38
YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

YouEDU

Staging Intelligent Interventionsin MOOC Discussion ForumsAkshay AgrawalJagadish VenkatramanShane LeonardAndreas Paepcke

Page 2: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 2

Page 3: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 3

Page 4: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 4

Page 5: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

An Intelligent Forum

Agrawal 5

Page 6: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

An Intelligent Forum

• Phase 1: Detect Confusion

Agrawal 6

Page 7: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

An Intelligent Forum

• Phase 1: Detect Confusion• Phase 2: Intervene Automatically

Agrawal 7

Page 8: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Challenges

Agrawal 8

Page 9: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Challenges

• Scale:

Agrawal 9

Page 10: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Challenges

• Scale:

• Vocabulary of confusion is domain-dependent

Agrawal 10

Page 11: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Challenges

• Scale:

• Vocabulary of confusion is domain-dependent

• TA overloaded

Agrawal 11

Page 12: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Challenges

• Scale:

• Vocabulary of confusion is domain-dependent

• TA overloaded– lack of forum structure

Agrawal 12

Page 13: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

• No tagged forum datasets• Availability of large-scale forum data

Agrawal 13

Why are forums still dumb?

Page 14: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

YouEDU

• Pre-work: Dataset– Stanford MOOCPosts

• Phase 1: Confusion Detection– Classify individual posts w.r.t. confusion

• Phase 2: Intervention–Map confused posts to video snippets

Agrawal 14

Page 15: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

MOOCPosts Dataset

• 30,000 posts,11 courses– Humanities/Sciences, Medicine,

Education

• Human-coded, 6 dimensions– confusion, sentiment, urgency [1-7]– opinion, question, answer [0/1]

Agrawal 15

http://datastage.stanford.edu/StanfordMoocPosts/

Page 16: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 16

Phase 1: Detecting Confusion

Page 17: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 17

Page 18: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 18

Page 19: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 19

Page 20: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 20

Classifier Performance

Page 21: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 21

Recap: Phase 1

Page 22: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Phase 2: Staging Interventions

Agrawal 22

Page 23: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 23

Page 24: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 24

Page 25: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 25

Page 26: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 26

Page 27: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 27

Page 28: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 28

Page 29: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 29

Page 30: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 30

Page 31: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Interventions: Evaluation

• 20 confused posts, course in statistics

• Six recommendations for each– randomize order

• 3 human raters– Label each snippet as relevant or

irrelevant

• k-precision– precision of retrieved documents,

limited to the first k recommendationsAgrawal 31

Page 32: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 32

Page 33: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

YouEDU Architecture

Agrawal 33

Page 35: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 35

Page 36: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 36

Page 37: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 37

Page 38: YouEDU Staging Intelligent Interventions in MOOC Discussion Forums Akshay Agrawal Jagadish Venkatraman Shane Leonard Andreas Paepcke

Agrawal 38