Written Arguments in Favour of Defendant Where Identification of Property in Dispute

7/28/2019 Written Arguments in Favour of Defendant Where Identification of Property in Dispute

1/29


2/29

FI QMH OCXWQ CD OFTF@ NXABH -NW AI& EIA NJDO OCXWQEQ

BXGGF

C)_) 7;8#7;;1

[@EFIQFDD T_ AHDHIAEIQ_

JE@@EFEM $ CW_ _EIIEXBWEFEM $ CW_

RWFQQHI EWBXJHIQ_ DF@HA GV OCXI_H@ DCW @W_ CD A*7

GE_FO [@HEAFIB_ CD [@EFIQFDD

5) _uft prhshitha ci 5?*57*7;;1)7) Oeush cd eotfci aeth e``hbha fi pèfit fs tmh aeth cd df`fib cd suft fi C_ 5?6#7;;1 -?5*

;=*7;;1& eia e`sc ghdcrh 57*55*7;;1)

?) Wh`fhds oèfjha erh Ahoèretfci $ [hrjeihit Finuiotfci)1) _uft somhau`h prcphrty fs Ebrfou`ture` èia fi survhy iujghr =5#5G jhesurfib 5

eorh esshssha et Ws 5*5; sftuetha fi Ie`ùr Breje, Omhùr Mcg`f, Buggf Qeùl

Gcuiaha gy Hest>* Acaaejutmeppe s#c omflleiie, Rhst>* $ _cutm>* Hhreiie s#c

Buiaefem, Icrtm>* Gesevefem s#c leèfem)

8) _uft somhau`h prcphrty wes puromesha gy pèfitfdds detmhr Leèfem fi 5? *;6*5648drcj ahdhiaeit ic*5 eia mfs detmhr)

4) [mysfoe` pcsshssfci eia hincyjhit drcj tmh aeth cd se`h tc aeth cd df`fib cd suftp`heaha)

2) Auh tc f``fthreoy pèfitfdd p`heas tc mevh ict epprceomha eutmcrftfhs dcr omeibh filetme)

=) Oc`ùsfci cd ahdhiaeit 5 eia 7 e``hbha)6) Hddcrt jeah gy ahdhiaeits oc`ùsfvh`y tc cgtefi ahorhh fi C_ 5?6#7;;1 tc omeibh

letme fi tmh iejh cd ahdhiaeit*5 e``hbha)

5;)Etthjptha afspcsshssfci cd suft somhau`h prcphrty gy ahdhiaeits e``hbha, -hxeotaeth ict p`heaha,& mcwhvhr fi quctfib oeush suom etthjpt fs hxpèfiha tc mevhcoourrha ci cr ghdcrh 57*55*7;;1)

55)Ahife` cd tft`h e``hbha tc mevh ghhi jeah ci cr ghdcrh 57*55*7;;157)Oeush cd eotfci e``hbha tc mevh ghhi coourrha fi Ie`ùr Breje)

GE_FO [@HEAFIB_ CD A*5 -56*;?*7;;8&


3/29

5) E`` tmh p`heafibs cd pèfit fs ahifha gy ahdhiaeit ic)5 wmc ci`y mevh sfbiha fiwrftthi stethjhit)

7) Qmh tft`h cd suft somhau`h prcphrty wftm ahdhiaeit*5 eia mfs detmhr fs ahifhasphofdfoe``y)

?) Qmh tft`h cd suft somhau`h prcphrty fs oèfjha tc gh`cib crfbfie``y tc cih Aeseiie cdIe`ùmettf vf`èbh -breia detmhr cd gctm ahdhiaeits&) Edthr mfs ahetm 7ia ahdhiaeit

suoohhaha) Letme fs oèfjha tc mevh ghhi jeah ci pevetmf veres tc ahdhiaeit*7)

1) Edthr tmh ahetm cd detmhrs cd gctm ahdhiaeits tmh suft somhau`h prcphrty fs oèfjha tcmevh ghhi cre``y afvfaha eia bct suom smerh tc ahdhiaeit*5-?; yhers geol&

8) A*5 oèfjs tc mevh epp`fha dcr omeibh cd letme tc Qemsfàer eia p`heas tc mevhphiafib)

4) Oèfjs tmet 5st ahdhiaeit fs fi eotue` pcsshssfci eia hincyjhit cd somhau`hprcphrty)

F__XH_ DWEJHA CI ;2*;1*7;;8 GV QMH OCXWQ

5) [èfitfdd tc prcvh tmet ahdhiaeit *5 eia mfs detmhr Hhrefem mes hxhoutha se`h ahha ci5?*;6*5648 eia scà tmh suft prcphrty tc pèfitfdd detmhr leèfem dcr èwdu``

ocisfahretfci)

7) [èfitfdd tc prcvh tmet tmhy erh fi èwdu` pcsshssfci hincyjhit cvhr suft prcphrty esci tmh aeth cd df`fib cd suft)

?) [èfitfdds tc prcvh tmh f``hbe` fithrdhrhioh gy ahdhiaeits)1) Ahdhiaeits tc prcvh tmh `fjftetfci pcfit)8) Ahdhiaeits tc prcvh tmet tmrcubm cre` pertftfci tmrhh ahoeahs geol suft prcphrty

de``hi tc tmh smerh cd A*5)

4) Rmhtmhr [èfitfdds erh hitft`ha dcr rh`fhd es preyha dcr 3

GE_FO [@HEAFIB_ CD @W_ CD A*7 -;1*55*7;5;&

5) Hitfrh p`heafibs cd pèfitfdd fs afsputha eia ahifha)7) Qmh B*Qrhh cd Ahdhiaeits eiohsthrs hxpèfiha wftm oèrfty)?) _fx scis cd detmhr cd ahdhiaeits fioùafib A*5 eia A*7 afvfaha cre``y tmh survhy

iujghr =5 tmh tcte` hxthit cd wmfom 2 eorhs 2 buites)

1) Cih Jeaefem s#c Aeseiie bct 5 eorh ;1 buites smerh fi suom survhy iujghr eiascà ft tc Buiaefem -A*7& ci 78*;8*5686 tmrcubm rhbfsthrha se`h ahha dcr veùeg`h

ocisfahretfci)

8) Ici ncfiahr cd ihohssery perty tmh dhje`h mhfr -aeubmthr& cd A*7 e``hbha)4) Qmh tft`h cd vhiacrs cd pèfitfdd fs afsputha eia o`her`y ahifha)2) _ugshquhit ahvh`cpjhit cd f``hbe` omeibh cd rhvhiuh letme fi 7;;2*;= eia fts

ome``hibh ghdcrh rhvhiuh eutmcrftfhs rhsu`tha fi stey e``hbha)


4/29

=) [èfitfdds pcsshssfci cd suft prcphrty ahifha eia afsputha)6) Whvhiuh rhocras steiafib uiafsputha drcj `cib phrfca eia wftm `hbe` d`cw cd ve`fa

tft`h tc ahdhiaeits oèfjha)

5;)Gcuiaerfhs cd suft somhau`h afsputha, fahitfdfoetfci cd prcphrty ftsh`d afsputha)55)Oèfjha tc mevh Gcrhwh`` eia ocociut trhhs ebha 1; *18 yhers fi tmh suft somhau`h

èia)

57)Qmh gcuiaerfhs cd _y)ic) =5#5G es jctfciha fi pèfit afsputha eia ocithiaha tmethxthit cd 5 eorh ;1 buites fi tmet survhy iujghr fs oèfjha tc mevh gcuiaerfhs

tcweras Hest * @eia cd =5#5E gh`cibfib tc A*7, Rhst * _mfveiie s#c

omfollesfaaefem, Icrtm * [èfitfdds prcphrty, _cutm * s)l) vhileteomeèsmhttys

prcphrty -Weneiie s#c ghtteppe&

F__XH_ DWEJHA CI ;7*;4*7;55

5) [èfitfdd tc prcvh tmet tmhy erh tmh egscùth cwihr cvhr suft somhau`h prcphrty)7) [èfitfdd tc prcvh tmet tmhy erh fi èwdu` pcsshssfci cvhr suft somhau`h prcphrty es

ci tmh aeth cd suft)

?) [èfitfdds tc prcvh tmh e``hbha fithrdhrhioh gy ahdhiaeits)1) Rmhtmhr [èfitfdds erh hitft`ha dcr rh`fhd es preyha dcr 3

ACOXJHIQ_ CD [@EFIQFDD_ EIA FQ_ WH@HTEIOH

IC H]MFGFQ EIA [EWQFOX@EW_ WH@HTEIOH EIA FJ[CWQEIQ QMFIB_ QC CG_HWTH

5 H]*[5 OHWQFDFHA OC[V CD _E@H AHHAAEQHA 5?*;6*5648

JEIAE@IE AE_EIIE_ _CI HHWEFEM

EIA MF_ _CI _EIIE XBWE RWFQQHI QCMETH H]HOXQHA _E@H AHHA FI DETCXW

CD LE@EFEM _#C JE@EFEM)_E@H F_ FI WH_[HOQ QC _V)IC) =5#5

H]QHIQ 5 EOWHGCXIAEWFH_>*

H* OMFOLEIIE_ @EIA

R* BXIAEFEM_ @EIA

I* LE@EFEM_ @EIA

_* BXIAEFEM_ @EIA

OCI_FAHWEQFCI UXCQHA* W_ ?;;#*@QJ CD HHWEFEM, _EIIEXBWE, EIA

RFQIH__ _FAAE[[E -DEQMHW IEJH ICQ

JHIQFCIHA& BXIAEFEM -DEQMHW IEJHICQ JHIQFCIHA&

JEWLHA RFQM CGNHOQFCI

Rmhi Acoujhit fs jerlha wftm cgnhotfci pèfitfdd mes tc prcvh

tmh hxhoutfci cd acoujhit gy hxejfifib prcphr wftihss) Rmhihxhoutfci ftsh`d fs afsputha ft fs gcuiahi auty cd pèfitfdd tc

shia tmh crfbfie` acoujhit dcr te``yfib sfbieturh cd A*5 fi tmhacoujhit wmfom fs ict acih gy pèfitfdd) [èfitfdd fs ict af`fbhit

fi prcshoutfib tmh oesh)

Es phr rhvhiuh rhocras prcauoha gy tmh ahdhiaeit wmhi es ci

tmh aeth cd tmfs se`h ahha tmh survhy iujghr =5#5 fs pmcaha

wey geol fi 5647 es =5#5E eia =5#5G, tmh fahitfdfoetfci cd

prcphrty ftsh`d fs fi afsputh)

Qmh Gcuiaerfhs erh e`sc uiahr afsputh wmhi ocjperha tc

=5#5G prcphrty es hxfstha fi 5686 ftsh`d) Mhioh ft oei gh hesf`y

prhujha drcj suom deots tmet pèfitfdd mes ict puromesha =5#5G

es ci 5?*;6*5648)

Jcrhcvhr pèfitfdd mes ict prcauoha e pfhoh cd pephr crhxejfiha eiy fiahphiahit wftihss tc smcw mfs vhiacrs tft`h tc

sy)ic)=5#5G mhioh tmh prcphrty jhitfciha fi tmfs se`h ahha

afddhrs drcj tmh oèfj jeah fi suft somhau`h prcphrty, mhioh

pèfitfdd def`ha tc prcauoh mfs hxeot tft`h ahha dcr suft somhau`h

prcphrty)

7 H]*[7

WQO 7;;8*;4

_V)IC) =5#5G

H]QHIQ 5 EOWH ;1 BXIQE_

Qmfs acoujhit ihftmhr smcws pèfitfdd tft`h cr pcsshssfci icr ft

smcws ve`fa d`cw cd `hbe` tft`h eia pcsshssfci mhioh acoujhit

oei gh cd ic ush tc pèfitfdd) _fioh tmh acoujhit fs fi tmh iejh

cd A*7 tmh prhsujptfci cd hitry uiahr Lerietele èia rhvhiuh

eot shotfci 5?? fs ict rhgutha hftmhr gy tmfs acoujhit, crtmrcubm eiy ocbhit eia rh`feg`h hvfahioh)

? H]*[?

