3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com
CS Mahesh A. Athavale
KANJ & Associates
Partner
3RD JULY 2015
INDEPENDENT DIRECTORS –
WHO ARE THEY & WHY HAVE THEM?
Various committees have studied the role of non-
executive independent directors and have explained
the kind of independence required.
To bring an independent judgment on issues of
strategy, performance and resources, including key appointments and standards of conduct.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
To bring objectivity in making decisions that
determine the survival and prosperity of the
organization.
To ensure well-being of the stakeholders i.e.
shareholders, workers , suppliers, customers ,
society at large and the company itself.
To help company to outperform competitors
and dominate.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Can a person who does not have stake in
the company take decisions in the interest
of the company? An ID can do so, perhaps YES, because he is………
Self Governed , autonomous and free from obligations & influence.Not affiliated ,aligned or integrated with PDsNot prejudiced or conditionedNot looking to others for opinion or guidance of one's conduct.Not biased by others.Not bound by or committed to one of the parties.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Possible reasons for mandatory provision that at least 50% of the Board should be Independent Directors.
Need for multidisciplinary inputs
Numerous shareholders with geographical stretch
Holistic approach in decision making
Advantage of talent and high performers
Independent performance analysis
Control and coordination in the organization
Discipline of process and clarity in values
Wide latitude for innovation
Ability to see the big picture while knowing when
to drill down on specifics
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Related Issues
Role of IDs has come under intense scrutiny in the wake of various collapses- the notorious Enron , Worldcom, Xerox debacle and many more.
In India SATYAM has provoked the discussions.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Directors‟ Role
“The directors are not servants to obey directions
given by the shareholders as individuals; they are not
agents appointed by and bound to serve the
shareholders as their principals. They are persons
who may by the regulations be entrusted with the
control of the business, and if so entrusted they can
be dispossessed from that control only by statutory
majority which make the articles.” – Lord Justice
Buckley (1908)
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
IDs‟ ContributionFunctions of the Board are two-fold;
1. To lead company into the future by determining strategy, finalizing vision and policies. 2. Monitoring and controlling its performance in the
present.
IDs should contribute in both areas.
To choose IDs just to monitor on behalf of the shareholders is a waste of an opportunity to use their talents and experience and can be a divisive factor, polarizing the board into “executive” and “non-executive” groups. It is not healthy.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
IDs contribute significantly in
AUDIT
AND
NOMINATION & REMUNERATION COMMITTEES
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Qualities of Independent Director
Integrity.Business acumen.Adequately trained.Willingness to actively participate Unafraid of performance reviews.Updated about happenings around.Commanding position in his peer groupCourage and ability to act and say “ NO” .
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Capable of assessing the company‟s problem
and identify opportunities.
Should have clarity, decisiveness and
confidence.
Be Devoid of any vested interest.
Should have sufficient financial sources so that
the sittings fees do not become substantial
percentage of the ID‟s income.
Trustworthy .
Law abiding by nature
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
A director cannot be treated as an independent
director if he has any material pecuniary
relationships or transactions with:-
(a) the company;
(b) its promoters;
(c) its senior management;
(d) its holding company;
(e) its subsidiaries; or
(f) its associated companies.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Promoters Vs Independent Directors
Some possible situations :
Preferential allotment of securities to Promoter group.
Granting advances/ loans to the relatives of Partners.
Entering into Immovable property related
transactions– These are claimed to have been kept
outside the scope of section 297.- DCA‟s view. ( OLD
Provision )
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Promoters Vs Independent
Directors…..Contd
Need to borrow fund , its utilization and
management.
Taking Car/ property of PD / his relative
on rent by the company and giving it back to
the same person as a perquisite.- Tax Planning?
Is it Fair ?
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Promoters Vs Independent
Directors…..Contd
Creating Public Charitable Trusts, where relatives
of Directors are Trustees and giving huge donations
to such trusts. At times even beneficiary is a
selected person.
Transaction of Purchase / sale of goods – services
with a private company in which relative of
Director is interested .
