8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
1/28
01he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
W O R K I N G P A P E R
N u m b e r 4 , M a r c h 2 0 1 0
TheMyThof excluding
ModeraTe islaMisTsinThe
arabWorld
Khalil al-Anani
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
2/28
TheMyThof excluding
ModeraTe islaMisTsinThe
arabWorld
Khalil al-Anani
W O R K I N G P A P E R
N u m b e r 4 , M a r c h 2 0 1 0
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
3/28
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
4/28
he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
,
,
M q, M B , J, ,
, M J -
P (PJ)
T S
I
K
I -
B
M
I ,
, , J, M, -
,
M S
I
I, ,
I 1979, S 1989,
1990, I I , -
M,
, , J -
I
,
S I M B -, I
S ,
S
, -
W B,
,
, ,
I
I , - I -
,
, -
S T
-
, -
z
, S
M, S
,
T S -
I-
M T
I
xecutive Summary
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
5/28
he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
T S -
I I
I -
, I -
I , I
S
T S
-- I
:
Rethink the Basic Understanding of Mod-
erate Islamists. T
S
I
I ,
S
I ,
S
Understand the Internal Dynamics of Is-
lamist Movements. T S
I -
z, -
,
Do Not Treat Democracy Promotion Sole-
ly as a Response to Terrorism. T
S -
-
-
S
;
, -
Capitalize on the New Generation of Mod-
erate Islamists. T S
I
T
;
,
, , q, ,
; -
W
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
6/28
he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
Insight j
Egypt Daily News, q
, Al Hayat,Al Ahram Weekly,Al Ghad(J), Al Watan
()
I 2008, - P V-
S C M P
B I B
C, -
Al Masry Al Youm -
M - M P S
C P
S I
, K
K - S - , C jAl Siyassa Al Dawliya, C P
S S - -
z M
I , z,
, ,
I-
I , ,
z, ,
Te Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt: Search-
ing or the ruth (2008) Dismantling the GreatWalls: ribalism, Authoritarianism, and Islamism in
the Arab World() -
, Arab Afairsj, Al Mustaqbal Al Arabi j, Arab
he uthor
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
7/28
he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
I S C M P B I, , I M I, K P, C W, M,
, K I P
T -
J
cknowledgements
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
8/28
1he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
Introduction: The New Map of Islamists
I
W W -
S q,
S -
I T z
I -
,
S I
The Meaningof ModeraTion
, -
T
S
, I
W T,
,
S, -
I
-, ,
,
, , q, -
, ,
I - T ,
, W,
-Q,
,
,
T ,
W
S S 11, 2001 ,
I
S
M M,
f
,
S ,
S -
I T
, ,
z B , S
I1
T
: C ,
S,
1 Francois Burgat,Face to Face With Political Islam, (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2003), p. 77.
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
9/28
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
10/28
3he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
I, S -
,
I M,
S, S W,
S,
, B
S M
,
S S I
, -
I -
, -
z q ,
, ,
, -
,
, , ,
,
T
S ,
-
, S -
, -
J S, ,
: , -
I z
B
I
,
j S J
S , -Q, -
W S
-Q
Iq,
,
,
T, f
J S
T S
S,
P S
: -
I
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
11/28
4he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
Exclusionary Policies: Who Stoppedthe Tsunami?