WQO 7;;?*;1

_V)IC) =5#5GH]QHIQ 5 EOWH ;1 BXIQE_

Qmfs acoujhit ihftmhr smcws pèfitfdd tft`h cr pcsshssfci icr ft

smcws ve`fa d`cw cd `hbe` tft`h eia pcsshssfci mhioh acoujhit

oei gh cd ic ush tc pèfitfdd) _fioh tmh acoujhit fs fi tmh iejhcd A*7 tmh prhsujptfci cd hitry uiahr Lerietele èia rhvhiuh


5/29

eot shotfci 5?? fs ict rhgutha hftmhr gy tmfs acoujhit, cr

tmrcubm eiy ocbhit eia rh`feg`h hvfahioh)

1 H]*[1

WWQ -AF_& 65*;1*;8 CWAHW OC[V

Qmfs crahr fs quesmha es phr H]*A*?8, Qmfs crahr fs gesha ci

cih _urvhy pephr wmfom fs jerlha es H]*[5;, wmfom ethr dcuia

tc gh delh rhocra es phr hiacrshjhit prcauoha fi H]*A14, eia

sugshquhit rhjeia crahr es pessha fi H]*A*?8) Mhioh tmh

acoujhit ihftmhr smcws pèfitfdd tft`h cr pcsshssfci icr ftsmcws ve`fa d`cw cd `hbe` tft`h eia pcsshssfci mhioh acoujhitoei gh cd ic ush tc pèfitfdd)

8 H]*[8JW 45#7;;2*;=

Qmfs JW fs iu`` eia vcfa es phr crahrs prcauoha fi H]*A?8,mhioh tmfs acoujhit ihftmhr smcws pèfitfdd tft`h cr pcsshssfciicr ft smcws ve`fa d`cw cd `hbe` tft`h eia pcsshssfci mhioh

acoujhit oei gh cd ic ush tc pèfitfdd)

4 H]*[4

WQO 7;;2*;=

Qmfs hitrfhs fi WQO fs iu`` eia vcfa es phr crahrs prcauoha fi

H]*A?8, mhioh tmfs acoujhit ihftmhr smcws pèfitfdd tft`h crpcsshssfci icr ft smcws ve`fa d`cw cd `hbe` tft`h eia pcsshssfci

mhioh acoujhit oei gh cd ic ush tc pèfitfdd)

2 H]*[2

DCWJ*58_XG*WHBF_QWEW BXGGF

FI _XWTHV IXJGHW =5#5AEQHA 54*;5*7;;=

Qmh Dcrj 58 fs rhètha tc survhy iujghr =5#5 eia es suom

survhy iujghr fs ict fi hxfsthioh aurfib 5648, tmh DCWJ 58eia fts hitrfhs ihftmhr smcws pèfitfdd tft`h cr pcsshssfci icr ft

smcws ve`fa d`cw cd `hbe` tft`h eia pcsshssfci mhioh acoujhitoei gh cd ic ush tc pèfitfdd)

= H]*[=QE] [EFA WHOHF[Q

56*;6*7;;1

[EFA FI QMH IEJH CD BXIAEFEM

Qmfs rhocra fs cd tmh crfbfi cd nust ghdcrh df`fib cd suft) Qmhacoujhit fs cd evef` tc prcvh mfs pcsshssfci drcj 5648) Qc

cgvfeth gfes, tmh acoujhits just mevh ghhi prcauoha wmfom

jeah eith `fthj jctej, wmfom jheis ict jhrh`y ghdcrh tmh

ocjjhiohjhit cd `hbe` prcohhafibs, gut ghdcrh hvhi tmh

hxfsthioh cd eiy eotue` ocitrcvhrsy, ociohrifib tmh sugnhot

jetthr cd tmh suft)

6 H]*[6

MF__E QF[[EIF IELE@

CD _V)IC) =5#5GF__XH AEQH 7=*;?*7;;2

JEWLHA RFQM CGNHOQFCI Qmhrh fs ic hitrfhs rhètha tc

pèfitfdd iejh fi suom rhocra eia mhioh ft ihftmhr smcws

pèfitfdd tft`h cr pcsshssfci icr ft smcws ve`fa d`cw cd `hbe` tft`heia pcsshssfci mhioh acoujhit oei gh cd ic ush tc pèfitfdd)

5; H]*[5;

DCWJ 55H[WH[EWHA GV @FOHI_HA _XWTHVCW

CD _V)IC) =5#5GAEQHA 7=*;1*7;;1

JEWLHA RFQM CGNHOQFCI Qmfs fs e degrfoetha rhocra es phr

H]*A?8 $ H]*A14, pèfitfdd ihftmhr afso`cshs wmc prhperha tmfseia ic cih fs hxejfiha fi tmet ghme`d tc prcvh fts eutmhitfofty

tmfs acoujhit, mhioh ft ihftmhr smcws pèfitfdd tft`h crpcsshssfci icr ft smcws ve`fa d`cw cd `hbe` tft`h eia pcsshssfci


55 H]*[55

B*QWHHRWFQQHI CI FIDCWJEQFCI BFTHI GV

CIH _)L) HHWEIIE

AEQHA> IF@@

JEWLHA RFQM CGNHOQFCI Qmh phrsci wmc ahpcsha suom B*

trhh ghdcrh cddfohr fs ict ghfib hxejfiha eia tmh eutmhitfofty fse`sc uiahr afsputh wmhi ocjperha wftm eajfssfcis cd pèfitfdd

eia A*5) Qmh acoujhit fs ahvcfa cd aeth) Ft fs e`sc wh`` shtt`ha

tmet stethjhits cr ahoèretfcis ghdcrh phrscis cd ocjphthit

licw`habh jeah eith `fthj jctej erh rhohfveg`h tc prcvh

eiofhit rfbmts cd e pug`fo cr bhihre` ieturh) Qmh eajfssfgf`fty cdsuom ahoèretfcis fs, mcwhvhr, ocisfahreg`y whelhiha fd ft

phrtefis ict tc pug`fo rfbmts gut tc purh`y prfveth rfbmts) Ft fs

hque``y wh`` shtt`ha tmet ahoèretfcis cr stethjhits jeah pcst`fthj jctej wcuà ict gh eajfssfg`h ghoeush fi oeshs cr

prcohhafibs telhi cr ahoèretfcis jeah eith `fthj jctej, tmhh`hjhit cd gfes eia ociocotfci fs h`fjfietha)

57 H]*[57C)_) IC) 4;#7;;2

CWAHW _MHHQ

Qmhrh fs ic p`heafibs fi rhsphot tc suom rhocra eia tmhrh fsevhrjhits fi eddfaevft) Mhioh acoujhit oeiict gh cd mh`p tc

pèfitfdd) Qmh H]*A?2 prcauoha gy ahdhiaeit smcws phiafib

jfs oesh dcr fts rhstcretfci) Qmh pèfitfdds oesh fs ict prcvha

wftm suom acoujhits

5? H]*[5?

C)_) IC) 4;#7;;2

[@EFIQ

**

51 H]*[51

CWFBFIE@ _E@H AHHA E_ JHIQFCIHA FIH]*[5

Rmhi hxhoutfci ftsh`d fs afsputha ft fs gcuiahi auty cd pèfitfdd

tc shia tmh crfbfie` acoujhit dcr te``yfib sfbieturh cd A*5 fitmh acoujhit wmfom fs ict acih gy pèfitfdd) [èfitfdd fs ict

af`fbhit fi prcshoutfib tmh oesh)

Es phr rhvhiuh rhocras prcauoha gy tmh ahdhiaeit wmhi es ci

tmh aeth cd se`h ahha tmh survhy iujghr =5#5 fs pmcaha wey

geol fi 5647 es =5#5E eia =5#5G, tmh fahitfdfoetfci cd prcphrty

ftsh`d fs fi afsputh) Qmh Gcuiaerfhs erh e`sc uiahr afsputh wmhi

ocjperha tc =5#5G prcphrty es hxfstha fi 5686 ftsh`d) Mhioh ft

oei gh hesf`y prhsujha drcj suom deots tmet pèfitfdd mes ictpuromesha =5#5G es ci 5?*;6*5648)

Jcrhcvhr pèfitfdd mes ict prcauoha e pfhoh cd pephr tc smcw

mfs vhiacrs tft`h tc sy)ic)=5#5G mhioh tmh prcphrty jhitfciha

fi tmfs se`h ahha afddhrs drcj tmh oèfj jeah fi suft somhau`h

prcphrty, mhioh pèfitfdd def`ha tc prcauoh mfs hxeot tft`h ahha


6/29

dcr suft somhau`h prcphrty)

58 H]*[58

WQO 7;5;*7;55

_V)IC) =5#5G

Qmfs hitrfhs fi WQO fs iu`` eia vcfa es phr crahrs prcauoha fi

H]*A?8, mhioh tmfs acoujhit ihftmhr smcws pèfitfdd tft`h cr

pcsshssfci icr ft smcws ve`fa d`cw cd `hbe` tft`h eia pcsshssfci


54 H]*[54

QE] [EFA WHOHF[QAEQHA 54*55*7;55

Qmh acoujhit fs cd rhohit crfbfi ft ihftmhr prcvhs eiy wey tmh

oesh cd pèfitfdd

GWFHD [CFIQ_ CD DEOQ_ FI OMFHD HTFAHIOH CD [@EFIQFDD [R5 JE@@EFEM>* -56*;5*7;;4&

5) _uft somhau`h prcphrty fs Ebrfou`ture` èia fi survhy iujghr =5#5G tcte``yjhesurfib 5 eorh ;1 buites, sftuetha fi Ie`ùr Breje, Omhùr Mcg`f, Buggf Qeùl

Gcuiaha gy Hest>*Acaaejutmfem s#c omflleiie, Rhst>* $ _cutm>* Hhreiie s#cBuiaefem, Icrtm>* Gesevefem s#c leèfem)

7) _uft somhau`h prcphrty wes puromesha gy pèfitfdds detmhr Leèfem fi 5? *;6*5648drcj ahdhiaeit ic*5 eia mfs detmhr Hhrefem)

?) [csshssfci eia hincyjhit cd somhau`h prcphrty drcj tmh aeth cd se`h wftm Leèfem)1) [csshssfci eia hincyjhit cd _omhau`h prcphrty edthr tmh ahetm cd Leèfem wftm

pèfitfdds

8) Oc`ùsfci cd ahdhiaeit 5 eia 7 e``hbha)4) Hddcrt jeah gy ahdhiaeits oc`ùsfvh`y tc cgtefi ahorhh fi C_ 5?6#7;;1 tc omeibh

letme fi tmh iejh cd ahdhiaeit*5 e``hbha)

2) Ahdhiaeits supprhssha tmh deots cd se`h ahha aetha 5?*;6*5648 eia pèfitfddspcsshssfci eia fithiaha tc ahdreua pèfitfdds)

=) Ic rfbmts eia pcsshssfci cd suft somhau`h prcphrty wftm ahdhiaeits swherha)6) 7ia Ahdhiaeit df`ha oesh ebefist [R5 fi C_ 4;#;2 eia tmh oesh afsjfssha acoujhits

prcauoha tc smcw ft)

[@EFIQFDD_ ETHWWJHIQ_ AHDHEQFIB MF_ CRI OE_H

E_ v [ b L vbvz)q*5, 5=*;?*7;;6 b i [Ef

Xvb) * X DX 18

)q*5 W U ^bu ftvbz 56*;5*7;;4 b O 14 Nvb)

)q*5 bb 5?*57*7;;1 b b zvz 18 vb)

Hz UEf bE[ vvbvz)

)q*5 v 56*;5*7;;4 b W ^buEfz w J` t 5 N[b ;1 XEj b X[ fqvb)

)q*5 v 5?*57*7;;1 b z vz 5 N[b

;1 XEj Hbz wzr vb ;?*5;*7;;6 b

v [ X Ub _XEf XEzz Hzb)


7/29

wzr Od 5 N[b [ vb

)q*5 v 5=*;?*7;;6 b i zq v v> wX vv ztXnz NEz OXEfvb)

wX XTbvz NzOXEfvb)

X fr[EqX 5 wX z vEbvz Nz

_v t X 5 w [ UbvbNz n)

wEfb vvEb X Eb X X

Xwb)

N)[) Dbt v w X Ob EnXEEzs Hb)

z w X wX bz Ab Ab i[bt zWzb Nz

z v 5 v 7 wEfb q AzX 5 wX Ebvz NEz z

nEf)

wEfb vv ztX 4 E [)

f[b f[v J[)v Eqb X X Ev NEz rEXEffX UEf AX f EffEf[w Efwb) Oz wEvEffz zW f EffEf[ab r)

w 5 v 7 bb Tzb NEz Abvb) Tzz aATz _v t fr[ EffEf[ Eff[ bUv _v zuXJEz bb Od [izb Uv, NEf OEz X bu H)

7 wEf n _v HzX _vzuX a bEzbNzbEf Ef nEf Effz UEf Hz Nz OnXvz)

w 7 bb bzbb [ib Uv zWX Azsbz zzbw*5 v X Tbz`[ v Hz)

5 wEf b Ub i 5wX z v Ez N BzzEfwEfb vEzX J Hb [ NEzi [vb, J 4 a [NE v b[vb) 4 a [ NEv UnX v 5 wX wzbOz bf^ Efwbvb) Hz XO[ fr[q NEz nzTbvz)

w*5 bb q[Ef XEf fq Ox w*7 bnX fq Ox A Ib nEz XWnzb NE zEvz O[fr[qz[ w*5 bb Ubw*7 bb JXEf rEX EffXUEffT EfX qEfz [ vnbz[ b Tbvz) -z n` jEj 5 w fv frbzXz&

)q*5 E[ ;2*;5*7;57 b 7 wEfbzbb Ubz N)d) bbiz Eb =5-& t X Xw)

zn Eb v> EffnX nbvz NEzX Xw)

Eb =5 v> Ez BbsEzEfX bvEzb nEf)

Efb v z vz [v, zw [v, ^nv v ^[EEf X U

rEf O UEf -Rmhtmhr mh fs e

ocjphthit wftihss* Ic&) * O * UEfvX [ W^bz X [ XzXX Xw Xw Nz Xzb,Av U Ov vnvz

Ef z vz W OEXX X

Xw NE Bvb qvb)


8/29

EzEf X zt NEzb X Xw)

ztX 5 X EfbEf 7 X BXEf,b X zEf, 1 X DbEf, 8 XXEqEf, 4 X t BXEf NEzb X Xw)

Eb =5 qTbz X Xw)

Eb =5# DX 1; z EzqTbvz) vEzEf nX ATbvz) DXzW z) vEz nX ATb it A[b Ez zb )[ bv)

Eb =5 J` t 5; N[b 5 XEjNEzb X Xw)

Eb =5 b J` ^[E X Xw)

z E)X EEzEv 5642 nEz 7;;2bbX Effz tX EffEfzb NEzb X Xw)

58 b X N) EffEfz vqEffhrbvbEzb X Xw)

1; z Ez z v t BXEfv XEqEf [qEz [Ef[ qbv)

XEqEf [Ef v[ ba fr NEzb nEf)

wEfb E[ 78*;8*84 bEz z v[Ef[ qbvbEzb X Xw)

zEfEz 7 wEf [Ef[ qbvOz X Xw)

58*55*5645 b zt X XEqEf nXqTbvz NEzb X Xw)

O û[T f[b Hb NEzbnEfvb) zX r*5 bb Ub[zX zt Effb NEz z U EvbXwvb)

Eb qTbz XwvbXEf Ob vEz nX 1; z EzqTv Nvb) it O[b Ezzb wEf Effb nX ATz NB[z zWEf v vEz nXqTz Oz ab rz Nvb) Ab)i, ab r NwzEv Xwvb)

rEX, W^bu v E

i v ziEf zw 5 v 7 bnEz v WnbzTvb)

Xw N z Bvb Effz OhEzAX O[bvEf XvEzXbz Hbz Xz) Effzv X nEvz Oz nEfEzOx Eznz BvbEz Effz vX n Ez Oz[ XwEz

hn [ Uzb q[ XUbvz)

