Open Government DataCeBit, 2.3.2011
tonzijlstra.euknowledge work, learning, social media
Networked life, networked work, networked learning
Findtoilet
Tine Müller
Dirk Houtgraaf
Rudi Kragh
Richard Jansen
Networked life, networked work, networked learningPartizipation + Open Data
Open Government
Networked life, networked work, networked learningParticipation as talking
Partizipation?
http://www.flickr.com/photos/vredeseilanden/3646968183/
Networked life, networked work, networked learningParticipation = life
Partizipation!
Networked life, networked work, networked learningOpen Gov Data
Offene Verwaltungsdaten
WikiLeaks <> Open Data
Das was öffentlich ist
Offene Daten, Prinzipien
• Komplett: alles was öffentlich ist
• ‘Rohe’ Daten: wie ursprünglich erfasst
• Rechtzeitig: so schnell wie möglich
• Zugänglich: für jeden, für alles
• Ohne Unterschied: Grund / Registrieren
• Maschinenlesbar
• Offene Formate
• Freie Lizensen
Viele Daten = Anders
http://www.flickr.com/photos/walkingsf/4671578001/
tekst
Viele Daten = Anders
Networked life, networked work, networked learning
Data ermöglicht Partizipation
Partizipation stimuliert Wiederverwendung
Networked life, networked work, networked learning
Politicians Civil Servants
Organisations Citizens
E
questions
solutions
Die Verwaltung als Plattform
what data do citizens need to help gov or take
on tasks?
what skills, literacy, attitude, do citizens need?
what data makes relationship possible?
what data, what form?(privacy, org interest, unfair info advantages to solve)
what data from other dept. needed?
what to offer?
Unbenützter Überflut
EU PSI Directive
http://www.flickr.com/photos/docjohnboy/4106899304/
Piemonte
Catalunya
Griechenland
Norwegen
Niederlande
Paris
Fingal, Irland
tekst
München
Region Helsinki
IATI
Networked life, networked work, networked learning
Most visible in our immediate enviro: our city, feed
serendipity, intervene in complex enviro
Impakt in eigener Umgebung
Wofür zahlt man Steuern?
Networked life, networked work, networked learning
safe to eat
Restaurantwahl
Networked life, networked work, networked learning
fix my street
‘Fix My Street’
Networked life, networked work, networked learning
frankfurt gestalten
Frankfurt Gestalten
Feinpartikel Alarm
http://www.nationalgeographic.com/resources/ngo/education/ideas912/912choleraho3.html
Jeder kann Doctor Snow sein
Wie macht man das?
Schnell
http://www.flickr.com/photos/nahkahousu/2301066415/
Vorsichtig / ‘richtig’
http://www.flickr.com/photos/bitboy/47009878/
Stakeholders?
http://www.flickr.com/photos/twose/887903401/
Stakeholders• Bürger
• Aktivisten
• Programierer
• Unternehmer
• NGO’s
• Akademiker
• Beambten
• Verwaltungen
Anwendungen?
http://www.flickr.com/photos/factoryjoe/195492568/
Wo liegt der Wert?
• Partizipation / Selbstbestimmung
• Transparenz, demokratische Kontrolle
• Bessere Produkte, Dienstleistungen
• Neue Produkte, Dienstleistungen
• Effektmessungen, Sinngebung (D-Journ.)
• Effiziente / Effektive Verwaltung
• Neues Wissen, Innovation
Innovation startet an unerwarteten Stellen
Networked life, networked work, networked learning
Costs too much; Whatʼs the business case; Has commercial value; Possible privacy issues; Confidential info; Itʼs not ours, and we donʼt know who owns it; Itʼs not ours and supplier wonʼt allow it; The quality isnʼt very good; We donʼt know where it is; Not our job; Itʼs in a useless format anyway; I donʼt have the authority; People will misuse the data; People will use it wrongly; Only we understand our data; Weʼll get sued; Files are just too big; Too little bandwith; It starts with this, but whereʼs the end? Itʼs there, but canʼt be opened; Data is dated/too old; Itʼs not in digital format; Is this even legal?; Our Minister says no; We never have done this before, why start now?; I donʼt see the use; Nobody will be interested; No time; No resources; Just do FOIA requests; Weʼll publish it redacted; Itʼs not complete; It contains errors; Itʼs commercially sensitive; Combining this with other data is dangerous; People will come to wrong conclusions; People will get lost and confused; It will trigger endless discussions; We canʼt confirm or deny we have that data; Weʼll get feedback, and canʼt handle that; Our IT supplier says itʼs not possible; Our IT supplier will charge too much; Our site will crash; Itʼs already online! (but in unfindable PDFs); If people download it and use it later it will be outdated; I canʼt take responsibility for all the reuse; People will get angry; Our data is in contradiction to the data of the department that is in charge of the topic; Only we truly understand.....statistics/meteo/geo/laws; Weʼll disrupt the market; It will only be used to attack us.
Ausreden? Redliche Fragen?
Networked life, networked work, networked learning
“Yet we have clear evidence about an impact. There has not been a strong backlash effect. Even when delicate data like public spending were published, like the COINS database in the UK, no big scandal has emerged. And most certainly, we have not seen an increase in demagogic or conflictual discussions about those data.
So while we don’t have evidence yet to prove the benefits of opening up data, I think we can say that the risks have proved not to be excessive. Which is one of the main arguments AGAINST opening up data for less innovative public administrations.”
(David Osimo, egov20.wordpress.com)
Kein Backlash
Bürger beziehen
Beambte beziehen
Networked life, networked work, networked learning
know the gov does not exist. find 1 civil servant
Die Verwaltung? Es reicht schon eine Person!
Konkrete Situationen, Lernen durch tun
CreditsAll photos: Ton Zijlstra, by nc saExcept where mentioned on the photo.
Slides: http://slideshare.net/tonzijlstraBlog: http://zylstra.org/blogContact: [email protected]: ton_zylstra
tonzijlstra.euknowledge work, learning, social media