Argument ErrorsArgument Errors
Critical thinking as an across the curriculum course
www.themegallery.com
Contents
Introduction1
Structural Fallacies2
����Structural Fallacies2
Content Fallacies33
Argument Refutation4
www.themegallery.com
1. Premise
2. Premise
3. Premise
Elements of argument
factual errors
3. Premise
4. ConclusionInferencelogical errors
(structure/formal and content/informal)
factual errors
www.themegallery.com
Types of Fallacies
�Structural Fallacies� logical errors that
cause the invalidity of the argument
�Content Fallacies� logical and factual
errors that weaken the inductive strength or cause the unsoundness of the unsoundness of the argument
� dubious and clearly false premises
www.themegallery.com
Ex: structural fallacy/ formal logical fallacy
invalid
www.themegallery.com
�"It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single man in possession of a good fortune, must be in want of a wife." (Jane
Ex: content fallacy/ informal logical fallacy
in want of a wife." (Jane
Austen wrote this in her
novel Pride and Prejudice)�Alleged certainty: dubious
premise
http://www.media-awareness.ca/english/resources/educational/handouts/online_hate/logical_fallacies_handout.cfm
invalid weak argument
www.themegallery.com
1. All kangaroos have two heads.
2. All bats are kangaroos.
valid, but unsound
Ex: content fallacy/ factual fallacy
3. All bats have two heads.
www.themegallery.com
Contents
Introduction1
Structural Fallacies2
�������� Structural Fallacies2
Content Fallacies33
Argument Refutation4
����
www.themegallery.com
If the dog barks, then I will wake up.
I didn’t wake up.
So the dog didn’t bark.
If the dog barks, then I will wake up.If the dog barks, then I will wake up.
I woke up.
So the dog barked.
If the dog barks, then I will wake up.
The dog didn’t bark.
So I didn’t wake up.
www.themegallery.com
All beagles are dogs.
All dogs have bark.
So all beagles bark.
Some students at HULIS are Chinese.Some students at HULIS are Chinese.
Some Chinese people are enjoying their holidays in the North Pole.
So some students at HULIS are enjoying their holidays in the North Pole.
www.themegallery.com
All dogs bark.
No professor is a dog.
So no professor barks.
All dogs bark.
No professor barks.
No professor is a dog.No professor is a dog.
Most dogs bark.
Fido is a dog.
Fido barks.
Most dogs bark.
Fido barks.
Fido is a dog.
www.themegallery.com
Almost all dogs like peanut butter.
Almost all things that like peanut butter don’t bark.
So almost all dogs don’t bark.
www.themegallery.com
Structural Fallacies
• If you have Gucci bags, you’ll look cool.
• If you don’t have Gucci
http://www.vnexpress.net/Vietnam/Kinh-doanh/2007/10/3B9FB08B/
have Gucci bags, you won’t look cool.
•You may still look cool, probably not like this
www.themegallery.com
Structural Fallacies
www.themegallery.com
A: I can’t stand Siamese cats. Ugh. They have those strange blue eyes.
B: Mary Ellen has a kitten with blue eyes. I didn’t
Structural Fallacies
with blue eyes. I didn’t know its was Siamese.
Siamese cats have strange blue eyes.
Ellen’s kitten has blue eyes.Ellen’s kitten is Siamese.
www.themegallery.com
Contents
Introduction1
Structural Fallacies2
������������
Structural Fallacies2
Content Fallacies33
Argument Refutation4
��������
www.themegallery.com
Content Fallacies
�Fallacies of Presumption�Fallacies of Relevance�Fallacies of Ambiguity
www.themegallery.com
Fallacies of presumption
�Arguments that commit fallacies of presumption contain false premises or lack premises, and so fail to establish their conclusion.
www.themegallery.com
Fallacies of presumption
�"You are either with us or against us. You have refused to join our cause, therefore you must be working against our cause.”
�False dilemma = there are not only 2 False dilemma = there are not only 2 choices (false premise)
http://onegoodmove.org/fallacy/ig.htm
www.themegallery.com
� Residents of this state should vote to elect Kravitz as state governor in the upcoming election. During Kravitz’s final term as a state senator, she was a member of a special legislative committee that explored ways the state can reduce its escalating
Fallacies of presumption
committee that explored ways the state can reduce its escalating rate of violent crime. Elect Kravitz for governor, and our cities’ streets will be safer than ever.
