Download pdf - 05.09.2013. BRIEF OF AMICUS CURIAE LUCAS DANIEL SMITH, PRO SE, IN SUPPORT OF APPELLANTS. HUGH McINNISH, et al. vs BETH CHAPMAN, in her capacity as Secretary of State. SUPREME COURT

7/30/2019 05.09.2013. BRIEF OF AMICUS CURIAE LUCAS DANIEL SMITH, PRO SE, IN SUPPORT OF APPELLANTS. HUGH McINNI

1/40

Iasl Eh% 114:0> 1- mhiatl` ke Ohodasa- Drktksf Zrhtlithratl

hn Cleya%

Aokiusdlmklvls tfat tfl Bhvlreolets phsktkhe prh`uils `aeblrshol ae` amarokeb

prlil`let% Rflrlnhrl fl annadmy ae` rlsplitnummy ohvls tfks Fhehradml Ihurt th ihesk`lr fks

drkln ke supphrt hn tfl Applmmaets%


8/40

:


9/40

:0;-

`kstkebuksfl`%

9% Pfl Pwlmntf Aoleòlet `hls eht dar a phmktkiam party nrho rlqukrkeb hn a iae`kàtl nhr

Zrlsk`letkam Lmlithr ke kts prkoary a pml`bl th supphrt tfl ehokells hn kts Eatkheam Ihevletkhe%%

0% Pfl rlqukrlolet hn suif a pml`bl `hls eht `ley lquam prhtlitkhe hr ùl prhilss ue`lr

tfl Nhurtlletf Aoleòlet%Ekxhe v% Flre`he- 429 \%Y% - `kstkebuksfl`%

Kt sfhum` amsh dl ehtl` tfat- aiihr`keb th Drae`he Thttkebfaus- \ekvlrskty hn Plxas-

Asshikatl Zrhnlsshr hn Zhmktkiam Yikleil ae` tfl Yleathr @he Fle`lrshe Yifhmar- tfl Fhehradml

Prkam Ihurt ae` tfl Fhehradml Amadaoa Yuprlol Ihurt `h favl sudglit/oattlr gurks`kitkhe

iheilrekeb tfl lmlitkhe &ae` rllmlitkhe+ hn a \Y Zrlsk`let% &sllIheimuskhe- pp% 1> tfru 1;+

Nurtflrohrl- tfl Applmmaets praylr nhr prl/lmlitkhe &ZHP\Y+ rlmkln ks uelqukvhiammy eht

ohht% Applmmaets ifammlebl th sfhrt/tlro iheùit wfkif oay rliur ke tfl nuturl ks `lehokeatl`

as a `ksputl iapadml hn rlpltktkhe- ylt lva`keb rlvklw%YllYhutflre Zaiknki Plrokeam Ih% v%

KII- 41; \%Y% 0;6-


10/40

: \%Y% 11;+- Applmmaets- wfh wlrl ke`lple`let iae`k`atls nhr prlsk`letkam lmlithrs nrho Kmmkehks ke tfl

1;>6 lmlitkhe- shubft `limarathry ae` kegueitkvl rlmkln nrho a `lekam hn ilrtknkiatkhe dy applmmlls-

olodlrs hn tfl Ytatl"s Lmlithram Dhar`% Ae Kmmkehks statutl prhvk`ls tfat ehokeatkeb pltktkhes nhr

ke`lple`let iae`k`atls oust favl 4


11/40

:

lva`keb rlvklw%$ Thsarkh v% Thiclnlmmlr- 01: \% Y% 2 &1;>;+3 Yhutflre Zaiknki Plrokeam Ih% v% KII- 41; \% Y% 0;6- 41; \% Y%


12/40

:1%

Aokius fas prhhn%

Ke tfl ohetf hn Nldruary 4::;Aokius was he tfl ihetkelet hn Anrkia ke tfl @lohiratki

Tlpudmki hn tfl Ihebh ae` tfl Tlpudmki hn tfl Ihebh% Pfks was ehtAokiusnkrst trkp th tfl `arc

ihetkelet% Pfl nkrst tkol tfatAokius slt nhht he Anrkiae shkm was ke tfl ylar 4::2% Ke Nldruary hn

4::;Aokius travlml` th tfl Ihebh th `hiuolet tfl sthry hn a iryptk` &as ke irypthzhhmhby+

aekoam tfat mkvls tflrl ke tfl Ihebh%

Pfks nadml` irlaturl ks a `kehsaur/mkcl aekoam tfat ks ihoohemy rlnlrrl` th as Ohclml

Odlodl% Kt sfhum` dl ehtl` tfat htflr suif fk``le- hr heil nadml`- aekoams favl dlle

`ksihvlrl` ke wfat ks ehw tfl @lohiratki Tlpudmki hn tfl Ihebh% Pfl aekoam ehw cehwe th

ohst hn tfl whrm` as tfl Hcapk was heil ihesk`lrl` th dl a oytfkiam irlaturl dy Lurhplaes wfh

rlnlrrl` th kt as tfl Anrkiae \ekihre%

Ke tfl saol ohetf hn Nldruary 4::;Aokius travlml` tfrhubfhut dhtf hn tfl Ihebhs-

\bae`a ae` Cleya%Aokius wlet th Eakrhdk- Cleya spliknkiammy th ketlrvklw a oae wfh imakos

th favl slle tfl aekoam &Ohclml Odlodl+ ylars abh wfle fl was a shm`klr ke tfl Ihebh%


13/40

:


14/40

:


15/40

:


16/40

:


17/40

:


18/40

:


19/40

:1% Fl was dhre th a natflr wfh fkoslmn was dhre ke tfl Ihmhey hn Cleya% Pfl natflr-

