1
PERCEPTIONS AND EXPERIENCES OF SUDANESE REFUGEE AND RUSSIAN
IMMIGRANT MEN AS FATHERS IN THE CANADIAN CONTEXT
Father Involvement Conference 2008:Diversity.Visibility.Community
Toronto, OntarioOctober 2008
David Este, Ph.D.
Admasu Tachble, Ph.D. (C)University of Calgary
This study was funded by the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council
2
OBJECTIVES
Participants will leave with an increased understanding
of the perceptions and experiences of Sudanese refugee
and Russian immigrant men as fathers.
This will involve sharing with the audience: Brief contextual information Study’s methodology and methods Salient results Implications for social work:
Education Practice Programs and services
3
FATHERHOOD AND IMMIGRATION
The importance of the family in immigration is vital
Major motivation for parents is to provide a better life for their children
Families provide security / emotional reliance Limited exploration on the impact of
immigration on fathers
Roer-Strier, et al., 2005
4
SUDANESE COMMUNITY IN CANADA AND CALGARY
In Calgary, there are approximately 7,500 Sudanese
Two major waves of Sudanese migration in the past six years (2000 and 2002)
Majority of government-assisted refugees (GARs)
Kuol & Este, 2005
5
1990s – PRESENT: “PROFESSIONAL WAVE”
Most of the incoming Russian immigrants are highly
qualified specialists who were successful in Russia and
are looking for a job in Canada to apply their skills and
knowledge.
6
METHODOLOGY
Recruitment Three human service agencies Personal contacts
7
METHODOLOGY
Sample 20 Sudanese men 14 Russian men All participants resided in Canada a minimum
of 8 months
8
METHODOLOGY
Utilization of the pragmatic qualitative method as described by Patton (2002)
Use of strategies to collect and analyze data collected in the field
9
DATA COLLECTION METHODS
Semi-structured interviews focused on: Meaning of fatherhood Values influencing practice of being a father Interaction with children Decision making in family Challenges being a father in the Canadian
context
Este & Tachable, 2006
10
METHODOLOGY
Data Analysis Thematic analysis was conducted to determine
salient themes
11
MEANING OF BEING A FATHER
Responsibilities – Provider Teacher
12
MEANING OF BEING A FATHER: RESPONSIBILITIES – PROVIDER
Being a father means a lot of responsibilities to all the
family and towards my wife and my children. You have
To look after them, buy what they need, and take care
of them.
Sudanese Male
If you want to feel like a father, you want to bring some
income to the family . . .
Russian Male
13
MEANING OF BEING A FATHER:TEACHER
Being a father means being the head of the family . . . it means one has to be very responsible to his wife, to his children . . . he must teach the children about community work and respect.
Sudanese Father
Role modeling is the most important thing because the
child would just take on the behaviour from someone else.
Russian Father
14
PROVIDING AS A FORM OF PATERNAL INVOLVEMENT
Some literature (Stearn, 1991; Christiansen & Palkovitz, 2001) contends that providing is indeed a strong and legitimate form of paternal involvement
Perspective recognizes that providing from an economic perspective enables fathers to contribute to the well-being of their families
15
SOCIAL CAPITAL
Pleck (2007), who has written extensively on fathers, states that the concept of social capital useful theoretical approach in understanding father involvement.
16
FINANCIAL AND SOCIAL CAPITAL
Two types of capital that contribute to child development: Financial Capital Social Capital: parenting behaviour that
promotes the child’s cognitive-social development, school readiness, and educational aspirations – parents’ socialization of their children (p. 198)
17
GUIDING VALUES
Sudanese Fathers Respect Children acquiring a good education Giving back to one’s community
Russian Fathers Positive family relationship Importance of getting a university education
18
LEARNING TO BE A FATHER
Males in the family The family
19
LEARNING TO BE FATHERMALES IN THE FAMILY
I learned through my father, through my uncle, the
elder uncle . . . The way they brought me up is the way
I like to bring my children up.
Sudanese Father
20
LEARNING TO BE A FATHER:FAMILY INFLUENCE
I learned from being a son of a very responsible family . . . when I grew up I pursued my education with the values of trying to keep the good name of the family.
