1
Schema-Script Theory
Listening and Reading Process
S. Faiza Hassan
S. Faiza Hassan- MS Applied Linguistics
2
• Comprehension−Knowledge stored in reader’s mind and
the Process through which readers tackle it.• Reading: knowing language, processing it to
get meaning out of it.
• For Example:−Rain
• Good weather• Things to be covered by plastic sheets• Chill• Slippery roads• Not a day for new/favourite sandals
Meaning
S. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics
3
Schema Theory
S. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics
4
• Schema −It is the background information which
facilitates comprehension of written or spoken text.• What the text is about?
• Culture specific
• Individual specific
Schema Theory
S. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics
5
Examples1. ‘Shall I compare thee to a pleasant
summer’s day- Shakespeare’ {in South Asia (Pakistan, India, Bangladesh) Summers are not considered pleasant and it appears mockery to them}
2. ‘Persimmon being a deciduous plant reacts unhappily to change of pot in spring’. Daily Dawn {makes sense to people who know the word deciduous}
3. ‘Readers, suppose you were an idiot and suppose you were member of congress, but then I repeat myself.’-Mark Twain (Samuel Clemens) {makes sense to people who know Mark Twains stance on Politics}
S. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics
6
Further elaboration on e.g. 3• ‘Readers, suppose you were an idiot and
suppose you were member of congress, but then I repeat myself.’ Mark Twain
• ‘All congresses and Parliaments have kindly feeling for idiots, and a compassion for them, on account of personal experience and heredity.’ Mark Twain
• ‘Fleas can be taught nearly anything that a congressman can.’ Mark Twain−When learners are exposed to several texts
containing similar idea it starts making sense to them as a schema starts developing.
S. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics
7
Studies• Adams (1983)
−Learners were good at learning vocabulary in L1−Sharing ‘what the text is about’ helped learners in
both languages (L1 & L2) equally.
• Patricia Carrell (1984)−Lack of context affected comprehension−L2 learners found use of vague words like things
and facilities instead of clothes and washing machine a hindrance.
• Roller and Motambo (1992)−Speakers of Shona remembered more text in
English then in their mother tongueS. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics
8
Scriptsand discourse
S. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics
9
Script• Coined by Roger Schank-1977• Computer programs
− Do not know the obvious thing that humans take for granted; context
• Ali had a sandwich at the cafe (talked to sales person, chose a flavour, paid, used a table & chair, might have taken a drink or sauces)
• Schank and Abel (1977)
A predetermined , stereotyped sequence of actions that defines a well-known situation
• Schank; ‘the scrpit has remained an influential view of how memory is organized’S. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics
10
Script Theory• Script is a template of conversation/actions that
exists in Language Learners mind for a situation
• Universal− Ticketing (go to ticket counter, greet, ask rates, ask for
discounts, pay, get the ticket)− Accommodation
• Culture specific templates− Seeking help from neighbors (in some cultures you must
go in their house and chat; in others you wait outside)
• Absence of any such template− unpleasant surprise: “I want somebody to proofread an article
I have written” this naïve request from an L2 PhD met several responses of “I want never gets” by L1 speakers on Linkedin
S. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics
11
Benefits for the teacher• Increased awareness reading &
writing difficulties−Comprehension of spoken or written or
spoken text involves knowledge of script and initiation of activation of schema
−For written text learners have to depend on their own script only.
−Literacy skills: writing system of L1 is very different from that of L2
−Cognitive deficits: difficulty of processing information in a second language.
S. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics
12
• Teaching Schemas: −cross cultural awareness
• thanking people• Asking for help
S. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics
13
Schema and script theory• Reading is building learners
background knowledge
• Application:1. Teaching vocabulary-Context facilitates
learning and retaining new vocabulary.2. Pre-Reading Activities3. Series of long connected reading
passages instead of short unconnected passages
4. Devising mental processing activities; labeling diagrams, developing a flowchart, narrating the read story to a peer.
S. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics
14
Key Lessons
S. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics
15
Key lessons• Developing schema and knowledge
of script goes hand in hand with developing receptive language skills
• Cultural differences in L1 and L2 can prove a hindrance for learning L2
• Learners need to develop ability to process information embedded in spoken or written text
S. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics
16
Questions & Comments
S. Faiza Hassan-MS Applied Linguistics