Perhaps Legal but unfair.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Promoters Vs Independent
Directors…..Contd
Deciding Arm‟s Length Transactions by keeping
on record „created‟ tenders.
Buy back of shares to increase promoter group
stake in the company.
Appointment of relative ( wife's brother ) on a
disproportionate salary.
Perhaps legal – but unfair.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Instances of Conflict
Mr. D an ID raises an objection in the meeting on
the growing expenses on staff welfare. He wants to
make his presence felt in the meeting. After the
meeting he wants the company to book Air ticket , a
car and five star accommodation for his personal
tour.
Case of double standards?
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Instances of Conflict…. Contd
Mr. Q, a Director wants that company should
purchase cement from X & co where Mrs. Q is 90%
Partner . CS of the company draws attention to
section 188. The Board asks Mr. Q to resign as
Director. Contract is entered into for supply of cement
for next 10 years. Later on after 10 days of execution
of the contract Mr. Q re-enters the board as an
Additional Director.
Legal but unfair( ?)
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Instances of Conflict….Contd
X ltd a pharmaceutical company is selling a
medicine which is very effective on certain decease.
But that medicine has few serious side effects.
Company has been selling the medicine since last ten
years and turnover is Rs. 100 Million p.a.
However for all these years there has been outcry
from certain sections of society about serious side
effects and that medicine being hazardous.
X Ltd never bothered for these allegations .
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Admittedly there were certain bad side effects but there
was no ban on the medicine .
Recently, as public outcry increased , Government
conducted the laboratory tests, which proved about ill
effects of the medicine
Now company has received secret information that
Government will ban the medicine from 15th July 2015.
Stock of Rs. 50 Crores is with the company.
PDs are insisting for disposal of the stock at what ever
price . While one ID suggests for destruction of stock
Which is a better option heavy discount or destruction
of the stock?
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Instances of Conflict…. Contd
XYZ Ltd. was incorporated in 2005 . Never
earned any profits . Return on capital was ZERO.
The company does not have accumulated reserves/
surplus.
XYZ Ltd. for the first time has earned
distributable profits .
Promoters intend to transfer 10 percent to the
reserves, and distribute rest of it by way of dividend.
One of the IDs believes that it is more prudent to
transfer 50 percent to reserves and declare less % of
dividend.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
INDEPENDENT DIRECTORS DEFINED:
“Independent Director” means a Director as
referred to in sub section (6) of Section 149.
Section 149(6) reads as :
“An independent director in relation to a company,
means a director other than a managing director or
a whole-time director or a nominee director,--
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
(a) who, in the opinion of the Board, is a person of integrity and possesses
relevant expertise and experience;
(b)
(i) who is or was not a promoter of the company or its holding, subsidiary or
associate company;
(ii) who is not related to promoters or directors in the company, its holding, subsidiary or associate company;
(c) who has or had no pecuniary relationship with the company, its holding, subsidiary or associate company, or their promoters, or directors, during the two immediately preceding financial years or during the current financial year;
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
(d) none of whose relatives has or had pecuniary relationship or transaction with the company, its holding, subsidiary or associate company, or their promoters, or directors, amounting to two per cent. or more of its gross turnover or total income or fifty lakh rupees or such higher amount as may be prescribed, whichever is lower, during the two immediately preceding financial years or during the current financial year;
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
(e) who, neither himself nor any of his relatives--
(i) holds or has held the position of a key managerial personnel or is or has been employee of the company or its holding, subsidiary or associate company in any of the three financial years immediately preceding the financial year in which he is proposed to be appointed;
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
(ii) is or has been an employee or proprietor or a partner, in any of the three financial years immediately preceding the financial year in which he is proposed to be appointed, of—
(A) a firm of auditors or company secretaries in practice or cost auditors of the company or its holding, subsidiary or associate company; or
(B) any legal or a consulting firm that has or had any transaction with the company, its holding, subsidiary or associate company amounting to ten per cent. or more of the gross turnover of such firm;
(iii) holds together with his relatives two per cent. or more of the total voting power of the company; or
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
(iv) is a Chief Executive or director, by whatever name called, of any nonprofit organization that receives twenty-five per cent. or more of its receipts from the company, any of its promoters, directors or its holding, subsidiary or associate company or that holds two per cent. or more of the total voting power of the company; or
(f) who possesses such other qualifications as may be prescribed.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Companies which should have at least two IDs:
Listed Companies,
Public Companies having paid up share capital of one hundred crore rupees or more; or
Public Companies having turnover of three hundred crore rupees or more; or
Public Companies which have, in aggregate, outstanding loans or borrowings or debentures deposits, exceeding two hundred crore rupees.
