now that we have not

picked Vijay, we have limited options at the top. Multiple failures will further dent Shikhar's confidence and

there's no point getting an out of form batsman to play against Pakistan in a seriously high pressure game in

Adelaide. Rahane and Rohit are in good form and I'd want to start with them. Also, and this is most important,

I'd get Virat Kohli back at three. Every team has their best batter at three and India should be no different. Ricky

Ponting had won Australia many a match batting at three and Virat has an exceptional record batting at three.

Get him back to his best position and give him the maximum chance of winning you the match. This trying to

protect him at number four or trying to ensure he is there to manoeuvre once the new ball loses its shine

doesn't work for me. Also, there are two new balls these days so the balls will hardly lose their shine in the first

20 overs. What is your take about Virat at three?

Boria- I tend to agree with you. Sachin Tendulkar opened the batting for India in 2003 and had maximum

success. The initial thought was to bat him at No 4. Trying to protect your best is a defensive act. But the fact is,

he is your best because he has maximum talent and is the man to win you the most number of games. So I'd go

with you and say bring Virat back at three and make him as comfortable as possible.

Jamie- At four, five and six, I'd have Ambati Rayadu, Suresh Raina and MS Dhoni. There's hardly any option and

Dhoni and Raina are the two match winners we have. More importantly, I'd go with Axar Patel at 7 even if

Ravindra Jadeja recovers for Pakistan. Jadeja hasn't played any cricket at all for two months and to get him back

for the Pakistan game will be too big a risk. I can continue with Binny as well because he has shown glimpses of

talent in the England game but I'd not want to risk Jadeja.

Boria- I'd disagree on this. If possible, play Jadeja in at least one of the warm up matches, we play Afghanistan

on 10 February, and get him match ready. Axar's batting is a serious concern and Jadeja brings stability at

number 7. Else the tail becomes too long and Dhoni too gets constrained in trying to accelerate. I think the most

important selection conundrum for India at the moment is the number 7 slot. I agree with your point about

Binny, but for me, it's Jadeja at seven and only if you can't play him should you think of Binny.

Jamie- Against Pakistan, it's Ashwin who is my first choice as spinner. He bats better and has the experience of

the big stage and then, I will opt for the three quicks in Mohd Shami, Bhuvneshwar Kumar and Umesh Yadav.

Umesh has that X-factor and I still prefer him over Ishant despite not bowling at his best.

Boria- I agree. Someone who can bowl the way he did against Australia at the death is an enigma of sorts. How

can he be pedestrian in the very next game again? That's where the coach and the management need to talk to

him. But I agree with the bowling line-up. Ashwin surely has to be the first spinner.

Jamie- All said and done it's a very tough ask, you know, when you think of some of the other teams like

Australia, South Africa and New Zealand and the way they are playing.

© Cricbuzz

Comments

1/25/2015 World Cup musings: Do India look like title defenders? - Cricbuzz

http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-series/cricket-news/69585/world-cup-musings-do-india-look-like-title-defenders 4/6

Facebook social plugin

Also post on Facebook Posting as Nakul Surana ▾ Comment

Add a comment...

Sundaram Thiagarajan · Top commenter

I want India to defend World Cup successfully. That is my wish as an Indian. But based onform and performance as a team so far, India does not deserve to win nor has the requisite"wholesome" fire power in terms of batting and bowling to win in alien conditions (despitethe fact, the pitches have been more Indian friendly). May be, just as Sachin was Man of theWC Tournament (while India failed as a team), Kholi could win Man of the Tournament titlebut do not see India winning the cup.

Reply · Like · Follow Post · about an hour ago

Being Keshab Khanal · · Marketing Manager at Not at all

no doubt India still is a favorite to win the world cup but concern point is that how quicklytheir batsman( specially their opening pair) find the form and how their bowlers(specially indeath overs) cope with pressure.

Reply · Like · Follow Post · 5 hours ago

Follow

Biju Varghese · Works at Compass Group Australia

are you serious really buddy !!! after seeing India's performance in Australia. Notwon a single match in 2 months ?? kidding me

Reply · Like · 3 hours ago

Devarajan Doraiswamy · Works at Self-Employed

To enter 2nd round India must beat 2 team out of three namely WI, Pak and SA. Presentform suggests SA are formidable to India Chris Gayle will demolish Indian bowling

Reply · Like · Follow Post · about an hour ago

Prasanna Chellappan ·

INDIAN TEAM IS MY FAVOURITE BUT REALISTIC CHANCES OF A WIN IS QUITE LOW

Reply · Like · Follow Post · 2 hours ago

Follow

Latest News

(/cricket-series/cricket-news/69594/bailey-hopes-to-end-form-slump)

Bailey hopes to end form slump

(/cricket-series/cricket-news/69593/4th-odi-millers-maiden-ton-takes-sa-to-2628)

4th ODI: Miller's maiden ton takes SA to 262/8

1/25/2015 World Cup musings: Do India look like title defenders? - Cricbuzz

http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-series/cricket-news/69585/world-cup-musings-do-india-look-like-title-defenders 5/6

(/cricket-series/cricket-news/69592/jayasuriya-unhappy-with-sls-wc-preparations)

Jayasuriya unhappy with SL's WC preparations

(/cricket-series/cricket-news/69590/drs-under-the-scanner-in-dunedin)

DRS under the scanner in Dunedin

(/cricket-series/cricket-news/69589/wc-countdown-19-rain-to-pakistans-rescue)

WC Countdown #19 - Rain to Pakistan's rescue

(/cricket-series/cricket-news/69588/ms-dhoni-my-name-keeps-popping-up)

My name keeps popping up

More News (/cricket-news)

1/25/2015 World Cup musings: Do India look like title defenders? - Cricbuzz

http://www.cricbuzz.com/cricket-series/cricket-news/69585/world-cup-musings-do-india-look-like-title-defenders 6/6

© 2015 Cricbuzz.com, Times Internet Limited . All rights reserved | The Times of India

He was dropped last match. Now he gets to 50 off

49 balls and is keeping his side in the game.

Sammy thrilling the PE crowd. #savwi

Cricbuzz

@cricbuzz

Expand

Amidst the carnage at the other end, Marlon

Samuels brings up his 24th ODI fifty with a

crunching off-drive. WI: 118/5. #wivsa

Cricbuzz

@cricbuzz

Expand

Samuels was upset after Carter turned down an

easy run. It's the turn of his partner now, as he is

left hopelessly stranded. WI:73/5. #SAvWI

Cricbuzz

@cricbuzz

6m

36m

1h

Tweets Follow

Tweet to @cricbuzz