21st Century Healthcare Economics: How Will My Practice Change?
Kenneth H. Cohn, M.D., MBA, Facilitator CEO, HealthcareCollaboration
[email protected] http://healthcarecollaboration.com
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 2
Overview
• Context • Burnout • Leadership • Moving beyond malaise
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 3
I. My Journey • Recovering academic surgeon • Valentine’s Day Massacre 1996 • “I’m not ready to move!” • MBA school • “How will your teaching residents practice
management bring in revenue?” • “At least your future is the Tuck School’s
responsibility.” • 1st consulting job: “You need to stop thinking
like a doctor!” • 2nd job: Puff, the magic dragon • MVA: Gretsky strategy
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 4
Context: What We Know from the Literature
Physicians are experiencing 11 distinct losses, including: • losses of financial security, status, independent
clinical decision-making, collegiality, freedom of choice of specialty and practice location, and power in hospital governance
Daugird Arch Fam Practice 1996;34:497-501 Jonasson Ann Surg 1996;224:574-582 Knight, Am Surgeon 2002;68(6):519-523 Campbell Surgery 2001;130:696-705
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 5
ACS Survey: N = 7905
• 40% met criteria for burnout • 30% screened positive for depression • 28% had lower mental quality of life score
Shanafelt TD et al. Burnout and career dissatisfaction among American surgeons. AnnSurg 2009; 250:463-471. Balch CM et al. Surgeon distress as calibrated by hours worked and nights on call. J Am Coll Surg 2010; 211:609-619.
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 6
II. Dealing with Workforce Burnout: Dx
• Burnout happens when work and/or personal demands exceed one’s ability to cope: – Emotional exhaustion (“last spirochete just
died”) – Depersonalization (decreased ability to
empathize) – Lack of accomplishment (spinning wheels)
Cohn KH, Panasuk DB, Holland JC. 2005. “Workplace Burnout,” in Cohn KH. Better Communication for Better Care: Mastering Physician-Administrator Collaboration. Chicago, Health Administration Press, 56-62.
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 7
Burnout Dx, II
• Collect and monitor data: – Patients seen during and after hours – After-hours EMR sign-ons – Committees and projects with deadlines – Patient outcome issues – Family difficulties (not weakness or
tattling) – Change in appearance or affect – Ask what is going on
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 8
Workforce Burnout: Rx • Duty to intervene before patients, families, and
physician’s career suffers (vs “there but for the grace of God…”) – We all need help at some times in our life
• Express support and concern: – “I may be wrong, but I am concerned that life
is getting difficult for you. We all have times when we can use someone to vent to. I would like to help. Can we find a convenient time to talk in the next couple of days?”
• Avoid the commodity approach: – “Suck it up or we will have no choice but to
replace you!”
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 9
Burnout: Rx, II
Proven interpersonal remedies: • Sharing feelings with others • Showing concern for colleagues • Respecting colleagues’ time off
Proven intrapersonal remedies: • Humor (TV or movie comedies, jokes) • Exercise • Meditation, periodic “bilge-pumping” breaks • Vacation
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 10
Curt Marsh
http://www.imageslides.com/Sports/gallery/2313-Classic-Photos-of-the-Oakland-Raiders#19
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 11
The Healthcare Athlete Metaphor
“When I came to my first NFL camp, it was like I was a tall, cold can of beer. They popped the top and all that energy and desire and ability came out…. When I was empty, when I had no more to give, they just crumpled me up and threw me on the garbage heap. Then, they grabbed a new can and popped him open, and he flowed out till he was empty.”
Curt Marsh, Oakland Raiders, ‘81-86 Sports Illustrated May 7, 2001, p.62
Are we being treated like commodities? Is it time for us to rethink leadership?
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 12
III. Leadership
Leadership is a process of achieving worthwhile results, while acting with respect, care, and fairness for the well-being of all participants – Something you do with people, not to people – Best way to increase your influence is to
surround yourself with people who have skills that you do not have (Collaborate for success)
Blanchard, K. 2007. Leading at a Higher Level. New York: Prentice Hall.
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 13
Analyzing Your Leadership
• Are people following? • Are people changing? • Are people growing? • Are people succeeding?
Maxwell JG. 2008. Leadership Gold. Nashville: Nelson Books.
