8/3/2019 Five Ways to Squeeze Medicare
1/6
Five ways to squeeze Medicare
WASHINGTON Nearly 50 million people on Medicare, as well as those entering the
program at a pace of one every eight seconds, are likely to get more than their money's
worth before they die.
The same can't be said for anyone under 55 who will rely
on the federal health care program for those 65 and older
in the future. They face higher costs and, possibly, longer
waits before they qualify for coverage.
Medicare one of the most popular programs ever
devised by the federal government is on the chopping
block. Again.
Medicare at the center of budget debate
But just a year after President Obama's health care
overhaul called for $500 billion in Medicare savings, a
variety of factors may protect the program this time. An
effort to exempt older workers from cuts, the advertising
and lobbying clout of health care providers, and the
approaching 2012 elections all point toward putting off
major changes.
"There's not much left in the well," says Dan Mendelson,
CEO of Avalere Health, a consulting firm. "There's
nothing that is politically acceptable or pain-free."
Since its creation in 1965, Medicare has risen in public
esteem. Today it enjoys the sort of favorable ratings
President Obama and Congress can only dream of.
Since the late 1980s, Medicare has battled efforts to tame
its explosive growth or make it more self-sustaining.
Powerful lawmakers have been chased down city streets
and lofty commissions rendered impotent by the forces
that rely on Medicare for their health or wealth, from the
AARP to the American Medical Association.
Today the program is again the top target of budget-
cutters. They know the nation can't keep running the $1
trillion annual deficits that have sent the national debt to
$14.7 trillion nearly the size of the $15 trillion economy.
The aging of the Baby Boom generation will boost
enrollment by 1.6 million annually over the next two
decades, bringing it to 81 million by 2030. Actuaries must
project out 75 years; when they do, they see 120 million
people on Medicare.
Its annual cost $555 billion, more than 15% of the
By Richard Wolf, USA TODAY Updated 2d 7h ago
381
32
Reprints & Permissions
Ads by Google
Low Cost Health Insurance
Blue Cross, United, Aetna, CIGNA &
More! Compare Plans & View Rates.
www.GoHealthInsurance.com
AARP Medicare Supplement
Insurance Plans insured by
UnitedHealthcare Ins Co. Free info
aarp-medicaresupplement.com
Review Medicare Plans
Annual Enrollment Begins 10/15. See
What's New & Be Prepared to Enroll!
MedicareConsumerGuide.com
News from The Oval
Latest posts from USA TODAY The
Oval blog
1:01 PM Obama's next bus tour: NC and
Virginia
12:47 PM Michelle Obama visits Secret
Service
11:58 AM Obama jobs event includes
struggling Kodak
10:12 AM Obama's call for jobs vote
requires Democrats
8:53 AM Obama reads children book
about himself
Read all The Oval posts
Videos you may be interested in
Knox defends
herself in Italian
court
PAC of Dogs:
Canine Political
Committee Forms
Sponsored Link
How to Relieve
Joints?EverydayLifestyles.co
Today's Offers Home Refinance Daily Deals
Wisconsin:Mom spills secreton how she makes $6795/mo
part time.
Recession or not, pennystocks are the secret to beingable to afford anything you
want...
Amazing video reveals thesecret to learning anylanguage in just 10 days!
Same method used by FBI!
BREAKING: CambridgeScientists discover an all-natural sleep aid that really
works.
This #1 penny stock site canturn a few hundred dollars
into an overnight fortune!
Low priced penny stocks canmake you a fortune virtually
overnight...
Ads by
Stories
Early fall storm brings rain, snow to Calif.
Canadian Arctic nearly loses entire ice...
Texas' famed bat colonies at risk due to...
Tropical Storm Irene left rare seabird...
Tornadoes are Earth's most violent storms
Videos
Talking Tech | iPhone 4S
After 4-year ordeal, Knox home in Seattle
1 killed, 4 rescued in NYC chopper crash
Photos
Protests against Wall Street
Editorial Cartoons
Libya--Battle for Sirte and Bani Walid
Most Popular
WeatherTechYour LifeLifeSportsMoneyTravelNewsHome
News Google USA TODAY stories, photos and moreSubscribe Mobile Join USA TODAYSign in | Become a member
People protest cuts to Medicaid and Medicare on
Sept. 21 in San Francisco.