)q*5 E[ 72*;5*7;57 b 7 wEfbzbb Ubz N)d) bbi Eb =5#5N J` t 2 N[b 2 XEjHbvzEzb Xw)

Eb =5#5N tz ? N[b 8 XEj

` zEf HbvbEzb Xw) B[a w z HzbEzb Xw)

z v Effb [Ef[ bz[ibvbEzbX Xw)

) 58 b 1 XE wEf nX HbvzEzbn) ) 7, ? = zX wEfnbvEzb nEf)

z v _ a) z wwEfnX nz vET b v [

Xw, Xw N z zW AzsnvXX Oz v wn[XzEAÊf Bvnb UEf, JEz Evz) 58 b 1 XEj Hbz Jvb, OzOb zWX wEf nz NzOXEfvb)

b zWX z w vET

Tq [ Hbzb zX Ab)i)Ef Hzb [q z v _ vNvb) Eznz wX aOX H Nvb) OEzb z w vETb v [ wXz NEzJvb)z v bz[`bb Nz Êfwvb v v Ub vbAz[ Ob OdEf ATbX Oz

v Effb UEz e[


9/29

HbvzEzb nEf, UEf v> wXa HbzEz rEfvb)z wX EEzEv nX _v tHb) vEz nX Hb [EzEf bw

v tEf ab r NEzb nEf)

) 5; O vEffn OdEf [ib) )))) )) Effb Od [i)

Efwvb) D Nbq EvzEf qEfbz qb h UEf q[Efvnbvz)

D N q[Ef UEf E[X

OEz v EffEf[ vbf^vbEz nzTz, AvU v rEX X Ezt[ HT,rEX b ^b UEfnT, Eznz buEf bTU U[nT f EffEf znUEf wbnzTbvz)

[@EFIQFDD_ [@HEAFIB_, HTFAHIOH EIA ACOXJHIQ_ EIE@V_HA>*

5) Qmh pèfitfdd def`s tc sey fi tmh hvfahioh tmh deot cd ahife` cd tft`h eia fithrdhrhioh fipcsshssfci) [`heafibs wftmcut prccd oeiict gh `cclha fitc eia tmh oeush cd eotfci

ftsh`d ict prcvha fi eiy jeiihr)

7) Hxeot aeths cd oeush cd eotfci eia sphofdfo p`heafibs eia prccd fs strfot`y èolfib fihitfrh pèfitfdd oesh)

?)

[èfitfdd def`s tc prcauoh jeiy acoujhitery hvfahioh evefèg`h rhètha tc tmh suftsomhau`h prcphrty) Qmhrh fs supprhssfci cd trutm ghdcrh tmh ocurt)

1) [èfitfdd def`s tc prcauoh eiy eith aetha afsputh rhètha acoujhit tc prcvh mfsvhrsfci)

8) [èfitfdd def`s tc hxpèfi mfs cwi oesh wftm eooureth rhescis, rhètha tc fahitfty cdprcphrty, vhiacrs tft`h, gcuiaerfhs wftm eooureoy, mfs e`hrtihss fi omholfib

eithohahit tft`h cd vhiacr es rhqufrha uiahr shotfci 88 cd Qreisdhr cd

prcphrty eot)

4) [èfitfdd mes ict prcauoha eiy hioujgreioh ohrtfdfoeth cr rhvhiuh acoujhitswmfom fs cgtefiha es ci tmh aeth cd puromesh tc omhol cut tmh tft`h cd vhiacr)

2) [èfitfdd mes ict prcauoha eiy acoujhit tc smcw es ci tmh aeth cd puromesh tmhsurvhy iujghr eia gcuiaerfhs jhitfciha whrh fi hxfsthioh)

=) [èfitfdd utthr`y def`s fi mfs oesh tc prcvh pcsshssfci, tft`h eia fahitfty cd prcphrty tcbht eiy typh cd rh`fhd)

6) [èfitfdd wftmcut hxejfifib eiy rh`hveit wftihss eia prcauofib eiy rh`hveitacoujhits mevh def`ha fi mfs oesh)

AHDHIAEIQ_ AR5 H]EJFIEQFCI FI OMFHD [CFIQ_ CD WH@HTEIOH -58*;?*7;57&

5) Ihftmhr tmh pèfitfdd icr tmhfr detmhr puromesha 5 eorh ;1 buites fi _y)ic) =5#5G cdie`ùru breje, omhùr mcg`f, Buggf teùl)

7) Ihftmhr tmh pèfitfdd cr tmhfr detmhr erh fi pcsshssfci cd suft somhau`h prcphrty)


10/29

?) Qmh vhiacrs cd e``hbha se`h ahha aetha 5?*;6*5648 mea ict mcàfib tmh egscùtheia hxoùsfvh rfbmt tc ac sc eia ihvhr fi pcsshssfci cd suft somhau`h prcphrty)

1) _uft fs ict jefitefieg`h wftmcut shhlfib pcsshssfci eia ahoèretfci)8) Qmh oèfj cd pèfitfdd rhberafib survhy iujghr eia hxthit eia gcuiaerfhs erh

fiocrrhot eia fs ocitreafotcry wmhi ocjperha wftm se`h ahha eia p`heafibs eia

prccd)

4) Fiicohioh eia f``fthreoy cd A*7 fs ghfib jfs*utf`fsha gy oc`ùafib wftm A*5 gypèfitfdds)

2) Ici*ncfiahr cd ihohssery perty es @r cd A*7 e``hbha)=) Qmh deots cd jfs`heafib eia jfsahhas orhetha ebefist A*7 oejh tc tmh licw`habh cd

@rs cd A*7 edthr ocjfib ci rhocra gy hibebfib eictmhr ocuish`)

6) Qmh survhy ic) =5 rhpmcaha gy survhy eutmcrfty uiahr J[W ic) ?2=#45*47 ci 58*55*5645 ftsh`d es _urvhy ic) =5#5E , =5#5G)

5;)Qmh wrftthi stethjhit somhau`h prcphrty fs mevfib gcrhwh`` eutmcrfsha h`hotrfoociihotfci eia ocociut berahi)

55)[èfitfdds erh etthjptfib tc breg èia gy orhetfib acoujhits)57)Qmh survhy iujghr =5 ocisfstfib cd 2 eorh ;2 buites cre``y afvfaha ejcib tmrhh

scis cd jeiaeè K Jeieaeèfem, cut cd tmet 5 eorh fs ghfib scà gy Jeaefem tc A*7

tmrcubm se`h ahha aetha 78*;8*5686)

5?)Letme Qreisdhrrha fi JW ?1#568=*86 gy vfrtuh cd suom se`h)51)Qmh meagestm Aurestm wes jeah uiahr J[W ?2=#5645*47 eia rhpmcaha fitc _y)ic)

=5#5E $ =5#5G)

58)@cib steiafib rhvhiuh rhocras wftm ic hioujgereioh edthr eia ghdcrh rhpmcafibcphretfcis)

ACOXJHIQ_ CD AHDHIAEIQ_ EIA FQ_ WH@HTEIOH

IC H]MFGFQ EIA [EWQFOX@EW_ WH@HTEIOH EIA FJ[CWQEIQ QMFIB_ QC CG_HWTH

5 H]*A5_E@H AHHA AEQHA 78*;8*5686JEIAE@IE AE_EIIE_ _CI JXAAEFEM

RWFQQHI QC METH H]HOXQHA _E@HAHHA FI DETCXW CD BXIAEFEM _#C

JEIAE@IE AE_EIIE)

_E@H F_ FI WH_[HOQ QC _V)IC) =5#5

H]QHIQ 5 EOWH

GCXIAEWFH_>*

H*BXIAEFEM_ @EIA

R*OMFOLLE_FAAEFEM_ @EIA

I*LE@EFEM_ @EIA

_*_)L) THILEQEOMH@E_MHQQV_ @EIA

OCI_FAHWEQFCI W_ 8;*;;

_MCR_ TE@FA D@CR CD QFQ@H FI _XWTHV IXJGHW =5#5

RFQM [HWDHOQ GCXIAEWFH_)

7 H]*A7 * FIAH] CD @EIA_

C@AH_Q WHTHIXH WHOCWA

_V)IC) =5#5G

H]QHIQ 5 EOWH 1 BXIQE_

C@AH_Q WHTHIXH WHOCWA _MCRFIB JXQEQFCI CD IEJH

CD A*7 -BXIAEFEM _#C AE_EIIE& FI WHTHIXH WHOCWA

RFQM JXQEQFCI WHBF_QHW IXJGHW JW ?1#8=*86,WHOCWA CD WFBMQ_ WW IXJGHW 287 QC EI H]QHIQ CD 5

EOWH ;1 BXIQE_)

FIAH] CD @EIA_ EIA WHOCWA CD WFBMQ_ F_ QMH WHTHIXH

WHOCWA_ GHFIB LH[Q EIA JEFIQEFIHA FI WHTHIXH

AH[EWQJHIQ GHDCWH 564=)

? H]*A? * WHOCWA CD WFBMQ_ DCWJ *T

C@AH_Q @EIA WFBMQ_ WHBF_QHW

C@AH_Q WHTHIXH WHOCWA _MCRFIB _XWTHV JXQEQFCI

IXJGHW EIA IEJH CD A*7 -BXIAEFEM _#C AE_EIIE& FI

WHTHIXH WHOCWA RFQM _XWTHV JXQEQFCI WHBF_QHW


11/29

_V)IC) =5#5G

IXJGHW J[W _W 5;#45*47, WHOCWA CD WFBMQ_ WW

IXJGHW 287) FI _XWTHV IXJGHW =5#5G

1 H]*A1 * WHOCWA CD WFBMQ_ DCWJ *T


_@ IC) 5?7

_V)IC) =5

FI QMH IEJH CD AE_E _#C JEIAE@F

C@AH_Q WHTHIXH WHOCWA _MCRFIB _XWTHV IC)=5 FI

QMH IEJH CD AE_E _#C JEIAE@F EIOH_QHW CD A*7

-BXIAEFEM _#C AE_EIIE& FI WHTHIXH WHOCWA RFQM

_HWFE@ IXJGHW 5?7, FI _XWTHV IXJGHW =5)

8 H]*A8 * WHOCWA_ CD WFBMQ_


_@)IC)47?

FMO 4;#17*1?

_V)IC) 578#?, =5, 57?#7, 571#7

QMWCXBM FIMHWFQEIOH

FI QMH IEJH CD VHWWE _#C AE_E

QMF_ WHOCWA _MCR_ QMEQ CIH VHWE _#C AE_E

FIMHWFQHA _HTHWE@ [WC[HWQFH_ FI QMH DEJF@V, FQ F_ CD

OCJJCI COOXWWHIOH QMEQ CI@V DHR _MEWH HEOM

_XWTHV IXJGHW)

4 H]*A4 * WHOCWA_ CD WFBMQ_


_@)IC)2?5

JW 56

_V)IC) =5

QMWCXBM JHE_XWHJHIQ

FI QMH IEJH CD VHWWE _#C AE_E

QMF_ ACOXJHIQ _MCR_ JHE_XWHJHIQ FI QMEQ [HWFCA

FQ_H@D

2 H]*A2 * QF[[EIF GCCL IELE@X


AEQHA 58*55*5647

_V)IC) =5#5E EIA =5#5G

QMWCXBM J[W _W ?2=#45*47 _V)IC)=5

F_ [MCAHA QC =5#5E EIA =5#5G

_V)IC) =5#5G FI QMH IEJH CD

BXIAEFEM _#C AE_EIIE

QMF_ ACOXJHIQ _MCR_ IEJH CD A*7 FI _XWTHV IXJGHW

=5#5G E_ CI 58*55*5647) QMH HIQWFH_ EIA _XWTHV

IXJGHW =5#5G OEI GH _HHI DWCJ QMEQ C@AH_Q [CFIQCD QFJH

= H]*A= * ELEW GEIA


_V)IC) =5#5E $ =5#5G

QMF_ ACOXJHIQ _MCR_ LEWEG [CWQFCI FI _XWTHV

IXJGHW

6 H]*A6 * DCWJ 58

_V)IC) =5 EIA _V IC) =5#5G

DWCJ 78*;8*5686 QC 56*;2*7;5;

FI 78*;8*5686 CIH JXAAEFEM _C@A_V)IC) =5 @EIA QC BXIAEFEM DCW

OCI_FAHWEQFCI CD W_ 8;*;;

QMF_ DCWJ AF_O@C_H_ E_ [HW H]EOQ [MCA * CI@V CIH

_E@H AHHA HIQWV FI 5686 RFQM A*7 IEJH)

5; H]*A5; * WQO DWCJ 5646*2; QC 562?*

21

_V)IC) =5#5G

LEQME IC) 776

[C__H__FCI QMWCXBM J[W -_XWTHVJXQEQFCI&

IEJH>* BXIAEFEM _#C AE_EIIE

QMF_ C@AH_Q WHTHIXH WHOCWA F_ AH@FGHWEQH@V RFQM

MH@A GV [@EFIQFDD) QMH HIQWFH_ EIA _XWTHV IXJGHW

=5#5G OEI GH _HHI DWCJ QMEQ C@AH_Q [CFIQ CD QFJH

55 H]*A55 * WQO DWCJ 5621*28 QC 562=* QMF_ C@AH_Q WHTHIXH WHOCWA F_ AH@FGHWEQH@V RFQM


12/29

26

_V)IC) =5#5G

LEQME IC) 776

[C__H__FCI QMWCXBM J[W -_XWTHV

JXQEQFCI&




57 H]*A57 * WQO DWCJ 56=8*=4 QC 56=6*

6;