Sudanese Father
My father and my uncle both were good examples in
my life. They gave me schooling.
Russian Father
21
EXPECTATIONS FOR CHILDREN
Better Future . . . I am expecting a better future for my
kids, and I do not want them to experience the life I am experiencing right now.
Sudanese Father
Success in Life I think that it is extremely important that he
finds himself and does something with his life . . . that would be a career, family
Russian Father
22
INTERACTION WITH CHILDREN
Spending time with their children – important for both groups of fathers
Array of activities (walking, television watching [Sudanese], swimming, going to the park, sports [Russian])
Time spent with children was contingent upon number and types of jobs held
Hours of employment
23
ROLE CHANGES
Domestic tasks Greater parenting role
24
ROLE CHANGES
Domestic Tasks - Sudanese We share the kitchen. I do not wait for her
when I come home from work. I do not wait for her to prepare food. I can do it, prepare it myself, but in the Sudan, that does not happen. A man does not go in the kitchen.
Sudanese Father
25
ROLE CHANGES
Greater Parenting Role In the Sudan, I was not concentrating a lot
[in the raising of my children] because I know that 50% of bringing up the children in the family is done by neighbours and other people . . . When I came here, I became more involved in bringing up my children in the way that I want . . . So I became more responsible and more involved in their activities in bringing up my children.
Sudanese Father
26
CHALLENGES
Underemployment Encountering racism and discrimination Discipline of children Lack of social support Social isolation
27
UNDEREMPLOYMENT/RACISM – SUDANESE
We cannot get steady jobs that pay well. Many of us
Are working in meat plants that are oppressive and take
advantage of us. At these work places, we are subject
to name calling by white workers.
Sudanese Father
28
UNDEREMPLOYMENT
My education. I am an electrical engineer but in Canada
I work only using my hands, nothing using my head
and I cannot work with my head . . . My education is a
university degree, a Bachelor’s Degree, and I want to
work in my profession.
Russian Father
29
UNDEREMPLOYMENT
Lack of Financial Security
As long as you are underpaid, you do not feel good and
all the things that you need for your children do not get
so you are really under pressure and one can get distressed. Sudanese Father
In Canada, it is not that easy to make money, making money is not easy.Russian Father
30
CHALLENGE
Discipline of Children – Adapting to Canadian System
It is difficult to be a father in Canada because all the children are controlled by the government. The parents do not have the right to tell their children what they really need.- Sudanese Father
Within communist Russian society, children need to be respectful to anybody who is older than you. But that is not the case here. - Russian Father
31
LACK OF SOCIAL SUPPORTFROM FAMILY MEMBERS
. . . there is nobody here (family) to help us . . . I do not have my parents . . . We take care of everything ourselves.
Russian Father
. . . the house (in Sudan) is with a lot of our relatives who come from the countryside so the children are taken care of by a relative.
Sudanese Father
32
DECISION MAKING RELATED TO CHILDREN
RussianThree patterns were shared by the men: Parents – joint decision making Children involvement Wife primary decision make supported by
partner Sudanese
Joint process involving partners
33
IMPLICATIONS FOR SOCIAL WORKEDUCATION IN CANADA
Content about fathers and father involvement is virtually nonexistent in the majority of social work programs in Canada; even more sparse in relation to immigrant and refugee fathers
Some attention is given in MSW program at McGill
Need for our programs to begin to include this specific content
34
IMPLICATIONS FOR SOCIAL WORK PRACTICE
Fathers’ voices need to be heard in planning and implementing: Non-paternalistic, participative
interventions, culturally tailored to the unique needs, perceptions and cultural differences of different immigrant groups.
Assessment processes need to examine the needs of immigrant / refugee men as fathers
35
DELIVERY OF PROGRAMS / SERVICES
A challenge to social work agencies is how to recruit and engage immigrant / refugee fathers
Should there be specific programs for this subpopulation?
ORShould more inclusive programs be developed to involve immigrant / refugee families?
ORIs there a combination of these service delivery approaches required?