By Justin Sullivan, Getty Images
More videos
59ecommen
News: Comm uni ties Educa tion N ation Militar y Po lit ics Religi on Offb eat Washing ton W or ld Op inio n Your Life
Page 1 of 6Five ways to squeeze Medicare USATODAY.com
10/5/2011http://www.usatoday.com/news/washington/story/5-five-ways-to-cut-medicare/50640558/1
8/3/2019 Five Ways to Squeeze Medicare
2/6
USA TODAY Digital Services
Mobile E-Newsletters RSS Twitter PodcastsWidgets e-Edition USA TODAY for iPad Kindle
Edition Print Edition Subscribe to paper
Reprints & Permissions USA TODAY TopicsReporter Index Corrections/Clarifications Contact
Us Archives
federal budget will rise to 18% of the budget within a
decade. Over the next 75 years, it will owe $38 trillion to its beneficiaries.
So clear is the need to trim the program that Obama and Congress agreed on a deficit-
reduction law in August virtually guaranteeing some reductions: If lawmakers fail to do it
themselves, automatic cuts will begin to squeeze up to 2% savings from almost every part
of the program.
Here's one problem for the budget-cutters: There's not much appetite amongpolicymakers to give less to those age 55 and up, who will qualify for the program within
10 years.
Here's another: Doctors, drugmakers, hospitals, medical colleges, home health providers,
medical equipment manufacturers and insurers have been targeted before most
recently in last year's health care law. They agreed to those cuts because the overhaul is
projected to expand insurance coverage to 32 million people who likely would seek more
services. This time, they have no such incentive.
And another: Although a 12-member congressional "supercommittee" has until late
November to propose a deficit-reduction plan, the following November already beckons.
That's when Obama and most members of Congress run for re-election. In 2008, 70% of
seniors ages 65 to 74 turned out to vote, the highest rate of any age group.
The message from many Medicare beneficiaries, says Robert Blendon, professor of
health policy and political analysis at Harvard University's School of Public Health, is
simple: "Don't cut my benefits, and don't ask me to pay a lot more for what I have."
Most Americans, in fact, are protective of Medicare. A non-partisan Kaiser Family
Foundation poll in September found that 51% of people didn't want Medicare cut at allto
reduce the federal deficit. Only 13% favored "major reductions."
To make sure lawmakers get the picture, AARP, the nation's biggest seniors group with 37
million members, is running a multimillion-dollar ad campaign. "We're giving voice to what
people actually tell us," says legislative policy director David Certner.
Here are five ways Medicare could be squeezed and the reasons it will be difficult.
1 Target 'rich people'
Most proposals that focus on raising premiums or limiting benefits have only the wealthy in
mind and for good reason. Polls show that's the only way to win public support.
"Anything that has upper-income people pay more does well at the moment," Blendon
says.
But in 1989, those people rebelled against a new federal law intended to provide basic
catastrophic health care coverage under Medicare at their expense, going so far as to
chase Rep. Dan Rostenkowski, D-Ill., a House committee chairman, down a Chicago
street. The law was repealed later that year.
Under the health care overhaul passed last year, the 2.9% Medicare tax was raised for
individuals with income above $200,000 and couples above $250,000. Now the focus is
on upper-income Medicare beneficiaries with income above $85,000, who already pay
more for outpatient care and prescription drugs.
"I guess you go after rich people," says Robert Laszewski, a non-partisan health care
consultant. "That's where you've got the most ability to hurt someone who can take the
hurt."
Obama has proposed raising premiums for upper-income beneficiaries and gradually
bringing more people into that group, so that eventually one in four seniors would pay
more.
The question will be: Who can afford it?
"I would be cautious about that," says John Rother, president of the non-partisan National
Coalition on Health Care. "You're getting pretty deep into ordinary middle-income
families."
Sign up to get:
Top viewed stories, photo galleries
and community posts of the day
Most popular right now:Nancy Grace: Amanda Knoxverdict was 'miscarriage ofjustice'
Most Popular E-mail Newsletter
Page 2 of 6Five ways to squeeze Medicare USATODAY.com
10/5/2011http://www.usatoday.com/news/washington/story/5-five-ways-to-cut-medicare/50640558/1
8/3/2019 Five Ways to Squeeze Medicare
3/6
2 Give beneficiaries skin in the game
Making all Medicare beneficiaries pay more is tougher politically. But analysts say giving
patients more skin in the game will lead them to make better health care choices.
Obama last month recommended increasing beneficiary costs beginning in 2017. New
beneficiaries would face higher deductibles for outpatient care and co-payments for home
health care. Those who buy expensive Medigap policies to avoid co-payments would face
30% higher premiums.
Those proposals pale compared with what House Republicans passed in April: Budget
Committee Chairman Paul Ryan's plan to offer future Medicare beneficiaries a flat federal
payment in order to buy private or government insurance.