_V)IC) =5#5G

LEQME IC) OMEIBHA DWCJ 776 QC 5;5


JXQEQFCI&


OCOCIXQ QWHH_ FI OC@XJI 2 OEI GH_HHI




QMH HIQWV CD OCOCIXQ QWHH_ EIA EAJF__FCI CD [R5

FI OWC__ H]EJFIEQFCI EIA _[HOFDFO AH[C_FQFCI EIA

FAHIQFDFOEQFCI CD AR5 EIA AR7 FI QMHFW AH[C_FQFCI

[WCTH_ QMEQ QMH [WC[HWQV F_ FI [C__H__FCI EIA

HINCVJHIQ CD A*7 EIA MF_ @W_

5? H]*A5? * WQO DWCJ 566;*65 QC 5661*

68_V)IC) =5#5G



JXQEQFCI&


OCOCIXQ QWHH_ FI OC@XJI 2 OEI GH

_HHI


MH@A GV [@EFIQFDD) QMH HIQWFH_ EIA _XWTHV IXJGHW=5#5G OEI GH _HHI DWCJ QMEQ C@AH_Q [CFIQ CD QFJH




[WCTH_ QMEQ QMH [WC[HWQV F_ FI [C__H__FCI EIAHINCVJHIQ CD A*7 EIA MF_ @W_

51 H]*A51 * WQO DWCJ 5668*64 QC 5666*;;

_V)IC) =5#5G



JXQEQFCI&


OCOCIXQ QWHH_ FI OC@XJI 2 OEI GH

_HHI

GCWHRH@@ HIQWV FI OC@XJI =

JCWQBEBH QC T__I JW 12#66*;;

QMF_ C@AH_Q WHTHIXH WHOCWA F_ AH@FGHWEQH@V RFQMMH@A GV [@EFIQFDD) QMH HIQWFH_ EIA _XWTHV IXJGHW


QMH HIQWV CD OCOCIXQ QWHH_ EIA EAJF__FCI CD [R5FI OWC__ H]EJFIEQFCI EIA _[HOFDFO AH[C_FQFCI EIA




QMH JCWQBEBH $ GCWHRH@@ HIQWV E@_C [WCTH_[C__H__FCI CD @W_ CD A*7

58 H]*A58 * WQO DCW 7;;5*;7

_V)IC) =5#5G

LEQME IC) OMEIBHA DWCJ 5;5 QC 578


JXQEQFCI&


OCOCIXQ QWHH_ FI OC@XJI 2 $ 57-6&

OEI GH _HHI

GCWHRH@@ HIQWV FI OC@XJI 57-5?&


QMF_ WHTHIXH WHOCWA F_ AH@FGHWEQH@V RFQM MH@A GV

[@EFIQFDD) QMH HIQWFH_ EIA _XWTHV IXJGHW =5#5G OEIGH _HHI DWCJ QMEQ [CFIQ CD QFJH






QMH JCWQBEBH $ GCWHRH@@ HIQWV E@_C [WCTH_

[C__H__FCI CD @W_ CD A*7

54 H]*A54 * WQO DCW 7;;7*;?

_V)IC) =5#5G

LEQME IC) 578


JXQEQFCI&


QMF_ WHTHIXH WHOCWA F_ AH@FGHWEQH@V RFQM MH@A GV

[@EFIQFDD) QMH HIQWFH_ EIA _XWTHV IXJGHW =5#5G OEI

GH _HHI DWCJ QMEQ [CFIQ CD QFJH

QMH HIQWV CD OCOCIXQ QWHH_ EIA EAJF__FCI CD [R5FI OWC__ H]EJFIEQFCI EIA _[HOFDFO AH[C_FQFCI EIA





13/29


OEI GH _HHI





52 H]*A52 WQO DCW 7;;?*;1

_V)IC) =5#5G

LEQME IC) 578


JXQEQFCI&



OEI GH _HHI




FI OWC__ H]EJFIEQFCI EIA _[HOFDFO AH[C_FQFCI EIAFAHIQFDFOEQFCI CD AR5 EIA AR7 FI QMHFW AH[C_FQFCI




5= H]*A5= WQO DCW 7;;1*;8

_V)IC) =5#5G

LEQME IC) 578


JXQEQFCI&


OCOCIXQ QWHH_ FI OC@XJI 2 $ 57-6&OEI GH _HHI



QMF_ WHOCWA F_ AH@FGHWEQH@V RFQM MH@A GV [@EFIQFDD)








56 H]*A56 WQO DCW 7;;8*;4

_V)IC) =5#5G

LEQME IC) 578


JXQEQFCI&












7; H]*A7; WQO DCW 7;;4*;2

_V)IC) =5#5G

LEQME IC) 578


JXQEQFCI&



OEI GH _HHI



QMF_ WHOCWA F_ AH@FGHWEQH@V RFQM MH@A GV [@EFIQFDD)



FAHIQFDFOEQFCI CD AR5 EIA AR7 FI QMHFW AH[C_FQFCI[WCTH_ QMEQ QMH [WC[HWQV F_ FI [C__H__FCI EIA



75 H]*A75 WQO DCW 7;;2*;=

_V)IC) =5#5G






14/29

LEQME IC) 578






JW 21#7;;4*;2 [@A GEIL JCWQBEBH



77 H]*A77 WQO DCW 7;;=*;6

_V)IC) =5#5G

LEQME IC) _[@FQQHA 578 $ ?46

IEJH>*BXIAEFEM _#C AE_EIIE ;);1 BXIQE_


JXQEQFCI&

JE@@EFEM _#C LE@EFEM 5 EOWH

[C__H__FCI QMWCXBM FIMHWFQEIOH $

OCXWQ CWAHW JW 45#7;;2*;= * 75*;?*

7;;=





[C__H__FCI OC@XJI BXIAEFEM ME_

HIQFWH H]QHIQ CD 5 EOWH ;1 BXIQE_

QMH HIQWV CD JE@@FEM IEJH F_ JEAH E_ [HW CWAHW FI

H]*[1 EIA FQ F_ _XG_HUXHIQ@V UXE_MHA FI H]*A?8






7? H]*A7? WQO DCW 7;;6*5;

_V)IC) =5#5G

LEQME IC) _[@FQQHA 578 $ ?46

IEJH>*

BXIAEFEM _#C AE_EIIE ;);1 BXIQE_



[C__H__FCI QMWCXBM FIMHWFQEIOH $OCXWQ CWAHW JW 45#7;;2*;= * 75*;?*

7;;=


OEI GH _HHI






QMH HIQWV CD JE@@FEM IEJH F_ JEAH E_ [HW CWAHW FIH]*[1 EIA FQ F_ _XG_HUXHIQ@V UXE_MHA FI H]*A?8







71 H]*A71 WQO DCW 7;5;*55

_V)IC) =5#5G

LEQME IC) _[@FQQHA 578 $ 51?

IEJH>*

BXIAEFEM _#C AE_EIIE ;);1 BXIQE_[C__H__FCI QMWCXBM J[W -_XWTHV

JXQEQFCI&










15/29


[C__H__FCI QMWCXBM FIMHWFQEIOH $

OCXWQ CWAHW JW 45#7;;2*;= * 75*;?*7;;=


OEI GH _HHI




[C__H__FCI OC@XJI BXIAEFEM ME_HIQFWH H]QHIQ CD 5 EOWH ;1 BXIQE_

JE@@EFM IEJH IHR HIQWV CD 5*;;

EOWH DCXIA

EO OCXWQ ME_ _QEVHA QMH CWAHW CD

QEM_F@AEW FI JXQEQFIB JE@@EFEM_

IEJH78 H]*A78 WQO DCW 7;55*57

_V)IC) =5#5G

LEQME IC) _[@FQQHA 578 $ 51?

IEJH>*

BXIAEFEM _#C AE_EIIE ;);1 BXIQE_


JXQEQFCI&


[C__H__FCI QMWCXBM FIMHWFQEIOH $OCXWQ CWAHW JW 45#7;;2*;= * 75*;?*

7;;=







JE@@EFM IEJH IHR HIQWV CD 5*;;EOWH DCXIA

EO OCXWQ ME_ _QEVHA QMH CWAHW CD

QEM_F@AEW FI JXQEQFIB JE@@EFEM_

IEJH




FI OWC__ H]EJFIEQFCI EIA _[HOFDFO AH[C_FQFCI EIAFAHIQFDFOEQFCI CD AR5 EIA AR7 FI QMHFW AH[C_FQFCI




FQ F_ WH[HEQHA@V OCIQHIAHA GV [@EFIQFDD EIA MF_OCXI_H@ QMEQ _XFQ _OMHAX@H [WC[HWQV F_ E GEWWHI

@EIA, QMH WH@HTEIQ HIQWFH_ _XOM E_ OCOCIXQ QWHH_

EIA GCWHRH@@ FI WH@ETHIQ OC@XJI DWCJ 56=8*=4 QC

7;55*57 AF_[XQH_ QMH O@EFJ C)D [@EFIQFDD

74 H]*A74 QE] [EFA WHOFH[Q_V)IC)=5#5G

AEQHA 52*5;*5646


C@AH_Q QE] [EFA WHOFH[Q [WCTH_ A*7 EIA MF_ @W_

[C__H__FCI CD _V)IC) =5#5G

72 H]*A72 QE] [EFA WHOFH[Q_V)IC)=5#5G

AEQHA 72*;=*56=;




7= H]*A7= QE] [EFA WHOFH[Q

_V)IC)=5#5G

AEQHA 7?*;1*7;;7




76 H]*A76 EO OCXWQ HIACW_HJHIQ

_V)IC)=5#5G

AEQHA 75*5;*5;

QMH HDDCWQ_ JEAH GV [@EFIQFDD QC OWHEQH WHTHIXHWHOCWA_ DCW MF_ OE_H F_ GHFIB OME@@HIBHA GV A*7 @W_

?; H]*A?; EO OCXWQ CWAHW _MHHQ QMH HDDCWQ_ JEAH GV [@EFIQFDD QC OWHEQH WHTHIXH

WHOCWA_ DCW MF_ OE_H F_ GHFIB OME@@HIBHA GV A*7 @W_

?5 H]*A?5 EO OCXWQ _XJJCI_ _HWTHA

EOLICR@HABHJHIQ

QMH HDDCWQ_ JEAH GV [@EFIQFDD QC OWHEQH WHTHIXH


?7 H]*A?7 EO OCXWQ E[[HE@ JHJC QMH HDDCWQ_ JEAH GV [@EFIQFDD QC OWHEQH WHTHIXH


?? H]*A?? [EQQE GCCL [WCTH_ QFQ@H CD @W_ CD A*7 QC _V)IC) =5#5G

?1 H]*A?1 B*QWHH QC _MCR RMEQ [@EFIQFDD ME_ MFAAHI GHDCWH QMHOCXWQ


16/29

?8 H]*A?8 EO OCXWQ CWAHW_

AEQHA ;4*;=*7;57

CWAHW_ CD QEM_F@AEW OCXWQ JEAHQC HIQHW QMH IEJH CD JE@@EFEM F_

UXE_MHA)

[@EFIQFDD F@@HBE@ HDDCWQ_ H][C_HA

?4 H]*A?4 JF_ 55#7;57 CWAHW _MHHQ OE_H GHFIB WH*C[HIHA AXH QC DWEXA FITC@THA FI _XOM

JEQQHW_

?2 H]*A?2 JF_ 55#7;57 [HQFQFCI

_HHL_ QC WH_QCWH C_ 4;#7;;2

OE_H GHFIB WH*C[HIHA AXH QC DWEXA FITC@THA FI _XOM

JEQQHW_

?= H]*A?= WE ?6#7;57 CWAHW_MHHQ OE_H GHFIB WH*C[HIHA AXH QC DWEXA FITC@THA FI _XOMJEQQHW_

?6 H]*A?6 WE ?6#7;57 E[[HE@ JHJCEBEFI_Q C_ 5?6#7;;1

OE_H GHFIB WH*C[HIHA AXH QC DWEXA FITC@THA FI _XOM

JEQQHW_

1; H]*A1; GH_OCJ WHTHIXH WH[CWQ _MCR_ [C__H__FCI CD @W_ CD A*7

15 H]*A15 QE] [EFA WHOHF[Q

_V)IC)=5#5G


AEQHA ;?*;1*7;57




_V)IC)=5#5GBXIAEFEM _#C AE_EIIEAEQHA 54*;?*56=1



1? H]*A1? QE] [EFA WHOHF[Q_V)IC)=5#5G


AEQHA 56=8*=4




_V)IC)=5#5G




18 H]*A18 [EQQE GCCL [WCTH_ QFQ@H CD @W_ CD A*7 QC _V)IC) =5#5G

14 H]*A14 HIACW_HJHIQ

HIACW_HJHIQ CD _XWTHV CDDFOH FI

QEM_F@AEW _QEQFIB H]*[5; [WCAXOHAGV [@EFIQFDD E_ ICQ EI CDDFOFE@WHOCWA

[WCTTH_ DWEXA H]OHWOF_HA GV [@EFIQFDD FI [WCAXOHA

DCWBHA WHOCWA QC CGQEFI WHTHIXH OCXWQ CWAHW_

EIA EQQHJ[QFIB _EJH GHDCWH QMF_ OCXWQ

12 H]*A12 QC H]*A86 WQO

_V)IC =5#5E

DWCJ 7;;5*;7 QC 7;57*5?