The Board of all public listed companies shall comprise of at least 1/3rd of its total directors as IDs [Section 149 (4)]
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
DECLARATION BY INDEPENDENT DIRECTOR
Every independent director shall at the first meeting of the Board in which he participates as a director and thereafter at the first meeting of the Board in every financial year or whenever there is any change in the circumstances which may affect his status as an independent director, give a declaration that he meets the criteria of independence as provided in sub-section (6) of Section 149 of the Act, which defines the term “Independent Director”.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Sub section (1)
An Independent Director may be selected from a databank containing names, addresses and qualifications of persons who are eligible and willing to act as independent directors. This databank may be maintained by any body, institute or association, as may be notified by the Central Government, having expertise in creation and maintenance of such databank and put on their website, for use by the Company making appointment of such directors.
However, the responsibility of exercising due diligence before making selection from the databank, shall lie entirely with the company making such appointment.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Sub section (2):APPROVAL OF APPOINTMENT OF INDEPENDENT DIRECTOR
The appointment of independent director shall be approved by the company in general meeting.
The explanatory statement annexed to the notice of General Meeting so called, shall indicate the justification for choosing the appointee for appointment as Independent Director.
The Central Government may prescribe the manner and procedure of selection of independent directors who fulfill some requirements as per section 149(the same have been mentioned in the earlier slides).
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
“Any person who desires to get his name included in the data bank of independent directors shall make an application to the agency.”
Earlier to this amendment it required the above application to me made in Form DIR- 1. The said amendment has removed the words “in From DIR-1”
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
An Independent Director shall:
(1) uphold ethical standards of integrity and probity;
(2) act objectively and constructively while exercising his duties;
(3) exercise his responsibilities in a bona fide manner in the interest of the company;
(4) devote sufficient time and attention to his professional obligations for informed and balanced decision making;
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
Schedule IV of the Companies Act, 2013, is a guide to professional conduct for independent directors. Adherence to these standards by independent directors, and fulfillment of their responsibilities in a professional and faithful manner will help in promoting confidence of the investment community, particularly minority shareholders, regulators and companies, in the institution of independent directors.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
An Independent Director shall:
(1) uphold ethical standards of integrity and probity;
(2) act objectively and constructively while exercising his duties;
(3) exercise his responsibilities in a bona fide manner in the interest of the company;
(4) devote sufficient time and attention to his professional obligations for informed and balanced decision making;
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
(5) not allow any extraneous considerations that will vitiate his exercise of objective independent judgment in the paramount interest of the company as a whole, while concurring in or dissenting from the collective judgment of the Board in its decision making;
(6) not abuse his position to the detriment of the company or its shareholders or for the purpose of gaining direct or indirect personal advantage or advantage for any associated person;
(7) refrain from any action that would lead to loss of his independence;
(8) where circumstances arise which make an independent director lose his independence, the independent director must immediately inform the Board accordingly;
(9) assist the company in implementing the best corporate governance practices.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
The independent directors shall:
(1) help in bringing an independent judgment to bear on the Board’s deliberations especially on issues of strategy, performance, risk management, resources, key appointments and standards of conduct;
(2) bring an objective view in the evaluation of the performance of board and management;
(3) scrutinize the performance of management in meeting agreed goals and objectives and monitor the reporting of performance;
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
(4) satisfy themselves on the integrity of financial information and that financial controls and the systems of risk management are robust and defensible;
(5) safeguard the interests of all stakeholders, particularly the minority shareholders;
(6) balance the conflicting interest of the stakeholders;