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 14
Team-Building
• A team is a small number of people with complementary skills, who are committed to a common purpose, performance, goals, and approach, for which they hold themselves mutually accountable
• Common purpose creates a leveling effect, decreasing the importance of titles
• Leadership of a team tends to rotate based on expertise in a given area
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 15
Team-building, II
• Leaders generate trust, provide direction, focus on meeting deadlines and achieving results, and occasionally create enemies to inspire competitiveness and dedication
• Interdisciplinary teams are key to process improvement
Katzenbach & Smith. The discipline of teams. Harvard Business
Review. March-April 1993, 111-120.
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 17
Leadership Styles
• Command and control • Pace-setting • Visionary • Democratic • Affiliative • Coaching
Goleman D, Boyatzis R, McKee A. 2002. Primal Leadership: Realizing the Power of Emotional Intelligence. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 18
A Healthcare Professional’s Perception of Top-Down Management
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 19
Healthcare Champions: Overview
• Have earned the respect of their peers
• Clinically savvy: the experts
• Come from all fields of healthcare
• Have a vision of the greater good
• Willing to invest social capital
• Want to remain invested in their communities
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 20
Possible Roles for Champions
• Present and discuss clinical data
• Create a safe environment for learning
• Minimize turf battles
• Help to build transparency and trust
• Through the process of discovery, act like owners
• Leave a lasting legacy
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 21
IV. The Challenge of Transitioning
• Path is unclear • No one is telling you what to do • Outcome in doubt • Expense realities • No shortage of ways to expend scarce
resources without any guarantee of success • Failure not an option
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 22
Clinical Skills Assessment
• In what areas do I shine? • How do I know? • What strengths can I build on? • What gives me pleasure? • What do I want said about myself in 5,
10, 15 years? • How can I work smarter?
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 23
Financial Assessment
• How do I earn money? • Where do I spend it? • For what do I save? • What are my annual needs? • What are my wants and timetable for
satisfying them? • What is my/ my family’s risk tolerance? • How can I be (more) proactive?
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 24
Strengths to Project
• Authenticity, integrity • Excitement, passion, curiosity, can-do
attitude • Active listening • Service: sense of wanting to be part of
something larger than self • Comfortable with uncertainty and ambiguity
Expertise: What are you really good
at?
Reflecting on Your Niche
Where the circles intersect brings you closer to your niche
Collins JC. Good to Great. New York: Harper Business; 2001.
Market: What skills that you possess do people pay you to use?
Passion: When was the last time you felt really alive?
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 26
Reinvention
There is only one real deprivation, And that is not to be able to give one’s gifts... The gift turned inward becomes a heavy burden, Even a kind of poison It is as though the flow of life were backed up. May Sarton (1912-1955)
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 27
Enacting Reinvention: Overview
• Listen to people you are trying to serve • Tune into trends outside your field • Find the holes in the road and pave them • Regularly challenge what made you successful in
the past
Leadership is finding a bunch of people going in one direction and jumping in front of them. -Willie Nelson
Harari O. 2007. Break from the Pack. Philadelphia: Wharton School Publishing.
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 28
A Ten-Step Approach to Reinvention
• Assess your clinical skills, financial assessment, and strengths
• Discuss your answers with significant others • Form a group to continue discussion and to
promote accountability • Network to discuss your ideas with anyone
who will listen • Develop and demonstrate expertise by
listening, writing, and speaking
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 29
Reinvention, II
• Chunk big projects into 2-week steps • Reflect on progress quarterly • Systematize your learning • Celebrate all successes • Enjoy the journey
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 30
Advice from Someone Who Has Been There
“Think of your current career as a spring-board to your next one, not as a prison to escape from.”
Doug Patten, VPMA, Phoebe Putney Healthcare System
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 32
Recommendations
• Give yourself time to adapt – 21 days/ new habit – at least 90 days/ new way of earning income
• Make self-self comparisons over time, not to others
• View money spent on learning as an investment • Be open to all feedback • Keep paper and pen nearby • Start NOW • Have the courage to begin and the persistence to
endure Tracy B. 2007. The Luck Factor: How to Take the Chance Out of Becoming a Success. Niles, IL: Nightingale-Conant.