_MCRI QC H][C_H EICQMHW _XWTHV IXJGHW =5#5E

1= H]*A4;

CWAHW _MHHQ FI C_ 5?6#7;;1

QC _MCR QMH _EJH EATCOEQH MEIA@FIB A*7 OE_H FI

QMF_ JEQQHW RMHI MH QELHI C[[CIHIQ OE_H FI CA

5?6#7;;1

AHDHIAEIQ XI_MELHI HTFAHIOH ETHWJHIQ_ AF_[WCTFIB [@EFIQFDD_ OE_H

5) Qmh orcss hxejfietfci pcrtfci cd AR5 aetha ;1*5;*7;57 fi fts dfrst pere AR5o`her`y sphels cd B*trhh eia ici ncfiahr cd ihohssery perty)

7) Qmh pèfitfdd mes ict o`her`y fahitfdfha tmh suft somhau`h prcphrty wftm ocrrhotgcuiaerfhs, mhioh eiy quhstfci rhberafib suft somhau`h prcphrty eslha gy pèfitfdd

ocuish` eia tmh eiswhr bfvhi gy ahdhiaeit wftihss smcwfib ic sphofdfo eajfssfci

wftm oèrfty eia smcwfib fbicreioh fs cd ic suppcrt tc pèfitfdd oesh) Qmh pèfitfdd

mes tc prcvh mfs cwi retmhr tmei rh`yfib ci whelihss cd ahdhiaeit)

?) Qmh ahdhiaeit wftihss ocidusfci wftm rhbera tc pèfit suft somhau`h prcphrty oei ghshhi drcj mfs stethjhit fi pebh 5; shocia pere)

1) Qmh orcss hxejfietfci cd AR7 eia mhr evhrjhits rhberafib mhr detmhr mevfib scàtc A*7 eia fahitfdfoetfci cd prcphrty wftm ocociut trhhs eia jeibc trhhs

sugsteitfe``y ahstrcys tmh tmhcry cd pèfitfdd tmet suft somhau`h prcphrty fs gerrhi

èia)


17/29

GXWAHI CD [WCCD LICRI GV [@EFIQFDD EIA MEA DEF@HA QC @HA [WC[HWHTFAHIOH QC FQ3

Fi crahr tc suoohha fi tmh jetthr e af`fbhit pèfitfdd smcuà mevh telhi fi ahtef` tmh deots cd

mfs oesh tmrcubm prcphr ejhiajhit cr tmrcubm prcphr`y egrfabfib mfs p`heafibs, tmfs fs

ghfib ict acih gy pèfitfdd, sfioh mh drcj tmh ghbfiifib licw tmet mh mes pèyha dreua ci

fiicohits et shvhre` stebhs tc breg tmh prcphrty) Edthr df`fib cd wrftthi stethjhit gy @rs cd

A*7, pèfitfdd smcuà mevh df`ha rhncfiahr cr `ha hvfahioh tc tmet hddhot, tmhrh e`sc pèfitfdd

def`ha shrfcus`y wftm e`` ihohssery eia suddfofhit tfjh)

[èfitfdd gy stertfib mfs hvfahioh ci 56*;5*7;;4 ocitfiuha tc ;4*;?*7;;6 tc shourh tmh 5?

acoujhits prcauoha fi tmh oesh eia èthr fi ;7*;7*7;55 prcauoha eictmhr ? acoujhits)

Fi cvhre`` pèfitfdd dcr hxejfifib eia jerlfib mfs sfah cd acoujhits mh tccl dfvh yhers) Fi

tmet dfvh yhers mh ihvhr prcauoha eiy rh`hveit acoujhits tc prcvh mfs oesh) Mfs orcss

hxejfietfci ocjp`htha fi tmrhh aeys) Qmfs ociauot cd pèfitfdd fi ah`fghreth ahèy fi

prcshoutfib tmh oesh ftsh`d smcws mfs ociauot)

Ci`y hxejfietfci ghfib acih fi pèfitfdd sfah fs mfjsh`d wftmcut eiy ctmhr phrsci drcj mfs

sfah) Qmh evhrjhits erh sc egsura tmet pèfitfdd utthr`y def`ha tc prcvh mfs oesh wftm o`her

hxpèietfci eia prccd drcj mfs sfah)

Qmh p`heafibs eia prccd prcauoha gy pèfitfdd achs ict smcw eiy prfje deofh oesh dcr

susphotfib ahdhiaeits vhrsfci) Qmh hqufty `fhs wftm ahdhiaeit*7 tc bht hvhry rh`fhd et tmh

ocst cd pèfitfdd, sfioh tmh fiicohit A*7 eia mfs @rs erh sugnhot tc ui*ihohssery `ftfbetfcieia meressjhit et tmh meias cd pèfitfdd)

WH@HTEIOH CD ACOXJHIQ_ CD AHDHIAEIQ_ AF_[WCTFIB [@EFIQFDD_ OE_H EIA

[WCTFIB ETHWWJHIQ_ CD @W_ CD A*7

Qmh acoujhits cd ahdhiaeit fi hitfrhty sphofdfoe``y smcws tmet suft somhau`h prcphrty fs e

èia fiftfe``y hjhrbha drcj survhy iujghr =5, ft fs rhpmcaha fitc =5#5E $ =5#5G fi 58*55*

5647, drcj tmhi ciweras shvhre` rhvhiuh rhocras mevfib survhy iujghr =5#5G es fts

fahitfdfoetfci) Es suom pèfitfdd oèfjfib tc mevh puromesha fi survhy iujghr =5#5 wmhi

suom survhy iujghr fs ict fi hxfsthioh) Qmfs fs e shrfcus afsputh es tc fahitfdfoetfci cd

prcphrty) Fd wh try tc esohrtefi tmh fahitfty cd prcphrty tmrcubm gcuiaerfhs, tmhi e`sc

tcweras whst eia scutm cd suft somhau`h prcphrty pèfitfdd oèfjs prcphrty cd A*7, mh achs

ict hxpèfi gy hftmhr hvfahioh cr gy acoujhit, wmfom survhy iujghr prcphrty cd A*7 `fhs

tcweras whst eia scutm cd mfs oèfjha suft somhau`h) Fi orcss hxejfietfci pèfitfdd ocuish`


18/29

trfha tc ocivfioh tmh ocurt tmet suft somhau`h prcphrty fs e gerrhi èia mevfib ic ocociut

trhhs eia gcrhwh``) Qmh WQOs prcauoha rhètha tc survhy iujghr =5#5G drcj 56=8 tc

7;57 smcws ocociut trhhs eia gcrh wh`` fi rh`hveit ocùjis, mhioh tmfs fs tmfra pcfit

wmfom shrfcus`y afspuths tmh fahitfty cd prcphrty cd pèfitfdd)

@HBE@ E_[HOQ_ EIA CG_HWTEQFCI_ CD OFQEQFCI_ AF_[WCTFIB

[@EFIQFDD_ OE_H >*

IHR OWHHA CD @FQFBEIQ_ METH OWC[[HA X[ * RMC AC ICQ METH EIV WH_[HOQ

DCW QWXQM * WH_CWQFIB QC DE@_HMCCA EIA XIHQMFOE@ JHEI_ DCW EOMFHTFIB

QMHFW BCE@_ Fi tmh fisteit oesh tmh pèfitfdd mes smcwi suom ociauot eia mhioh tmh

cgshrvetfcis cd _uprhjh Ocurt tc gh ictha mhrh)

Fi Ae`fp _fibm v) _teth cd X)[), -7;5;& 7 _OO 551, tmh _uprhjh Ocurt cgshrvha tmet e ihw

orhha cd `ftfbeits mevh orcppha up fi tmh èst 1; yhers wmc ac ict mevh eiy rhsphot dcr

trutm eia smejh`hss`y rhscrt tc de`shmcca eia uihtmfoe` jheis dcr eomfhvfib tmhfr bce`s)

FQ F_ _HQQ@HA @ER QMEQ RMHI FAHIQFDFOEQFCI CD [WC[HWQV F_ FI AF_[XQH IC

WH@FHD GH BWEIQHA

NX_QFOH W Bururenei cd Lerietele Mfbm Ocurt fi tmh oesh cd Q)@) Iebhiare Gegu vs

Jeicmer Wec [ewer rhpcrtha fi F@W 7;;8 LEW ==1

5) [`heafibs smcuà gh vhrfdfha gy tmh perty wmc fs eoquefitha wftm tmh deots cd tmhoesh * E perty just e`sc sphofdy tmh iujghr cd perebrepms eia mfs licw`habh,

fidcrjetfci eia gh`fhd wftm rhbera tc tmh perebrepms * Thrfdfoetfci just gh sfbiha

gy tmh ociohriha perty gy jhitfcifib tmh aeth eia pèoh)

7) [rhsujptfci cphreths fi devcur cd tmh perty rh`yfib ci e acoujhit, prcvfaha mhjust prcvh tmet tmh acoujhit fs au`y hxhoutha eia eutmhitfoetha)

?) Xi`hss tmh Ocurt fs setfsdfha wftm rhbera tc jethrfe` ahtef`s fi tmh `fbmt cd tmhjethrfe` hvfahioh wftm rhbera tc tmh fahitfdfoetfci cd tmh prcphrty, ic

ahoèretfci eia finuiotfci oei gh breitha)

1) Qmhrh fs ic prcphr hvfahioh wftm rhbera tc jefitefiegf`fty cd tmh suft< tmhrh fs icprcphr hvfahioh wftm rhbera tc ocurt dhh< tmhrh fs ic prcphr hvfahioh wftm rhbera tc

oeush cd eotfci< tmhrh fs ic hvfahioh wftm rhbera tc pcsshssfci, gut ahspfth tmh

sejh, tmh `heriha Nuabh mes omcshi tc breit ei finuiotfci rh`fhd fi tmh oesh ci meia)

Breit cd finuiotfci fs shrfcus fi ieturh) Ft eddhots tmh rfbmts cd tmh pertfhs) Qmh Ocurt

just gh vhry oerhdu` fi hveùetfib tmh p`heafibs eia hvfahioh fi tmh jetthr cd

finuiotfci)


19/29

FD MH RFQMMC@A_ E TFQE@ ACOXJHIQ FI CWAHW QC BEFI EATEIQEBH EBEFI_Q

QMH CQMHW _FAH, QMHI MH RCX@A GH BXF@QV CD [@EVFIB DWEXA CI QMH OCXWQ

Fi tmh ahofsfci, _)[) Omhibe`vereye Iefau vs) Nebeiietm, rhpcrtha fi 5661 -5& _OO 5, tmh

Mci"g`h _uprhjh Ocurt mes mhà tmet e dreua fs ei eot cd ah`fghreth ahohptfci wftm tmhahsfbi cd shourfib scjhtmfib gy telfib uidefr eaveitebh cd eictmhr) Ft fs e ahohptfci fi

crahr tc befi gy eictmhr"s `css) Ft fs e omhetfib fithiaha tc bht ei eaveitebh) E `ftfbeit, wmc

epprceomhs tmh ocurt, fs gcuia tc prcauoh e`` tmh acoujhits hxhoutha gy mfj wmfom erh

rh`hveit tc ahofah tmh `ftfbetfci eia fd mh wftmmcàs e vfte` acoujhit fi crahr tc befi

eaveitebh ebefist tmh ctmhr sfah, tmhi mh wcuà gh buf`ty cd pèyfib dreua ci tmh ocurt es

wh`` es ci tmh cppcsfth perty)

DE@_H WH[WH_HIQEQFCI HTHI RFQMCXQ GEA JCQFTH F_ DWEXA

Fi Wej Omeiare _fibm vs) _evftrf Ahvf eia ctmhrs, rhpcrtha fi -7;;?& = _OO ?56, tmh

Mci"g`h Ephx Ocurt mes mhà tmet ft fs e dreua fi èw fd e perty jelhs rhprhshitetfcis wmfom

mh licws tc gh de`sh eia finury hisuhs tmhrhdrcj e`tmcubm tmh jctfvh drcj wmfom tmh

rhprhshitetfcis prcohhaha jey ict gh gea)

QMH OCXWQ_ OEI QELH ICQFOH CD QMH _XG_HUXHIQ HTHIQ_ EIA OEI JCX@A QMH

WH@FHD EOOCWAFIB@V

Fi Wenhsm A) Aerger eia Crs) v) Ieresfibrec Lrfsmienf Lu`lerif eia Crs) , -7;;?& 2 _OO 756

tmfs ocurt ictfoha> 'Qmh ocurts oei telh ictfoh cd tmh sugshquhit hvhits eia oei jcuà tmh

rh`fhd eoocrafib`y)

ICGCAV _MCX@A GH [HWJFQQHA QC FIAX@BH FI FJJCWE@ EOQ_ @FLH [HWNXWV,

[WHTEWFOEQFCI EIA JCQFTEQHA DE@_HMCCA_

Fi Omeiare _mesmf v) Eif` Lujer Thrje, -5668& 5 _OO 175, mhà tmet icgcay smcuà gh

phrjfttha tc fiau`bh fi fjjcre` eots `flh phrnury, prhverfoetfci eia jctfvetha de`shmccas

fi tmh nuafofe` prcohhafibs eia fd scjhcih achs sc, ft just gh ahe`t wftm epprcprfeth`y) Fi

oesh tmh rhocursh tc e de`sh p`he fs telhi wftm ei cg`fquh jctfvh, ft wcuà ahdfifth`y mfiahr,

mejphr cr fjphah tmh d`cw cd nustfoh eia prhvhit tmh ocurts drcj phrdcrjfib tmhfr `hbe`

autfhs)

IC @FQFBEIQ ME_ E WFBMQ QC XI@FJFQHA AWCXBMQ CI QMH OCXWQ QFJH EIA

[XG@FO JCIHV FI CWAHW QC BHQ MF_ EDDEFW_ _HQQ@HA FI QMH JEIIHW MH RF_MH_


20/29

Fi Ar) Guaamf Lcte _uggerec v) L) [ereserei $ Crs) EFW 5664 _O 74=2, _uprhjh Ocurt mes

cgshrvha es uiahr>* Ic `ftfbeit mes e rfbmt tc ui`fjftha arcubmt ci tmh Ocurt tfjh eia

pug`fo jcihy fi crahr tc bht mfs eddefrs shtt`ha fi tmh jeiihr mh wfsmhs) Mcwhvhr, eoohss tc

nustfoh smcuà ict gh jfsusha es e `fohioh tc df`h jfsociohfvha eia drfvc`cus phtftfcis)

IC [EWQV _MCX@A GH [HWJFQQHA QC QWETH@ GHVCIA FQ_ [@HEAFIB EIA QMEQ

E@@ IHOH__EWV EIA JEQHWFE@ DEOQ_ _MCX@A GH [@HEAHA GV QMH [EWQV FI

_X[[CWQ CD QMH OE_H _HQ X[ GV FQ

Fi QMH _X[WHJH OCXWQ CD FIAFE Ahofsfci fi e oesh cd h`hotfci jetthr, fi Le`yei _fibm