(7) determine appropriate levels of remuneration of executive directors, key managerial personnel and senior management and have a prime role in appointing and where necessary recommend removal of executive directors, key managerial personnel and senior management;
(8) moderate and arbitrate in the interest of the company as a whole, in situations of conflict between management and shareholder’s interest.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
The independent directors shall—
(1) undertake appropriate induction and regularly update and refresh their skills, knowledge and familiarity with the company;
(2) seek appropriate clarification or amplification of information and, where necessary, take and follow appropriate professional advice and opinion of outside experts at the expense of the company;
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
(3) strive to attend all meetings of the Board of Directors and of the Board committees of which he is a member;
(4) participate constructively and actively in the committees of the Board in which they are chairpersons or members;
(5) strive to attend the general meetings of the company;
(6) where they have concerns about the running of the company or a proposed action, ensure that these are addressed by the Board and, to the extent that they are not resolved, insist that their concerns are recorded in the minutes of the Board meeting;
(7) keep themselves well informed about the company and the external environment in which it operates;
(8) not to unfairly obstruct the functioning of an otherwise proper Board or committee of the Board;
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
www.kanjcs.com
(9) pay sufficient attention and ensure that adequate deliberations are held before approving related party transactions and assure themselves that the same are in the interest of the company;
(10) ascertain and ensure that the company has an adequate and functional vigil mechanism and to ensure that the interests of a person who uses such mechanism are not prejudicially affected on account of such use;
(11) report concerns about unethical behaviour, actual or suspected fraud or violation of the company’s code of conduct or ethics policy;
(12) acting within his authority, assist in protecting the legitimate interests of the company, shareholders and its employees;
(13) not disclose confidential information, including commercial secrets, technologies, advertising and sales promotion plans, unpublished price sensitive information, unless such disclosure is expressly approved by the Board or required by law.
3.07.2015
(1) Appointment process of independent directors shall be independent of the company management; while selecting independent directors the Board shall ensure that there is appropriate balance of skills, experience and knowledge in the Board so as to enable the Board to discharge its functions and duties effectively.
(2) The appointment of independent director(s) of the company shall be approved at the meeting of the shareholders.
(3) The explanatory statement attached to the notice of the meeting for approving the appointment of independent director shall include a statement that in the opinion of the Board, the independent director proposed to be appointed fulfills the conditions specified in the Act and the rules made thereunder and that the proposed director is independent of the management.
3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com
(4) The appointment of independent directors shall be formalized through a letter of appointment, which shall set out :
(a) the term of appointment;
(b) the expectation of the Board from the appointed director; the Board-level committee(s) in which the director is expected to serve and its tasks;
(c) the fiduciary duties that come with such an appointment along with accompanying liabilities;
(d) provision for Directors and Officers (D and O) insurance, if any;
(e) the Code of Business Ethics that the company expects its directors and employees to follow;
(f) the list of actions that a director should not do while functioning as such in the company; and
(g) the remuneration, mentioning periodic fees, reimbursement of expenses for participation in the Boards and other meetings and profit related commission, if any.
3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com
3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com
(5) The terms and conditions of appointment of independent directors shall be open for inspection at the registered office of the company by any member during normal business hours.
(6) The terms and conditions of appointment of independent directors shall also be posted on the company’s website.
The re-appointment of independent director shall be on the basis of report of performance evaluation.
VI. RESIGNATION OR REMOVAL:(1) The resignation or removal of an independent director shall be in the same manner as is provided in sections 168 and 169 of the Act.
(2) An independent director who resigns or is removed from the Board of the company shall be replaced by a new independent director within a period of not more than one hundred and eighty days from the date of such resignation or removal, as the case may be.
