Euronext N.V.: The Fight for LIFFE
2
The Fight for LIFFELate August 2001: LIFFE*, the prestigious British
derivatives exchange, is up for auction.
For Euronext - a newly minted combination of the former Paris, Amsterdam and Brussels stock exchanges – this
could be a perfect opportunity to position itself as one of the consolidators in the industry, rather than waiting to become
one of the consolidatees.
But the prize will not come easily. In the battle for LIFFE, Euronext will be up against the two biggest and most
powerful stock exchanges in Europe, and one of them will be fighting on home ground….
* London International Financial Futures and Options Exchange
3
Euronext’s Challenge
How can Euronext communications chief Thierry Barthez and CEO Jean-François
Théodore succeed where others have failed, in persuading a London exchange to sell out
to a little-known foreign buyer?
(for an idea of the challenge this represents: imagine a French-controlled company being
allowed to buy NASDAQ or the Chicago Mercantile Exchange!)
4
What is an Exchange?
• A marketplace, physical or virtual, where participants trade one or more types of financial products, such as:– Stocks and stock indices (known as “cash” markets)– Derivatives e.g. options, warrants, futures– Commodities e.g. metals, oil, cocoa – Currencies
5
What is Euronext?
• A cross-border stock and derivatives exchange
• Formed in 2000 from merger of Paris, Amsterdam and Brussels exchanges (the first ever successful merger in the industry)
• Became a public company in July 2001 IPO
6
The Battlefield• What kind of industry is this?
– Highly fragmented into regulated local monopoly markets (18+ national stock exchanges in Europe)
– Most exchanges owned/operated as mutual-co-operatives
– Customers are financial institutions, not the general public
• What dynamics are operating within it?– Global market forces and financial institutions pushing
for larger pools of capital, more liquidity, lower trading costs, ease of cross border transactions
– Political interests seeking to preserve national exchanges
7
Signs of Change?
• Changes in ownership status and structure– Deutsche Börse (DBAG), London Stock
Exchange (LSE) & Euronext become public listed companies in 2001
• Beginnings of merger activity:– Euronext born in 2000 from three-way merger,
creating #3 exchange in Europe.– DBAG attempts, unsuccessfully, to merge
with the LSE in 2000, as does OM, operator of the Stockholm Stock Exchange.
8
The Battlefield
LondonDeutsche Börse
Euronext
Lisbon
LondonDeutsche Börse
Euronext
Lisbon
LondonDeutsche Börse
Euronext
Lisbon
LondonDeutsche Börse
Euronext
Lisbon
Member of European Union (EU)
Member of EU but not in European single currency
Exchange
Key
Market position in Europe, by volumes traded*
LIFFE - #3 €144m+
LSE #1 - €315m
Euronext #3 #2 €698m
DBAG #2 #1 €760m
Stock
s*Der
ivativ
es*
2001
tota
l
reve
nues
How the combatants compare
2000 revenues+
Sources: company annual reports
9
Why Does Euronext Need LIFFE?
• Adds scale and scope:– Complementary products– Presence in London – a key world financial center
• Technology– Access to LIFFE’s CONNECT trading system
• Credibility– A successful LIFFE acquisition would position
Euronext to make further mergers/acquisitions elsewhere in Europe.
– Losing will put it a distant third to DBAG and LSE.
10
How the Rivals Line UpS
tren
gth
sW
eakn
esse
s
• Same language, location and currency as LIFFE
• Same regulator
• Complementary products (LIFFE offers options on LSE stocks)
• Did not raise spare cash from IPO – will need to make cash & shares offer
• Faces tough choice: keep own trading system or switch to LIFFE CONNECT
• Likely to need full integration to achieve synergies
• Cash from IPO
• Can switch to LIFFE CONNECT trading system
• Can offer LIFFE traders access to Euro products
• Could give LIFFE self-governance from London
• Cultural/political issues
• Different regulators
• Still facing integration issues from 2000 merger
• Still new on the scene
• Cash from IPO
• Can offer LIFFE traders access to Euro derivatives
• Probably strongest exchange overall in Europe
• EU anti-trust issues (#1 already in European derivatives market)
• Recent failed merger with LSE
• Cultural/political issues
• Different regulators
11
Who Will Decide?
LIFFE BOARDLIFFE’S
REGULATORS
• CEO Freedberg, Chairman Williamson
• Advises board on strengths of business cases submitted by bidders
LIFFE Board (consisting of its major shareholders, most of whom are also customers) choose which bid to accept
• UK Financial Services Authority & the European Competition Commission
• Must approve the merger
LIFFE MANAGEMENT
• Major shareholders, most of whom are also LIFFE customers
• Votes on which bid to accept
WHO?
HOW?
How can Euronext Win?
13
Euronext’s Strategy For Battle• Focus on customers
– LIFFE shareholders are also its customers: their long term livelihood is at stake. Euronext stressed its commitment to lowering trading costs, increasing liquidity and keeping existing technology.
• Build trust – Consistent words and deeds: consistency between business case
and Euronext’s corporate strategy: consistent in all communications with LIFFE.
– Exemplary behavior during auction: no leaking bids or negotiating through press.
• Be open, but keep low profile– Hard to win hearts of public, and probably not necessary.– Many in UK still very “Euro-sceptic”: sensitivity required when
talking about long term goals for European integration.• Be mindful of long term objectives
– UK government may be unlikely to intervene, but aggressive or insensitive approach might harm political chances for later acquisitions elsewhere in Europe.
14
Tactics: a Two Phase Campaign• Phase one (during auction):
– Sell acquisition business case to LIFFE management & shareholders (focusing on customer benefits)
– Limited media interviews; no public discussion of bid– Use English native speakers to help draft board presentation,
key messages and press releases
• Phase two (if bid is successful):– With assistance of LIFFE management, inform and educate UK
politicians and regulators; European Competition Commission– Educate LIFFE and Euronext employees on acquisition
rationale, benefits for customers– Sell acquisition business case to Euronext shareholders (focus
on long term value and customer benefits)
15
OM bid for LSE fails
How the Auction Played Out2000 2001
DBAG IPO
Feb
LSE IPO
July
Euronext IPO
Aug 5
Formation of Euronext announced: LSE
refuses to join
Apr
Sources: Company press releases; The Independent, 10/30/2001.
Nov
DBAG merger with LSE fails
Sep
LIFFE rumors begin
late Aug Sep 27
LIFFE says it has received a “number of approaches”
Oct 29
LIFFE and Euronext announce an agreed deal at £18.25 a share
Oct 25
Final bidder presentations to LIFFE board: LSE reportedly bids £18.50 a share
Sep 29
LSE says it plans to bid between £12-£15
Oct 28
LIFFE reportedly rejects last minute LSE bid of £19 a share
16
Battle Lessons
• Strategy is only as good as its articulation• Customers are the ultimate decision-makers• In every battle, never forget the objectives of the
war (i.e., manage for tomorrow)• Consistency of word and deed is essential in
building trust and reputation• You can never understand too much about the
environment in which you operate• Cash is not always king...