Omcumei vs O)[)Ncsmf 7;55 EFW 5572 : 7;55 -7 & _OW 754 : 7;55 -55 & _OO 2=4,

Nustfoh [) _EQME_FTEJ $ Nustfoh Ar) G)_) OMEXMEI cgshrvha dc``cwfib prfiofp`hs cd

oesh èw ci Fjpcrteioh cd p`heafibs es e`sc epp`foeg`h tc ofvf` ocurt prcohhafibs fs

afsoussha wftm dc``cwfib oftetfcis>* Qmfs Ocurt fi Wej _erup Bupte -ahea& gy @)Ws) v)

Gfsmui Ierefi Fithr Oc``hbh $ Crs), EFW 56=2 _O 5717 mhà es uiahr> 'Ft fs wh`` shtt`ha tmet

fi tmh egshioh cd p`heafib, hvfahioh, fd eiy, prcauoha gy tmh pertfhs oeiict gh ocisfahrha)

Ft fs e`sc hque``y shtt`ha tmet ic perty smcuà gh phrjfttha tc trevh` ghycia fts p`heafib eia

tmet e`` ihohssery eia jethrfe` deots smcuà gh p`heaha gy tmh perty fi suppcrt cd tmh oesh

sht up gy ft) Qmh cgnhot eia purpcsh cd p`heafib fs tc hieg`h tmh eavhrsery perty tc licw

tmh oesh ft mes tc jhht)))))))) Fi suom e oesh ft fs tmh auty cd tmh ocurt tc esohrtefi tmh

sugsteioh cd tmh p`heafibs tc ahthrjfih tmh quhstfci)' Qmfs Ocurt fi Geommen Iemer v)

If`fje Jeiae` $ Crs) , EFW 7;;6 _O 55;?, mhà es uiahr> 'Qmh cgnhot eia purpcsh cd

p`heafibs eia fssuhs fs tc hisurh tmet tmh `ftfbeits ocjh tc trfe` wftm e`` fssuhs o`her`y

ahdfiha eia tc prhvhit oeshs ghfib hxpeiaha cr brcuias ghfib smfdtha aurfib trfe`) Fts

cgnhot fs e`sc tc hisurh tmet heom sfah fs du``y e`fvh tc tmh quhstfcis tmet erh `flh`y tc gh

refsha cr ocisfahrha sc tmet tmhy jey mevh ei cppcrtuifty cd pèofib tmh rh`hveit hvfahioh

epprcprfeth tc tmh fssuhs ghdcrh tmh ocurt dcr fts ocisfahretfci) Qmh cgnhot cd fssuhs fs tc

fahitfdy drcj tmh p`heafibs tmh quhstfcis cr pcfits rhqufrha tc gh ahofaha gy tmh ocurts sc

es tc hieg`h pertfhs tc `ht fi hvfahioh tmhrhci) Rmhi tmh deots ihohssery tc jelh cut e

pertfouèr oèfj, cr tc shhl e pertfouèr rh`fhd, erh ict dcuia fi tmh pèfit, tmh ocurt oeiict

dcous tmh etthitfci cd tmh pertfhs, cr fts cwi etthitfci ci tmet oèfj cr rh`fhd, gy drejfib ei

epprcprfeth fssuh)))))))) Qmus ft fs sefa tmet ic ejcuit cd hvfahioh, ci e p`he tmet fs ict put

dcrwera fi tmh p`heafibs, oei gh `cclha fitc tc breit eiy rh`fhd) Qmh nurfsafotfci tc breit

rh`fhd fi e ofvf` suft ihohsserf`y ahphias ci tmh p`heafibs, preyhr, ocurt dhh pefa, hvfahioh

`ht fi, hto)'

E@@ 'JEQHWFE@ DEOQ_' JX_Q GH [@HEAHA GV QMH [EWQV FI _X[[CWQ CD QMH OE_H

_HQ X[ GV MFJ


21/29

Fi Jemeahcrec _ulenf _mfveiler Ts) Wejeretei Gepu $ Crs -7;;1& 2 _OO

5=5'jethrfe` deots' erh deots upci wmfom tmh pèfitfdd"s oeush cd eotfci cr ahdhiaeit"s

ahdhioh ahphias) Grcea`y sphelfib, e`` prfjery cr gesfo deots wmfom erh ihohssery hftmhr tc

prcvh tmh oeush cd eotfci gy tmh pèfitfdd cr ahdhioh gy tmh ahdhiaeit erh 'jethrfe` deots')

Jethrfe` deots erh deots wmfom, fd hsteg`fsmha, wcuà bfvh tmh phtftfcihr tmh rh`fhd eslha dcr)

Gut ebefi, wmet ocuà gh sefa tc gh jethrfe` deots wcuà ahphia upci tmh deots cd heom oesh

eia ic ru`h cd uifvhrse` epp`foetfci oei gh èfa acwi) Fi tmfs rhbera Fi suppcrt cd wrftthi

stethjhit evhrjhits eia cgnhotfcis tc FE tmfs ahdhiaeits rh`y ci tmh ahofsfci cd _uprhjh

ocurt tc smcw geèioh cd ocivhifhioh ci ahdhiaeit sfah) Fi Merlfret _fibm v) Ejrfiahr

_fibm -7;;8& 5? _OO 855, _uprhjh Ocurt ebefi rhfthretha tmh afstfiotfci ghtwhhi kjethrfe`

deots" eia kjethrfe` pertfouèrs" eia cgshrvha es uiahr> '85) E afstfiotfci ghtwhhi

'jethrfe` deots' eia 'pertfouèrs', mcwhvhr, just ict gh cvhr`cclha) 'Jethrfe` deots' erh

prfjery cr gesfo deots wmfom just gh p`heaha gy tmh pèfitfdd cr gy tmh ahdhiaeit fi

suppcrt cd tmh oesh sht up gy mfj hftmhr tc prcvh mfs oeush cd eotfci cr ahdhioh)

'[ertfouèrs', ci tmh ctmhr meia, erh ahtef`s fi suppcrt cd jethrfe` deots p`heaha gy tmh

perty) Qmhy ejp`fdy, rhdfih eia hjgh``fsm jethrfe` deots gy bfvfib afstfiotfvh tcuom tc tmh

gesfo ocitcurs cd e pfoturh e`rheay arewi sc es tc jelh ft du``, jcrh o`her eia jcrh

fidcrjetfvh) '[ertfouèrs' tmus hisurh ociauot cd defr trfe` eia wcuà ict telh tmh cppcsfth

perty gy surprfsh) 87) E`` 'jethrfe` deots' just gh p`heaha gy tmh perty fi suppcrt cd tmh

oesh sht up gy mfj) _fioh tmh cgnhot eia purpcsh fs tc hieg`h tmh cppcsfth perty tc licw tmh

oesh mh mes tc jhht wftm, fi tmh egshioh cd p`heafib, e perty oeiict gh e``cwha tc `hea

hvfahioh) Defùrh tc steth hvhi e sfib`h jethrfe` deot, mhioh, wf`` hitef` afsjfsse` cd tmh suft

cr phtftfci) [ertfouèrs, ci tmh ctmhr meia, erh tmh ahtef`s cd tmh oesh wmfom fs fi tmh ieturh

cd hvfahioh e perty wcuà gh `heafib et tmh tfjh cd trfe`)'

_XG_HUXHIQ AHTH@C[JHIQ_ OEI GH QELHI FIQC OCI_FAHWEQFCI QC EDDCWA

WH@FHD QC QMH [EWQFH_ RMHI FQ MEA E JEQHWFE@ FJ[EOQ CI QMC_H WFBMQ_ EIA

CG@FBEQFCI_)

Fi [retep Wef Qeiweif Ts) Xttej Omeia -7;;1 -=& _OO 16;&, _uprhjh Ocurt mhà tmet

sugshquhit ahvh`cpjhits oei gh telhi fitc ocisfahretfci tc eddcra rh`fhd tc tmh pertfhs,

prcvfaha ci`y wmhi suom ahvh`cpjhits mea e jethrfe` fjpeot ci tmcsh rfbmts eia

cg`fbetfcis)

RMHI [@EFIQFDD F_ ICQ FI [C__H__FCI JHWH AHO@EWEQFCI F_ ICQ

JEFIQEFIEG@H

Fi Wej _erei eia Eir) v) _jt) Beibe Ahvf, EFW 5627 _O 74=8, -562?& 7 _OO 4; tmh Ephx

Ocurt mes èfa acwi tmet e suft dcr jhrh ahoèretfci grcubmt gy tmh pèfitfdd wmc fs ict fi

pcsshssfci cd tmh prcphrty fs ict jefitefieg`h)


22/29

FI OFTF@ AF_[XQH OCIAXOQ CD [EWQFH_ F_ JEQHWFE@

Neilf Tesmahc Gmcnweif $ Eir) Ts Fiausfia Geil @ta) $ Crs) EFW 7;;8 _O 1?6, Fi ofvf`

afsputh tmh ociauot cd tmh pertfhs fs jethrfe`) Qmh epph`èits mevh ict epprceomha tmh

Ocurt wftm o`hei meias) Drcj tmh ociauot cd tmh pertfhs ft fs epperhit tmet ft wes e p`cy tc

se`vebh tmh prcphrty drcj se`h fi tmh hxhoutfci cd Ahorhh)

NXAFOFE@ [WCOH__ _MCX@A IHTHW GHOCJH EI FI_QWXJHIQ CD C[[WH__FCI CW

EGX_H CW E JHEI_ FI QMH [WCOH__ CD QMH OCXWQ QC _XGTHWQ NX_QFOH

Iccrauaafi v) Ar) L) @) Eieia, 5668 -5& _OO 717 > -5661 EFW _OR 8;6?& tmh Ephx

Ocurt cgshrvha es uiahr -et pebh 8;66 cd EFW _OR&> 'Qmh cgnhot cd èw fs tc jhth cut

nustfoh) Wfbmt tc tmh rfbmt, tft`h cr fithrhst cd e perty fi tmh fjjcveg`h prcphrty fs e

sugsteitfvh rfbmt) Gut tmh rfbmt tc ei eanuafoetfci cd tmh afsputh fi tmet ghme`d fs e

prcohaure` rfbmt tc wmfom ic cih mes e vhstha rfbmt) Qmh deftm cd tmh phcp`h fi tmh hddfoeoy cd

èw fs tmh sevfcur eia suoocur dcr tmh susthieioh cd tmh ru`h cd èw) Eiy whelhifib `flh fi

tmh nuafofe` prcohss wcuà rfp epert tmh hafdfoh cd nustfoh eia orheth e dhh`fib cd

afsf`ùsfcijhit fi tmh jfias cd tmh phcp`h cd tmh vhry èw eia ocurts) Qmh ru`hs cd

prcohaurh mevh ghhi ahvfsha es e omeiih` cr e jheis tc rhiahr sugsteitfvh cr et ghst

sugsteitfe` nustfoh wmfom fs tmh mfbmhst fithrhst cd jei eia e`jfbmty dcr tmh jeilfia) Ft fs e

dcuiaetfci dcr crahr`y mujei rhètfcis) Hque``y tmh nuafofe` prcohss smcuà ihvhr ghocjh

ei fistrujhit cd cpprhssfci cr egush cr e jheis fi tmh prcohss cd tmh Ocurt tc sugvhrt

nustfoh)'

JHWH JXQEQFCI FI WHTHIXH WHOCWA ACH_ ICQ OWHEQH QFQ@H

E)F)W) 5662 _O 7256 : 5662-2& _OO 5?2 -Ge`weit _fibm eia eictmhr hto) Ts Aeuèt

_fibm -ahea& gy @)Ws) eia ctmhrs& wmhrhfi tmh Mci"g`h _uprhjh Ocurt mes mhà es

dc``cws> Jutetfci cd e prcphrty fi tmh rhvhiuh rhocra achs ict orheth cr hxtfibufsm tft`h

icr mes ft eiy prhsujptfvh veùh ci tft`h) Ft ci`y hieg`hs tmh phrsci fi wmcsh devcur

jutetfci fs crahrha tc pey tmh èia rhvhiuh fi quhstfci) Qmus, jhrh jutetfci cd prcphrty

fi rhvhiuh rhocras achs ict orheth cr hxtfibufsm tft`h icr mes ft eiy prhsujptfvh veùh ci

tft`h) Fi suom ofroujsteiohs, jhrh`y ghoeush tmh pette mes ghhi omeibha, fi pursueioh, ft

wf`` ict ocidhr cr hxtfibufsm tft`h cd tmh pèfitfdds#rhspciahits mhrhfi cr tmh tmfra

ahdhiaeit#epph`èit mhrhfi)))

[WH_XJ[QFCI CD HIQWFH_ FI WHTHIXH WHOCWA_

Meiujeitmeppe vs Gmfjeppe F@W 566= LEW =?= _hotfci 5?? ic acugt prcvfahs tmet

eiy hitry fi rhocra cd rfbmts eia ohrtfdfha ocpy cd tmh rhbfsthr cd jutetfci cr fi tmh pette

gccl sme`` gh prhsujha tc gh truh uitf` tmh ocitrery fs prcvha cr e ihw hitry fs èwdu``y

sugstftutha tmhrhdcr)


23/29

XI@H__ QWEI_DHWHH H_QEG@F_MH_ QMEQ MH ME_ QELHI WHE_CIEG@H OEWH QC

E_OHWQEFI QMH QFQ@H CD MF_ QWEI_DHWCW, _XOM QWEI_DHW_ OEIICQ GH

TE@FAEQHA

F@W 7;;? Ler) 5221 \Je`èppe Eafvhppe Meaepea Ts) _jt) Wuarewwe eia CtmhrsZ< wmhrhfi

tmh rhvhiuh rhocras stcca fi tmh iejh cd tmh treisdhrcr et tmh tfjh wmhi tmh treisdhrhh

puromesha tmh prcphrty eia tmfs Ocurt mhà tmet ui`hss tmh treisdhrhh hsteg`fsmhs tmet mh

mea telhi rhescieg`h oerh tc esohrtefi tmh rfbmt cr tft`h cd tmh treisdhrcr eia tmh treisdhrhh

mea eotha fi bcca deftm, tmcubm tmh _e`h Ahhas erh dcr ve`fa ocisfahretfci fs ftsh`d mhà tc gh

ict suddfofhit tc ve`faeth suom treiseotfci uiahr _hotfci 15 cd tmh Eot)