The Congressional Budget Office estimated that plan would cost beneficiaries an average
of $6,400 more annually. Even so, a Kaiser Family Foundation poll in June found 45%
supported it, while 49% preferred the current system.
Eugene Steuerle, a health care specialist at the Urban Institute, argues that Medicare
should be forced to live within a budget. He would give beneficiaries options, such as
getting bundled services from one health care organization or taking a fixed federal
payment, as a way to ratchet down prices. "At least for a long time to come, you have to
offer traditional Medicare as the alternative," Steuerle says. "But if it's more expensive,
you should have to pay more for it."
3 Raise the eligibility age
In the midst of the summer's talks over hiking the nation's debt limit, Obama raised the
possibility of gradually increasing Medicare's eligibility age to 67. He has since backed off.
Little wonder: His health care law expanding insurance coverage remains a work in
progress and could get overturned by the Supreme Court or a Republican-led Congress.
That could leave people ages 65 and 66 in jeopardy.
The idea is patterned on the 1983 law that rescued Social Security: One provision
gradually increased the retirement age for collecting full benefits from 65 to 67.
But in this case, analysts say it could increase health care spending by passing on the
costs to employers that insure retirees and older Medicare beneficiaries who could face
higher premiums.
"Medicare would save some money, but overall health system spending would go up, notdown," says Robert Berenson, a Medicare official in the Clinton administration and now
vice chairman of MedPAC, which advises Congress on Medicare.
4 Reduce providers' profit margins
Nearly every effort to reduce Medicare costs has focused on doctors, hospitals,
drugmakers and insurers. It happened in 1990, 1993, 1997, 2006 and again last year.
Doctors already face a nearly 30% reduction in Medicare payments under an outdated
formula. It's avoided annually, but only by Congress finding the money elsewhere.
Repealing the formula would cost more than $300 billion over 10 years.
"Congress created the Medicare physician payment formula, and the congressional deficit
committee must now find a way to repeal it to preserve seniors' access to health care,"
says Peter Carmel, president of the American Medical Association, which plans an ad
campaign.
Other providers appear to be fair game again. Obama would get $135 billion over 10
years from drug companies by requiring them to offer discounts to low-income patients.
The drugmakers' trade association says that would eliminate thousands of jobs and result
in higher premiums.
Hospitals that swallowed $155 billion in reduced payments under last year's health law
face an additional $50 billion cut under Obama's plan. They, too, have launched an ad
campaign and are focusing on the potential job loss at hospitals often a community's
largest employer.
"Whatever it takes," says Rick Pollack, executive vice president for advocacy and public
Page 3 of 6Five ways to squeeze Medicare USATODAY.com
10/5/2011http://www.usatoday.com/news/washington/story/5-five-ways-to-cut-medicare/50640558/1
8/3/2019 Five Ways to Squeeze Medicare
4/6
policy at the American Hospital Association.
Insurers continue to profit under the popular Medicare Advantage program, which bundles
benefits together, but it was cut $200 billion under last year's overhaul. They are fighting
changes in Medigap coverage and endorsing a plan to enroll people who qualify for both
Medicare and Medicaid in private health plans.
Also on the chopping block are medical colleges and teaching hospitals that train doctors
while providing much of the nation's Medicaid and charity care. The Association of
American Medical Colleges is running ads to "make sure that we connect the dots forpeople," says chief advocacy officer Atul Grover.
Providers argue that the more reimbursements are reduced, the more likely it is that
doctors and others will limit Medicare patients, as they have done with Medicaid. Most
would rather accept the threatened 2% across-the-board cut than anything worse. "All the
providers are in a tenuous situation," says Chip Kahn, president of the Federation of
American Hospitals. "Across-the-board reductions are brutal justice. But on the other
hand, it's better than the alternative."
5 Root out waste and inefficiency
If providers fight successfully to avoid further cuts and lawmakers are afraid to hit
beneficiaries, the debate could turn to waste, fraud and abuse.
Medicare is considered a high-risk program by the Government Accountability Office
because it's prone to high rates of fraud, waste, abuse and improper payments. The GAO
estimates that $48 billion was lost through improper payments in 2010 nearly 10% of
Medicare's total cost.
Government recovery efforts have lagged far behind the problem. Inspector general
reports show that just $4 billion was recovered last year from improper payments in
government health care programs. Last year's health care law called for about $6 billion in
savings by cracking down on waste and fraud.
The attraction of targeting fraudulent and inefficient health care providers is obvious:
Unlike all the other cost-saving measures, it doesn't diminish the nation's health care
system. "If you put less money into health care," Steuerle says, "to some extent, you're
going to get less health care."