� Hasty generalization: Assuming that all things remain unchanged over time (false premise)
www.themegallery.com
� At the local Viewer Choice video store, the number of available movies in VHS-tape format remains about the same as three years ago, even though the number of available movies on DVD has increased tenfold over the past three
Fallacies of presumption
increased tenfold over the past three years. People who predict the impending obsolescence of the VHS format are mistaken, since demand for VHS movie rentals today clearly remains just as strong as ever.
� Hasty generalization: What’s true for a member is true for the whole group (false premise)
www.themegallery.com
Fallacies of presumption
- Mom: For a marriage to work, people have to have a lot in common
- Daughter: Wrong! I know a lot of miserable marriages where the people had a lot in common.
People have a lot in common
The marriage will work.
People have a lot in common
The marriage will be miserable.
misunderstanding between mother and daughter; mother only mentions a necessary condition, but daughter mistakes it for that her mother thinks that it’s sufficient.
Necessary and Sufficient Conditions: Mistaking a necessary condition for a sufficient condition (dubious premise)
www.themegallery.com
Necessary and sufficient Conditions
�(National Public Radio)� Interviewer: So, will we continue to see home
schooling in America?� Interviewee: As long as there are parents who � Interviewee: As long as there are parents who
love their kids and are willing to work hard, yes.
� That parents love their kids and are will to work hard is sufficient for home schooling in America.
www.themegallery.com
Fallacies of presumption
- Maria: Professor, professor, why wouldn’t you answer my question in class?- Professor Zzzyyxx: Questions in my class I do not allow. If one student I am allowing to ask a question, then others I must allow. And then I question, then others I must allow. And then I will have lots and lots of questions to answer. And time I won’t have for my lecture.
www.themegallery.com
Fallacies of presumption
If a student is allowed to ask question.
then all students are allowed to ask questions.
then all students will ask questions.
hidden premise: all students are equal
(if you add a premise here, U’ll change the context)??? insufficient to conclude that
(if you add a premise here, U’ll change the context)??? insufficient to conclude that
then the questions will be answered.
then I will have no time for my lecture.
� an example the fallacy of slippery slope (insufficient premises leading to false premises)
hidden premise: the time I spend answering all the questions will be at least equal to all the time I have.
??? insufficient to conclude that
www.themegallery.com
- Don’t go out with a football player.- Why not?- You’re crazy about football players, and if
you go out with one, you’re sure to sleep with him
- So?- Then you’ll get pregnant. And you’ll marry
Fallacies of presumption
- Then you’ll get pregnant. And you’ll marry the guy. But those guys are jerks. You’ll end up cooking and cleaning for him while he and his buddies watch football on TV. In twenty years you’ll have five kids, no life and lots of regrets
- Gosh, I guess you’re right. I’ll go out with a basketball player instead
www.themegallery.com
�Ông Đáng cũng khẳng định, mắm tôm chính là nguyên nhân đầu tiên gây bệnh tả trong vụ dịch vừa qua. Cục An toàn vệ sinh
Fallacies of presumption
qua. Cục An toàn vệ sinh thực phẩm đã điều tra 61 trường hợp mắc tả đầu tiên và nhận thấy, tất cả họ đều đã ăn mắm tôm.
�Post-hoc fallacy: “after this therefore because of this”: false premise
www.themegallery.com
�Tại TP HCM, Khoa cấp cứu của các bệnh viện Chợ Rẫy, Trưng Vương, Nhân dân Gia Định,
Fallacies of presumption
Nhân dân Gia Định, Nhân dân, số ca nhập viện bị chấn thương sọ não do tai nạn giao thông giảm gần 50%, so với trước khi thực hiện đội mũ bảo hiểm.
http://www.vnexpress.net/Vietnam/Xa-hoi/2007/12/3B9FD676/
www.themegallery.com
Fallacies of relevance
�the considerations that they offer in support of their conclusion are irrelevant to determining whether that conclusion is true � personal attack� irrelevant appeals� weak analogy
www.themegallery.com
�I hear that Brigitte Bardot is campaigning for animals rights. But she’s the one who used to do advertisements for fur coats.