WHTHIXH HIQWFH_ * WFBMQ_ QC [WC[HWQV * OFTF@ OCXWQ F_ E[[WC[WFEQH DCWXJ

7;;4 LEW

NX_QFOH A)T) _my`hiare Lujer, cd Lerietele Mfbm ocurt fi tmh oesh cd Ihrfe Hsteths Wure`

Fiaustrfhs ))) vs _teth Cd Lerietele Eia Crs) Whpcrtha fi 7;;4 -5& Ler@N 768 Qmh fjpubiha

crahr fs cih pessha gy tmh Qemsfàer eotfib es e Whvhiuh Eutmcrfty dcr tmh purpcsh cd

smcwfib tmh iejh cd tmh Bcvhrijhit fi tmh rhvhiuh rhocras) Qmh Qemsfàer eots es e

duiotfciery uiahr tmh Lerietele @eia Whvhiuh Eot, 5641 eia eiy vfhw hxprhssha fs ci`y

fiofahite`) Ft fs truh tmet tmh Qemsfàer fs ict tmh eutmcrfty tc ahthrjfih tmh rfbmts cd tmh

pertfhs fioùafib tc rhocra e dfiafib cr tc hxprhss e vfhw es tc wmc fs tmh cwihr cd e

pertfouèr pfhoh cd èia cr hvhi fi rhsphot cd tmh hitfrh hxthit cd èia tc wmfom tmh

phtftfcihr mea scubmt dcr ocidhrjhit cd cooupeioy rfbmts tc sey tmet tmh èias erh vhstha

wftm tmh _teth eia tmh Bcvhrijhit fs tmh cwihr)

EIV CIH METFIB QFQ@H QC GH _MCRI E_ LMEQHAEW

Q) _faahsmf vs Qmh Ahputy Ocjjfssfcihr, EFW 7;;5 Leit 762, F@W 7;;5 LEW 1== Qmh

icrje` rhqufrhjhits fi tmh @eia Whvhiuh Eot es phr tmh prcvfsfcis cd _hotfci 57= eiy

phrsci wmc pcsshsshs tft`h tc tmh èia fi quhstfci mes rfbmt tc gh smcwi es lmethaer fi tmh

rhocra cd rfbmts rhbfsthr eia jutetfci rhbfsthrs) Mcwhvhr, gy suom ei hitry ic fidhrhioh

oei gh arewi rhberafib tmh tft`h tc tmh prcphrty) _fioh tmh hitrfhs fi tmh rhvhiuh rhocras

erh ict acoujhits cd tft`h eia oeiict gh tmh sc`h gesfs tc prcvh tmh tft`h gy ftsh`d) Gut tmh

sefa hitrfhs jey mevh e ocrrcgcretfvh veùh dcr prcvfib tmh tft`h)

WH@HTEIOV CD _QEQHJHIQ JEAH AXWFIB JXQEQFCI [WCOHHAFIB_ 7;;? _O


24/29

NX_QFOH Acrefswejy Wenu $ NX_QFOH _mfveren T) [etf` cd Qmh _uprhjh Ocurt cd Fiafe fi oesh

cd Jemfè Genreibf -ahea& tmrcubm @)Ws) $ Crs T_ Gearfgef w#c Nebeiietm $ Eir) 7;;? -7&

_OO 141 Jutetfci prcohhafibs ghdcrh rhvhiuh eutmcrftfhs erh ict nuafofe` prcohhafibs fi

eiy Ocurt cd èw eia achs ict ahofah quhstfcis cd tft`h tc fjjcveg`h prcphrty) Whvhiuh

eutmcrfty crahrfib jutetfci cd rhvhiuh rhocras oeiict gh [rcteitc mhà tc gh e ofvf` ocurt

cd ociourrhit eia ocjphthit nurfsafotfci tc eanuafoeth quhstfcis cd tft`h tc fjjcveg`h

prcphrty)

WHTHIXH ACOXJHIQ_ EWH ICQ ACOXJHIQ CD QFQ@H FQ WEF_H_ [WHXJ[QFCI

XIAHW HTFAHIOH EOQ

EFW 7;;= _O 6;5 , BXWXIEQM JEICMEW [ETE_LEW $ CW_ T_ IEBH_M _FAAE[[E

IETE@BXIA $ CW_ E rhvhiuh rhocra fs ict e acoujhit cd tft`h) Ft jhrh`y refshs e

prhsujptfci fi rhbera tc pcsshssfci) [rhsujptfci cd pcsshssfci eia#cr ocitfiufty tmhrhcd

gctm dcrwera eia geolwera oei e`sc gh refsha uiahr s)55; cd tmh Hvfahioh Eot)

QEM_F@AEW OEIICQ AHOFAH QMH WFBMQ_ CD [EWQFH_ CI _E@H AHHA

_) _mfveiie vs Qmh _phofe` Qemsfàer Eia Crs) 7;;4 -5& LOOW 487, Ft fs ict tmh duiotfci cd

tmh Qemsfàer dcr tmh ahthrjfietfci cd tmh rfbmts cd pertfhs `flh e Ofvf` Ocurt wftm rhbera tc

tmh fithrhst tmh dcurtm rhspciahit ocuà stf`` oèfj uiahr tmh se`h ahha cd tmh yher 5671

eia ft fs e jetthr hsshitfe``y dcr tmh Ofvf` Ocurt eia ict dcr tmh Qemsfàer) @flhwfsh tmh

omeibh cd tmh iejh fi tmh rhvhiuh rhocras fd et e`` wes jeah fi devcur cd tmh phtftfcihr fi

tmh yher 5648 eia es ocithiaha gy tmh dcurtm rhspciahit, ft fs gy pèyfib' dreua hto), crwftm ociocotha acoujhits cr ctmhrwfsh, hvhi suom e``hbetfcis cd dreua hto), fs e jetthr tmet

smcuà gh jeah bcca ghdcrh e Ofvf` Ocurt eia ict ghdcrh tmh Whvhiuh Eutmcrftfhs)

Eutmcrftfhs `flh Qemsfàer tcte``y èol nurfsafotfci tc rhiahr dfiafib cr jelh e

ahthrjfietfci hftmhr fi rhsphot cd ei eot cd dreua cr dcr ahoèrfib tmh rfbmts fi devcur cd eiy

pertfhs uiahr e se`h ahha hto)

QMH @CIB OCXW_H CD HIQWFH_ FI WHTHIXH WHOCWA_ OEIICQ GH FBICWHA FI

[WHDHWHIOH QC QMH HIQWFH_ DCW E _C@FQEWV VHEW)

Qmh _uprhjh Ocurt mcwhvhr fi tmh oesh cd G)_)T) QHJ[@H v) [) LWF_MIE JXWQMF, EFW

562? _O 5766, -562?& 7 _OO 745 struol e icth cd oeutfci wftm rhbera tc hitrfhs fi tmh

rhvhiuh rhocras) Ft pcfitha cut tmet tmh prhsujptfci erfsfib drcj shvhre` hitrfhs fi tmh

rhvhiuh rhocras cd èrbh iujghr cd yhers fi rhsphot cd cwihrsmfp eia pcsshssfci cd èia

wftm ohrtefi phrsci achs ict steia rhguttha gy jhrh strey hitrfhs fi devcur cd ctmhr wmhi


25/29

tmh hvfahioh fs cd uiohrtefi omereothr eia fs fieahqueth) )) Qmh `cib ocursh cd hitrfhs

wmfom whrh ocisfsthit`y fi devcur cd tmh Eromeles oeiict gh fbicrha fi prhdhrhioh tc tmh

hitrfhs fi devcur cd tmh thjp`h dcr e sc`ftery yher)

[WH_XJ[QFCI CD OCWWHOQIH__ OEI E[[@V CI@V QC BHIXFIH, ICQ DCWBHA CW

DWEXAX@HIQ, HIQWFH_

Fi Tfsmwe Tfney Gmeretf v) Delmru` Messei eia ctmhrs, EFW 5624 _O 51=8, ahe`fib wftm

hitrfhs fi rhvhiuh rhocras eia shotfcis ?8 eia 551 cd tmh Hvfahioh Eot, tmh _uprhjh Ocurt

mhà es dc``cws> 'Ft fs truh tmet tmh hitrfhs fi tmh rhvhiuh rhocra cubmt, bhihre``y, tc gh

eoohptha et tmhfr deoh veùh eia ocurts smcuà ict hjgerl upci ei epph`èth fiqufry fitc

tmhfr ocrrhotihss) Gut tmh prhsujptfci cd ocrrhotihss oei epp`y ci`y tc bhiufih, ict dcrbha

cr dreuau`hit, hitrfhs) Qmh afstfiotfci jey gh dfih gut ft fs o`her, tmh afstfiotfci fs tmet cih

oeiict ome``hibh tmh ocrrhotihss cd wmet tmh hitry fi tmh rhvhiuh rhocra steths, gut tmh

hitry fs cphi tc tmh etteol tmet ft wes jeah dreuau`hit`y cr surrhptftfcus`y) Dreua eia

dcrbhry rcg e acoujhit cd e`` fts `hbe` hddhot eia oeiict dcuia e oèfj tc pcsshsscry tft`h')

RMHI _CJH CIH WHBF_QHW_ _E@H AHHA CD WHE@ CRIHW_ [WC[HWQV*RFQMCXQ

EXQMCWF_EQFCI, OCI_HUXHIOH_ EIA C[QFCI_ @HDQ QC WHE@ CRIHW

NX_QFOH W Wevhhiarei fi tmh oesh cd J) Wejelrfsmie Whaay vs _ug*Whbfstrer,

Wenenfieber, EFW 7;;; Leit 14, F@W 5666 LEW 7;?? Fi vfhw cd tmh egcvh, wmhi e phrsci

wmc oèfjs tc gh tmh cwihr cr e phrsci fithrhstha fi ei fjjcveg`h prcphrty, dfias tmet

scjhcih h`sh mes hxhoutha eia rhbfsthrha e se`h ahha cr ctmhr ahha fi rhbera tc mfsprcphrty, oèfjfib tc gh tmh cwihr cr e phrsci fithrhstha fi tmh prcphrty, tmh epprcprfeth

ocursh dcr mfj fs tc df`h e suft dcr ahoèretfci eia ocishquhitfe` rh`fhds) Fd mh fs setfsdfha suom

se`h ahha fs hxhoutha gy e phrsci wftmcut eiy tft`h eia tmet tmh ahha fs vcfa eg fiftfc, mh

jey hvhi omccsh tc fbicrh tmh sejh eia `hevh ft tc tmh phrsci oèfjfib tft`h uiahr suom

ahha tc hsteg`fsm mfs tft`h fi epprcprfeth prcohhafibs) E Ocurt cd @ew mes tmh nurfsafotfci tc

ahoèrh e acoujhit tc gh vcfa cr hvhi oeioh` e acoujhit) Gut uiahr ic ofroujsteiohs, e

phrsci oèfjfib tc gh tmh cwihr cd e prcphrty cr e mcàhr cd e prcphrty, oei rhqufrh tmh

Whbfsthrfib Eutmcrfty tc oeioh` tmh rhbfstretfci cd e acoujhit cr tc oeioh` tmh hitry jeah

fi Gccl Ic) 5 fi rhbera tc e rhbfsthrha acoujhit cr tc ah`hth cr rhjcvh tmh hitry jeah fi

tmh fiahxhs rhètfib tc Gccl Ic) 5) Qmh Whbfsthrfib Cddfohr mes ic suom pcwhr)

Ocishquhit`y, tmh quhstfci cd tmh Whbfsthrfib Cddfohr ah`htfib eiy hitry hftmhr drcj tmh

Fiahxhs cd Gccl Ic) 5 cr tmh hxtreots tmhrhdrcj ocitefiha fi tmh Hioujgreioh Ohrtfdfoeth

gy mcàfib treiseotfci ocvhrha gy e rhbfsthrha fistrujhit fs f``hbe` cr vcfa, achs ict erfsh)


26/29

_XFQ DCW OEIOH@@EQFCI CD FI_QWXJHIQ GV E [HW_CI RMC AFA ICQ H]HOXQH

QMH ACOXJHIQ RCX@A ICQ @FH

E Du`` Ghiom cd Jeares Mfbm Ocurt fi Juppuaetmf v) Lrfsmieswejf EFW 564; Jeares 5

-D)G)& wmhi tmh fistrujhit#acoujhit fs ict hxhoutha gy tmh pèfitfdd, tmh sejh achs ict

orheth e o`cua upci tmh tft`h cd tmh truh cwihr icr achs ft orheth epprhmhisfci tmet ft jey

gh e scuroh cd aeibhr) Eoocrafib`y, e suft dcr oeioh`ètfci cd fistrujhit gy e phrsci wmc

afa ict hxhouth tmh acoujhit wcuà ict `fh)

[WH_XJ[QFCI CD C@A ACOXJHIQ_ XIAHW _HOQFCI 6; AF_OWHQFCI CD OCXWQ QC

EOOH[Q FQ _ME@@ GH H]OHWOF_HA RFQM WHE_CI_

_rf @elif Geruei Eia Ctmhrs vs _rf [eaje Leite Le`fte $ Crs 5664 EFW 578?, NQ

5664 -?& 74= _hotfci 6; cd tmh Hvfahioh Eot fs dcuiaha ci ihohssfty eia ocivhifhioh

ghoeush ft fs hxtrhjh`y afddfou`t eia scjhtfjhs ict pcssfg`h tc `hea hvfahioh tc prcvh

meiawrftfib, sfbieturh cr hxhoutfci cd cà acoujhits edthr èpsh cd tmfrty yhers) Fi crahr tc

cgvfeth suom afddfou`tfhs cr fjprcgegf`ftfhs tc prcvh hxhoutfci cd ei cà acoujhit, _hotfci

