European Schoolnet
CELEBRATE
IST 2001 35188
Context eLearning with broadband technologies
European Schoolnet
A Cross Programme Action
• Budget over 7 MEuros - 30 months• EUN Office plus 21 partners
– Belgium (2)– Finland (4)– France (3)– Hungary (1)– Israel (1)– Italy (3)– Netherlands (1)– Norway (2)– Spain (1)– UK (3)
European Schoolnet
eLearning Summit 2001
• “Create the conditions to sustain a commercial market for eLearning content development.”
Recommendation 4
• Private sector calls for: “The creation of small learning ‘objects’ (based on open standards) could facilitate the development of new business models for content development and encourage innovative procurement mechanisms.”
European Schoolnet
Project Rationale• “To keep concentrating on content and ‘delivery’ – disregarding
context and “community” is attempting to build the Knowledge Society with the crude tools and frames of mind used to build the Industrial Society…..If Augumented Reality, WebTV, Mobile Platforms or any other technology become mere instruments of the mechanistic “delivery” of content – they will be no more than adornments of an old, old – desperately old – Education!”Antonio Dias de Figuerdo from the University of Coimbra in Portugal,
Learning 2.0 conference in Vasteras, 2001
• Content plus Context (Community & Collaboration)– Networked learning environments and constructivist learning models
require new metaphors for how we understand content and the exchanges that take place between learners.
European Schoolnet
The Celebrate Project• Learning Objects and Learning Community
Objects• Brokerage system of brokerage systems• Standards: LOM, SCORM 1.2• Application profiles
– ELR thesaurus– Richer set of vocabularies– Hierarchy of application profiles
• Learning Content Management Tools• Learning Management Tools• Addresses economic, organisational feasibility
European Schoolnet
European Schoolnet
European Schoolnet
European Schoolnet
European Schoolnet
European Schoolnet
European Schoolnet
European Schoolnet
European Schoolnet
Technical Challenge– Issues related to the interoperability of LMS/LCMSs
• how do we achieve interoperability of LOs and LCOs across LMS/LCMS?
– Multilinguality and the contribution of translation tools
– An investigation of emerging Educational Modelling Schemes and Languages
– Mechanisms for predicting/anticipating the needs of teachers/learners and matching these more precisely to available learning objects (a Predictor facility)
European Schoolnet
Interoperability of LOs
• How does one find learning objects?
• How does one create LOs and adapt LOs and ensure interoperability?
• How does one integrate learning objects with each other or into a larger structure (sequencing and courses)?
• How can one evaluate learning objects in terms of quality, the required attainment level of the student prior to using the resource, the learning gain after using the LO, and teaching effort required to integrate the LO?
European Schoolnet
9 Work Packages
1. Requirements & Validation2.Pedagogical Models3.Brokerage System4. Creation of LOs5. Demonstrator Portal6. Broadband Pilots (Finland, France, Hungary, Israel,
Norway, UK, ENIS)7.Evaluation8. Exploitation and Dissemination9. Project management
European Schoolnet
General ‘Bus’ Architecture
Server I Server II
Server III
Server IV
BUS
InterfaceInterface
Interface Interface
European Schoolnet
Brokerage System of Brokerage Systems
LCMS/LMS
VLE
LCMS EUN
Central
Services
BUS
InterfaceInterface
Interface Interface
European Schoolnet
Administration
PCs in the school
Administration
PC’s in the Classroom
CD-ROM
Networking
Resources CollaborationNetworked
School
Administration
RepositoriesLearning
Resources
Brokerage Systems Learning ObjectsLMS
LCMS
VLE
Polyhierarchy of
Brokerage Systems
Palm,
Tablet PC
Mobile
Intelligent
Learning
Personalised
VLEs
European Schoolnet
The OASIS Project
• Interoperability of administrative data• Based on the Schools Interoperability Framework
(SIF)
• Fitting it to European needs
European Schoolnet
Library
Transportation
Communications
Food ServicesStudent Administration
?
??
?
?
The Integration Problem
European Schoolnet
Growing Interoperability Problems
• Applications are isolated islands.• Data is locked in “data tombs”.• Redundant data entry is common.• Disconnected applications increase support costs.• Reporting is a costly, inefficient process.