For more information aboutreprints & permissions, visit our FAQ's. To report corrections and clarifications, contact Standards
EditorBrent Jones. For publication consideration in the newspaper, send comments to [email protected]. Include name,phone number, city and state for verification. To view our corrections, go to corrections.usatoday.com.
Posted 2d 16h ago | Updated 2d 7h ago
More from USATODAY
Medicare premiums drop, enrollment rises in
health care law USATODAY.com in News
VW sales jump Jetta Beetle 'girl's car' Passat
USATODAY.com in Drive On
Six tips to help your kids become
entrepreneurs USATODAY.com in Money
9/11 marked with tributes and tears
USATODAY.com in News
Friendly's files for Ch. 11 bankruptcy
protection USATODAY.com in Money
More from the web
Congress Set to Avert Shutdown The Fiscal
Times
ExxonMobils earnings: The real story you
wont hear in Washington ExxonMobil's Perspectives
Prophet Economist Issues Eerie Warning.Disturbing Charts Expose The Unthinkable.Newsmax.com
How Much and What Kind of Insurance Do
You Need? Promospread
10 Cars That Refuse to Die Kiplinger[?]
We've updated the Conversation Guidelines. Changes include a brief review of the moderation process and an explanation on
how to use the "Report Abuse" button. Read more.
What Do You Think?
To leave a comment, you need to sign up.
Sign up Log in
270 comments Sort:Oldest to Newest
Score: 35_LUNATIC_6:25 AM on October 3, 2011
Page 4 of 6Five ways to squeeze Medicare USATODAY.com
10/5/2011http://www.usatoday.com/news/washington/story/5-five-ways-to-cut-medicare/50640558/1
8/3/2019 Five Ways to Squeeze Medicare
5/6
Next
6 replies
OBAMACARE IS THE PROBLEM. Report Abuse
Score: 16bepajoe6:26 AM on October 3, 2011
4 replies
o.k. so here is the solution!
eliminate obama care and put everyone on medicare. YES EVERY ONE! This way
we have lots young healthy people paying into a system where we now have a
bunch of older and more sickly people draining the system.
And here is the thing: Medicare is already in place and i t works and there is no
question that it is unconstitutional.
Report Abuse
Score: 1Laterguy6:28 AM on October 3, 2011
1 reply
Gov't takes away our money and then gives us back the part it thinks we
"deserve". We would have been better off without gov't interference in our lives.Gov't should have never taken over funding our retirement.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
You are about 75 years too late to complain. And in today's world, just how
would someone save and plan for a collapsing economy? The dollar is worth less
and less every day and there is no interest on savings...nor any real increase in
401ks since it started. The money would have been there for Social Security
except for the fact that it was used to keep taxes down f or the last 30
years...while the wealthy scammed the system, and cleaned it out.
As for Medicare...yes, it will have to be cut down. And heroic measures to save
lives will have to be eliminated...totally. Especially that last year that costs most
of the expenses. We have the most expensive, for profit, medical system in the
developed world and are still way down the list for life expectancy and good
health.
The pack a day, six pack a day, obese American is just going to have to die of
his/her bad health choices in the years to come. Or pay c ash out of pocket for
treatments.
Report Abuse
Score: 70cato02116:33 AM on October 3, 2011
1 reply
"fraud, waste, abuse and improper payments...nearly 10% of Medicare's total
cost."
This should be an automatic starting place. Eligibility age, benefit reduction and
higher premiums should be reviewed as secondary cost savers. For that matter,
the entire gov't should be scrutinized for fraud, waste and abuse!!!! If the same
percentage holds true we could knock off nearly $1.5 dollars off the national
debt.
Report Abuse
Score: 15work4changein126:57 AM on October 3, 2011
3 replies
The debt problem is Bank bailouts, cash for clunkers, bailout of the GM, l oans to
China, yes China, and ALL of Obama's spend, spend & spend !!
Report Abuse
Page 5 of 6Five ways to squeeze Medicare USATODAY.com
10/5/2011http://www.usatoday.com/news/washington/story/5-five-ways-to-cut-medicare/50640558/1
8/3/2019 Five Ways to Squeeze Medicare
6/6
Visit our Partners: USA WEEKEND USA TODAY LIVE Sports Weekly Education Space.com Travel Tips
Contact us Advertise Pressroom Media Lounge Jobs FAQ Reprints/Permissions Privacy Notice/Your California Privacy Rights Ad Choices Terms of Service Site Index
2011 USA TODAY, a division of Gannett Co. Inc.
Home News Travel Money Sports Life Tech Weather
Page 6 of 6Five ways to squeeze Medicare USATODAY.com