6; mes ghhi fiocrpcretha fi tmh Hvfahioh Eot, wmfom achs ewey wftm tmh strfot ru`h cd prccd

cd prfveth acoujhits) [rhsujptfci cd bhiufihihss jey gh refsha fd tmh acoujhits fi

quhstfci fs prcauoha drcj prcphr oustcay) Ft fs, mcwhvhr, tmh afsorhtfci cd tmh Ocurt tc

eoohpt tmh prhsujptfci d`cwfib drcj _hotfci 6;) Qmhrh fs, mcwhvhr, ic jeiihr cd acugt

tmet nuafofe` afsorhtfci uiahr _hotfci 6; smcuà ict gh hxhrofsha ergftrerf`y eia ict ghfib

fidcrjha gy rhescis)

RMHI _CXWOH CD QFQ@H F_ ICQ AF_O@C_HA JHWH _QEQHJHIQ RFQMCXQ [WCCD

CD ACOXJHIQ E_ QC _CXWOH CD QFQ@H F_ ICQ WH@HTEIQ

[regmeler Easu`h vs _teth Cd J)[) $ Eir 7;;1 EFW ?882 : 7;;1 -55 & _OO 716 Fi tmh

pèfit tmh scuroh cd _cjenf"s tft`h wes ict afso`csha eia ft wes jhrh`y stetha tmet mh wes

cwihr cd tmh afsputha èia eia tmh sejh wes ocjfib fi mfs pcsshssfci sfioh 565=) Fi mfs

stethjhit fi Ocurt, tmh pèfitfdd oejh cut wftm e oesh tmet tmh èia mea ghhi bfvhi gy wey

cd breit) Mcwhvhr, tmh pèfitfdd afa ict `hea eiy lfia cd hvfahioh tc prcvh tmh deotuj cd

breit) Ic acoujhit wes prcauoha tc smcw tmet tmh èia mea ghhi bfvhi gy wey cd breit

hftmhr tc _cjenf cr tc mfs eiohstcrs)

WH[@V QC OCIQHIQFCI_ WEF_HA GV [@EFIQFDD OCXI_H@>*

5) Qmh ahdhiaeit*7 ocuish` mes df`ha jhjc eoohptfib tmh p`heafibs cd A*5)


27/29

Qmfs ocithitfci fs frrh`hveit sfioh tmh Ahdhiaeit*7 mes ic phrscie` licw`habh cd suom

stethjhit eia mh mes ict sfbiha hvhi jhjc) Es phr Crahr TF Wu`h 51 cd O[O wmfom seys

Hvhry p`heafib sme`` gh sfbiha gy tmh perty eia mfs p`heahr -fd eiy&> [rcvfaha tmet wmhrh e

perty p`heafib fs, gy rhesci cd egshioh cr dcr ctmhr bcca oeush, uieg`h tc sfbi tmh p`heafib,

ft jey gh sfbiha gy eiy phrsci au`y eutmcrfsha gy mfj tc sfbi tmh sejh cr tc suh cr ahdhia

ci mfs ghme`d) Fi sugsteitfetfib tmh egcvh ocithitfci, Nuabjhit cd Lerietele Mfbm Ocurt fi

_rf _mejrec Wulejeiie Qe`wer vs _jt) _uverie rhpcrtha fi F@W 7;;= LEW 516?

wmhrh fi tmh Mcig`h ocurt cgshrvha tmet Drcj e rheafib cd tmh edcrhsefa prcvfsfcis ft fs

aher tmet icrje``y e p`heafib sme`` gh sfbiha gy tmh perty) Mcwhvhr, tmhrh erh ohrtefi

hxohptfcis oervha cut) Fd gy rhesci cd egshioh cr dcr ctmhr bcca oeush tmh perty fs uieg`h tc

sfbi tmh p`heafib, ft jey gh sfbiha gy eiy phrsci auty eutmcrfzha gy mfj tc sfbi tmh sejh

cr tc suh cr ahdhia ci mfs ghme`d) Qmhrhdcrh, e phrsci wmc fs au`y eutmcrfzha gy tmh perty

jey sfbi tmh p`heafib) Mh smh jey gh e phrsci mcàfib e Bhihre` [cwhr cd Ettcrihy cr e

phrsci mcàfib suom ctmhr ve`fa eutmcrfzetfci) Qmh cgnhot cd sfbieturh eia vhrfdfoetfci fs tc

dfx upci tmh perty tmh rhspcisfgf`fty dcr tmh stethjhits eia tc eddfrj tmh buereithh cd bcca

deftm)

7) [èfitfdd Ocuish` refshs tmet tmhrh fs sfbieturh fi H]*[51, * suom sfbieturhs erh ictjerlha eia fahitfdfha)

?) [èfitfdd Ocuish` refshs tmh ocithitfci tmet H]*A*7 hitry wmfom steths Gcbmye tcBuiaefem wmfom fs cd tmh yher 568;*85 fs ict e`` fi afsputh) Qmh @rs cd A*7 erh

oèfjfib tft`h drcj 5686 se`h ahha)

1) [èfitfdd ocuish` sugjfts tmet prcphrty fi H]*A2 gh`cibs tc pèfitfdd Es phr A*2 ftgh`cibs tc A*7, de`sfty fi sugjfssfci e`sc)

8) [èfitfdd ocuish` sugjfts tmet tmh Essfsteit ocjjfssfcihr crahr fi H]*A?8 fs ictwcrtmy sfioh tmh jetthr fs phiafib ghdcrh ofvf` ocurt) Qmh sejh prfiofp`h fs

epp`foeg`h tc pèfitfdd wmc bct crahr fi H]*[1 wmhi tmh jetthr fs phiafib

ghdcrh ofvf` ocurt) Qmfs fs hqufty wmfom mes ghhi dcrbctthi gy `heriha ocuish`)

4) [èfitfdd ocuish` sugjfts tmet C_ 5?6#7;;1 ahorhh mes bcih tmhfr sfah) * Ic ft fsci`y afsjfsse` cd pèfitfdd suft eia ict ahoèretfci cd ahdhiaeits rfbmts fi tmet

oesh)

2) [èfitfdd ocuish` sugjfts tmet 55H slhtom H][*5;, smcws tmhfr pcsshssfci Gut tmethxmfgft fs jerlha wftm cgnhotfci eia pèfitfdd def`s tc `hea prcphr hvfahioh

cvhr tmh acoujhit tc prcvh ft) Jcrh cvhr tmh 55H slhtom fs etthjptha dcr

pertftfci eia ft fs ict dcr eiy treisdhr cd èia tmrcubm tmhfr se`h ahha) Qmh

hitfrh acoujhit fs ociocotha es mhà fi H]*A?8 $ H]*A14)


28/29

=) [èfitfdd ocuish` oèfjs tmet shvhre` acoujhits prcauoha gy ahdhiaeit erh fi tmhfrdevcur Gut def`ha tc ocivfioh wmfom erh fi tmhfr devcur eia wmy tmhy mevh ict

prcauoha ft fi tmhfr hvfahioh)

OCIO@X_FCI>*

Es cgshrvha egcvh pèfitfdd mes ah`fghreth`y def`ha fi mfs oesh wftm e`` licw`habh es tc mfs

de`sh, fiocjp`hth, ocidusfib eia dreuau`hit rhprhshitetfci) Qmh pèfitfdd mes ict

epprceomha ocurt wftm o`hei meias eia du`` deots) Ah`fghreth`y supprhssha trutm) [èfitfdd

mes meressha tmh @rs cd ahdhiaeit*7 eia jeah e de`sh oesh eia ui*mhe`tmy oc` usfci) Qmh

fjpcsftfci cd mhevy eia rhe` ocst tc tmh tuih cd Ws 8;,;;;*;; es phrjfttha uiahr ejhiaha

O[O ebefist afsmcihst `ftfbeit fs tmh ept scùtfci) Ft fs e shtt`ha prcpcsftfci cd èw gy e

oethie cd nuabjhits cd tmh _uprhjh Ocurt tmet eiy perty oèfjfib rh`fhd ghdcrh ocurts cd

Nustfoh, fs auty gcuia tc jelh e truh eia ocrrhot afso`csurh cd e`` tmh jethrfe` eia rh`hveit

deots fi tmh phtftfci) E `ftfbeit wmc epprceomhs tmh Ocurt, fs gcuia tc prcauoh e`` tmh

acoujhits hxhoutha gy mfj wmfom erh rh`hveit tc tmh `ftfbetfci) Fd mh wftmmcàs e vfte`

acoujhit cr fidcrjetfci fi crahr tc befi eaveitebh ci tmh ctmhr sfah tmhi mh wcuà gh

buf`ty cd pèyfib dreua ci tmh Ocurt es wh`` es ci tmh ctmhr perty) _uom `ftfbeit smcuà gh

mhevf`y phie`fsha tc shia strcib sfbie` tc tmh afsmcihst `ftfbeits)

Rmhrhdcrh ft fs mujg`y preyha tc afsjfss tmh suft cd pèfitfdd wftm mhevy phie` ocsts

fi tmh hias cd Nustfoh)

Aeth>*

Buggf Eavcoeth dcr @rs cd A*7


29/29

FI QMH OCXWQ CD OFTF@ NXABH -NW AI& EIA NJDO OCXWQEQBXGGF

C)_) 7;8#7;;1

[@EFIQFDD T_ AHDHIAEIQ_

JE@@EFEM $ CW_ _EIIEXBWEFEM $ CW_

@F_Q CD OFQEQFCI_ _XGJFQQHA FI QMH DCWJ CD OA CI GHME@D CD @W_ CD A*7

IC OFQEQFCI [EWQFOX@EW_

5 AE@F[ _FIBM T) _QEQH CD X)[), -7;5;& 7 _OO 551

7 Q)@) IEBHIAWE GEGX T_ JEICMEW WEC [EREW WH[CWQHA FI F@W 7;;8 LEW ==1

? _)[)OMHIBE@TEWEVE IEFAX T_) NEBEIIEQM, WH[CWQHA FI 5661 -5& _OO 5

1 WEJ OMEIAWE _FIBM T_) _ETFQWF AHTF EIA CQMHW_, WH[CWQHA FI -7;;?& = _OO ?56

8 WENH_M A) AEWGEW EIA CW_) T) IEWE_FIBWEC LWF_MIENF LX@LEWIF EIA CW_) , -7;;?& 2

_OO 756

4 OMEIAWE _ME_MF T) EIF@ LXJEW THWJE, -5668& 5 _OO 175,

2 AW) GXAAMF LCQE _XGGEWEC T) L) [EWE_EWEI $ CW_) EFW 5664 _O 74=2

= LE@VEI _FIBM OMCXMEI T_ O)[)NC_MF 7;55 EFW 5572 : 7;55 -7 & _OW 754

6 JEMEAHCWEC _XLENF _MFTEILEW T_) WEJEWEQEI GE[X $ CW_ -7;;1& 2 _OO 5=5

5; [WEQE[ WEF QEIREIF T_) XQQEJ OMEIA -7;;1 -=& _OO 16;&,

55 WEJ _EWEI EIA EIW) T) _JQ) BEIBE AHTF, EFW 5627 _O 74=8,

57 NEILF TE_MAHC GMCNREIF $ EIW) T_ FIAX_FIA GEIL @QA) $ CW_) EFW 7;;8 _O 1?65? ICCWAXAAFI T) AW) L) @) EIEIA, 5668 -5& _OO 717 > -5661 EFW _OR 8;6?&

51 E)F)W) 5662 _O 7256 : 5662-2& _OO 5?2 -GE@REIQ _FIBM EIA EICQMHW HQO) T_ AEX@EQ_FIBM -AHEA& GV @)W_) EIA CQMHW_&

58 MEIXJEIQME[[E T_ GMFJE[[E F@W 566= LEW =?=

54 F@W 7;;? LEW) 5221 \JE@@E[[E EAFTH[[E MEAE[EA T_) _JQ) WXAWERRE EIA CQMHW_Z

52 IHWFE H_QEQH_ WXWE@ FIAX_QWFH_ ))) T_ _QEQH CD LEWIEQELE EIA CW_) WH[CWQHA FI

7;;4 -5& LEW@N 768

5= Q) _FAAH_MF T_ QMH AH[XQV OCJJF__FCIHW, EFW 7;;5 LEIQ 762, F@W 7;;5 LEW 1==

56 JEMF@E GENWEIBF -AHEA& QMWCXBM @)W_) $ CW_ T_ GEAWFGEF R#C NEBEIIEQM $ EIW)

7;;? -7& _OO 1417; EFW 7;;= _O 6;5 , BXWXIEQM JEICMEW [ETE_LEW $ CW_ T_ IEBH_M _FAAE[[E

IETE@BXIA $ CW_

75 _) _MFTEIIE T_ QMH _[HOFE@ QEM_F@AEW EIA CW_) 7;;4 -5& LOOW 487

77 G)_)T) QHJ[@H T) [) LWF_MIE JXWQMF, EFW 562? _O 5766, -562?& 7 _OO 745

7? TF_MRE TFNEV GMEWEQF T) DELMWX@ ME__EI EIA CQMHW_, EFW 5624 _O 51=8

71 J) WEJELWF_MIE WHAAV T_ _XG*WHBF_QWEW, WENENFIEBEW, EFW 7;;; LEIQ 14, F@W 5666

LEW 7;??

78 JX[[XAEQMF T) LWF_MIE_REJF EFW 564; JEAWE_ 5 -D)G)&

74 _WF @ELIF GEWXEI EIA CQMHW_ T_ _WF [EAJE LEIQE LE@FQE $ CW_ 5664 EFW 578?, NQ

5664 -?& 74=72 [WEGMELEW EA_X@H T_ _QEQH CD J)[) $ EIW 7;;1 EFW ?882 : 7;;1 -55 & _OO 716

7= _rf _mejrec Wulejeiie Qe`wer vs _jt) _uverie rhpcrtha fi F@W 7;;= LEW 516?

76 Rrftthi erbujhits fi wcra dcrjet dcr ocurt ocivhifhioh

Aeth>*

Buggf Eavcoeth dcr @rs cd A 7

Documents

Written Arguments in Favour of Defendant Where Identification of Property in Dispute