European Schoolnet
Food Services
AgentAgent
Agent
AgentAgent
ZIS
Student Administration
Curriculum
Transportation
Library
A More Elegant Solution: The SIF Zone
European Schoolnet
European Schoolnet
Food
Serv
ice
Gra
de B
ook
HR
/ Finance
Libra
ry
SIS
Tra
nsp
orta
tion
Instru
ction
al S
erv
ices
Voice
Tele
phony
Integration
Data Warehousing
K12 Data Model
Accountability, Reporting, Planning, etc…
European Schoolnet
Local
School
Regional
National
European Schoolnet
Future Developments
PCs in the school
Administration
PC’s in the Classroom
CD-ROM
Networking
Resources CollaborationNetworked
School
Administration
RepositoriesLearning
Resources
Brokerage Systems Learning ObjectsLMS
LCMS
VLE
Polyhierarchy of
Brokerage Systems
Palm,
Tablet PC
Mobile
Intelligent
Learning
Personalised
VLEs
European Schoolnet
Why reuse? • Cost of producing a Learning Object
– 400 € for languages up to 1500 € for maths
– Given that you get graphics and manuscript for free
– If every teacher in Europe would make his own LO it would cost at least 20 billion €
• Quality– An LO being reused gains in quality
• Time– Reuse saves time for the teacher
European Schoolnet
Does it work?
• This presentation is for more than 60% reuse
• Reuse works when LOs are designed for it and tools to share are available
• Reuse involves: find, evaluate, acquire, adapt, integrate
• A reusable LO should make this easy
European Schoolnet
Why metadata?
• Search engines do a good job now in finding web pages, but will deliver better results if they can make use of metadata
• Learning Objects are typically packaged (e.g. in a zip file) and stored in repositories inaccessible for search engines
• A better model online bookstores
European Schoolnet
Why metadata (cont.)• Search engines will not answer questions such as
– For which age?– Who owns the LO?– What are the conditions of use?– How much do I need to learn before using it?– Does it fit the curriculum?– What are the technical requirements?– How can I adapt it?
• Metadata are an important element for reuse• Questions like this will not get answered unless
the information is provided in addition to the LO
European Schoolnet
Issue: How, not Why
• How can we facilitate assigning metadata to Learning Objects– Inheritance of collections
• Publisher, audience, language, …
• Drag and drop into a folder
– Predictive metadata tagging
European Schoolnet
Why Standards?• Do you know your clothes size:
– 38 D, NL, F (sometimes)– C38 Norway, Sweden and Finland– 40 B, F (sometimes)– 44 I– 44/46 Portugal and Spain– 12 UK
• Also:– …, S, M, L, XL, XXL, …– …, 39, 40, 41, …– …, 80B, 100C, …
European Schoolnet
“Standards help to remove barriers”
http://europa.eu.int/comm/enterprise/library/enterprise-europe/issue6/articles/en/enterprise12_en.htm
•About 1800 standards per year produced in Europe•Increasing political importance•Contribution to
•Single market•Construction products (cement)
•Consumer health•Sustainable development•Environment•Safety
•voluntary activity carried out by, and for, interested parties in accountable standards organisations that have been recognised by the European Union•involvement of 'societal stakeholders‘•Toys, weighing instruments, gas applicances, medical devices, etc.
European Schoolnet
But also…
• Semantic interoperability– help people to understand each other better
• Technical interoperability– open systems, components
• Increase freedom– integrate content & components from various origins– think about DIN A4!
• Lower cost– Not reinventing the wheel
European Schoolnet
Alternatives?
• De facto standards– Commercial inequalities– Dominance of US based model over European one
(cultural diversity)
• Segregated development because incompatibilities– Hypermedia before the web– Education and training: no base platform
• Disparate projects• No reuse and further development• No uptake & no impact
European Schoolnet
Finally
• No standards, metadata, reuse will be successful
• Unless– A minimum set of high quality Los
• Produced by publishers
• Teachers with the appropriate tools
– A well supported community of teachers
European Schoolnet
Thank you !
European Schoolnet
Useful Links
• http://etb.eun.org/• http://celebrate.eun.org/• http://www.cenorm.be/isss/workshop/lt/• http://ltsc.ieee.org/wg12/• http://dublincore.org/• http://www.imsproject.org/• http://www.sifinfo.org/ • http://www.adlnet.org/• http://eml.ou.nl• http://reusability.org