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 33
Keys to Peak Performance • Motivation – laser-like focus on goals
• Dedication – partial achievement not an option
• Involvement – passion: belief in self/goals; refusal to see
self as victim – willingness to take risks; fear lost
opportunity > failure
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 34
Keys to Peak Performance, II
• Present orientation – recognize and limit anger (past) & fear (future)
• Chunking – overwhelming tasks into smaller pieces
• Judgment – self-self comparisons, kaizen, celebrations of
small victories – perspective: detached self-awareness, battle
joy, humor
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 35
Reframing Our Perspective
• The golden age of medicine (1965-85) was an anomaly
• In 1913, the AMA estimated that no more than 10% of physicians were able to earn a comfortable living
• Intrinsic dissatisfaction can lead to social good • “It’s the sand in the oyster that creates the
pearl.” Zuger A. 2004. "Dissatisfaction with Medical Practice."New Engl J Med 350(1):69-75
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 36
IV. Moving Beyond Malaise
Listen to patients talk about what was good about their healthcare experience. They will often express it in terms that describe how much someone paid attention to them, really cared for them, listened to them, or improved their life on a very personal level. There is no machine that can replicate that sensation. Marcus LJ, Dorn BC. 2001. Beyond the malaise of American medicine. J Medical Practice Management;16(5):227-230.
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 37
Moving Beyond Malaise, II
• The pendulum has swung far from the center. What forces will it take to push it back toward a more balanced future for medicine and medical practice?
• This is a time of opportunity, one in which we define a new mission and role for ourselves... Consumers want us to remain key to the workings of the healthcare system.
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 38
Moving Beyond Malaise, III
• When our patients are facing a frightening procedure or a discouraging diagnosis, it is common for us to comfort them by offering a course of action, something that can be done to offer them a sense of hope, and with it, a future. This formula is what good medicine is about, and it is time we do the same for ourselves and for our profession.
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 39
Possible Approaches to Current Problems
Problem Solution
Complexity Dialogue
Victimhood Leadership
Exhaustion Passion
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 40
Top Three Physician Desires N > 1500
• Meaningful work that makes a difference in people’s lives
• A sense of community and camaraderie • Regular, reliable positive feedback that
affirms participants’ value
Wong B. A Prescription for Physician Reengagement. Futurescan 2009. Chicago: Health Administration Press, 23-26.
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 41
Why Act Now?
• Our present non-system of healthcare delivery is unsustainable
• We are moving from volume-based measures of productivity to more value-based metrics
• Silos are interfering with consumers’ and regulators’ demands that healthcare become more seamless
• Regardless of the outcome of the 2012 election, we are facing pressures to develop more coordinated, cost-effective care
• When the trap door shuts, providers who are least ready will get hurt the most
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 42
Possible Reactions
• Retirement • DABDA: denial, anger, bargaining, depression,
acceptance • Apathy • Engagement
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 43
Engaged Healthcare Professionals:
• Exceed expected level of effort • Are inspired to do their best work • Feel part of the greater work community • Make meaningful contributions through their
work • Are personally motivated to help their
organization succeed • Feel valued for their work contributions
Achieving Breakthrough Engagement: Lessons from High-Performing Organizations. 2007. Washington: The Advisory Board Company, p.14.
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 45
The Genius of Einstein
"We can't solve problems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created them."
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 46
As the portions grow smaller, table manners may deteriorate
Can we find solutions that enlarge the pie?
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 47
Change
• Change is disturbing when it is done to us.
• Change is exciting when it is done by us.
Rosabeth Moss Kanter, Professor, Harvard Business School
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 48
Asking the Right Questions
Instead of asking: – When are they going to grow up? – Who dropped the ball this time? – Who’s going to solve the problem they
created? – When is somebody going to train them? – Why is this happening to me?
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 49
Asking the Right Questions, II
Substitute: – How can I help? – How can I adapt to the changing healthcare
marketplace? – What can I do to develop my talents? – How can I understand better others’ challenges
and frustrations? – How can I become part of the solution? Miller JG. QBQ: The question behind the question. Putnam, NYC, 2004
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 50
QBQ Prayer
God grant me the serenity to accept the people I cannot change, the courage to change the one I can, and the wisdom to know… it’s me!
Miller JG. QBQ: The question behind the question. Putnam, NYC, 2004
21st Century Healthcare Kenneth H Cohn MD, MBA, FACS 51
Conclusion
• We are facing a decade of transformation that will revolutionize healthcare delivery and dramatically change the way we practice medicine
• The choice is up to us whether we shape the transformation or fall victim to the forces of creative destruction
• Start now, working together to improve clinical and financial performance