(3) Where the company fulfils the requirement of independent directors in its Board even without filling the vacancy created by such resignation or removal, as the case may be, the requirement of replacement by a new independent director shall not apply.
3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com
(1) The independent directors of the company shall hold at least one meeting in a year, without the attendance of non-independent directors and members of management;
(2) All the independent directors of the company shall strive to be present at such meeting;
(3) The meeting shall:
(a) review the performance of non-independent directors and the Board as a whole;
3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com
(b) review the performance of the Chairperson of the company, taking into account the views of executive directors and non-executive directors;
(c) assess the quality, quantity and timeliness of flow of information between the company management and the Board that is necessary for the Board to effectively and reasonably perform their duties.
3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com
(1) The performance evaluation of independent directors shall be done by the entire Board of Directors, excluding the director being evaluated.
(2) On the basis of the report of performance evaluation, it shall be determined whether to extend or continue the term of appointment of the independent director.
3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com
CIRCULAR NO. 14 DATED 09/06/2014: Clarification on rules regarding Appointment and Qualification of Directors and Independent Director
The ID shall have no pecuniary relationship with the Company concerned or its holding/subsidiary or associate company, or other specified categories.
“Pecuniary Relationship” does not include receipt of remuneration from one or more companies by way of fee provided u/s 197(5) [fee for attending meetings of the Board or Committee thereof or for any other purpose whatsoever as may be decided by the Board], reimbursement of expenses for participation in Board and other meetings and profit related commission approved by the members, in accordance with the provisions of the Act.
3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com
3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com
Tenure of appointment of an ID on the commencement of the Act shall not be counted for his appointment under the Act.
5 consecutive years shall form one term of appointment for the ID.
Cooling-off period of 3 years for the ID, if two consecutive terms of appointment are over (even if the total term is less than 10 years).
Appointment of IDs (whether new or existing) shall be formalized by a letter of appointment.
Need for Legal Compliance Reporting System
The multiplicity of laws, rules, regulations, has
necessitated introduction of a system to ensure
compliances under the laws
This has two fold objective
To protect the interests of the customers,
employees, revenue, environment and the directors
and officers of the company
To avoid any unwarranted legal actions by the law
enforcing agencies and other persons.
3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com
Features of Legal Compliance Reporting
System
All major laws affecting the Company‟s affairs at different
levels are divided amongst the various divisions having regards
to their functions.
The main responsibility for the legal compliances will rest
with the concerned Department who will designate officers to
undertake the operational responsibility in this regard.
The officers in the Secretarial and Legal Department will act
as counselors to guide and advise the officers who have
operational responsibility, in respect of certain laws which will
be specified in the format being devised for this purpose.
3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com
Features of Legal Compliance Reporting
System….. Contd
Every officer will submit a Report in the prescribed form to the
concerned Department who will sign it and forward to the
Managing Director through the Company Secretary, who will have
the overall responsibility to ensure legal compliances and secure
Legal Compliance Report
The Managing Director will submit a Report to the Board of
Directors at the periodical Board meetings
A copy of every show cause or demand notice received from any
government authorities or any other party, regarding non-
compliance of any law, or terms and conditions of contracts, shall
be forwarded to the Company Secretary or some other officer in
the Secretarial & Legal department immediately on receipt.
3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com
Benefits of Legal Compliance Reporting System
Relieving the Company and its Directors from the
consequences of unintended non-compliance of law.
Introducing professionalism.
Effective control and proper Corporate Governance.
Avoiding disputes due to proper maintenance of
statutory books and records.
3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com
Benefits of Legal Compliance Reporting System…..Contd
Improving and strengthening quality and speed of
services to investors.
Nurturing investors and creditors confidence.
Timely and proper conduct of Board and General
Meetings and proper recording of their minutes.
Ease in raising of funds from the public, banks and
financial institutions due to proper maintenance of
statutory records.
www.kanjcs.com 3.07.2015
THANK YOU
3.07.2015 www.kanjcs.com