Daraic Fusslke Hdaoa Yr &dhre ke 1;9> hr 1;90+- elvlr aiqukrl` \Y iktkzlesfkp wfle fl was ke

tfl \ektl` Ytatls hn Aolrkia vka a stu`let vksa%

Aokius fas dlle prhvk`l` wktf- vka a irl`kdml Cleyae shuril- a ihpy hn Daraic Fusslke

Hdaoa Yrs 1;0+ Tlpudmki hn Cleya Zassphrt%

Pfl dkh`ata mkstl` ke Daraic Fusslke Hdaoa Yrs 1;%1;90 &k%l%- Guel 16- 1;90+i% Lyls7 Dmaic`% Fakr7 Dmaicl% Flkbft7


20/40

:0/kssul` Tlpudmki hn Cleya Zassphrt

keimu`ls- tfhubf ks eht mkoktl` th- tfl nhmmhwkeb7

a% Eatkheam Ytatus7 Iktkzle hn Cleya%d% @atl hn dkrtf7 16%>%1;9> &k%l%- Guel 16- 1;9>+% Ehtl tfat tfl 1;


21/40

:

IHEIM\YKHE

\Y Yleathr Pl` Iruz &T/PV+- wfhsl ihopmltl eaol applars th dl Tanalm L`war` Iruz- applars

th favl dlle dhre he @lilodlr 44- 1;2: ke Iambary- Amdlrta ke tfl ihuetry hn Iaeaà%

Iruz was nhur ylars hm` dlnhrl fl ohvl`- wktf fks parlets- th tfl \ektl` Ytatls hn Aolrkia%

\emkcl Daraic Fusslke Hdaoa KK- wfh prhdadmy hemy splet a euodlr hn àys ke Cleya dlnhrl

ihokeb th tfl \YA- Iruz applars th favl splet at mlast tfl nkrst nhur &0+ ylars hn fks mknl ke

Iaeaà dlnhrl ihokeb th tfl \YA% Nhur ylars ks a rlmatkvlmy mheb tkol plrkh` hn tkol%

Iruzs natflr- Tanalm Iruz- was a Iudae kookbraet ke tfl \ektl` Ytatls hn Aolrkiae ùrkeb

tfl Iudae Tlvhmutkhe% Fl iaol th tfl \YA ke 1; rue ae` fas dlle lvlr skeil Iruz whe tfl 4:14 \Y Yleatl lmlitkhe ae`

ehtadmy ohrl sh ehw antlr ae Hithdlr 4;- 4:14 spllif bkvle dy Iruz ke Rasfkebthe- @I at tfl

Aolrkiae Zrkeikpmls Zrhglit ke wfkif Iruz ketrhùil` a iheilpt wfkif fl iamms Hpphrtuekty

Iheslrvatkso%

Drae`he Thttkebfaus- \ekvlrskty hn Plxas- Asshikatl Zrhnlsshr hn Zhmktkiam Yikleil ae` tfl

Yleathr @he Fle`lrshe Yifhmar- fas wlkbfl` ke rlbar`keb Iruz ae` tfl Eaturam Dhre Iktkzle

imausl saykeb tfat tfl stkickeb phket ihols nrho wfat tfl `lnkektkhe hn a eaturam dhre iktkzle ks-

ae` wfltflr Iruzs Iaea`kae dkrtfpmail ks a``rlssl` dy tfl maw% Eaturam dhre iktkzlesfkp ks eht


22/40

:1- ae` sfl fa`

eht dlle a \Y Iktkzle nhr tfl rlqukrl` < ylars antlr abl 10 dliausl a plrkh` hn < ylars fa` eht

ylt traespkrl`%+

Kt sfhum` dl ehtl` flrl tfat prhnlsshr ^hmhcf iamms fkoslmn a nrkle` hn Iruz ae` fas cehwe

fko skeil tfl 1;;:s% Kt sfhum` amsh dl ehtl` flrl tfat ke 4::6 ^hmhcf wrhtl adhut Daraic

Hdaoa ae` iaol th tfl saol iheimuskhe rlbar`keb lmkbkdkmkty%

Zltlr G% Ypkrh- wfh fhm`s tfl Ifarmls Rlkelr Ifakr ke ketlreatkheam maw- at Plopml

\ekvlrskty says tfat- Pl` Iruz `k`et eaturamkzl% Fl was eaturam at dkrtf%


23/40

: K whum` mkcl- ae` `loae`- tfl Amadaoa Ylirltary hn Ytatl

tacl rlilkpt hn- rlvklw ae` ihenkro autfletkikty hn a taebkdml &k%l%- paplr+ ilrtknkl` ihpy hn Iruzs

hrkbkeam &k%l%- eht ae adstrait+ ilrtknkiatl hn dkrtf gust as tfl Amadaoa Ylirltary hn Ytatls sfhum`

dl rlqukrl` th tacl rlilkpt hn- rlvklw ae` ihenkro autfletkikty hn a taebkdml &k%l%- paplr+ ilrtknkl`

ihpy hn Daraic Fusslke Hdaoa KKs hrkbkeam &k%l%- eht ae adstrait+ ilrtknkiatl hn dkrtf%


24/40


25/40


26/40


27/40

:1 Ihast Zrhvkeil Blelram Fhspktam- Ohodasa- Drktksf

Zrhtlithratl hn Cleya- Ilrtknkiatl hn Dkrtf hn \Y Zrlsk`let &`l naith+ Daraic Fusslke

Hdaoa KK%


28/40


29/40

:


30/40


31/40

:

LVFKDKP I- @- L- N

Daraic Fusslke Hdaoa Yrs 1;0+%


32/40

:


33/40

:


34/40

:


35/40

:


36/40

:0/kssul` Tlpudmki hn Cleya Zassphrt &eh% >+%


37/40

:


38/40

:


39/40

:


40/40