Fallacies of relevance
coats. �personal attack
www.themegallery.com
The Presidential IQ Report
WASHINGTON --In a published report, the Lovenstein Institute of Scranton, Pennsylvania has detailed 147 Franklin D. Roosevelt (D)132 Harry Truman (D)122 Dwight D. Eisenhower (R)174 John F. Kennedy (D)174 John F. Kennedy (D)126 Lyndon B. Johnson (D)155 Richard M. Nixon (R)121 Gerald R. Ford (R)176 James E. Carter (D)105 Ronald W. Reagan (R)98 George H. W. Bush (R)182 William J. Clinton (D)91 George W. Bush (R)
http://lovenstein.org/
www.themegallery.com
Fallacies of relevance
� Tôi cũng không hoàn toàn đồng tình với quan điểm là việc quan hệ trước hôn nhân là hoàn toàn hợp tự nhiên nếu tình yêu đủ chín. Vội vàng gì nhỉ? Tại sao các bạn trẻ không đợi thêm thời gian xây dựng tình cảm được lớn dần, lớn dần đơm hoa, kết được lớn dần, lớn dần đơm hoa, kết trái bằng một cuộc hôn nhân, đem lại hạnh phúc cho cả hai họ, lại hợp với thuần phong mỹ tục của người Việt.
� Appeal to traditions
http://www.vnexpress.net/Vietnam/Ban-doc-viet/Tam-su/2007/12/3B9FD84A/
www.themegallery.com
�Nếu không đội mũ bảo hiểm, bạn sẽ thấy mình lạc lõng
�Appeal to popularity
Fallacies of relevance
Don’t be the last to buy…
www.themegallery.com
Fallacies of relevance
�Appeal to Novelty
www.themegallery.com
�Do you believe in God?
�No, I don’t like the thought that I’m
Fallacies of relevance
thought that I’m not in control.
�Appeal to consequences
www.themegallery.com
�"During her 17 years as a professor of botany, Professor Thomas has proved herself to be well worth her annual salary of $50,000. Her classes are among the largest at the university, demonstrating her popularity among students. Moreover, the money she has brought to the
Fallacies of relevance
Moreover, the money she has brought to the university in research grants has exceeded her salary in each of the last two years. Therefore, in consideration of Professor Thomas' demonstrated teaching and research abilities, we recommend that she receive a $10,000 raise and a promotion to Department Chairperson; without such a raise and promotion, we fear that Professor Thomas will leave Elm City University for another college."
www.themegallery.com
Wherever there's a pool there's always a flirtwherever there's school there'll always be homeworkwherever there's a beat there's always a drumwherever there’s fun there's always coca cola
doo doo doo doo doo doo doo doo doo dooo. doo doo doo doo doo always coca cola
Fallacies of Relevance
doo doo doo always coca colaThe stars will always shine, the birds will always singAs long as there's thirst, there's always the real thingCoca-cola is always the oneWherever there is fun there's always Coca-cola
Weak analogy
www.themegallery.com
Fallacies of ambiguity
�Fallacies of ambiguity appear to support their conclusions only due to their imprecise use of language.
�Once terms are clarified, fallacies of Once terms are clarified, fallacies of ambiguity are exposed.
www.themegallery.com
Contents
Introduction1
Structural Fallacies2
������������
Structural Fallacies2
Content Fallacies33
Argument Refutation4
������������
www.themegallery.com
1. Premise
2. Premise
3. Premise
Elements of argument
factual errors
3. Premise
4. ConclusionInferencelogical errors
(structure/formal and content/informal)
factual errors
Company Logo
Argument by Jennifer
� Premise 1: In a debate debaters argue as hard as they can while in a deliberation it is easy for them to give up their side earlier than they should.
� Premise 2: The debating style is used in crucial argument.
� Premise 3: The debating style may let people get hurt � Premise 3: The debating style may let people get hurt but that does not have a considerable effect on the effectiveness of the style.
� Conclusion: A debate is better than a deliberation in getting us to the truth.
� Evaluation: Premise 2: appeal to popularity; Premise 1 & 3: no evidence to support these premises.
Company Logo
Argument by Mark
�Premise 1: The pressure to save face or to win distracts debaters from the truth.
�Premise 2: Getting at the truth is much more important than winning.
�Premise 3: Because of the possible pain, �Premise 3: Because of the possible pain, people are afraid of debating over issues they really care.
�Conclusion: A deliberation is better than a debate in getting us at the truth.
�Evaluation: Premise 1 & 3: no evidence
Company Logo
Counter Arguing Strategies
�Asking for clarification of terms: � I'd like a definition of “flashiest arguments”,
What do you mean by “at the beginning”?,
�Giving counter examples: � What if it's a presidential debate and the
Democrat suddenly says, "Oh, I see you've been right all along, I'm going to go out and register Republican."
Company Logo
Counter Arguing Strategies
�Asking for evidence: � Aren't we missing a central piece of
evidence? We don't know whether people would be more willing to deliberate than debate. Would you be willing to try an debate. Would you be willing to try an experiment? We would poll whatever number of people you think would make a convincing sample to at least see what people think they'd prefer.