W
3 S
, M- B , -
( )
2005,
,
J 2006 P ,
W T
B B -
P , I q
T I-
q
T -
S
,
T M-
B , , f
2005 T B-
B 2004 2005, M I I- 2 W
, S -
B
, , -
, J, , -
, K, , M,
I T
I:
S
; I ;
S
T B 2004
2005,
, I
I J 2005, S S Czz
-
, , , S,
M ,
2 M , I P: T , I, J 20063 S S Czz C, , J 20, 2005
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
12/28
5he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
,
B,
W B-
j
, B J -
j
, I
(I) T J
-, - , 1993,
-
-
(SV)6 T
,
I , -
1993 ,
-
, , I ,
2007 , -
20037 T B
T
-
I C S (ICS), B-
f , , ,
M B- J
I M,
I T J -
P
S 2007
,
I I-
(II) I
(I) T PJ j -
P (P)
,
T
B
2004
2005,
T
M B, -
, ,
S, -
B
z B
T
2007, B-
I
2008, ,
4 M -
,
B,
,
B, M -
5 T
P
T B - -
C T
5,
-
(marjiiyya) T
2 C
I
S, 88 -
j -
,
4 K -S, B , M, B, , M B, B ,
5 T B M B f I S C
6 P, 7 S 2007 , I ,
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
13/28
6he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
I C M (),
-
K ,
K M-
B,
, ,
T S
,
,
(
) I , S z
, -
,
10
, S
S
,
S
11
I , S
-
, I
C (I) ,
2011 S
V W j
S Mj
-Z, P I ,
W S
12 I , -
- V V
C
325,
2002
T PJ
I -
C M 20038
M, PJ, ,
-
j M M
C W , T -
-
- -
,
,
, 9
,
,
(T,
- I-
,
- )
T -
I S,
B T
K-
2008 , S
8 M 16, 2003, , , C, S K B , M S S; 41 S B,
Washington Post, M 18, 20039 M M C W, T , Journal o Democrac 19, 1 (2008), 19-33
10 K 2008 , J B, S I Kuwait imes, M30, 2008
11 J -Q, B -S, -z, z -, Aljarida (K; ), J 5, 2008,
12 -S M, Z, C S P , I ( ), M 2, 2007, ; S , S , 24, 2004,
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
14/28
7he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
M zz, B-
, M M, P
B, M , -
B
, -,
, ,
, I -Z, K
z I 2007-8,
B-
- j,
-
B , K -
S, --,
, I
M B
, -
z
z ,
B ,
, -
, -
B
T
J 2010 M B -
T B ,
M B, z ,
-
B,
B -
( -
, q
) W
,
-
I
; ,
13 T
S - I -
The induSTryof exTreMiSM
T I -
-
T q S -
: W
S
-- I
z -
T
,
-
,
I
I , -
, , -
I 1950 1960,
P , -
, M B , z
I B
I ,
M
,
I M B -
T
M B-f-
z-
T B
T
13 J S, V C,Al Arabiya ( ), J 15, 2008,
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
15/28
8he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
M
2007 M
, B,
J P, -
I
-
-
15
I , I-
T I S
(IS), , , -
1990 1991,
(),
, IS
I (I),
S P
C (SPC) j -Q,
-Q I M16
T IS
1990 -
depoliTiCizing arab SoCieTieS
W
, I
B
,
j-
S I
q
, -
B
,
14
S, J, I -
-
,
2007 -
,
T , Z
B I, S I
, z
, ,
J B
T S C
-
-
j
I 2008, J M B
, S, -
,
, S , T -
q M
B
S S ,
B
j -
T -
, -
14 , S I I M, - ( ), J 31, 2010,
15 , M J Cz S , I ( ), 14, 2008,
16 B , T P -Z , q-( ), S 15, 2006,
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
16/28
9he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
J S
I
C, M
S -
; , S-
M B
, z -
, -
M,
,
,
S ,
T
,
-
I ,
( -
) ,
S S S -
,
I
T, , ,
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
17/28
10he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
Myths Used to Justify ExcludingModerate Isl amists
I
j
I T j -
W
The MyThof one-Man, one-VoTe,
one-TiMe
M W I
q T
I
S
, T - : I
1979, S 1989,
1990 T
, I
I I,
I I S-
,
-B, ,
-, I
, I I ,
-
I 1996 T
-
,
, ,
, j , j - I
- I ,
q
I
W f
I-
, , ,
S , W-
M 2006,
I
, I-
,
M, , , K,
, B
I
I , -
1990,
, -
I T q
,
T -
-
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
18/28
11he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
J P
T -
,
z
I , M B- M-
S P (MSP)
T
1997 -
j
I 2002 2007 -
,
, ,
-
P zz B (
)
T
-
I , I
1993 S -
, I P S
T 1994 -
T,
I
-
I J,
I -
,
J
1991 M, 1994 B
j J
I - B J ,
17
S,
,
,
, ,
, , , , S T,
-, -, -
,
I
z
I ,
I ,
J M B -
f -
2007
The MyThof inCluSionand exCluSion
S W I-
-
SC, ,
I
18 , -
,
-
I -
I M, K M VI
1999, z
17 , Te Future o Political Islam, ( : P M, 2003), 9718 S C, T M M I, Foreign PolicyW , J 2008,
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
19/28
12he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
T , ,
1980 1990,
, , -
I I ,
9/11
- M
, M-
, ,
,
I ,
M B I,
j -Q
T, I
,
M
I ,
, , J, M, ,
,
, ,
2007 2008 T
T
,
, I ,
I ,
, , S, S, -
S
, , -
, , T, -
,
I -
19
I I -
,
-
P
T -
I
,
-
, 2007,
M B -
-
, C
( j ),
, -
,
The MyThof STabiliTyinSTeadof
deMoCraCy
S S
M
T
,
I, , -
19 T B I, S M S , TeMuslim Brotherhood in the 2007 Jordanian Parliamentary Elections: A Passing Political Setback or Diminished Popularity?(: --S, 2007), 24,
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
20/28
13he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
I, I-
P, ,
I , 2005
-
f M B,
I
P (P)
M B j
( j
P)20 S, J,
2007 I
- I K
2008 2009 -
, , -
I
z z
q, j I ,
,
M J ,
I -
j
,
,
The MyThof proMoTing deMoCraCy
VerSuS eMpowering iSlaMiSTS
M f
M -
I T ,
q -
I T I
,
, I-
-
, -
z
I ,
T J P
M j
S 2007 ,
z,
M
20 T z (), S , M 14, 2007,
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
21/28
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
22/28
15he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
howShouldThe uniTed STaTeS deal
wiTh ModeraTe iSlaMiSTS?
T P -
,
I P -
I
, z
M B J, J
P M, M
S P , ,
M B S,
M I ,
M I I ,
I ,
q T
S -
I:
Rethink the Basic Understanding of Moder-
ate Islamists. -
I S B
- S I
S
Iq -
I , -
S
T,
I
-
I
S z
M,
, -
-
S -
, j ,
j I ,
- -
j21 I,
-
, -
f
T I-
I
, -
,
, , -
T
, -
S
I, I
S, -
S- W S
, S
I P-
I
S W
I B I -
, S
( -
Iq
I)
21 M M, M , I, S J, , J 25, 2008,
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
23/28
16he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
;
,
I , -
,
, , -
, -
I
S
-
, -
S -
I
S T
I
M I-
S
- -
Understand the Internal Dynamics of the
Moderate Islamist Movements. I S
I z,
,
I-
T
I,
,
I J,
-
M B
I ,
B
-
, ,
q z
, S
I
q -
,
I -
z-
,
S -
I
I ,
S -
I ,
S
, W
I-
,
,
S, S
z I
S - T,
S z I
j , -
, S z
I
,
-
,
Do Not Treat Democracy Promotion Solely
as a Response to Terrorism. ,
S -
-
S
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
24/28
17he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
-
,
j j
, , ,
, -
z
T S
I
-
T -
--
S,
S
W -
J 2009,
-
, ,
S
, 22
I , S z
,
I - T
S -
I
,
W
Open Channels for Direct Dialogue with
Moderate Islamists. I
S I -
--
W
-
z I ,
M S P
B S
- Mj M
I M J -
P
,
S - -, B-
, ,
M
Capitalize on the New Generation of Mod-
erate Islamists. T -
I
T S
-
T -
-
;
, , -
, q, , -
; W
T , ,
-
I M
T
-
,
M B
B
,
M 4, 2008
( M B
) T
22 I M B , , J- 2009
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
25/28
18he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
S,
J P
ConCluSion
T 9/11
M -
, S
I
I
S
I z
I T S q-
I
T
, S
,
,
I I
,
S T
-
-
I B
, , ,
,
T
--
z
I
T,
I
I -
I
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
26/28
19he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
Project on Middle East Democracy and Development
S- C M P Pj M
(M) T j -
S
M
M P V , M -
M , -, - B S, , M
M T - - M T - I
S C M :
C W M, De-mocracy Promotion Under Obama: Lessons rom the Middle East Partnership Initiative, S CM M #13, M 2009;
C W , Eu-rope, the United States, and Middle Eastern Democ-racy: Repairing the Breach, S C P, 18, J 2009;
C W, Freedoms Unsteady March: Americas Role in Building Arab Democracy(W-, C: B I P, 2008);
S , Upgrading Authoritarianism in
the Arab World, S C P, -
13, 2007;
C W & M, Elec-tions in the Arab World: Progress or Peril?, S C- M M #11, 12, 2007;
C W & S , WhatPrice Freedom? Assessing the Bush AdministrationsFreedom Agenda, S C P, 10, S 2006;
M S , An Ambivalent Alliance:
Te Future o U.S.-Egyptian Relations, S C- , 6, J 2006
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
27/28
20he Saban Center at he Brookings Institution
M CI M ISMISS I B W
The Saban Center for Middle East Policy
S C M P M 13, 2002 - Mj K II J-
T S C
B I -
M
S
T S C W - , j, - - M T B
T S C j M -
T - C S - M S I, V P P B S C K M P W S C M
T - B , , M S S-
C - CI; Sz M, S f I - ; S , Pj S I W; , B C; S , S C M; B, M T P S P B
T S C : Iq, - - ; I - ; q - - I-P ; , ; - , q z
8/3/2019 201003 Moderate Islamists Alanani
28/28
BROOKINGS
1775 Massachusetts Ave., NW
Washington, D.C. 20036-2103
.k.